GOVERNMENT OF NUNAVUT Procurement Activity Report kNo1i ZKm4fPi9rle pWapr5eyCd6 tbfy 5 Nunalingni Kavamatkunnilu Pivikhaqautikkut Department of Community and Government Services Ministere des Services Communautaires et Gouvernementaux Fiscal Year 2010/11 GOVERNMENT OF NUNAVUT Procurement Activity Report Table of Contents Purpose . 1 Objective . 1 Introduction . 1 Report Overview . 2 Sole Source Contract Observations . 3 General Observations . 6 Summary . 7 1. All Contracts (> $5,000) . 7 2. Contracting Types . 11 3. Contracting Methods . 15 4. Sole Source Contract Distribution . 19 Appendices Appendix A: Glossary and Definition of Terms . 25 Appendix B: Sole Source (> $5,000) . 27 Appendix C: Contract Detailed Listing (> $5,000) . 43 1 GOVERNMENT OF NUNAVUT Procurement Activity Report Purpose The Department of Community and Government Services (CGS) is pleased to present this report on the Government of Nunavut (GN)’s procurement and contracting activities for the 2010/11 fiscal year. Objective CGS is committed to ensuring fair value and ethical practices in meeting its responsibilities. This is accomplished through effective policies and procedures aimed at: • Obtaining the best value for Nunavummiut overall; • Creating a fair and open environment for vendors; • Maintaining current and accurate information; and • Ensuring effective approaches to meet the GN’s requirements. Introduction The Procurement Activity Report presents statistical information and contract detail about GN contracts as reported by GN departments to CGS’s Procurement, Logistics and Contract Support section. Contracts entered into by the GN Crown agencies and the Legislative Assembly are not reported to CGS and are not included in this report. Contract information provided in this report reflects contracts awarded and reported during the 2010 /11 fiscal year. CGS can not guarantee the accuracy of contract information reported by departments, however, CGS makes best efforts to verify the information and ensure departments are fully aware of the reporting requirements set out in the Nunavummi Nangminiqaqtunik Ikajuuti (NNI Policy) and applicable GN policies and procedures manual. 3 GOVERNMENT OF NUNAVUT Procurement Activity Report Report Overview This report focuses on the distribution of contracts awarded to corporations, organizations and sole proprietors. Charts and tables are used to illustrate the information presented. CGS aims to enhance its reporting of the GN’s contracting activities each year as part of its commitment to ensure transparency and accountability. Many factors can influence the comparability of data. Unusually high or low values for a given year in reported data can result from a blend of several external factors that may not necessarily be obvious to a reader including such significant items as annual variations in operating budgets or capital budgets, policy revisions and one-time initiatives. Readers of this report should seek informed explanations respecting contributing factors before making judgments. Readers should not base judgments solely on the graphs and tables contained in this report. Readers should also consider the many other reports and published program information made available by the GN. When viewing such comparative information, it is important to note that certain factors such as planned changes in the GN’s priorities from year to year can impact the annual results. For instance, a significant level of capital projects in one year would likely reveal a high level of Public Tendering which is the typical approach when awarding large value major works projects. A reduction in major works projects the following year, however, could reveal a related decrease in Public Tenders by value which is not necessarily indicative of any change in approach in the government’s procurement and contracting practices. Therefore it is important to consider the broader perspective and context before making conclusions when assessing the comparative information presented. Each year there is a portion of contracting activities which relate directly to the GN’s ongoing role in maintaining essential services and basic programs. Other contracting activities are closely aligned to the cyclical nature of the GN’s capital spending commitments. Major capital projects typically follow a period of planning which includes inception, planning and design phases prior to the period of intense construction activity starting. The following year would normally show a large reduction in contracting activity. Comparisons made across such years may reveal an unexpected change in the level of contracts which were competitively awarded as well as the relative percentage of contracting activities by type or method. A year in which a number of large capital projects are entering their design phase would see an increase in the volume and value of spending activity on design contracts (“A/E”). Given that the design phases of capital projects are typically followed by construction, it would be logical to see corresponding increases in the number and value of major construction contracts awarded (“CON”) in the following year. 4 GOVERNMENT OF NUNAVUT Procurement Activity Report Given that design and construction contracts are typically higher value contracts awarded through a public RFP or Tender method, whereas other types of contracts are typically of smaller value awarded through an invitational process; a significant decrease in the infrastructure contract values with no change in the other contract values could imply an increase in Invited Tenders or Proposals even though there is no real increase in those activities. It is worthwhile to note that contract activities which relate to the GN’s ongoing responsibility for maintaining basic services and safeguarding the health and welfare of Nunavummiut may warrant special measures to ensure prompt attention and immediate action. Depending on the nature, this may warrant engagement of expertise or necessary services outside the normal competitive process. This can occur where a delay would be injurious to the public interest, or where there is only one vendor available and qualified enough to perform the contract. Therefore in a year in which the level of capital spending is low, the proportion of non- competitively awarded contracts may appear high even though there has been no underlying change to the GN’s procurement and contracting practices. Readers are therefore cautioned from making specific conclusions upon reviewing the comparative information presented. As the GN’s primary Contracting Authority, CGS continues to monitor and assess annual indicators, enhance services offered to clients and client departments, and review its contracting activities regularly to ensure best practices across the GN. Sole Source Contract Observations Sole Source contracting practices are monitored closely. The GN believes we get the best value for our money through competitive bidding processes, however, there are limited situations where the contracting regulations permit awarding contracts without competition. Section 3 of this report discusses the acceptable conditions for awarding contracts without competition. The GN continues to review the contributing factors to contracts that have been Sole Sourced. CGS monitors the various types of contracts entered into without competition, and can offer strategic planning and other services to assist departments in decreasing their reliance on the Sole Sourcing methodology; especially where the permitted Sole Source criteria may not be met. For example, ‘delay would be injurious to the public interest’ is sometimes misunderstood, and the criterion ‘there is only one party capable and available’ is also sometimes relied upon without sufficient marketplace research or other appropriate data to support the request. We will continue to work with departments towards reducing the occurrence of this contracting method. In 2010/11 Sole Source contracts, decreased in volume by 3.5% and increased in value by 10%. The number of Sole Source contracts are more prevalent in contracts with value under $100,000. 5 GOVERNMENT OF NUNAVUT Procurement Activity Report Not Included in These Statistics Note: The statistical numbers in this report do not include four (4) large categories of contracts. Those are: 2008/09 2009/10 2010/11 1. Scheduled Medical Travel $32M (est.) $29M (est.) $32.5M (est.) 2. Fuel (PPD) $195M (est.) $140M (est.) $162.5M (est.) 3. Police and Laboratory Services 25M (est.) $26M (est.) $28.3M (est.) 4. Physician Services $16.8M (est.) $10.7M (est.) These four high value categories total approximately $234 million. Medical Travel, Fuel Resupply and Physician Services are the result of a competitive bidding process, Police and Laboratory Services is an extension of a previous contract with the RCMP. If we include these numbers, Sole Source contracts would value approximately 7.5% of total expenditures. Eliminating these numbers from statistical analysis allows for a more detailed and closer examination of Sole Source contracts. Appendix A outlines the definitions of terms and abbreviations. Appendix B entitled Sole Source Listing provides a listing of all Sole Sourced contracts by value (> $5,000) in ascending order. Appendix C entitled Contract Detailed Listing provides a listing of all contracts (> $5,000) and is presented by Contract Type in ascending Award Value. The intent of these appendices is to enhance transparency of GN contracting and procurement practices by presenting