DOCSLIB.ORG

Malema Facing More Charges

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Malema Facing More Charges Legalbrief | your legal news hub Sunday 03 October 2021 Malema facing more charges ANC Youth League leader Julius Malema's shenanigans outside the court where he is defending a hate speech action - he has whipped up supporters, urging them to chant a variation of the lyrics of the 'shoot the boer' song that is central to the complaint brought by AfriForum - has landed him with another hate speech charge, writes Legalbrief. The civil rights group said it would lay additional hate speech charges against Malema and Youth league spokesperson Floyd Shivambu at the Equality Court today. 'AfriForum took this decision after Malema encouraged his followers ... to sing a song with the words 'shoot to kill' with him,' the civil rights organisation's deputy CEO Ernst Roets said, according to a report on the IoL site. 'Shivambu also sang the song dubula ibhunu (shoot the boer) outside the court this afternoon (yesterday) in front of a group of Youth League supporters, and encouraged them to sing along with him,' Roets added. 'If the Youth League really wanted to encourage peaceful co-existence in SA, they would rather have encouraged their followers to refrain from singing songs like that until the judge has given his verdict,' he said. Shivambu said no one sang any song containing the word 'boer' outside the court. 'They are being ridiculous. If they (AfriForum) want to waste their time and money, they are welcome to do that (lay charges),' he added. Full report on the IoL site See also a Beeld report Malema has likened the case to a test for the 'revolution', telling hundreds of supporters yesterday: 'There is no individual on trial... they are testing our revolution... they are testing methods we used to defeat them.' According to a report on the IoL site, he added: 'These judges are our judges, whether you like it or not, they work for the government... the government which is us, the ANC,' Malema said. He asked the group to maintain their 'militancy' and to not apologise for being radical. 'We are here to defend our history,' he said, adding that the 'incoming youth' should know about struggle songs. Malema said blacks were still engaged in a struggle for economic emancipation and wanted to 'own in this economy of SA'. Malema told the crowd that singing the song (shoot the boer) did not mean they were declaring war, or going to kill whites. 'Even in our singing, we must never be confused that we are declaring war... Even at the funeral of Chris Hani, even when we are angry... marching through the white suburbs... we have never killed any white person,' he said to cheers. And Winnie Madikizela got in on the act, too, promising supporters victory. 'You will have cause to celebrate, we promise you,' she said, according to a report ion The Mercury . Many supporters, including a young girl, carried posters depicting white children riding on the backs of black children. When the little girl was asked if she knew what this meant, her reply was 'boere is bad'. Full report on the IoL site Full report in The Mercury (subscription needed) Inside the court, it was a slow day - a day of academics and experts carefully explaining the different definitions of the word 'boer' and the meaning 'dubula Ibhunu' held for the Afrikaner community, says a report in The Mercury. The cornerstone of the Transvaal Agricultural Union's (TAU's) argument against Malema is that hate speech has nothing to do with the speaker's intent. 'It's about the reaction of the target group, the infringement of their rights. It doesn't matter what the ANC says it means by 'boer' if I understand that to be directed at me,' said Advocate Roelof du Plessis SC, interpreting the Equality Act. General Chris van Zyl, assistant CEO of TAU, described the problem of farm murders to the court as the context against which the song had to be examined. According to a report compiled by TAU, there were 2 633 farm attacks between 1990 and last year. Of these, 1 489 were murders. Equality law expert Professor Anton Kok ended the day's testimony with an examination into why the Equality Act was set up. 'We must talk to each other, sometimes very angrily, yes, but we must talk,' he said. 'That is the point of these courts: to develop a community where there is a place where people can voice their issues so that other hurtful action isn't taken. That is what Parliament meant with the Equality Act.' Full report in The Mercury (subscription needed) Afrikaners' national identity was also discussed, with an expert saying the concept of 'kill the boer' threatens Afrikaners' symbolic connection to SA. According to a Mail & Guardian Online report, Federasie Vir Afrikaanse Kultuur Vereeniging (the federation of Afrikaans culture organisations) (FAK) chair, Professor Danie Goosen, told the court that the words 'kill (shoot) the boer are experienced as an utterance which places the ideals of Afrikaners in a difficult space'. He added: 'The prevalent feeling (among the Afrikaans community) is very negative ... not a single Afrikaner supports it (the utterance) within the confines that I move. It is seen as a threat to their (Afrikaners) symbolic connection to SA. This 'kill the boer' concept creates a problem with the respect between the majority and minority,' he claimed. Goosen told the court the FAK consisted of 27 organisations and was the largest body for Afrikaners, representing about 200 000 people. The utterances 'shoot the boer' or 'kill the boer' came from deep-seated insensitivity, he said. He said the majority did not understand the problems of minority groups. Full Mail & Guardian Online report The issue has drawn a heated reaction from Freedom Front Plus leader Pieter Mulder, who has accused the ANC of double standards. A report in The Citizen quotes him as saying that while the ANC was fighting in court to retain the slogan 'shoot the boer', the party's secretary general Gwede Mantashe was objecting to a Constitutional Court decision 'that Robert McBride may indeed be called a murderer'. 'It is absolute double standards of the ANC to want to decide which history they want to keep and which history does not suit them,' he said. 'To try and justify in court 'shoot the boer' in the current times of farm murders and then to sing it in front of the court, reveals an insensitivity and an arrogance by the ANC that does not promote harmony and peace,' said Mulder. He said SA needed 'a Mandela atmosphere ... not a Malema atmosphere'. Full report in The Citizen .
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Political Parties in South African Law
    View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by South East Academic Libraries System (SEALS) POLITICAL PARTIES IN SOUTH AFRICAN LAW By Zaahira Tiry Submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Magister Legum (LLM) in the Faculty of Law at the Nelson Mandela Metropolitan University February 2012 Supervisor: Prof PHG Vrancken DECLARATION I, Zaahira Tiry with student number 202323951, hereby declare that the dissertation for Masters in Law to be awarded is my own work and that it has not previously been submitted for assessment or completion of any postgraduate qualification to another University or for another qualification. Zaahira Tiry CONTENTS SUMMARY ............................................................................................................................... i CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION 1.1 Introduction .......................................................................................................................... 1 1.2 Objectives ............................................................................................................................ 2 1.3 Research Questions .............................................................................................................. 2 1.4 Importance of the Study ....................................................................................................... 2 1.5 Methodology .......................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • An Investigation Into Whether the Weekly
    AN INVESTIGATION INTO WHETHER THE WEEKLY NATIONAL NEWSPAPERS REPORTED UNETHICALLY ON SOUTH AFRICA’S 2014 GENERAL ELECTIONS: A CRITICAL DISCOURSE ANALYSIS OF THE CITY PRESS, SUNDAY TIMES AND THE MAIL & GUARDIAN BY VILOSHNEE NAIDOO submitted in accordance with the requirements for the degree of MASTER OF COMMUNICATION SCIENCE in the subject Media Studies at the University of South Africa SUPERVISOR: Professor Stefan Sonderling November, 2018 DECLARATION Name: Viloshnee Naidoo Student number 36522147 Degree: Master of Communication Science Title of dissertation: An investigation into whether the weekly national newspapers reported unethically on South Africa’s 2014 General Elections: A Critical Discourse Analysis of the City Press, Sunday Times and the Mail & Guardian I declare that the above dissertation is my own work and that all the sources that I have used or quoted have been indicated and acknowledged by means of complete references. 10 November, 2018 ____________________ _________________ SIGNATURE DATE ii DEDICATION I dedicate this research project to my very special, only, late, big sister Suraya Naidoo who passed away from Lupus in March, 2012. You wanted me to achieve this ‘for the both of us’. Although you won’t see my completed work, I know how proud you would have been of me. This is for you! iii ABSTRACT This thesis investigates whether or not the press reported unethically on South Africa’s 2014 General Elections in the weekly national newspapers the City Press, Sunday Times and the Mail & Guardian. This study was undertaken on the basis of the ongoing contention between the press and the state which has resulted in polarised positions between both institutions amid accusations of press bias.
    [Show full text]
  • Out of the ANC – and Into a League of His Own
    NEWSBREAK 10 November 2011 MALEMA JUDGEMENT Out of the ANC – and into a League of his own ULIUS MALEMA’s five-year suspension from the Julius Malema’s suspension ruling African National Congress (ANC) and removal Jas president of its youth league is the defining moment & removal as ANC youth of the ANC’s 99th year. league president stops his anti- It not only brings Malema’s career to a grinding halt (and with it the challenge he has led against a second term Zuma campaign dead. Expect for Jacob Zuma); it also delivers massive collateral damage to those in the ANC who have encouraged and supported massive collateral damage to him in mounting his challenge. His spokesperson, Floyd Shivambu was suspended for his backers. Karima Brown three years. The decisions of the ANC National Disciplinary Com- assesses the implications mittee (NDC) terminate his role as kingmaker at the ANC’s centenary conference at Mangaung in December 2012. For 2 Southern Africa Report MALEMA JUDGMENT 10 November 2011 process to run its course. The cases of former ANC chief ANCYL - who's who in the dock whip Mbulelo Goniwe and Bantu Holomisa are instruc- tive. Both went before the NDC, appealed its findings to the NDCA and threw themselves on the mercy of the NEC. Julius Malema (president) Both were ultimately expelled. Sanction l Removed as youth league president His legal team’s argument that the youth league is an l 5–year suspension (plus a further 2 autonomous body, and that he should therefore retain his years – his 2010 suspended sentence presidency even if he loses membership of the ANC itself, triggered by his conviction on a similar does not align with the ANC constitution’s clear position offence).
    [Show full text]
  • Continuity, Representation, Redress: Khoi-San Testimony on Land Expropriation
    Aliosha Bielenberg 9 February 2019 Continuity, Representation, Redress Khoi-San Testimony on Land Expropriation In February 2018, the Parliament of South Africa established a committee to explore whether and how to “make it possible for the state to expropriate land in the public interest without compensation.”1 In order to hear testimony from across South African society, the committee organized public hearings in all provinces from 26 June to 4 August 2018.2 Many spoke of how white farmers — less than 9% of South Africa’s population — still own 67% of the land a quarter-century after the end of apartheid.3 Redistributing this land, for many, is a clear step toward redress of historical injustices perpetuated by white settler colonialism. Others invoked the specter of Zimbabwe, where land seizures led to economic freefall and long-term political instability. While few testifying before the committee opposed land reform in principle, many argued against the arbitrary abrogation of property rights and the concomitant sprawl of government power. On 6 September 2018, the committee heard seven hours of oral submissions in Cape Town. One of the first to testify was the head of Indigenous First Nation Advocacy South Africa (IFNASA), Anthony Williams, who claimed to represent the Khoi-San community. Williams argued in favor of land expropriation without compensation. For him, this meant not just amending the constitution to correct for the injustices of apartheid (which only really began after 1 From a parliamentary press release on 27 February 2018, available at https://www.parliament.gov.za/press- releases/national-assembly-gives-constitution-review-committee-mandate-review-section-25-constitution.
    [Show full text]
  • Popular Expressions of Southern African Nationalism(S): Convergences, Divergences, and Reconciliations in South Africa and Zimbabwe
    POPULAR EXPRESSIONS OF SOUTHERN AFRICAN NATIONALISM(S): CONVERGENCES, DIVERGENCES, AND RECONCILIATIONS IN SOUTH AFRICA AND ZIMBABWE By Blessing Shingirirai Mavima A DISSERTATION Submitted to Michigan State University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of African American and African Studies – Doctor of Philosophy 2019 ABSTRACT POPULAR EXPRESSIONS OF SOUTHERN AFRICAN NATIONALISM(S): CONVERGENCES, DIVERGENCES, AND RECONCILIATIONS IN SOUTH AFRICA AND ZIMBABWE By Blessing Shingirirai Mavima Popular Expressions of Pan-Africanism and Southern African Nationalism(s): Convergences, Divergences, and Reconciliations in South Africa and Zimbabwe is a dissertation study that traces the transformations, reveals the tensions, and critically analyzes diverging and converging trajectories of different manifestations of African nationalism, including ethnic nationalism, state nationalism, and Pan-Africanism using contemporary South Africa and Zimbabwe as sites of analyses. Focusing on the metropolitan provinces of Gauteng and Harare respectively, I use the study to interrogate how popular expressions of African nationalism have emerged and evolved in the neighboring nations during their anti-colonial/anti-apartheid struggles throughout the 20 th century, and how they exist today. Presenting a thesis that I call nationalisms from below, the research study reveals how these manifestations of nationalism are imagined, practiced, and represente d by the initiatives and actions of different members of the civil society including artists, activists, laborers, and migrants in the two countries’ contemporary politics and society. My findings lead to a nuanced determination of the factors that influence the intersections, divergences, and convergences of what I refer to in the study as Africa’s tripartite nationalist expressions and identities—ethnicism, African Nationalism, and Pan- Africanism.
    [Show full text]
  • The EFF Is Malema and Malema Is the EFF — What Happens When He Falls? Sello Lediga • 19 December 2019
    The EFF is Malema and Malema is the EFF — what happens when he falls? Sello Lediga • 19 December 2019 Under Julius Malema, the EFF has turned into a pseudo- revolutionary religious cult. He has alienated many in the party, and with criminal and corruption charges looming, he is on shaky ground. Like him or hate him, Sello Julius Malema is the most formidable politician post-apartheid South Africa has produced. Only eight years old when Nelson Mandela emerged from 27 years in prison, Malema was too young to vote in 1994 when for the first time South Africans voted for a democratic government, led by the African National Congress with Mandela as the first president. In 2000 Malema rampaged through the streets of Johannesburg as president of the Congress of South African Students and eight years later claimed the mantle of president of the ANC Youth League after a boisterous and gruelling campaign in which he emerged partly bruised but victorious. In 2013, after his expulsion from the ANC, he founded the Economic Freedom Fighters and contested national elections a year later. Against all odds, in the first elections it contested, the EFF became the third largest parliamentary party with over a million votes and 25 seats in the National Assembly. Malema nearly doubled his presence in Parliament with nearly two million votes and 44 seats in Parliament in the 2019 general elections. By any standards, the growth of the EFF has been impressive. It is doubtful if the EFF would have achieved this without the domineering personality of Julius Malema.
    [Show full text]
  • OPEN LETTER: Effective Legislative Oversight, Transparency and Engagement During the National State of Disaster
    OPEN LETTER: Effective legislative oversight, transparency and engagement during the national state of disaster 10 April 2020 For Attention: National Parliament Speaker Thandi Modise [email protected] NCOP Chairperson Amos Masondo [email protected]; [email protected] Acting-Secretary Penelope Tyawa [email protected] Chair of Chairs Cedrick Frolick [email protected] Chief Whips: ANC: Pemmy Majodina [email protected] DA: Natasha Mazzone [email protected] EFF: Floyd Shivambu [email protected]; [email protected] IFP: Narend Singh [email protected] ACDP: Steve Swart [email protected] FF Plus: Petrus Mulder [email protected] Al-Jamah: Mogamad Hendricks [email protected] GOOD: Shaun August [email protected] COPE: William Madisha [email protected] ATM: Vuyolwethu Zungula [email protected] NFP: Shaik Emam [email protected] PAC: Mzwanele Nyhontso [email protected] AIC: Lulama Ntshayisa [email protected] UDM: Nqabayomzi Kwankwa [email protected] Eastern Cape Provincial Legislature Speaker Helen Mercedes Sauls-August [email protected] Secretary Vuyani Mapolisa [email protected]; [email protected] Chair of Chairs Ntombovuyo Nkopane [email protected]; [email protected] Free State Provincial Legislature Speaker Ntombizanele Sifuba [email protected] Secretary Thabo Mofokeng [email protected]; [email protected] Chair of Chairs Mojalefa Buti [email protected] Gauteng Provincial Legislature
    [Show full text]
  • The Private Funding of Political Parties: What Do We Know?
    THE PRIVATE FUNDING OF POLITICAL PARTIES: WHAT DO WE KNOW? This report, compiled by My Vote Counts (MVC), is a compilation of information on the private funding of political parties through donations and/or other financial transfers. The negative impact of the unregulated private funding of political parties in South Africa, stretches back to the period prior to the inception of democracy in 1994. However, this document serves as an informative reminder of donations allocated to current political parties contesting the 2019 general elections, in the absence of an effective party funding transparency disclosure regime for voters to make an informed vote. In the lead up to any elections, political parties are surely receiving a spike in private donations to fund their campaigns. Without this information being made public, political parties have been able to operate without proper scrutiny and conceal key information from the very people they depend on for votes. The following information is already available in the public domain, but not all the sources referenced are available online or compiled collectively as they are here. The fact that this information is restricted to five political parties, and in light of the vulnerability our political system has faced in the absence of party private funding transparency regulations, there is surely a huge gap in publicly available information on the various private donations allocated to political parties. This report cannot claim to have all the publicly available information on political parties private funding, but has included the most accessible sources. This report provides the following information: ● Political parties: The report mainly lists donations allocated to the African National Congress, the Democratic Alliance, the Economic Freedom Fighters, the Inkatha Freedom Party and the United Democratic Movement.
    [Show full text]
  • Richard Poplak – Daily Maverick Saudi Crown Prince’S Business Empire’
    19 21 26 29 30 Mail Guardian & 35 Years Mail Guardian35 Years For 35 years& the M&G has been at the forefront of journalism in South Africa. Mail Guardian35 Years Our newsroom& has been the training ground for the finest journalists in the country. It has also given birth to investigative units, such as amaBhungane and Bhekisisa. This has been possible because people like you support our newsroom. For just R75,00 per month, you can access all of this journalism and help grow the next generation of editors, reporters and columnists. Signup up here for this special offer that is exclusive to our colleagues. www.mg.co.za/journalistoffer Africa’s Best Read AFRICA’S BEST READ SOUTH AFRICA June 11 to 17 2010 Vol 26, No 22 May 23 to 29 2008⁄ Vol 24, No 21 / R16,50 in SA / www.mg.co.za / SMS “subs” to subscribe or “mg” for news via cellphone (one-off R1 charge) to 32368 Mozambique SOUTH AFRICA / Zambia ZMK11 850 / Zimbabwe $210 000 000 / Kenya Ksh277 / Angola US$6,10 / Botswana P15,28 / Swaziland E15,28 / Malawi MWK 283 / Lesotho M16,50 Celebrating 25 years of the M&G http://2010.mg.co.za www.mg.co.za Bumper special pull-out Chantel Dartnall Dada Masilo Daniel Buckland Lindi Matshikiza Lira Adam Levy Catherine Luckhoff Zibusiso Mkhwanazi Andy Higgins Claire Reid Nick Ferreira Pria Chetty Mpumelelo Paul Grootboom Musa Nxumalo Kesivan Ways of escape Naidoo BLK JKS Nicholas Hlobo Nontsikelelo Veleko Trevor Noah Warwick Allan Oliver Hermanus Barbara Mallinson Eusebius McKaiser Tania Steenkamp Castro Ngobese Xolani Mtshizana Kaajal Ramjathan-Keogh
    [Show full text]
  • FOCUS 53 Focus HELEN SUZMAN MEMORIAL by Nicky Oppenheimer
    Tracing Political Trends focus Issue 53 • 1st Quarter • April 2009 • R24.95 www.hsf.org.za Suzman Tribute Edition Eulogy Motion of Condolence 53 Memorial 74 M&G CRITICAL THINKING FORUM • Ready to Govern? • Where to now?• The struggle must go on SAIRR BRIEFING 86 • No more honeymoon • The task is to realign politics • Meeting the great expectations of the young 98 COALITION GOVERNMENT • Crafting a coalition • G20, Beyond the London Summit BOOK REVIEWS • Choice, Not Fate • The Mandela Files • Fixing Global Finance 108 FOCUS EDITORIAL Hamba Kahle By Raenette Taljaard Beloved Helen his edition of FOCUS marks a solemn and sad event “Within the galaxy of outstanding South Africans are Members – the passing of our beloved Patron-in-Chief Helen of our democratic Parliament to whom we had the misfortune since T Suzman. It is a moment of bereavement we wish to mark last February to bid the final farewell. They include Brian Bunting, Billy by publishing a special Helen Suzman Tribute edition as a fitting Nair, Ncumisa Kondlo, John Gomomo, Joe Nhlanhla, Cas Saloojee, John honour to a life well-lived with a sound moral compass. Schippers and Jan van Eck. Hers was a life that set an example worthy of emulation by “To these, I would also like to add Ms Helen Suzman, a truly us all for its sheer tenacity, principle and commitment. This is a distinguished South African, who represented the values of our new moment of reflection accompanied by an outpouring of grief, Parliament in the chambers of the old.” both locally and abroad, that has been breathtaking in both scale As Mamphela Ramphele emphasised in a tribute in the Sunday and scope – a collective emotion that saw our nation’s flags Times after Helen’s passing, her spirit of public service and ethos flown half-mast in tribute to a daughter of the struggle who gave of serving first and foremost the needs and lives of others must every sinew of her spirit to the fight for justice and the cause of be the most salient characteristic of Helen Suzman’s life journey.
    [Show full text]
  • Eisa Election Resource Center
    ISSUE NO. 2 | 10 APRIL 2019 EISA ELECTION RESOURCE CENTER A weekly review of the South African 2019 national and provincial elections WHY SMALL PARTIES MATTER IN SOUTH Political parties: AFRICA’S DEMOCRACY The voter’s choice WRITTEN BY NANCY HAKIZIMANA WHY SMALL Despite the sway the ANC holds in South African politics, there is no PARTIES shortage of healthy democratic competition thanks to the number of MATTER IN smaller political parties that take part in national, provincial and SOUTH AFRICA’S municipal elections. Their significance is often underestimated, and it DEMOCRACY is often assumed that voting for them is irrelevant to the political context, a “wasted vote”. But, in recent times, it has become common A PARTY to view a vote for a smaller party as a vote against the ruling party. DIVIDED: THE ANC’S FACTIONS, FRICTIONS AND A recent poll by the Institute of Race Relations (IRR) found that voter FUTURE support for the ANC has decreased from 62.1% in 2014 to 54.7% in 2019. This corresponds with the number of seats the party lost in the 2014 national elections and 2016 local government elections, making WHO’S OLD? WHO’S NEW? room for smaller parties to enter the parliamentary fray. Despite their lack of voter support, smaller parties hold relative DECISION 2019: negotiating power, not only because their elected members are in the HAS THE DA position to act as whistleblowers, propose or challenge new bills, and REACHED A CEILING? fight state corruption, but because they are able to use their seats to bargain with larger parties.
    [Show full text]
  • The Economic Freedom Fighter's Rise to Power: a Threat to South Africa's Democratic Consolidation
    The Economic Freedom Fighter’s Rise to Power: A Threat to South Africa’s Democratic Consolidation by Isabel Greta Nel Thesis presented in fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Science Arts in the Faculty of Arts and Social Sciences at Stellenbosch University. Supervisor: Dr Nicola de Jager April 2019 Stellenbosch University https://scholar.sun.ac.za Declaration By submitting this thesis electronically, I declare that the entirety of the work contained therein is my own, original work, that I am the sole author thereof (save to the extent explicitly otherwise stated), that reproduction and publication thereof by Stellenbosch University will not infringe any third-party rights and that I have not previously in its entirety or in part submitted it for obtaining any qualification. April 2019 Copyright © 2019 Stellenbosch University All rights reserved i Stellenbosch University https://scholar.sun.ac.za Abstract The world is witnessing a decline in the support for democracy. This has been evident in numerous countries across the globe and in South Africa today. Domestic and Global Social Structures and Ruptures have created fertile conditions for populism to flourish. Populism in Africa has derived from a fertile environment, one shaped by a distinctive historical context imbued with the ideas of socialism and nationalism. The ideological context also evident in South Africa, combined with the current socio-economic challenges, has resulted in high (but unmet) expectations of the state. High levels of poverty, unemployment and inequality, combined with poor and corrupt governance, have left many young South African citizens marginalised, resentful and discontent towards the current ANC government.
    [Show full text]