DOCSLIB.ORG

Legislative Gap Analysis Oct 2020

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Legislative Gap Analysis Oct 2020 LEGISLATIVE GAP ANALYSIS COMMISSIONER’S FOREWORD This report is the culmination of a year’s work – work that has required both a great deal of patience and expertise on the part of its authors. But their efforts have been worth it, because what we now have in these pages is a comprehensive, independent analysis of the extent to which Jersey legislation complies with the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (UNCRC). For the first time, we have a clear understanding of where our laws meet the expectations of the United Nations Committee, and where they continue to fall short of them. However, this report should not be viewed as a document that seeks to attach fault or blame for any lack of compliance with the UNCRC. Instead, it should be seen as part of an ongoing collaboration between my office and the Government of Jersey, the intended outcome of which is to achieve genuine progress – as opposed to nominal, tick-box compliance – with both the letter and the spirit of the UNCRC. In order to do that effectively, though, we need to have an accurate map. This document provides that. It illuminates the areas of our statute which we can already chalk up as ‘wins’ in our journey along the continuum of compliance, and it also exposes those parts of the Island’s legislation that are most in need of attention. I am thinking, in particular, of aspects of the Children (Jersey) Law 2002, as well as other major pieces of legislation relating to education, healthcare, adoption, young offending, and many other areas. Thanks to the tireless work of Simon Hoffman and Sally Sellwood at Swansea University’s Observatory on Human Rights of Children, who have spent the past year sifting through hundreds of legal documents, we now have a reliable touchstone for our elected representatives to use when debating propositions. Or, to put it another way, we have an overview of the changes that will be required if the Government is to truly deliver on its commitment to Putting Children First. Now that we have such an overview, it is my recommendation that the Government revisits its transformation programme for children’s legislation, which was set at a time before any independent and thorough gap analysis had been undertaken. Reliable, detailed information is essential for good decision-making. The Council of Ministers were very clear on this point when they first asked me to deliver this piece 1 of work. And I am confident that, in the same spirit of informed decision-making, they will now want to act on the information that is set out here. From my point of view, I will simply say that I made three clear undertakings in 2018 when I took up my post as the Island’s first Children’s Commissioner. I said that I would: develop and embed a culture of children’s human rights in Jersey; form a strong, resilient and inspiring organisation which promotes and protects children’s human rights; make sure children’s human rights are at the centre of laws, policies and practice in Jersey. It is not only on the last of these strategic aims that this report is focussed, but on all three. Because for us to truly embed a culture of children’s human rights in the Island, we must reflect our commitment as signatories to the UNCRC in both our policy-making and our law-making. Of course, this cannot happen overnight. Compliance with the UNCRC is a continuum – it does not happen from one day to the next; it happens incrementally. But careful consideration of the articles of the UNCRC is something that we can incorporate right away into the services that we deliver and the policies that we debate. This is why I would like to see the introduction of a Child Rights Impact Assessment (CRIA) in the process of drafting and debating States propositions. The Government of Jersey has already begun piloting the use of a CRIA approach, and it makes sense for that to become a permanent fixture as we strive to address the findings of this report. This would not be a straitjacket for States Members, nor would be it a tactic for crowbarring in consideration of children’s rights where they are not thought to be relevant. It would merely be a way of ensuring that the UNCRC, which was formally extended to Jersey six years ago, becomes a natural and permanent part of our political and social consciences. Deborah McMillan Commissioner for Children and Young People, Jersey 2 LEGISLATIVE GAP ANALYSIS relating to STATES OF JERSEY FINAL REPORT Authored by: Simon Hoffman, Sally Sellwood Swansea University Submitted to the Office of the Children’s Commissioner for Jersey 26th August 2020 (updated 18th September 2020) (This report supersedes all previous versions) 3 CONTENT GLOSSARY AND ABBREVIATIONS .............................................................................. 6 STATES OF JERSEY LAW: SHORT FORM ................................................................... 7 BACKGROUND .............................................................................................................. 8 NOTE ON RECOMMENDATIONS .................................................................................. 8 NOTE ON PROGRESSIVE REALISATION .................................................................... 9 ONGOING DEVELOPMENTS ...................................................................................... 10 METHODOLOGY .......................................................................................................... 10 Developing an Analytical Compliance Framework ..................................................... 12 HOW THE REPORT IS SET OUT................................................................................. 14 DISABILTY, BASIC HEALTH AND WELFARE ............................................................. 16 Areas Covered ........................................................................................................... 16 Right to Life, Survival and Development (Article 6) ................................................... 17 Findings: Article 6 ...................................................................................................... 24 Childcare Services and Facilities (Article 18.3) .......................................................... 25 Findings: Article 18(3) ................................................................................................ 26 Disabled Children (Article 23) .................................................................................... 27 Findings: Article 23 .................................................................................................... 28 Health and Health Services (Article 24) ..................................................................... 28 Findings: Article 24 .................................................................................................... 33 Social Security and Standard of Living (Articles 26 and 27) ...................................... 33 Findings: Articles 26 and 27 ...................................................................................... 37 Protection from Harmful Substances (Article 33) ....................................................... 38 Collated Findings: Disability, Basic Health and Welfare ............................................ 38 EDUCATION, LEISURE AND CULTURAL ACTIVITIES ............................................... 41 Areas Covered ........................................................................................................... 41 Education (Article 28) ................................................................................................ 42 Findings: Article 28 .................................................................................................... 50 The Aims of Education (Article 29) ............................................................................ 51 Findings: Article 29 ................................................................................................... 55 Leisure and Cultural Activities (Article 31) ................................................................. 55 Findings: Article 31 ................................................................................................... 58 Collated Findings: Education, Leisure and Cultural Activities .................................... 58 FAMILY ENVIRONMENT AND ALTERNATIVE CARE ................................................. 60 Areas Covered ........................................................................................................... 60 Parental Responsibility and Guidance (Articles 5 and 18(1) and (2)) ........................ 61 Findings: Article 5 and 18(1) and (2) .......................................................................... 64 4 Separation From Parents (Article 9) .......................................................................... 64 Findings: Article 9 ..................................................................................................... 72 Family Reunification (Article 10) ................................................................................ 73 Findings: Article 10 ................................................................................................... 74 Illicit Transfer and Non-return of Children (Article 11) ................................................ 74 Children Deprived of Family Environment (Article 20) ............................................... 75 Findings: Article 20 .................................................................................................... 82
Load more

Recommended publications
  • JCG Life - Issue 23 March 2018 NOVEMBER 2017:Layout 1 02/11/2017 10:56 Page 1 STEPHEN COHU
    JCG Life - Issue 23 March 2018 NOVEMBER 2017:Layout 1 02/11/2017 10:56 Page 1 STEPHEN COHU A large selection of decorative garden furnishings now on display at The Hidden Garden Company, St Lawrence DEALERS IN FINE ANTIQUES, WORKS OF ART, JEWELLERY AND OBJECTS We are the Channel Islands’ leading purchaser of antiques, jewellery and effects. These, together with my extensive experience and knowledge enable us to offer the most comprehensive service in the Islands, whether buying or selling. NOVEMBER 2017:Layout 1 02/11/2017 10:56 Page 1 STEPHEN COHU develop breast cancer awareness, in addition to the organisation of Dear Parents revision academies, biomedical summer schools, bursaries, work placements, in addition to many reunions. On behalf of all the College, I would like to thank Leanda for the legacy she leaves. One of the delights of being Principal is that I receive, out of the How we communicate to you about life at JCG has been the subject blue, communications from previous students about their lives after of much thought at the College following the recent survey about JCG. In education, we spend our lives planting acorns and it’s great to JCG Life. It is clear that this termly magazine is an appreciated digest sometimes see the oak trees that have gone on to grow. of our activity. It works best in paper copy, as it was designed to be in this format, though we also put it on our website for those who wish to One of the emails I received recently was from a student who left read it online.
    [Show full text]
  • Read the Full Report
    sey Da ANNUAL Fulfilling the obligations of the Authority under Article 44 of the Data Protection Authority (Jersey) Law 2018 and the Information Commissioner 2020 REPORT under Article 43 of the Freedom of Information (Jersey) Law 2011. 2020 ANNUAL REPORT | 1 CONTENTS 04 THE JERSEY DATA PROTECTION AUTHORITY’S ROLE, 34 ANNUAL REPORT OF FREEDOM OF INFORMATION VISION, MISSION, PROMISE AND 2020 STRATEGIC OUTCOMES 2020 Operational Performance & Appeals Our Role Significant 2020 Decision Notices Our Vision Our Promise 38 COMMUNICATIONS Message From the Chair Annual Registrations Message From The Commissioner Data Protection Toolkits Pandemic Messaging 10 JERSEY DATA PROTECTION AUTHORITY Data Protection Week 2020 Independence #AskTheCommissioner Campaigns 2020 12 LOOKING FORWARD - PRIVACY & HORIZON SCANNING CCTV Data Protection Obligations 14 GOVERNANCE, ACCOUNTABILITY AND TRANSPARENCY Individual Rights The Data Protection Authority Blogs Delegation of Powers Education 2020 Authority Structure Privacy Courtroom Challenge Authority Meetings The JOIC Talks For Industry Board Members Remuneration Communications Summary Risk Management Public Engagements and Awareness Environmental & Social Policy National/International Liaison 2020 Social 19 MANAGING PERFORMANCE & REGULATORY DELIVERABLES 48 FINANCIAL INFORMATION Summary 20 ORGANISATION Grant The Structure Registration Fee Income The Team Expenditure Year Ahead 24 SUMMARY OF 2020 DATA PROTECTION ACTIVITIES 2020 Operational Performance 2020 Case Data Complaints Investigation Matrix 2020 Case Outcomes Breach Reporting www.jerseyoic.org Enforcement 2 | JERSEY OFFICE OF THE INFORMATION COMMISSIONER 2020 ANNUAL REPORT | 3 OUR ROLE The Jersey Data Protection Authority (the Authority) is an independent OUR 2020 statutory body. Its mission is to promote respect for the private lives of individuals through ensuring privacy of their personal information by: STRATEGIC OUTCOMES Æ Implementing and ensuring compliance with the Data Protection (Jersey) Law 2018 and the Data Protection Authority (Jersey) Law 2018.
    [Show full text]
  • Post-16 Education Review
    P a g e | 1 Post-16 Education Review Highlands College of Further and Higher Education’s response to the Scrutiny Panel terms of reference Report submitted to the Education and Home Affairs Scrutiny Panel October 2018 This report may be made available to the general public for borrowing, photocopying or consultation without the prior consent of the authors. P a g e | 2 This page is intentionally blank P a g e | 3 Contents Introduction ................................................................................. 5 1: Background to post-16 Vocational and Technical Education ................. 7 2: The provision for 16-19 year olds at Highlands College ..................... 10 3: Meeting the needs of Jersey’s young people .................................. 14 4: Meeting the needs of Jersey businesses and industries .................... 16 5: Equipping Jersey’s young people to be active participants in society ... 19 6: Highlands College performance as a post 16 education provider ......... 20 7: Future plans for Highlands College .............................................. 21 8: Recommendations ................................................................... 22 9: Authorship ............................................................................. 23 Bibliography .............................................................................. 25 P a g e | 4 This page is intentionally blank P a g e | 5 Introduction The Senior Leadership Team at Highlands College of Further and Higher Education welcomes this opportunity to provide the Education and Home Affairs Scrutiny Panel our collective views on Post-16 Education in Jersey. This report provides a contextual discussion around the place of vocational and technical education in general and how this applies to the provision of post-16 education in Jersey. Highlands College plays a central role in providing post-16 education to Jersey’s young people. The contribution that Highlands College makes to social cohesion and to the economic capital of the island cannot be underestimated.
    [Show full text]
  • Working for a Fairer Island
    General Election Manifesto 2018 Working For A Fairer Island 1 Contents Introduction ................................................................................................................................ 4 About Reform Jersey .................................................................................................................... 5 Our Ten Key Pledges .................................................................................................................... 6 Our Record .................................................................................................................................. 7 An Economy That Works For All .................................................................................................... 8 Finance Digital Agriculture Tourism and Hospitality Supporting Jersey businesses Low pay and insecure work Population A Governance Structure for the 21st Century ............................................................................... 12 The States of Jersey as an employer Improving your experience with the government States-owned companies, contractors and arms-length organisations A Tax System with Fairness and Sustainability at its core ............................................................ 14 Income Tax Corporation Tax High Net Worth Individuals Other Taxes Finding Jersey’s Place in the World ............................................................................................. 16 Channel Islands Co-operation Our special relationship with the United Kingdom
    [Show full text]
  • Police Force (Jersey) Law 1974
    POLICE FORCE (JERSEY) LAW 1974 Revised Edition 23.375 Showing the law as at 1 January 2007 This is a revised edition of the law Police Force (Jersey) Law 1974 Arrangement POLICE FORCE (JERSEY) LAW 1974 Arrangement Article PART 1 5 GENERAL 5 1 Interpretation ...................................................................................................5 2 Duty of police officer ......................................................................................6 3 Power of police officer....................................................................................6 PART 2 6 THE HONORARY POLICE 6 4 Composition of Honorary Police.....................................................................6 5 Jurisdiction ......................................................................................................7 6 Prescribed offences .........................................................................................7 7 Report of occurrences......................................................................................7 PART 3 8 THE STATES OF JERSEY POLICE FORCE 8 8 Duties and powers of Minister ........................................................................8 9 The Chief Officer and Deputy Chief Officer ..................................................8 10 Jurisdiction ......................................................................................................9 11 The Police Negotiating Board .........................................................................9 PART 4 9 PORT CONTROL UNIT
    [Show full text]
  • ISSUE 1 Spring 2012
    ISSUE 1 Spring 2012 The Parish springs into life In this issue : P3 Welcome P4 Steve Luce: the first six months P5 Parish News: from the Conne ́table P13 Clubs and Activities: join and make new friends See P23 Claire Jehan opens our eyes to St Martin in spring page Quacking 29 P25 Sports Clubs: you can expect a warm welcome P27 School News: a dream becomes reality News P32 Parish Office: new faces and dates for your diary Feature Articles listed on P3 Spring 2012 Les Nouvelles 3 From the Editor From the Connétable Welcome to Issue 1 of Welcome to the inaugural edition of Les Nouvelles de St Les Nouvelles de St Martin. Martin. I hope you find the contents interesting and informative and that future editions go from strength to My sincere thanks to everyone who strength in bringing you Parish news, information on has contributed such excellent forthcoming and past events and a whole range of material, to the team at interesting Parish related features. MediaMasters for their encouragement and professionalism I would like to express my sincere thanks to Graham Crosby who has worked and, especially, to the Connétable, tirelessly in taking on responsibility for Les Nouvelles, collating the features, meeting with the publishers and carrying out the editing of the copy that he has received. His Michel Le Troquer, for his unfailing enthusiasm for the role has been tremendous and had it not been for that support and enthusiasm. commitment then it is unlikely that you The August Issue is well under way; if you wish to would be reading contribute to that or to future issues or to become this magazine today.
    [Show full text]
  • States Greffe Annual Report 2020
    ST ATES ASSEMBLY ANNUAL REPORT 2020 PRIVILEGES AND PROCEDURES COMMITTEE July 2021 R.121/2021 Foreword by the Bailiff of Jersey Foreword by the Bailiff of Jersey Foreword by the Bailiff of Jersey President of the States I am delighted to contribute to the annual report of the States Assembly for 2020, the second time I have been able to do so as President of the States. The States has faced truly exceptional challenges in 2020, as indeed did we all, because of the Covid-19 pandemic. For most of the year Members were not able to convene in person and our business, as well as the work of committees and panel, was conducted online. Some Members found it easier to adapt than others, but collectively we got on with the job of adjusting to new ways of working to ensure that the Island's parliamentary system of government could continue. I am particularly proud of the fact that Jersey was the first Commonwealth jurisdiction to move the proceedings of its Assembly entirely online. Indeed, as this report shows, we have had one of our busiest ever years. Not only were numerous novel and complex pieces of legislation fully debated by the Assembly but there were more questions asked than ever before, particularly following the introduction of special periods of questions without notice to all ministers on Covid-19 matters. This was especially significant because the public had so many questions about Covid rules and the potential effects of the virus on all aspects of Island life. Indeed, I noted during the debate on opening our borders in the early part of the summer something like 3,000 people were following our proceedings online.
    [Show full text]
  • To Pegasus Bridge with Our Veterans • Foods to Boost Your Feel-Good
    ‘Liberation’ To Pegasus Bridge with our veterans • Foods to boost your feel-good factor St Helier closes a GAAP in its accounts • Elections for St Helier deputies Inaugural Halkett Hoedown for Headway • View on St Helier – André Ferrari Delivered by Jersey Post to 19,000 homes and businesses every month. Designed and produced by MailMate Publishing Jersey in partnership with the Parish of St Helier. elcome to the October edition of the Town WCrier which features on its cover a new variety of Contents tulip, called ‘Liberation’. This Parish matters 4 was developed by Dutch growers, Jac. Uittenbogaard & Zonen B.V. at Help make a difference 6 the request of the Dutch government to To Pegasus Bridge with our veterans 8 mark the Liberation of the Netherlands by the Allied Forces and officially launched at a ceremony at Foods to boost your feel-good factor 9 the Dutch Embassy this year. Due to the St Helier Parks and St Helier closes a GAAP in its accounts 10 Gardens Department’s close relationship with the bulb company over the years, it was suggested that the Channel The French Connection 12 Islands should be included in the launch of the new bulb, Elections for St Helier deputies 14 with 1,000 bulbs of the red and yellow ‘Triumph’ tulip 16 being prepared for planting this month. Director of Parks, Inaugural Halkett Hoedown for Headway Tony Andrews, says that it is a great honour for the Parish View on St Helier 18 to be receiving the new tulips. ‘We will be inviting the Historic St Helier by Geraint Jennings 20 primary schools of the Parish
    [Show full text]
  • The Best Start for Children in Jersey
    The Best Start for Children in Jersey By getting it right from the start, Jersey will become an island that works for all children and makes a sound investment in the island’s future. 1 About the Partnership Achieving better outcomes for children and families means working across traditional boundaries between government departments and partner agencies in both the public, private, voluntary and community sectors with parents and their children. The Best Start Partnership1 offers a new ‘whole system’ approach by bringing together a wide range of stakeholders in a single body. It has and will continue to draw on the voices of children and families with local representatives from the public, private, community and voluntary sectors to provide unique insights representing the interests of children in the development, implementation and evaluation of government strategy and policy. The purpose of the Partnership is to: • represent the interests of children in the development, implementation and evaluation of government strategy and policy • ensure that early years and childhood policy is co-ordinated, resource allocation is effectively prioritised and high quality practice is embedded across services and organisations • support and help implement, integrate and monitor delivery plans for relevant outcomes • support the delivery of the children’s plan • monitor and review the impact of policies and services for children and families Why the Early Years are crucial What happens in pregnancy and early childhood has the greatest impact on children’s futures as it impacts on physical and mental health throughout adulthood. “The period from conception to the start of school opens a critical and singular window of opportunity to shape the development of a child’s brain.
    [Show full text]
  • Administrative Decisions (Review) (Jersey) Law 1982, As Amended
    ADMINISTRATIVE DECISIONS (REVIEW) (JERSEY) LAW 1982, AS AMENDED: REPORT OF THE ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS PANEL REGARDING COMPLAINTS RECEIVED BETWEEN 1ST JANUARY AND 31ST DECEMBER 1999 _______________ Presented to the States on 8th February 2000 by the Special Committee to consider the relationship between Committees and the States ______________________________ STATES OF JERSEY STATES GREFFE 150 2000 R.C.5 Price code: C ADMINISTRATIVE DECISIONS (REVIEW) (JERSEY) LAW 1982, AS AMENDED: REPORT OF THE ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS PANEL REGARDING COMPLAINTS RECEIVED BETWEEN 1st JANUARY AND 31st DECEMBER 1999 Foreword by Chairman of the Appeals Panel Dear Mr. President, I am pleased to send herewith a copy of the Report of the Panels convened under the Law relating to Administrative Appeals. You will see from the Report that nine complaints were received by the Greffier of the States. Of that number two went to a full Hearing, whilst three Appeal Boards have been deferred until 2000 (including one complaint carried forward from the end of 1998). Of the two Hearings, the appropriate Board upheld the Committee’s decision on one occasion and requested a reconsideration of the other. From time to time there are those who say that Administrative Appeal Boards, or an equivalent ombudsman, should be given more teeth. I have to record that in the United Kingdom a recommendation is generally found acceptable as the appropriate authority almost always accepts the ruling of the ombudsman. Unfortunately such is not always the case in Jersey. I would point to the matter referred to under (b) below where the Planning and Environment Committee agrees with the recommendation and accepts the justice of the Board’s findings; but over a year has passed since the Board gave its decision and nothing has happened.
    [Show full text]
  • Enforcement-Of-Credi
    REGISTRATION FORM Please note that this form is for registration only and does not include accommodation. Title: First Name: Surname: University/Company/Firm: Address: Tel: Email: REGISTRATION FEES: Delegate - registration before 14 September 2014 £245.00 Delegate - registration after 14 September 2014 £295.00 Academic/student rate £195.00 METHOD OF PAYMENT: I enclose a cheque payable to “Institute of Law” in GBP I am arranging for a bank transfer in GBP to Account Name: Institute of Law; Bank: HSBC; Branch: St Helier; Sort Code: 40-25-34; Account Number: 12245620. Please use delegate name as reference. PLEASE RETURN THIS FORM TO: Lori-Ann Foley, Manager Institute of Law, Law House, 1 Seale Street, St Helier, Jersey, Channel Islands, JE2 3QG Tel: + 44 (0)1534 826060 Email: [email protected] Website: www.lawinstitute.ac.je INFORMATION The Enforcement of Creditors’ Rights HOW TO GET TO JERSEY HOTEL INFORMATION in the Channel Islands: Jersey has daily air links with many United Kingdom The Institute of Law has negotiated a corporate rate airports. London Gatwick, London City and Stanstead (per night) at the following hotels: have direct links to Jersey with BA (www.ba.com) and Flybe (www.flybe.com). Regular scheduled flights also The Pomme d'Or Hotel (4 star hotel in the centre of Issues in Asset Security and Insolvency depart from several UK regional airports such as St Helier) (www.seymourhotels.com/PommedOrHotel) Edinburgh, Manchester, Birmingham, Bristol, Southampton £88.00 per night for a standard room including breakfast. and Exeter. Blue Islands (www.blueislands.com) operate direct flights to Paris, Amsterdam, Geneva and Zurich.
    [Show full text]
  • 39 St Saviour Q2 2018.Pdf
    StSaviour-Q2-2018 copy.qxp_Governance style ideas 25/05/2018 15:40 Page 1 Summer 2018 Esprit de St Sauveur Edition39 St Saviour’s Church Refurbished Reopened Parish Personality Rededicated EricBastiman StSaviour-Q2-2018 copy.qxp_Governance style ideas 25/05/2018 15:40 Page 2 StSaviour-Q2-2018 copy.qxp_Governance style ideas 25/05/2018 15:40 Page 3 Summer 2018 St Saviour Parish Magazine p3 Front Page Picture: St Saviour’s Chuch From the Editor by Steve Wyatt Featured articles At last, Spring has sprung albeit late, and I have noticed lots of fresh green foliage growing on established shrubs, hedges and trees. From sudden cold to sudden heat and back to sudden P9 cold again, some plants have been lost, but certainly we enjoyed a 'host of Golden daffodils', to Easter egg quote the poet, William Wordsworth. Then we enjoyed a truly hot Bank Holiday weekend at the hunt beginning of May; I hope that sets the trend for a long hot summer. On that horticultural theme, a lovely lady called Jackie de Gruchy has entered a poem called 'Gardening' and no doubt there will be many entries for the Gardens competition in the Parish in Bloom event. Nance Hicklin has written an introductory piece about the Parish in Bloom competition. A most interesting and educational article has been written by local St Saviour dairy farmer, Paul P14 Houze. He explains how agricultural practices have changed over the years and decades to become more environmentally practical and hospitable. The welfare and health of animals is paramount, and Longueville field husbandry and maintenance of hedges, hedgerows and trees takes equal importance.
    [Show full text]