Download This PDF File
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Cover’s comment Smile of a Stem Cell: A Dialogue between Science and Society The exhibition Smile of a Stem Cell comprises 54 pictures collected from scientists working in the research network ESTOOLS (www.estools.eu). Supported by the European Union's Sixth Framework Program, ESTOOLS investigated embryonic stem cell, science, ethics and law across 10 different Eu- ropean countries. Aiming at improving integration and coordination in the Euro- pean area, geographically dispersed research institutes shared their experience to foster development in both science and ethics. As part of the project, a large emphasis was placed on the production of outreach tools able to match and min- gle with different cultural and religious contexts. Scientists involved in the project selected their pictures following aesthetic crite- ria. The caption of each image is comprised of a fantasy title and a condensed scientific detail. Scientists looked at their everyday research from an external and unusual perspective. They imagined something beyond the meaning they attribute to pictures in their everyday laboratory activities: a cell or a fluorescent marker might become a fairy, an astronomical phenomenon or a mundane urban activity. The focus of the exhibition was to present science in a neutral way. Each picture is expression of a scientific activity and contributes to foster debate, promote enthusiasm and perplexity, though purposely avoiding influencing the observer from an ethical perspective. Smile of a Stem Cell tries to use art as a universal form of communication and – just like art does – it makes visible what the naked eye would not usually see, highlighting the role of interpretation. One of the aim of the exhibition was to attract the lay public to a scientific event. In these occasions, people often fear they will face complicated and incomprehensible scientific data, something bound to remain in the domain of few experts. Smile of a Stem Cell does not require any scientific background: whoever is interested or attracted by either science or art can appreciate it. Art and science cannot be the same thing but both work as lenses or mirrors to know more about the universe. The exhibition triggers the power of imagination and displaces the perspectives of observers making them aware of the need for interpretation, in an attempt to deal with the issue of visibility and to pave the way for public debate. Gianfranco Munizza (Project Manager at Cattaneo Lab) Cover Pictures are reproduced with permission from Estools’s photo exhibition “Smile of Stem Cell” (http://www.estools.eu). Tecnoscienza is a scientific journal focusing on the relationships between science, technology and society. The Journal is published twice a year with an open access and peer reviewed policy; it is managed by an Editorial Board with the supervision of an International Advisory Board. Tecnoscienza è una rivista scientifica che indaga i rapporti tra scienza, tecnolo- gia e società. La rivista è semestrale, open access e peer-reviewed; la rivista è gestita da un Comitato di Redazione, con la supervisione di un Comitato Scientifi- co Internazionale. Tecnoscienza by Tecnoscienza.net is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribuzione-Non commerciale-Condividi allo stesso modo 2.5 Italia License. Board Coordination International Advisory Board Attila Bruni Maria Carmela Agodi (Università di Trento) (Università di Napoli – IT) Paolo Magaudda Barbara Allen (Università di Padova) (Virginia Tech University – USA) Assunta Viteritti Mario Biagioli (Università di Roma La Sapienza) (University of California Davis – USA) Wiebe Bijker (Maastricht University – NL) Editorial Board Geoffrey Bowker (University of Pittsburgh – USA) Stefano Crabu Massimiano Bucchi (Università di Padova) (Università di Trento – IT) Claudio Coletta Barbara Czarniawska (Università di Trento) (Göteborg University – SE) Enrico Marchetti Steven Epstein (Università di Ferrara) (UC San Diego – USA) Alvise Mattozzi Silvia Gherardi (Libera Università di Bolzano) (Università di Trento – IT) Francesca Musiani Luca Guzzetti (MINES ParisTech – FR) (Università di Genova – IT) Laura Lucia Parolin Christine Hine (Università di Milano Bicocca) (University of Surrey – UK) Annalisa Pelizza Alessandro Mongili (University of Twente – NL) (Università di Padova – IT) Giuseppina Pellegrino Michela Nacci (Università della Calabria) (Università dell’Aquila – IT) Barbara Pentimalli Federico Neresini (Università di Roma La Sapienza) (Università di Padova – IT) Manuela Perrotta Trevor Pinch (Norwegian University of (Cornell University – USA) Science and Technology – NO) Lucy Suchman Tiziana Piccioni (Lancaster University – UK) (IULM Milano) Paolo Volontè (Politecnico di Milano – IT) Tecnoscienza is promoted by STS Italia (www.stsitalia.org) Società Italiana di Studi sulla Scienza e la Tecnologia Tecnoscienza c/o STS Italia Dip. FISPPA, Via Cesarotti, 10-12, 35100 – Padova – Italy www.tecnoscienza.net – [email protected] – ISSN 2038-346 Table of Contents TECNOSCiENZA Italian Journal of Science & Technology Studies Vol. 4, Nr. 1, June 2013 Special Issue: Re-conceiving Life in the Labs: The Emerging Meanings of Cells in the Italian Reproductive Biomedicine and Beyond Cover Smile of a Stem Cell Editors’ Note p. 5 Guest Editor’s Introduction Manuela Perrotta Creating Human Life Itself. The Emerging Meanings of Reproductive Cells among Science, State and Religion p. 7 Lecture Sarah Franklin Embryo Watching. How IVF Has Remade Biology p. 23 Essays Patrick Hanafin Law, Biopolitics and Reproductive Citizenship. The Case of Assisted Reproduction in Italy p. 45 Alessandra Gribaldo Substances, Knowledge, Gaze. The Bio-aesthetics of Reproductive Technology in a Sicilian Fertility Clinic p. 69 Tecnoscienza - 4 (1) 2 Giulia Zanini Neither Gametes nor Children. Italian Prospective Parents and the Variable Meaning of Donor Embryos p. 87 Lorenzo Beltrame ‘Sidestepping the Embryo’. The Cultural Meaning and Political Uses of Ethical Stem Cells p. 111 Conversations Laura Lucia Parolin, Ingrid Metzler and Alexander Schuster (Not) Making ‘Hexternologous’ Fertilization. The Italian ART Law and its Paradoxes p. 133 Elena Cattaneo, Giuseppe Testa and Assunta Viteritti The Italian Pathways of Stem Cells p. 145 Cartography Katarina Prpić STS in a (Post)Socialist Context. Science and Technology Studies in Croatia p. 165 Book Reviews M. T. Schäfer Bastard Culture! How User Participation Transform Cultural Production, by Claudio Coletta R. Abadie The Professional Guinea Pig. Big Pharma and the Risky World of Human Subject, by Stefano Crabu E. B. Silva Technology, Culture, Family. Influences on Home Life, by Michela Cozza A. Rudinow Saetnan, H. Mork Lomell and S. Hammer (Eds.) The Mutual Construction of Statistics and Society, by Orazio Giancola 3 S. Houdart and O. Thiery (Eds.) Human and Non-Human: How to Repopulate Social Science, by Anne-Sophie Godfroy A. Cannellotto and E. Luchtenberg (Eds.) Medicalizacioń y sociedad: lecturas criticaś sobre la construccioń social de enfermedades, by Roberto Lusardi H. Nowotny and G. Testa Naked Genes: Reinventing the Human in The Molecular Age, by Federico Neresini C. Méadel Quantifier le public. Histoire des mesures d’audience de la radio et de la télévision, by Paola Pallavicini D. Kaiser How the Hippies Saved Physics: Science, Counterculture, and the Quantum Revival, by Assunta Viteritti Tecnoscienza - 4 (1) 4 Editors’ Note Three years after the release of its first issue, Tecnoscienza looks at it- self in the mirror, and starts a new three-year cycle with some notable accomplishments and a few novelties. In recent years the journal has gained great visibility at both national and international level (it currently has about 1,500 registered users and an average of 750 downloads upon the release of each new issue), estab- lishing itself as the only Italian academic journal specifically devoted to social studies of science and technology, as well as one of the only one coming from a southern European country. At a national level, this achievement has also been symbolically acknowledged by the awarding of Premio Filosofico Castiglioncello, a prize awarded last year to Tecnoscienza as the “best online academic journal in 2012”. The Journal has also strengthened and consolidated its position in the international debate, thanks to the publication of original materials in English and its ability to carve out for itself an increasingly central role in the international academic community (see for example the special issue dedicated to the 2010 EASST conference: http://www.tecnoscienza.net/ index.php/tsj/issue/view/18). The reputation of Tecnoscienza has also been enhanced by the contributions included in the Cartography section, which have so far focused on the STS debate in several European coun- tries (i.e. Spain, Germany, Norway and Croatia) and the review section, which includes in-depth analyses (in English) of STS books written in other languages. In the perspective of a more incisive positioning of the Journal both nationally and internationally, we have implemented various actions in preparation for the next three years, aimed at enhancing Tecnoscienza’s institutional recognition and reputation. We have recently participated in the processes of accreditation and evaluation promoted by Italian aca- demic and scientific institutions, having been included by the National Agency for the Evaluation of Universities and Research (ANVUR) in the list of scientific journals. Moreover, Tecnoscienza has also been selected