SUBMISSION TO THE VILLANOVA LAW REVIEW 10/16/06 Comments to
[email protected] FIRST ANNUAL SCARPA CONFERENCE IN CATHOLIC LEGAL STUDIES Reconciling Evangelization and Dialogue through Love of Neighbor by Amelia J. Uelmen* INTRODUCTION Pope Benedict and Interreligious Dialogue A year and a half into his papacy, Benedict XVI faced his first major international crisis. On September 12, 2006 he delivered an academic lecture in Germany at the University of Regensburg on the theme of faith and reason in Western culture.1 In the context of a discussion on compulsion in religion, Benedict referred to a fourteenth century dialogue in which the Byzantine Emperor addressed an Islamic scholar: “Show me just what Mohammed brought that was new, and there you will find things only evil and inhuman such as the command to spread by the sword the faith he preached.”2 Two days later the Organization of the Islamic Conference, representing fifty-seven Islamic states, issued a press statement expressing “regret” for the “derogatory fallacies defaming Islam,” and for the “smear campaign” which indulged in “character assassination of the prophet Mohammed.”3 In the days that followed, protests, some violent, occurred in Jakarta, Delhi, London, and other cities. Seven Christian churches in the West Bank and Gaza were attacked. On September 17, 2006 an Italian missionary nun and her bodyguard were shot and killed as they left a children’s hospital in Mogadishu, Somalia.4 A flurry of questions accompanied the intense reactions to the pope’s quotation of the