Tibet Digest August 2015
www.fnvaworld.org
TIBET DIGEST AUGUST 2015 ! !1 Tibet remains under heavy security, with visits by foreign China’s Minority media ghtly restricted, making an independent assessment of the situa on difficult. Policies Ac vists say China has violently tried to stamp out religious freedom and culture in Tibet. China rejects the cri cism, saying its rule has ended serfdom and brought development to a backward region. Exiled Tibetans oppose 50th Vice president of Gu-Chu-Sum (Tibetan Poli cal Prisoners anniversary celebrations of TAR by Movement), Namgyal Dolkar, proposed a worldwide campaign to spread informa on about ground reali es in China Tibet. Business Standard “We are definitely going to try to let more and more August 31, 2015 people know about it. That is very crucial not for Tibet or Tibetans living in exile have opposed China’s 50th China but the en re world,” said Dolkar. anniversary celebra on of the forma on of the Tibet Autonomous Region (TAR), saying Beijing has always denied basic human rights to the people. This year marks several sensi ve anniversaries for the Major policy meeting on Tibet in remote region that China has ruled with an iron fist since buildup to sensitive anniversary 1950, when Communist troops marched in and took Interna onal Campaign For Tibet control of Tibet, in what Beijing calls a “peaceful August 29, 2015 libera on”. A MAJOR POLICY MEETING ON TIBET PRESIDED OVER BY It is 50 years since China established what it calls the Tibet CHINA’S TOP LEADER XI JINPING CONCLUDED THIS WEEK Autonomous Region and also the 80th birthday of Tibetan IN BEIJING, AS SECURITY IS TIGHTENED IN LHASA IN spiritual leader, the Dalai Lama, who has lived in exile in ADVANCE OF A POLITICAL ANNIVERSARY ON SEPTEMBER 1 India since fleeing Tibet in 1959 following an abor ve The Tibet Work Forum on August 24-25, se ng out Tibet uprising. policy for the coming years, is the sixth such strategy China will wage an unceasing fight against separa sm in mee ng on Tibet to be held since the Chinese took over its res ve mountainous region of Tibet, President Xi Tibet in 1949-50. Jinping said, as the government repeated it would never A ended by the en re Politburo, the Party leadership, the accept exiled Tibetan spiritual leader the Dalai Lama’s emphasis of the Work Forum was on ‘stability’, a poli cal genuine autonomy proposals. term associated with a drama c expansion of military and President of the Tibetan Youth Congress, Tenzing Jigme, police powers. According to the Chinese state media, the said they were against such false celebra ons as people mee ng also emphasised the struggle against ‘separa sm’, lacked freedom of religion, freedom of speech and above economic development, in contrast to the last Tibet freedom of press. Work Forum in January, 2010. The official Global Times “It is just another sign of Chinese’s a tude and they are reported: “Stressing that na onal unity, consolida ng trying to show that all is well inside Tibet but which is not ethnic unity, and realising long-term and comprehensive the case. The case is that Tibetans are s ll being denied social stability should be regarded as the primary task for basic human rights – freedom of religion, freedom of the region, Xi said that the country should “firmly take the speech, freedom of press and so we are totally against this ini a ve” in the fight against separa sm, and adhere to kind of false celebra ons,” Jigme said in Dharamsala. the principle of governing Tibet under the rule of The TAR was established on September 1, 1965 a er the law.” (August 27, 2015, Global Times). The Chinese People’s Libera on Army invaded the region in 1949. authori es state that the Dalai Lama is a prime cause of Tibetan ‘separa sm’. Tibet later signed an agreement with China in 1951 a er which the Tibetan government was converted into a local There has been an intensifica on of security in the Tibet government. Autonomous Region, including an increased number of checkpoints, stepping up of surveillance and controls, and large-scale movement of troops in July.[1] This is likely to be a part not only of the renewed emphasis on poli cal
TIBET DIGEST AUGUST 2015 ! !2 ‘stability’ but also in the buildup to the 50th anniversary of Rule of law is the most important means to realise a more the establishment by the Chinese authori es of the Tibet scien fic and modernised governance of Tibet, said the Autonomous Region. researcher, stressing its great significance. Ma eo Mecacci, President of the Interna onal Campaign Everyone is equal before the law. Monks and nuns are no for Tibet said: “The sight of armed troops in trucks excep on,” said Norbu, head of the administra on displaying poli cal slogans moving through Tibet serves commi ee of Drepung Monastery in Lhasa,the regional only to underline the failed policies of the Chinese Party capital. state a er more than half a century. These hardline The administra on commi ee will deal with lawless measures, and the insistence of the Chinese authori es to monks according to law to ensure the monastery and ensure Tibetans ‘celebrate’ this upcoming anniversary, monks abide by law and religious ac vi es con nue reveal the CCP’s uncertain es over lack of its authority in normally, said Norbu. Tibet. This is a leadership that needs to assert itself over a With the promo on of legal knowledge, people’s people who emphasise peace and non-violence, through awareness of law and protec on of their interests has tanks, ‘counter-terrorist’ measures and rhetoric resonant seen remarkable improvement, said Zhou Yalin, a senior of the Cultural Revolu on. The anniversary on September official of Damxung County, Tibet. 1 is an empty celebra on, as there is no genuine autonomy in the ‘Tibet Autonomous Region’, as promised They used to turn to monasteries for help in case of by Beijing in the 1950s. There is a need for a disputes or simply solve them privately, but more and fundamentally new approach on Tibet. Interna onal more people now know they can seek help from police or governments must signal its alarm over the priori es courts, said Zhou. revealed by the Sixth Work Forum, which undermine Xi Jinping underlined the policy of maintaining a prudent chances of achieving a genuine stability.” and steady manner in the long-term development of Tibet, requiring far-sight and sustainability in work and measures. China Focus: CPC’s upgraded governance policy of Tibet He stressed pu ng ecological protec on first. applauded The central leadership’s prudent a tude takes into account the ecological pressure of the plateau, said Penpa Xinhua Lhamo. August 28, 2015 “Each genera on is obliged to protect the region’s pure The ruling Communist Party of China’s governance land,” she said. strategies in Tibet, unveiled at a recent mee ng, show This is a required adjustment for Tibet’s sustainable and improvement in line with the region’s development, coordinated development a er its economic volume analysts say. reaches a certain scale, said Wang Daiyuan, also with the At a conference on Tibet held by central leadership in academy. Beijing earlier this week, President Xi Jinping underlined In the past, fast development was stressed because the na onal and ethnic unity as the key plans for the Tibet region was poor, he explained. Autonomous Region, vowing to focus on long-term, comprehensive stability and an unswerving ba le against Xi also urged persistent stability for Tibet and separa sm. neighbouring provinces, which are home to many Tibetan and other ethnic minori es, including Qinghai, Sichuan, He stressed important principles such as governing Tibet Yunnan and Gansu. according to the law and striving to make people rich and the region prosperous with long-term development. These To s ck to the struggle against the Dalai Lama clique thoughts have been put forward by the central leadership accords with the interests of people of all ethnic groups in since the 18th na onal congress of the CPC in 2012. Tibet, said Penpa Lhamo. “These new thoughts show our governance strategies in Tibet have been gradually perfected,” said Penpa Lhamo, deputy head of the contemporary studies ins tute of the Tibet Academy of Social Sciences.
TIBET DIGEST AUGUST 2015 ! !3 China’s Xi vows unceasing fight monasteries in the long run, encouraging interpreta ons against Tibet separatism of religious doctrines that are compa ble with a socialist society,” state media said. Xinhua There should also be more campaigns to promote ethnic August 28, 2015 unity and promote a sense “of belonging to the same China will wage an unceasing fight against separa sm in Chinese na onality,” he added. its res ve mountainous region of Tibet, President Xi Tibet remains under heavy security, with visits by foreign Jinping said, as the government repeated it would never media ghtly restricted, making an independent accept exiled Tibetan spiritual leader the Dalai Lama’s assessment of the situa on difficult. genuine autonomy proposals. This year marks several sensi ve anniversaries for the remote region that China has ruled with an iron fist since Dalai Lama’s ‘Middle Way Approach’ 1950, when Communist troops marched in and took control in what Beijing calls a “peaceful libera on.” snubbed by Xi Jinping It is 50 years since China established what it calls the Tibet August 28, 2015 Autonomous Region and also the 80th birthday of Tibetan spiritual leader the Dalai Lama, who has lived in exile in India since fleeing Tibet in 1959 following an abor ve uprising. At a two-day conference this week of the senior leadership about Tibet, only the sixth ever held, Xi repeated the government’s standard opposi on to Tibetan independence, saying he would fight an “an unswerving an -separa sm ba le,” state media said in comments reported late on Tuesday. “We should fight against separa st ac vi es by the Dalai A Tibetan Buddhist monk walks into the Jokhang Temple on June group,” Xi was quoted as saying. 18, 2009 in Lhasa, Tibet. (Photo by Feng Li/Ge y Images/CFP) The Dalai Lama denies seeking independence, saying he A er the conclusion of the CPC Central Commi ee and only wants genuine autonomy for Tibet, something he State Council’s 6th Forum on Tibetan Work, Chinese calls the Middle Way and which Beijing believes is merely president Xi Jinping stated that the focus of policy towards a smokescreen for independence, arguing Tibet already Tibet should be centered on maintaining na onal integrity has real autonomy. and unity among Chinese people, as well as ensuring the An accompanying commentary published by the United long-term peaceful governance of the region and to Front Work Department, which has led unsuccessful on- crackdown on separa sm and maintain an unshakeable off talks with the Dalai Lama’s envoys, said the stance against the campaign of the Dalai Lama and his government had not accepted, and would never accept, followers, according to Duowei News, a media outlet run the Middle Way. by overseas Chinese. The Middle Way seeks to cleave off one-quarter of China, Xi also came up with a catchy 20-character summary of his as it would include historic parts of Tibet in neighbouring Tibet policy which roughly translates as, “Rule Tibet by Chinese provinces, the commentary, carried on the law; Make Tibetans prosper and Tibet thrive; Build Tibet department’s WeChat account, said. up over the long-term; Consolidate hearts and minds; “The so-called ‘Middle Way’ is in essence a spli st Build a solid founda on,” the first major policy poli cal demand,” it said. announcement on Tibet since the 18th CPC Na onal Congress. Ac vists say China has violently tried to stamp out religious freedom and culture in Tibet. China rejects the Xi’s a empt to set the basic tone of policy for the next five cri cism, saying its rule has ended serfdom and brought to ten years, comes in the run up to celebra on marking development to a backward region. the 50th year of the establishment of the Tibet autonomous region and seems largely to con nue China’s Xi called for efforts to promote “patrio sm among the previous stance. This does not mean that there are no Tibetan Buddhist circle and effec vely manage changes, as there were some new touches, including,
TIBET DIGEST AUGUST 2015 ! !4 “ruling Tibet by law” and “insis ng on people’s equality sugges ng changes were in store for China’s ethnic before the law. minority policy, allowing them to adopt a less passive Xi made many references to an -separa sm in his speech stance in Chinese poli cs. and stated that separa sts or people a emp ng to disturb A er the discussion between Zhu and Alai was social stability should be dealt with according to the law. republished in a Hong Kong news outlet, it was cri cised A state-media report on the forum commented on the by seven opinion pieces in China Ethnic News, a paper run Dalai Lama and his “Middle Way Approach” which looks to by the State Ethnic Affairs Commission. The opinion pieces “peacefully resolve the issue of Tibet and to bring about accused Zhu and Alai of fabrica ng a contradic on and stability and co-existence between the Tibetan and conflict between ethnic differences and na onal iden ty. Chinese peoples based on equality and mutual co- The pieces accused Zhu and Alai of taking a homogenous opera on,” according to the Dalai Lama’s official website, ethnic iden ty and homogenous culture to be the sta ng that the separa st tendencies of the Dalai Lama standard, in a move similar to the Kuomintang’s strategy and his followers have not changed, but that they are just of homogenisa on and exclusion. The pieces said that adop ng a new strategy to achieve the same goal. The differences must be acknowledged, but at the same me, ar cle stated that the Dalai Lama’s Middle Way Approach they acknowledged that the use of the term “look a er” does not acknowledge Tibet to be Chinese territory, is was derogatory when used in reference to China’s policy opposed to the principles enshrined in the Chinese on its ethnic minority peoples. Cons tu on, does not accept the socialist system being Zhu was, for a long me, vice minister in charge of daily implemented in Tibet or its status as an autonomous affairs for the United Front Work Department and once region of China and wishes to unify the 12 Tibetan served as China’s representa ve in nego a ons with the autonomous prefectures across the four provinces of Dalai Lama. Zhu previously discussed ethnic iden ty in a Qinghai, Gansu, Sichuan and Yunnan under an study report he published at the beginning of 2012, which independent Tibet. a racted a lot of a en on at the me. At the beginning of The ar cle also stated that the “Middle Way Approach” 2013 Zhu was moved to a secondary-level post, as the would never be accepted by the Chinese government, chair of the Subcommi ee of Ethnic and Religious Affairs sugges ng a con nuing hard-line stance on the Dalai of the CPPCC Na onal Commi ee, but he is s ll voicing his Lama. opinion on the sensi ve issue. The Dalai Lama has a empted to court Xi Jinping several A state-run paper openly cri cising a member of a CPPCC mes since the la er assumed power, even making Na onal Subcommi ee is very rare and what’s rarer s ll is reference to his friendship with Xi’s father Xi Zhongxun. that Zhu has not chosen to bear the cri cism in silence, The Dalai Lama has also consistently expressed a wish to mocking the paper for behaviour worthy of the Cultural visit Mount Wutai, but the comments from Xi suggest that Revolu on. This suggests that divisions exist within the this is unlikely. Communist Party on ethnic minority issues, specifically with regard to the governance of Tibet. Although the date of the celebra ons for the 50th anniversary of the establishment of the Tibet autonomous The hopes kindled by the talks between Zhu and Alai that region are yet to be announced, in previous years they China will reflect on its policy towards ethnic minori es have taken place on Sept. 1. and Tibet in par cular appear to have been ex nguished by Xi’s recent comments. Previously there had been sugges ons that changes were in the air for China’s policy on ethnic minori es and Tibet, when chair of the Subcommi ee of Ethnic and Religious Rule of law to ensure Tibet’s future Affairs of the CPPCC Na onal Commi ee Zhu Weiqun and peace, prosperity Alai, a Tibetan writer from Sichuan, held a series of discussions on the stability and development of Sichuan’s Global Times three Tibetan autonomous prefectures and the future of August 27, 2015 China’s ethnic minori es. In the just concluded sixth mee ng of the work of the Zhu stated in the discussion, “It is me for reflec on and Tibet Autonomous Region, Chinese President Xi Jinping changes to policy on ethnic minori es.” Although the idea raised a general plan for administering Tibet. Stressing of taking emphasis off ethnic differences in order to that na onal unity, consolida ng ethnic unity, and strengthen na onal iden ty is hardly new, many realising long-term and comprehensive social stability interpreted the discussion between Zhu and Alai as should be regarded as the primary task for the region, Xi said that the country should “firmly take the ini a ve” in
TIBET DIGEST AUGUST 2015 ! !5 the fight against separa sm, and adhere to the principle of China says it will never accept governing Tibet under the rule of law. ‘Middle Way’ solution to Tibet issues This year marks the 50th anniversary of the establishment of the Tibet Autonomous Region. The region has Tibet Post Interna onal Aug 26, 2015 witnessed rapid development during the half century, especially a er the adop on of a policy which requires different provinces to provide aid to designated areas in Tibet. According to a report from the People’s Daily, the region’s gross domes c product has rocketed from 3.7 billion yuan ($577 million) in 1993 to 92 billion yuan in 2014, while its local fiscal income reached 16.5 billion yuan, 104 mes more than the figure in 1993. All these achievements benefit from the long-term stability of society. However, under the surface of such frui ul development, separa sm, led by the Dalai Lama, has been con nuously causing turbulence in the region. Be it the March 14 riots in Lhasa in 2008, or the disrup on Special Envoy of His Holiness the Dalai Lama, Kasur Lodi Gyari, with Envoy of the Olympic torch relay in London and Paris, separa st Kelsang Gyaltsen during their mee ng with Vice Chairman of Chinese groups have brought blood, casual es, destruc on and People’s Poli cal Consulta ve Conference Du Qinglin during their mee ng on 30 January 2010 a ernoon. (Photo credit DIIR/CTA) splits among different ethnic groups in the country. Dharamshala — The Chinese central government will Given such a backdrop, the unswerving an -separa sm never accept the “Middle Way” proposed by the Dalai ba le is not only a keynote for the future Tibet policy, but Lama group, China’s United Front said in its official also a prerequisite to future peaceful development in this website in an ar cle pen-named Kelsang. Himalayan region. It also accords with Xi’s strategy ideas – “governing border areas is the key for governing a country, The ar cle was posted a er the Chinese Central while stabilising Tibet is the priority for governing border Government ended its sixth working conference on Tibet areas.” Tuesday in Beijing. The rule of law is the guarantee of social fairness and “The Central Government did not in the past, nor is now jus ce, and only by s cking to it can we avoid conflicts and and will not in the future accept the Middle Way solu on defuse tensions. to the Tibet issue,” reads the ar cle. Stressing the rule of law in Tibet means the country will The essen al intent of the ‘Middle Way’ is to split China, ” con nue the fight against separa sm, and crack down on adds the commentary , saying that the Dalai group refuses any behaviour that disrupts social stability. to accept China’s sovereignty in Tibet and wants to seize the reins of power and set up a semi-independent poli cal The rule of law also indicates that Tibet is guaranteed to regime.” have equal rights of development as any other regions in China. The development results, which other provinces In par cular, China is against the Dalai Lama’s proposal for are pursuing, are also bound to be realised in Tibet. a “high degree of autonomy” in Tibet, saying “the essence of ‘a high degree of autonomy’ is to setup ‘a state within a That’s why Xi also vowed to provide sustainable measures state’ free of any control from the central government. and preferen al policies to promote economic growth and social progress in the area. Stability and unity are the The ar cle recalls that the central government has founda on and the only way toward prosperity in Tibet. a ached great importance to Tibet, holding six Tibet working conferences since 1980, with the second one in 1984, the third one in 1994 , the fi h one in 2010 and the sixth conference ended just on Tuesday. Each Tibet working conference worked out specific measures to push forward Tibet’s economic development and secure social stability.
TIBET DIGEST AUGUST 2015 ! !6 On Tibetan Buddhism, the ar cle promotes “poli cal unity Many Uighurs have complained of harsh cultural and and respec ng religious belief ” saying the government is religious suppression as well as economic marginalisa on against intervening and limi ng Tibetan’s religious under Chinese rule, and have increasingly tried to flee the freedom. country. China has repeatedly accused Uighurs of joining However, the Central Tibetan Administra on (CTA) interna onal terror groups and has a empted to prevent repeatedly reaffirmed its commitment to the “Middle Way them from leaving. Approach” (MWA) of engaging China through dialogue to Following intense pressure by Beijing, Thailand last month achieve meaningful autonomy for all Tibetans, saying the returned over 100 Uighurs to China, in a move slammed Middle Way Approach, which neither seeks “Greater by many human rights groups. Tibet” nor a “high degree of autonomy”, but “genuine or FILE – Suspected Uighurs are transported back to a meaningful autonomy” for all Tibetan people under a deten on facility in the town of Songkhla in southern “single administra on.” Thailand a er visi ng women and children at a separate During the seventh round of talks in Beijing on 1 and 2 July shelter, March 26, 2014. 2008, the Tibetan side has presented to the Chinese China denies mistrea ng the Uighurs, arguing that it has leadership a Memorandum on Genuine Autonomy for the launched a massive campaign of economic development Tibetan people and Note on the Memorandum on in Xinjiang. It has also launched a massive security Genuine Autonomy for the Tibetan People, seeking crackdown in Xinjiang, which has been plagued by recent genuine autonomy for Tibet as enshrined in the Chinese violent a acks that Beijing has blamed on Islamic cons tu on and Law on Regional Na onal Autonomy. militants.
China Jails 45 in Unrest-Hit Xinjiang 50 years of connecting Tibet VoA – News People’s Daily Online August 27, 2015 August 26, 2015 Editor’s note: 2015 marks Tibet’s 50th anniversary of peaceful libera on. Located on the world’s highest plateau, Tibet used to be known for its underdeveloped transporta on system. Over the last half century, the Chinese government has been dedicated to modernising the connec ons on the roads, on the rails, and in the air. Here are eight public transporta on icons in Tibet.