FOAR & EIS Scoping Consultation Submissions Report
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
April 2018 Water Supply Project, Eastern and Midlands Region Final Options Appraisal / EIS Scoping Report Consultation Submissions Report A Plan for the Future of Water Services 1 | Irish Water | [Type Document Title] IW/FF/LDB/0115 Table of Contents 1. Executive summary ................................................................................................ 1 1.1 Introduction ........................................................................................... 1 1.2 Background ........................................................................................... 1 1.3 Consultation publicity and activity ......................................................... 1 1.4 Feedback from Fourth Public Consultation ........................................... 4 1.5 Response to Feedback from Fourth Public Consultation ...................... 4 1.6 Next steps ............................................................................................. 4 2. Introduction ............................................................................................................. 5 2.1 Project background ............................................................................... 5 2.2 Project development.............................................................................. 6 3. Consultation publicity and activity...................................................................... 11 3.1 Introduction ......................................................................................... 11 3.2 Publication of FOAR and EIS Scoping Report .................................... 12 3.3 Information materials ........................................................................... 13 3.4 Advertising .......................................................................................... 14 3.5 Media .................................................................................................. 15 3.6 Project website .................................................................................... 16 3.7 Landowner engagement ...................................................................... 18 3.8 Consultation events ............................................................................. 19 3.9 Direct engagement .............................................................................. 22 3.10 Information services and making submissions ................................. 31 4. Feedback from Fourth Public Consultation ....................................................... 32 4.1 Theme 1: The need for the project ...................................................... 34 4.2 Theme 2: Benefiting corridor ............................................................... 36 4.3 Theme 3: Alternative options ............................................................... 36 4.4 Theme 4: Planning .............................................................................. 38 4.5 Theme 5: Pipeline ............................................................................... 38 4.6 Theme 6: Construction and operation ................................................. 39 4.7 Theme 7: Environmental issues .......................................................... 41 4.8 Theme 8: Water .................................................................................. 47 4.9 Theme 9: Land use ............................................................................. 48 4.10 Theme 10: Project cost and funding ................................................ 52 4.11 Theme 11: Public consultation ......................................................... 52 4.12 Theme 12: Community gain ............................................................. 53 1 Irish Water | Consultation Submissions Report 5. Response to Feedback from Fourth Public Consultation ................................ 55 5.1 Theme 1: The need for the project ...................................................... 55 5.2 Theme 2: Benefiting corridor ............................................................... 64 5.3 Theme 3: Alternative options ............................................................... 65 5.4 Theme 4: Planning .............................................................................. 72 5.5 Theme 5: Pipeline ............................................................................... 74 5.6 Theme 6: Construction and operation ................................................. 78 5.7 Theme 7: Environmental Issues .......................................................... 82 5.8 Theme 8: Water .................................................................................. 91 5.9 Theme 9: Land use ............................................................................. 93 5.10 Theme 10: Project cost and funding ................................................ 99 5.11 Theme 11: Public consultation ....................................................... 101 5.12 Theme 12: Community gain ........................................................... 103 6. Next steps ............................................................................................................ 105 Irish Water | Consultation Submissions Report Table of Tables Table 3-1 Local planning authorities in the study area………………………………………12 Table 3-2 Summary of Radio Advertisement for Consultation……………………………...15 Table 3-3 Public Representatives contacted………………………………………………….22 Table 4-1 Themes arising from consultation………………………………………………….32 Table 5-1 Cost Benefit Analysis 2016………………………………………………………..100 Table of Figures Figure 1-1 Method of feedback received during the consultation period ................................................. 4 Figure 2-1 The Preferred Scheme (Abstraction from Parteen Basin and transferred via pipeline through the Midlands to Peamount, South County Dublin) .................................................................................... 6 Figure 2-2 WSP Project Consultation Roadmap ..................................................................................... 8 Figure 3-1 Advertising Channels ............................................................................................................. 15 Figure 3-2 Consultation Media Coverage ............................................................................................... 16 Figure 3-3 Project Website Homepage ................................................................................................... 17 Figure 3-4 Project Website Statistics ...................................................................................................... 18 Figure 3-5 Video Animation .................................................................................................................... 18 Figure 3-6 Landowner Information Evenings .......................................................................................... 20 Figure 3-7 Public Open Days .................................................................................................................. 21 Figure 4-1 Feedback received by communication channel .................................................................... 32 Figure 5-1 Leakage reductions in the GDWSA 2018 to 2050 ................................................................ 61 Figure 5-2 Groundwater abstraction ....................................................................................................... 71 Figure 5-3 Parteen Basin ........................................................................................................................ 93 Irish Water | Consultation Submissions Report 1. Executive summary 1.1 Introduction Over 1,000 stakeholders participated in the latest consultation stage of the preferred scheme and environmental impact assessment scoping report which ran from fourteen weeks from 8 November 2016 to the 14 February 2017. This Consultation Submissions Report details the consultation activities undertaken and sets out a summary of the feedback received from the fourth consultation, and the project team’s response to this feedback. 1.2 Background A new water supply source is needed for Irish Water’s Eastern and Midlands Region to deliver secure, reliable and sustainable long term water supplies to the region. In 2015 Irish Water embarked on an extensive four-stage public consultation process to identify a suitable new source of water supply for the region. The project which has identified Irish Water’s preferred new water supply scheme is titled ‘Water Supply Project, Eastern and Midlands Region’ abbreviated to WSP. After analysing feedback from four phases of public consultation, carrying out detailed on-the-ground investigations and computer modelling, abstraction from the Parteen Basin has been identified as the single option which delivers the widest benefit to the greatest number of people with the least environmental impact. The preferred new water supply scheme comprises the abstraction of water from the Lower River Shannon at Parteen Basin in County Tipperary, with water treatment nearby at Birdhill. Treated water would then be piped 170km to a termination point reservoir at Peamount in south County Dublin, enabling connection into the Greater Dublin water supply network. Supplies of treated water would be made available to Midland communities at a number of specified locations along the pipeline route from Parteen Basin to Dublin. 1.3 Consultation publicity and activity Public participation is an essential element of the development of any infrastructure