Pennsylvania Magazine of HISTORY and BIOGRAPHY VOLUME CXXXII
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
THE Pennsylvania Magazine OF HISTORY AND BIOGRAPHY VOLUME CXXXII 1300 LOCUST STREET, PHILADELPHIA, PA 19107 2008 CONTENTS ARTICLES Page A Tale of Two Deists: John Fitch, Elihu Palmer, and the Boundary of Tolerable Religious Expression in Early National Philadelphia Eric Schlereth 5 Cornelia Bryce Pinchot and the Struggle for Protective Labor Legislation in Pennsylvania Nancy R. Miller 33 “Seditious Libel” on Trial, Political Dissent on the Record: An Account of the Trial of Thomas Cooper as Campaign Literature Forrest K. Lehman 117 From Anglophile to Nationalist: Robert Walsh’s An Appeal from the Judgments of Great Britain Joseph Eaton 141 The “Problem” of the Black Middle Class: Morris Milgram’s Concord Park and Residential Integration in Philadelphia’s Postwar Suburbs W. Benjamin Pigott 173 “Alive to the Cry of Distress”: Joseph and Jane Sill and Poor Relief in Antebellum Philadelphia Trisha Posey 215 Robert Hare: Politics, Science, and Spiritualism in the Early Republic Timothy W. Kneeland 245 Introduction Michael J. Birkner and Randall M. Miller 307 A Tale of Two Cities: Pittsburgh, Philadelphia, and the Elusive Quest for a New Deal Majority in the Keystone State Kenneth J. Heineman 311 Pennsylvania 1941: War, Race, Biography, and History David Goodman 341 Urban Politics and the Vision of a Modern City: Philadelphia and Lancaster after World War II John F. Bauman and David Schuyler 377 Pennsylvania and the Presidency: A Twain That Seldom Meets G. Terry Madonna and Michael Young 403 The Pennsylvania Prince: Political Wisdom from Benjamin Franklin to Arlen Specter Matthew Pinsker 417 NOTES AND DOCUMENTS Tales from the Chew Family Papers: The Charity Castle Story Phillip R. Seitz 65 Newly Available and Processed Collections at The Historical Society of Pennsylvania Eric Klinek and HSP Archives Staff 87 REVIEW ESSAYS Matters of Perspective: Intepreting the Revolutionary Frontier Patrick Spero 261 “Corrupt and Contented”: Where Have All the Politicians Gone? A Survey of Recent Books on Pennsylvania Political History, 1787–1877 William G. Shade 433 EDITORIALS Tamara Gaskell 305 BOOK REVIEWS 95, 191, 271 INDEX 459 THE HISTORICAL SOCIETY OF PENNSYLVANIA OFFICERS Chair SARAH D. PRICE Executive Vice Chair BRUCE K. FENTON Vice Chairs MAJID ALSAYEGH HOWARD H. LEWIS WALTER LICHT THOMAS J. SUGRUE Secretary HENRY LAFAYETTE COLLINS III Treasurer THOMAS C. WOODWARD Councilors THOMAS BISHOP JAMES R. ROEBUCK ROBERT BOGLE ROBERT G. SOUAID LEONARD L. COMBS PAGE TALBOTT BARBARA GOHN ALICE LEA TASMAN KRISHNA LAHIRI JOSEPH WATKINS TSIWEN M. LAW BINNEY H. C. WIETLISBACH CAROL CLARK LAWRENCE GEORGE W. CONNELL, Emeritus JERRY J. MAGINNIS JACK M. FRIEDLAND, Emeritus CHARLES E. MATHER III BRUCE H. HOOPER, Emeritus COLLIN F. M CNEIL DAVID W. MAXEY, Emeritus KAREN NAGEL HARRISON M. WRIGHT, Emeritus CHARLES W. NICHOLS THOMAS BARBANO, Ex officio DAVID A. OTHMER JOHN C. HAAS, Ex officio ROBERT J. RITTENHOUSE as of October 2008 STAFF KIM SAJET, President and CEO PRESIDENT’S OFFICE LIBRARY Development LEE ARNOLD, Director of the Library and MARYGRACE GILMORE, Director of Major Collections Gifts and Planned Giving CHRISTIANNE BALSASMO, Coordinator of ARCHIVES AND COLLECTIONS MANAGEMENT Membership and Public Programs LAURI CIELO, Coordinator of Communications MATTHEW LYONS, Director of Archives and JON-CHRIS HATALSKI, Coordinator of Grants Collections Management CARY MAJEWICZ, Technical Services Archivist Administration CHRIS BRUNO, Director of Administration and Special Projects Operations CATHLEEN MILLER, Project Archivist, NICOLE JONIEC, Administrative Assistant and NEH/Chew Family Papers Coordinator of Board Materials NATALIE WHITTED, Project Archival Processor, MICHAEL RYAN, Visitor Services Representative NEH/Chew Family Papers Cataloging BUSINESS OFFICE JACQUELINE TADDONIO, Director of Cataloging MICHAEL HAIRSTON, Director of Accounting Conservation and Finance TARA O’BRIEN, Director of Preservation and KATHERINE WALDRON, Staff Accountant Conservation Services FLORA SYLVESTER, Accounting Clerk LEAH MACKIN, Preservation Technician ANNI ALTSHULER, Preservation Technician FACILITIES RESEARCH SERVICES ILLIAM C OLDRICK W M G , Facilities Manager DAVID HAUGAARD, Director of Research TYRONE LITES, Assistant Facilities Manager Services ADEMA ICKERSON N D , Facilities Technician SARAH HEIM, Research Services Librarian RONALD MEDFORD, Senior Research Services EDUCATION AND INTERPRETATION Associate DANIEL N. ROLPH, Historian and Head of JOAN SAVERINO, Assistant Director for Reference Services Education STEVEN SMITH, Reference Librarian MELISSA M. MANDELL, Project Coordinator/PhilaPlace Remote Services DWIGHT SWANSON, Digitial Media DANA M. LAMPARELLO, Digital Reproductions Coordinator Coordinator LOUIS MEEHAN, Photographer Publications TAMARA GASKELL, Director of Publications as of October 2008 INDEX 2008 459 AAAS (American Assoc. for the Almost a Dynasty: The Rise and Fall of the Advancement of Science), 245, 249, 252, 1980 Phillies, by Kashatus, rev., 298–99 254, 257, 258 Amdur, Emanuel (attorney), denounces abolition: PA Act for the Gradual Abolition Lindbergh, 352–53 of Slavery, 67, 67n; Robert Purvis and, America First Committee (A.F.C.): conse book on, 103–4; and Quakers, book on, quences of Pittsburgh rally, 355–57; 200–201 Coughlinite faction in, 351, 353; An Account of the Trial of Thomas Cooper Pittsburgh branch, 347–55; rally in (handbill), 117–39 passim Pittsburgh, PA (1941), 341–47 ADA (Americans for Democratic Action), An American Aristocracy: Southern Planters 337–38 in Antebellum Philadelphia, by Kilbride, Adams, Henry (historian), 286 rev., 280–81 Adams, John: and Cooper sedition trial, American Assoc. for the Advancement of 117–39 passim; and Robert Walsh, 160 Science, 245, 249, 252, 254, 257, 258 Adams, John Quincy, 156; Letters from American Aurora: A Democratic-Republican Silesia, 152; translation by, 151; and Returns: The Suppressed History of Our Robert Walsh, 141, 160 Beginnings and the Heroic Newspaper Address to the People of Northampton That Tried to Report It (Rosenfeld), in (Cooper), 121 review essay, 440 Adkins v. Children’s Hospital, 34n, 54, 56, 57, American Battle Monuments Commission, 63, 63n 369 A.F.C. See America First Committee (A.F.C.) American Daily Advertiser (newspaper), 21 AFL (American Federation of Labor), 38, 39, American Federation of Labor (AFL), 38, 39, 40, 41, 334–35 40, 41, 334–35 African Americans: absence in movies and, American Friends Service Committee, 177–78 367; in Lancaster, PA, 390; Murray’s American imperialism, Carnegie and, 424 assurances to, 329; nineteenth-century vil American Journal of Science and Arts, 252, lage of, book on, 104–6; northward migra 254 tion after WWI, 312; in Pittsburgh American Leviathan: Empire, Nation, and (1932), 323–24; in pre-WWII Phila., 378; Revolutionary Frontier (Griffin), in review Robert Purvis (abolitionist), book on, essay, 261–70 103–4; race and politics in Phila., book American National Biography (Garraty and on, 294–95; rehousing during Phila.’s Carnes, eds.), 141 urban renewal, 389; and suburban devel American political memoirists, in opments, 173–90 passim; unemployment Machiavellian tradition, 417–32 in Pittsburgh (1930s), 349; in war debate, American Politics in the Early Republic: The 357 New Nation in Crisis (Sharp), in review African immigration, Reed on, 372 essay, 438 AFSC (American Friends Service American Quarterly Review, 166, 167 Committee), 177–78 American Register, or General Repository of The Age of Federalism: The Early American History, Politics, and Science (journal), Republic, 1788–1800 (Elkins and 144, 146, 152 McKitrick), in review essay, 438 American Review of History and Politics Algonquians, book on, 191–92 (quarterly), 144–46 “‘Alive to the Cry of Distress’: Joseph and Jane American Revolution: early America after, Sill and Poor Relief in Antebellum books on, 261–70, 273–75; and national Philadelphia,” by Trisha Posey, 215–43 identity, book on, 195–96; Phila. in, book Allen, George (Delaware Indian), 274–75 on, 193–95; revolutionaries, book on, Allen, George (militiaman), 274–75 275–76; Robert Walsh and, 141–71 All in the Day’s Work (Tarbell), 425 Americans for Democratic Action (ADA), The Almanac of American Politics (Barone 337–38 and Ujifusa), 414 Ames, Fisher, 155 460 Amish, and Civil War, book on, 282–83 Aurand, Martin, The Spectator and the Amos brothers, 105–6 Topographical City, rev., 107–9 Analectic Magazine, 146 Aurora (newspaper), 118, 121, 122, 125–26 Anderson, David L., ed., Profiles of Autobiography of Benjamin Franklin, 417–20 Revolutionaries in Atlantic History, Axelrod, Alan, Blooding at Great Meadows: 1700–1850, with Weisberger and Young George Washington and the Hupchick, rev., 275–76 Battle that Shaped the Man, rev., 96–97 Anderson, Martin, 401 Anderson, Mary (U.S. Dept. of Labor’s Bache, Alexander Dallas (scientist), 253 Women’s Bureau chief ), 57, 58 Bache, Benjamin Franklin (editor): Aurora, Andrews, John (American Assoc. of Labor 121; General Advertiser,28 Legislation secretary), 51 Backcountry Crucibles: The Lehigh Valley Andrews, William L., on autobiographical from Settlement to Steel, by Soderlund form, 431 and Parzynski, eds., rev., 278–80 Anecdotes of Public Men (Forney), 429 Bacon, Edmund (architect), 377, 380, 381, Annan, Robert (minister), 27–28, 30 382–84, 387; Penn Center planning by, Another Civil War: Labor, Capital, and the 387–88; speaks at Lancaster public forum, State of the Anthracite Regions of 393; Triangle Plan of, 389 Pennsylvania, 1840–68 (Palladino), in Bacon, Margaret Hope: book rev.