AMS / MAA TEXTBOOKS VOL 23 Learning Modern Algebra From Early Attempts to Prove Fermat’s Last Theorem
Al Cuoco and Joseph J. Rotman i i “book2” — 2013/5/24 — 8:18 — page i — #1 i i
10.1090/text/023
Learning Modern Algebra
From Early Attempts to Prove Fermat’s Last Theorem
i i
i i i i “book2” — 2013/5/24 — 8:18 — page ii — #2 i i
c 2013 by The Mathematical Association of America (Incorporated) Library of Congress Control Number: 2013940990 Print ISBN: 978-1-93951-201-7 Electronic ISBN: 978-1-61444-612-5 Printed in the United States of America Current Printing (last digit): 10987654321
i i
i i i i “book2” — 2013/5/24 — 8:18 — page iii — #3 i i
Learning Modern Algebra
From Early Attempts to Prove Fermat’s Last Theorem
Al Cuoco EDC, Waltham MA and Joseph J. Rotman University of Illinois at Urbana–Champaign
Published and distributed by The Mathematical Association of America
i i
i i i i “book2” — 2013/5/24 — 8:18 — page iv — #4 i i
Committee on Books Frank Farris, Chair MAA Textbooks Editorial Board Zaven A. Karian, Editor Matthias Beck Richard E. Bedient Thomas A. Garrity Charles R. Hampton John Lorch Susan F. Pustejovsky Elsa J. Schaefer Stanley E. Seltzer Kay B. Somers
MAA TEXTBOOKS Bridge to Abstract Mathematics, Ralph W. Oberste-Vorth, Aristides Mouzakitis, and Bonita A. Lawrence Calculus Deconstructed:A Second Coursein First-Year Calculus, Zbigniew H. Nitecki Combinatorics: A Guided Tour, David R. Mazur Combinatorics: A Problem Oriented Approach, Daniel A. Marcus Complex Numbers and Geometry, Liang-shin Hahn A Course in Mathematical Modeling, Douglas Mooney and Randall Swift Cryptological Mathematics, Robert Edward Lewand Differential Geometry and its Applications, John Oprea Elementary Cryptanalysis, Abraham Sinkov Elementary Mathematical Models, Dan Kalman An Episodic History of Mathematics: Mathematical Culture Through Problem Solving, Steven G. Krantz Essentials of Mathematics, Margie Hale Field Theory and its Classical Problems, Charles Hadlock Fourier Series, Rajendra Bhatia Game Theory and Strategy, Philip D. Straffin Geometry Revisited, H. S. M. Coxeter and S. L. Greitzer Graph Theory: A Problem Oriented Approach, Daniel Marcus Knot Theory, Charles Livingston Learning Modern Algebra: From Early Attempts to Prove Fermat’s Last Theorem, Al Cuoco and and Joseph J. Rotman Lie Groups: A Problem-Oriented Introduction via Matrix Groups, Harriet Pollatsek Mathematical Connections: A Companion for Teachers and Others, Al Cuoco Mathematical Interest Theory, Second Edition, Leslie Jane Federer Vaaler and James W. Daniel
i i
i i i i “book2” — 2013/5/24 — 8:18 — page v — #5 i i
Mathematical Modeling in the Environment, Charles Hadlock Mathematics for BusinessDecisionsPart 1: Probability and Simulation (electronic text- book), Richard B. Thompson and Christopher G. Lamoureux Mathematics for Business DecisionsPart 2: Calculus and Optimization (electronic text- book), Richard B. Thompson and Christopher G. Lamoureux Mathematics for Secondary School Teachers, Elizabeth G. Bremigan, Ralph J. Bremi- gan, and John D. Lorch The Mathematics of Choice, Ivan Niven The Mathematics of Games and Gambling, Edward Packel Math Through the Ages, William Berlinghoff and Fernando Gouvea Noncommutative Rings, I. N. Herstein Non-Euclidean Geometry, H. S. M. Coxeter Number Theory Through Inquiry, David C. Marshall, Edward Odell, and Michael Star- bird A Primer of Real Functions, Ralph P. Boas A Radical Approach to Lebesgue’s Theory of Integration, David M. Bressoud A Radical Approach to Real Analysis, 2nd edition, David M. Bressoud Real Infinite Series, Daniel D. Bonar and Michael Khoury, Jr. Topology Now!, Robert Messer and Philip Straffin Understanding our Quantitative World, Janet Andersen and Todd Swanson
MAA Service Center P.O. Box 91112 Washington, DC 20090-1112 1-800-331-1MAA FAX: 1-301-206-9789
i i
i i i i “book2” — 2013/5/24 — 8:18 — page vi — #6 i i
i i
i i i i “book2” — 2013/5/24 — 8:18 — page vii — #7 i i
vii
Per Micky: Tutto quello che faccio, lo faccio per te.
i i
i i i i “book2” — 2013/5/24 — 8:18 — page viii — #8 i i
i i
i i i i “book2” — 2013/5/24 — 8:18 — page ix — #9 i i
Contents
Preface xiii SomeFeaturesofThisBook ...... xiv ANotetoStudents ...... xv ANotetoInstructors ...... xv
Notation xvii
1 Early Number Theory 1 1.1 AncientMathematics ...... 1 1.2 Diophantus ...... 7 GeometryandPythagoreanTriples ...... 8 TheMethodofDiophantus ...... 11 Fermat’sLastTheorem ...... 14 Connections:CongruentNumbers...... 16 1.3 Euclid...... 20 GreekNumberTheory...... 21 DivisionandRemainders ...... 22 LinearCombinationsandEuclid’sLemma ...... 24 EuclideanAlgorithm...... 30 1.4 NineFundamentalProperties ...... 36 1.5 Connections...... 41 Trigonometry ...... 41 Integration ...... 42
2 Induction 45 2.1 InductionandApplications ...... 45 UniqueFactorization...... 53 StrongInduction...... 57 DifferentialEquations ...... 60 2.2 BinomialTheorem ...... 63 Combinatorics ...... 69 2.3 Connections...... 73 AnApproachtoInduction ...... 73 FibonacciSequence ...... 75
3 Renaissance 81 3.1 ClassicalFormulas ...... 82 3.2 ComplexNumbers ...... 91 ix
i i
i i i i “book2” — 2013/5/29 — 16:18 — page x — #10 i i
x Contents
AlgebraicOperations ...... 92 AbsoluteValueandDirection ...... 99 TheGeometryBehindMultiplication ...... 101 3.3 RootsandPowers ...... 106 3.4 Connections:DesigningGoodProblems ...... 116 Norms ...... 116 PippinsandCheese ...... 118 Gaussian Integers: Pythagorean Triples Revisited ...... 119 EisensteinTriplesandDiophantus...... 122 NiceBoxes...... 123 NiceFunctionsforCalculusProblems ...... 124 LatticePointTriangles...... 126
4 Modular Arithmetic 131 4.1 Congruence ...... 131 4.2 PublicKeyCodes ...... 149 4.3 CommutativeRings...... 154 UnitsandFields ...... 160 SubringsandSubfields...... 166 4.4 Connections:JuliusandGregory ...... 169 4.5 Connections:PatternsinDecimalExpansions ...... 177 RealNumbers ...... 177 DecimalExpansionsofRationals ...... 179 PeriodsandBlocks...... 182
5 Abstract Algebra 191 5.1 DomainsandFractionFields ...... 192 5.2 Polynomials...... 196 PolynomialFunctions ...... 204 5.3 Homomorphisms ...... 206 ExtensionsofHomomorphisms ...... 213 Kernel,Image,andIdeals ...... 216 5.4 Connections:BooleanThings...... 221 Inclusion-Exclusion ...... 227
6 Arithmetic of Polynomials 233 6.1 Parallels to Z ...... 233 Divisibility...... 233 Roots...... 239 GreatestCommonDivisors ...... 243 UniqueFactorization...... 248 PrincipalIdealDomains ...... 255 6.2 Irreducibility ...... 259 RootsofUnity ...... 264 6.3 Connections:LagrangeInterpolation ...... 270
7 Quotients, Fields, and Classical Problems 277 7.1 QuotientRings ...... 277 7.2 FieldTheory...... 287 Characteristics ...... 287 ExtensionFields ...... 289
i i
i i i i “book2” — 2013/5/24 — 8:18 — page xi — #11 i i
Contents xi
AlgebraicExtensions ...... 293 SplittingFields...... 300 ClassificationofFiniteFields ...... 305 7.3 Connections:Ruler–CompassConstructions ...... 308 Constructing Regular n-gons ...... 320 Gauss’sconstructionofthe17-gon ...... 322
8 Cyclotomic Integers 329 8.1 ArithmeticinGaussianandEisensteinIntegers ...... 330 EuclideanDomains ...... 333 8.2 PrimesUpstairsandPrimesDownstairs ...... 337 LawsofDecomposition ...... 339 8.3 Fermat’sLastTheoremforExponent3 ...... 349 Preliminaries...... 350 TheFirstCase ...... 351 Gauss’sProofoftheSecondCase ...... 354 8.4 ApproachestotheGeneralCase ...... 359 Cyclotomicintegers ...... 360 Kummer,IdealNumbers,andDedekind...... 365 8.5 Connections:CountingSumsofSquares ...... 371 AProofofFermat’sTheoremonDivisors ...... 373
9 Epilog 379 9.1 AbelandGalois...... 379 9.2 SolvabilitybyRadicals ...... 381 9.3 Symmetry...... 384 9.4 Groups...... 389 9.5 WilesandFermat’sLastTheorem ...... 396 EllipticIntegralsandEllipticFunctions ...... 397 CongruentNumbersRevisited...... 400 EllipticCurves...... 404
A Appendices 409 A.1 Functions ...... 409 A.2 EquivalenceRelations...... 420 A.3 VectorSpaces ...... 424 BasesandDimension ...... 427 LinearTransformations ...... 435 A.4 Inequalities ...... 441 A.5 GeneralizedAssociativity...... 442 A.6 ACyclotomicIntegerCalculator ...... 444 EisensteinIntegers ...... 445 SymmetricPolynomials ...... 446 AlgebrawithPeriods...... 446
References 449
Index 451
About the Authors 459
i i
i i i i “book2” — 2013/5/24 — 8:18 — page xii — #12 i i
i i
i i i i “book2” — 2013/5/24 — 8:18 — page xiii — #13 i i
Preface
This book is designed for college students who want to teach mathematics in high school, but it can serve as a text for standard abstract algebra courses as well. First courses in abstract algebra usually cover number theory, groups, and commutative rings. We have found that the first encounter with groups is not only inadequate for future teachers of high school mathematics, it is also unsatisfying for other mathematics students. Hence, we focus here on number theory, polynomials, and commutative rings. We introduce groups in our last chapter, for the earlier discussion of commutative rings allows us to explain how groups are used to prove Abel’s Theorem: there is no generalization of the quadratic, cubic, and quartic formulas giving the roots of the general quintic polynomial. A modest proposal: undergraduate abstract algebra should be a sequence of two courses, with number theory and commutative rings in the first course, and groups and linear algebra (with scalars in arbitrary fields) in the second. We invoke an historically accurate organizing principle: Fermat’s Last The- orem (in Victoriantimes, the title of this book wouldhave been Learning Mod- ern Algebra by Studying Early Attempts, Especially Those in the Nineteenth Century, that Tried to Prove Fermat’s Last Theorem Using Elementary Meth- ods). To be sure, another important problem at that time that contributed to modern algebra was the search for formulas giving the roots of polynomials. This search is intertwined with the algebra involved in Fermat’s Last Theo- rem, and we do treat this part of algebra as well. The difference between our approach and the standard approach is one of emphasis: the natural direction for us is towards algebraic number theory, whereas the usual direction is to- wards Galois theory. Four thousand years ago, the quadratic formula and the Pythagorean The- orem were seen to be very useful. To teach them to new generations, it was best to avoid square roots (which, at the time, were complicated to compute), and so problems were designed to have integer solutions. This led to Pythag- orean triples: positive integers a;b;c satisfying a2 b2 c2. Two thousand years ago, all such triples were found and, when studyingC D them in the seven- teenth century, Fermat wondered whether there are positive integer solutions to an bn cn for n>2. He claimed in a famous marginal note that there are noC solutions,D but only his proof of the case n 4 is known. This problem, called Fermat’s Last Theorem, intrigued many ofD the finest mathematicians, but it long resisted all attempts to solve it. Finally, using sophisticated tech- niques of algebraic geometry developed at the end of the twentieth century, Andrew Wiles proved Fermat’s Last Theorem in 1995.
xiii
i i
i i i i “book2” — 2013/5/24 — 8:18 — page xiv — #14 i i
xiv Preface
Before its solution, Fermat’s Last Theorem was a challenge to mathemati- cians (as climbing Mount Everest was a challenge to mountaineers). There are no dramatic applicationsof the result, but it is yet another triumph of human in- tellect.What is trueis that,over thecourseof 350 years, much of contemporary mathematics was invented and developed in trying to deal with it. The num- ber theory recorded in Euclid was shown to have similarities with the behavior of polynomials, and generalizations of prime numbers and unique factoriza- tion owe their initial study to attempts at proving Fermat’s Last Theorem. But these topics are also intimately related to what is actually taught in high school. Thus, abstract algebra is not merely beautiful and interesting, but it is also a valuable, perhaps essential, topic for understanding high school mathematics.
Some Features of This Book We include sections in every chapter, called Connections, in which we explic- itly show how the material up to that point can help the reader understand and implement the mathematics that high school teachers use in their profession. This may include the many ways that results in abstract algebra connect with core high school ideas, such as solving equations or factoring. But it may also include mathematics for teachers themselves, that may or may not end up “on the blackboard;” things like the use of abstract algebra to make up good prob- lems, to understand the foundations of topics in the curriculum, and to place the topics in the larger landscape of mathematics as a scientific discipline. Many students studying abstract algebra have problems understanding proofs; even though they can follow each step of a proof, they wonder how anyone could have discovered its argument in the first place. To address such problems, we have tried to strike a balance between giving a logical develop- ment of results (so the reader can see how everything fits together in a coherent package) and discussing the messier kinds of thinking that lead to discovery and proofs. A nice aspect of this sort of presentation is that readers participate in doing mathematics as they learn it. One way we implement this balance is our use of several design features, such as the Connections sections described above. Here are some others. Sidenotes provide advice, comments, and pointers to other parts of the text related to the topic at hand. What could be more fitting for a book related to Fermat’s Last Theorem than to have large margins? Interspersed in the text are boxed “callouts,” such as How to Think About It, which suggest how ideas in the text may have been conceived in the first place, how we view the ideas, and what we guess underlies the formal exposition. Some other callouts are: Historical Note, which provides some historical background. It often helps to understand mathematical ideas if they are placed in historical con- text; besides, it’s interesting. The biographies are based on those in the MacTutor History of Mathematics Archive of the School of Mathemat- ics and Statistics, University of St. Andrews, Scotland. It can be found on the internet: its URL is www-history.mcs.st-andrews.ac.uk Etymology, which traces out the origin of some mathematical terms. We believe that knowing the etymology of terms often helps to understand the ideas they name.
i i
i i i i “book2” — 2013/5/24 — 8:18 — page xv — #15 i i
Preface xv
Etymology. The word mathematics comes from classical Greek; it means “knowledge,” “something learned.” But in ancient Rome through the thirteenth century, it meant “astronomy” and “astrology.” From the Middle Ages, it acquired its present meaning. The word arithmetic comes from the Greek word meaning “the art of counting.” The word geometry, in classical Greek, meant “science of measuring;” it arose from an earlier term meaning “land survey.”
It is a pleasure to acknowledge those who have contributed valuable com- ments, suggestions, ideas, and help. We thank Don Albers, Carol Baxter, Bruce Berndt, Peter Braunfeld, Keith Conrad, Victoria Corkery, Don DeLand, Ben Conrad’s website Fischer, Andrew Granville, Heini Halberstam, Zaven Karian, Tsit-Yuen Lam, www.math.uconn.edu/ Paul Monsky, Beverly Ruedi, Glenn Stevens, and Stephen Ullom. ˜kconrad/blurbs/ is full of beautiful ideas.
A Note to Students
The heart of a mathematics course lies in its problems. We have tried to or- chestrate them to help you build a solid understanding of the mathematics in the sections. Everything afterward will make much more sense if you work through as many exercises as you can, especially those that appear difficult. Quite often, you will learn something valuable from an exercise even if you don’t solve it completely. For example, a problem you can’t solve may show that you haven’t fully understood an idea you thought you knew; or it may force you to discover a fact that needs to be established to finish the solution. There are two special kinds of exercises. Those labeled Preview may seem to have littleto do withthesection at hand; they are designed to foreshadow upcoming topics, often with numerical ex- periments. Those labeled Take it Further develop interesting ideas that are connected to the main themes of the text, but are somewhat off the beaten path. They are not essential for understanding what comes later in the text. An exercise marked with an asterisk, such as 1.8*, means that it is either used in some proof or it is referred to elsewhere in the text. For ease of finding such exercises, all references to them have the form “Exercise 1.8 on page 6” givingboth its number and the number of the page on which it occurs.
A Note to Instructors
We recommend giving reading assignments to preview upcoming material. This contributesto balancing experience and formality as described above, and it saves time. Many important pages can be read and understood by students, and they shouldbe discussed inclass onlyif studentsask questions about them. It is possible to use thisbook as a text for a three hour one-semester course, but we strongly recommend that it be taught four hours per week.
—Al Cuoco and Joe Rotman
i i
i i i i “book2” — 2013/5/24 — 8:18 — page xvi — #16 i i
i i
i i i i “book2” — 2013/5/24 — 8:18 — page xvii — #17 i i
Notation
.a; b; c/ 4 triangle with sides of lengths a;b;c ABC 4 triangle with vertices A; B; C N 21 natural numbers Z 21 integers a b 21 a is a divisor of b j gcd.a; b/ 24 greatest common divisor x 29 greatest integer in x b c Q 36 rational numbers R 36 real numbers 46 implies ) lcm.a; b/ 55 least common multiple n r 63 binomial coefficient .z/ 92 real part of complex number z <