Embryonic Lethality Is Not Sufficient to Explain Hourglass-Like Conservation of Vertebrate Embryos
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Uchida et al. EvoDevo (2018) 9:7 https://doi.org/10.1186/s13227-018-0095-0 EvoDevo RESEARCH Open Access Embryonic lethality is not sufcient to explain hourglass‑like conservation of vertebrate embryos Yui Uchida1* , Masahiro Uesaka1, Takayoshi Yamamoto1, Hiroyuki Takeda1,2 and Naoki Irie1,2* Abstract Background: Understanding the general trends in developmental changes during animal evolution, which are often associated with morphological diversifcation, has long been a central issue in evolutionary developmental biology. Recent comparative transcriptomic studies revealed that gene expression profles of mid-embryonic period tend to be more evolutionarily conserved than those in earlier or later periods. While the hourglass-like divergence of devel- opmental processes has been demonstrated in a variety of animal groups such as vertebrates, arthropods, and nema- todes, the exact mechanism leading to this mid-embryonic conservation remains to be clarifed. One possibility is that the mid-embryonic period (pharyngula period in vertebrates) is highly prone to embryonic lethality, and the resulting negative selections lead to evolutionary conservation of this phase. Here, we tested this “mid-embryonic lethality hypothesis” by measuring the rate of lethal phenotypes of three diferent species of vertebrate embryos subjected to two kinds of perturbations: transient perturbations and genetic mutations. Results: By subjecting zebrafsh (Danio rerio), African clawed frog (Xenopus laevis), and chicken (Gallus gallus) embryos to transient perturbations, namely heat shock and inhibitor treatments during three developmental periods [early (represented by blastula and gastrula), pharyngula, and late], we found that the early stages showed the highest rate of lethal phenotypes in all three species. This result was corroborated by perturbation with genetic mutations. By tracking the survival rate of wild-type embryos and embryos with genetic mutations induced by UV irradiation in zebrafsh and African clawed frogs, we found that the highest decrease in survival rate was at the early stages particu- larly around gastrulation in both these species. Conclusion: In opposition to the “mid-embryonic lethality hypothesis,” our results consistently showed that the stage with the highest lethality was not around the conserved pharyngula period, but rather around the early period in all the vertebrate species tested. These results suggest that negative selection by embryonic lethality could not explain hourglass-like conservation of animal embryos. This highlights the potential contribution of alternative mechanisms such as the diversifying efect of positive selections against earlier and later stages, and developmental constraints which lead to conservation of mid-embryonic stages. Keywords: Developmental conservation, Hourglass model, Phylotypic period, Lethality, Pharyngula period Background been one of the major issues in the feld of EvoDevo. As Morphological novelty is realized through the alteration attempts to formulate the relationship between develop- of developmental programs during evolution [1], and ment and evolution, early studies predicted that the earli- general tendency of the embryonic evolution has long est developmental processes would tend to be conserved through evolution, because they establish fundamental *Correspondence: [email protected]‑tokyo.ac.jp; [email protected]‑tokyo.ac.jp information required for later developmental processes 1 Department of Biological Sciences, University of Tokyo, 7‑3‑1 Hongo, [2–4]. Tis idea was formulated independently in the Bunkyo‑ku, Tokyo 113‑0033, Japan “stepping stone model” [2], “developmental burden,” [3] Full list of author information is available at the end of the article © The Author(s) 2018. This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver (http://creativecommons.org/ publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated. Uchida et al. EvoDevo (2018) 9:7 Page 2 of 11 and “generative entrenchment” [4]. In contrast, the highly does not preclude a possibility that negative selections similar morphological features of the mid-embryonic contributed to the hourglass-like divergence of animal period in vertebrates have been recognized since the embryos. Given these, it is thus worth exploring other nineteenth century [5], and the “developmental hourglass mechanisms, such as negative selection by embryonic model” [6, 7] predicts that the mid-embryonic phase is lethality which might contribute to the transcriptomic the most conserved stage in embryogenesis. It has also conservation of the mid-embryonic period. been predicted that anatomical patterns shared in this Here, we asked whether strong negative selection by conserved mid-embryonic phase defne a body plan for embryonic lethality acts on the conserved mid-embry- each animal phylum, and thus this phase has been named onic period of vertebrates (pharyngula period [18–21]). the phylotypic period [6–10]. Tough no consensus has In pioneering research, Galis and Metz [33] paved the been reached as to which period is the most conserved way to evaluating the contribution of negative selec- in morphological perspective [11–14], recent transcrip- tions by measuring prenatal death and abnormalities of tomic studies support hourglass-like divergence pat- embryos. By performing a meta-analysis of the suscep- terns in embryogenesis in a variety of animal groups: tibility of various developmental stages to teratogens in Te highest conservation has been reported in the mid- rodent embryos, they reported that teratogen-induced embryonic periods in vertebrates [15–22], arthropods death and abnormalities were highest during the phar- (Drosophila species and Anopheles gambiae) [21, 23, 24], yngula period, implying that strong negative selections nematodes [25], and molluscs and annelids [26]. Further- act on this period [33]. However, embryonic death dur- more, conserved molecular features of genes expressed ing early developmental periods could have been under- in mid-developmental phases have also been reported estimated, since the papers assessed by this report used in other multi-cellular organisms such as plants (Arabi- one of the eutherian group, namely rodents, and techni- dopsis thaliana) [27] and fungi (Coprinopsis cinerea) [28]. cal problems associated with estimation of prenatal death However, the exact mechanisms that make embryos fol- in eutherians have been identifed [34]. To measure the low hourglass-like divergence remain to be clarifed. embryonic lethality throughout embryogenesis, we uti- One possible evolutionary mechanism for hourglass- lized three non-eutherian vertebrate species in which we like conservation at transcriptomic level is that less-posi- can reliably detect early death [zebrafsh (Danio rerio), tive selections act on embryos during the mid-embryonic African clawed frog (Xenopus laevis), and chicken (Gal- period than during earlier or later periods. For example, lus gallus)]. We frst measured their embryonic lethal- Slack et al. [29] referred to variability of earlier periods ity following transient perturbations (i.e., inhibition of caused by adaptation to reproductive strategies or to the transcription, translation, and heat shock) and evalu- demands of embryonic nutrition. Similarly, Kalinka and ated stage-specifc lethality. Since genetic mutations are Tomancak [9] proposed that diversifcations of earlier important sources of changes in embryogenesis in evo- and later periods can be attributed to adaptations to eco- lutionary processes, we also measured embryonic death logical niches. However, the absence of positive selections rate under a condition expected to generate genetic toward mid-embryonic period may not be sufcient to mutations. explain the hourglass-like divergence. For example, with- out negative selections, rapid neutral evolution [30, 31] Methods could diversify the mid-embryonic period. Accordingly, Animal care and embryo sampling Raf hypothesized that because the molecular signals Riken wild-type (RW) zebrafsh were maintained at in mid-embryos consist of complex inductive interac- 28.5 °C on a 14 h light: 10 h dark cycle. Embryos were tions among organ primordia, changes in the develop- obtained by natural mating and incubated at the same mental processes during this period would likely cause temperature as adults in 1/3 Ringer’s solution. Te lethal phenotypes, and thus there would be strong nega- embryos were staged according to standard criteria out- tive selection to conserve the mid-embryonic period [7]. lined previously [35]. Female African clawed frogs were Another possibility is that smaller phenotypic deviation purchased from a local breeder (Watanabe Zoshoku, is produced in the mid-embryonic period: A recent study Hyogo, Japan), and males were purchased from another has shown smaller transcriptomic deviation in the con- local breeder (Zenopasu Yoshoku Kyozai, Ibaraki, Japan). served mid-embryonic period of nematode strains that Te eggs were artifcially fertilized, dejellied in 2% w/v were established under the condition of near-absence l-cysteine-HCl (pH 7.8), and reared