SECRETARIAT / SECRÉTARIAT
SECRETARIAT OF THE COMMITTEE OF MINISTERS SECRÉTARIAT DU COMITÉ DES MINISTRES
Contact: John Darcy Tel: 03 88 41 31 56
Date: 18/04/2019 DH-DD(2019)434
Documents distributed at the request of a Representative shall be under the sole responsibility of the said Representative, without prejudice to the legal or political position of the Committee of Ministers.
Meeting: 1348th meeting (June 2019) (DH)
Item reference: Action plan (17/04/2019)
Communication from the Russian Federation concerning the KALASHNIKOV group of cases v. Russian Federation (individual measures) (Application No. 47095/99)
* * * * * * * * * * *
Les documents distribués à la demande d’un/e Représentant/e le sont sous la seule responsabilité dudit/de ladite Représentant/e, sans préjuger de la position juridique ou politique du Comité des Ministres.
Réunion : 1348e réunion (juin 2019) (DH)
Référence du point : Plan d’action
Communication de la Fédération de Russie concernant le groupe d’affaires KALASHNIKOV c. Fédération de Russie (mesures individuelles) (Requête n° 47095/99) (anglais uniquement) ACTION PLAN on the execution of the judgments of the European Court of Human Rights in the Kalashnikov group of cases (prepared for the 1348th CMCE meeting)
No. Case Applicant's name Detention facility, date of Nature of violation Information on applicant's current I Payment of compensation (Application no.) (Application no.) imprisonment and date of status Date of final judgment release (according to the ECtHR judgment) 1. Kutepov Valery Anatolyevich KUTEPOV I Correctional colony IK-11 of the Lack of appropriate Released on 2 November 2017. The payment was effected in full (application no. 13182/04) Republic of Mordoviya medical assistance in Currently is not detained in the on 19.05.2014 in roubles at the 14.04.2014 correctional facility institutions of the penitentiary exchange rate applicable as of from 2003 to the present day system. the payment date (payment order no. 223550 for the amount of 713,511 roubles). 2. Tse/ovalnik (application Sergey Vitalyevich Correctional colony no. 43 of Lack of appropriate Action Report has been sent to the Action Report has been sent to no. 28333/13) TSELOVALNIK Kemerovo medical assistance in CMCE: the CMCE: 08.01.2016 from 2010 to the present day correctional facility DH-OO(2017)841 DH-OO(2017)841 Released on 10 November 2017. 3. Gorbulya Vadim Vladislavovich Correctional colony IK-56 of the Poor conditions of Action Report has been sent to the Action Report has been sent to (application no. 31535/09) GORBULYA Sverdlovsk Region detention in correctional CMCE: the CMCE: 06.06.2014 facility DH-OO(2017)863 DH-OO(2017)863 from 04.11.2010 to the present day V.V. Gorbulya is presently charged with commission of another crime and is kept in a remand prison where adequate detention conditions, complying with international standards, have been provided for him. The circumstances of the applicant's detention in the remand prison were not subject of consideration by the ECHR. 4. Dubov Oleg Yuryevich DUBOV Correctional colony IK-11 (UZ- Poor conditions of Action Report has been sent to the Action Report has been sent to (application no. 16747/12) 62/11) of the Nizhniy Novgorod detention in correctional CMCE: DH-OO(2017)862 the CMCE: 15.10.2015 Region facility DH-OO(2017)862 Another judgment was issued due from 31.01.2011 to the present day applicant's complaints. Information about its execution is reflected in paragraph 53 of the table (the case of Dandayev and Others) 5. Kolesnikovich Vladimir Vladimirovich Correctional colony no. 288/17 of Lack of appropriate Serving punishment The payment (in the amount of (application no. 44694/13) KOLESNIKOVICH Krasnoyarsk medical assistance in in FKU IK-17 facility of the Main EUR 15,090) was effected in full 12.09.2016 correctional facility Department of the Federal Service on 28.10.2016 in roubles as of from 11.09.2013 to the present day on Execution of Punishment of the the payment date (payment order Il was noted that during Russian Federation ("the GUFSIN of no. 304217 for the amount of the first 2 years medical Russia") for the Krasnoyarsk 1,024,992.78 roubles) without control was not carried Territory where he is provided with interest in connection to late out with respect to the adequate medical assistance provision of bank account details. DH-DD(2019)434: DH-DD(2019)434: Communication Russian the from Federation. Representative of a the request at distributed Documents responsibility sole the under be shall the said of Representative, without prejudice to the legal or political position of Ministers. Committee of the applicant, that in some complying with international The payment of legal costs and
cases the applicant was standards. expenses (in the amount of EUR
DGI not provided with the 1,000) was effected in full on
DES ARRETS DE LA CEDH LA DE ARRETS DES
17 AVR. 2019 AVR. 17 SERVICE DE L’EXECUTION L’EXECUTION DE SERVICE DH-DD(2019)434: Communication from the Russian Federation. Documents distributed at the request of a Representative shall be under the sole responsibility of the said
Representative, without prejudice to the legal or political position of the Committee of Ministers.
6. 6.
06.07.2017 06.07.2017
(application (application
Yudlna Yudlna
and and
no. no.
Others Others
12860/11) 12860/11)
MALTSEV MALTSEV
(application (application
Maksim Maksim
(no. (no.
Nikolay Nikolay
77799/14) 77799/14)
Pavlovich Pavlovich
Nikolayevich Nikolayevich
no. no.
55432/16) 55432/16)
TYURIN TYURIN
from from
IK-29 IK-29
from from
Sverdlovsk Sverdlovsk
IK-56, IK-56,
28.10.2011 28.10.2011
27.12.2010 27.12.2010
of of
Lozvinskiy Lozvinskiy
the the
Kirov Kirov
Region Region
to to
to to
Region Region
settlement, settlement,
the the
the the
present present
present present
the the
day day
2 2
day day
I I
I I
facility facility
detention detention
Poor Poor
facility facility
detention detention
Poor Poor
diagnosis diagnosis make make
carried carried
drugs, drugs,
hospitalization hospitalization compatibility compatibility
delivery delivery
assessment assessment
drugs drugs
conditions conditions
conditions conditions
an an
and and
and and
out out
of of
in in
accurate accurate
in in
the the
prescribed prescribed
timely timely
in in
correctional correctional
correctional correctional
of of
of of
2007 2007
was was
the the
of of
medicinal medicinal
of of
to to
not not
carried carried
disinfestation disinfestation
applicant applicant
maintained. maintained.
ventilation, ventilation, proper proper
sleeping sleeping
a a
according according
applicant applicant
sufficient sufficient
The The
standards, standards,
him. him.
complying complying
Russia Russia adequate adequate
in in
the the
Serving Serving
carried carried
outside outside
disinfestation disinfestation
applicant applicant ventilation, ventilation,
maintained. maintained.
proper proper
according according
applicant applicant
sleeping sleeping
a a
The The
sufficient sufficient
where where
him. him.
standards, standards,
complying complying for for
Federation Federation
of of
of of
in in
Serving Serving