DOCSLIB.ORG

Fair Trade, CRS, and the NY Times

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Fair Trade, CRS, and the NY Times Fair Trade, CRS, and the NY Times Typically, Thanksgiving is considered a slow news day. Stories of which turkey the President will pardon and which big-box parking lots will be occupied by bargain-hungry shoppers seem to dominate the media reports. But this Thanksgiving was different for many in the Fair Trade movement. The New York Times gave front page (albeit in the business section) attention to the recent controversies in the Fair Trade movement. One colleague of mine referred to the story–which relates reactions to the decision by Fair Trade USA to leave the global Fairtrade certification system–as airing the movement’s dirty laundry. But I’m glad to see attention being given to the issues “brewing.” There is a lot at stake for the people that Fair Trade serves. The words of Merling Preza, general manager of PRODECOOP, in a recent interview with CRS, keep popping into my mind. She noted that for small-scale farmers, new certification standards are “…just a theory.” What works and what doesn’t, who wins and who loses by changing the standards will be tested in the lives of farmers struggling to overcome poverty. For companies, market share may be lost or gained. For consumers, there may be confusion or consternation. But for farmers the real impacts will be felt in their wallets, in their democratic organizations, and in their communities. Then again, there may also be positive changes in the lives of and opportunities for landless workers and unorganized farmers, groups historically left out of the coffee and cocoa certification systems. Clearly the issues are complex, and emotions are running high. As we debate and deliberate, a top priority needs to be accuracy (not to mention civility). Let me take this opportunity to clarify the NY Times quote: ” The logo overload will include a redesigned Fair Trade USA seal; a Fairtrade International seal….; and labels from smaller programs, like one run by Catholic Relief Services.” The CRS Fair Trade logo (seen to the right) is actually just that, a “logo” not a label. We use it as part of our “branding” or marketing efforts: to identify resources CRS has created (like this website), partners we have united with, conferences we sponsor, etc. Unlike a certification process of commodity value chains, CRS doesn’t conduct audits, inspections, or other activities to verify that standards are being made from “crop to cup.” Instead, we recognize as partners those businesses and organizations that go through an independent, third-party process to prove that they are fully- committed to Fair Trade principles and practices. At the moment, the groups that we look to for that verification are Fair Trade Federation and Fair Trade USA. For example, when a company such as SERRV applies for, receives, and maintains status in the Fair Trade Federation, CRS considers SERRV eligible to be a CRS partner. Or when a coffee company like Nectar of Life, purchases 100% of its coffee from farmer cooperatives certified Fair Trade, they are eligible to be in the CRS Fair Trade network. Both our partners and CRS itself uses the logo to identify our relationship. We also use the logo to celebrate accomplishments like the awarding of Fair Trade Fund grants, which are made possible from partner contributions based on Catholic-affiliated purchases. The logo is not a certification label, but it is an endorsement: the companies who use it are businesses we believe in. Knowing what and who to believe in, especially for a faith-based organization, is something we take very seriously at CRS. We thank the New York Times for its coverage, and we welcome any questions for further clarification from our readers. .
Load more

Recommended publications
  • The Future of Fair Trade Coffee: Dilemmas Facing Latin America's Small-Scale Producers Author(S): Douglas L
    Oxfam GB The Future of Fair Trade Coffee: Dilemmas Facing Latin America's Small-Scale Producers Author(s): Douglas L. Murray, Laura T. Raynolds and Peter L. Taylor Source: Development in Practice, Vol. 16, No. 2 (Apr., 2006), pp. 179-192 Published by: Taylor & Francis, Ltd. on behalf of Oxfam GB Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/4029878 . Accessed: 13/12/2013 07:44 Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at . http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp . JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected]. Taylor & Francis, Ltd. and Oxfam GB are collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Development in Practice. http://www.jstor.org This content downloaded from 129.82.28.124 on Fri, 13 Dec 2013 07:44:01 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions Development in Practice, Volume16, Number2, April 2006 lRTaylorE&FranciSsGroup The future of Fair Trade coffee: dilemmas facing Latin America's small-scale producers Douglas L. Murray, Laura T. Raynolds, and Peter L. Taylor Fair Tradehas become a dynamic and successful dimensionof an emerging counter-tendency to the neo-liberal globalisation regime. This study explores some of the dilemmasfacing the Fair Trade movementas it seeks to broaden and deepen its impact among the rural poor of Latin America's coffee sector.
    [Show full text]
  • What Is Fair Trade?
    What is Fair Trade? . A system of exchange that honors producers, communities, consumers and the environment. A model for the global economy rooted in people-to-people connections, justice and sustainability. A commitment to building long-term relationships between producers and consumers. A way of life! Fair Trade - Criteria . Paying a fair wage . Giving employees opportunities for advancement . Providing equal employment opportunities for all people, particularly the most disadvantaged . Engaging in environmentally sustainable practices Fair Trade - Criteria . Being open to public accountability . Building sustainable long-term trade relationships . Providing healthy and safe working conditions . Providing financial and technical assistance to producers whenever possible What does the Fair Trade label look like? What does the Fair Trade label mean? Fair Price Democratically organized groups receive a minimum floor price and an additional premium for certified organic agricultural products. Farmer organizations are also eligible for pre-harvest credit. Artisan groups and cooperatives receive a fair living wage for the time it takes to make a product. What does the Fair Trade label mean? Fair Labor Conditions Workers on fair trade farms and other environments enjoy freedom of association, safe working conditions, and living wages. Forced child labor is strictly prohibited. What does the Fair Trade label mean? Direct trade Importers purchase from Fair Trade producer groups as directly as possible, eliminating unnecessary middlepersons and empowering farmers and others to develop the business capacity needed to compete in the global marketplace. What does the Fair Trade label mean? Democratic and transparent organizations Workers decide democratically how to invest Fair Trade revenues. What does the Fair Trade label mean? Environmental Sustainability Harmful agrochemicals and GMOs are strictly prohibited in favor of environmentally sustainable farming methods that protect farmers’ health and preserve valuable ecosystems for future generations.
    [Show full text]
  • American University a Sip in the Right Direction: The
    AMERICAN UNIVERSITY A SIP IN THE RIGHT DIRECTION: THE DEVELOPMENT OF FAIR TRADE COFFEE AN HONORS CAPSTONE SUBMITTED TO THE AMERICAN UNIVERSITY HONORS PROGRAM GENERAL UNIVERSITY HONORS BY ALLISON DOOLITTLE WASHINGTON, D.C. APRIL 2009 Copyright © 2009 by Allison Doolittle All rights reserved ii Coffee is more than just a drink. It is about politics, survival, the Earth and the lives of indigenous peoples. Rigoberta Menchu iii CONTENTS ABSTRACT . vi Chapter Page 1. INTRODUCTION . 1 Goals of the Research Background on Fair Trade Coffee 2. LITERATURE REVIEW . 4 The Sociology of Social Movements and Resource Mobilization Fair Trade as a Social Movement Traditional Studies and the Failure to Combine Commodity Chain Analysis with Social Movement Analysis to Study Fair Trade 3. NONGOVERNMENTAL ORGANIZATIONS IN THE DEVELOPMENT OF FAIR TRADE . 9 Alternative Trade for Development Alternative Trade for Solidarity Horizontal and Vertical Institution-building within the Movement Roles of Nongovernmental Organizations in Fair Trade Today 4. STRATEGIC COMMUNICATIONS TO TRANSFORM PUBLICS INTO SYMPATHIZERS . 20 Initial Use of Labels and Narratives to Tell the Fair Trade Story The Silent Salesman: Coffee Packaging that Compels Consumers Fair Trade Advertising, Events and Public Relations Fair Trade and Web 2.0: Dialogue in the Social Media Sphere Internet Use by Coffee Cooperatives to Reach Consumers iv 5. DRINKING COFFEE WITH THE ENEMY: CORPORATE INVOLVEMENT IN FAIR TRADE COFFEE . 33 Market-Driven Corporations: Friend or Foe? Fair Trade as a Corporate Strategy for Appeasing Activists and Building Credibility Fair Trade as a Strategy to Reach Conscious Consumers Internal Debates on Mainstreaming Fair Trade Coffee 6. CONCLUSIONS .
    [Show full text]
  • Co-Operatives and Fair-Trade
    KATHOLIEKE UNIVERSITEIT LEUVEN Co-operatives and Fair-Trade Background paper commissioned by the Committee for the Promotion and Advancement of Cooperatives (COPAC) for the COPAC Open Forum on Fair Trade and Cooperatives, Berlin (Germany) Patrick Develtere Ignace Pollet February 2005 Higher Institute of Labour HIVA ‐ Higher Institute for Labour Studies Parkstraat 47 3000 Leuven Belgium tel. +32 (0) 16 32 33 33 fax. + 32 (0) 16 32 33 44 www.hiva.be COPAC ‐ Committee for the Promotion and Advancement of Co‐operatives 15, route des Morillons 1218 Geneva Switzerland tel. +41 (0) 22 929 8825 fax. +41 (0) 22 798 4122 www.copacgva.org iii TABLE OF CONTENTS Introduction 1 What is fair-trade? What is co-operative trade? What do both have in common? 2 1. Fair-trade: definition and criteria 2 2. Roots and related concepts 6 3. Actual significance of fair-trade 8 4. Fair-trade and co-operative trade 9 4.1 Where do co-operatives enter the scene? 9 4.2 Defining co-operatives 10 4.3 Comparing co-operative and fair-trade movement: the differences 11 4.4 Comparing the co-operative and fair-trade movement: communalities 13 2. Involvement of co-operatives in practice 14 2.1 In the South: NGOs and producers co-operatives 15 2.2 Co-operatives involved with fair-trade in the North 16 3. Co-operatives and Fair-trade: a fair deal? 19 3.1 Co-operatives for more fair-trade? 19 3.2 Fair-trade for better co-operatives? 20 4. What happens next? Ideas for policy 22 Bibliographical references 25 1 INTRODUCTION This paper is meant to provide a first insight into an apparently new range of activities of the co-operative movement: fair-trade activities.
    [Show full text]
  • Wfto Annual Report 2019
    WFTO ANNUAL REPORT 2019 ANNUAL REPORT 2019 1 WFTO ANNUAL REPORT 2019 Table of Contents Message from the President 2 Message from the Chief Executive 4 Global Community of Fair Trade Enterprises 7 WFTO Projects in 2019 9 WFTO Supporting Market Access 12 15th International Fair Trade Summit in Lima 14 Communications, Campaigns and Advocacy 17 Highlights from WFTO Regions 23 Finances 27 WFTO Team 32 Partners 33 Cover photo: Global Mamas/Nicholas Ruffalo 1 WFTO ANNUAL REPORT 2019 Photo: Sasha Fair Trade A Message from the President would summarise 2019 as a year of great and business. If consumers wanted to Ichange at the WFTO. We celebrated spend to support ethical or fair products, our 30th anniversary in Lima at our the products of WFTO members would be International Fair Trade Summit, where we among the few options they had. Through came together as a movement to update our the last decade or so, this has changed principles of Fair Trade to strengthen the radically. We now face a market with a commitment on tackling climate change and broad range of ethical claims from a growing protecting our planet. We also saw the end list of brands, certifiers and initiatives – of the tenure of some of the giants of our some credible, some less so. In this growing movement, namely our former president marketplace of ethical claims, the market Rudi Dalvai, and board members Bob Chase, has shifted and we have needed to evolve Geoff White and Johny Joseph. All remain with it. closely connected to us but a new era began, with new board members and with me Gone are the days where most WFTO stepping into the huge shoes of president.
    [Show full text]
  • Socially Conscious Consumer Trends
    International Markets Bureau MARKET ANALYSIS REPORT | APRIL 2012 Socially Conscious Consumer Trends Fair Trade Source: Fairtrade Canada. Source: Fairtrade Canada. Socially Conscious Consumer Trends Fair Trade EXECUTIVE SUMMARY INSIDE THIS ISSUE Grocery shoppers base their buying decisions on their personal Executive Summary 2 perceptions of value. Value considers the balance between quality and price, and how a product fits into a consumer’s culture, lifestyle and Socially Conscious Consumers 3 social consciousness. Global public opinion surveys have identified the growing influence of personal values in purchase behaviour. The most Introduction to Fair Trade 4 common, relative to the food and beverage industry, include animal welfare, Fair Trade, provenance, vegetarianism, sustainable sourcing Public Opinion 5 and manufacturing, and packaging. The series “Socially Conscious Consumer Trends,” of which this report is a part, examines each of Country Profiles 7 these issues within the global food market to assist Canadian food and Domestic Perspective 10 beverage producers and processors in positioning their products within, and as alternatives to, these influences. Growing Pains 11 Fair Trade is described as a social movement representing alternatives In The Marketplace 13 to conventional trade models that operate within a framework of international development, social justice, environmental sustainability Conclusions 16 and equitable economic returns. In 2010, global retail sales increased 27% over 2009 to reach US$5.8 billion (Fairtrade International, 2011) A Fair Trade Glossary 16 and involved over 900 producer organizations in more than 63 countries to benefit over one million farmers and workers (Fairtrade References 18 International, 2011). With a history stretching back nearly 75 years, the principles of Fair Trade are now influencing trade negotiations, corporate social responsibility (CSR) policies, new product development, and retail channels.
    [Show full text]
  • SIGNS of FAIR TRADE Product Certification Fair Trade Certified
    SIGNS OF FAIR TRADE Product certification Fair Trade Certified: This is the most common label currently used in the USA, administered by Fair Trade USA (Oakland, CA). The work of certification is done by Scientific Certification Systems, a close neighbor in the Bay Area. This FTC label dates from 2012, superseding the black-and-white ‘bucket boy’ logo introduced in 1998 by Transfair USA, the original US Fair Trade labeling body set up by the Institute for Agriculture and Trade Policy in Minneapolis. In December 2011, Transfair USA left the international Fair Trade network and, somewhat controversially, adopted the name Fair Trade USA. Click here for information on Fair Trade USA’s Multiple-Ingredients Product Policy. Fairtrade: The International Fairtrade Mark is the principal global sign of Fair Trade product certification, owned by Fairtrade International, based in Bonn, Germany. The Mark came into use in 2002 when all national Fair Trade labeling organizations bar one adopted it, replacing their own logos. Canada was among them but not the USA. The work of certification is done by FLOCERT, also located in Bonn. With Fair Trade USA’s departure from the international system, Fairtrade International was free to establish the International Fairtrade Mark in the USA. In 2013, Fairtrade America was set up in Washington, DC as the US member of Fairtrade International to promote the scheme and award the Mark. Fair for Life: This alternative Fair Trade label was initially promoted by the Institute for Marketecology, Switzerland, in 2007. Founded in 1989, IMO has, since 2014, been part of the international ECOCERT group, set up in France in 1991.
    [Show full text]
  • Fair and Ethical Trade: an Explanation1 ______
    Fair and Ethical Trade: An Explanation1 ________________________________________________________ It appears natural that the concern for the distribution of benefits and costs from economic activity is as old as the economy itself. However, during the restructuring of the international system in the aftermath of the Second World War, considerable attention was paid to the distributional issues arising from what was, by then, a significantly internationalized economic system. While governments came together to provide for international institutions which would better help manage this situation – with the development of the International Monetary Fund (IMF), International Bank for Reconstruction and Development (IBIRD)2 and the World Trade Organization (WTO) – various groups in civil society became specifically concerned with the outcomes of international trade. Specifically, the Alternative Trade movement was a loose and often unconnected group of organizations that for various reasons, entered functions of international trade with the specific commitment to assist people normally marginalized from its benefits. In some cases organizations were faith-based and secular international relief agencies (e.g. Mennonite Central Committee, SERRV and Oxfam) that helped those who had seen their livelihoods impacted by the war. In others instances, Alternative Trade Organisations in the North began importing and retailing goods (primarily handcrafts and then increasingly food items) produced by small and marginalized groups in the South as a means to facilitate community development (Kocken 2003). Irrespective of these differences, these grass roots social movements established the important idea that consumers have a responsibility not just towards their own utility, but also for the ways in which their choices impact on wider stakeholders such as producers and even the environment.
    [Show full text]
  • What Is Fair Trade?
    1 What What is isFair Fair Trade? Trade? www.FTRN.org Fair Trade is a lot of things: a social justice movement, an alternative business model, a system of global commerce, a tool for international development, a faith-based activity. It means different things to different people. There is no single, regulatory, authoritative body. So, individuals need to explore various models and concepts. Fair Trade’s many definitions do ―Every business transaction always center is a challenge to see that both parties come out fairly.‖ around the exchange of – Adam Smith, 1759 goods based Credit: GlobalExchange Credit: Swaziland artisan at work on on principles of economic and social justice. the loom A Useful Definition of Fair Trade In 1998, four European organizations created a widely accepted definition of Fair Trade. Fairtrade Labeling Organizations (now Fairtrade Interna- tional, FI), International Fair Trade Association (now World Fair Trade Organization, WFTO), the Network of European Worldshops (NEWS!) and the European Fair Trade Association (EFTA) created a workgroup known as FINE, an acronym of their names, and defined Fair Trade as: ―a trading partnership, based on dialogue, transparency, and respect, that seeks greater equity in international trade. It contributes to sustainable development by offering better trading conditions to, and securing the rights of, disadvantaged producers and workers—especially in the South.‖ (FINE, 1998) Identifying Fair Trade With many different definitions, and no single, authoritative body, Fair Trade takes many forms in the U.S. and around the world. Different organizations and individuals use different criteria for determining what is, and isn’t, Fair Trade.
    [Show full text]
  • Fair Trade Basics Myth-Busters & Faqs
    Fair Trade Basics Myth-busters & FAQs Fair Trade Campaigns is a powerful grassroots movement mobilizing thousands of conscious consumers and Fair Trade advocates at schools, on campuses and in communities across the United States. We are part of a global effort to normalize Fair Trade as an institutional practice and consumer preference across 24 countries and on six continents. Fair Trade Myths Courtesy of the Fair Trade Federation (click to open) Myth: Fair Trade is about paying developed world wages in the developing world. Reality: Wages are designed to provide fair compensation based on the true cost of production, and are not based on North American wage standards. Fair wages are determined by a number of factors, including: • The amount of time, skill, and effort involved in production • Minimum and living wages where products are made • The purchasing power in a community or area • Other costs of living in the local context Myth: Fair Trade siphons off American jobs to other countries. Reality: Fair Trade seeks to improve the lives of the poorest of the poor who frequently lack alternative sources of income. Most Fair Trade craft products stem from cultures and traditions which are not represented in North American production. Most Fair Trade food products do not have North American-based alternatives. Also, as North American Fair Trade organizations grow as successful small businesses, they employ more and more individuals in their communities. Myth: Fair Trade is anti-globalization. Reality: International exchange lies at the heart of Fair Trade. Fair Trade organizations seek to maximize the positive elements of globalization that connect people, communities, and cultures through products and ideas.
    [Show full text]
  • Transfair USA, Annual Report 2009 About Us
    Making History TransFair USA, Annual Report 2009 About Us TransFair USA is a nonprofit, mission-driven organization that tackles social and environmental sustainability with an innovative, entrepreneurial approach. We are the leading independent, third-party certifier of Fair Trade products in the United States, and the only U.S. member of Fairtrade Labelling Organizations International (FLO). We license companies to display the Fair Trade Certified™ label on products that meet our strict international standards. These standards foster increased social and economic stability, lead- ing to stronger communities and better stewardship of the planet. Our goal is to dramatically improve the livelihoods of farmers, workers and their families around the world. Our Mission TransFair USA enables sustainable development and community empowerment by cultivating a more equitable global trade model that benefits farmers, workers, consumers, industry and the earth. We achieve this mission by certifying and promoting Fair Trade products. Letter from the President & CEO Contents Dear Friends, 04 2009 Accomplishments In 2009, the Fair Trade movement In 2009, we certified over 100 million As we move forward, we have renewed ushered in a new era. Our eleventh year pounds of coffee for the first time, more hope for economic recovery and of certifying Fair Trade products saw than was certified in our first seven continued growth in sales of Fair 06 Fair Trade Certified Apparel social consciousness emerge as a top years of business combined. We saw Trade products. This next phase of priority for consumers, and the numbers opportunities for farm workers broaden Fair Trade is just beginning, and the 08 Social Sustainability reflected it.
    [Show full text]
  • Fair Trade Purchasing Guide for College and University Food Service Purchasers
    2 Thank you for picking up the Fair Trade Purchasing Guide for College and University Food Service Purchasers. This Guide is here to give you certification information, sample contract language, and other quick tools that will make fair trade purchasing a snap. The Guide is organized to be a fast read – the first two pages, in boxes, should give you all the basics you’ll need. If you want more information about a certain subject you find there, just click the link to jump further down in the document. Also, feel free to get in touch with Responsible Purchasing Network (www.responsiblepurchasing.org) or Fair Trade Campaigns (www.fairtradeuniversities.org) to find any more resources you need. Thanks for your interest in fair trade purchasing! Fair Trade Campaigns houses the Fair Trade Colleges & Universities Campaign, which can help your campus achieve fair trade status. Find the Campaign at www.FairTradeUniversities.org. This Guide was developed by the Responsible Purchasing Network on behalf of Fair Trade Campaigns, July 2013. Find more purchasing guides at www.ResponsiblePurchasing.org. 3 FAIR TRADE PURCHASING GUIDE FOR COLLEGES AND UNIVERSITIES HIGHLIGHTS “Fair trade” represents an innovative, market-based strategy that works to ensure fair labor practices and environmental sustainability in commodity and craft production abroad. Fair trade products, available through many vendors of office supplies, food and food services, are often easily identified by their certification labels. WHY BUY FAIR TRADE? (Page 5) The principles of fair trade include guarantees of fair wages, safe working conditions, sustainable soil and water use practices, and funds for community development.
    [Show full text]