No. 171 THE SHEFFIELD CO-OPERATIVE PARTY NEWSPAPER THE CO-OPERATIVE PARTY CELEBRATES ITS CENTENARY 100 YEARS OF CO-OPERATION A WARM WELCOME TO THE BEST WISHES: A MESSAGE SHEFFIELD CO-OPERATOR TO THE CO-OPERATOR Shefeld Co-operative Party published was only in power for 6 years) it could be Te frst edition of the Shefeld Co-op- the Shefeld Co-operator every month considered that the Labour Government erator carried this message; from May 1922 to July 1939. Tere were made a good start. But that has now all 170 editions in all, with a circulation of been overturned, even the most bacon- “All good wishes to the “Shefeld 30,000. Tis edition, the 171st, has been sidered that the Labour Government Co-operator” for a useful and prosper- published to celebrate the centenary of made a good start. But that has now ous career in carrying the message of the Co-operative Party 1917 - 2017. all been overturned, even the most ba- co-operation to the electors of Shefeld. During the 1920s and 1930s the sic services have been privatised, run for Te voters of this country have listened Co-operator not only criticised the pow- the purpose of generating private wealth, long enough to the voice of the capital- ers that be, but put forward constructive undermining the integrity and quality of ist preaching through press and Parlia- suggestions to the end that “the Co-op- the services. Te public are paying com- ment the false doctrine of self-interest erative system should be substituted for pany shareholders, middlemen; a dream and proft-making, which is destroying the Competitive one in local and nation- come true for the rich and idle. the world. It is time for co-operation to al afairs.” Perhaps the most successful example speak in the home and the house. May of common ownership, although some- it have a strong voice in the “Shefeld COMMON OWNERSHIP thing which has now been lost is Mu- Co-operator.” nicipal Ownership. In the 1890s Shef- - A. Honora Enfeld. (National Secre- Te need to encourage community in- feld tramways (later buses), markets, tary, Women’s Co-operative Guild). itiatives as an alternative to private in- electricity, water, education, parks, and terests is as vital today as ever. In 1652 council housing and services were all in Tough twritten almost 100 years ago, at the time of the English Revolution, municipal ownership. Tey were owned Honora Enfeld’s words are just as relev- Gerrard Winstanley wrote a pamphlet and controlled by the people of Shef- ent today as they were then. entitled ‘Te Law of Freedom’. In his feld through their elected council. It view, true human dignity would be pos- is important to note that until recently, sible only when communal ownership people working in these services were was established. Land was in the hands directly employed by Shefeld Council. CO-OPERATORS ELECTED of the inheritors of the Norman inva- Tis promoted integrity, quality, prop- sion. Tis gave them complete power to er working conditions, and none of the control people, increase their personal shoddiness of proft driven enterprises. IN RECORD NUMBERS wealth and in turn further increase their Te ratepayers did not have to pay mid- power. Te victims of this were the peo- dlemen (profteers). Municipal owner- Following a strong 2017 General Elec- co-operative values at Westminster. ple, the 99%. Land has the capacity to ship was helped by certain well meaning tion campaign, a record number of MPs produce food, but ownership gave the individuals who made gifts to the people from the Co-operative Party have been NOT WAITING FOR WHITEHALL landowners the power to withhold pro- of Shefeld, people like J.G. Graves. elected to Parliament. Not only did the duction, and the people were starving. In the years between the wars, the party retain all of its existing MPs on in- It is important to remember however, Winstanley’s view, novel at the time, was Conservatives and Liberals joined forc- creased majorities, it was able to add nine that Labour did not win a majority, and that people should lay claim to land, cul- es to campaign for the city to get rid of further co-operative voices to parlia- the Conservatives are still in governmnt, tivate it, and eat. the council employees and instead to ment, making the Co-operative Party the albeit propped up by the Democratic Ownership gives political control. It contract private businesses to deliver third largest party in Westminster with Unionist Party of Northern Ireland, with can be in the hands of private interests to services. Te electorate resolutely voted 38 MPs. a slim majority. increase personal wealth at the expense Labour and kept the afairs of the city in Among those elected were Tat is why the Co-operative Party of the 99%. Or it can be in communal public control. Shadow International Development have decided that it is no longer appro- ownership where work carries integrity Common ownership has not endured. Minister Kate Osamor, who held Ed- priate to “Wait For Whitehall” to make because the outcome of that work sup- Political resistance by private interests monton with 71.5% of the vote, and Jon the necessary reforms to local govern- plies genuine needs, and surplus is not campaigning through the Conservative Ashworth, the Shadow Health Minister ment. At its June conference in Birming- needed to pay idle speculators. Party have proved too great. But this who held Leicester South with 73.5%. ham, the Party launched its “6 Steps to Keir Hardie, frst Chair of the Inde- should not signal defeat for ‘collectivism’. Te Party was able to welcome back Building Community Wealth,” a policy pendent Labour Party (founded in 1893) Centralised public ownership is not the David Drew, who returned to Parlia- document which outlines the ways that and also the frst Chair of the Labour only way (although it has an important ment as the Member for Stroud, having local authorities can adopt to co-opera- Party made clear in his book ‘From Serf- role to play). previously held the seat from 1997-2010. tive approaches to working. Tis includes dom to Socialism’; “Te economic object New MPs included Ged Killen (Ruth- adopting Co-operative Polical Lead- of Socialism, therefore is to make land THE CO-OPERATIVE PARTY erglen and Hamilton West) and Paul ership at Council level, creating new and industrial capital common proper- Sweeney (Glasgow North East), who Co-operative Development Groups and ty, and to cease to produce for the proft Tere is a valuable role for the co-opera- together form a frm base for a progres- Anchor Institutions, and using progres- of the landlord and the capitalist and to tive model of collective ownership. It has sive revival in Scotland. Joining them are sive procurement. begin to produce for the use of commu- proved successful in challenging the mo- Anneliese Dodds (Oxford East), Alex At the recent Labour Party Confer- nity.” nopoly of private enterprise in the 19th Norris (Nottingham North), Luke Pol- ence, Shadow Chancellor John McDon- But how can communal or common and 20th centuries. lard (Plymouth Sutton and Devonport), nell promised that if Labour were to win ownership be organised when there is Tere was an urgent and immedi- Jo Platt (Leigh), Lloyd Russell-Moyle an election, he would oversee a huge ex- so much resistance from private inter- ate need for co-operatives when private (Brighton Kemptown), and Alex Sobel pansion of the co-operative sector. ests? Te Labour Party got its chance commerce and industry were abusing (Leeds North West) Te Co-operator encourages all of its in 1945 and introduced nationalisation their monopoly power. Te Movement’s All of of the successful candidates readers to read this document, and for which served a valuable purpose, but it strength has been built upon group sol- should be applauded for their fne eforts Shefeld Council to consider ways in had its faws. In the circumstances, and idarity and support for other co-opera- throughout the election campaign, and which it can adopt some of its sensible within the time scale available (Labour tives, promoting social wellbeing, deliv- should be further encouraged to spread and level headed proposals. together? Joined up Heritage is working THE CO-OP PARTY HAS to develop a strategic plan for heritage STRONG ROOTS IN SHEFFIELD LETTERS TO THE EDITOR across the city and raise funding for train- A JOINED UP HERITAGE not alone. Tere are over 2,000 events ing groups in the skills needed for run- “Co-operation is a theory of society STRATEGY FOR SHEFFIELD a year. Many cities across the globe ning their local groups. Heritage Lot- and therefore a legitimate basis for a have used heritage and the reuse of the tery funding to provide apprenticeships political party.” I was trying to visualise in my mind buildings to spark regeneration. Across in building restoration and retro-ftting what it must have been like at the start Shefeld there are good examples of this (making a building greener). Arts fund- Tis quote was made at the Swansea of the Co-operative Party. As a histori- such as Portland Works and Regather. ing to help create local festivals. Using Congress of the Co-operative Move- an I know that in 1917 times were hard. Others wait in the wings such as Save heritage to boost neighbourhood morale ment in 1917, by Mr W T Allen, Chair Te war was obviously not going to end Mount Pleasant, Friends of Meersbrook and encourage tourism as Manor Lodge of the meeting, where the Co-operative quickly and for many the constitutional- Hall and Friends of Abbeyfeld Park. has. Reftting buildings with profes- Party was created. Te Co-operative ly illegal conscription the year before had Joined up Heritage grew from discus- sional kitchens that can be used both for Party is the political wing of the British caused uneasiness in many areas. Wom- sions after Le Tour about how poorly private enterprise and social enterprise, Co-operative Movement. It believes in en were pushing for the vote. Very vola- the Co-operative Values and Principles tile times and many must have thought and how they can be used for the beneft not the most appropriate time to make of all communities. changes to the political system, but from Te opening of the Rochdale Pi- the poor’s point of view there was no oneers Shop in 1844 was a political stability. I am old enough to remember statement, they wanted to provide pure the signs of poverty in the 1950s. My and unadulterated produce, at honest parents had the marks of TB and my weights and measures, for their mem- teacher clear signs of childhood rickets. bers. Te Pioneers eschewed party pol- And in the late 60s as a nurse I saw the itics in their Societies at frst, preferring fear in people’s eyes of being in hospital. to do it themselves. After all they could It brought images of the Workhouse to not vote, and were barred from holding them when hospitals were the last resort political meetings. and it was unlikely they would leave But the argument in the Movement alive. went on, 1890’s Scottish CWS Chair Te “hipster” generation with and Congress President William Max- co-working spaces, shared ownership, well stating that he did not seek “to in- and community shares are well aware of troduce politics into co-operation, but the technicalities of setting up co-op- I am most anxious to see co-operation eratives even if they don’t always call introduced more into politics” them that. Tat is because the system of Te Party was created because of co-operatives was a good idea and still the gross unfairness and attacks on the is. It is not only in developing countries Co-operative movement. Local traders that we need more co-ops, it is in this and politicians set up anti co-operative city. Te Co-op Party and the co-opera- groups, these later became Chambers of tive movement is as relevant to creating Commerce. a fairer society today as it was 100 years Tings came to a head in the First ago. Tere are major inequalities with- MOUNT PLEASANT: A COMMUNITY GROUP HAS BEEN FORMED World War, local draft boards called in the city and for many the chance of TO TRY AND SAVE AND RENOVATE THIS LOCAL LANDMARK. up men from Co-operatives and spared lifting themselves out of poverty seems their own staf in private business. Gov- mere fantasy. Even if they do fnd a job, Shefeld’s venues were marketed and raising skills level, and encouraging local ernment refused to use the vast expe- the low wages and the high cost of travel how we as heritage groups could im- enterprise. Te refurbishment skills that rience of the Co-operative Movement means their situation changes very little. prove on that. It became obvious that we apprentices learn could be applied else- on bodies such as Food Supply ignor- Yet city planners continue to focus on had several problems in Shefeld. Her- where to bring old houses up to mod- ing calls for rationing and fair distribu- work being in the centre and housing on itage organisations had been relying on ern standards. Tey could also work in tion of food. Te Excess Profts tax was the outskirts. Lottery funding in the main, but fund- co-operative housing schemes to supply threatened, “a bill to tax the members Within Shefeld there is a shortage of ing was often refused due to lack of in- housing to those on low income who do dividend.” skills in the building and catering trades. frastructure and strategic thinking. Even not qualify for social housing, possibly Working in areas of high deprivation in if funding was achieved the amount was small units centrally, so placing housing Wales and Glasgow, Oxfam has found often too small to make a long lasting where the work is, not several miles out. that many of the poor lack the self conf- impact and help create the infrastructure By using a variety of funding schemes dence to change things. So for many the that would make it self sustainable. and volunteers and apprenticeship frst step has to be raising self esteem, We have in Shefeld a wide range of schemes to kick start these hubs we then training in necessary skills to fnd heritage buildings owned by the Council would take the cost of running and re- employment, or to create their own em- such as libraries and buildings within lo- furbishing the buildings away from the ployment. With small amounts of seed cal parks. For many reasons they are in a Council and give local people the con- capital, Oxfam has managed to encour- poor state, but the Council hasn’t enough trol of their own neighbourhood. To age people to creating their own busi- available fnance to repair and refurbish change inequality in the city we have to nesses. them. Many of these buildings are in help strengthen people’s collective iden- Shefeld is rich in heritage, though areas of high deprivation. Research by tity, encourage them to be involved in if you looked at the promotional flms the Heritage Lottery Fund and Historic planning decisions, help them gain con- you’d be hard put to fnd it mentioned. England amongst others has found that fdence and create the kind of commu- Tat is not because we have no venues historic buildings are important to lo- nity they want. We need to work co-op- that visitors fnd attractive. Te National cal communities and give them a strong eratively as a city to build a resilient Emergency Services Museum (NESM) sense of community identity. What is a economy. A difcult target I know, but for example, has seen paying visitor fnancial liability for the Council could it worked 100 years ago so why not now? numbers almost double from 38,000 to be a major asset to the community. - JOY BULLIVANT 80,000 in the past year, and NESM is What if we combined several threads A. V. ALEXANDER
So in 1917 members from the whole of the movement agreed, “that, in view of persistent attacks and misrepresenta- tions made by the opponents of the Co-operative Movement in Parliament and on local administrative bodies this Congress is of the opinion that the time has arrived when co-operators should se- cure direct representation in Parliament and on all local administrative bodies.” Te Co-operative Party was born. Shefeld can lay claim to one of the greatest Co-operative Party Politicians. Albert Victor Alexander, 1st Earl Al- exander of Hillsborough, KG, CH, PC (1 May 1885 – 11 January 1965) was a British Co-operative politician. He was elected for Hillsborough in November 1922, one of only four Co-op MPs. He was re-elected in 1923, 1924 and 1929. He would continue to represent Shef- feld, with one break, until 1950. He was three times First Lord of the Admiral- ty, including during the Second World War, and then Minister of Defence un- der Clement Attlee. His work is being carried on today by the 38 MP’s and over 500 Co-op Party Councillors around the country. To fnd out more about what we do today visit www.party.coop we can put you in touch with your local party. - JOHN BOYLE CO-OP PARTY SUPPORT AND PRINCIPLE SIX OFFICER 2 Reporting on the matter, the Shefeld Co-operator chastised the Citizens’ Par- ty, stating the likelihood that long after FREEDOM OF THE CITY FOR many of the “public” men who had pre- viously received the honour were utterly forgotten, “in perhaps 100 years’ time,” Edward Carpenter would be honoured EDWARD CARPENTER by a sculptured monument in a promi- nent Shefeld location. Particular ire was Tis year marks the 50th anniversary of for many of the social crusades of the Donald, who opened up to him about directed at Councillor Irwin Mitchell, the partial decriminalisation of homo- day, from land nationalisation to female the stresses of national leadership. who confessed after the vote that he had sexuality in Britain. In Shefeld, the oc- sufrage, and was an active member of never heard of Edward Carpenter. “Tese casion was commemorated with a series the Shefeld Socialist Society and the FREEDOM OF THE CITY be thy gods, 0 Ecclesall!” the Co-opera- of events in the last week of February, to Independent Labour Party. tor exclaimed. coincide with LGBT+ History Month. In June 1928, the year before his death at Te elitist attitude of some Council- Hosting academics and writers, flm A POLITICAL RADICAL the age of 84, Labour councillors moved lors of the day in regards to titles was showings, and activity sessions, the to award Carpenter the Freedom of the confrmed two years later, when Richard weekend culminated with a Full Moon Appalled by the grinding poverty and City of Shefeld, along with the Labour Bennett, the Prime Minister of Canada, “Tea Dance” hosted by DJ Wendy and sickness of Shefeld residents, in 1887, MP Cecil Wilson MP, Alderman J.G. and James Scullin, the Prime Minister of the Out Aloud! LGBT choir. he and other members of the Socialist Graves, and Alderman Henry Stephen- Australia were awarded the Freedom of One of the highlights of the weekend Society took over the old debtors’ jail on son. the City for services to the Empire. Both was Sally Goldsmith’s lecture – support- Scotland Street, opening the downstairs were accomplished men, but it is cer- ed by the Friends of Edward Carpen- foor as the “Commonwealth Café”, tain that neither contributed anything of ter - on the relationship between famed which gave assistance to the local poor note to the cultural life of Shefeld, as Victorian writer and political activist and hosted lectures by notable radicals, Edward Carpenter had. Edward Carpenter and locally born ra- such as Annie Besant, and the anarchist Carpenter has been repeatedly redis- zor grinder George Hukin. Carpenter Peter Kropotkin. covered in the years since his death. In is known to the LGBT+ community as Tough never directly involved with 1972, Rony Robinson, the Radio Shef- an early advocate for sexual equality: his the Shefeld Co-operative Party, Car- feld presenter, staged Edward Carpen- writings on “homogenic” love and his penter had been inspired by the exper- ter Lives! the frst new play staged at open espousal of a homosexual identi- imental co-operative agricultural associ- the Crucible. In 1979, Noel Greig in- ty often put him at odds with the more ations he’d encountered on his trips to troduced Carpenter to the Gay Liber- conventional radical Labour community Europe. He later lectured on the idea ation Movement in his play “Te Dear of the time, but they have helped him of an economic transformation, fuelled Love of Comrades,” produced for the achieve lasting fame. by co-operative banks, unions and so- Gay Sweatshop. And in 2009, the frst A native of Brighton, and Fellow of cieties that could generate social forms full length biography of Carpenter, Shei- Trinity College, Cambridge, Carpenter of wealth. On the liberation wing of the la Rowbotham’s A Life of Liberty and travelled the north for many years as a socialist movement, he disliked state in- Love, was published by Verso. lecturer, making Shefeld his base. Re- tervention, believed that change could In this celebratory year, almost ninety ceiving an inheritance from his late fa- only grow out of existing roots, and “vol- years since his death, it is time to heed ther, he moved to Millthorpe, a farming untary collectivism,” and like Kropotkin, the call of the Shefeld Co-operator and hamlet not far from Dronfeld, in 1883. believed that small-holdings encouraged erect a statue worthy of Edward Car- It was there that he wrote his most fa- enterprise, attention to detail and all- penter in the city centre, and correct a mous books, including Towards Democ- round skills. historic injustice by rewarding him post- racy, a narrative poem inspired by Walt Such was Carpenter’s repute inside EDWARD CARPENTER humously with the Freedom of the City. Whitman’s Leaves of Grass. Carpenter and outside the Labour movement that Tis is the task that Friends of Edward twice travelled to the United States to on the eve of his seventieth birthday – So often a formality, the application was Carpenter have chosen to undertake. visit Whitman, and later published an and again on his eightieth – he received rejected after councillors from the Citi- Tey can often be found at the Mugen account of the days they spent together. a letter of congratulations signed by over zens’ Party – a Conservative/Liberal co- Tea House, located on Scotland Street, Making a career as a market gardener, 200 notable fgures, including Ramsey alition – refused to vote on the matter. just a stone’s throw away from the site of selling his produce at Chesterfeld, Car- MacDonald, Rabindranath Tagore, and Tough all the Labour councillors voted the old Commonwealth Café. Why not penter consciously attempted a “simpli- Bernard Shaw, expressing the “feelings in favour, a decision was made that the join them in singing Edward Carpen- fcation of life” which challenged the in- of admiration and gratitude” with which vote had not been quorate. Te Citizens’ ter’s well known hymn “England Arise!” dustrial triumphalism of the 1870s and they regarded his body of work. Carpen- Party refused to comment on their rea- - CHRISTOPHER OLEWICZ 1880s. A vegetarian, he was an advocate ter frequently corresponded with Mac- soning for refusing to vote.
WELCOME Labour and Co-operative candidates. -CONTINUED FROM PAGE 1 Te purpose of the Co-operative Party is to defend and promote co-operatives. ering goods and services which the com Te co-operative style of common own- munity has a need for, the commitment ership is very diferent from the national- CO-OPERATIVELY OWNED AND MANAGED HISTORIC BUILDING WITH isation of the 1945 Labour Government of members, education and social recrea- tion and the equitable distribution of any or Municipal Socialism. It is rooted in AMPLE CAR PARKING, CREATING THE RIGHT WORKING ENVIRONMENT surplus. Vitally, co-operatives and their collective self-help and social enterprise property are owned by the members and and governed by the members through their agreed constitution. All co-opera- HIGH PROFILE UNITS TO RENT FOR NEW AND ESTABLISHED BUSINESSES that gives democratic control provided CO-OPERATIVELY OWNED AND MANAGED HISTORIC BUILDING WITH that there is good governance and mem- tives are guided by the same values and ber participation. Unfortunately, some principles which apply throughout the co-operatives got very big and distant world. AMPLE CAR PARKING, CREATING THE RIGHT WORKING ENVIRONMENT from the members and co-operative cul- Co-operative awareness, education, activity and culture form the foun- A COMPLETE RANGE OF DIFFERENT SIZED UNITS TO SUIT ALL TYPES OF BUSINESS ture became eroded with the result that the Movement became marginalised. dation stones for building an alter- HIGH PROFILE UNITS TO RENT FOR NEW AND ESTABLISHED BUSINESSES native economy to capitalism. If you NEEDS, INCLUDING A COMPREHENSIVE RANGE OF SUPPORT SERVICES As stand-alone businesses, co-oper- atives are neither secure nor part of a think that the commitment to this Movement towards a democratic and aim is worthwhile, join a co-opera- Switchboard & telephone answering collective economy. In a highly compet- tive and join the Co-operative Party. A COMPLETE RANGE OF DIFFERENT SIZED UNITS TO SUIT ALL TYPES OF BUSINESS itive world there are always private con- Voicemail cerns which are ready to defeat collectiv- NEEDS, INCLUDING A COMPREHENSIVE RANGE OF SUPPORT SERVICES ist eforts, history has proved this. Tat is why the Co-operative Union was es- Conferences facilities & meeting rooms tablished; to co-ordinate and defend the Switchboard & telephone answering Co-operative Movement. Broadband internet access At an early stage in the development Voicemail of the Co-operative Movement, it was Yorkshire Co-operative On site ICT support agreed that there should be political Resource Centre neutrality. Tis avoided fragmentation Conferences facilities & meeting rooms between Owenite co-operators, and var- Excellent car parking ious other socialist groups and Chartists. Broadband internet access But there came a time during the First Members Lending Library Website hosting World War when the need for political and Co-operative Archive On site ICT support representation became urgent. Te Con- Wide range of optional services servatives and Liberals were using their political power to discriminate against Excellent car parking co-operatives in favour of private enter- NEW MEMBERS WELCOME
Email: [email protected] prises. Tis had the potential to destroy 011 4 2 8 2 3 1 2 3 Website: F a www.aizlewoodsmill.comxWebsite 011 hosting4 28 2 3150 the eforts of the Movement. In 1917, Te Co-operative Congress (the sover- Aizlewood’s Mill