Meeting Notes PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION ADVISORY
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Meeting Notes PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION ADVISORY COMMITTEE (PTAC) TUESDAY, APRIL 4, 2017 @ 7:00 PM BROOKLINE TOWN HALL, ROOM 408 333 WASHINGTON STREET, BROOKLINE MA 02446 7:00 CALL MEETING TO ORDER AND APPROVE MINUTES FROM MARCH 7, 2017 MEETING. CONGRATULATE NEW MEMBER DAVID SALTMAN AND WELCOME CANDIDATE JONATHAN ZELIG. PTAC members present: Abby Swaine, Linda Jason, Jane Gould, David Saltman PTAC liaison to Transportation Board present: Scott Englander PTAC candidate present: Jonathan Zelig March 7 minutes approved unanimously. 7:05 TAKE PUBLIC COMMENT ON ITEMS NOT ON THE AGENDA. No guests present. 7:15 BROOKLINE HIGH SCHOOL STUDENT TRANSIT: FEEDBACK FROM MARCH 16 TRANSPORTATION BOARD MEETING AND NEXT STEPS. Abby recounted main points from summary presented to the Transportation Board (appended). The TB directed PTAC to approach the School Dept and School Committee to consider providing school bus service to BHS students, after school as well as potentially before school. (Currently no town school bus service is provided to BHS students after school, but some service is provided in the morning, appended to elementary school busing.) The TB feels it is reasonable to expect that the Town should pay, in moderation, for school bus transportation for BHS students not well-served by MBTA transit. The TB recommends that PTAC seek support from Town Meeting Members whose constituents may benefit, and from School Committee candidates. Now is an appropriate time to broach the issue, as the Town anticipates and plans for large increases in school enrolment, which will result in more traffic congestion at BHS and other schools. Students residing in parts of Brookline other than South Brookline may also face lengthy commutes to BHS. Some Baldwin (9th elementary) school students may need busing. Abby passed along member Deborah Dong’s observation that for BHS students taking the Green Line to Reservoir after school, and then the 51 bus to South Brookline, the Route 51 buses often arrive late at Reservoir (but perhaps not so late to be officially considered late by the MBTA—more than 15 minutes). Therefore, the entire trip takes longer and is more frustrating than the MBTA represents, or perhaps than the Town realizes (and would consider acceptable transport for BHS students). Deborah spoke to a Baker School employee who often takes the 51 bus from Beverly Rd to Reservoir Station around the 3:00- 3:30 timeframe, and she said that that particular bus was so inconsistent that Baker staff have stopped relying on it. Linda will ask the Tab to include school busing as an interview question for School Committee candidates. Abby will ask the School Committee, School Dept, and BHS administration for a meeting to plan next steps, including a needs assessment. PTAC intends to clarify how many BHS students utilize town-provided morning school bus transportation, and how many more might use it if students could make it to BHS in time for Z block. We noted that parents may find it more convenient to drop off students in the morning on their way to work than to pick them up in the middle of the afternoon. PTAC also intends to find out how much the School Dept currently pays for student transportation within Brookline, in order to estimate the cost of additional service (which will have to be approved as part of the Town budget). Additional service could be provided on a pilot basis. 7:35 ALLSTON I-90 INTERCHANGE PROJECT PRESENTATION BY MASSDOT AT MARCH 20 TRANSPORTATION BOARD MEETING: HIGHLIGHTS AND NEXT STEPS. Abby related high points of MassDOT’s presentation at the March 20 hearing, and responses from the Board, staff and audience (agenda: http://www.brooklinema.gov/AgendaCenter/ViewFile/Agenda/_03202017-4713). The entire project, including West Station, will proceed to permitting. Funding needs to be appropriated and is uncertain, so the project may be built in stages. The Draft Environmental Impact Report will model West Station, but according to MassDOT the case for building it will need to be made once the project area shows demand. This is in part due to a new station on the same Commuter Rail route, just ½ mile away, coming on line soon (the “New Balance” station). Whether or not the station gets built, pedestrian and bicycle access through the area from points South and North will be secured. MassDOT’s vision is to build the pedestrian and bike ramps from points South first, on bridge structures that might later accommodate bus access if/when West Station is built. On the subject of whether bus-only road access (as opposed to all vehicle access) could be provided from points South (including Brookline) to West Station and beyond (potentially north as far as Harvard Square), MassDOT said that restricting access into perpetuity could fail (and has in other cases). There is no way of building roadway access in such a way as to preclude future use by vehicles other than buses. MassDOT must present the all-vehicle-access scenario as part of environmental scoping/review, but is wary of the potential sizeable impacts on Babcock and (to a lesser extent) Pleasant streets. In any case, the envisioned I-90 off-ramp accounts for 50% of projected traffic impacts to those streets. In the Draft Environmental Impact Report, MassDOT will provide estimates of total traffic impact. To date, MassDOT has heard from few proponents of all-vehicle access; there is no “bloc” of allied interests, but some Allston residents are interested in allowing such access to points South as a way of potentially lessening traffic in/near the project area. The MBTA will not speculate on the benefits of providing new or modified bus service to/through the project area until it is built and demand can be assessed. MassDOT stated that they took seriously the input received at the February 29, 2016 Brookline hearing on the project regarding the desire for bus transit access. The City of Boston has expressed interest in Bus Rapid Transit between Longwood and Harvard Square, via the Allston project location. Boston University has also come out in favor of bus-only access. MassDOT will model the transit-only scenario, in addition to the all-vehicle scenario. MassDOT raised the question of whether neighborhoods that might see new bus transit will accept it. Crowningshield neighborhood residents were vocal at the meeting in opposition to increased traffic. The DEIR should be out for public comment by the end of September, 2017; MassDOT will walk the Transportation Board through it. At that point the Town will have an opportunity to formally comment. 7:55 MASSDOT PROPOSAL TO ELIMINATE ROUTE 60 OUTBOUND STOP OPPOSITE 850 BOYLSTON ST: DISCUSSION AND ACTION ON RECOMMENDATION TO TRANSPORTATION DEPARTMENT. PTAC continued discussion of this item; see March 7 2017 minutes for first discussion. David reported that he has repeatedly sought feedback from managers of the Brigham & Women’s Hospital medical office building at 850 Boylston. A Patient Relations rep said that a large number of staff and patients arrive via automobile. There is also a shuttle service that connects 850 Boylston to the main Brigham and Women's Hospital site, satellite parking, and the Green Line. Those who ride the outbound 60 seem to board at the Reservoir Rd stop, instead of trekking to 850 Boylston. David will make a few more attempts to verify that there is no utilization of this stop by businesses across Route 9. Adjacent to the stop there are no trip-generating land uses. Given the poor condition, desolate location, and hazardous access to the stop in question, its extremely low utilization, proximity to alternative Route 60 and Green Line stops, and the poor prospect of increased usage were it to be improved, Abby will communicate to Todd Kirrane on behalf of PTAC that the Town should acquiesce to MassDOT’s proposal to eliminate it, barring any findings by MassDOT’s survey of riders to the contrary. 8:10 BUS STOP CENSUS: REVIEW PROGRESS AND MAKE PLANS FOR FINALIZING. Abby passed along Deborah Dong’s comment that assessing stops on Route 51 was impossible due to unshoveled snow rendering sections of sidewalk impassable. This is consistent with other PTAC members’ observations of stops on other routes this winter. After the record snows of February 2015, Brookline DPW agreed to give clearing snow from bus stops the same attention as Town parking spaces, but in reality access from the sidewalk to the curb at bus stops is often obstructed by snow/ice banks. Linda Jason and Jane Gould presented their findings on Route 66 bus stops. Conditions were generally good, although shelters were few. Once all census results are in and polished, PTAC will present them to the Transportation Department and Board, the Planning and Community Development Department, and the MBTA, in the interest of leveraging improvements. 8:30 UPCOMING GATEWAY EAST PUBLIC HEARING ON 25% DESIGN: PREPARE BY REVIEWING PRIOR PTAC RECOMMENDATIONS AND CHANGES SINCE THEN. Abby characterized PTAC’s recommendations for bus stop placement and amenities from the last time this project progressed to 25% design, several years ago. Since then, project design changes, including those occasioned by adding a cycle track, may have rendered some PTAC recommendations inapplicable. Abby will circulate to PTAC members those prior recommendations and information on the upcoming meeting. [DONE.] Jane, and tentatively Jonathan and Linda as well, will attend the hearing on April 26 to listen on behalf of PTAC. 8:50 WRAP UP AND ADJOURN. Abby relayed news from the March 16 Transportation Board meeting, provided by Todd Kirrane, that an MBTA-financed test of Transit Signal Prioritization on the C Line at Carleton St had been completed, and that the Town is studying the feasibility and cost of full deployment, which may require traffic signal hardware upgrades.