Geochemical Zoning of Volcanic Chains Associated with Pacific
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
LETTERS | FOCUS PUBLISHED ONLINE: 18 SEPTEMBER 2011 | DOI: 10.1038/NGEO1263 Geochemical zoning of volcanic chains associated with Pacific hotspots Shichun Huang1*, Paul S. Hall2 and Matthew G. Jackson2 Recent Hawaiian volcanism is manifest as two geographically a 1 West Molokai and geochemically distinct groups of volcanoes , the Loa East Molokai trend in the south and the Kea trend in the north2,3. The ° 21 N West Maui Kea differences between the Loa and Kea lavas are attributed to spatial variations in the geochemical structure of the Lanai underlying Hawaiian mantle plume4–9. In turn, the Hawaiian Kahoolawe plume structure is thought to reflect heterogeneities in its 7,8 10 Kohala mantle source . Here we compile geochemical data from 20° N Mahukona the Hawaiian and two other volcanic ocean island chains—the Latitude Mauna Kea Samoan and Marquesas—that formed above mantle plumes Hualalai upwelling beneath the Pacific plate. We find that the volcanoes 100 (km) Loa Mauna Loa Kilauea at both Samoa11 and the Marquesas12 show geographic and ° geochemical trends similar to those observed at Hawaii. 19 N Hawaii Specifically, two subparallel arrays of volcanoes exist at both Loihi locations. In each case, the southern trend of volcanoes has 157° W 156° W 155° W 208 ∗ 206 ∗ higher radiogenic lead isotope ratios, Pb = Pb , and lower Longitude neodymium isotope ratios, "Nd, than those of the corresponding northern trend. We suggest that geochemical zoning may be a b Muli Vai common feature of mantle plumes beneath the Pacific plate. 14° S Vailulu’ u Furthermore, we find that the pattern repeats between island Ofu Ta’ u 208 ∗ 206 ∗ Tutuila chains, with the highest Pb = Pb and the lowest "Nd Latitude 208 ∗ 206 ∗ found at Samoa in the south and the lowest Pb = Pb 14° 40' S Samoa Malu Malumalu and the highest "Nd observed at Hawaii in the north. We infer 171° W 170° W 169° W that isotopically enriched material is preferentially distributed Longitude in the lower mantle of the Southern Hemisphere, within the Pacific low seismic velocity zone. c Although considerable variability exists in the geophysical and geochemical characteristics of hotspots, implying variations in their Hawaii particular origins, a range of evidence strongly suggests that at 8° S Eiao Marquesas least some hotspots are caused by mantle plumes rising from Samoa a thermal boundary layer (TBL) at the core–mantle boundary (CMB; refs 13–16). This set of hotspots, which include Hawaii, Nuku Hiva Samoa and the Marquesas, thus provide an important window into 9° S Nuku the lowermost mantle. Ua Huka Latitude Hawaiian volcanism (<2 Myr) manifests itself as two subparallel, Ua Pou en echelon groups of volcanoes, the Loa (southern) and the Kea HivaOa (northern) trends1 (Fig. 1). The formation of en echelon volcanic 10° S trends at Hawaii has been attributed to the patterns of stress within Motu Tahuata the lithosphere that develop as a result of volcanic loading following a change in the direction of relative motion between the plate and Marquesas Fatu Hiva MotuNao plume17,18. Important geochemical differences in lavas from the two 2–4,9 Hawaiian volcanic trends have been documented . Specifically, 141° W 140° W 139° W 138° W 2 206 204 Abouchami et al. showed that at a given Pb= Pb, Loa trend Longitude lavas have higher 208Pb=204Pb than Kea trend lavas. This Pb isotopic difference can be expressed using a combined Pb isotopic ratio, Figure 1 j Maps of Hawaiian, Samoan and Marquesas volcanoes and their 208Pb∗=206Pb∗, the ratio of radiogenic ingrowth of 208Pb and 206Pb positions in the Pacific Ocean. since the formation of the Earth that measures the time-integrated Th/U (ref. 19). At Hawaii, 208Pb∗=206Pb∗ is correlated with Sr and geochemical structure within the conduit of the Hawaiian plume, Nd isotopic ratios2,3 and La/Nb (ref. 20), and Loa trend lavas have and several models of plume structure have been proposed2,4–8. 208 ∗ 206 ∗ higher Pb = Pb and lower "Nd than Kea trend lavas (Fig. 2). Samoan volcanism also forms two subparallel, en echelon This inter-trend difference has been interpreted as reflecting volcanic trends, known as the Malu (southern) and Vai (northern) 1Department of Earth and Planetary Sciences, Harvard University, 20 Oxford Street, Cambridge, Massachusetts 02138, USA, 2Department of Earth Sciences, Boston University, 675 Commonwealth Avenue, Boston, Massachusetts 02215, USA. *e-mail: [email protected]. 874 NATURE GEOSCIENCE j VOL 4 j DECEMBER 2011 j www.nature.com/naturegeoscience © 2011 Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved. NATURE GEOSCIENCE DOI:10.1038/NGEO1263 FOCUS | LETTERS a 10 Hawaii 8 Loa trend Kea trend West Molokai East Molokai 6 Lanai West Maui Kahoolawe 4 Kohala Nd ε Mahukona 2 Mauna Kea Hualalai Kilauea 0 Mauna Loa Loihi ¬2 Samoa ¬4 0.90 0.94 0.98 1.02 1.06 Malu trend Vai trend 208Pb∗/206Pb∗ b 10 Tutuila Masefau Muli Malumalu Ofu 8 Ta'u 6 Kea Vailulu'u Vai The Marquesas 4 Nd Motu trend Nuku trend ε 2 Ua Pou Eiao 0 Tahuata Nuku Hiva Loa Fatu Hiva Ua Huka ¬2 Malu Motu Nao HivaOa ¬4 0.90 0.94 0.98 1.02 1.06 208Pb∗/206Pb∗ 208 ∗ 206 ∗ Figure 2 j Pb = Pb versus "Nd for the Pacific hotspot lavas. a, The Hawaiian and Samoan lavas. b, The Marquesas lavas compared with the Hawaiian and Samoan lavas. 208Pb∗=206Pb∗ measures the radiogenic ingrowth of 208Pb=204Pb and 206Pb=204Pb since the formation of the Earth, and is 208 204 208 204 206 204 206 204 208 204 defined as [( Pb= Pb)sample–( Pb= Pb)Earth Initial]/ [( Pb= Pb)sample–( Pb= Pb)Earth Initial], with ( Pb= Pb)Earth Initial D 29:475 and 206 204 19 143 144 143 144 ( Pb= Pb)Earth Initial D 9:307 based on Canyon Diablo Troilite . "Nd DT( Nd= Nd)sample=( Nd= Nd)CHUR −1U×1,000, where 143 144 146 144 143 144 ( Nd= Nd)CHUR D 0:512638 for Nd isotopic measurements normalized to Nd= Nd D 0:7219, and ( Nd= Nd)CHUR D 0:511836 for Nd isotopic measurements normalized to 146Nd=142Nd D 0:636151. Data sources are in Supplementary Table S1. The analytical uncertainties are in generally smaller than the symbol size. trends21 (Fig. 1). The separation of the Malu and Vai trends consistent with the individual intra-hotspot trends. In particular, 208 ∗ 206 ∗ is ∼50 km, similar to that between the Loa and Kea trends at Pb = Pb increases and "Nd decreases from north to south in the Hawaii (Fig. 1). Samoan lavas form a negative 208Pb∗=206Pb∗– order of Hawaii–Marquesas–Samoa (Figs 2 and 3). Moving from "Nd array, and as at Hawaii, the southern trend (Malu) lavas north to south, these variations imply an increase in the relative 208 ∗ 206 ∗ 208 ∗ 206 ∗ have higher Pb = Pb and lower "Nd than the northern proportion of a high- Pb = Pb and low-"Nd component at the trend (Vai) lavas (Fig. 2). TBL where these plumes originate (Fig. 3). The high-208Pb∗=206Pb∗ The physical pattern of volcanism at the Marquesas is somewhat and low-"Nd isotopic signature at Samoa is likely to reflect a recycled, less well defined than that at Hawaii or Samoa, owing in part to a ancient continental crustal component11. At Hawaii, although other 22 208 ∗ 206 ∗ lack of high-resolution bathymetric data that would better constrain interpretations exist , the high- Pb = Pb and low-"Nd isotopic submarine volcanism in the area (Fig. 1). However, the Marquesas signature is arguably best explained as reflecting a recycled, ancient volcanoes show a clear geographic–geochemical correlation12. This oceanic crustal component, including sediments20,23. Consequently, 208 ∗ 206 ∗ correlation is very similar to that exhibited at both Hawaii and we suggest that the high- Pb = Pb and low-"Nd components Samoa. In detail, lavas from the southern (Motu) trend of the exhibited at Hawaii, Marquesas and Samoa are related to the Marquesas volcanoes (Ua Pou, Tahuata, Fatu Hiva and Motu DUPAL anomaly, a globe-encircling region of isotopic enrichment 208 ∗ 206 ∗ 208 ∗ 206 ∗ Nao) have lower "Nd at a given Pb = Pb than lavas from (high Pb = Pb ) at the base of the southern hemispheric mantle the northern (Nuku) trend (Eiao, Nuku Hiva, Ua Huka, and that is believed to be a heterogeneous assemblage of ancient recycled Hiva Oa; Figs 1 and 2). crustal materials24. This is not to say that the Hawaiian, Marquesas 208 ∗ 206 ∗ The Hawaiian, Marquesas and Samoan hotspots exhibit and Samoan lavas sample the same high- Pb = Pb and low-"Nd strikingly systematic geographic–geochemical variations. At an component. Rather, the enriched components at these three intra-hotspot scale, lavas from the southern trend at each hotspot hotspots have the same isotopic characteristics (high-208Pb∗=206Pb∗ (Loa at Hawaii, Malu at Samoa, Motu at the Marquesas) have and low-"Nd), which, together, can be best explained as recycled 208 ∗ 206 ∗ more enriched (higher Pb = Pb and lower "Nd) isotopic ancient crustal components. compositions than lavas from the respective northern trends (Kea at The surface distribution of hotspot lavas characterized by the Hawaii, Vai at Samoa, Nuku at the Marquesas). At an inter-hotspot DUPAL anomaly has been shown to be correlated with the large scale, the Samoan, Marquesas and Hawaiian hotspots as a whole regions of low seismic velocity in the lowermost mantle, commonly exhibit trends in isotopic composition that are at least qualitatively called superplumes25,26. The three hotspots considered here all NATURE GEOSCIENCE j VOL 4 j DECEMBER 2011 j www.nature.com/naturegeoscience 875 © 2011 Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved. LETTERS | FOCUS NATURE GEOSCIENCE DOI:10.1038/NGEO1263 a 1.06 a 40° N Hawaii 1.04 Kea 20° N Loa 1.02 ∗ C Marquesas G Pb 1.00 0° Samoa 206 Nuku / Vai ∗ Samoa Motu Pb 0.98 ° Malu 20 S S 208 P E 0.96 L M T 40° S 0.94 Marquesas 160° E 180° 160° W 140° W 120° W 100° W Longitude Hawaii 0.92 b ° 20° N10° N0° 10° S20° S 40 N Latitude b 8 20° N G 6 0° C S 4 20° S Hawaii P Nd E ε ε L M 2 40° S T 160° E 180° 160° W 140° W 120° W 100° W Marquesas Longitude 0 Southern trends c 40° N Northern trends Samoa ¬2 20° N10° N0° 10° S20° S ° Latitude 20 N Figure 3 j Geochemical variation of the Hawaiian, Samoan and Marquesas C G 0° lavas with latitude.