Chapter 3 05 0672327139 Ch03 7/22/05 9:56 AM Page 89

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Chapter 3 05 0672327139 Ch03 7/22/05 9:56 AM Page 89 05 0672327139_ch03 7/22/05 9:56 AM Page 88 1 Chapter 3 05 0672327139_ch03 7/22/05 9:56 AM Page 89 = 2 Focus is perhaps the most important FOCUS AND component in the success of an image. We all focus our eyes in the natural process of seeing, although lighting DEPTH OF conditions, attention span, and our emotional engagement with the scene impact exactly what we comprehend FIELD and react to. Thus, we use our eyes to bring the world into optical focus, but we also focus our minds to con- centrate our attention on the things we’re trying to understand. This chapter looks at the act of focusing with both our eyes and our minds. Getting the camera to render the world in sharp detail is the first step, while controlling what is in or out of focus allows us to cre- ate emphasis and to control the composition of the image. This chapter starts by outlining the basics of digital focusing techniques, and moves quickly to explaining how to control depth of field effects. The final pages of this chapter present tips for controlling focus and depth of field in specific types of scenes, including landscapes, objects, and close-up photography. 1 Fence 2 Montepulciano Altar Nikon D2H Nikon D2H, 1/125 sec, f/5.6 1/60 sec, f/4.5 Focal length 185mm Focal length 75mm 3 89 05 0672327139_ch03 7/22/05 9:56 AM Page 90 3 = Focus, Sharpness, and Depth of Field Focus and sharpness may sound like the same thing, but they really are two related but separate components of good photogra- phy. Sharpness refers to the crisp clarity and detail present in a photograph, while focus refers to the controls and action required by your camera to achieve the final sharpness result. Camera manufacturers have been on a holy quest to get us to forget about focus, assuring us that the cameras are automatic and intuitive enough to read the scene—as well as our minds. Although this is often true, there are times when the camera is less than intuitive, and we have to give it a nudge to get the focus right. To help you do that, we’re going to examine the mechanics behind focusing systems, explaining how they work and when you should shift from auto to manual. Focus is also one of the means by which you determine a photo’s depth of field. Depth of field is interesting because it controls what parts of the image are in focus as well as the overall clarity of the subject. Thus depth of field plays a significant role as a compositional element, controlling where the viewer looks and the speed with which his or her eyes move through the scene. These issues are covered in greater detail in the next chapter on composition, but for now, the important thing is to understand what depth of field is and how to control it. 90 Focus and Depth of Field • Chapter 3 05 0672327139_ch03 7/22/05 9:56 AM Page 91 4 5 6 Types of Autofocus that you can get the best results although its infrared signal can pro- 3 Val D’Orcia and avoid focusing mistakes. hibit you from focusing through Nikon D2H All of today’s cameras use some glass windows or other transparent 1/250 sec, f/7.6 The primary types of autofocus are form of autofocus, where the cam- objects. EV -1.33 era automatically detects the dis- known as active and passive sys- Focal length 78mm tance from the camera to the tems. Active autofocus sends out an Autofocus cameras define active 4 subject and sets the focus on the infrared signal that is reflected by areas within the viewfinder that act Montalcino Ring fly. With each generation of new the subject, allowing the system to as focusing zones. When one of Nikon D2H 1/100 sec, f/10 cameras, engineers continue to calculate the distance to the subject these areas is active, it reacts to EV -0.33 ISO 640 and set the focus. Passive autofocus areas of contrast and edge detail, advance the intelligence and capa- Focal length 75mm bility of digital autofocus, trans- systems determine the subject’s reflecting back information to both forming it from a clumsy yet distance from the camera based on passive and active systems for the 5 Olivetto Trees interesting concept into a func- the light and contrast in the subject reading. The number, placement, Nikon D2H tional piece of photographic tech- matter. and sophistication of these focusing 1/80 sec, f/4.5 nology. Having said that, although zones vary based on manufacturer Focal length 200mm Passive autofocus systems are less the technology has improved great- and price point of your camera, but desirable in that they are limited by 6 Duomo Statue ly, it is by no means automatic or it’s safe to say that all autofocus the available light; they have trouble Nikon D2H foolproof. It’s important to under- implementations are a marked focusing if there is little or no con- 1/500 sec, f/4.5 stand a bit about how the focusing advancement from where we were trast in the subject matter or if the EV -0.33 system in your camera works, so just a few years ago. scene is too dark. Active autofocus Focal length 75mm works well in most instances, 91 05 0672327139_ch03 7/22/05 9:56 AM Page 92 PHOTOtip Blurring on Purpose adding blur to the moving subject. This R emember that it’s not always nec- approach allows you to blur just the essary to keep everything tack sharp subject, while avoiding the inevitable in order to create a great image. There camera shake that comes from hand- are times when I intentionally create holding a slow shutter setting. images that are soft, and sometimes blurred beyond recognition. In other instances, I experiment with abstraction by setting the camera to a For example, many museums in Europe very slow setting and shooting out the don’t allow flash photography or window of my car while the car is tripods (even though they do allow you moving. Now, I don’t necessarily rec- to use your camera on its own). I think ommend that you do this if you’re the Experiment with intentional blur in low-light it’s their way of allowing tourists to get driver (I always have someone else at conditions. their snapshots without giving up any- the wheel as I’m shooting these kinds thing good to the professionals. Thus, of images). With some experimenta- if I’m standing in front of a great sculp- tion, you can achieve some interest- ture and I don’t have enough light to ing, fluid abstractions that would be capture a sharp image, I’ll introduce very difficult to emulate, even with some intentional camera shake to Photoshop’s filter set. In this second make the image even more abstract. If example, I was shooting at 1/13 of a I’m going to get camera shake, I’m at second at f/25, allowing for a well- least going to get shake that’s interest- exposed image with a great tonal ing. In the example shown here, I was range, in spite of the extreme abstrac- in the museum of the church of Santa tion. Croce in Florence, shooting sculptures from the original façade. ’ Intentional blur is an obvious way to imply motion within the image. A Motion-induced abstraction. tripod-mounted camera with a slow shutter speed can keep the static por- tion of the scene tack-sharp, while 92 Focus and Depth of Field • Chapter 3 05 0672327139_ch03 7/22/05 9:56 AM Page 93 7 8 Controlling Autofocus halfway to focus, and then recom- zone you want to use). Nikon has a 7 Duomo Scaffold III The skill you need with the auto- pose your image before pressing the button that toggles through all the (detail) Nikon D2H focus technique is being able to release button the rest of the way available zones. Most systems work 1/250 sec, f/7.6 quickly identify the desired focus down to take the picture. This well with a little practice, provided approach to focusing is similar to a that you understand what it’s doing. EV -1.33 point in your image and select the Focal length 78mm nearest focusing zone in the feature called Focus Lock, which is available on many advanced cameras. viewfinder. If the subject is not When to Switch to Manual 8 Duomo Scaffold III aligned with the focus zone of the Instead of pressing the shutter Nikon D2H Although autofocus can be a life- viewfinder, the camera will focus on halfway, Focus Lock allows you to 1/250 sec, f/4.5 saver in certain situations when you the background or the foreground, center the subject and press the EV +0.33 need to react quickly to get the shot, and the subject will be out of focus. Focus Lock button to set the focus, Focal length 75mm then recompose the scene as you can also see that it has its limita- If your camera is older or more of a desired. tions. As a result, be mindful that point-and-shoot model, you might you can switch your SLR camera not be able to select specific focusing Digital SLRs and advanced all-in- from autofocus to manual mode to zones, although your owner’s manual one digital cameras allow you to set the focus exactly where you want should outline where the focusing select which focusing zone is active it by adjusting the focus ring on the zone is and how to optimize focus.
Recommended publications
  • AF-S 17-35Mm.Pdf
    1 4 2 5 Nomenclature 1Focal length scale !Aperture scale Jp 2Focal length scale index line "Aperture-direct-readout scale 3Distance index line #Minimum aperture signal post 4Distance scale (EE servo coupling post) 5Hood mounting index $Aperture indexing post En 6Focus ring %CPU contacts 7Focus mode switch &Meter coupling ridge 8Aperture index/Mounting index (Aperture ring 9Minimum aperture lock lever )Zoom ring De Introduction The AF-S Zoom-Nikkor ED 17-35mm f/2.8D IF employs a Silent Wave Motor inside the lens to drive the focusing mechanism, thus the “S” designation. As a result, autofocusing is smooth, silent, and almost instantaneous. In addition, this lens features internal focusing (IF), so there is no change in the overall length of the lens Fr from infinity to its closest focusing distance of 0.28m (0.9 ft.), contributing to balanced hand-held operation. Moreover, three aspherical and two ED (Extra-low Dispersion) lens elements ensure that images that are sharp and clear from center to edges and virtually free of color fringing, regardless of the focal length setting. Also, by utilizing a 9-bladed diaphragm that produces a nearly circular aperture, out-of- Es focus images in front of or behind the subject are rendered as pleasing blurs. Note: This lens offers Silent Wave autofocusing with Nikon F5, F4-Series, F100, F90X/N90s*, F90-Series/N90*, F80-Series/N80-Series*, F70-Series/N70*, F65-Series/N65-Series*, Pronea 600i/6i*, Pronea S cameras, in addition to D2H, D1-Series, D100 and D70 Digital Cameras. It * Sold exclusively in the USA.
    [Show full text]
  • Portraiture and the Human Subject Print Viewing
    1 Natalie Krick, My Head on Mom's Shoulder, from the "Natural Deceptions" series, 2014 PORTRAITURE AND THE HUMAN SUBJECT PRINT VIEWING This print viewing introduces students to a range of photographs with a focus on portraiture where visual information such as setting, clothing, body language, and facial expression speak to the identity of the subject. Choices made by the photographer such as use of vantage point, lighting, framing, timing and composition also impact the viewer’s perception of the subject. The 2018–2019 exhibition season is generously sponsored by The Andy Warhol Foundation for the Visual Arts, the Illinois Arts Council Agency, the City of Chicago's Department of Cultural Affairs and Special Events (DCASE), and the Efroymson Family Fund. 22 JULIA MARGARET CAMERON British, 1815–1879 Eleanor, 1948 Julia Margaret Cameron's subjects were almost always family 1984:10 members or friends from a social circle of prominent cultural figures. Sir John Frederick William Herschel was a famous Victorian astronomer whose contributions to photography include the invention of the cyanotype "blue-print," inventing photographic fixers, and even coining the term “photography” in 1839. Cameron was a lifetime friend of Herschel, whom she met in South Africa while visiting the Cape of Good Hope in 1835 and later photographed on multiple occasions. While Cameron rigorously sought to maintain the distinction between art photography and "professional" photography (she proudly saw herself as part of the former), she was not unconcerned with the market for her work. That she obtained a copyright for "Herschel" (on April 9, 1867) suggests that she thought the image was especially marketable.
    [Show full text]
  • Cinematography
    CINEMATOGRAPHY ESSENTIAL CONCEPTS • The filmmaker controls the cinematographic qualities of the shot – not only what is filmed but also how it is filmed • Cinematographic qualities involve three factors: 1. the photographic aspects of the shot 2. the framing of the shot 3. the duration of the shot In other words, cinematography is affected by choices in: 1. Photographic aspects of the shot 2. Framing 3. Duration of the shot 1. Photographic image • The study of the photographic image includes: A. Range of tonalities B. Speed of motion C. Perspective 1.A: Tonalities of the photographic image The range of tonalities include: I. Contrast – black & white; color It can be controlled with lighting, filters, film stock, laboratory processing, postproduction II. Exposure – how much light passes through the camera lens Image too dark, underexposed; or too bright, overexposed Exposure can be controlled with filters 1.A. Tonality - cont Tonality can be changed after filming: Tinting – dipping developed film in dye Dark areas remain black & gray; light areas pick up color Toning - dipping during developing of positive print Dark areas colored light area; white/faintly colored 1.A. Tonality - cont • Photochemically – based filmmaking can have the tonality fixed. Done by color timer or grader in the laboratory • Digital grading used today. A scanner converts film to digital files, creating a digital intermediate (DI). DI is adjusted with software and scanned back onto negative 1.B.: Speed of motion • Depends on the relation between the rate at which
    [Show full text]
  • New Mode of Cinema V1n1
    New Mode of Cinema: How Digital Technologies are Changing Aesthetics and Style Kristen M. Daly, Columbia University, New York Abstract This article delves intrinsically into how the characteristics of digital cinema, its equipment, software and processes, differ from film and therefore afford new aesthetic and stylistic modes, changing the nature of mise-en-scène and the language of cinema as it has been defined in the past. Innovative filmmakers are exploring new aesthetic and stylistic possibilities as the encumbrances of film, which delimited a certain mode of cinema, are released. The article makes the case that the camera as part of a computer system has enabled a more cooperative relationship with the filmmaker going beyond Alexandre Astruc’s prediction of the camera-pen (camére-stylo) to become a camera-computer. The technology of digital cinema makes the natural indexicality of film and the cut simply options amongst others and permits new forms of visual aesthetics not premised on filmic norms, but based on other familiar audiovisual forms like video games and computer interface. Voir le résumé français à la fin de l’article ***** “We see in them, if you like, something of the prophetic. That’s why I am talking about avant-garde. There is always an avant-garde when something new takes place . .” (Astruc, 1948, 17) In this article, I will examine some of the material qualities and characteristics of the equipment, software and processes of digital cinema production and propose how these afford a new aesthetics and style for cinema. Of course, many styles are available, including the status quo.
    [Show full text]
  • A Curriculum Guide
    FOCUS ON PHOTOGRAPHY: A CURRICULUM GUIDE This page is an excerpt from Focus on Photography: A Curriculum Guide Written by Cynthia Way for the International Center of Photography © 2006 International Center of Photography All rights reserved. Published by the International Center of Photography, New York. Printed in the United States of America. Please credit the International Center of Photography on all reproductions. This project has been made possible with generous support from Andrew and Marina Lewin, the GE Fund, and public funds from the New York City Department of Cultural Affairs Cultural Challenge Program. FOCUS ON PHOTOGRAPHY: A CURRICULUM GUIDE PART IV Resources FOCUS ON PHOTOGRAPHY: A CURRICULUM GUIDE This section is an excerpt from Focus on Photography: A Curriculum Guide Written by Cynthia Way for the International Center of Photography © 2006 International Center of Photography All rights reserved. Published by the International Center of Photography, New York. Printed in the United States of America. Please credit the International Center of Photography on all reproductions. This project has been made possible with generous support from Andrew and Marina Lewin, the GE Fund, and public funds from the New York City Department of Cultural Affairs Cultural Challenge Program. FOCUS ON PHOTOGRAPHY: A CURRICULUM GUIDE Focus Lesson Plans Fand Actvities INDEX TO FOCUS LINKS Focus Links Lesson Plans Focus Link 1 LESSON 1: Introductory Polaroid Exercises Focus Link 2 LESSON 2: Camera as a Tool Focus Link 3 LESSON 3: Photographic Field
    [Show full text]
  • High ISO Heroes Which APS-C and Full-Frame Cameras Perform the Best in Poor Light?
    Saturday 4 February 2017 High ISO heroes Which APS-C and full-frame cameras perform the best in poor light? All-new Passionate about photography since 1884 BUYING GUIDE COMPLETE GUIDE 550 cameras & lenses listed ISO & rated and How to get pictures as good as this at high ISO Get great low light images and keep noise right down ● What ISO and when ● Best noise removers ● Settings of the pros Digital ISO demystified Fujifilm Where noise comes from first look and how it relates to X-T20 mirrorless & sensor size & resolution X100F compact The high ISO king? We see how Nikon’s D5 copes with ice-hockey boot camp Ice on the black sand beach at Jökulsárlón.raw ON THE ICE BEACH IT’S A DARK, SOMBRE WINTER’S DAY. The grey cloud is low, and the rain is steady, but the muted light is just perfect for the subject matter all around me, namely waves lapping around the artfully sculpted blocks of ice on the black sand. Now I’ve seen many images of this unique combination before – it’s an Icelandic photographic staple – but there’s no resisting the appeal of such stark, elemental beauty. In fact it’s a beauty that is enhanced by the flat lighting, a cold scene of black and blue with simple graphic appeal. But as so often is the case here in Iceland the conditions are difficult: apart from the rain, salty spray is being driven inshore off the waves and onto my increasingly crusty camera, lens and filter. So be it, such adversity is now familiar.
    [Show full text]
  • Mise-En-Scene Analysis
    Mise-en-scene Analysis http://www.slideshare.net/kjera/mise-en-scene-analysis-presentation The Dominant Where is our eye attracted first? Why? The dominant contrast can be created by any number of techniques. The size of an object may draw our attention to it. In black and white movies, the dominant contrast is generally achieved through a juxtaposition of lights and darks. In color films, the dominant is often achieved by having one color stand out from the others. Placing one object in sharper focus than the rest of the shot can also create a dominant. Lighting Key High key? Low key? High contrast? Some combination of these? • High key lighting--features bright, even illumination and few conspicuous shadows. This lighting key is often used in musicals and comedies. • Low key lighting--features diffused shadows and atmospheric pools of light. This lighting key is often used in mysteries and thrillers. • High contrast lighting--features harsh shafts of lights and dramatic streaks of blackness. This type of lighting is often used in tragedies and melodramas. Shot and Camera Proxemics What type of shot? How far away is the camera from the action? Shots are defined by the amount of subject matter that's included within the frame. They can be divided into six basic categories: • Extreme long shot--taken from a great distance, showing much of the locale. If people are included in these shots, they usually appear as mere specks. • Long shot--corresponds to the space between the audience and the stage in a live theater. The long shots show the characters and some of the locale.
    [Show full text]
  • Sept.News 2003
    BEAU PHOTO SUPPLIES INC. 1520 W. 6TH AVE. PHONE: (604) 734 7771 VANCOUVER, BC FAX: (604) 734 7730 CANADA V6J 1R2 www.beauphoto.com LAMINATES UP TO 70% OFF !!! SALE ON NEW OVERSTOCK LAMINATES! Canvas rolls Regular $187.00 Sale ! $99.50 Matte Smooth 8x22 sheets (200) Regular $130.00 Sale ! $79.50 CLEARANCE on slightly flawed, open laminate boxes! Regular $219.00 12”x15” sheets (minimum 150 sheets per box) 9”x22” sheets (minimum 150 sheets per box) ONLY $49.95 ea full and almost full rolls Variety of finishes available - canvas, matte smooth, leather, small texture As is. All sales final. While quantities last! News from the back !!! For those who have been waiting, you already know! For those of you who haven’t, it has finally been announced! Nikon’s next generation Professional Digital SLR for photojournalism, action and sports. The new D2H incorporates an amazing combination of speed, resolution, handling and faster workflow for total image quality and performance. As for specs ? Check these out: 8 fps for up to 40 consecutive JPEG or 25 RAW (NEF) full resolution (2,464 x 1,632 pixel) images. The D2H also has a very short 37ms shutter time lag. Instant power up means the D2H is ready to go when you are. Nikon’s exclusive new 4.1 mp imaging sensor improves on power consumption and minimize dark noise all while increasing speed and image quality. This new sensor is also built to read 2 channels of data from each pixel at once for maximum speed in image reproduction.
    [Show full text]
  • The Lens: Focal Length Control of Perspective in the Image Is Very Impor- 5.21 Wide-Angle Distortion in Mikhail Tant to the Filmmaker
    The Phongraphic Image r69 The lens of a photographic camera does roughly what your eye does. It gath- ers light from the scene and transmits that light onto the flat surface of the film to form an image that represents size, depth, and other dimensions of the scene. One difference between the eye and the camera,, though, is that photographic lenses may be changed, and each type of lens will render perspective in different ways. If two different lenses photograph the same scene, the perspective relations in the result- ing images could be drastically different. A wide-angle lens could exaggerate the depth you see down the track or could make the foreground trees and buildings seem to bulge; atelephoto lens could drastically reduce the depth, making the trees seem very close together and nearly the same size. The Lens: Focal Length Control of perspective in the image is very impor- 5.21 Wide-angle distortion in Mikhail tant to the filmmaker. The chief variable in the process is the focal length of the Kalatozov's The Cranes Are Flyipg. lens. In technical terms, the focal length is the distance from the center of the lens to the point where light rays converge to a point of focus on the film. The focal length alters the perceived magnification, depth, and scale of things in the image. We usually distinguish three sorts of lenses on the basis of their effects on perspective: 1. The short-focal-length (wide-angle) lens. In 35mm-gauge cinematography, a lens of less than 35mm in focal length is considered a wide-angle lens.
    [Show full text]
  • Catalogue of Tokina Lenses in English
    Tokina New Lens Catalog V4 5/17/07 7:18 PM Page 1 LENS CATALOG LENSES FOR DIGITALSLR CAMERAS www.tokinalens.com Tokina New Lens Catalog V4 5/17/07 7:18 PM Page 2 Digital Eyes Floating Element Assembly Aluminum Alloy Die-Cast Model VISIONARY TECHNOLOGY MAKES A DIFFERENCE YOU CAN SEE. Tokina’s proprietary AT-X technology has been evolving toward optical perfection for more than 20 years. Since our mission began in 1981 we have made continuous advances. Each new model is a further refinement in a continuing legacy of excellence in design and materials. The current AT-X PRO series continues this evolution of excellence by using the most state-of-the-art technology anywhere. More Quality Than Meets The Eye. The Tokina difference comes from special material selection and assembly technology that employs micron-unit quality control. This ensures optimum consistency while maintaining the highest quality for every lens. Worldwide, both professionals and knowledgeable photography enthusiasts rely on Tokina lenses. AT-X Technology AT-X comes from our original concept of “Advanced Technology Extra.” This vision encompasses a special group of lenses that are manufactured without compromise, using the most advanced design and fabrication technologies available. The use of unique and unprecedented optical systems independently pioneered by Tokina, has made advanced features, high performance, lightweight, and compact designs a reality. Of course, we have also given full attention to ergonomics and handling. To any user, AT-X means excellent performance through superior technology. 2 Tokina New Lens Catalog V4 5/17/07 7:18 PM Page 3 DIGITAL SERIES Flexible printed circuit board SD (Super Low Dispersion) Glass Mechanisms 1.
    [Show full text]
  • Backup of 2014 Update Backup of Lensbaby Class Lesson 1 Copy
    Lensbaby Magic Lesson 1 “When subject matter is forced to fit into preconceived patterns, there can be no freshness of vision.” -Edward Weston Welcome to my Lensbaby Magic Class! The Basics Craig Strong invented the Lensbaby when he was trying to find a different look for his images. He was looking for a way to be able to do this in-camera, instead of spending hours sitting at his computer. He wanted to combine the soft, imperfect look produced by Holga film cameras, with the convenience of digital imagery. He says that the Lensbaby he developed gave him some options to match a certain mood in a theme, or to render an image the way he envisioned it. With the trend these day being the most refined, precise, high speed automatic lenses, the Lensbaby is a refreshing Lensbaby Magic Kathleen Clemons 1 step backwards. It’s sort of an odd combination of an old, manual focus lens where you had to do it right the first time, and a modern day video game joystick. The original lens models are mounted on a plastic bellows, which allows you to manually focus by pushing, pulling and bending. A selected part of your image will be in focus, and you control just where that ‘sweet spot” of focus will be by manipulating either the bellows section (the part that looks like vacuum cleaner hose) on the Muse and the original models, or the focus ring on the Composer, which has a ball and socket type design. The remaining areas of your image are softly and gradually blurred, creating unique, eye-catching images.
    [Show full text]
  • Gregg Toland: Cinematogrpaher I. Film Appreciation
    Gregg Toland: Cinematogrpaher I. Film Appreciation: http://www.twyman-whitney.com/film/celluloid_profiles/toland.html Toland's trademarks included sharp, deep focus pictures, black-and-white film, ceilinged sets, low-angle lighting, and touches of Germanic expressionism. After much success in his early career, Toland remarked, "I want to work with someone who's never made a movie. That's the only way to learn anything from someone who doesn't know anything." He got his chance in 1941 with Orson Welles and "Citizen Kane". Toland received numerous nominations for best cinematography ( Misérables, Les (1934), Dead End (1937), Long Voyage Home, The (1940), Citizen Kane (1941). II. Blockbuster. http://www.blockbuster.com/browse/catalog/personDetails/101151 The most influential and innovative cinematographer of the sound era, He first made a name for himself in 1924 by creating a soundproof camera housing which blocked any mechanized noise from reaching recording equipment, a major advance in the new era of sound, as it allowed directors to film intimate moments without accidentally capturing the winding of film as well. Toland's fame rested on his gifts for innovative lighting techniques and crystalline deep-focus photography. His work was remarkably evocative. He revamped the Mitchell BNC camera to include a new anti-noise device which allowed even greater flexibility of movement and control, eliminating the need to intercut between scenes and enabling Welles to create long, continuous shots. Toland was duly rewarded for his innovations on Kane by receiving credit alongside Welles at the film's close -- the director's clear acknowledgment of the crucial importance of Toland's work -- and it has often been suggested that the film's brilliance was as much a product of his vision as it was Welles'.
    [Show full text]