Korean Cinema of Perseverance: Pushing the Boundaries of Quality During the Park Chung Hee Authoritarian Era, 1961-1970
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Korean Cinema of Perseverance: Pushing the Boundaries of Quality During the Park Chung Hee Authoritarian Era, 1961-1970 By Ae-Gyung Shim A Dissertation submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy (English, Media and Performing Arts) at the UNIVERSITY OF NEW SOUTH WALES 2010 Table of Contents Tables and Figures page vi Abbreviations vii Acknowledgements viii Abstract x Originality Statement xi Introduction: Korean Cinema Now and Then 1 Revisiting the Golden Age: Cinema of Perseverance 5 Methodology 11 Chapter Summaries 14 Chapter 1. Building A Propaganda Factory 17 1. Restructuring the Film Industry 18 1) Establishment of the National Film Production Centre 18 Newsreels (Daehan News) 20 Cultural Film (Munhwa Yeonghwa) 21 2) Consolidation: Pre-MPL Period 23 2. Rebuilding of the Film Industry with the Motion Picture Law (MPL) 25 1) Producer Registration System (PRS) 26 2) Censorship 32 3) Import Policy 38 Import Recommendation System (IRS) 39 Import Licence Reward System (ILRS) 40 3. Resistance: Anti-MPL Campaign 41 4. Conclusion: Impact of the MPL on Production, Direction and Genre 46 Chapter 2. Producer Registration System: Forming An Industry Cartel 48 1. The Cartel 50 1) The Janus Trade: Daemyeong Jejak 55 2) Import Licences as a Cash Cow 59 ii 3) Bobbing for Presales with the Exhibitor-Investors 63 2. Shin Film and the Success of Industrialisation 66 1) The Political Favourite 68 2) Leading by Internationalisation 72 3) Focus on Education 76 3. Conclusion: Cartel – Core of the Golden Age 77 Chapter 3. Propaganda Production and Anticommunist Filmmaking Efforts 79 1. Origins of the Anticommunist Genre 81 2. Anticommunist Genre As A Super Genre 83 3. Transgenre Possibilities 88 1) Reproduction of War Memories Through Spectacle: Five Marines (1951) 89 2) Separation Melodrama And Emotional Tenderness: South And North (1965) 94 3) Cold War Politics And Spies: Correspondent in Tokyo (1967) 98 4. Post-Anticommunist Genre 100 5. Conclusion: Revisiting the Anticommunist Genre 102 Chapter 4. Constructing Literary Films: Intersecting Genre, Policy and Industry 105 1. Origin of the Literary Genre 107 2. Rise of Literary Films in the 1960s 110 3. Literary Film Themes 113 1) Praising Cultural Nationalism: Deaf Samryong (1963) 113 2) Traditionalism, Locality, Festival Films: Seashore Village (1965) 119 3) Exploring Modernism: Mist (1967) 126 4. Conclusion: The Literary Genre As Cultural Propaganda 131 Chapter 5. Shin Sang-Ok and the Duality Between Film and Politics 133 1. From Political Artist and Propaganda Creator to Industry Leader 134 1) Ideological Conformity: Escape From Poverty 138 iii 2) The Pure Endorsement Film: Rice (1963) 143 3) Glorification of Militarism: The Red Muffler (1964) 146 2. Downward Spiral 149 1) Soft-pornography as Political Satire: Eunuch (1968) 151 3. Conclusion: Perseverance and Survival 156 Chapter 6. Lee Man-hee: Anticommunism Chaser and Genre Experimenter 158 1. Anticommunist Filmmaking: Collaborating with the Powers 159 1) Quintessential Anticommunism: Marines Who Never Returned (1963) 161 2. Conflicts with Censorship: Becoming a Political Scapegoat 167 1) Portraying A Few Good North Korean Men: Seven Female POWs (1965) 167 3. Melodrama: Cinematic Experiment and Social Realism 174 1) A Life of Living Hell: Holiday (1968) 177 4. Conclusion: Negotiating Spaces For Integrity 180 Chapter 7. Yu Hyun-mok: Auteurship Challenges 182 1. Authorship Within the Korean Context 184 1) Auteur Canvas: Aimless Bullet (1960) 186 2. Expansion of Auteurship: Spreading Beliefs in Film As An Art 193 1) Vanguard of Art Filmmaking: The Empty Dream (1965) 194 3. Beyond the PRS 201 4. Conclusion: Auteurship As Privilege 202 Conclusion. Cinema of Perseverance 206 Cinema of Qualities 209 Appendix A: List of Interviews 214 Appendix B: Selected Filmography 217 Bibliography 220 iv Tables and Figures List of Tables Table 1-1. Number of Changes of Registered Companies (1961-1970) page 24 Table 1-2. Number of Domestic Feature Film Productions in the 1960s 29 Table 1-3. Summary of the MPL Changes in the 1960s 48 List of Figures Figure 1-1. Film Censorship Process in the Late 1960s 33 Figure 2-1. Registered Producers at the Centre of the Industry 48 Figure 2-2. Daemyong 55 Figure 2-3. Poster of Rice (Donga Daily 15 November 1963: 4) 71 Figure 2-4. Election Campaign Poster (Donga Daily 2 October 1963: 1) 71 Figure 2-5. Poster of Last Woman of Shang (Kyeonghyang Daily 18 September 1964: 4) 75 Figure 3-1. Anticommunist Genre As a Super Genre: A New Canon of Genre Films 85 Figure 3-2. Poster of South and North (Donga Daily 9 January 1965: 4) 97 Figure 4-1. Poster of Deaf Samryong (Kyeonghyang Daily 10 Sept 1964: 4) 116 Figure 4-2. Poster of Seashore Village (Donga Daily 18 November 1965: 6) 121 Figure 4-3. Poster of Mist (Donga Daily 24 October 1967: 5) 127 Figure 5-1. Poster of The Red Muffler (Donga Daily 4 March 1964: 4) 146 Figure 5-2. Poster of Eunuch (Kyeonghyang Daily 7 December 1968: 4) 152 Figure 6-1. Poster of Marines (Donga Daily 10 April 1963:6) 161 Figure 7-1. Poster of Aimless Bullet (Donga Daily 21 October 1963: 4) 190 Figure 7-2. This Is How A Screenwriter Works (Silver Screen August 1965: 58) 195 Figure 7-3. Poster of The Empty Dream (Donga Daily 3 July 1965: 5) 198 v Abbreviations Import Recommendation System IRS Import Licence Reward System ILRS Korean Film Archive KOFA Korean Film Council KOFIC Ministry of Public Information MPI Motion Picture Law MPL MPL Enforcement Ordinance MPL-EO MPL Enforcement Rules MPL-ER National Film Production Centre NFPC Korean Motion Pictures Producers Association KMPPA Motion Pictures Association of Korea MPAK National Archives of Korea NAK Korean Movie Database KMDB Producer Registration System PRS Screen Quota System SQS Supreme Court of National Reconstruction SCNR United States Army Military Government In Korea USAMGIK United States Intelligence Agency USIA vi Acknowledgments I should first thank my partner and mentor, Dr Brian Yecies, not only for his continuous intellectual and emotional support for my PhD over the last six years, but also for fulfilling my life in general. Apart from writing the dissertation, my last six years have been full of challenges, including my complicated twin pregnancy and premature birth of my sons, as well as their early child care, all of which I would not have survived without Brian. I thank my supervisor, Annette Hamilton, for her insightful advice, which always showed me the bigger picture and broadened my scope of knowledge. My dissertation benefited enormously from her guidance and comments. I wish to express sincere thanks to the following industry people and scholars/researchers who willingly agreed to an interview and to share their vast knowledge. I am gratefully indebted to cinema owner Gwak Jeong-hwan, producers Kim In-gi, Hwang Nam, You In-taek and Yi Wu-seok, PIFF director Kim Dong-ho, film directors Yi Hyeong- pyo, An Cheol-hyeon, Lee Chang-ho, Im Won-sik, Yu Hyun-mok, Park Gwang-su and Im Kwon-taek, screenwriters Baek Gyeol and Kim Ji-heon, actor Yun Il-bong, former MPEA representative in Korea Cha Yun, and Megabox distribution manager Jang Gyeong-ik, for sharing their industry experiences and insights. I am also grateful for the deep insights that KOFIC researchers Kim Hyae-joon, Kim Mee- hyun and Kim Hyun-jung, KOFA researchers Cho Jun-hyung, Chung Jong-hwa and Jeong Hye-yeon, policymaker Kim Tae-hoon at the Ministry of Culture and Tourism, and scholars Kim Soyoung, Byon In-sik and Yi Hyoin shared with me. All of them shared with me their knowledge about the past and present Korean cinema. Institutional support was crucial for completing my dissertation. I also express my thanks to those many librarians and archivists from the National Assembly Library, Korean National Library, Yonsei University Library, Korean Film Council Library, Korean Film Archive and Lee Young-il Archive in Seoul, National Archives of Korea (NAK), and Kyongpook National University Library in Daegu, who helped me find much-needed data. A University Postgraduate Award from the University of New South Wales and a prestigious Graduate Fellowship from the Korea Foundation enabled me to focus on the research and writing during my candidature without having to seek vii employment. Travel grants from the University of New South Wales enabled me to make two valuable research trips to Korea in 2004 and 2005, which provided a strong foundation of industry and archive materials for constructing the dissertation. Finally, I thank my family who has always been supportive: my parents, my brother, my mother-in-law, my sister-in-law and my precious troublemaking twins. I thank my parents back in Korea, who always were on my side whenever I made big life decisions. I thank my mother-in-law, who considered me as her second daughter from the first moment we met. Lastly, I thank my precious troublemaking boys, Robert and Alex, who have entered kindergarten at the time of my completing this project in 2010, for coming into my life and making it brighter than I ever imagined. viii Abstract This thesis analyses film policy, production practices and genre construction under Park Chung Hee’s totalitarian government, which ruled South Korea between 1961 and 1979. It offers new theoretical insights about the modernisation of film culture in Korea, which left a rich legacy for filmmakers in the 21st Century. The period chosen for this study (1961-1970) is best known for the compressed industrialization that the nation experienced. This period called a golden age of the Korean cinema is known for struggle and success under the constraints of industrialisation, when the industry produced an average of 164 films per year.