The Programming of Women Composers: Perceptions And
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
THE PROGRAMMING OF WOMEN COMPOSERS: PERCEPTIONS AND PRACTICES OF OKLAHOMA SECONDARY SCHOOL BAND DIRECTORS A THESIS SUBMITTED TO THE GRADUATE FACULTY in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of MASTER OF MUSIC EDUCATION JUNE 2020 By STEVEN RANDALL COLLINS Norman, Oklahoma 2020 THE PROGRAMMING OF WOMEN COMPOSERS: PERCEPTIONS AND PRACTICES OF OKLAHOMA SECONDARY SCHOOL BAND DIRECTORS A THESIS APPROVED FOR THE SCHOOL OF MUSIC BY THE COMMITTEE CONSISTING OF Dr. Christopher Baumgartner, Chair Dr. Melissa Baughman Dr. Brian Wolfe © Copyright by STEVEN RANDALL COLLINS 2020 All Rights Reserved. Acknowledgements I would like to thank all of my previous music professors for their life-long impact on how I learn, teach, and create music. Specifically, thank you to Dr. Michael Raiber for guiding me through my undergraduate studies and giving me the confidence and tools to pursue my graduate degree. You have been a beacon of student-centric teaching that has molded me into a better version of myself. Thank you to Dr. William Wakefield, Dr. Steven Curtis, Mr. Josh Phelps, and Dr. Irvin Wagner for refining my ears, mind, and technique throughout my time at the University of Oklahoma. I would also like to thank Dr. Christopher Baumgartner for mentoring me through my graduate program and spending invaluable time to make me a more measured, thoughtful researcher. I could not have asked for a better advisor during my graduate studies. Thank you to all of my friends and family for their unconditional support and encouragement. Specifically, I would like to thank Brent and Marilyn Courtney for providing me lodging and company near the university during the summer months. I would not have been able to finish this degree without your gestures of kindness. Thank you to Brandon, my twin, for being the study partner I always needed. Finally, thank you to Caitlin, for everything you are and everything you will be. iv Table of Contents List of Tables .............................................................................................................. viii Abstract ........................................................................................................................... x Chapter 1: Introduction ................................................................................................... 1 History of Women Composers ................................................................................ 1 Male-Dominated Paradigm of Band ................................................................... 2 Wind Band Repertoire ........................................................................................ 4 Programming Wind Band Music ............................................................................ 6 Higher Education Inclusion ................................................................................ 7 Secondary Level Programming ........................................................................... 8 Need for the Study .................................................................................................. 9 Purpose of the Study ............................................................................................. 10 Research Questions ............................................................................................... 10 Definitions ............................................................................................................. 11 Chapter 2: Review of Literature ................................................................................... 12 Historical Context of Women’s Roles in Western Music ..................................... 12 Women’s Roles in Wind Music ............................................................................ 15 Women in American Music .............................................................................. 15 Women as Wind Performers ............................................................................. 17 Women as Wind Band Composers ................................................................... 18 Composer Diversity Databases ..................................................................... 19 Women Band Directors ..................................................................................... 20 Wind Band Programming ...................................................................................... 24 v Quality in Music ............................................................................................... 28 Prescribed Music Lists ...................................................................................... 30 Post-secondary Wind Band Programming ........................................................ 31 Secondary Wind Band Programming Considerations ....................................... 32 Secondary Wind Band Programming Practices ................................................ 35 Gender-Based Wind Band Programming Research ....................................... 35 Summary ............................................................................................................... 37 Chapter 3: Methodology ............................................................................................... 39 Research Design .................................................................................................... 39 Participant Selection ......................................................................................... 40 Survey Instrument ................................................................................................. 40 Section One: Demographics .................................................................................. 41 Section Two: Knowledge, Attitudes, and Programming of Women Composers ................................................................................................ 45 Pilot Testing .......................................................................................................... 50 Data Collection ..................................................................................................... 51 Data Analysis ........................................................................................................ 52 Chapter 4: Results ......................................................................................................... 53 Descriptive Analysis ............................................................................................. 53 Participant Demographics ................................................................................. 53 Programming Perceptions and Considerations of Women Composers ............ 57 Programming Practices of Works by Women Composers ............................... 65 Interactions Between Variables ............................................................................ 68 vi Gender ............................................................................................................... 68 Race/Ethnicity ................................................................................................... 74 Experience ......................................................................................................... 75 OSSAA District Classification ......................................................................... 76 OSSAA Contest Participation ........................................................................... 76 Chapter 5: Discussion ................................................................................................... 79 Summary of Results .............................................................................................. 79 Knowledge of Wind Band Literature by Women Composers .......................... 80 Frequency of Programming Women Composers .............................................. 83 Programming of Specific Wind Band Literature Composed by Women ......... 85 Perceptions and Attitudes Toward Women Composers ................................... 87 Demographic Findings ...................................................................................... 90 Limitations ............................................................................................................ 91 Suggestions for Future Research .......................................................................... 94 Conclusion ............................................................................................................ 96 References ..................................................................................................................... 98 Appendix A: Institution Review Board Documentation ............................................. 111 Appendix B: Study Pilot, Invitation, and Follow-up Messages .................................. 112 Appendix C: Survey Instrument ................................................................................. 116 Section One: Demographics ............................................................................... 118 Section Two: Knowledge, Attitudes, and Programming of Women Composers ............................................................................................. 123 vii List of Tables Table 4.1 Respondents’ Age, Gender, and Race/Ethnicity ............................................ 54 Table 4.2 Respondents’ Years of Experience and Credentials ..................................... 55 Table 4.3 Respondents’ Job Title, Grade Levels Taught, and School Demographics ..........................................................................................