DOCSLIB.ORG

On Bengal: a Post-Mortem "N a R a D"

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
On Bengal: a Post-Mortem THE ECONOMIC WEEKLY August 15, 1952 On Bengal: A Post-Mortem "N a r a d" EOPLE keep on asking: What identifying themselves with the Congress had the unfortunate effect P has happened to Bengal? But Indian National Congress. The of isolating Bengal from the rest of my question is: Does Bengal exist Gandhian credo of non-violence was, India. What is more, it accentuat­ today? There are, of course, East however, an object of ridicule to ed the anti-Bengalee feeling that Bengal and West Bengal. But, them . It was the mass-character of was brewing all over India because alas! Bengal is no more. This, in the movement that appealed to of a number of historic causes. 'a nutshell, is what has happened to their pragmatic mind. C. R. Das Naturally, it was the Congress orga­ Bengal. with his call of l Swaraj for the nisation in Bengal that received the L need not go into the causes or masses' captured the imagination severest jolt from Subhas's secession the rationale of Partition-politics. of these revolutionaries even more from it. Indeed, Congress in Ben­ It is the reaction of the Partition than Gandhiji with his innocuous gal was - threatened with complete with which I am concerned at the charka. However, they decided to extinction. moment. give Gandhian leadership a chance. True, there were the orthodox One thing is sure: Partition After his resignation from the ICS khadi elements. But they were seems to have caught us quite Subhas found himself in close asso­ neither united enough nor organi­ a wares., If our leaders had any ciation with these" revolutionaries, sationally competent to shoulder notion about its possible effects, also. Inevitably, the: British Gov­ the burden of Congress leadership their pre-partition activities and ernment and its indigenous allies in Bengal. The khadi elements utterances furnish little proof of sensed a danger in this new com­ were divided into three groups with their prescience. This dismal failure bine. So the top-ranking among little or no co-ordination among on their part to anticipate the the Jugantar revolutionaries, Bhu- them. The Khadi Pratisthan of results of the Partition as also their pen Datta, A run Cuha, Suren Satish Das Gupta was far too aloof failure to prepare the public mind Ghosh, Jiban Ghatterjee, Suresh and isolated to be in the thick of for those results show a mental Das were placed under arrest along active1 politics while the Abhay lacuna that is almost incredible. with Subhas and were deported to Ashram group of Dr Prafulla Ghosh Our leaders seem to have staked Burma to be kept under detention and Arambag group of Prafulla everything on the hope that the there. After the death of C. R. Sen (the present Supply Minister therapeutics of freedom would do Das, with Jugantar leaders along in West Bengal Cabinet) were too the trick and all would be well in with Subhas in detention, the poli­ limited in their outlook to take the end. But that hope has proved tical situation in Bengal drifted to upon themselves the leadership of a chimera. True, the end is yet factional feuds over the Calcutta the Congress. At that juncture of to be. But that, again, is little Corporation affairs which have our national life it. was the jugantar consolation in our present predica­ continued to dominate Bengal poli­ group winch stepped in and stood ment. tics eve: since. The " Big five ' by the Congress. But like what Bengal, like Prance, is a party- Cabal of Bengal which came into had happened at Calvary, the savi­ striken country, where, if anywhere being then, in the late 'twenties, ours could not save- themselves. in India, people try and make an have in varying degrees wielded an The new BPCC that was formed intellectual approach to every issue. influence over Bengal politics not began to function with vigour and But this intellectualism draws its always wholesome nor entirely determination for its General Secre­ inner sustenance from a unique healthy for it. Of the Big Five, tary Arun Guha Believed in activis- emotionalism inherent in the genius Sarat Bose is no more. Of the ing the organisation down to its of the Bengalee people. remaining four, Tulsi Goswamy has lowest units. It was going ahead The intellect is at a discount virtually faded out from public life and getting into its stride when now-a-days. The fashion is to while Ninnal Chandra Ch under British Government struck again as decry an intellectual. So an intel­ seems to have staged a come-back it had done in the past at all psy- lectual of intellectuals, Jean Paul to politics this year as the Mayor etiological movements. And Arun Sartre says, an intellectual is never of the Calcutta Corporation. Of Guha found himself .in detention a true revolutionary; he is just good course, NaJini-Bidhau partnership again along with a number of his enough to be an assassin. This is (between NaliniRanjan Sarkar and close associates. only an obiter dictum that one need Dr B. C. Roy) is still going strong From now on the situation in not accept. The revolutionary Sarat Bose's historic indictment Bengal was one of confusion and movement in Bengal was not mere of Naliniraajan notwithstanding. chaos because of the war and fire-works as staid politicians may To take up the thread of my famine on the one hand and riot- imagine. Both in its initial and narrative, the long absence of the psychosis on the other. evolutional .stages, it reveals an Jugantar leaders behind prison bars, The Communist Party, as is very intellectual leadership rare in the —some of them could have cele­ natural for it, sought to rish in the history of revolutionary movements brated their Silver Jubilee of prison- troubled waters and it achieved a anywhere in the world. There were life-and a mysterious change in measure of success also for it could political realists in this movement Subhas's party-affiliation in the secure even Congress leaders of the who could set- beyond a slogan and mid-'thirties very adversely affected eminence of Mrs Sarojini Naidu could intelligently plan for the progressive movements in Bengal and Dr Bidhan Roy to identify Future. politics. So it was a dismal day themselves with certain aspects of Therefore, with Gandhiji's advent for Bengal when Subhas finally its activities. Dr Roy is reported in Indian polities, we find the broke away from the Gandhian to have sent a letter to Gandhiji at Jugantar group of revolutionaries leadership. Subhas's break with the about this time denouncing his 818 THE ECONOMIC WEEKLY August 15, 1952 leadership, mand that nobody could offer him- Nalini Sankar and Dr Roy were Dr Shyamaprasad,: with his voce- self for election on the Congress Avoided during the general and ferous advocacy of national com- ticket from behind the prison bars. Constituent ' Assembly elections. immalism was, of course, playing An exception was made in the case Extremely touchy by nature, Dr Roy his usual role. And the only Con­ of only one jugantar Ieader. So by seems to have made a serious gress leader of status outside the the time Arun Guha, Bhupen Datta, grievance of it and his subsequent prison, Kiron Sankar Roy, was Manoranjan Gupta and others were break with the Jugantar is believed playing a good younger brother's released, things had begun to drift to have been at least partially due role to Shyamaprasad. The release and undesirables were more and to his pique over this issue. of Suren Ghosh did not bring any more being pushed to the forefront. Sarat Bose had again broken relief for with A run Guha, Bhupen Arun Guha was not reinstalled as away from the Congress and had Datta, Manoranjan Gupta still in the General Secretary of the been busy organising a party of his jail, he was completely overwhelm­ BPCC though according to the own on the scheme of Independent ed by the fast developing situation constitution and practice he should Bengal. The question of electing a in the country. Sarat Bose was have been. Indeed, coming events leader of the Congress Assembly also released at about the same time cast their shadows before. Party loomed large before the West and his spectacular return to Con­ On the eve of the Partition and Bengal Congress legislators. The gress in a blaze of glory robbed transfer of power, group alignments obvious choice was, of course, Suren Ghosh of much of his effec­ in Bengal politics were, as was Kiron Sankar Roy who had been tiveness even though he was reinstal­ perhaps natural before such cata­ functioning as the leader of the led as the President of the BPCC. clysmic changes, very fluid. It is Opposition for so long in the Ben­ So the Parliamentary Board that interesting to note that neither Dr gal Assembly. But Kiron Sankar was formed to run the general Bidhan Roy nor Nalini Sarkar sprang a surprise by refusing to elections was almost entirely domi­ was in the picture at all. Dr stand for the election. He made nated by Sarat Bose, though Dr Roy's stock was so low that he it clear that he had opted for East Ghosh and Prafulla Sen managed even failed to get himself elected Bengal in his own mind and could to snatch away quite a number of as an alderman of the Calcutta not therefore offer himself for elec­ seats for their respective groups. Corporation of which he was a tion. It was, I am sure, an act of The only group, and the dominant Mayor for so long.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Nationalism in India Lesson
    DC-1 SEM-2 Paper: Nationalism in India Lesson: Beginning of constitutionalism in India Lesson Developer: Anushka Singh Research scholar, Political Science, University of Delhi 1 Institute of Lifelog learning, University of Delhi Content: Introducing the chapter What is the idea of constitutionalism A brief history of the idea in the West and its introduction in the colony The early nationalists and Indian Councils Act of 1861 and 1892 More promises and fewer deliveries: Government of India Acts, 1909 and 1919 Post 1919 developments and India’s first attempt at constitution writing Government of India Act 1935 and the building blocks to a future constitution The road leading to the transfer of power The theory of constitutionalism at work Conclusion 2 Institute of Lifelog learning, University of Delhi Introduction: The idea of constitutionalism is part of the basic idea of liberalism based on the notion of individual’s right to liberty. Along with other liberal notions,constitutionalism also travelled to India through British colonialism. However, on the one hand, the ideology of liberalism guaranteed the liberal rightsbut one the other hand it denied the same basic right to the colony. The justification to why an advanced liberal nation like England must colonize the ‘not yet’ liberal nation like India was also found within the ideology of liberalism itself. The rationale was that British colonialism in India was like a ‘civilization mission’ to train the colony how to tread the path of liberty.1 However, soon the English educated Indian intellectual class realised the gap between the claim that British Rule made and the oppressive and exploitative reality of colonialism.Consequently,there started the movement towards autonomy and self-governance by Indians.
    [Show full text]
  • The Great Calcutta Killings Noakhali Genocide
    1946 : THE GREAT CALCUTTA KILLINGS AND NOAKHALI GENOCIDE 1946 : THE GREAT CALCUTTA KILLINGS AND NOAKHALI GENOCIDE A HISTORICAL STUDY DINESH CHANDRA SINHA : ASHOK DASGUPTA No part of this publication can be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise without the prior permission of the author and the publisher. Published by Sri Himansu Maity 3B, Dinabandhu Lane Kolkata-700006 Edition First, 2011 Price ` 500.00 (Rupees Five Hundred Only) US $25 (US Dollars Twenty Five Only) © Reserved Printed at Mahamaya Press & Binding, Kolkata Available at Tuhina Prakashani 12/C, Bankim Chatterjee Street Kolkata-700073 Dedication In memory of those insatiate souls who had fallen victims to the swords and bullets of the protagonist of partition and Pakistan; and also those who had to undergo unparalleled brutality and humility and then forcibly uprooted from ancestral hearth and home. PREFACE What prompted us in writing this Book. As the saying goes, truth is the first casualty of war; so is true history, the first casualty of India’s struggle for independence. We, the Hindus of Bengal happen to be one of the worst victims of Islamic intolerance in the world. Bengal, which had been under Islamic attack for centuries, beginning with the invasion of the Turkish marauder Bakhtiyar Khilji eight hundred years back. We had a respite from Islamic rule for about two hundred years after the English East India Company defeated the Muslim ruler of Bengal. Siraj-ud-daulah in 1757. But gradually, Bengal had been turned into a Muslim majority province.
    [Show full text]
  • Dictionary of Martyrs: India's Freedom Struggle
    DICTIONARY OF MARTYRS INDIA’S FREEDOM STRUGGLE (1857-1947) Vol. 5 Andhra Pradesh, Telangana, Karnataka, Tamil Nadu & Kerala ii Dictionary of Martyrs: India’s Freedom Struggle (1857-1947) Vol. 5 DICTIONARY OF MARTYRSMARTYRS INDIA’S FREEDOM STRUGGLE (1857-1947) Vol. 5 Andhra Pradesh, Telangana, Karnataka, Tamil Nadu & Kerala General Editor Arvind P. Jamkhedkar Chairman, ICHR Executive Editor Rajaneesh Kumar Shukla Member Secretary, ICHR Research Consultant Amit Kumar Gupta Research and Editorial Team Ashfaque Ali Md. Naushad Ali Md. Shakeeb Athar Muhammad Niyas A. Published by MINISTRY OF CULTURE, GOVERNMENT OF IDNIA AND INDIAN COUNCIL OF HISTORICAL RESEARCH iv Dictionary of Martyrs: India’s Freedom Struggle (1857-1947) Vol. 5 MINISTRY OF CULTURE, GOVERNMENT OF INDIA and INDIAN COUNCIL OF HISTORICAL RESEARCH First Edition 2018 Published by MINISTRY OF CULTURE Government of India and INDIAN COUNCIL OF HISTORICAL RESEARCH 35, Ferozeshah Road, New Delhi - 110 001 © ICHR & Ministry of Culture, GoI No part of this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording, or any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher. ISBN 978-81-938176-1-2 Printed in India by MANAK PUBLICATIONS PVT. LTD B-7, Saraswati Complex, Subhash Chowk, Laxmi Nagar, New Delhi 110092 INDIA Phone: 22453894, 22042529 [email protected] State Co-ordinators and their Researchers Andhra Pradesh & Telangana Karnataka (Co-ordinator) (Co-ordinator) V. Ramakrishna B. Surendra Rao S.K. Aruni Research Assistants Research Assistants V. Ramakrishna Reddy A.B. Vaggar I. Sudarshan Rao Ravindranath B.Venkataiah Tamil Nadu Kerala (Co-ordinator) (Co-ordinator) N.
    [Show full text]
  • Conspiracy Rises Again Racial Sympathy and Radical Solidarity Across Empires
    Conspiracy Rises Again Racial Sympathy and Radical Solidarity across Empires poulomi saha When in 1925 members of the Jugantar, a secret revolutionary asso- ciation in colonial India, began to conceive of what they believed to be a more effective strategy of anticolonial revolt than that of non- violence promoted at the time by the mainstream Congress Party in Chittagong, they chose for themselves a new name: the Indian Re- publican Army (IRA). In so doing, they explicitly constructed a rev- olutionary genealogy from which their future actions were to draw inspiration, a direct link between the anticolonial revolt in East Ben- gal and the 1916 Easter Uprising in Ireland.1 The 1930 attack on the Chittagong Armory, the first in a series of revolutionary actions tak- en by the IRA, also marked the anniversary of the Irish rebellion. The very language of Irish revolt seeped into the practices of the Indian organization as they smuggled in illegal copies of the writings of Dan Breen and Éamon de Valera and began each meeting with a reading of the Proclamation of the Irish Provisional Government. The ideological and textual kinship between these two anticolo- nial communities and another former holding of the British empire, the United States, illuminates transcolonial circuits that formed a qui parle Vol. 28, No. 2, December 2019 doi 10.1215/10418385-7861837 © 2019 Editorial Board, Qui Parle Downloaded from https://read.dukeupress.edu/qui-parle/article-pdf/28/2/307/740477/307saha.pdf by UNIV CA BERKELEY PERIODICALS user on 05 February 2020 308 qui parle december 2019 vol.
    [Show full text]
  • Swap an Das' Gupta Local Politics
    SWAP AN DAS' GUPTA LOCAL POLITICS IN BENGAL; MIDNAPUR DISTRICT 1907-1934 Theses submitted in fulfillment of the Doctor of Philosophy degree, School of Oriental and African Studies, University of London, 1980, ProQuest Number: 11015890 All rights reserved INFORMATION TO ALL USERS The quality of this reproduction is dependent upon the quality of the copy submitted. In the unlikely event that the author did not send a com plete manuscript and there are missing pages, these will be noted. Also, if material had to be removed, a note will indicate the deletion. uest ProQuest 11015890 Published by ProQuest LLC(2018). Copyright of the Dissertation is held by the Author. All rights reserved. This work is protected against unauthorized copying under Title 17, United States C ode Microform Edition © ProQuest LLC. ProQuest LLC. 789 East Eisenhower Parkway P.O. Box 1346 Ann Arbor, Ml 48106- 1346 Abstract This thesis studies the development and social character of Indian nationalism in the Midnapur district of Bengal* It begins by showing the Government of Bengal in 1907 in a deepening political crisis. The structural imbalances caused by the policy of active intervention in the localities could not be offset by the ’paternalistic* and personalised district administration. In Midnapur, the situation was compounded by the inability of government to secure its traditional political base based on zamindars. Real power in the countryside lay in the hands of petty landlords and intermediaries who consolidated their hold in the economic environment of growing commercialisation in agriculture. This was reinforced by a caste movement of the Mahishyas which injected the district with its own version of 'peasant-pride'.
    [Show full text]
  • The Black Hole of Empire
    Th e Black Hole of Empire Th e Black Hole of Empire History of a Global Practice of Power Partha Chatterjee Princeton University Press Princeton and Oxford Copyright © 2012 by Princeton University Press Requests for permission to reproduce material from this work should be sent to Permissions, Princeton University Press Published by Princeton University Press, 41 William Street, Princeton, New Jersey 08540 In the United Kingdom: Princeton University Press, 6 Oxford Street, Woodstock, Oxfordshire OX20 1TW press.princeton.edu All Rights Reserved Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Chatterjee, Partha, 1947- Th e black hole of empire : history of a global practice of power / Partha Chatterjee. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978-0-691-15200-4 (hardcover : alk. paper)— ISBN 978-0-691-15201-1 (pbk. : alk. paper) 1. Bengal (India)—Colonization—History—18th century. 2. Black Hole Incident, Calcutta, India, 1756. 3. East India Company—History—18th century. 4. Imperialism—History. 5. Europe—Colonies—History. I. Title. DS465.C53 2011 954'.14029—dc23 2011028355 British Library Cataloging-in-Publication Data is available Th is book has been composed in Adobe Caslon Pro Printed on acid-free paper. ∞ Printed in the United States of America 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 To the amazing surgeons and physicians who have kept me alive and working This page intentionally left blank Contents List of Illustrations ix Preface xi Chapter One Outrage in Calcutta 1 Th e Travels of a Monument—Old Fort William—A New Nawab—Th e Fall
    [Show full text]
  • Communism and Religion in North India, 1920–47
    "To the Masses." Communism and Religion in North India, 1920–47 Dissertation zur Erlangung des akademischen Grades doctor philosophiae (Dr. phil.) eingereicht an der Kultur-, Sozial- und Bildungswissenschaftlichen Fakultät der Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin von Patrick Hesse Präsident der Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin Prof. Dr. Jan-Hendrik Olbertz Dekanin der Kultur-, Sozial- und Bildungswissenschaftlichen Fakultät Prof. Dr. Julia von Blumenthal Gutachter: 1. Michael Mann 2. Dietrich Reetz Tag der mündlichen Prüfung: 20. Juli 2015 Abstract Among the eldest of its kind in Asia, the Communist Party of India (CPI) pioneered the spread of Marxist politics beyond the European arena. Influenced by both Soviet revolutionary practice and radical nationalism in British India, it operated under conditions not provided for in Marxist theory—foremost the prominence of religion and community in social and political life. The thesis analyzes, first, the theoretical and organizational ‘overhead’ of the CPI in terms of the position of religion in a party communist hierarchy of emancipation. It will therefore question the works of Marx, Engels, and Lenin on the one hand, and Comintern doctrines on the other. Secondly, it scrutinizes the approaches and strategies of the CPI and individual members, often biographically biased, to come to grips with the subcontinental environment under the primacy of mass politics. Thirdly, I discuss communist vistas on revolution on concrete instances including (but not limited to) the Gandhian non-cooperation movement, the Moplah rebellion, the subcontinental proletariat, the problem of communalism, and assertion of minority identities. I argue that the CPI established a pattern of vacillation between qualified rejection and conditional appropriation of religion that loosely constituted two diverging revolutionary paradigms characterizing communist practice from the Soviet outset: Western and Eastern.
    [Show full text]
  • Calcutta & West Bengal, 1950S
    People, Politics and Protests I Calcutta & West Bengal, 1950s – 1960s Sucharita Sengupta & Paula Banerjee Anwesha Sengupta 2016 1. Refugee Movement: Another Aspect of Popular Movements in West Bengal in the 1950s and 1960s Sucharita Sengupta & Paula Banerjee 1 2. Tram Movement and Teachers’ Movement in Calcutta: 1953-1954 Anwesha Sengupta 25 Refugee Movement: Another Aspect of Popular Movements in West Bengal in the 1950s and 1960s ∗ Sucharita Sengupta & Paula Banerjee Introduction By now it is common knowledge how Indian independence was born out of partition that displaced 15 million people. In West Bengal alone 30 lakh refugees entered until 1960. In the 1970s the number of people entering from the east was closer to a few million. Lived experiences of partition refugees came to us in bits and pieces. In the last sixteen years however there is a burgeoning literature on the partition refugees in West Bengal. The literature on refugees followed a familiar terrain and set some patterns that might be interesting to explore. We will endeavour to explain through broad sketches how the narratives evolved. To begin with we were given the literature of victimhood in which the refugees were portrayed only as victims. It cannot be denied that in large parts these refugees were victims but by fixing their identities as victims these authors lost much of the richness of refugee experience because even as victims the refugee identity was never fixed as these refugees, even in the worst of times, constantly tried to negotiate with powers that be and strengthen their own agency. But by fixing their identities as victims and not problematising that victimhood the refugees were for a long time displaced from the centre stage of their own experiences and made “marginal” to their narratives.
    [Show full text]
  • Journal of Literature, Linguistics and Cultural Studies
    RAINBOW Vol. 9 (2) 2020 Journal of Literature, Linguistics and Cultural Studies https://journal.unnes.ac.id/sju/index.php/rainbow Pre-partition India and the Rise of Indian Nationalism in Amitav Ghosh’s The Shadow Lines: A Postcolonial Analysis Sheikh Zobaer* * Lecturer, Department of English and Modern Languages, North South University, Dhaka, Bangladesh. Article Info Abstract Article History: The Shadow Lines is mostly celebrated for capturing the agony and trauma of the artificial Received segregation that divided the Indian subcontinent in 1947. However, the novel also 17 August 2020 provides a great insight into the undivided Indian subcontinent during the British colonial Approved period. Moreover, the novel aptly captures the rise of Indian nationalism and the struggle 13 October 2020 against the British colonial rule through the revolutionary movements. Such image of pre- Published partition India is extremely important because the picture of an undivided India is what 30 October 2020 we need in order to compare the scenario of pre-partition India with that of a postcolonial India divided into two countries, and later into three with the independence of Keywords: Partition, Bangladesh in 1971. This paper explores how The Shadow Lines captures colonial India Nationalism, and the rise of Indian nationalism through the lens of postcolonialism.s. Colonialism, Amitav Ghosh © 2020 Universitas Negeri Semarang Corresponding author: Bashundhara, Dhaka-1229, Bangladesh E-mail: [email protected] but cannot separate the people who share the INTRODUCTION same history and legacy of sharing the same territory and living the same kind of life for The Shadow Lines is arguably the most centuries.
    [Show full text]
  • National Revolutionism to Marxism – a Narrative of Origins of Socialist Unity Centre of India
    NATIONAL REVOLUTIONISM TO MARXISM – A NARRATIVE OF ORIGINS OF SOCIALIST UNITY CENTRE OF INDIA Dr. Bikash Ranjan Deb Associate Professor of Political Science Surya Sen Mahavidyalaya Siliguri, West Bengal, India [email protected] INTRODUCTION: The national revolutionary movement, one of the early trends of ‘Swadeshi Movement’, constituted a significant aspect in the history of the Indian freedom movement. The colonial rulers, however, preferred the term ‘terrorism’1 to denigrate the movement. For the purpose of the present study, let us confine the term ‘national revolutionism’ following Gopal Halder, ‘to describe a pattern of activity pursued for a prolonged period of thirty years, from 1904 to 1934’. (Halder, 2002: 195; Habib, S. Irfan, 2017: 2)2 Imbued with the spirit of unrelenting fight against British imperial power in India, the national revolutionaries tried to set before the people of the country a bright example of personal courage and heroic self-sacrifice, and thereby wanted to instill a mood of defiance in the minds of the people in the face of colonial repression. The national revolutionaries represented the uncompromising trend of Indian freedom movement in terms of both their willingness and their activities for complete national freedom and people’s liberation from colonial exploitation, by arousing revolutionary upsurge. But this was not the dominant trend of the national freedom struggle. The reformist and compromising section of the Indian National Congress (INC) playing the role of ‘reformist oppositional’ was the
    [Show full text]
  • East Bengali Refugee Narratives of Communal Violence
    Interrogating Victimhood: East Bengali Refugee Narratives of Communal Violence Nilanjana Chatterjee Department of Anthropology University of North Carolina-Chapel Hill Introduction In this paper I am interested in analyzing the self-representation of Hindu East Bengali refugees as victims of Partition violence so as to historicize and politicize their claims to inclusion within India and their entitlement to humanitarian assistance in the face of state and public disavowal. I focus on the main components of their narratives of victimhood, which tend to be framed in an essentializing rhetoric of Hindu-Muslim difference and involve the demonization of “the Muslim.” I conclude with a brief consideration of the implications of this structure of prejudice for relations between the two communities in West Bengal and the rise of Hindu fundamentalism nationwide. A story I was told while researching East Bengali refugee agency and self-settlement strategies in West Bengal bring these issues together for me in a very useful way. Dr. Shantimoy Ray, professor of history and East Bengali refugee activist had been sketching the history of the refugee squatter colony Santoshpur, referred to the enduring sense of betrayal, loss and anger felt by East Bengalis after the partition of Bengal in 1947: becoming strangers in their own land which constituted part of the Muslim nation of Pakistan, being forced to leave and rebuild their lives in West Bengal in India, a “nation” that was nominally theirs but where they were faced with dwindling public sympathy and institutional apathy. Spurred by their bastuhara (homeless) condition-- a term which gained political significance and which referred to their Partition victimhood, groups of middle and working class refugees began to “grab” land and resettle themselves in West Bengal.
    [Show full text]
  • Access Provided by Stanford University at 08/11/11 7:50PM GMT Who Becomes a Terrorist? Poverty, Education, and the Origins of Political Violence
    Access Provided by Stanford University at 08/11/11 7:50PM GMT WHO BECOMES A TERRORIST? Poverty, Education, and the Origins of Political Violence By ALEXANDER LEE* ANY public figures and scholars have argued that poverty and Mlack of education play a role in participation in political vio- lence.1 Even George Bush declared that “we fight against poverty be- cause hope is an answer to terror,”2 and the prevention of terrorism has become a common justification for increasing foreign aid. By contrast, others have argued that terrorism is unrelated to poverty, either across countries3 or among individuals.4 This latter view has had the advan- tage, at least within the social sciences, because most individual-level studies of terrorist groups have concluded that these groups are com- posed of people who are wealthier and better educated than the average member of the societies from which they recruit.5 These accounts have uncovered an important empirical regularity in both terrorism and political participation more generally. Terrorists, like members of other political groups, are drawn not from a random sample of the population but, rather, from those who have acquired information about the political process, are connected to politicized *The author would like to thank the staffs of the State Archives of West Bengal (Kolkata), West Bengal State Secretariat Library (Kolkata), National Library (Kolkata), National Archives of India (New Delhi), and British Library (London) for their assistance. He would like to thank James Fearon, Martha Crenshaw, Saumitra Jha, Michael Silvestri, Kenneth Schultz, David Laitin, Karen Jusko, four anonymous referees, and participants in panels at the Midwest Political Science Association’s 2009 Conference, UC Berkeley, and Stanford for their comments.
    [Show full text]