WU—Revision Draft
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
University of Hawaii Mail - Re: errata request https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0?ik=50495d6aa1&view=pt&search=all... Dore Minatodani <[email protected]> Re: errata request 1 message Alex Golub <[email protected]> Wed, Jul 21, 2021 at 3:13 PM To: Mingjen Wu <[email protected]>, Krystyna Aune <[email protected]> Cc: Dore Minatodani <[email protected]> Aloha everyone, Having reviewed this errata statement, I approve its inclusion in Mānoa’s official records. Let me know if you need anything else from me in this regard. Cheers, -A On Jan 18, 2021, 3:44 PM -1000, Krystyna Aune <[email protected]>, wrote: Hi Mingjen, Thank you for following up on this matter. Per our procedures regarding errata statements, you can proceed with Step 3. This entails you sending a draft of the errata statement to [email protected] and me at [email protected] for review. Include the following information in the statement: bibliographic citation of the original document library call number, or URL from ScholarSpace current date explanation of the issue being addressed by the errata statement corrections send in PDF format (not MS Word) After we approve the statement, you will then be asked to email the statement in PDF format to your committee chair for review, approval, and confirmation/verification. Best regards, Dean Aune ------------------------------------------------ Krystyna S. Aune, Ph.D Dean of Graduate Division University of Hawai‘i at Mānoa 2540 Maile Way, Spalding 360 Honolulu, HI 96822 (808) 956-7541 (phone) (808) 956-4261 (fax) ------------------------------------------------- On Mon, Jan 18, 2021 at 3:19 PM Mingjen Wu <[email protected]> wrote: Hi Dean Anue, I just want to keep track of my request. Let me know if I need to provide more information about the case or identity verification. 1 of 2 7/22/21, 1:33 PM University of Hawaii Mail - Re: errata request https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0?ik=50495d6aa1&view=pt&search=all... Best, Mingjen On Jan 6, 2021, 1:40 PM +0800, Mingjen Wu <[email protected]>, wrote: Hi Dean Aune, Thanks for your reply. In October, I got a complaint, via the UH library, from one of my consultants in the village where I conducted my dissertation fieldwork in Papua New Guinea (PNG). The complaint was about the leader's name of a specific clan in my dissertation (Table 6.1, page 163). Leadership and clan heads in the very village are very competitive, and the Table might give an impression that clan heads are fixed. I have phoned the complainant, and I need to address that issue and add an online errata to my dissertation. Best, Mingjen On Jan 6, 2021, 4:40 AM +0800, Krystyna Aune <[email protected]>, wrote: Hi Mingjen, I'm writing to follow up with you and with your advisor regarding the errata request for your dissertation. Can you provide me with more information about why this request is being made? It's unclear from the sentence in your 12/9 message to Graduate Division. Sincerely, Dean Aune ------------------------------------------------ Krystyna S. Aune, Ph.D Dean of Graduate Division University of Hawai‘i at Mānoa 2540 Maile Way, Spalding 360 Honolulu, HI 96822 (808) 956-7541 (phone) (808) 956-4261 (fax) ------------------------------------------------- 2 of 2 7/22/21, 1:33 PM Dissertation Errata Page Request Author: Ming-Jen Wu Graduation year: 2020 Department: Anthropology Degree: Ph.D. Bibliographic citation: Wu, Ming-Jen. 2020. “Sago and Kago: The History and Memory of Hiri on the Southeast Coast of Papua New Guinea.” diss., University of Hawaiʻi, Manoa. URL from ScholarSpace: http://hdl.handle.net/10125/68926 Explanation of the issue: Since my dissertation’s publication, the UHM library has received a complaint from informants of the very village where I conducted the dissertation fieldwork. In responding to the case, I request an online errata (ming-jenwu.com or https://web.archive.org/save/ https://ming-jenwu.com/new-page). The issue was about the names of leaders on a table in Chapter 6. Date: January 29, 2021 Online Errata Statement Table 6.1. on pages 162 and 163 of the dissertation attempts to show so-called clan leaders often occupy the position of deacons within churches, which is a common phenomenon among the Motu- Koita villages in Papua New Guinea. The leadership within clans and villages is competitive and contested, although it might be based on genealogy. Therefore, the table is not to valorize the political organization of the village. SAGO AND KAGO: THE HISTORY AND MEMORY OF HIRI ON THE SOUTHEAST COAST OF PAPUA NEW GUINEA A DISSERTATION SUBMITTED TO THE GRADUATE DIVISION OF THE UNIVERSITY OF HAWAI’I AT MĀNOA IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY IN ANTHROPOLOGY 2020 By Ming-Jen Wu Dissertation Committee Dr. Alex Golub (Chairperson) Dr. Jonathan Padwe Dr. Ty P. Kāwika Tengan Dr. Emanuel Drechsel Dr. Terence Wesley-Smith Abstract This dissertation is an account of the discourse of development, change, and tradition among the Motu-Koitabu population on the southeast coast of Papua New Guinea (PNG) since the development of the nation’s first liquefied natural gas (LNG) project in 2008. The material of the dissertation derives from fieldwork conducted over 18 months between late 2014 and mid-2016 and four months of archival research. Specifically, the fieldwork was mainly conducted among Motu language speakers around the liquefaction plant site, located 15 miles west of Port Moresby, the capital city of PNG. To understand social change, I explore a variety of aspects of the discourse of events—the hiri tradition, the Pacific Games, the PNG LNG infrastructure, and the church politics. Hiri, considered a tradition of the Motuans, was a trading system of pots for sago. The Motuans around Port Moresby manufactured pottery and exchanged their products for sago with the people of Kikori-Kerema in Gulf Province. It is believed that hiri had brought food, cargo, and prosperity to a highly sterile environment inhabited by the Motuans. The PNG LNG project has transported natural gas from the production field in the Highlands through the onshore pipeline to Kikori-Kerema, and then through the offshore pipeline from Kikori-Kerema to the liquefaction plant site. Some Motu people indicated that PNG LNG is like the traditional hiri, bringing prosperity and development to the coastal area. However, the project has resulted in a series of tussles, not only in the gas field region but also among the villages around the downstream plant site. In this dissertation, I attempt to show the longue durée of the Motu-Koitabu’s connection with the outside world to draw food, wealth, and resources toward them. Instead of seeing the colonial history and modern development of the southeast coast as a disruption or alienation, I attempt to demonstrate the Motu-Koitabu’s innovation in reproducing themselves in the infertile environment and in the lack of state services. ii Table of Contents ABSTRACT II TABLE OF CONTENTS III LIST OF FIGURES V LIST OF TABLES VI CHRONOLOGY OF KEY EVENTS IN PAPUA VII ABBREVIATIONS VIII ACKNOWLEDGMENTS IX CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION 1 ONE VILLAGE, FOUR MOMENTS 1 LITERATURE REVIEW 8 The politics of culture and cosmopolitanism 8 Anthropology of oil and spectacle 16 Church-state in Melanesia 24 CHAPTERS INTRODUCED 26 CHAPTER 2. THE ETHNOGRAPHIC AND HISTORICAL SETTINGS 31 THE LIFEWORLD OF THE MOTU-KOITABU 31 Landscape and the environment 31 Language and the people 36 The community and social life 40 THE ANTHROPOLOGY OF HIRI 44 Hiri as a trade for subsistence 45 Hiri as an ethnographic inquiry 48 DEVELOPMENTS OF RESOURCES AND LABOR AROUND PORT MORESBY 51 Mangrove exploitation 53 The cattle farm 55 Medical labor on Gemo Island 58 CONCLUSION 60 CHAPTER 3. HIRI MOALE FESTIVAL AND ITS POLITICS OF CULTURE 61 INTRODUCTION 61 FESTIVALS IN THE FIRST HALF OF THE 20TH CENTURY 67 THE HIRI MOALE FESTIVAL 72 The 1969 South Pacific Games 73 1971, 1972, 1976, and 1978—Port Moresby City Council 78 1979–1986—Suspension 81 1987–1990s—The NCDC 82 The mid-1990s–2000s—Motu-Koitabu Council/MKA 83 MULTIPLE RELATIONSHIPS BETWEEN BOERA, THE MKA, AND THE NCDC 84 THE DECENTRALIZATION OF TRADITION 92 CONCLUSION 95 CHAPTER 4. SPECTACULAR CEREMONIES OF THE PACIFIC GAMES AND NATURAL GAS DEVELOPMENT 98 INTRODUCTION 98 PNG LNG AND ITS EFFECTS 102 A brief history of oil and gas in PNG 102 From blessing to a curse? 107 iii Exclusion from land and sea 113 THE XVTH PACIFIC GAMES—THE UNPRECEDENTED GAMES 115 Wan Solwara 116 Hanuabada betel nut ban and the conflict 121 CONCLUSION 125 CHAPTER 5. YOUTH AND BODILY EXPERIENCES UNDER THE NATURAL GAS DEVELOPMENT PROJECT 131 INTRODUCTION 132 DISCOURSES OF LAZINESS, THE WEAK BODY, HUNGER, AND AIMLESSNESS 136 Body (tauanina) 137 “Laziness” 139 Kava 140 Hunger (“hitolo”) 143 THE YOUNG GENERATION AND MONEY WITCHCRAFT 145 The first story: The dog 146 The second story: “Teddy Bear” 147 The third story: Foreigners 148 Implications 148 CONCLUSION: BUMA 153 CHAPTER 6. THE CHURCH IS OUR GOVERNMENT 156 INTRODUCTION 156 CHRISTIANITY AS A TRADITION 159 Lagatoi theology 159 Political structure 161 The spatialization of the village 166 The church is our government 168 BAITA GOADA 172 Fewer participants in church activities 173 Not able to pray 176 Challenges from other denominations 178 CONCLUSION 180 CHAPTER 7. CONCLUSION 183 BEYOND HISTORICAL CONSCIOUSNESS 187 TRANSITION FROM PNG LNG TO PAPUA LNG 189 ENGAGING IN RESEARCH AND WRITING IN PNG 191 REFERENCE LISTS 195 MANUSCRIPTS 195 PATROL REPORTS 195 PUBLISHED WORKS 196 iv List of Figures Figure 1.1. The study area for the dissertation. ............................................................................... 4 Figure 2.1.