1991-07: the Story of Reflexes
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
VII liliLdi gp e IRa~dln~o by PETER LANKSHEAR The story of `Reflexes' This month's column is not about rubber hammers and kneecaps, but a technology that persisted throughout the history of valve radio, and one that was exploited to its greatest extent in Australia. With semiconductors available today tal detector and then reflexed the audio valves coincided with a boom in at only a few cents apiece, it is difficult back to the grid of the valve to again `midget' radios, and an increasing de- to appreciate just how expensive ampli- amplify the signal. Any problems like mand for car radios. Economies in space fication was in the early days of radio. erratic operation and distortion were of and battery consumption became import- Not only valves, but every milliampere- little consequence. ant, providing an incentive to resurrect hour of precious battery power cost a lot reflexing. of money. Any way to economise was Early superhet use From late 1933 the Americans, espe- well received. An early 'high tech' application of re- cially RCA, made some use of the 6B7 in During World War 1, much research flexing was in Edwin Armstrong's first car radios as a reflexed IF and trans- went into triode valve applications. One generation of RCA superheterodynes, in former-coupled audio amplifier, with the US Navy worker, W.H. Priess, patented 1924. To keep the number of valves to a one valve providing IF and AF amplifi- the concept of passing a signal twice minimum, the first valve was used as an cation, diode detection and AGC. This through the one valve — once at RF and RF amplifier, and then again as the first was an effective system, but a problem then, after detection, at audio frequen- IF stage operating at about 50kHz. was that it was practically impossible to cies. Provided that there was no over- After 1925, as valves became cheaper, make an inexpensive wide range audio loading, with `reflexing' (as it was and users became more critical of its coupling transformer with sufficient in- called) one valve could, theoretically, do complications and limitations, reflexing ductance for pentodes such as the 6B7. the work of two. was generally abandoned. But during The result was a restricted audio re- There seems to have been little im- 1932, the 6B7 and 2B7 double-diode- sponse — acceptable enough in a car, but mediate interest, but with the advent of pentodes, and the 6F7 triode-pentode ap- inadequate for a domestic receiver. broadcasting, reflexing became an at- peared. Each had a general purpose With its pentode section used as an RF tractive proposition to manufacturers pentode suitable for both RF and AF am- or IF amplifier and the triode as an audio and experimenters. Notable 1922 models plification. The triode of the 6F7 was amplifier or detector, the 6F7 soon be- were Marconi's two valve V2, and De suitable as a detector or audio amplifier, came a popular alternative to reflexing Forest's D7 with three valves. Similarly and the diodes in the other valves were for economical and compact receivers — many enthusiasts used their one precious for detection and AGC. typical Australian examples being the valve as an RF amplifier feeding a crys- The arrival of these multifunction 1933 Healing 44F and Stromberg Carl- Regenerator Unit CIRCUIT DIAGRAM OF THE MARCONIPHONE V.2 RECEIVER Figl: One of the earliest British receivers made commercially was the 1922 Marconi W22', a reflex with the first valve combining the functions of RF and AFamplifler. Marconi used plug-in 'pancake' coils, tuned by adjustable copper 'spades 86 ELECTRONICS Australia, July 1991 O-?1f high, a less complex system became pop- ular for economical receivers. Many Eu- A-337 r !~ ropean output pentodes, such as the PENA4, AL3, and EL3 had very high 6F7 12A7 mutual conductances — typically g A-243 9mA/V, compared with the 2.5mA/V of E i A-340 the standard 2A5, 42 and 6F6 pentodes available in the US. With an efficient IF amplifier it was possible to eliminate the audio voltage amplifier, by driving these high gain valves directly from a diode detector. A-34/JI The EL3 even had diodes incorpo- (orA-339) R-263 rated, to become the EBL1 for this ser- R-138-4b1. vice. Unfortunately the EBL1 was a very R-255 tall valve, limiting its use in compact U-fOorU-fff f2A7 6F7 receivers. Circuit of the final run on the Kadette Jr., Modal F. Some early Australian sets such as the 1933 Astor OX, and a few New Zealand Fig.2: Using two double valves and a classic example of reflexing from 1933, the `Ultimate' sets, did use this arrangement International Kadette Jr was a 'midget' which could be fitted into an overcoat but their use of the insensitive American pocket. The pentode section of the 6F7 was both RF and AF amp, with volume pentodes was a serious limitation. Later, controlled by varying its screen voltage. The triode section of the same valve was the Radio & Hobbies `Little General', used as a grid-leak detector. Note the absence of a power transformer. using the higher gain beam tetrode 6V6G, was quite successful in good re- son 564. Some writers confused this with If AGC was used, there was 'play ception areas. reflexing, but the concept was quite dif- through', or significant audio output ferent — multiple valves within the one even with the volume control at zero. As By 1937 reflexing had been pretty well envelope, rather than multiple use of a the control was advanced, there was a abandoned in America, but not so in this single valve. `minimum volume' effect accompanied part of the World. New Zealand's Ulti- However the American firm Interna- by distortion. As a compromise, some mate produced a small four-valve reflex tional did reflex the 6F7 in their unique receivers did not use AGC, but had the during the period 1937-39, but Australia 1933 `Kadette' TRF series. Claimed as manual volume control ahead of the IF became the real stronghold of reflexing. 'The World's Smallest Radio' (for amplifier. `World' read `America'), a Kadette could Other problems included distortion at The great Aussie reflex be fitted into an overcoat pocket. They high modulation levels, and total re- The second generation of reflexing had only two valves, combining the ceiver gain was significantly less than was to be taken up enthusiastically in functions of RF amplifier, grid leak de- with the use an extra valve in a conven- Australia — particularly by AWA, who tector, two AF stages and mains rectifier! tional receiver. in 1934 introduced the fust of their re- Emerson and RCA made some small In Europe, where signal strengths were flexed Radiolettes, the model 27. reflexed domestic superheterodynes in the mid 1930's, but they resorted to a resistive audio load for the 6B7. This compromise improved the audio perfor- mance, but created a serious limitation for IF/AF reflexing that was never fully overcome. Limitations There is insufficient space here to cover all aspects of reflex design. Read- ers interested in a full discussion are re- ferred to the classic Radiotron Designer's Handbook, where an entire chapter was devoted to reflexing. Briefly, to obtain a reasonable audio gain, the anode load resistor of the re- flexed amplifier needed be of the order of 50k to 100k ohms. At the same time, RADIO ANC/ N0R011 for an acceptable IF performance, at least REFLEX RECEIVER 100 volts were needed at the anode. With 24OV HT supplies normally around 250V, the DRAWNM W maximum current through the anode re- Fig.3: This 1952 'Radio & Hobbles' design represents the final development of the sistor was therefore restricted to less than Australian reflex, with the screen grid of the 6AR7-GT IF valve acting as the audio 2mA — inadequate for good IF amplifier stage anode. Breakthrough and low level distortion could be avoided only by performance. using a manual gain control. ELECTRONICS Australia, July 1991 87 VINTAGE RADIO Anienns Despite the shortcomings of reflexing, 000>M. f the little five valve Radiolettes proved to y lktiziargavyerf C—, be very popular with the public, although -1f------ AblbrCä7 .0 less so with servicemen! a,T vx 49,50 With more gain than a straight five- valve receiver, their extra sensitivity A could be useful. Shortwave models were 41111, O added to the range in 1936. Other firms OAS • too found a demand for reflexes. The Flg.4: The wheel goes 1938 Australian Official Radio Service 401. full circle! At right is the 411, Manual lists eight different brands of re- National one valve reflex flex receiver, including battery powered for hobbyists, dating GM versions. from 1925, while below is 001 Au: arc* For about 15 years Australia persisted its solid state equivalent, anans' - with the reflex. AWV even developed described 37 years later agar '•• 1 valves more suited to reflexing than the by Jim Rowe in the then whiv Nand Hobbies 1 -TUBE semi variable-mu 6B7 and its octal `Radlo, Rhea 10s" REFLEX equivalent, the 6B8G. There was an ex- tended-cutoff and better shielded ver- X4r' sion, the 6B7S, and later in octal form, 0 0 0 the 6G8G. Then in 1949 came the unique -A +A tB lead shielded 6AR7GT, with more than -B If r. double the transconductance of the 6B7. An interesting but late improvement came in November 1947, from a Radio REACTION & Hobbies reader, S.L. Marsh of 10K .0047 HIGH Belmore in NSW. By using the screen IMPEDANCE grid of the reflexed valve as a triode PHONES anode at audio frequencies, the pentode anode could be run at full current and voltage.