DOCSLIB.ORG

Hereof, Please Address Your Written Request to the New York University Annual Survey of American Law

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Hereof, Please Address Your Written Request to the New York University Annual Survey of American Law \\server05\productn\n\nys\66-2\front662.txt unknown Seq: 1 12-OCT-10 15:54 NEW YORK UNIVERSITY ANNUAL SURVEY OF AMERICAN LAW VOLUME 66 ISSUE 2 NEW YORK UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF LAW ARTHUR T. VANDERBILT HALL Washington Square New York City \\server05\productn\n\nys\66-2\front662.txt unknown Seq: 2 12-OCT-10 15:54 New York University Annual Survey of American Law is in its sixty-ninth year of publication. L.C. Cat. Card No.: 46-30523 ISSN 0066-4413 All Rights Reserved New York University Annual Survey of American Law is published quarterly at 110 West 3rd Street, New York, New York 10012. Subscription price: $30.00 per year (plus $4.00 for foreign mailing). Single issues are available at $16.00 per issue (plus $1.00 for foreign mailing). For regular subscriptions or single issues, contact the Annual Survey editorial office. Back issues may be ordered directly from William S. Hein & Co., Inc., by mail (1285 Main St., Buffalo, NY 14209-1987), phone (800- 828-7571), fax (716-883-8100), or email ([email protected]). Back issues are also available in PDF format through HeinOnline (http://heinonline.org). All articles copyright 2010 by the New York University Annual Survey of American Law, except when otherwise expressly indicated. For permission to reprint an article or any portion thereof, please address your written request to the New York University Annual Survey of American Law. Copyright: Except as otherwise provided, the author of each article in this issue has granted permission for copies of that article to be made for classroom use, provided that: (1) copies are distributed to students at or below cost; (2) the author and journal are identified on each copy; and (3) proper notice of copyright is affixed to each copy. Manuscripts: The Annual Survey invites the submission of unsolicited manuscripts. Text and citations should conform to the 18th edition of A Uniform System of Citation. Please enclose an envelope with return postage if you would like your manuscript returned after consideration. Editorial Office: 110 West 3rd Street, New York, N.Y. 10012 (212) 998-6540 (212) 995-4032 Fax http: //www.law.nyu.edu/pubs/annualsurvey \\server05\productn\n\nys\66-2\front662.txt unknown Seq: 4 12-OCT-10 15:54 iv \\server05\productn\n\nys\66-2\front662.txt unknown Seq: 5 12-OCT-10 15:54 NEW YORK UNIVERSITY ANNUAL SURVEY OF AMERICAN LAW 2009-2010 BOARD OF EDITORS Editor-in-Chief DANIELLE A. KANTOR Managing Editors DAVID K. LUKMIRE ANDREW OSORIO Development Editors Executive Article Editors Senior Articles Editor MICHAEL BLASIE STEPHANIE ARONZON JEANA BISNAR JOACHIM BENO STEINBERG ANTHONY BADARACCO ELIZABETH DONDLINGER CHRISTINA KUHN Note Editors KATHERINE MARSHALL Symposium Editor CLAIRE JAMES JOE RICHIE LAURA COLLINS JAMES A. LONG BENJAMIN A. SILVERMAN NIQUI WINDBERG Article Editors NATHANIEL H. BENFORADO ADRIAN C. GRIFFITHS DANIEL R. MARX ALFRED J. CHIANESE ALISON A. HAGGERTY CHRISTOPHER C. MCGUIRE DAVID W. EARLEY ROBERT M. HILTON MARK RIZIK ADAM B. FELSENTHAL DAVID P. IOZZI KENNETH J. SANOCKI NICOLE PIECHOWSKI FIELD FLORIN VALERIU IVAN MICHAEL R. SARINSKY NICHOLAS M. FOGG JOSHUA A. KASS CASEY E. SCHWARZ RYAN L. FORD KATHARINE M. LADD NATASHA SMALKY NICHOLAS R. FUNG JOANNE LEE JANINE M. TIEN MATTHEW A. GLICK ANDREW LICHTMAN CAROLINE W. WALDNER DAVID L. GOODWIN TRACY A. LUNDQUIST SHAWN MALHOTRA DAVID M. MARCUS Staff Editors JONAH ABRAMOWITZ HAYES HOLDERNESS JR.PHILIP N. PILMAR THOMAS ADAMS ANDREW S. JACOBS GIULIA STELLA PREVITI BRANDON ADONI ELISA KAO RYAN G. REIFFERT LINA BENSMAN MATTHEW M. KARLAN JARED ROSCOE ALLA BERENSHTEYN JOSH LEVY SARAH M. SCHOENBACH ALEXANDER S. BIRKHOLD ED LINTZ JOSH SIMPSON MATT BROWN ANDY LUTES ANDREW R. SPERL KATHERINE COMEAU JAIME A. MADELL DARRYL G. STEIN CLAIRE DECAMPO STEPHEN S. MAR ROBERT TAYLOR ISABELLE KINSOLVING FARRAR PAUL MILETIC JAMES M. THOMPSON EVA GARDNER ALEXANDER MINDLIN NEIL J. TOOMEY QAIS GHAFARY ALEXANDRA MITTER LERON THUMIM MATTHEW D. GIBBS MICHAEL MIX JASON VINOKUR COLIN GILLESPIE MICHAEL NADLER TIMES WANG JESSICA GREENBAUM NICOLLE NONKEN LENNOX WHITE JASON B. GUMER DAN PASSESER MADELYN K. WHITE Faculty Advisor HARRY FIRST \\server05\productn\n\nys\66-2\front662.txt unknown Seq: 6 12-OCT-10 15:54 vi \\server05\productn\n\nys\66-2\front662.txt unknown Seq: 7 12-OCT-10 15:54 SUMMARY OF CONTENTS ARTICLES CHALLENGES PRESENTED TO MILITARY LAWYERS REPRESENTING DETAINEES IN THE WAR ON TERRORISM Matthew Ivey 211 THE VETERANS’ JUDICIAL REVIEW ACT TWENTY YEARS LATER: CONFRONTING THE NEW COMPLEXITIES OF THE VETERANS BENEFITS SYSTEM James D. Ridgway 251 NOTES 100% CAPITALIST, 90% OF THE TIME: THE 20 DAY SHORT-SALE BAN Jeana Bisnar 299 SUBSTANTIVE CONSOLIDATION AND PARTIES’ INCENTIVES IN CHAPTER 11 PROCEEDINGS Scott R. Bowling 341 CAN THE COURTS TAME THE COMMUNICATIONS DECENCY ACT?: THE REVERBERATIONS OF ZERAN V. AMERICA ONLINE David Lukmire 371 \\server05\productn\n\nys\66-2\front662.txt unknown Seq: 8 12-OCT-10 15:54 viii \\server05\productn\N\NYS\66-2\NYS201.txt unknown Seq: 1 12-OCT-10 16:07 CHALLENGES PRESENTED TO MILITARY LAWYERS REPRESENTING DETAINEES IN THE WAR ON TERRORISM MATTHEW IVEY* INTRODUCTION On September 11, 2001, four planes were hijacked and used in attacks on the Pentagon and World Trade Center.1 In the days that followed, Congress authorized the use of military force against “those nations, organizations, or persons” determined to be respon- sible for these terrorist acts.2 In early October 2001, the United States and its allies launched missile and air strikes against the Taliban and al Qaeda in Afghanistan.3 In the ensuing fighting on the ground, many prisoners were captured and approximately 700 persons were sent to the facilities at Guantanamo Bay, some arriv- ing as early as January 11, 2002.4 In a Military Order dated November 13, 2001, President George W. Bush announced that military commissions would ad- minister trials of detainees captured in Iraq or Afghanistan who were believed to have “engaged in, aided or abetted, or conspired * Matthew Ivey is a Lieutenant in the United States Navy. The views expressed in this paper are the Author’s own. They do not necessarily represent the views of the Department of Defense, the United States Navy, or any of its components. The Author would like to thank Professor Frank R. Herrmann, S.J., for his guidance and mentorship on this project. The Author would also like to thank military prosecutors and defense lawyers for their assistance in researching this project, especially Lieutenant Colonel Colby C. Vokey, United States Marine Corps (retired). Finally, the Author would like to thank the staff of the New York University Annual Survey of American Law for their outstanding editorial assistance, especially Dominique Windberg and Daniel Passeser. 1. NAT’L COMM’NON TERRORIST ATTACKS UPON THE U.S., THE 9/11 COMM’N REPORT: FINAL REPORT OF THE NATIONAL COMMISSION ON TERRORIST ATTACKS UPON THE UNITED STATES (2003). 2. Authorization for Use of Military Force, Pub. L. No. 107-40, 115 Stat. 224 (2001) (codified as amended in 50 U.S.C. §§ 1541–48 (2006)) [hereinafter AUMF]. 3. Jason Straziuso, U.S. Plans for Longer Stay in Afghanistan, CHI. TRIB., Oct. 7, 2007, at 16. 4. See Carol D. Leonnig & Julie Tate, Some at Guantanamo Mark Five Years in Limbo; Big Questions About Low-Profile Inmates, WASH. POST, Jan. 16, 2007, at A1; Steve Vogel, U.S. Takes Hooded, Shackled Detainees to Cuba, WASH. POST, Jan. 11, 2002, at A10. 211 \\server05\productn\N\NYS\66-2\NYS201.txt unknown Seq: 2 12-OCT-10 16:07 212 NYU ANNUAL SURVEY OF AMERICAN LAW [Vol. 66:211 to commit, acts of international terrorism.”5 Pursuant to this order, Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld established procedures for military commissions.6 Thus, the United States has since faced a need to develop rules for military commissions that allow the na- tion to protect its security while adhering to international standards of human rights and respect for due process. Since their inception, these military commissions have been subject to controversy and legal challenges.7 President Barack Obama described the events of the past seven years at Guantanamo Bay as a “sad chapter in American history” and promised to close down the prison.8 On January 21, 2009, President Obama ordered the suspension of all prosecutions of Guantanamo Bay detainees for 120 days to allow his administration to review all detainee cases.9 Shortly thereafter, President Obama issued an executive order mandating the closure of Guantanamo Bay within a year.10 Al- though President Obama has called for review of all detainee files and for the closure of the facility within the year,11 his plans have seen some setbacks. Many of the detainees have incomplete or nonexistent files.12 Further, although some detainees have been cleared for release, there has been difficulty in the repatriation pro- cess in parent countries.13 Undoubtedly, the U.S. government will continue to have to make difficult decisions regarding the legal process afforded to detainees at Guantanamo. Of the 700 detain- 5. Military Order of Nov. 13, 2001, Detention, Treatment, and Trial of Cer- tain Non-Citizens in the War Against Terrorism, 66 Fed. Reg. 57,833 (Nov. 16, 2001). 6. See Department of Defense Military Commission Order No. 1 (Mar. 21, 2002), available at http://www.defense.gov/news/Mar2002/d20020321ord.pdf. 7. See, e.g., Mary Cheh, Should Lawyers Participate in Rigged Systems? The Case of the Military Commissions, 1 J. NAT’L SEC. L. & POL’Y 375, 379 (2005); Joshua L. Dratel, Ethical Issues in Defending a Terrorism Case: How Secrecy and Security Impair the Defense of a Terrorism Case, 2 CARDOZO PUB.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • “You Probably Don't Know Who Or What You Are Talking About”: Cultural and Moral
    Brown et al. Justice Policy Journal, Spring 2015 “You probably don't know who or what you are talking about”: Cultural and Moral Incompetence in Evaluating the Veteran in the Criminal Justice System William Brown1, Robert Stanulis2, Misty Weitzel3 and Kyle Rodgers4 Justice Policy Journal Volume 12, Number 1 (Spring) © Center on Juvenile and Criminal Justice 2015 www.cjcj.org/jpj Abstract The topic veterans entangled in criminal justice is not novel. Veterans have often been used to occupy jail cells and fill empty prison beds since at least the end of the Civil War. Massive numbers of World War I veterans made the transition from war to prison. While there are no specific data regarding World War II veterans and criminal justice encounters, the Vietnam War produced many veterans who landed in prison. Today many Iraq and Afghanistan veterans are beginning the long process from war to jail and prison. Historically, the criminal justice system, along with much of the general public, has ignored the intricate details of military culture and the impact that culture plays on veterans trying to find their place in the civilian culture. The primary purpose of this article is to awaken and educate those in the criminal justice system about the importance of cultural competency when it comes to processing veterans through the criminal justice system. We also introduce the 1 Department of Criminal Justice, Western Oregon University 2 Clinical Psychologist, Veterans Advisory Board, Western Oregon University 3 Department of Criminal Justice, Western Oregon University 4 Department of Criminal Justice, Western Oregon University Corresponding Author: William Brown Email: [email protected] or [email protected] Phone: 503-269-6065 “You probably don’t know who or what you are talking about” 1 importance of employing a multidisciplinary approach to enable a comprehensive understanding of the plight of veterans as they attempt to re-acculturate back into civilian communities.
    [Show full text]
  • Early Bird, Coast Behind a "Line of Death." the Danger of War January 9, 2008
    CURRENTNEWS EARLYBIRD January 10, 2008 Use of these news articles does not reflect official endorsement. Reproduction for private use or gain is subject to original copyright restrictions. Story numbers indicate order of appearance only. IRAQ 1. Blast Kills 6 As Troops Hunt Iraqi Insurgents (Washington Post)....Amit R. Paley and Joshua Partlow The explosion of a booby-trapped house killed six American soldiers on Wednesday during an offensive against Sunni insurgents in Diyala province, making it the deadliest day for U.S. troops in Iraq since November. 2. Booby Trap Kills 6 U.S. Soldiers In Iraq (Los Angeles Times)....Alexandra Zavis and Julian E. Barnes Senior Sunni Arab insurgents may have fled the Diyala River valley this week just as U.S. troops were preparing to attack, but they left behind a deadly calling card. 3. For U.S., The Goal Is Now 'Iraqi Solutions' (Washington Post)....Thomas E. Ricks and Karen DeYoung In the year since President Bush announced he was changing course in Iraq with a troop "surge" and a new strategy, U.S. military and diplomatic officials have begun their own quiet policy shift. After countless unsuccessful efforts to push Iraqis toward various political, economic and security goals, they have decided to let the Iraqis figure some things out themselves. 4. ’05 Use Of Gas By Blackwater Leaves Questions (New York Times)....James Risen The helicopter was hovering over a Baghdad checkpoint into the Green Zone, one typically crowded with cars, Iraqi civilians and United States military personnel. 5. New Estimate Of Violent Deaths Among Iraqis Is Lower (Washington Post)....David Brown and Joshua Partlow A new survey estimates that 151,000 Iraqis died from violence in the three years following the U.S.-led invasion of the country.
    [Show full text]
  • UN Assistance Mission for Iraq 1
    ﺑﻌﺜﺔ اﻷﻣﻢ اﻟﻤﺘﺤﺪة .UN Assistance Mission for Iraq 1 ﻟﺘﻘﺪﻳﻢ اﻟﻤﺴﺎﻋﺪة ﻟﻠﻌﺮاق (UNAMI) Human Rights Report 1 July – 31 December 2007 Table of Contents Executive Summary .....................................................................................................2 Recommendations.........................................................................................................4 Recommendations to the Government of Iraq.................................................................5 Recommendations to the Kurdistan Regional Government.............................................6 Recommendations to the Multinational Force – Iraq ......................................................7 Protection of Human Rights .....................................................................................7 Extrajudicial executions, targeted and indiscriminate killings ........................................7 Targeted killing of professional groups, government employees and religious figures 10 Civilian deaths involving private security contractors...................................................11 Civilian deaths in the context of MNF military operations ...........................................12 Situation of women........................................................................................................14 Situation of minorities and other groups........................................................................16 Freedom of expression and the targeting of media workers..........................................18
    [Show full text]
  • KPCC-KPCV-KUOR Quarterly Report JAN-MAR 2012
    Quarterly Programming Report Jan- Mar 2012 KPCC / KPCV / KUOR Date Key Synopsis Guest/Reporter Duration Pasadena Police Department will deploy more officers as Occupy activists plan to demonstrate at the 1/1/2012 POLI Rose Parade. CC :19 Skiers and snowboarders across the western United States face a "snow drought" this winter on some 1/1/2012 SPOR of their favorite slopes. Unknown :16 The three-year old Clean Trucks Program at the ports of Los Angeles and Long Beach moves into its 1/1/2012 TRAN final phase as the year begins. Peterson :58 1/1/2012 LAW Another dozen arson fires broke out overnight in Los Angeles and West Hollywood. CC :17 1/1/2012 ART Native American creation story and bird songs come alive in new Riverside art exhibition. Cuevas 1:33 1/1/2012 MEDI We asked KPCC listeners to look back on 2011 and ahead to 2012. CC :13 1/1/2012 DC Congressmangpyy shares a New Year's Day breakfast recipe. Felde 1:33 contract with United Teachers Los Angeles – an unprecedented agreement that Deasy called “groundbreaking work,” aimed at providing more freedom for teachers, school administrators and 1/2/12 YOUT parents top,gpggpp, manage their respective schools. John Deasy 00:31 of course. Comedy Congress has hung up its Christmas stocking and finds it full of Mitt and Newt and Barack – and it’s our holiday gift to you. Perry ups the voting age; Obama very politely asks Iran for his Alonzo Bodden, Greg 1/2/12 POLI drone back and we play the highlight reel of Cain’s self-described brain twirlings! And just as we thoughtProops, Ben Gleib 00:65 Dr.
    [Show full text]
  • Differences in Accountability Types Affecting Public Military and Private Military Actors
    Differences in accountability types affecting Public Military and Private Military Actors. The cases of the Haditha Killings and Nisour Square Killings Master of Science Crisis and Security Management Master Thesis Name: Hendrik Bruno Weijenborg Student ID: s1749838 Thesis Supervisor: Dr. J. Matthys Second reader: Dr A. van Leeuwen Date: July, 2016 Abstract The use and deployment of private military companies (PMCs) operating alongside the public army has increased considerably last decades, especially with the U.S. government’s continuous budget cuts. However, issues on how to hold them accountable for civilian deaths during armed conflicts in foreign countries have been the subject of much debate, media coverage and is poorly understood. Therefore, the present research aimed at investigating the differences in accountability types between public military and private military. Accountability is a contested concept as it is widely used and is based on the nature of the forum, actor, conduct and obligation. Based on Bovens accountability framework (2010), in this thesis these aspects of accountability are investigated for the involvement of U.S. public military (i.e. U.S. Marines) in the Haditha massacre (2005) and PMC (i.e. Blackwater guards) in the Nisour Square massacre (2007) in Iraq. These cases were selected on basis of their similarity, while having a clear different actor background, the U.S. Department of Defense (DoD) and PMC respectively. In total 262 newspaper articles, 1 press release and 7 official documents produced by the U.S. Courts, U.S. Marines Corps, UN Working Group, OHCHR Press Release were analysed. The present research makes clear that the major differences observed in accountability types between public military and private military are at the within the nature of the forum, especially within the legal and political domain.
    [Show full text]
  • Usd Magazine
    W E C A N N O T L E A R N H O W T O L I V E T O G E T H E R I N P E A C E B Y K I L L I N G E A C H O T H E R ’ S C H I L D R E N . USD UNIVERSITY OF SAN DIEGO /SPRING 2007 MAGAZINE . USD MAGAZINE D UNIVERSITY OF SAN DIEGO / SPRING 2007 R A W E R N FEATURES M AY PEACE BE WITH YOU. W O S 14 / WHY IS THERE WAR? T I How can we not be perplexed by war, the destroyer of S families, of cities, and of nations? A political science I professor ponders the big questions. E C A E 16 / BLESSED ARE THE PEACEMAKERS P Training graduates to cool off global hot spots isn’t easy, but USD’s School of Peace Studies and the Joan B. Kroc E Institute for Peace & Justice are up to the task. N I Z A DEPARTMENTS G A AROUND THE PARK M 4 / Commitment to Safety D It’s a big responsibility, but Public Safety has S a handle on keeping students safe on campus. U 6 / Fresh New Look 10 USD’s revamped logo is part of the university’s push to reinforce Catholicity and brand itself for the 21st century. 7 / Save the Date Autism Conference, Grandparents Weekend, Kyoto Laureate 30WOUNDS INTO WISDOM. Symposium, Alumni Honors. ON THE COVER: 8 / Serenity Seekers POINT OF VIEW Illustration by School of Peace Studies students Monya Kian, Yusuf Gawany and 12 / The Chrysalis Effect Barbara Ferguson Zacharia Akol are blazing a trail of peace around the globe.
    [Show full text]
  • Report on Human Rights in Iraq: 2011
    Report on Human Rights HUMAN RIGHTS Office of the in Iraq: 2011 High Commissioner for Human Rights UNAMI Human Rights Office/OHCHR, Baghdad UNITED NATIONS Assistance Mission for Iraq (UNAMI) Human Rights Office Report on Human Rights in Iraq: 2011 UNAMI HUMAN RIGHTS OFFICE and OFFICE OF THE HIGH COMMISSIONER FOR HUMAN RIGHTS May 2012 Baghdad Map of Iraq Source: United Nations Department for Peacekeeping Operations Cartographic Section, 2011 Table of Contents Recommendations ........................................................................................................................................ iii Kurdistan Region ................................................................................................................................... viii Human Rights in Iraq: 2011 .......................................................................................................................... 1 1. Introduction ............................................................................................................................................... 1 1.1 Overview ........................................................................................................................................................................ 1 2. Armed Conflict and Civilians ................................................................................................................... 2 2.1 Civilian casualties ..............................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • 2010 Report on Human Rights in Iraq
    2010 Report on HUMAN RIGHTS Office of the High Commissioner Human Rights in Iraq for Human Rights UNAMI Human Rights Office/OHCHR, Baghdad UNITED NATIONS Assistance Mission for Iraq (UNAMI) Human Rights Office JANUARY 2011 2010 Report on Human Rights in Iraq UNAMI HUMAN RIGHTS OFFICE and OFFICE OF THE HIGH COMMISSIONER FOR HUMAN RIGHTS January 2011 Baghdad Map of Iraq Source: UN DPKO - Cartographic Centre, NY (2004) Table of Contents Executive Summary ..........................................................................................................................iii Recommendations .............................................................................................................................vi Human Rights in Iraq: 2010 .............................................................................................................1 1. Introduction....................................................................................................................................1 1.1 Overview............................................................................................................................................... 1 1.2 Legal responsibilities ............................................................................................................................ 1 2. Armed conflict and civilians .........................................................................................................3 2.1 Civilian casualties ................................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • University of San Diego /Spring 2007 Bykillingeachother’Schildren
    USD MAGAZINE UNIVERSITY OF SAN DIEGO /SPRING 2007 BYKILLINGEACHOTHER’SCHILDREN. TOGETHERINPEACE WECANNOTLEARNHOWTOLIVE USD MAGAZINE I NJUSTICE ANYWHERE IS A THREAT TO JUSTICE EVERYWHERE. UNIVERSITY OF SAN DIEGO / SPRING 2007 CONTENTST HE STORY ALWAYS OLD AND ALWAYS NEW. FEATURES M AY PEACE BE WITH YOU. 14 / WHY IS THERE WAR? 20 / GREETING THE How can we not be perplexed by war, the destroyer of TENSE NEW DAWN families, of cities, and of nations? A political science When the people took to professor ponders the big questions. the streets in Nepal, the IPJ was there. 16 / BLESSED ARE THE PEACEMAKERS PEACEISITSOWNREWARD. Training graduates to cool off global hot spots isn’t easy, 30 / BACK FROM but USD’s School of Peace Studies and the Joan B. Kroc THE BRINK Institute for Peace & Justice are up to the task. As Oct. 2006, the bloodiest 24 month in a year for U.S. troops in Iraq, wound down, 24 / THE DEFENSE NEVER RESTS DEPARTMENTS Chris Simonds ’05 was Military defense attorney Neal A. Puckett ’89 (L.L.M.) thankful to be alive after doesn’t shy away from high-profile clients. Why should he? AROUND THE PARK taking a bullet in the back. He’s never lost a case. 4 / Commitment to Safety It’s a big responsibility, but Public Safety has BEAD BY BEAD. a handle on keeping students safe on campus. CLASS NOTES USDMAGAZINE 6 / Fresh New Look 10 CAMPAIGN CORNER CLASS NOTES USD’s revamped logo is part of the university’s push to 32 / The Future is Now 36 / Maritime Man reinforce Catholicity and brand itself for the 21st century.
    [Show full text]
  • Civilian Death and Injury in Iraq, 2003-20111 Neta C. Crawford Boston University September 2011 ''I Would Say 30,000, More Or Le
    Civilian Death and Injury in Iraq, 2003-20111 Neta C. Crawford Boston University September 2011 ''I would say 30,000, more or less, have died as a result of the initial incursion and the ongoing violence against Iraqis." George W. Bush, December 20052 In March 2003 the U.S. and others in its coalition invaded Iraq. We know the number of U.S. soldiers killed in the war in Iraq. We know their names and how they died. The number of Iraqi civilians killed due to the Iraq war, however has been hotly debated.3 The Iraq war was undertaken to end the (illusory) threat of weapons of mass destruction possibly under construction in Iraq and to install a democracy. Because the legitimacy of the cause of the Iraq war was controversial from the outset, the human costs of the war have been under intense scrutiny. I estimate that at least 126,000 Iraqi civilians have died as a direct consequence of the war's violence. This is an extremely conservative estimate based on what has been documented by public sources. To understand the complete toll of the Iraq War, to this estimate of civilian killed from 2003, one must add the estimate approximately 10,000 Iraqi military killed at the outset of the war, the approximately 19,000 insurgents killed from June 2003-September 2007, the more than 10,100 Iraqi military and police killed since June 2003 and the nearly 6,300 U.S. and allied soldiers and U.S. contractors killed in the war. Total direct violent deaths are thus 171,000: about 165,000 Iraqis and 6,300 US and allied soldiers and contractors.4 Many thousands more Iraqis have been wounded by bombs, bullets, and the fire that is often triggered by bombing.
    [Show full text]
  • Volume 15, 2012 Correspondents' Reports
    YEARBOOK OF INTERNATIONAL HUMANITARIAN LAW — VOLUME 15, 2012 CORRESPONDENTS’ REPORTS Contents Overview — United States Penal Sanctions Against Its Service Members For Violations of International Humanitarian Law................................................................................................1 Cases — United States Military Courts — United States Army ...............................................4 Cases — United States Military Courts — United States Marine Corps ..................................7 Cases — United States Military Courts — United States Navy..............................................10 1 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA Overview — United States Penal Sanctions Against Its Service Members For Violations of International Humanitarian Law In 2012 the United States military deployment as part and in support of Operation Enduring Freedom in Afghanistan reached the eleven-year mark. Over 100,000 US service members were deployed to Afghanistan at the start of 2012. Yet by July, the US withdrew over 20,000 troops in accordance with President Barack Obama’s plan to drawdown US force levels in Afghanistan. This operation represented the vast majority of US military involvement in armed conflict in 2012, the remainder being exponentially smaller special operations missions in places other than Afghanistan, including US drone strikes in Pakistan, Somalia, and Yemen. 2012 saw several instances whereby the US publicly disclosed aspects of its drone strike program, including President Obama discussing the CIA’s role during a town hall webcam chat in January,2 a news story on US ‘kill lists’ in May,3 and the White House declassifying and releasing portions of a letter Obama sent to the US Congress on US military operations. 4 Accordingly, combat operations in Afghanistan account for the overwhelming number of instances where US service members were applying, and in the cases described below, violating, international humanitarian law (IHL)/the law of armed conflict in 2012.
    [Show full text]
  • Jonasova, Jana (2017) Outsourcing Sustainability in US Expeditionary
    Outsourcing Sustainability in US Expeditionary Operations: The Contribution of Private Military and Security Industry in Phase IV Operations in Iraq 2003-2011 Jana Jonasova Thesis submitted to the University of Nottingham for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy November 2016 ii Abstract This thesis examines the contribution of the Private Military and Security Industry (PMSI), as an element of the United States (US) total force, to the US military capability in pursuing Phase IV Operations in Iraq from 2003 until 2011. In order to do so, the study proposes a typology of five types of contribution categories which define the link between the ends demanded by the US government (strategic goals) and the use of the PMSI as a tool to help achieve them. By incorporating a model from the operations management field, the Hayes and Wheelwright's Four-Stage model, this thesis identifies the categories of Assistant, Implementer, Crucial Supporter, Driver, and Spoiler as distinct forms of engagement, constituting a framework for the assessment of the nature of the relationship between the contractors’ activities and the strategic goals they sought to help achieve. Applied to the case studies of armed private security services and base support services, this framework reveals that contractors became the Crucial Supporter of the US military efforts in Phase IV Operations in Iraq. In the aftermath of the ill-planned regime-change, followed by unforeseen operational circumstances on the ground, and constrained by the US domestic policy reservations towards prolonged nation-building efforts, the US government found both armed security contractors and base support contractors to be a critical asset of the US military strategy on the ground.
    [Show full text]