DOCSLIB.ORG

More‐Than‐Water More‐Than‐Human

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
More‐Than‐Water More‐Than‐Human ore More‐Than‐Water More‐Than‐Human A TRANSDISCIPLINARY SOCIOLOGY OF W ATER CONFLICT IN CENTRAL IRAN A THESIS BY SEYED EHSAN TAVAKOLI-NABAVI Submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy of the Australian National University December 2017 © Copyright by Seyed Ehsan Tavakoli‐Nabavi, 2017. All Rights Reserved i ii Candidate's Declaration This thesis is presented as a “Thesis by compilation” following guidelines of the Australian National University. This thesis is structured as a series of nine connected papers, each forming one Chapter. These papers have been published, accepted or submitted for publication at the time of thesis submission. For further information regarding the authorship, status, journal and extent of the candidate’s contribution in each paper, see the “paper specification” section. This thesis comprises 95,987 words (excluding footnotes, appendices, references, tables and boxes). The thesis was evaluated and approved by the Australian National University Human Research Ethics Committee, protocol number 2014/030. This thesis contains no material accepted for the award of any other degree or diploma in any university. The thesis is wholly my own work except where otherwise acknowledged. Ehsan Nabavi Date: BEng. (Civil), MEng. (Civil) 5/12/2017 iii Acknowledgments Undertaking this PhD has been a truly life-changing experience for me and it would not have been possible without the support and guidance that I received from many people. During my time at Australian National University (ANU), I have been lucky enough to study something that I am fascinated with and I am very grateful to Dr. Katherine Daniell whose support provided me with this opportunity to do something that I dreamed of when I finished my Masters. I have been very privileged in having Katherine as my supervisor during these past five years, and I wish to express my sincere gratitude and appreciation for her unwavering patience and support. Thanks also to Professor Ian White, Professor Mark Evans, and Dr. Sarah Milne for supporting me through the research. And special thanks to Professor Jacqueline Lo and Dr Annmarie Elijah and other colleagues at ANU Centre for European Studies for hosting and supporting me with all their means during most part of my PhD career. This thesis would not have been possible without the support of a scholarship award from the Research School of Social Sciences (RSSS). I also gratefully acknowledge the funding received as travel grants and visit scholarships from the Institute of Development Studies (IDS), Helmholtz Centre for Environmental Research Fellowship to take part in some great training programs which became an invaluable part of my PhD experience and has shaped my approach to research. I benefitted greatly from working as a visiting scholar in the Department of Political and Cultural Change, Center for Development Research (ZEF) University of Bonn, Centre for Water and Development, School of African and Oriental Studies (SOAS), University of London. In this period, I had chance to share my thoughts and works and receive guidance from Professor Peter Mollinga, Professor Larry Swatuk and Dr. Saravanan Subramanian. To Professor Sheila Jasanoff and STS research fellow team at Program on Science, Technology and Society Harvard Kennedy School of Government, where I was a Research Fellow in 2016-2017, for seeing the potential of this research and for your wonderful hospitality and support during my time in the US. iv I acknowledge the help of Dr. Ahmad Khatoon-Abadi, Dr. HamidReza Safavi, Isfahan Chamber of Commerce, and Charmahal-Bakhtiari local government hosting me and helping me for conducting the research during the fieldwork. Special mention to Seyed Ahmad for inspiring love of research, as well as Mohammad at the Iranian Water Policy Research Institute who were so helpful in numerous ways. I would also like to acknowledge Katherine Daniell, Maryanne McKay, Merran Laver for proofreading the papers and their helpful comments. A very special thank you to Hessam and Ali for hosting me and supporting me during my fieldwork. To my friends and family throughout Australia, Iran, US and who have supported me in so many different ways throughout the long process of research, writing, and my travels. In particular, to Salim, MohamadReza, Fatemeh, Anna, Hossein, Pooya, Anja, Ehsan, Alireza, and Suzy for helping in whatever way they could during this challenging period. And I would also like to say a heartfelt thank you to my Mum and Dad, my sisters Maryam and Mitra, and my very old friend Mohammad for always believing in me and encouraging me to follow my dreams, and for being on my side when it feels like no one else is. v gÉ Åç ÑtÜxÇàá Mahboub and Mohammad vi vii Abstract Water conflict situations represent an intense meeting point of society and nature, particularly in terms of increasing water demand and diminishing resources. However, less tangible interactions also occur in these situations: between hydraulic infrastructure, governments, science and communities. Such connections are often left unidentified because of the assumption of the division between culture and nature and between the human and the nonhuman as separate categories. This thesis argues the water conflicts that our current world seeks to govern—often through technical, apolitical, acultural approaches—are ‘hybridized’ in nature. They are immersed in myriad of nested networks of heterogeneous elements (e.g. humans, technologies, scientific evidence, laws, ideas, and biophysical processes), interacting together and connecting the past, present, and future. Specifically, what is understood in societies as ‘water conflict’ is the outcome of dynamic interactions that continuously form and reform the conflict situation, and determine the social and political orders surrounding it. The thesis argues that we can and should go beyond singular disciplinary viewpoints to unpack this ‘water conflict assemblage’. To this end, it proposes a transdisciplinary frame of analysis, called Actor-Network-Systems (ANSs). The thesis offers a new way to reconceptualise water conflict, including the well-established notion of ‘hydrohegemony’, and ‘hydropolitics’ more generally. The theoretical shift is brought about in two ways: first, by revisiting the meaning and implication of the ‘political’, and the ‘social’ in water research through considering the role of nonhumans; second, by establishing the connection between ‘conflict’ and ‘the future’ and the ways in which it affects the ‘sustainability’ discourse circulated in society. Using the example of the Zayandeh-Rood water conflict in Iran, the study illustrates how different concepts developed in this thesis encourage a higher level of understanding, deeper reflection, and renewed purpose to the study of water conflict. To put the provided insights into practice, the thesis also developed and trialled a form of participatory drama, called Pathways Theatre, as an innovative initiative to influence a conflict situation, so as to transform it into a more sustainable configuration. The Zayandeh-Rood case demonstrates the value and policy-relevance of the approach to real-world conflict transformation. viii Table of Contents INTRODUCTION Paper specification .................................................................................................. xv Thesis rationale: why am I writing this thesis? ......................................................... 2 Intoduction……......................................................................................................... 3 Summary of literature review and research gaps ..................................................... 7 Research questions and approach ............................................................................ 14 Thesis structure and content .................................................................................... 18 PART 1 DIAGNOSING THE PROBLEM Chapter 1 Boundary Matters: The Potential of System Dynamics to Support Sustainability? 1. 1. Introduction ..................................................................................................... 28 1.2. Sustainability and System Dynamics ............................................................... 30 1.2.1. Sustainability and sustainable development ......................................... 30 1.2.2. Systems theory and System Dynamics ................................................. 33 1.3. The challenge of boundary setting in System Dynamics for sustainability ...... 37 1.3.1. Judgements on sustainability principles as system boundaries ............. 40 1.3.2. Judgements on problem extent for system boundaries ......................... 41 1.3.3. Judgements on methodologies for developing models ......................... 43 1.4. The politics of System Dynamics modelling: why boundaries matter ............. 44 1.4.1. Dynamic Integrated Climate-Economy Model: preliminary problem scope challenges ............................................................................................. 45 1.4.2. Lake Urmia basin: complex modelling politics around multiple boundary judgements ...................................................................................... 46 1.4.3. Zayandeh-Rood Basin: beyond the limits of System Dynamics modelling and bringing water management politics into the open ................. 50 1.5. The future of System Dynamics modelling for sustainability .......................... 51 Chapter 2 Who Speaks for Water
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Planning Strategies to Reduce Rural-Urban Disparities In
    22-' \t . PLANNING STRATEGIES TO REDUCE RI]RAL.TIRBAN DISPARITIES IN DEVELOPING COUNTRIES WITH PARTICULAR REFERENCE TO IRAN Ati A. Taghvaee, B.Sc. (Hons) (Shiraz), MRP (Kansas) Thesis submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Faculty of Architecture and Urban Design University of Adelaide June 1995 f\**n d.o\ lqq6 TABLE OF CONTENTS Page LIST OF TABLES vll LIST OF FIGURES x ABSTRACT xll1 DECLARATION XV ACKNOWLEDGMENTS xvi PREFACE xviii INTRODUCTION 1 CHAPTER I A REVIEW OF THEORIES AND 10 APPROACHES TO RURAL.URBAN DEVELOPMENT 1.1. BACKGROUND 1.1.1 Philosophical background 10 I.I.2 Learning from other countries l7 1.1.3 Some lessons of experience 22 I.2. THEORETICAL APPROACHES TO 33 RURAL-URBAN DEVELOPMENT 1.2.1 Basic human needs 33 t.2.2 Friedmann and Douglas' Agropolitan 34 Development Approach 1.2.3 Christaller's Approach to Central Place 35 Theory 1.2.4 Rondinelli's Growth Pole Approach 39 t.2.5 Lipton's Theory of Urban Bias 43 r.2.6 Stohr and Taylor: Bottom-Up Development 44 1.2.7 Sustainable development 45 11 Page 1.3 BASIC CONCEPTS IN RURAL-URBAN 48 DEVELOPMENT 1.3.1 Development 48 I.3.2 Underdevelopment 53 1.3.3 Integrated rural development 54 1.3.4 Integrated rural-urban development 55 1.3.5 Social justice and social equity 56 1.3.6 Socio-economic welfare 57 1.3.7 Quality of life 58 1.3.8 Socio-economic indicators of 58 develoPment 1.4 CONCLUSIONS 59 CHAPTER II THE RURAL AND URBAN 6I DEVELOPMENT CONTEXT 2.1 BACKGROUND 6T 2.2 RURAL-URBAN DISPARITIES 63 2.3 RI.]RAL AREAS OF THE WORLD 69 2.4
    [Show full text]
  • Iota Directory of Islands Regional List British Isles
    IOTA DIRECTORY OF ISLANDS sheet 1 IOTA DIRECTORY – QSL COLLECTION Last Update: 22 February 2009 DISCLAIMER: The IOTA list is copyrighted to the Radio Society of Great Britain. To allow us to maintain an up-to-date QSL reference file and to fill gaps in that file the Society's IOTA Committee, a Sponsor Member of QSL COLLECTION, has kindly allowed us to show the list of qualifying islands for each IOTA group on our web-site. To discourage unauthorized use an essential part of the listing, namely the geographical coordinates, has been omitted and some minor but significant alterations have also been made to the list. No part of this list may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise. A shortened version of the IOTA list is available on the IOTA web-site at http://www.rsgbiota.org - there are no restrictions on its use. Islands documented with QSLs in our IOTA Collection are highlighted in bold letters. Cards from all other Islands are wanted. Sometimes call letters indicate which operators/operations are filed. All other QSLs of these operations are needed. EUROPE UNITED KINGDOM OF GREAT BRITAIN AND NORTHERN IRELAND, CHANNEL ISLANDS AND ISLE OF MAN # ENGLAND / SCOTLAND / WALES B EU-005 G, GM, a. GREAT BRITAIN (includeing England, Brownsea, Canvey, Carna, Foulness, Hayling, Mersea, Mullion, Sheppey, Walney; in GW, M, Scotland, Burnt Isls, Davaar, Ewe, Luing, Martin, Neave, Ristol, Seil; and in Wales, Anglesey; in each case include other islands not MM, MW qualifying for groups listed below): Cramond, Easdale, Litte Ross, ENGLAND B EU-120 G, M a.
    [Show full text]
  • Socio-Political Change and Development in Iran: Reza Sah and the Shi’I Hierocracy
    Socio-Political Change and Development in Iran: Reza Sah and the Shi’i Hierocracy By Zahra Seif-Amirhosseini A Thesis submitted for the Degree of Doctor of philosophy (Ph.D.), London School of Economics, University of London July 2002 1 UMI Number: U61BB37 All rights reserved INFORMATION TO ALL USERS The quality of this reproduction is dependent upon the quality of the copy submitted. In the unlikely event that the author did not send a complete manuscript and there are missing pages, these will be noted. Also, if material had to be removed, a note will indicate the deletion. Dissertation Publishing UMI U613337 Published by ProQuest LLC 2014. Copyright in the Dissertation held by the Author. Microform Edition © ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved. This work is protected against unauthorized copying under Title 17, United States Code. ProQuest LLC 789 East Eisenhower Parkway P.O. Box 1346 Ann Arbor, Ml 48106-1346 11-VcSe- S h cf l&O Abstract The thesis offers an analysis of the Reza Sah period in terms of the balance between religion and politics and their societal and institutional power, the discussion of which is located within a historical framework. The relationship between religion and politics and their related effect on the ‘legitimacy’ of the structure of domination are considered within Weber’s tripartite typology of domination. Whilst acknowledging the overall implications of the feasibility of adopting a Weberian framework and criticisms concerning the lack of accuracy of Weber’s study of Islam, the thesis proposes that it is nevertheless possible to use a Weberian perspective in the study of Iranian Shi’ism.
    [Show full text]
  • Towards Reflexive Land and Water Management in Iran Linking Technology, Governance and Culture
    Towards Reflexive Land and Water Management in Iran Linking Technology, Governance and Culture Mohammad Reza Balali I Thesis committee Thesis Supervisors Prof. dr. M.J.J.A.A. Korthals Professor of Applied philosophy Wageningen University Prof. dr. F.W.J. Keulartz Associate professor, Applied Philosophy Group Wageningen University Other members Prof. dr. Paul Richards, Wageningen University Prof. dr. Josee van Eijndhoven, Erasmus University Rotterdam Prof. dr. ir. Wouter. T. de Groot, Leiden University Dr. Maurits Ertsen, Delft University of Technology This research was conducted under the auspices of the Graduate School of Social Sciences II Towards Reflexive Land and Water Management in Iran Linking Technology, Governance and Culture Mohammad Reza Balali Thesis Submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of doctor at Wageningen University by the authority of Rector Magnificus Prof.dr.M.J.Kropff, in the presence of the Thesis Committee appointed by the Doctorate Board to be defended in public on Tuesday 8 September 2009 at 4 PM in the Aula III Mohammad Reza Balali Towards reflexive land and water management in Iran. Linking technology, governance and culture, 255 pages Thesis, Wageningen University, Wageningen, NL (2009) With references, with summaries in Dutch and English ISBN 978-90-8585-427-2 IV Contents Preface 1 Chapter1. Introduction 7 1.1. General picture of Iran 8 1.2. Land and water problems 15 1.3. Linking land and water issues 19 1.4. Research questions and methodology 21 1.5. Overview and structure of dissertation 22 Part I: Theoretical and conceptual 29 Chapter2. Theoretical and conceptual framework 31 2.1.
    [Show full text]
  • Participatory Modelling Platform for Groundwater Irrigation Management with Local Farmers in Iran (Kashan)
    PARTICIPATORY MODELLING PLATFORM FOR GROUNDWATER IRRIGATION MANAGEMENT WITH LOCAL FARMERS IN IRAN (KASHAN) By FOROUGH JAFARY A thesis submitted to the University of Birmingham for the degree of DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY School of Geography, Earth and Environmental Sciences University of Birmingham (UK) April 2016 University of Birmingham Research Archive e-theses repository This unpublished thesis/dissertation is copyright of the author and/or third parties. The intellectual property rights of the author or third parties in respect of this work are as defined by The Copyright Designs and Patents Act 1988 or as modified by any successor legislation. Any use made of information contained in this thesis/dissertation must be in accordance with that legislation and must be properly acknowledged. Further distribution or reproduction in any format is prohibited without the permission of the copyright holder. Abstract This thesis develops a participatory modelling process to study improvement in the management of irrigation efficiency, including physical and social dimensions in the context of arid and semi-arid regions of Iran. This study develops an interdisciplinary and participatory method to understand and strengthen collective decision-making in local Iranian farming systems. Specific attention is given to groundwater irrigated agricultural practices under the Iranian governance system to provide wider context. Kashan City, in central Iran is selected as a case study area for specific reasons, such as historical water use, the farmers’ rich indigenous knowledge, and successful agricultural practices under conditions of water scarcity. The accessibility and willingness of local farmers to engage in a participatory modelling process are considered. The thesis suggests the first use of role- play simulation for irrigation management practices in Iran, is an effective and insightful method of achieving adaptive management solutions.
    [Show full text]
  • Frequently Asked Questions (Faq)
    FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS (FAQ) WHAT IS IOTA? WHY DO I NEED TO SEND QSL CARDS? WHY NOT JUST A Created in 1964 by Geoff Watts, a leading English short wave CERTIFIED CHECKLIST? listener, and taken on by the RSGB in 1985, IOTA is an amateur IOTA is a difficult award programme to administer. IOTA groups radio activity programme designed to encourage contacts with are not always distinguishable by the call-sign prefix or suffix. island stations world-wide. The oceans’ islands have been Also, occasionally, the island named on the QSL may not be grouped into some 1200 ‘IOTA groups’ with, for reasons of recognised immediately by the Checkpoint as falling within a geography, varying numbers of ‘counters’, i.e. qualifying islands, particular claimed group. In such cases it may be necessary to in each. The objective, for the island chaser, is to make radio check a good atlas or even to seek advice from IOTA contact with at least one counter in as many of these groups as Headquarters (HQ) in England. This takes time and it is possible and, for the DXpeditioner, to provide such island considered unreasonable to expect busy national award contacts. For both it is a fun pastime adding much enjoyment to managers or local radio club officials to carry out this function to on the air activity. 21 separate certificates are currently available the level of accuracy required. However, a number of overseas for island chasers, graded in difficulty, as well as two prestigious Checkpoints have been appointed to process IOTA applications awards for high achievement.
    [Show full text]
  • Curriculum Vitae
    Curriculum Vitae Mehran Arian Personal Data: Name Surname Date of Birth Nationality Sex Marital Status Mehran Arian 22/09/1973 Iranian Male Married Telephone Mobile E-mail +9821-44865757 +98-09123007525 [email protected] Educational Background: (Last One First) Certificate Degree Field of Specialization Name of Institution Attended Date Received Ph.D. Structural Geology Shahid Beheshti University, Tehran 2005 M.Sc. Structural Geology Shahid Beheshti University, Tehran 1998 B.Sc. Geology Teacher Training University, Tehran 1996 Diploma Experimental Sciences Razi High School, Zahedan 1992 Title of M.Sc. Thesis: Structural Analysis of SE part of Takab Quadrangle, Iran Title of Ph.D. Dissertation: Structural Significance of Garmsar, Sorkheh, Semnan and Attary faults In the Alborz-Central Iran Border Zone Teaching Experiences: Title of Course Level Dates Name of Institution From To Basement Tectonics Ph.D. Geology 2011 Recent Islamic Azad University Evolution of the Continents Ph.D. Geology 2007 Recent Islamic Azad University Tectonics of Suspected Terrains Ph.D. Geology 2005 2007 Islamic Azad University Diapirism Ph.D. Geology 2005 Recent Islamic Azad University Collision Tectonics Ph.D. Geology 2007 Recent Islamic Azad University Folding Ph.D. Geology 2005 Recent Islamic Azad University Stress Ph.D. Geology 2005 2007 Islamic Azad University Tectonics and Sedimentation Ph.D. Geology 2005 Recent Islamic Azad University Ore Deposits and Tectonics M.Sc. Geology 2007 2008 Islamic Azad University Advanced Structural Geology 1 M.Sc. Geology 2005 2006 Islamic Azad University Applied Structural Geology M.Sc. Geology 2004 2007 Islamic Azad University Neotectonics M.Sc. Geology 2004 Recent Islamic Azad University Middle East Tectonics M.Sc.
    [Show full text]