DOCSLIB.ORG

A Betrayal of Trust

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
A Betrayal of Trust A BETRAYAL OF TRUST The independent report into the handling of allegations that have come to the attention of the Church of England concerning the late Hubert Victor Whitsey, former Bishop of Chester. His Honour David Pearl, Lead Reviewer Kate Wood, Review Adviser Hannah Sinclair, Project Manager A BETRAYAL OF TRUST Contents Preface .................................................................................................................................................... 5 Chronological Timeline ........................................................................................................................... 7 Executive Summary ............................................................................................................................... 20 Chapter 1: Background ......................................................................................................................... 23 1. Biography of Whitsey .................................................................................................................... 23 2. Events Leading up to Whitsey’s Resignation ................................................................................ 24 3. The Diocese of Chester at that Time: The Evidence of Bishop Michael Baughen ........................ 25 Chapter 2: The Police Investigation ...................................................................................................... 26 1. Operation Coverage ...................................................................................................................... 26 Chapter 3: Terms of Reference of this Review ..................................................................................... 28 1. The Standard of Proof ................................................................................................................... 28 Chapter 4: Terminology ........................................................................................................................ 29 PART A: The Victims .............................................................................................................................. 31 Chapter 5: M1 ....................................................................................................................................... 31 1. The 2014 Disclosure ...................................................................................................................... 31 2. The Chester DSA’s Early Involvement ........................................................................................... 34 3. The First NST Core Group Meeting - 25th July 2016 ...................................................................... 36 4. M1’s Interview with the Police ..................................................................................................... 37 5. Our View of these Allegations ....................................................................................................... 38 6. Disclosures to Two People ............................................................................................................ 39 7. Alleged Disclosure to Bishop Glyn Webster, Bishop of Beverley .................................................. 39 7.1. M1’s Interview with the Police .................................................................................................. 40 7.2. Minutes of the Core Group ........................................................................................................ 40 7.3. The Northern Provincial Safeguarding Adviser’s Correspondence and Meeting with Bishop Glyn Webster .................................................................................................................................... 41 7.4. The Chester DSA’s Telephone Call to M1 - 10th November 2016 .............................................. 42 7.5. The Evidence Given to the Review ............................................................................................. 42 7.6. Cleric A’s Report ......................................................................................................................... 44 7.7. Two Other Worrying Aspects ..................................................................................................... 45 7.8. Bishop Glyn Webster’s Evidence to us ....................................................................................... 46 7.9. Our Conclusions ......................................................................................................................... 47 1 A BETRAYAL OF TRUST 7.10. Other Concerns ........................................................................................................................ 49 Chapter 6: M2 ....................................................................................................................................... 50 1. M2’s Interview with the Police ..................................................................................................... 50 2. Early Disclosures by M2 ................................................................................................................ 51 3. Meeting with Bishop Michael Baughen ........................................................................................ 53 4. Our View on Whether there was Disclosure to Bishop Michael Baughen ................................... 53 5. Alleged Disclosure to Bishop Peter Forster in 2001/2 .................................................................. 54 6. Conclusion on the Disclosures ...................................................................................................... 55 7. The Period 2016-2018 ................................................................................................................... 56 Chapter 7: M3 ....................................................................................................................................... 59 1. Second Core Group - 10th November 2016 .................................................................................. 59 2. How Did M3 Come to the Attention of the Church? .................................................................... 60 3. Bishop Peter Forster’s Meeting with M3 ...................................................................................... 62 4. Evidence of Bishop Peter Forster to IICSA .................................................................................... 63 5. Interview of Bishop Peter Forster with the Review Team ............................................................ 64 6. Our Conclusions ............................................................................................................................ 64 7. M3’s Contact with Canon Peter Lee in the Early 1990s ................................................................ 65 8. M3’s Alleged Disclosure to Bishop David Urquhart, then Bishop of Stockport in 2002 ............... 66 9. Contact Between Bishop Peter Forster and Bishop David Urquhart ............................................ 68 10. Bishop Peter Forster’s Contact with Canon Peter Lee ................................................................ 68 Chapter 8: F1, F2, F3, F4 & F5 ............................................................................................................... 69 1. Conversation Between Canon Roger Clarke and F3 ..................................................................... 69 2. The Interview with F1 by the Review Team - 24th March 2020 .................................................... 71 3. Evidence F1 gave to the Police ...................................................................................................... 73 4. Our Conclusions Regarding F1 and F2........................................................................................... 73 5. F3 ................................................................................................................................................... 75 6. F4 and F5 ....................................................................................................................................... 76 7. Our Conclusions ............................................................................................................................ 77 Chapter 9: F6 & M4 ............................................................................................................................... 78 1. The Core Group - 7th July 2017 ...................................................................................................... 78 2. Information from Canon Chegwin Hall ......................................................................................... 78 3. F6’s Evidence to IICSA ................................................................................................................... 79 4. F6’s Video Conference with the Review Team on 25th March 2020 ............................................. 80 5. Our Conclusion .............................................................................................................................. 80 2 A BETRAYAL OF TRUST 6. Overheard Conversation at the Interment of their Mother’s Ashes - April 2015......................... 81 7. Telephone Contact by F6 with the Diocese .................................................................................. 83 8. Lack of Apology Letter..................................................................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Sundays in Advent
    Holy Eucharist with Confirmation in Eastertide President and Preacher: The Right Reverend David Urquhart Bishop of Birmingham Deacon: The Very Reverend Matt Thompson Dean of Birmingham The Cathedral Church of St Philip, Birmingham Saturday 8 May 2021 Welcome to Birmingham Cathedral for this celebration of Holy Communion with Confirmation. We are very pleased to welcome candidates for Confirmation to this special service, together with their supporters and all joining the service via the livestream. Gluten-free wafers If you require a gluten-free wafer, please let the verger know before the service. Face coverings Unless exempt, you are required to wear a face covering whilst in the cathedral. There are hand sanitising stations in the north and south aisles for your use as you remove and replace face coverings to receive Communion, or you may prefer to use your own. Accessibility Large print copies of this order of service are available. An induction loop system is provided for hearing aid users – please switch to ‘t’. Guidance as to posture is given but if you need to sit at any point, please feel able to do so. In the event of fire or other emergency Please remain seated until advised to evacuate. This is normally through the entrance door and the door by the disabled toilet. The assembly point is the Burnaby Monument – the large white obelisk in cathedral square. Material for this service is taken from Common Worship © The Archbishops’ Council, 2000 The Bible reading is from the New Revised Standard Version © National Council of the Churches of Christ in the United States of America Music is reproduced with CCLI Licence 420397 Order of Service Shortly before the service, The Very Reverend Matt Thompson, Dean of Birmingham, welcomes the congregation As the procession enters, please stand The Gathering The Greeting We remain standing Bishop Blessed be God, Father, Son and Holy Spirit.
    [Show full text]
  • The Cultural Role of Christianity in England, 1918-1931: an Anglican Perspective on State Education
    Loyola University Chicago Loyola eCommons Dissertations Theses and Dissertations 1995 The Cultural Role of Christianity in England, 1918-1931: An Anglican Perspective on State Education George Sochan Loyola University Chicago Follow this and additional works at: https://ecommons.luc.edu/luc_diss Part of the History Commons Recommended Citation Sochan, George, "The Cultural Role of Christianity in England, 1918-1931: An Anglican Perspective on State Education" (1995). Dissertations. 3521. https://ecommons.luc.edu/luc_diss/3521 This Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by the Theses and Dissertations at Loyola eCommons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Dissertations by an authorized administrator of Loyola eCommons. For more information, please contact [email protected]. This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 3.0 License. Copyright © 1995 George Sochan LOYOLA UNIVERSITY OF CHICAGO THE CULTURAL ROLE OF CHRISTIANITY IN ENGLAND, 1918-1931: AN ANGLICAN PERSPECTIVE ON STATE EDUCATION A DISSERTATION SUBMITTED TO THE FACULTY OF THE GRADUATE SCHOOL IN CANDIDACY FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY BY GEORGE SOCHAN CHICAGO, ILLINOIS JANUARY, 1995 Copyright by George Sochan Sochan, 1995 All rights reserved ii TABLE OF CONTENTS Chapter I. INTRODUCTION • ••.••••••••••.•••••••..•••..•••.••.•• 1 II. THE CALL FOR REFORM AND THE ANGLICAN RESPONSE ••.• 8 III. THE FISHER ACT •••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••• 35 IV. NO AGREEMENT: THE FAILURE OF THE AMENDING BILL •. 62 v. THE EDUCATIONAL LULL, 1924-1926 •••••••••••••••• 105 VI. THE HADOW REPORT ••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••• 135 VII. THREE FAILED BILLS, THEN THE DEPRESSION •••••••• 168 VIII. CONCLUSION ••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••• 218 BIBLIOGRAPHY •••••••••.••••••••••.••.•••••••••••••••••.• 228 VITA ...........................................•....... 231 iii CHAPTER I INTRODUCTION Since World War II, beginning especially in the 1960s, considerable work has been done on the history of the school system in England.
    [Show full text]
  • Bishop John Taylor RIP 1929-2016
    July/August 2016 Issue 06 News The Diocese of St Albans in Bedfordshire, Hertfordshire, Luton & Barnet Bishop John Taylor RIP 1929-2016 Bishop John Taylor was In 1993 I wrote a guide to Bishop of St Albans from 1980 Church communications and to 1995, preceeding Bishop Bishop John contributed Christopher Herbert. the foreword.” It said: “The His appointment was a return Church’s communication to the county of his childhood, should be accessible, not having attended Watford Boys obscure, and human, not lost Grammar School and having in technicality. In these media- found faith at the youth group minded days, the Church in St Luke’s Church, Watford. needs to follow the example of Ordained in 1956, his early its Lord in taking infinite pains parish experienced was to get the message heard.” followed by a long and Peter reflects: “Bishop John’s distinguished teaching career advice is as relevant today as it at Oak Hill. Following that was more than 20 years ago.” he had 8 very happy years Bishop Alan took Bishop in Chelmsford Diocese as John’s funeral service in a DDO, some of that time packed cathedral. The notes being combined with parish to the service say: “In spite ministry in Woodford Wells. of his apprehensions, John There followed by 5 years was Bishop of St Albans for as Archdeacon of West Ham 15 deeply happy years, and before his consecration. loved ministering to the clergy He was troubled at the thought of leaving parish life and people of the St Albans diocese, with Linda always for Archdiaconal responsibilities, but was obedient to by his side.
    [Show full text]
  • January 2015
    Our Church is eco-friendly Bishop Allan Scarfe on 2014 Annual Youth Conference “The earth is the Lord’S, and the from page 6….as part of our time there, as well as participate in the Youth Conference. We are fullness thereof: the world, and they grateful too for the care of the people at Thokoza that dwell therein”. and for the friendships we have made, especially net Psalm 24:1 dJanuaryio 2015 issue15 Vol 2 with our translators and drivers. We bring home a new song in our hearts quite literally, as a Seswati song you taught us has ANGLICAN CHURCH DIOCESE OF SWAZILAND NEWS LETTER been turned into an English song of praise by our talented musician. Some of us are pondering “We aspire to be a caring church that empowers people for potential vocations which we heard from God as we were with you. The Dioceses are working on ABUNDANT LIFE” Youth from Iowa and Brechin rendering a song during the 2014 annual youth confer- ence at St Michaels Chapel. Reflection from The Dean new projects and plans to deepen our work together and we are entrusting the future to God and to your I greet you in the name of our Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ. I write hands and hearts together now that the introductions have been made. Thank you, dear people of Swazi- to you just before we begin Lent and in one of the past important land. You are God‘s instruments of encouragement and spiritual renewal for us all. days we remembered a host of important Saints.
    [Show full text]
  • Bishop Gets All Steamed up to Celebrate Christmas
    E I D S The year’s The films that IN news in sparked a Hunger review in 2012 4,5 p11 THE SUNDAY, JANUARY 6, 2013 No: 6158 www.churchnewspaper.com PRICE £1.35 1,70j US$2.20 CHURCH OF ENGLAND THE ORIGINAL CHURCH NEWSPAPER ESTABLISHED IN 1828 NEWSPAPER Group to tackle Synod impasse By Amaris Cole in the Synod and across the coming months we will find the February and again in May to lation is ready for introduction to Church. means to make that a reality”. come to a decision on the new the Synod there will be a separate THE WORKING group on the “That is why we will begin the The Bishop of Coventry added package of proposals which it decision about the membership of new legislative proposals on process with conversations at var- that he was also happy to have intends to bring to the Synod in the Steering Committee. women bishops was announced ious levels outside the legislative been asked to be a member of the July. This new Steering Committee, just before Christmas, containing process. newly announced group, working The brief includes facilitating which will, as usual, contain only only two members who voted “Many people on different sides towards the mandate given by the discussions with a wide range of those who support the legislation, against the previous legislation in of the debate have stated that they Archbishops’ Council. people across the Church in Feb- will have the responsibility for the November. want to find a way forward – my The working group’s task is to ruary.
    [Show full text]
  • Theos Turbulentpriests Reform:Layout 1
    Turbulent Priests? The Archbishop of Canterbury in contemporary English politics Daniel Gover Theos Friends’ Programme Theos is a public theology think tank which seeks to influence public opinion about the role of faith and belief in society. We were launched in November 2006 with the support of the Archbishop of Canterbury, Dr Rowan Williams, and the Cardinal Archbishop of Westminster, Cardinal Cormac Murphy-O'Connor. We provide • high-quality research, reports and publications; • an events programme; • news, information and analysis to media companies and other opinion formers. We can only do this with your help! Theos Friends receive complimentary copies of all Theos publications, invitations to selected events and monthly email bulletins. If you would like to become a Friend, please detach or photocopy the form below, and send it with a cheque to Theos for £60. Thank you. Yes, I would like to help change public opinion! I enclose a cheque for £60 made payable to Theos. Name Address Postcode Email Tel Data Protection Theos will use your personal data to inform you of its activities. If you prefer not to receive this information please tick here By completing you are consenting to receiving communications by telephone and email. Theos will not pass on your details to any third party. Please return this form to: Theos | 77 Great Peter Street | London | SW1P 2EZ S: 97711: D: 36701: Turbulent Priests? what Theos is Theos is a public theology think tank which exists to undertake research and provide commentary on social and political arrangements. We aim to impact opinion around issues of faith and belief in The Archbishop of Canterbury society.
    [Show full text]
  • Cathedral Eucharist
    Cathedral Eucharist 2nd Sunday after Trinity 21st June, 2020 at 10.00am President: The Very Revd Dr Tim Stratford Preacher: The Rt Revd Keith Sinclair Deacon: Canon Jeremy Dussek WELCOME We welcome you to this beautiful church in the heart of the city for a celebration of the Holy Eucharist. This cathedral is the seat of the Bishop of Chester and the core of a Christian community that has worshipped here and worked together for over 1100 years. It is a place where the mission of the church is to proclaim God’s love is central, and your on line welcome presence here for worship helps to strengthen this vital act of witness. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Material from Common Worship included in this service is copyright © The Archbishop’s Council 2000 Scripture quotations are from New Revised Standard Version Bible: Anglicized Edition, copyright © 1989, 1995 National Council of the Churches of Christ in the United States of America. Used by permission. All rights reserved. CCLI Licence Number: 177097 2 THE GATHERING HYMN 1 Take up thy cross, the Saviour said, if thou wouldst my disciple be; deny thyself, the world forsake, and humbly follow after me. 2 Take up thy cross-let not its weight fill thy weak spirit with alarm: his strength shall bear thy spirit up, and brace thy heart, and nerve thine arm. 3 Take up thy cross, nor heed the shame, nor let thy foolish pride rebel: thy Lord for thee the Cross endured, to save thy soul from death and hell. 4 Take up thy cross then in his strength, and calmly every danger brave; 'twill guide thee to a better home, and lead to victory o'er the grave.
    [Show full text]
  • The Reverend John Michael Blakeley
    The Licensing of The Reverend John Michael Blakeley by the Bishop of Southwell and Nottingham The Right Reverend Paul Williams and the Installation by the Archdeacon of Nottingham The Venerable Phil Williams in the presence of The Bishop of Beverley The Right Reverend Glyn Webster Photo credit Jordan Dawson as Priest-in-Charge of St Stephen’s with St Matthias, Sneinton th on Tuesday 15 June 2021 at 7.30pm About this service This is a special service of celebration that marks the beginning of a new phase of ministry both for John and for the people of this community. Although a more limited gathering, necessitated by the requirement to be Covid-19 safe, this service gives the community an opportunity to welcome the priest to their new role, and allows both priest and people to commit themselves to the ministry ahead, praying for God’s leading in it. We are immensely grateful to many who, whilst not able to form part of this evening’s formal welcome, are upholding John and the parish in prayer at this time. The ministry to which John is being appointed is to the local parish and the wider community. The role of the Anglican parish priest is to care for the whole community and to nurture the faithful. They work with all those in the local community, whether they are people of faith or not. Therefore, within this service, the welcome is made by both church and representatives of the wider community. In this service, John is presented to the Bishop and then presented to the community by the Bishop.
    [Show full text]
  • Why Vote? 2013
    FUTURE_FIRST_Issue 38 April 2015_Newsletter_05 12/03/2015 11:41 Page 1 P2 |FUTURE FIRST |04 15 P3 |FUTURE FIRST |04 15 P4 |FUTURE FIRST |04 15 The first chart shows the current age of Bishops and Archdeacons, A YouGov survey Very little firm evangelism. Mark Avery notes that people Middle-class Christians. Christians viewing pornography. usually don’t read your well-developed write up. Archdeacons tending to be younger than Bishops. The reason why so SNOWFLAKES recently found that 62% of churchgoers are middle- information on this is available, but a small sample Using Numbers COHABITEES many Bishops and Archdeacons have under 10 years of experience is So they don’t listen to your assumptions, but they Bishops and Archdeacons class. Unfortunately the phrase “middle-class” is undertaken by Christianity magazine showed that: because they were appointed when older rather than younger, as the Chris Maynard, Transforming Information make their own assumptions about your At the start of 2015, the Church of England was led by 114 Bishops In a worldwide survey of 64,000 notoriously difficult to define, so different people While the number of people cohabiting was second chart shows. Appointments to senior leadership take in many Happiness. assumptions. and 132 Archdeacons, an increase of 9 posts over 2012, since in the people (1,000 in each of 64 countries), Gallup have different perceptions about it. The web ascertained and published through the 1991 factors, but one of them is length of existing prior experience. • 30% of Christian leaders accessed porn more interim some new Suffragan Bishop and Archidiaconal posts had been found 70% of the people in the world “Happy” “answers” feature, however, says 71% of the British There is sometimes a resistance to using 5) “Your numbers may not tell the whole story.” Population Census, the long-term stability of than once a month created.
    [Show full text]
  • Welcome-To-The-Diocese-Of-York.Pdf
    Welcome to the Diocese of York The Diocese of York is a family of 607 churches and 127 schools in 470 parishes, stretching from the Humber to the Tees and the A1 to the coast. We hope this pack will give you a good idea of what it might be like to live and work in the Diocese of York. Contents: Vision and mission Living in the Diocese Housing and money Ministry together Lifelong learning Spiritual sustenance York Minster Central support Young people Who’s who “We will grow to become in every respect the mature body of him who is the head, that is, Christ.” Ephesians 4:14 & 15 Vision and mission We have a vision of Generous Churches Making and Nurturing Disciples. “We will grow to become in every respect the mature body of him who is the head, that is, Christ. From him the whole body, joined and held together by every supporting ligament, grows and builds itself up in love, as each part does its work.” Ephesians 4:14 & 15 As a Diocese, we want to see our churches making disciples of all ages. We want to see mutual resourcing to build up the Body of Christ, to grow in five areas: • Christ-likeness Becoming like Christ is the fundamental call of Christian discipleship. It is not always easy to assess, but we often recognise the flavour of a life becoming more godly. • Commitment Commitment itself has several features, including: commitment to God, to seeking God’s kingdom, to Christ’s body the Church. • Partnership Working with other churches, locally and globally, with schools, community groups, people, organisations for the common good, peace, justice and a healthy environment.
    [Show full text]
  • Service Rota 20-10
    THE PARISH OF ST PETER & ST LEONARD, HORBURY, with ST JOHN, HORBURY BRIDGE Registered Charity No. 1147711 SERVICE ROTA: OCTOBER 2020 Day/Date Observance Service Time Place Notes/Intention Pr Thu 1 St Therese of the Child Jesus, Said Mass 12 noon St Peter’s The Bishop of Leeds CJ V, Dr Fri 2 The Holy Guardian Angels Said Mass 9.30 a.m. St John’s The sick CJ Sat 3 Feria Said Mass (EF) 9.00 a.m. St Peter’s Leeds School of Ministry CJ 27TH SUNDAY IN Said Mass 5.00 p.m. St Peter’s Those who live in Horbury CJ Sun 4 ORDINARY TIME Sung Mass 9.00 a.m. St John’s Those who live in Horbury Bridge CJ Sung Mass 10.30 a.m. St Peter’s The growth of the faith in the parish CJ E Prayer & B 5.00 p.m. St Peter’s CJ Mon 5 Feria No services Tue 6 Feria Said Mass 9.00 a.m. St Peter’s Our cleaners CJ Wed 7 Our Lady of the Rosary Said Mass 7.00 p.m. St Peter’s Our prayer life CJ Thu 8 Feria Said Mass 12 noon St Peter’s The Bishop of Wakefield CJ Fri 9 Feria Said Mass 9.30 a.m. St John’s Royal British Legion CJ Sat 10 Feria Said Mass (EF) 9.00 a.m. St Peter’s Shrine of OLW CJ 28TH SUNDAY IN Said Mass 5.00 p.m. St Peter’s Those who live in Horbury CJ Sun 11 ORDINARY TIME Sung Mass 9.00 a.m.
    [Show full text]
  • A Celebration of Ministry with the Enthronement of the Rt Revd Mark Tanner As the 41St Bishop of Chester
    A Celebration of Ministry with the Enthronement of The Rt Revd Mark Tanner as the 41st Bishop of Chester Saturday 26th June at 2.00pm 1 Welcome from Tim Stratford, Dean of Chester A very warm welcome to Chester Cathedral on this significant day in the life of the Church of God and Diocese of Chester. It seems to have taken a long time coming. There has been a long process of discernment and selection which led up to the announcement that Bishop Mark Tanner, then Bishop of Berwick, was to be the forty-first and next Bishop of Chester. This included consultations in communities across the diocese and meetings of the Crown Nominations Commission in which the diocese was represented. Following an announcement made by 10 Downing Street, the College of Canons of this Cathedral met and unanimously elected him. Bishop Mark was confirmed as the Bishop of Chester during online proceedings presided over by the Archbishop of York on Wednesday 15th July last year. At the time we were still in the midst of the first coronavirus lockdown. Archbishop Stephen’s own confirmation had only been completed the week before, and he was still unable to move to York from Chelmsford Diocese. During these proceedings Archbishop Stephen laid a charge on Bishop Mark which is included in these pages. Bishop Mark picked up the reins here in Chester following an innovative “Crozier Service” on 20th September that was created to mark the beginning of his ministry in these unusual times. He was unable formally to occupy the Bishop’s Seat, known as the Cathedra, in the Cathedral Quire until paying homage to Her Majesty the Queen.
    [Show full text]