CENTRAL COUNCIL OF INDIAN MEDICINE NEW DELHI
MINUTES OF 163 rd MEETING OF EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE HELD ON 16 & 17 th May, 2011 AND ADJOURNED MEETING HELD ON 26.5.2011 AT NEW DELHI
PRESENT
1. Vaidya Raghunandan Sharma, President, CCIM Chairman 2. Prof. Hakim Syed Khaleefathullah, Vice-President (Unani) Member 3. Dr. V Stanley Jones, Vice-President (Siddha) Member 4. Dr. PK Jain Member 5. Vaidya Ved Prakash Tyagi Member 6. Dr. Niranjan Singh Tyagi Member 7. Dr. D Ramanathan Iyer Member 8. Dr. Rashidullah Khan Member 9. Dr. V Arunachalam Member Dr. PR Sharma Secretary, CCIM
Following could not attend the meeting:-
1. Dr. Jayaprakash Narayan, Vice-President (Ayurved) 2. Dr. Khalid Siddiqui Member
Agenda Item No.1. Confirmation of minutes of the 162nd meeting of Executive Committee held on 31.1.2011.
It was noted that 162 nd meeting of Executive Committee was held on 31.1.2011. The minutes of the same were circulated to all members of Executive Committee vide letter No. 5-1/2011-EC (162 nd ) dated 10.2.2011 with the request to suggest addition/deletion if any within 15 days.
No comments in respect of the correctness of the minutes were received, therefore, Executive Committee confirmed the minutes.
Agenda Item No.2. Policy decision in respect of the Ayurveda, Unani and Siddha Colleges for the year 2011-12.
It was noted that Government of India was asked to inform the policy for adoption for the year 2011-12 in respect of Ayurveda, Unani and Siddha colleges. The consequent upon a representation of All India Federation of Ayurveda Colleges submitted to HFM and Secretary, AYUSH in respect of the lack of Post-graduate
1163ec teaching staff in almost all specialities as well as of some subjects i.e. Panchkarma, Swasthvritta, Prasuti & Striroga, Kaumarbhrittya and Agadtantra etc. Moreover, there is also a shortage of higher faculty (professor + Reader). In this regard two meetings with HFM and Secretary, AYUSH were convened. As per discussion, the following policy was informed by the CCIM to Government of India.
S. Parameters Minimum Standards Norms for conditional permission for No 2011-12 1. Teaching staff for 1. Under-graduate Course ASU colleges (i) At least 90% of the total requisite teaching staff as per norms with no minimum requirement of teachers from modern faculty. + (ii) 50% higher faculty (Professor+Reader) of the total required higher faculty. + (iii) Availability of at least one teacher in each Department.
(iv) In respect of the Colleges established under section 13 A from 2004-05 to 2008-09 be assessed on the basis of 100% teaching staff. In respect of the Colleges established in 2009- 10 be assessed upto 2 nd professional and established in 2010- 11 be assessed upto 1 st Professional.
Excess number of teacher (over and above from the requirement of CCIM) in any Department will not be taken into consideration of as whole in percentage of teaching staff.
2. Post-graduate Course
i. One Professor/Reader and one Lecturer in concerned subject in addition to requirement of UG teacher-student ratio for deciding PG intake capacity in case of Professor be 1:3 in case of Reader 1:2 and in case of Lecturer 1:1. ii. Where there is no UG, only running PG course 1 Professor, 1 Reader and 1 Lecturer will be required. 2. Number of beds of 1. Under-graduate Course teaching hospital for ASU colleges 1:2 student-bed ratio. However, at least 100 beded hospital
2. Post-graduate Course
Minimum 150 beds 3. OPD of teaching 1. Daily Average OPD attendance of the OPDs running in the hospital for ASU college premises and other own running OPDs in accordance Colleges with the student-patient ratio (1:2) as under:-
Students capacity OPD
50 100 60 120 75 150 100 200
Data of OPDs will be taken into consideration from 1 st January, 2010 to 31 st December, 2010.
2163ec
4. IPD of teaching 1. Under-graduate Course 40% hospital for ASU 2. Post-graduate Course 50% colleges Data for assessment of bed occupancy will be taken into consideration from 1 st January, 2010 to 31 st December, 2010.
5. Constructed area 1. College -- 20,000 Sq.ft. for ASU colleges 2. Hospital -- 20,000 Sq.ft. 6. Nursing Staff 80% of total required staff. 7. Other Para-medical 80% of total required staff. (except Nursing and non-teaching staff)
Note: No fresh teacher appointed and similarly resubmitted data of OPD & IPD will not be taken into consideration after visitation.
In response of the same, Government of India has informed following policy for adoption for the year 2011-12 Applicable to 13 A & 13 C Colleges of Ayurveda, Unani and Siddha colleges.
1. FOR UNDER GRADUATE COURSE.
Sl. Parameter Minimum Standards Requirements for conditional No. permission for the academic session 2011-12 1. Teaching staff for (i) At least 90% of the total requisite teaching staff as per under graduate ASU the CCIM’s draft norms with no minimum requirement of colleges teachers from modern faculty. and (ii) 50% higher faculty (Professor + Reader) of the total required higher faculty staff as per the CCIM’s draft norms. and (iii) Availability of at least one teacher in each Department. 2. Number of beds of For hospitals of Ayurveda and Siddha colleges: Student- teaching hospital for Bed Ratio will be 1:2. However, minimum 100 bedded under graduate ASU hospital is required. colleges For hospitals of Unani colleges: Student-Bed Ratio will be 1:1. However, minimum 50 bedded hospital is required. 3. OPD attendance of Daily average OPD attendance of the OPDs will be teaching hospital for required on an average 100 patients per day during 1 st UG courses in ASU January 2010 to 31 st December, 2010. Colleges 4. Bed Occupancy in IPD Minimum 40% bed occupancy during 1 st January 2010 to of teaching hospital for 31 st December, 2010. under graduate ASU colleges
3163ec
2. FOR POST-GRADUATE COURSE.
Sl. Parameter Minimum Standards Requirements for conditional No. permission for the academic session 2011-12 1. Teaching and non A. All Ayurveda and Siddha colleges are required to be teaching staff for post recommended on the basis of provisions as exist in the graduate ASU colleges notified PG regulations for Ayurveda entitled ‘ The Indian Medicine Central Council (Postgraduate Ayurveda Education) Regulations, 2005’ , except for the following two modifications which are separately being notified- a. The students teachers ratio of 1:3 shall be allowed instead of 1:2 in case of professor for PG students to be admitted per year. b. The minimum annual average bed occupancy in the IPD of the hospital shall be at least 50% instead of 60%. It is reiterated that all the provisions (measurable and non measurable) as contained in the Indian Medicine Central Council (Postgraduate Ayurveda Education) Regulations, 2005 shall be examined by CCIM before sending their recommendation. B. All Unani colleges are required to be recommended on the basis of provisions as exist in the notified PG regulations for Unani entitled ‘ The Indian Medicine Central Council (Postgraduate Unani Education) Regulations, 2007’. It is reiterated that all the provisions (measurable and non measurable) as contained in the Indian Medicine Central Council (Postgraduate Unani Education) Regulations, 2007 shall be examined by CCIM before sending their recommendation. 2. Number of beds of 1. For Post-graduate Course in Ayurveda and Siddha- teaching hospital for post Minimum 150 beds are required including 50 beds for 10 graduate ASU colleges PG seats in clinical subjects with UG intake capacity of 50 students. However, no. of beds in hospital for PG seats in clinical subjects will be maintained in 1:5 student- bed ratio in addition to beds required for UG seats. 2. For PG courses in Unani- Minimum 75 beds are required including 25 beds for 5 PG seats in clinical subjects with UG intake capacity of 50 students. However, total no. of beds in hospital for PG seats in clinical subjects will be maintained in 1:5 student- bed ratio in addition to beds required for UG seats. 3. OPD of teaching hospital Daily average OPD attendance of the OPDs will be for PG ASU Colleges required on an average 100 patients per day during
4163ec
Sl. Parameter Minimum Standards Requirements for conditional No. permission for the academic session 2011-12 period from 1 st January, 2010 to 31 st December, 2010. 4. Bed Occupancy in IPD of Minimum 50% bed occupancy during period from 1 st teaching hospital for post January, 2010 to 31 st December, 2010. graduate ASU colleges
Executive committee noted the same for consideration of the visitation report.
Agenda Item No.3. Consideration of Visitation Report of Ayurved colleges.
It was noted that 250 Ayurved Colleges were visited by the visitors of CCIM appointed as per decision of the Executive Committee in its meeting held on 31.1.2011 under Agenda Item No.03 to assess the available facilities of teaching and practical training for conducting UG and PG course as the case may be and to verify the compliance of the shortcomings informed by the Government of India.
After receipt of the visitation reports, President, CCIM had constituted a Screening Committee of following members to screen the visitation report. the meeting of the Screening Committee was held on 12-13&14.5.2011.
1. Dr. Jayaprakash Narayan, Vice-President (Ayurveda) Convener 2. Dr. PK Jain, Member 3. Dr. VP Tyagi Member 4. Dr. NS Tyagi Member 5. Dr. D Ramanathan Member
Before starting the consideration of the visitation report following decisions were taken:-
i) If required number of teaching staff in accordance to the intake capacity are not available, the decision may be taken by reducing the intake capacity in UG and PG Course as the case may be in accordance to the availability of number of teaching staff. ii) Ayurveda, Unani and Siddha Colleges established under Section 13 A from 2004-05 to 2008-09 be assessed upto 3 rd Professional and colleges established in 2009-10 be assessed upto second professional and colleges established in 2010-11 be assessed for first professional course in respect of requirement of teaching staff.
In view of the above decisions, the visitation reports alongwith the assessment sheet and recommendation of the Screening Committee as well as documents submitted by the college were considered by the Executive Committee and decided as under:-
5163ec
S. College Name Recommendations No 1. SV Ayurved College, Tirupati Recommended UG for 50 seats and PG in Dravyaguna 01 Rasashastra & Bhaishajya Kalpana 01 Kaumarbrittya 03 Shalya (Kshar evam Anushastra Karma) 01
But not recommend PG in Panchkarma and Ayurved Siddhant 2. Vagdevi Ayurved Medical College, Not Recommended Warangal 3. Shree Vageshwari Ayurved Not Recommended Medical College, Karimnagar 4. Government Ayurved College, Recommended UG for 50 seats and Guwahati PG in 1. Samhita 03 2. Siddhant 03 3. Kayachikitsa 01 5. Ravindranath Mukherji Ayurved Not Recommended College, Motihari 6. Swami Raghwendracharya Not Recommended Tridandi Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Gaya 7. Shri Motisingh Jageshwari Ay. Not Recommended College & Hospital, Chhapra 8. Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Gaya Not Recommended 9. Dayanand Ayurved College & Recommended UG for 50 seats Hospital, Siwan 10. Rajiv Lochan Ayurved Chikitsa Recommended UG for 50 seats. Mahavidyalaya, Durg 11. Chhatisgarh Ayurved Medical Not Recommended College, Rajnandgaon, Chhatisgarh 12. Shri Dhanwantry Ayurved College Recommended UG for 50 seats. & Hospital, Chandigarh 13. Bharteeya Sanskrit Prabodhini Recommended UG for 40 seats. Gomantak Ayurved Mahavidyalaya & Research Centre, South Goa. 14. Parul Institute of Ayurved, Limda, Recommended UG for 50 seats. Vadodra
6163ec
15. Arya Kanya Sudh Ayurved Not Recommended Mahavidyalaya, Baroda 16. Balahanunam Ay. College, Lodhra Not Recommended 17. OH Nazar Ayurved College, Surat Recommended UG for 50 seats. 18. JS Ayurved College, Nadiad Recommended UG for 50 seats. 19. Government Ayurved College, Not recommended Junagarh 20. Shri Baba Mastnath Ayurved Not Recommended College, Asthal Bohar, Rohtak 21. Shri Maru Singh Memorial Mahila Not Recommended Ayurved Degree College, Sonepat 22. Seth Murarilal Rasiwasia Ayurved Recommended UG for 50 seats. College Hospital, Charkhi Dadri 23. Surya Mukhi Dinesh Ayurved Recommended UG for 40 seats. College & Hospital, Booty, RANCHI 24. NK Jabashetty Siddharudh Math Recommended UG for 60 seats and Ayurved Medical College, Bidar PG in Prasuti & Striroga 05 Rachna Sharir 05 Panchkarma 03 and Shalya 05 seats. 25. JSS Ayurved Medical College, Recommended for UG with 50 seats Mysore and PG in Rasashastra 04, Panchkarma 05 Dravyaguna 03 26. SS Ayurvedic Medical College, Recommended for UG with 40 Haveri, Karnataka seats. 27. Shri Vijay Mahenthesh Ayurvedic Re-visitation – to clarify the Medical College, Ilkal, (Karnataka) contradiction of total number of patient admitted and total number of bed days occupied of reporting period. 28. Bapuji Ayurvedic Medical College, Recommended UG for 40 seats. Shimoga (Karnataka) 29. TMAE Society’s Ayurved Medical Not Recommended College, Hospet 30. TMAE Society’s Ayurved College, Not Recommended Shimoga 31. Amrutha Ayurved Medical College, Not Recommended Distt. Chitradurga 32. Bapuji Ayurvedic College, Re-visitation – to clarify the Challakere contradiction of total number of
7163ec
patient admitted and total number of bed days occupied of reporting period. 33. SDM College of Ayurveda, Hassan Recommended for UG with 75 seats and PG in Manasroga 05 Swasthavritta 04 Panchkarma 04 Shalakya 04 Shalya 05 Kaumarbhritya 05 Ayurved Samhita 06 Kayachikitsa 06 Kriya Sharir 03 Parsuti & Striroga 03 34. KVG Ayurved Medical College & Recommended for UG with 60 seats Hospital, Sulliya and PG in Dravyaguna 06 Shalya 05 Panchkarma 03 35. Shri JG Cooperative Hospital Recommended UG for 40 seats and Ayurved Medical Collegeg, PG in Ghataprabha Dravyaguna 05, Shalya 05, Kayachikitsa 05, Shalakya 05 Prasuti & Striroga 05
36. Shri Kalabhairaveshwara Swami Recommended UG for 60 seats and Ayurved College, Bangalore PG in Prasuti & Striroga 05 and Panchkarma 05 seats. 37. SDM Ayurved Medical College, Not Recommended Terdal 38. Alva’s Ayurvedic College, Recommended UG for 100 seats Moodbidri, Dakshin Kannada and PG in Rachna Sharir 05 Panchkarma 05 Shalya 05 Kaumarbhritya 05 Dravyaguna 05 Ayurved Siddhant 05 Rasashastra 05 Bhaishajya Kalpana 05
8163ec
Kayachikitsa 05 Prasuti & Striroga 05 Agadtantra 05
39. SNVV Samasthe’s SGV Ayurved Not Recommended College, BAILHONGAL, Belgaum 40. Shri Shivayogeshwar Rural Recommended UG for 50 seats and Ayurvedic Medical College, Inchal PG in Shalya 05 Panchkarma 05 But not recommended for PG in Dravyaguna. 41. Taluka Shikshana Prasaraka Not Recommended Sahakara Mandal Ayurvedic College SINDHAGI Bijapur 42. Acharya Desh Bhushan Ayurved Although college fulfils the criteria Medical College, Bedkihal of permission but there are serious shortfalls mentioned in the assessment sheet, therefore, it is not recommended 43. Shri Jagadguru Gavisiddeshwar Recommended UG for 50 seats and Sansthan, Koppal PG in
Dravyaguna 05, Rasashastra & Bhaishajyakalpana 05 Swasthavritta 05, Shalya 05 Panchkarma 03 seats. 44. Shri Hingulambika Education Not Recommended Society Ayurved College, Gulbarga 45. Shri Basaveshwar Vidya Vardhak Recommended UG for 50 seats. Sangha Ayurved College, Bagalkot 46. Gramin Ayurved Medical College, Not Recommended Terdal 47. Shri SBS Ayurved College, Not Recommended Mundargi 48. CB Guttal Ayurved Medical Not Recommended College, Dharwad 49. Atreya Ayurved Medical College, Not Recommended Bangalore 50. Shri Raghvendracharya Ayurved Not Recommended Medical College, Chitradurga
9163ec
51. Veerpulikeshi Vidyavardhak Not Recommended Samasth’s Rural Ayurved College & Research Centre, Badami, Bagalkot 52. Kannada Balag Society’s Rural Not Recommended Ayurved College, Belgaum
53. Bhagvan Mahavir Jain Ayurved Recommended UG for 50 seats and College, Gajendergarh, Gadag PG in Kayachikitsa 05, Panchkarma 05, Rasashastra & Bhaishajya Kalpana 05 Shalya 05 seats. 54. Rajiv Gandhi Education Society Recommended UG for 40 seats. Ayurvedic college, Ron 55. Rama Krishna Ayurved College, Not Recommended Bangalore 56. Shushrutha Ayurved College, Recommended UG for 50 seats. Bangalore . 57. Ashwin Ayurved College, Tumkur Recommended for UG with 50 seats. 58. AV Samiti’s Ayurved Recommended UG for 50 seats and Mahavidyalya, Bijapur PG in Rasashastra with 05 seats. 59. Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Old Hubli Recommended UG for 50 seats and PG in Ayurved Siddhant 05 Kayachikitsa 05 Shalya 02 Rasashastra 01 Panchkarma 01 60. Shri DM College of Ayurveda, Recommended UG for 75 seats and Udupi PG in Kayachikitsa 06, Shalya 06 Prasuti & Striroga 06 Panchkarma 05 Roganidan 03 Drayaguna 03 Rasashastra 05 Bhaishajyakalpana 02 Rachna Sharir 06 61. Shri DGM Ayurved College, Recommended UG for 60 seats and Gadag PG in Kayachikitsa 05
10 163ec
Dravyaguna 04 Rasashastra 05 Panchkarma 05
62. Govt. Taranath Ayurved College, Recommended UG for 40 seats and Ballary PG in Rasashastra with 07 seats.
63. KLE Society’s Shri Karnataka BM Recommended UG for 75 seats and Kankanwadi Ayurved PG in Mahavidyalaya, Belgaum Rasashastra 05 Dravyaguna 04 Agadtantra 03 Kayachikitsa 03 Shalya 03 Panchkarma 06 Bhaishajya Kalpana 06 Kaumarbhritya 06 But not Recommended for Sangyaharan. 64. Dhanwantri Ayurved Medical Not Recommended College, Hospital & Research Centre, Nipani 65. Smt. Rajeshwari Karpurmath Not Recommended Memorial Ayurved Medical College, Bijapur 66. Sri Siddharameshwar Ayurved Not Recommended Medical College, Hospital, Bidar 67. Shri Siddhvinayak Rural Not Recommended Ayurdvedic Medical College, Belgaum 68. Govt. Ayurved College & Hospital, Recommended UG for 50 seats and Mysore PG in
Ayurved Siddhant 01 Kayachikitsa 07 69. Nangelil Ayurved College, Not Recommended Nangelil 70. PN Panicker Sauhruda Ayurved Not Recommended Medical College, Kasaragod 71. Santhigiri Ayurved College, Not Recommended Palakkad 72. Vishnu Ayurved College, Not Recommended Shoranur, Palkkad
11 163ec
73. Ahalia Ayurved Medical College, Recommended UG for 50 seats. Pallakkad, Kerala 74. VPS Varier Ayurved College, Recommended UG for 50 seats and Edarikode PG in Manasroga with 06 seats but not recommended for Dravyaguna, Swasthavritta, Panchkarma and Agadtantra. 75. KMCT Ayurved Medical College, Not Recommended Kozhikode
76. Mannam Ayurved Medical College, Recommended UG for 50 seats. Pandalam 77. PNMM Bharteeyasastra Recommended UG for 50 seats. Vidyapeeth Ayurved College, Shoranur 78. Pankaj Kasthuri Ayurved College, Not Recommended Thiruvanathapuram (Kerala) 79. Vaidyaratnam Ayurved College, Recommended UG for 40 seats. Ollur, Trichur 80. Parrasianikkadavu Ayurved Recommended UG for 50 seats. College, Kannur 81. Amrita Ayurved Medical College, Recommended UG for 60 seats. Kollam 82. Smt. Dharia Prabhadevi Sojatiya Not Recommended Ayurved Medical College, Bhanpura 83. Ajivan Swasthya Samvardhan Not Recommended Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Satna 84. Rajiv Gandhi Ayurved Not Recommended Mahavidyalaya, Shahpur, Bhopal 85. Rani Dhullaiya Ayurved College & Recommended for UG with 50 seats Hospital, Bhopal and PG in Ayurved Siddhant 05 Rachna Sharir 05 Swastha Vritta 05 Agadtantra 05 Kaumar Bhritya 01 86. Govt. Ayurved College & Hospital, Not Recommended Gwalior 87. Government Ayurved College, Not Recommended Jabalpur 88. Bharti Vidyapeeth’s College of Recommended for UG with 100 Ayurved, Pune seats and PG in
12 163ec
Rachna Sharir 02 Kriya Sharir 02 Dravyaguna 02 Rasashastra 02 Rognidan 04 Swasthavritt 02 Agadtantra 02 Prasuti & Striroga 04 Kayachikitsa 04 Shalya 02 Shalakya 04 Panchkarma 04 But not recommended for PG in Samhita, Kaumarbhritya and Sangyaharan. 89. Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Rahuri Recommended UG for 60 seats and Factory, Ahmednagar PG in Kayachikitsa 06, Prasuti & Striroga 06 Shalya 03 Rasashastra 04 Roganidana 04 Shalakya 04 90. Maharashtra Arogya Mandal’s Recommended for UG with 60 seats Sumati Bhai Shah Ayurved and PG in Mahavidyalaya, Pune Kriya Sharir 03 Rachna Sharir 03 Rasashastra 03 Prasuti & Striroga 02 Kayachikitsa 02 Shalya 02 Ayurved Siddhant 01 Dravyaguna 03 Roganidana 03 Agadtantra 03 91. College of Ayurveda & Research Recommended UG for 60 seats and Centre, Akurdi PG in Kayachikitsa 04, Rachna Sharir 04, Kriyasharir 02 Rognidan 02 Swasthavirtta 02 Shalya 02 Dravyaguna 02
13 163ec
Panchkarma 02 Ayurved Siddhant 02 Prasuti & Striroga 02 92. Sangam Sevabhavi Trust’s Recommended UG for 50 seats. Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Sangamner 93. Vasant Kusum Rural Yoga & Recommended UG for 60 seats and Ayurved Sansthan Siddhakala PG in Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Prasuti & Striroga 02 Sangamner Kaumbar Brittya 02 Shalya 02 Kayachikitsa 01 Rachna Sharir 04 94. Bharatiya Sanskriti Darshan Trust Recommended UG for 60 seats and Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Wagholi PG in Samhita 02 Rachna Sharir 01 Kayachikitsa 02 95. Chhatrapati Sahu Maharaj Recommended UG for 100 seats Shikshan Sansthan Ayurved and PG in Mahavidyalaya, Aurangabad Kayachikitsa 04 Rachna Sharir 03 96. Yashwant Ayurved Recommended UG for 80 seats and Mahavidyalaya, Kodoli PG in
Roganidana 02 Agadtantra 02 Shalakya 02 Samhita 06 Kayachikitsa 06 Rasashastra 06 Rachna Sharir 06 Swasthavirtta 06 Prasuti & Striroga 06 Kaumabrittya 06 Shalya 06 97. Hanuman Shikshan Prasarak Recommended UG for 50 seats. Mandal’s Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Kolhapur
98. Ganga Education Society’s Not Recommended. Ayurved College, Kolhapur 99. Smt. KC Ajmera Ayurved Recommended UG for 40 seats. Mahavidyalaya, Dhule
14 163ec
100. Dada Saheb Surupsingh Naik Not Recommended Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Nangaon, Dhule 101. Chaitanya Ayurved Mahavidyala, Recommended UG for 50 seats. Jalgaon 102. Shri KR Pandav Ayurved College Recommended UG for 50 seats. & Hospital, Nagpur 103. Yerala Medical Trust & Ayurved Recommended UG for 80 seats and College, Mumbai PG in Rachana Sharir 04 Kriya Sharir 04 Dravyaguna 04 Rasashastra 04 Bhaishajya Kalpana 04 Kayachikitsa 04 Shalya (Samanya) 04 Shalaya (Kshar Karma & Anushastra Karma) 04 Shalakya 04 104. Nalasopara Ayurved College, Recommended UG for 40 seats. Vasai, Thane 105. Bhau Saheb Maulak Ayurved Recommended UG for 60 seats. Mahavidyalaya, Nagpur 106. Shri Gajanan Maharaj Sansthan Recommended UG for 50 seats. Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Pusad
107. Gramin Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Not Recommended Patur
108. Lt.Sunil Ramshingji Chunawale Recommended UG for 40 seats. Ayurved College, Chikhli, Buldana 109. Mahadeorao Shivankar Ayurved Recommended UG for 50 seats. College & Research Institute, Gondia 110. Shri Saptashrungi Ayurved Recommended UG for 50 seats. College, Nasik 111. Padamshri Dr. DY Patil College of Recommended UG for 100 seats. Ayurveda & Research Institute, Narul, Navi Mumbai 112. Cap. Kedari Redekar Ayurved Recommended UG for 50 seats and College, Kolhapur PG in
Roganidana 04
15 163ec
Rasashastra 05 Shalya 05 113. Padamshri Dr. Vitthal Rao Vikhl Recommended UG for 40 seats. Patil Foundation Ayurved College Shevgaon, Ahmednagar
114. Dr. DY Patil Pratishtan Ayurved Recommended UG for 75 seats and College, Pimpri, Pune (MS). PG in
Samhita 04 Rachna Sharir 04 Prasuti & Striroga 04 Kayachikitsa 04 Shalya 04 115. Jupiter Ayurved College & Tarini Not Recommended Ayurved Hospital, Nagpur 116. Annasaheb Dange Ayurved Recommended UG for 50 seats and College, Sangali PG in Kriya Sharir 05 Rasashastra 05 Shalya 05 Rachna Sharir 02 117. Manjara Ayurved College & Recommended UG for 50 seats. Hospital, Latur 118. Dhanwantari Ayurved College Re-visitation – to clarify the UDGIR contradiction of total number of patient admitted and total number of bed days occupied of reporting period. 119. Ashvin Rural Ayurved College, Recommended UG for 40 seats. Manchi Hill, Ashvi B.K., Ahmednagar 120. Ramrao Patil Ayurved Not Recommended Mahavidyalaya & Rugnalaya, Purna, Parbhani 121. Loknete Rajarambapu Patil Recommended UG for 50 seats and Ayurved College, Sangli PG in Bhaishajya Kalpana 06 Roganidan 06 Swasthavritta 06 Agadtantra 06 Kayachikitsa 05 Shalya 05 Shalakya 06
16 163ec
Prasuti & Striroga 02 Panchkarma 04 122. Rural Institute of Ayurved & Recommended UG for 50 seats. Research Centre, Hospital, Myani 123. JJ Magadum Ayurved Medical Recommended UG for 40 seats. College, Kolhapur 124. Mahatma Gandhi Ayurved Recommended UG for 50 seats. College, Hospital & Research Centre, Wardha 125. Aditya Ayurved College, Distt. Not Recommended Beed 126. SMBT Ayurved College, Igatpuri, Recommended UG for 50 seats. Nashik 127. Mahila Utkarsh Ayurved College, Recommended UG for 50 seats. Hospital & Research Centre, Washim 128. Tilak Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Recommended for UG with 100 Pune seats and PG in Rachna Sharir 02 Dravyaguna 02 Rasashastra 02 Prasuti & Striroga 04 Kayachikitsa 04 Rognidan 04 Shalya (Samanya) 01 Shalakya 04 Panchkarma 04 Agadtantra 01 But not recommended for PG in Sangyaharan, Samhita Siddhant, Kriya Sharir, Swasthavritta, Kaumarbhritya 129. Ashtang Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Recommended for UG with 40 seats Pune and PG in Samhita 03 Prasuti & Striroga 01 But not recommended for PG in Rachna Sharir 130. Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Nasik Recommended for UG with 50 seats and PG in Kayachikitsa 03 Shalya 04 But not recommended for PG in Panchkarma
17 163ec
131. KVTR Ayurved College, Dhule Recommended for UG with 30 seats.
132. Shri Gangadhar Shastri Gune Recommended UG for 50 seats. Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Ahmednagar 133. Vasant Dada Patil Ayurved College, Not Recommended Sangli 134. Seth Chandanmal Mutha Aryangla Recommended UG for 50 seats and Vaidyak Mahavidyalaya, Satara PG in Kayachikitsa with 03 seats. 135. Seth Govindji Raoji Ayurved Not Recommended Mahavidylaya, Sholapur 136. Smt. KG Mittal Punarvasu Recommended UG for 50 seats and Ayurved Mahavidyalaya , Mumbai PG in Samhita 04 Dravyaguna 02 Kayachikitsa 08 But not recommended in Rasashastra 137. RJVS Bhaisaheb Sawant Ayurved Recommended UG for 40 seats. Mahavidyalaya, Sawantwadi 138. Maharashtra Education Society, Recommended UG for 50 seats Ghanekhunt-Lote, Tal. Khed, Distt. Ratnagiri (MS) 139. Shree Gurukrupa Shikshan Recommended UG for 50 seats. Prasarak Mandal, Rahul Villa, Kosara Road, Padoli, Chandrapur (MS) 140. Shri Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Recommended UG for 60 seats and Nagpur PG in Shalakya 03 Kayachikitsa 05 Kriya Sharir 03 But not recommended for Rognidan,Panchkarma, Agadtantra, Ayurved Samhita,Sharir Rachana, Dravyaguna, Rasashastra, Shalya and Kaumarbhritya 141. Shri Radha Krishna Toshniwal Recommended UG for 50 seats and Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Akola PG in Samhita 01 Shalya 01 But not recommended for Rachna Sharir & Kayachikitsa
18 163ec
142. Vidarbha Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Recommended UG for 50 seats but Amrawati not Recommended for PG in Shalakya 143. Shri Gurudev Ayurved Recommended UG for 50 seats. Mahavidyalaya, Amrawati 144. Mayurbhanj Ayurved Not Recommended Mahavidyalaya, Mayurbhanj
145. Shri Nrusinghnath Ayurved Recommended UG for 30 seats. College & Research Institutie, Paikmal 146. Indira Gandhi Memorial Ayurved Not Recommended College & Hospital, Bhubneshwar 147. Babe Ke Ayurved College & Recommended UG for 50 seats. Hospital, Moga 148. Desh Bhagat Ayurved College & Recommended UG for 60 seats. Hospital, Fatehgarh Sahib 149. SSMD Ayurved College, Moga Not Recommended 150. Saint Sahara Ayurved Medical Recommended UG for 50 seats College & Hospital, Bhatinda 151. Mai Bhago Ayurved College for Recommended UG for 50 seats. Women, Muktsar 152. Guru Nank Ayurved College & Recommended UG for 60 seats. Hospital, Muktsar 153. Shri Laxminaryan Ayurved Not Recommended College, Amritsar 154. Guru Nanak Ayurved College & Recommended UG for 50 seats. Research Institute, Ludhiana 155. Dayanand Ayurved College, Recommended UG for 50 seats. Jallandhar
156. Shaheed Kartar Singh Sarabha After obtaining the clarification of Ayurved College & Hospital, the NOC of the State Government Ludhiana and affiliation of the University as well as latest status of the court the matter will be consider. 157. JR Tatia’s Shriganganagar College Recommended UG for 50 seats. of Ayurvedic Sciences, Shriganganagar 158. Punjab Ayurved Medical College & Not Recommended Hospital, Sriganganagar 159. Shikhawati Ayurved Medical Not Recommended College, Pillani
19 163ec
160. Shri Bhanwar Lal Dugar Ayurved Recommended UG for 40 seats. Vishwabharti, Sardar Shehar 161. Shri Shirdi Sai Baba Ayurved Recommended UG for 50 seats. College & Hospital, Mundiyagarh, Kishangerh, Renwal, Jaipur, 162. Ayurved College, Coimbatore Not Recommended 163. Dharma Ayurved College & Not Recommended Hospital, Kanchipuram 164. Sri Sairam Ayurved College & Recommended UG for 40 seats. Research Centre, Chennai 165. Shri Jayendra Saraswati Ayurved Recommended UG for 50 seats. College, Nazarepet 166. Uttaranchal Ayurved College, Recommended UG for 50 seats. Dehradun 167. Himalayaiya Ayurved Yoga Avam Recommended UG for 50 seats. Prakritic Chikitsa Sansthan, Dehradun 168. Patanjali Ayurved Medical College, Recommended UG for 50 seats. Roorki, Haridwar 169. Government Gurukul Ayurved Recommended UG for 50 seats. College, Haridwar 170. Government Rishikul Ayurved Recommended UG for 60 seats and PG College, Haridwar in Rasashastra 07 Shalya 05 But Not recommended in Panchkarma 171. Aligarh Ayurved & Unani College & Recommended UG for 50 seats. Hospital, Aligarh 172. JD Ayurvedic Medical College & Recommended UG for 50 seats. Hospital, Aligarh 173. Lal Bahadur Shastri Govt. Not Recommended Mahavidyalaya, Handia 174. Major SD Singh Ayurved Medical Recommended UG for 50 seats. College & Hospital, Farrukhabad 175. Bharat Ayurvedic Medical College, Recommended UG for 50 seats. Muzaffarnagar (UP) 176. Belley Sankerpur Rajiv Gandhi Recommended UG for 50 seats. Memorial Ayurved College & Hospital, 24, Pargnas (N) 743129.
As consideration of visitation report of all Ayurved colleges could not taken place, therefore, it was decided to adjourned the meeting for 26 th may, 2011.
20 163ec
Agenda Item No.4 Consideration of Visitation Report of Unani colleges.
It was noted that 41 Unani Colleges were visited by the visitors of CCIM appointed as per decision of the Executive Committee in its meeting held on 31.1.2011 under Agenda Item No.03 to assess the available facilities of teaching and practical training for conducting UG/PG course as the case may be and to verify the compliance of the shortcomings informed by the Government of India.
After receipt of the visitation reports, President, CCIM had constituted a Screening Committee of following members to screen the visitation report of Unani colleges. the meeting of the Screening Committee was held on 14-15.5.2011.
1. Prof. Syed Khaleefathullah, Vice-President (Unani) Convener 2. Dr. Khalid Siddiqui Member 3. Dr. Rashidullah Khan Member
At the time of consideration of the visitation report, Executive Committee observed that bed occupancy has been calculated by Screening Committee(Unani) by restricting the bed strength upto 50 by maintaining the student bed ratio as 1:1 in order of letter issued by Government of India dated 18.3.2011 (referred under Agenda Item No.2) instead of actual bed strength informed by the college and duly verified by the visitors.
Moreover, it was also observed that Screening Committee (Unani) has taken into consideration the essentiality of 7 departments in each Unani college instead of 10 departments. Executive Committee was of the opinion that observance of 10 departments in each college should be followed as per letter issued by the Government of India i.e. No.R.11011/08/2009-EP dated 22.12.2009 as well as decision of the Central Council of Indian Medicine under Minimum Standards and Requirements of Unani College & Hospital. Vice-President (Unani) and Dr. Rashidullah Khan, Member, EC objected the same and later on walked out in protest.
After departing of Vice-President (Unani) and Dr. Rashidullah Khan, Member, EC, Executive Committee decided that minimum bed strength of the hospital should be observed 50. The college having less than 50 beds should not be recommended for granting permission for the year 2011-12 as per letter of Government of India dated 18.3.2011 (referred under Agenda Item No.2). Moreover, The bed occupancy should be calculated on the basis of actual bed strength informed by the college in its visitation proforma and duly verified by the visitors. It was also decided that observance of 10 departments in each college should be followed as per letter issued by the Government of India i.e. No.R.11011/08/2009-EP dated 22.12.2009 as well as decision of the Central Council of Indian Medicine under Minimum Standards and Requirements of Unani College & Hospital.
21 163ec
In view of the above and decision taken at the time of consideration of Ayurved colleges, the visitation reports alongwith the assessment sheet and recommendation of the Screening Committee as well as documents submitted by the college were considered by the Executive Committee and decided as under:-
S. Name of the College Recommendation of Executive No Committee 1. Abdul Haque Unani Medical Recommended College, Kurnool (A.P) 2. Mohsin-e-Millat Unani Revisit Medical College, RAIPUR 3. Saifia Hamidia Unani Tibbia Recommended College, BURHANPUR (M.P.) 4. A&U Tibbia College, Not Recommended Karolbagh, New Delhi 5. Jamia Hamdard, New Delhi Not Recommended 6. Luqman Unani Medical Recommended College, Bijapur 7. Tipu Sultan Unani Medical Recommended College, Gulbarga 8. Govt. Unani Medical College, Not Recommended Bangalore 9. HMS Unani Medical College & Not Recommended Hospital, Tumkur 10. MIJ Tibbia Unani Medical Recommended College, Mumbai 11. Mohammadia Tibbia College Recommended for 50 seats only of UG & Hospital,Malegaon & PG in 2 subjects 12. Iqra Society’s Unani Medical Recommended College, Jalgaon 13. Rajputana Unani Medical Not Recommended College, Jaipur 14. Ibne-Sina Tibbia College & Recommended Hospital, Azamgarh 15. State Unani Medical College, Not recommended Allahabad 16. Aligarh Unani Medical Not Recommended College, Aligarh 17. Shame-Ghausia Unani Recommended Medical College, Ghazipur 18. Ajmal Khan Tibbia College, Not recommended Aligarh 19. Calcutta Unani Medical Recommended College, KOLKATA (W.B.)
22 163ec
20. Yunus Fazlani Unani Medical Recommended College, Kunjekheda (MS)
As consideration of visitation report of all Ayurved colleges could not taken place, therefore, it was decided to adjourned the meeting for 26 th may, 2011.
Agenda Item No.5. Consideration of Visitation Report of Siddha colleges.
It was noted that 09 Siddha Colleges have been visited by the visitors of CCIM appointed as per decision of the Executive Committee in its meeting held on 31.1.2011_under Agenda Item No.03 to assess the available facilities of teaching and practical training for conducting UG/PG course as the case may be and to verify the compliance of the shortcomings informed by the Government of India.
After receipt of the visitation reports, President, CCIM had constituted a Screening Committee of following members to screen the visitation report. the meeting of the Screening Committee was held on 14.5.2011 .
1. Dr. V Stanley Jones, Vice-President (Siddha) Convener 2. Dr. V Arunachalam Member 3. Dr. Natrajan, Siddha Expert Member
The visitation reports alongwith the assessment sheet and recommendation of the Screening Committee as well as documents submitted by the college were considered by the Executive Committee in the view of decision taken at the time of consideration of the visitation reports of Ayurveda colleges and decided as under:-
S.No. Name of the College Recommendations 1. Govt. Siddha Medical College, Recommended Tirunelveli 627002, UG:75 PALAYAMKOTTAI, TN PG:60 (6) (i) Maruthuvam- 10 seats (clinical), (ii) Gunapadam-10 seats (iii) Sirappu Maruthuvam - 10 seats (clinical) (iv) Kuzhanthai Maruthuvam -10 seats(clinical) (v) Noi Nadal- 10 seats and (vi) Nanju Nooium Maruthuva Needhi Nooium- 10 seats 2. Govt. Siddha Medical College, Recommended Arumbakkam, CHENNAI, TN UG: 50 PG: 34 (5)
(i) Maruthuvam- 10 seats (clinical), (ii) Gunapadam-10 seats (iii) Sirappu Maruthuvam - 5 seats (clinical) (iv)
23 163ec
Kuzhanthai Maruthuvam -5 seats(clinical) (v) Noi Nadal- 4 seats 3. Akila Thiruvithamcore Siddha Not Recommended Vaidya Sangam Siddha Maruthuva Kallory & Hospital, Munchirari, KANYAKUMARI, 4. Sri Sai Ram Siddha Medical Recommended College & Research Centre, UG: 40 CHENNAI, TN 5. Velumailu Siddha Medical Not recommended College, Sriperumbudur, KANCHEEPURAM, TN 6. Santhigiri Siddha Medical Recommended College, UG: 50 THIRUVANATHAPURAM, 7. National Institute of Siddha, Recommended Tambaram, CHENNAI, TN PG: 41 (6) (i) Maruthuvam- 6 seats (clinical), (ii) Gunapadam-7seats (iii) Sirappu Maruthuvam - 7 seats (clinical) (iv) Kuzhanthai Maruthuvam -7 seats(clinical) (v) Noi Nadal- 7 seats and (vi) Nanju Nooium Maruthuva Needhi Nooium- 7 seats 8. RVS Siddha Medical College, Recommended 242 B, Trichy Road, SULUR,TN UG 30 seats 9. Sivaraj Siddha Medical Recommended UG 50 seats college, Salem, TN
Agenda Item No.6 Sanction of Allied Subjects of Ayurveda
It was noted that Government of India vide letter No.R.11011/5/2010-EP dated 18.3.2011 in response of the letter No.28-14/2010-Ay.UG (Regl) dated 14.1.2011 of CCIM was conveyed the sanction of allied subjects of Ayurveda reads as under and directed to follow the same. Further, it was noted that the same with the views of the Government of India have been notified in the Gazette of India from Part III of Section 4 dated 2.4.2011.
***In absence of the candidate of Post-graduate qualification in concern subject the candidate of the following subjects as mentioned against them shall be eligible for the post of Lecturer/Asstt. Professor:-
S.No. Subject Discipline Post-graduate 1. Swastha Vritta 1. Kayachikitsa 2. Agadtantra 2. Dravyaguna/Rasashastra 3. Rog Vigyan 3. Kayachikitsa 4. Rachna Sharir 4. Shalya
24 163ec
5. Kriya Sharir 5. Samhita Siddhant 6. Shalakya 6. Shalya 7. Panchkarma 7. Kayachikitsa 8. Balroga 8. Prasuti & Striroga/Kayachikitsa 9. Kayachikitsa 9. Manasroga
A provision of allied subject will be allowed for five years. b. the teacher(s) who had been considered eligible in the past on the basis of previous Regulations shall not be considered ineligible on the basis of amendment.
Executive Committee noted the same.
Agenda Item No.7. Sanction of Allied Subjects of Unani.
It was noted that Government of India while approving the policy of adoption for the year 2011-12 for furnishing the recommendation in respect of Ayurveda, Unani and Siddha colleges also conveying the sanction for proposed allied subjects of Unani reads as under vide letter No.R.11011/5/2010-EP dated 18.3.2011 and directed to follow the same.
S. Subject Allied Subjects No. 1. Kulliyate Tib --- 2. Tashreehul Badan Ilmul Jarahat 3. Munafeul Aza Kulliyate Tib 4. Ilmul Advia --- 5. Saidla Ilmul Advia 6. Ilmus Samoom wa Tibbe Qanooni Tahaffuzi wa Samaji Tib/Moalajat/ Ilmul advia 7. Tahaffuzi wa Samaji Tibb ---
8. Moalajat --- 9. Sareeriyat Moalajat 10. Mahiyatul Amraz Moalajat/ Kulliyate Tib 11. Ilaj bil Tadabeer Moalajat/Tahaffuzi wa Samaji Tib 12. Amraze Jild Moalajat 13. Ilmul Jarahat ---- 14. Amraze Uzn, Anf wa Halaq Ilmul Jarahat 15. Amraze Ain Ilmul Jarahat 16. Ilmul Atfal Moalajat/Qabalat wa Amraze Niswan
Process of issuing Gazette Notification is under process.
25 163ec
Executive Committee noted the same.
Agenda item No.8 Approval of the recommendations of screening committee constituted to examine the matter of MACP.
It was noted that as Government of India has implemented the MACP scheme to the employees of the CCIM and Executive Committee in its 153 rd meeting held on 14.7.2009 decided to implement the same with the sanction of Government of India. Accordingly Government of India was requested to convey the sanction for the same. After receipt of the sanction of Government of India, a Sub Committee was constituted consisting of following member to examine the matter of employees of Group B in view of the guidelines issued by Government of India in the matter.
1. Sh. Sube Singh, Assistant Secretary (Admn.) 2. Sh. Ram Swaroop, Consultant (R.T.I.). 3. Sh. K. N. Subudhi, Legal Consultant
The Screening Committee in its meeting held on 04.4.2011 has recommended as under:-
S. Name of the eligible Existing Pay Proposed Grade Pay Recommendations of the No. employee, post held Band & Grade under MACP Scheme. Screening Committee and date of initial Pay or Basic Pay appointment 1. Smt. Bimla Wadhwa, OS PB – 2 Rs.9300- Rs.4800/- with 3% Recommended 34800 plus Grade increment (P.B.+G.P.) 01.11.75 Pay Rs.4600/- w.e.f. 01.9.08 3rd MACP w.e.f. 01.9.2008 (i.e. the date of in the grade pay of Rs.4800/- 1.1.06 = 18930 implementation of with 3% increment (PB+GP) (14330+4600) M.A.C.P.
1.7.06 = 19500 (14900+4600)
1.7.07 = 20090 (15490+4600)
1.7.08= 20700 (16100+4600)
Further, it was noted that to consider the matter of MACP for the employees of Group ‘C’ & ‘D’ a Screening Committee consisting of following employees were constituted:-
1. Sh. Sube Singh, Assistant Secretary (Admn.) 2. Sh. Rajesh Jain, Accountant 3. Smt. Vijay Laxmi, Office Superintendent
26 163ec
The meeting of Screening Committee was convened on 05.2.2011 and recommendations of the Screening Committee are as under:-
S.No. Name of the employees, Post & date of initial Recommendations of the Screening appointment Committee 1. Sh. H.D. Bhardwaj Agreed. Ex- Jr. Steno. (01.3.74) Recommended 3rd MACP w.e.f. Existing Grade Pay Rs.4200/- 01.9.08 in the Grade Pay of Rs.4600/- Retired on 30.6.09 with 3% increment (P.B.+G.P.). 2. Smt. Uma Sharda Agreed. LDC (25.10.76) Recommended 3rd MACP w.e.f. Existing Grade Pay Rs.4200/- 01.9.08 in the Grade Pay of Retired on 31.3.09 Rs.4600/- with 3% increment (P.B.+G.P.). 3. Smt. Vijay Laxmi Agreed
LDC ( 14.10.80 ) Recommended 3rd MACP w.e.f. Promoted as UDC on 19.2.96 14.10.10 in the Grade Pay of Rs.4600/- with 3% increment 2nd ACP on 13.12.04 (P.B.+G.P.)
Existing Grade Pay Rs.4200/- 4. Sh. BKBasvaraju Agreed LDC (10.12.86) Recommended 2nd MACP w.e.f. Promoted as UDC on 19.2.96 01.9.08 in the Grade Pay of Rs.2800/- Existing Grade Pay Rs.2400/- with 3% increment (P.B.+G.P.) 5. Sh. Lal Babu Mahto Filed CWP No.1671/97 Sh.Lal Babu Chowkidar(13.12.72) Mahto V/s. Central Council of Indian Medicine & Union of India and Appointed as LDC on 27.9.79 Others before High Court of Delhi at New Delhi regarding reversion from Promoted as UDC 13.2.08 the post of Upper Division Clerk to Lower Division Clerk which is still Existing Grade Pay Rs.2800/- pending.
Retired on 30.6.10 Agreed.
Recommended 3rd MACP w.e.f. 27.9.09 in the Grade Pay of Rs.4200/- with 3% increment (P.B.+G.P.) subject to submit undertaking to safeguard the pubic money.
27 163ec
6. Sh. Mazhar-e-Islam Agreed. LDC (04.12.86) Recommended 2 nd MACP w.e.f. Promoted as UDC on 24.3.10 01.09.08 in the Grade Pay of Rs.2800/- Grade Pay with 3% Existing Grade Pay Rs.2400/- increment (P.B.+G.P.). 7. Sh. Nihal Miyan Agreed. LDC (04.12.86) Recommended 2 nd MACP w.e.f. Existing Grade Pay Rs.2400/- 01.09.08 in the Grade Pay of Rs.2800/- with 3% increment (P.B.+G.P.).
8. Sh. Rajpal Singh Agreed. Peon-cum-Chowkidar 06.5.83 Recommended 2 nd MACP w.e.f. Appointed as LDC 04.12.86 01.09.08 in the Grade Pay of Rs.2800/- with 3% increment Existing Grade Pay Rs.2400/- (P.B.+G.P.). 9. Sh. Santosh Upadhyay He was working as Accountant on LDC (06.8.97) deputation basis w.e.f. 16.2.06 to (Deputed on 16.2.06 AN on deputation 30.1.09 in the PB – 1 5200-20200 and basis as Accountant in Principal Accounts G.P. Rs.2800/- was drawn. Hence, no Office, Ministry of Urban Development, arrear of MACPS will be drawn for Nirman Bhawan the said period. Repatriated to parent office CCIM on 30.1.09 (AN). Agreed.
Existing Grade Pay Rs1900/- Recommended 1st MACP w.e.f. 01.09.08 in the Grade Pay of Rs.2000/- with 3% increment (P.B.+G.P.) but the arrear will be payable w.e.f. 31.1.09.
10. Sh. Harban Meena Agreed. L.D.C. (11.8.97 ) Recommended 1st MACP w.e.f. Existing Grade Pay Rs1900/- 01.09.08 in the Grade Pay of Rs.2000/- with 3% increment (P.B.+G.P.). 11. Smt. Shashi Wariyal Agreed. L.D.C. (08.9.97) Recommended 1st MACP w.e.f. 01.09.08 in the Grade Pay of Existing Grade Pay Rs1900/- Rs.2000/- with 3% increment (P.B.+G.P.).
28 163ec
2. Details of employees entitled for financial upgradation under TBOP/BCR/ACP-1/ACP-2 to the erstwhile Group ‘D’ now classifieds as multi-tasking staff Group ‘C’ during the period 1.1.2006 to 31.8.2008
S.No. Name of the employees Recommendations of the Screening Committee 1. Sh. Anand Parkash 1. Recommended financial Peon(23.4.71) upgradation only Grade Pay of Rs.2000/- w.e.f. 01.1.06 Daftary on 25.6.73 to 31.8.08. Duplicating Operator on 01.12.81 2. Recommended 3 rd MACP w.e.f. 01.09.08 to Grade Pay on the date of retirement Rs1900/- 28.2.10 in the Grade Pay of Rs.2400/- with 3% increment Retirement on 28.2.10 (P.B.+G.P.). Died on March, 2010 2. Sh. Kishan Lal 1. Recommended financial Safaiwala (16.10.75) upgradation only Grade Pay of Rs.2000/- w.e.f. 01.1. 06 Retired on 31.10.09 to 31.8.08 .
As per ACP scheme upgradation in the pay 2. Recommended 3 rd scale of Rs.2750-70-3800-75-4400/- vide O.O. MACP w.e.f. 01.09.08 to 13-15/01 dated 11.9.01 w.e.f. 01.10.99 31.10.09 in the Grade Pay of Rs.2400/- with 3% increment Grade Pay on the date of retirement Rs1800/- (P.B.+G.P.).
3. Sh. P.S. Meena Agreed Peon (24.6.92) 1. Recommended financial upgradation only Grade Pay Promoted as Daftary of Rs.1900/- w.e.f. on adhoc basis dated 02.12.96 01.1.06 .
He was appointed as LDC on Appointed as LDC on purely temporary basis purely temporary basis on on 21.2.08 and reverted to his initial post of 21.2.08 in the Grade Pay of Daftary on 02.2.09. Rs.1900/- and reverted to his initial post of Daftary on Promoted as Duplicating Operator 02.2.09 . Hence, no arrear of as on 25.3.10 . financial upgradation under MACPS will be drawn for the Existing Grade Pay Rs1900/- period w.e.f. 21.2.08 to 01.2.2009.
29 163ec
4. Sh. Ramchander, Peon (04.12.86) Agreed 1st ACP on 09.8.99 in the pay scale of Rs.2610- 1. Recommended financial 4000/ upgradation only Grade Pay of Rs.1900/- w.e.f. Daftary on 23.8.05 01.1.06 to 31.8.08 . 2. 2 nd MACP is to be fixed in Existing Grade Pay Rs1800/- the Grade Pay of Rs.2000/- w.e.f. 01.9.08 with 3% increment (P.B.+G.P.). 5. Sh. Dharamvir Agreed. Recommended Peon (01.10.91) financial upgradation only 1st ACP on 01.10.03 in the pay scale of Rs.2610- Grade Pay of Rs.1900/- w.e.f. 4000/- 01.1.06. Existing Grade Pay Rs1800/-
The above recommendations were placed before the President, CCIM and President, CCIM approved for implementation of the same and further directed to placed before the Executive Committee.
Executive Committee approved the same.
Agenda Item No. 9 Extension of period of Legal Consultant
It was noted that Mr. KN Subudhi was engaged to look after the legal work of the Council. Initially he was engaged for three months, thereafter for six months which was expired on 31.3.2011. The President, CCIM after satisfying with the services of Mr. KN Subudhi agreed to extend the tenure of Mr. KN Subudhi as Legal Consultant for next 11 months i.e. upto 28 th February, 2012.
Executive Committee ratified the same.
Agenda Item No.10 List of Visitors
It was noted that as per decision of the Executive Committee in its meeting held on 30 th January, 2011 under Agenda Item No.3. The members of Executive Committee of respective systems under the Chairmanship of Vice-Presidents (Ayurveda, Unani & Siddha) prepared the list of the visitors. After the approval of the President, CCIM, all colleges have been visited. On denial of the teachers, the alternate arrangement was made by the office with the directions of the President, CCIM time to time.
Executive Committee noted the same.
30 163ec
Agenda Item No. 11. Amendment in IMCC (PG Ayurveda Education) Regulations, 2005 - reg. , It was noted that Government of India vide letter No R. 11011/5/2010-EP dated 18.3.2011 in response of the CCIM’s letter No. 26-74/2010-Common Matters dated 10.03.2011 has conveyed the approval of competent authority on proposed Amendment in IMCC (PG Ayurveda Education) Regulations, 2005 as follows:-
Regulation Existing provision under IMCC Proposed amendment No. (PG Ayurveda Education) Regulations, 2005 13. (9) and The annual average bed- The annual average bed-occupancy 17. (7) occupancy in the hospital shall be in the hospital shall be at least fifty more than sixty percent. percent. 15. Students teacher ratio.- The Students teacher ratio- The teacher student ratio shall be teacher student ratio shall be such such that the number of post- that the number of post-graduate graduate teachers to the number teachers to the number of post- of post-graduate student graduate student admitted per year admitted per year is maintained is maintained at 1:3 in case of at 1:2 in case of Professors and Professors, 1:2 in case of Readers Readers and 1:1 for Lecturer(s). and 1:1 for Lecturer(s). Maximum Maximum number of students per number of students per specialty specialty shall not exceed six. shall not exceed six.
Accordingly, a Gazette Notification amending the IMCC (Post-graduate Education in Ayurveda) Regulations, 2005 has been issued on 2 nd April, 2011.
Executive Committee noted the same.
Agenda item No.12 To enhance the power of Secretary, CCIM.
It was noted that President, CCIM again desiring to authorize the Registrar to sanction expenditure of miscellaneous and contingent nature upto an amount of Rs.25,000/- instead of Rs.2,000/- on the following grounds.
However, in this connection provision in General Regulation reads under:-
“81. The Registrar shall have power to sanction expenditure of miscellaneous and contingent nature upto an amount not exceeding Rs.2000/- in each case and expenditure in excess of this amount shall require the sanction of the President. 82. A permanent advance of Rs.2000/- shall be made to the Registrar.”
Grounds:
1. To obtain the sanction of the President, CCIM on the contingent expenditure more than Rs.2000/- in respect of essential as well as regular expenses like post, telegram, telephone, speed-post, internet etc. takes time because
31 163ec
President is residing out of Delhi. To ensure the timely payment of these bills, either the file has to be sent to the residence of the President, CCIM i.e. Jaipur through messenger or President, CCIM may have to come to the office frequently. It also involve the regular expenditure, therefore, to avoid such type of recurrence expenditure as well as penalty on account of delay payment, it will be in the interest of the Office to enhance the sanction of Registrar from Rs.2000/- to 25000/- for smooth functioning of the Office of CCIM. 2. As sanction of Rs. 2,000/- for the Registrar was sanction by Government of India in 1996. Now due to escalation Rs. 2,000/- has become equivalent to approximate Rs. 25,000/-.
Executive Committee agreed the same and decided to send the proposal to Government of India for sanction.
Agenda Item No.13 Reporting of Action taken by Government of India – regarding.
i) To regularize the admission of Rishikul Ayurved Medical College, Hardwar.
Government of India vide letter No.R.17011/193/2009-EP dated 10.2.2011 has regularized the admission of Rishikul Ayurved Medical College, Haridwar admitted for the session 2008-09.
ii) Withdrawal of letter to transfer the students from Shekhawati Ayurved Medical College, Pilani.
In pursuance of decision of Hon’ble High Court of Rajasthan, Jaipur/Jodhpur Government of India vide letter No.R.12011/0802008-EP dated 14.2.2011 has withdrew the letter regarding transfer of the admitted students to other permitted colleges of the State of Shekhawati Ayurved Medical College, Pilani.
iii) Gujarati Devi Ayurved College, Gwalior
Government of India vide letter No.R.12011/47/2006-EP dated 6.4.2011 in pursuance of the Order of Hon’ble High of Madhya Pradesh Bench at Gwalior has withdrew the para 01 of their previous letter dated 5.1.2011 in respect of transfer of students.
iv) Admissions made by Bapuji Ayurved Medical College, Shimoga for the year 2008-09.
Government of India, Department of AYUSH, New Delhi informed vide letter No.R.17011/50/2009-EP dated 14.7.2010 has regularized the admission made by
32 163ec
Bapuji Ayurved Medical College, Shimoga for the session 2008-09 vide letter No. R.17011/50/2009-EP dated 4.2.2011.
v) Reject the scheme of Amjadia Educational and Welfare Trust, Ahmednagar Bara Chikia East Champaran.
Government of India, Department of AYUSH vide letter No. R.12012/01/2010-EP dated 4.2.2010 has rejected the scheme of Amjadia Educational and Welfare Trust, Ahmednagar Bara Chikia East Champaran to start new Unani college vide letter No.R.12011/01/2010-EP dated 4.2.2011.
vi) Reject the scheme of Warsi Welfare and Education ORB’s Ashmhl, Sambhal Moradabad.
Government of India, Department of AYUSH vide letter No. R.12012/03/2010-EP dated 3.2.2011 has rejected the scheme of Warsi Welfare and Education ORB’s Ashmhl, Sambhal, Moradabad to start new Ayurved college.
vii) Reject the scheme of Prabhav Hem Kamdhanu Giri Vihar Trust’s Ayurved College, Vaghadhera.
Government of India, Department of AYUSH informed vide letter No. R.12011/15/2010-EP dated 4.2.2011 has rejected the scheme of Prabhav Hem Kamdhanu Giri Vihar Trust’s Ayurved College, Vaghadhera.
viii) Application of Shubhdeep Ayurved Medical College, Indore.
Government of India, Department of AYUSH, New Delhi vide R.14011/26/2010-EP dated 1.2.2011 has returned the application of Shubhdeep Ayurved Medical College, Indore for starting PG course in (i) Kayachikitsa (ii) Samhita & Siddhant (iii) Rasashastra (iv) Rachna Sharir with 05 seats in each subject.
ix) Vagdevi Ayurved Medical College Bollikunta WARANGAL
Government of India vide letter No.R.12011/23/2005-EP dated 1.2.2011 has not permitted for the year 2010-11.
x) To regularize the admission of Ayurved & Unani Tibbia College, Delhi
Government of India vide letter No.R.17011/17/2009-EP dated 9.3.2011 has regularized the admission of 40 students made by Ayurveda & Unani Tibbia College, Delhi in BUMS Course for the session 2008-09
33 163ec
xi) To regularize the admission of Ayurved & Unani Tibbia College, Delhi
Government of India vide letter No.R.17011/17/2009-EP dated 9.3.2011 has regularized the admission of 40 students made by Ayurveda & Unani Tibbia College, Delhi in BAMS Course for the session 2008-09
xii) To regularize the BVVS Ayurved Medical College, Bagalkot.
Government of India vide letter No.R.17011/193/2009-EP dated 10.2.2011 has regularized of BVVS Ayurved Medical College, Bagalkot to the students admitted for the session 2008-09 vide.
xiii) Regarding granting permission to Yashwant Ayurved Medical College, Kodoli
Government of India, Department of AYUSH vide letter No. R.13011/13/2010-EP dated 29.4.2011 did not agree to issue the LOI for proposed courses.
Rognidan 2-4 Shalakya 2-6 Agadtantra & Vidhi Vaidyak 2-6
xiv) Regarding granting permission to Chhatrapati Sahuji Ayurved Medical College, Aurangabad.
Government of India, Department of AYUSH vide letter No. R.14011/28/2010-EP dated 29.4.2011 has issued the LOI for sarting PG courses in i) Prasuti & Striroga 06 ii) Kaumarbhrittya 06 iii) Shalya 06
xv) Withdrawal of letter to transfer the students from SSUD Ayurved Medical College, Washim.
In pursuance of decision of Hon’ble High Court of Maharashtra, Bench at Nagpur under Writ Petition No.4918/2010 Government of India vide letter No.R.12011/10/2007-EP dated 09.5.2011 has withdrew the letter regarding transfer of the admitted students to other permitted colleges of the State.
34 163ec
xvi) Muniyal Institute of Ayurveda Medical Sciences, Manipal.
Government of India vide letter No.R.14011/28/2009-EP dated 12.5.2011 has granted the permission to Muniyal Institute of Ayurveda Medical Sciences, Manipal for conducting PG Course as under:-
1. Bhaishajya Kalpana 05 2. Dravyaguna 05 3. Kayachikitsa 05 4. Panchkarma 05 5. Shalya 05
Executive committee noted all above.
Agenda Item No.14 Remuneration to the visitors to visit Ayurveda, Unani & Siddha Colleges.
It was noted that as per decision of the Executive Committee in its meeting held on 31.1.2011 the visitation of Ayurveda, Unani and Siddha Colleges is being conducted by the teachers of Government Ayurved, Unani and Siddha Colleges considering as Expert (fulfilling the criteria of qualification and experience as per concerned Regulations). The teachers of Government Ayurveda, Unani and Siddha colleges while visiting the office to submit the visitation report have quarry in respect of remuneration to be paid to the visitors for visitation.
In this regard it was noted that as Executive Committee in its meeting held on 17- 18 th May, 2010 decided to pay the remuneration of Rs.2000/- to the members for the visitation purpose and it was decided to obtain the sanction of Government of India as required under Section 12 (d) of IMCC Act, 1970. The Government of India has been requested to convey the sanction vide letter No.8-4/2007-Act dated 16.6.2010 and subsequent reminder of even number dated 18.1.2011.
It was further noted that Government of India while granting the sanction vide letter No.V.12015/1/2008-Ay.Desk dated 19.7.2010 of remuneration to the members of the CCIM or outside experts @ Rs.1,500/- for full day and Rs. 750/- for half day alongwith the room rent (i.e.Rs.1500/- per day) and taxi charges limiting the amount (actual with ceiling of Rs.600/- per day). The CCIM is also paying the remuneration as per above rate to the teachers of Ayurveda, Unani & Siddha Colleges while being invited as Expert in CCIM.
In view of the above, President, CCIM decided that visitors be treated as outside expert, therefore, it was decided to pay Rs.1500/- per day for two days (not for journey period) as visitation of Ayurveda, Unani & Siddha colleges have been proposed for two days to the visitors (teachers/Expert) who visited (Ayurveda, Unani & Siddha colleges) for the year 2011-12.
35 163ec
Executive Committee ratified the same. Agenda Item No.15 Ratification of the Action taken by the President, CCIM
1. DY Patil Ayurved Medical College, Navi Mumbai
It was noted that as per decision of the Executive Committee in its meeting held on 24.11.2010 the recommendations for issuing the letter of Intent in following subject for starting PG Course were sent to the Government of India. The Government of India has issued the Letter of Intent vide letter No.R.14011/32/2010-EP dated 21 st January, 2011 as under:-
1. Sharir Rachna 03 2. Sharir Kriya 03 3. Samhita 03 4. Swasthavritta 03 5. Rognidan 03 6. Rasashastra 03 7. Shalya 03
It was also asked to the college to submit the compliance of shortcomings mentioned in under reference letter. The CCIM was asked to verify the compliance and furnish the recommendation to Government of India for issuing the Letter of Permission. As college was proposed for visitation, therefore, it was considered that recommendation for issuing the LOP may be made to the Government of India on the basis of latest visitation report.
There was two or three calls from the Department of AYUSH asking to furnish the recommendations on the pending proposals under Section 13 A lying with the CCIM.
After assessment of the visitation report, it was recommended to the Government of India for issuing LOP as per LOI issued by the Government of India.
Executive committee ratified the same.
2. MAM Ayurved College, Hadapsar
It was noted that as per decision of the Executive Committee in its meeting held on 24.11.2010 the recommendations for increasing intake capacity in following subjects from 03 to 06 were sent to the Government of India as per previous visitation report there were only 200 beds. The Government of India gave an opportunity of hearing to the college. The college at the time of hearing submitted a CD of hospital in favour of verification of the 250 beds in the hospital. After examination of the CD it was observed that there were 250 beds. However, as visitation for the year 2011-12 was already been conducted, therefore, it was decided that as per latest visitation report the bed strength may be taken into
36 163ec consideration. On the basis of the latest visitation report, it was observed that college is possessing 225 beded hospital. Moreover, Government of India had also pointed out that State Government and concerned University has been issued NOC and consent respectively for 02 seats in Rasashastra.
There was two or three calls from the Department of AYUSH asking to furnish the recommendations on the pending proposals under Section 13 A lying with the CCIM.
In view of the above, as per instructions of President, CCIM it has been informed that CCIM has made the following recommendations on the basis of availability of teaching staff in the department.
LOP may be recommended as follows to increase PG in
Kriya Sharir 3-6 Rachna Sharir 3-6 Rasashastra 3-6 Stri & Prasuti 3-6 Kayachikitsa 3-6 Shalya 3-6
Executive committee ratified the same.
3. Shri Bhanwar Lal Dugar Ayurved College, Sardarshar, Rajasthan
It was noted that college was visited on 18-19.3.2010 for the year 2010-11. After assessment of the teaching and practical training and observing the bed occupancy 34.13% against the 40%, the college was not recommended to Government of India for granting the permission for the session 2010-11. However, after hearing Government of India visited the college to verify the facts submitted by the college at the time of hearing. However, after assessment of bed occupancy from March, 2010 to 29 th September, 2010 observed the bed occupancy more than 40%. Therefore, Government of India granted the permission for the session 2010-11. Considering the lack of bed occupancy on the basis of date from 1.1.2009 to 31.12.2009, the proposal of the college was not considered by CCIM for increasing intake capacity from 40 to 50. But Government of India asked the comments of the CCIM by stating that standards for 40 and 50 seats are same while Government of India has permitted the college for the session 2010-11 considering the bed occupancy more than 40% after the visitation.
There was two or three calls from the Department of AYUSH asking to furnish the recommendations on the pending proposals under Section 13 A lying with the CCIM.
37 163ec
However, President, CCIM as per latest assessment agreed to send the recommendation to Government of India for increasing intake capacity from 40 to 50.
Executive committee ratified the same.
Addl. Agenda item No.1. Enhancement of consolidated salary of Ayurveda, Unani & Siddha Experts
It was noted that a representation of Ayurveda, Unani and Siddha Experts working in the Council to enhance their consolidated salary by Rs.10,000/- per month has been received by stating that they are working all types of technical work including assessment of visitation report, duplicity of teachers, fake experience and other technical work of respective systems.
Executive Committee agreed to enhance consolidated salary from Rs.30,000/- to Rs.40,000/- engaged for first six month and Rs.35,000/- to Rs.45,000/- who have completed six months in the Council. Further, it was decided that Experts should be appointed at least on consolidated salary of Rs.35,000/- initially in the Council.
Addl. Agenda item No.2. Changes of the clarification in respect of nomenclature of the subject of Ayurveda.
It was noted that due to changes of the nomenclature of PG Degree/subject time to time reads as under holder of PG degree are facing the difficulty to get the service.
Rogavigyana Rognidan & Vikriti Vigyan Dravyaguna Dravyaguna Vigyan Kriya Sharir Kriya Sharir Vigyan Maulik Siddhant Samhita Siddhant, Samhita Avum Siddhant, Samhita Bhaishajya Kalpana Bhaishajya Kalpana Vigyan
Executive Committee considered the matter and agreed to send the clarification to all concerned i.e. State Government and University for the same.
38 163ec
Addl. Agenda item No.3. Letter received from Dr. D Ramanathan, Member, EC.
Dr. D Ramanathan, Member, EC at the time of discussion submitted a letter reads as under the following contents
“The Government order (issued on 21.2.2011) permits the Parambarya Vaidyas (Traditional Practitioners) of Malabar region in Kerala to practice Ayurveda. They do not have any qualifications, so this is illegal and against the IMCC Act, 1970. Hence, CCIM had approached the Kerala High Court through a Contempt Petition. After notice, the case is now posted for final hearing on 08.6.2011.
Since the matter is very serious and has potential to affect the standing of the CCIM in the eyes of common people, and also since this can have disastrous consequences for public health in Kerala, it is necessary that CCIM takes this issue very seriously and defend the case vigorously.
Therefore, it was proposed that CCIM may engage a Senior Advocate to defend the interests of CCIM in the Kerala High Court on 08.6.2011. the fees etc. of the Senior Advocate is likely to be about Rs.60,000/- for the hearing which may kindly be sanctioned.”
Executive Committee agreed to appoint the Senior Advocate to defend the case in the High Court of Kerala.
Addl. Agenda item No.4. Visitation report of Dhanwantri Ayurved College at Koydam, Distt. Kheda, Gujarat - regarding
It was noted that Dhanwantri Ayurved College at Koydam, Distt. Kheda, Gujarat has been visited on 3 rd & 4 th May, 2011 in compliance of order dated 28.10.2010 of Hon’ble High Court of Gujrat at Ahmedabad under Writ Petition No.14227/2010 to assess the available facilities of teaching and practical training as well as compliance of shortcomings informed by Government of India while not granting the permission and withdrawing the LOI issued earlier.
Executive Committee after going through the Visitation Report, it was decided not to recommend to Government of India for issuing LOP.
As all Visitation reports of Ayurveda and Unani could not be considered, therefore, it was decided to adjourned the meeting for 26 th May, 2011.
Meeting adjourned by 26.5.2011 with a vote of thanks to the chair.
39 163ec
Further adjourned meeting continued on 26 th May, 2011 and following were present:-
PRESENT
1. Vaidya Raghunandan Sharma, President, CCIM Chairman 2. Prof. Hakim Syed Khaleefathullah, Vice-President (Unani) Member 3. Dr. V Stanley Jones, Vice-President (Siddha) Member 4. Dr. PK Jain, Member 5. Vaidya Ved Prakash Tyagi Member 6. Dr. Niranjan Singh Tyagi Member 7. Dr. D Ramanathan Iyer Member 8. Dr. Rashidullah Khan Member 9. Dr. V Arunachalam Member 10. Dr. Khalid Siddiqui Member Dr. PR Sharma Secretary, CCIM
Dr. Jayaprakash Narayan, Vice-President (Ayurved) could not attend the meeting.
At the outset of the meeting, Vice-President (Unani) raised the issue regarding not to follow the letter of Government of India dated 18.3.2011 by Executive Committee in word and spirit while considering the visitation report of Unani colleges and taking the decision.
Further, he stated that the assessment made by Executive Committee in respect of bed occupancy on the basis of existing number of beds is not in accordance to the instructions of Government of India issued vide letter dated 18.3.2011. Hence, Unani Members Prof. Syed Khaleefathullah, Vice-President (Unani), Dr. Khalid Siddiqui, Dr. Rashidullah Khan submitted their note of dissent on the procedure of the assessment in respect of bed strength and calculation of bed occupancy on existing bed strength. They stressed for their previous stand taken in the previous meeting i.e. 16-17.5.2011.
Further Prof. Syed Khaleefathullah, Vice-President (Unani) placed a letter No.Z.28015/15/2011-EP-IM-2 dated 19.5.2011 of Department of AYUSH, New Delhi. The content of letter reads as under:-
“it may be noted that the Department’s letter dated 22.12.2009 was to communicate decisions taken by the Central Government to incorporate in the draft Regulations of the Central Council of Indian medicine on Minimum Standard Requirements for Ayurveda, Siddha and Unani colleges and attached hospitals, whereas, the Department’s letter dated 18.3.2011 is for Minimum Standards Norms for conditional permission to ASU colleges for the academic session 2011-12. Hence, there is no question of mention of continuation of previous letter dated 22.12.2009 in the recent communication dated 18.3.2011.”
Vice-President (Unani) also pointed out that assessment of teaching staff in respect of Ayurveda & Siddha colleges has been made on the basis of the intake capacity
40 163ec
50, 60, 80 and 100 as per Minimum Standards & Requirements of Ayurveda & Siddha Colleges & Hospital laid down by CCIM instead of 50, 75 and 100 as was stipulated by Government of India as per draft CCIM norms, therefore, the same may be adopted in the Ayurveda & Siddha also.
Executive Committee noted the same.
Further it was brought to the notice of the Executive Committee that due to over sight of bed occupancy of Government Siddha Medical College, Pallayamkottai was recommended to Government of India for granting permission for the session 2011- 12, therefore, Executive Committee reviewed the recommendations and decided to recommend to Government of India for not granting the permission for the said college for the session 2011-12.
Meanwhile, it was observed that AMO/MO have been deputed by State Government in Ayurveda Colleges to fulfill the required number of teaching staff against Lecturer. Executive Committee decided that AMO/MO possessing the PG qualification in concerned subject attaining the age of 40 years at the time of deputation against the post of Lecturer be treated as eligible teacher in respect of Ayurved colleges
For Unani Colleges deputed after 12.5.2010 against the post of Lecturer provided that possessing PG AMO/MO in concerned subject and attaining the age of 40 years at the time of deputation be taken into consideration as eligible teacher. The similar consideration shall be applicable for Medical Officer/AMO deputed prior to 12.5.2010 against the post of Lecturer possessing UG qualification and at the time of deputation attaining the age upto 40 years may be taken into consideration as eligible teacher for the assessment of teaching staff.
It was also decided that all cases considered in previous meeting and to be considered today should be reviewed and latest assessment should be sent to Government of India accordingly.
In view of the decision taken earlier as well as decision taken in respect of MO/AMO, the visitation reports of remaining colleges of Unani alongwith the assessment sheet and recommendation of the Screening Committee held on 24-25.5.2011 as well as documents submitted by the college were considered by the Executive decided as under:-
Unani
S. College Name Recommendations No 1. Govt. Nizamia Tibbia College, Recommended for UG not 75 only Hyderabad (AP) Not for PG 2. National Institute of Unani Medicine, Not recommended Bangalore
41 163ec
3. Zulfequar Haider Unani Medical Not recommended College & Hospital, (Siwan) 4. Salfia Unani Medical College & Recommended Hospital, Darbhanga 5. Mohsine Millat Unani Tibb education Recommended Society Unani Medical College, Raipur Chhattisgarh 6. Nizamia Unani Medical College, Not recommended Gaya 7. Institute of Asian Medical Science, Recommended, it was decided that Zakoora (Srinagar) recommendation be sent to the Govt. of India and complaint may be verified later on. 8. Kashmir Tibbia College Hospital & Recommended, it was decided that Research Centre, (Srinagar) recommendation be sent to the Govt. of India and complaint may be verified later on. 9. Govt. Tibbia College, Patna (Bihar) Not recommended 10. Al Farooque Unani Tibbia College, Not Recommended (Indore) 11. Hakim Abdul Hamid Unani Medical Recommended College, Dewas (M.P) 12. HSZH Govt. Unani Medical College, Not recommended (Bhopal) 13. ZVM Unani Medical College & Recommended UG 50 only & PG in 3 Hospital, subject i.e.Ilmul Jarahat, Moalajat & Pune (Maharashtra) Tahafuzi wa Samaji Tib 14. Ahmed Gharib Unani Medical College Not recommended & Hospital, Akkalkuwa, (Nandurbar) 15. Govt. Unani Medical College, Not recommended (Chennai) 16. Rajasthan Unani Medical College & Recommended Hospital, Jaipur (Raj.) The Council will conduct enquiry later 17. Jamia Tibbia Deoband, Recommended for UG & PG Saharanpur(UP) 18. Deoband Unani Medical College & Recommended Hospital (Saharanpur) 19. State Takmil-ul-Tib-College & Recommended (after taking eligibility Hospital, Lucknow (UP) of MO/AMO into consideration as per decision of EC) 20. Allama Iqbal Unani Medical College & Recommended Hospital, (Muzaffarnagar) 21. Eram Unani Medical College & Recommended for UG 50 only. Hospital, (Lucknow) 22. Abdul Ali Tibbia College & Hospital, Not recommended (Lucknow)
42 163ec
It is submitted that in view of the decision regarding consideration of the MO/AMO as eligible teacher the matter was examined and it was observed that 8 MO/AMO of State Unani Medical College, Allahabad and 5 MO/AMO of Govt. Unani Medical College, Bangalore have become eligible but recommendation in view of the policy dated 18.03.2010 informed by the Govt. of India remains unchanged.
Ayurveda
In view of the decision taken earlier as well as decision taken in respect of MO/AMO, the visitation reports of remaining colleges alongwith the assessment sheet and recommendation of the Screening Committee as well as documents submitted by the college were considered by the Executive Committee and decided as under:-
S. College Name Recommendations No 1. Dr. BRKR Ayurved Medical Not Recommended for UG & PG College, Hyderabad 2. Dr. NR Shastry Government Not Recommended for UG & PG Ayurved College, Vijayawada 3. Anantha Laxmi Government Not Recommended Ayurved College, Warangal 4. MNR Ayurved Medical College, Not Recommended Medak 5. Government Ayurved College PG Recommended UG for 40 seats and Training & Research Institute, PG in Patna Dravyaguna 04 Rasashastra 04 6. Rajkiya Ayodhya Shivkumari Not Recommended Ayurved mahavidyalaya, Begusarai 7. Nitishwar Ayurved College & Afresh re-visitation Hospital, Muzzafarpur 8. Shri Narayan Prasad Awasthy Recommended UG for 55 seats and Prasad Government Ayurved PG in College, Raipur Samhita 03 Rasashastra 02 Kayachikitsa 05 Shalya 02 But not for PG in Rachna Sharir. 9. Ayurved & Unani Tibbia College, Not Recommended for UG & PG New Delhi both.
43 163ec
10. Chaudhary Brahma Prakash Recommended UG for 80 seats Ayurved Charak Sansthan, Najafgarh, New Delhi 11. Government Akhandanand Recommended for UG for 50 seats Ayurved Mahavidyalalya, and PG in Ahmedabad Kayachikitsa 06 But not recommended PG in Panchkarma. 12. Government Ayurved Not Recommended Mahavidyalaya, Baroda 13. Seth JP Government Ayurved Not Recommended College, Bhavnagar, Gujarat 14. Shri Gulabkunverba Ayurved Not Recommended Mahavidyalaya, Jamnagar (Gujarat) 15. Institute of PG Training & Recommended PG in Research, Gujrat Ayurved Maulik Siddhant 06 University, Jamnagar Dravyaguna 06 Kayachikitsa 04 Panchkarma 06 Rasashastra 03 Prasuti & Striroga 06 Shalakya 05 Bhaishajya Kalpana 02 But not recommended PG for Roga Nidana Kaumarbhrittya and Shalya . 16. Govindbhai Jorabhai Patil Ayurved Not Recommended Medical College, Anand 17. Gaur Brahmin Ayurved College & Not Recommended Hospital, Rohtak 18. Ayujyoti Ayurved Medical College, Recommended UG for 50 seats. Sirsa 19. Government Ayurved College, Not recommended Kurukshetra 20. Chaudhary Devilal College of Recommended UG for 50 seats. Ayurveda, Jagadhari 21. Rajiv Gandhi Government Recommended UG for 50 seats and Ayurved College, Paprola PG in Kayachikitsa 06 Shalya 04 Shalakya 04 Samhita 04
44 163ec
Roganidan 01 Swasthavritta 03 Balaroga 02 Panchkarma 02 But not recommended for PG in Dravyaguna, Rasashastra and Prasuti & Striroga.
22. Government Ayurved College, Recommended UG for 50 seats and Bangalore PG in Dravyaguna 07 Shalya 07 Shalakya 07 Panchkarma 07 But not recommended PG in Rasashastra and Roganidana.
23. ALN Rao Memorial Ayurved Recommended UG for 60 seats and Mahavidyalaya, Koppa PG in Dravyaguna 06 Kayachikitsa 05 Bhaishajya Kalpana 05 24. KPSVS Ayurved Medical College, Re-visitation to clarify the Manvi, Raichur contradiction of total number of patient admitted and total number of bed days occupied of reporting period. 25. Ashwini Educational Association’s Recommended UG for 50 seats and Ayurved College, Davangere PG in Kayachikitsa 02 Shalya 01 26. Indian Institute of Ayurvedic Not Recommended on the basis of Medicine & Research, Bangalore the reporting of visitors (not correct) as well as other shortcomings pointed out in visitation report. 27. Muniyal Institute of Ayurvedic Not recommended Sciences, Manipal 28. Dhanwanty Ayurved College, Recommended UG for 40 seats Siddhapur 29. Karnataka Ayurved Medical Not Recommended College, Mangalore 30. Sri Sri College of Ayurvedic Not Recommended Sciences, Bangalore
45 163ec
31. Shree Narayan Institute of Recommended UG for 50 seats. Ayurvedic Studies & Research, Puthur 32. Government Ayurved College, Tripunitura 33. Government Ayurved College, Recommended UG for 50 seats and Thiruvananthapuram PG in Ayurved Siddhant 06 Dravyaguna 06 Prasuti & Striroga 06 Shalya 03 Shalakya 03 Rasashastra 01 Bhaishajya Kalpana 01 Kayachikitsa 03 Kaumar Bhrittya 01 Panchkarma 03 Swasthavritta 03 Agadtantra 01 34. Govt. Ayurved College, Kannur, Recommended UG for 40 seats and Kerala PG in Kriya Shasrir 01 Roganidana 05 35. College of Ayurved Medical Not Recommended College, Gwalior 36. Pt. Shivshaktilal Sharma Ayurved Recommended UG for 50 seats and Medical College, Ratlam PG in Ayurved Sidhant 04 Kayachikitsa 06 Panchkarma 05 37. Subhdeep Ayurved Medical Recommended UG for 50 seats. College, Indore
38. Veena Vadini Ayurved Medical Recommended UG for 50 seats. College, Bhopal 39. Govt. Dhanwantary Ayurved Not Recommended for UG & PG Medical College, Ujjain 40. Govt. Ayurved College, Burhanpur Not Recommended 41. Govt. Ashtang Ayurved Medical Not Recommended College, Indore 42. Govt. Ayurved College, Rewa Not Recommended for UG & PG both.
46 163ec
43. Pt. Khushilal Sharma Govt. Recommended UG for 50 seats. Ayurved College, Bhopal 44. RA Podar Ayurved College, Worli, Recommended UG for 50 seats and Mumbai PG in Samhita 03 Dravyaguna 02 Swasthavritta 01 Prasuti & Striroga 05 Shalakya 01 Sharir Kriya 01 Rasashastra 02 Agadtantra 01 Shalya 04 Panchkarma 02 But not recommended PG for Rachna Sharir, Roganidana and Kayachikitsa. 45. Kisan Dnyanoday Mandal Gudhe’s Recommended UG for 40 seats Ayurved College , Jalgaon 46. DMM Ayurved mahavidyalaya, Recommended UG for 50 seats but Yeotmal not recommended PG in Kayachikitsa 47. Government Ayurved Medical Recommended UG for 50 seats and College, Nagpur PG in Rachna Sharir 04 Kriya Sharir 04 Swasthavritta 01 Shalya (Samanya) 01 Rog Nidan 01 Shalakya 01 Agadtantra 01 But not recommended PG in Rasashastra & Kayachikitsa.
48. Govt. Ayurved College, Recommended UG for 50 seats but Osmanabad not recommended for PG.
49. Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Sion, Recommended UG for 50 seats Mumbai and PG in Samhita 02 Kayachikitsa 02 But not recommended PG in Dravyaguna
47 163ec
50. Govt. Ayurved College, Nanded As data is not clear therefore, it was decided that college should be called to appear in the office with original records of OPD and IPD for verification 51. Gopabandhu Ayurved Not Recommended for UG & PG Mahavidyalaya, Puri both. 52. Kaviraj Anantha Tripahti Sharma Not Recommended Ayurved College, Ganjam 53. Govt. Ayurved College, Bolangir Not Recommended 54. Rajiv Gandhi Ayurved College, Recommended UG for 50 seats Pudduchery 55. Govt. Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Not Recommended for UG & PG Patiala both. 56. Smt. Urmila Devi Ayurvedic Recommended UG 50 seats. College & Hospital, Hoshiarpur 57. National Institute of Ayurveda, Recommended UG for 80 seats and Jaipur PG in Ayurved Samhita 08 Kriya Sharir 08 Rasashastra 09 Kaumbarbhritya 02 Rachna Sharir 02 Dravyaguna 02 Roganidana 08 Kaya Chikitsa 09 But not recommended PG in Swasthavritta, Agadtantra, Prasuti & Striroga, Shalya, Shalakya and Panchkarma. 58. MMM Govt. Ayurved Not Recommended for UG & PG Mahavidyalaya, Udaipur both. 59. College of Ayurved, Rajasthan, Recommended UG for 50 seats. Rajasthan University, Jodhpur 60. Govt. Ayurved Medical College, Not Recommended Nagercoil 61. State Ayurved Medical College, Not Recommended for UG & PG Lucknow both. 62. Rajkiya Lalit Hari Ayurved Not Recommended for UG & PG College, Pilibhit both. 63. Bundelkhand Govt. Ayurved Not Recommneded College, Jhansi
48 163ec
64. Sri Sai Ayurved Medical College, Not Recommended on the basis of Aligarh observations of the visitors (not correct) as well as shortcomings mentioned in the visitation report. 65. Vaidya Yagya Dutt Sharma Recommended UG for 75 seats and Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Khurja PG in Kriyasharir 05 Shalya 05 66. Shri SG Minority Ayurved College, Recommended UG for 50 seats and Gazipur PG in Roganidhana 03 Prasuti & Striroga 01 67. SRM Government Ayurved Not Recommended College, Bareilly 68. Government Ayurved College & Not Recommended Hospital, Attara, Banda 69. Swami Kalyandev Govt. Ayurved Not Recommended College, Muzaffarnagar 70. Faculty of Ayurved Institute of Not Recommended for UG & PG Meical Sciences, BHU, Varanasi both. 71. Govt. Ayurved College, Varanasi Not Recommended 72. JB Roy State Ayurved College, Not Recommended Calcutta 73. Institute of PG Ayurved Education Not Recommended & Research, Calcutta
The changed position of Ayurved Colleges in respect of decision regarding consideration of the MO/AMO as per decision of the Executive Committee will be placed before the next Executive Committee.
List of colleges not visited for the year 2011-12:-
It was noted that following colleges have not been visited on the reason as mentioned against them-
S. College Name Reason for not visitation No 1. Dhanwantri Ayurved College, Chhata Transfer of the Students 2. Om Ayurved College, Betul Transfer of the Students 3. BNM Ayurved College, Bijapur Transfer of the students. 4. SSUD Ayurved College, Washim Transfer of the Students 5. Acharya Gyan Ayurved College, Indore Hon’ble Court has authorized
49 163ec
to Government of India to conduct the visitation for the year 2011-12 and take the decision accordingly. 6. Jammu Institute of Ayurved & Research Court Case Centre, Jammu Tawi 7. Mahesh Ayurved College, Asthi Beed College is closed. 8. Kalidas Ayurved College, Badami Asked the time to fulfill the shortcomings. However, decision of the CCIM is under Agenda Item No. 7 9. Bhanwar Lal Nehata Ayurved College, Not consented for visitation. Mandsaur However decision is under Agenda Item No. 9.
Addl. Agenda item No.6. Representation of Consultant, RTI and Legal Consultant.
It was noted that a representation has been submitted by Shri Ram Swaroop Singh, Consultant, RTI and Shri A Subudhi, Legal Consultant to enhance the 33% of consolidated salary i.e. approximate 6,600/- per month proportionately as consolidated salary of retired Assistants engaged in the Council has been increased from Rs.15,000/- to Rs.20,000/- after completion of six months.
In this regard, it was noted that both Consultants were engaged on the consolidated salary of R s.20,000/- per month and have successfully completed six months in the CCIM.
Executive Committee agreed to enhanced 25% the consolidated salary i.e. Rs.20,000/- to 25,000/-.
Addl. Agenda item No. 7 Representation of Sri Kalidas Ayurved Medical College, Badami
It was noted that Sri Kalidas Ayurved College, Badami was proposed for visitation report for furnishing the recommendation to the Govt. of India for the year 2011-12. In response of the same the college vide letter No. SKAMCB/1537/2011 dated 23.03.2011 informed that under Secretary Govt. of India Ministry of Health and Family Welfare of Dept. of AYUSH has pleased to order that the required teaching staff and is 35 and above including the Professor and Reader. But the present teaching staff is only 24 and appointment is to be made for the rest of the teaching staff and the staff for the other two Departments including Rachana Sharir, and Kaumarbhritya.
50 163ec
We have sought an opportunity and time for obeying the said order referred above.
The college and the management are taking steps to follow-up and for appointment of the teaching staff for the said Departments and other subjects.
It was requested to grant time for follow-up and for visitation of the college by the visitors CCIM.
In view of the above, college has not been visited so far.
Executive Committee noted the same and decided to recommend for not granting the permission for the session 2011-12 be forwarded to Government of India. It was also decided that State Government, Department and University should be approached to know the status of the college in respect of admission etc.
Addl.Agenda Item. No. 8 Verification reports
It was noted that as per decision of Executive Committee held on 16-17.05.2011, the following colleges were proposed for visitation to clarify during the contradiction of total number of patient admitted and total number of bed days occupied submitted reporting period as mentioned in the visitation report conducted by the visitors recently. The colleges have been re-visited for the same as per details given below:-
S.No. Name of the College Name of the visitors Date of visitation 1. SVM Ayurved College, 1. Dr. P.K. Jain 21.05.2011 Ilkal 2. Dr. N.S. Tyagi 2. Bapuji Ayurved College, 1. Dr. P.K. Jain 23.05.2011 Challakere 2. Dr. N.S. Tyagi 3. Dhanwantary Ayurved 1. Dr. V.P. Tyagi 24.05.2011 College, Udgir 2. Dr. Manoj Dubey
Visitors have reported as under:-
1. SVM Ayurved College, Ilkal a. Total No. of patient attended OPD during reporting period = 71609 b. Total No. of patient admitted during reporting period =10340 c. Total No. of Bed occupied, during reporting period= 55138 In view of the above bed occupancy comes = 75.53%
51 163ec
Executive Committee decided to recommend to Government of India for granting the permission for the session 2011-12.
2. Bapuji Ayurved College, Challakere a. Total No. of patient attended OPD during reporting period = 67842 b. Total No. of patient admitted during reporting period =4479 c. Total No. of Bed occupied, during reporting period= 23571
In view of the above bed occupancy comes = 60.92%
Executive Committee decided to recommend to Government of India for granting the permission for the session 2011-12.
3. Dhanwantary Ayurved College, Udgir After going through the records, following observations have been made by visitors. 1. There is no similarity maintained in the data submitted by the college at the time of recent visitation and presented during the re- visitation conducted on 24.5.2011 was maintained. 2. OPD register was maintained day to day basis not year-wise(by mentioning the Central Register number year-wise). CR number was not maintained. 3. The Principal re-confirmed number of admitted patient submitted at the time of previous visitation i.e. 21948. 4. The Principal re-confirmed the total number of bed days occupied at the time of previous visitation i.e. 16355.
In view of the above, the data submitted and presented by the college at the time of previous visitation and on 24.5.2011 (re-visit) seems to be at variance.
Executive Committee observed that data is not clear therefore, it was decided that college should be called to appear in the office with original records of OPD and IPD for verification.
Agenda Item. No. 9 Visitation of Shri Bhanwarlal Nahata Ayurved College, Mandsaur
It was noted that Shri Bhanwarlal Nehata Ayurved College, Mandsaur was proposed for visitation report for furnishing the recommendation to the Govt. of India for the year 2011-12. In response of the same visitors have reported for non-cooperation of the Society with the views of the Chairman of the Society reads as under:-
52 163ec
1. CCIM conducted 5 visits so far and given away late permission for admitting the first year students to BAMS course. 2. The State Government did not permit to carry out admissions, and hence no students were admitted into the course. CCIM has not pointed out any shortcoming and granted permission to admit the batch. 3. Basing on this point, Chairman refused to co-operate with us for conduction of visitation procedures. As they did not allow and blindly rejected to initiate the enquiry. We have requested to submit the same in writing (ref. No-2). In spite of our repeated requests; the college authorities prevented us from conducting inspection of college as well as hospital building and other infrastructure facilities. They finally dropped us at the airport with a delay and we missed our return journey which was advanced to 28 th march instead of 30 th March. So we were forced to stay at hotel on 28 th and commenced our return journey on 29 th March.
Visitors have forwarded the representation of the college on the same issue. The content of the letter are as under:
“The inspection team consisting of Dr. Sarama Karra Nishteswar and Dr. Dei Laxmipriya have arrived our college – “Mandsaur Institute of Ayurveda Education and research, Mandsaur” today. We have not been informed of their visit by CCIM. We came to know only when the inspectors informed us of their visit to Mandsaur. We immediately enquired from you and informed that no students were admitted this year. It was confirmed verbally on phone that it might have been issued by mistake and necessary action would be taken. But still inspection Team has been sent to Mandsaur.
It may please be acknowledged that the letter of approval was received by us after the due date for admission. And since then there has been several communications made to CCIM and AYUSH to extend the time limit to admit students. Hon’ble High Court, Indore Branch (MP) has also instructed to CCIM/AYUSH to consider our appeal to extend the date of admission. The action on all those communications is still awaited.
The said inspection is to be carried out in the existing colleges for second year. Since we were not permitted to admit students inspection was not required for us. The relevant records were already submitted to CCIM and AYUSh based on which the approval was granted. It is thus requested that since we are not going into second year, due to delay in letter of Approval and there is no short comings cited to be complied with the current inspection should not be carried out.
53 163ec
It is further requested that we may be granted permission to admit students even at this stage. And the inspection of the college may be carried out after 2011-12 when the first year students advance into the second year.”
In this regard, it is also submitted that college has also filed a Court Case to treat the permission granted for the year 2010-11 to 2011-12 as admission could not taken place in previous year on account of delay of granting permission by Government of India.
Executive Committee noted the same and decided that recommendations for not granting permission for the session 2011- 12 be forwarded to the Government of India.
Meeting concluded with the vote of thanks to the Chair.
@^@ @^@^@
54 163ec