Palo 6°Ê888]Ê ÕLiÀÊ£ÈÊUÊ>Õ>ÀÞÊÓÎ]ÊÓää N xäZ Alto Business license tax proposed Page 3
www.PaloAltoOnline.com
Eyewitness to history Locals relate personal experiences of the Inauguration page 18
Movies 35 Eating Out 37 Crossword/Sudoku 64 N Sports Stanford men emerge from own tennis shadow Page 26 N Arts & Entertainment Musical vagabonds return to Palo Alto Page 31 N Home & Real Estate Take a deep breath — indoors Page 41 @6É6E:=6/HJGK>K:9 6CJCEG:8:9:CI:9-% =DJGHL>I=DJI6A>K:G 8JGG:CIAN/A:6K>C< I=:B:9>8>C:IDBDB#
?JHI6CDI=:GG:B6G@67A:96N>CI=:C:><=7DG=DD9# Nine years ago, Ka’apeha was in dire need of a new liver. Until they could find a suitable donor, Ka’apeha’s doctors gave him the next best thing: time. They did it using a new method of “liver assistance” known as CVVH (continuous venovenous hemofiltration). The treatment was unconventional to say the least. But CVVH allowed Ka’apeha to remain stable until a donor © 2009 Lucile Packard Children’s Hospital became available (an unprecedented 80 hours). The results were ideal. Ka’apeha got a healthy new liver and his mom, Averi, got a healthy new profession. She was so inspired by the care her son received that she changed her career path. Today she works at Packard Children’s Hospital Lucile Packard as a nurse. And Ka’apeha, well, he spends his time elsewhere. Children’s Hospital Visit www.lpch.org for more information. AT STANFORD
Page 2ÊUÊ>Õ>ÀÞÊÓÎ]ÊÓääÊUÊ*>ÊÌÊ7iiÞ UpfrontLocal news, information and analysis Business tax could be on November ballot Facing budget shortfalls, Palo Alto ponders start participating in its enactment. “I encourage you guys to be real “The goal of staff is to ensure we As City Council member John Bar- clear, as a business group, about what don’t put a burden on the business collecting revenue from businesses ton told a Chamber of Commerce it is that’s important to you,” Barton community,” Perez said. audience Wednesday, many voters said. “You’re going to influence it by Just about every city in Cali- by Gennady Sheyner would see this proposal as a “slam being united, by being clear about fornia has some sort of business- reating a new tax in the midst With the city facing a $2.6 million- dunk” and would likely support it. what you want, and by participating license tax, Perez said, with Palo of a recession is never a popu- and-growing fiscal gap in this year’s Because the tax would require ap- in every step of the way.” Alto being a rare exception. Some, C lar proposition, even a tax with budget, and a projected gap of $5.3 proval from only 50 percent of the But the details remain fuzzy. including San Mateo, Menlo Park as appetizing a name as the BLT. million next year, city officials be- voters, the proposal’s passage may Staff and consultants have been and East Palo Alto, base their But as business leaders learned lieve most residents would support be inevitable, in his estimation. compiling a list of local businesses taxes on gross receipts and gener- Wednesday morning, Palo Alto’s the new tax, which could keep the Business owners ought not to fight over the past few months and sur- ate $2.9 million, $1.3 million and long-discussed but never actualized city from cutting services. the tax, but rather, clearly communi- veying surrounding communities $400,000 in revenue per year, re- plan to institute a business-license The prospect of a BLT may seem cate their concerns to city officials to see what methodologies they use spectively. tax could be on the ballot as early as scary to some business owners, but between now and November, the for taxing their business, said Lalo The average annual tax rates at this November — whether or not the many were urged Wednesday to earliest time the proposal could face Perez, the city’s director of admin- business community approves of it. stop opposing the new tax and to the voters, Barton said. istrative services. (continued on page 8)
EDUCATION District proposes two stories for Garland Palo Alto school district is taking into account earthquake-safety standards by Emilie Doolittle o make room for more class- rooms, the Palo Alto Unified T School District is considering adding two-story buildings to Gar- land Elementary School before it re-opens in 2010. The district staff presented sever- al design concepts for the Garland campus at a Board of Education meeting Jan. 13. The elementary school site, located next to Jordan Middle School and currently leased by the private Stratford School, would be re-opened by the district in November 2010. The retrofitted North California Avenue campus would have a new
Dana Ullman library, multipurpose room and 24 classrooms. Construction would be- gin in June 2010. “This community is not ready for two-story buildings,” Superinten- Funds needed to keep donkeys ‘out to pasture’ dent Kevin Skelly said. However, Barron Park neighborhood’s two donkeys, Niner (right) and Perry, graze in their pen at Bol Park last week. Their caretakers are seeking “The safest place for our kids is in funds to secure future veterinary care. See story on page 13. these two-story buildings. ... There is a safety element in these build- ings that you won’t find in shopping ect, which includes a grocery store, lic hearing for Alma Plaza, at the malls and other buildings.” CITY COUNCIL 37 homes, a commercial building Nov. 19 meeting of the Planning and The new facilities would have to with 14 below-market-rate apart- Transportation Commission. Mem- adhere to seismic-safety standards ments, a park and a community bers of the neighborhood group in accordance with the California Battle over Alma Plaza’s room. “Friends of Alma Plaza” and several Building Code, he noted. Several issues are expected to planning commissioners argued at Skelly also said that the district come into play Monday night, in- that time that the room should be would like community input regard- future resumes Monday cluding how the South Palo Alto open throughout the day and char- ing design concepts for Garland. development in the 3400 block of acterized the proposed time restric- “We want to be good neighbors City Council to discuss mixed-use project, Alma Street would be subdivided tions as a bait-and-switch tactic by with the process,” Skelly said. community room hours and whether the proposed commu- the developer. Elisa De Martel lives next to nity room could still be considered a McNellis has vehemently denied Garland and has four children, one by Gennady Sheyner public benefit if it’s closed between any switch, citing early discussions who attends Stratford School, and fter 14 public hearings span- milestone Monday night. 11 a.m. and 7 p.m. daily, as the de- about the time restrictions on use a baby who will attend Garland El- ning more than two years, That’s when the City Council is veloper has proposed. of the room due to peak shopping ementary. A John McNellis’ effort to rede- scheduled to discuss and possibly The community room emerged velop Alma Plaza could hit a crucial decide on the widely debated proj- as a hot-button issue at the last pub- (continued on page 11) (continued on page 9) *>ÊÌÊ7iiÞÊUÊ>Õ>ÀÞÊÓÎ]ÊÓääÊU Page 3 703 HIGH STREET, PALO ALTO, CA 94302 (650) 326-8210 Our PUBLISHER William S. Johnson EDITORIAL AND Jay Thorwaldson, Editor Jocelyn Dong, Managing Editor Carol Blitzer, Associate Editor Town Keith Peters, Sports Editor by Don Kazak Tyler Hanley, Express™ and Online Editor Rebecca Wallace, Arts & Entertainment Editor Rick Eymer, Assistant Sports Editor Tony Ciampi’s vindication Don Kazak, Senior Staff Writer Emilie Doolittle, Gennady Sheyner, Staff Writers t was one of those cases that timony, then burst out of his van, Sue Dremann, Staff Writer, Special Sections Editor Karla Kane, Editorial Assistant turn up on the daily police log yelled at the officers, and went Veronica Weber, Staff Photographer I and get a few paragraphs on- back into his van, slamming the Jeanne Aufmuth, Dale Bentson, Colin Becht, line or in the paper. door. Kit Davey, Iris Harrell, Jack McKinnon, Susan Tavernetti, Robert Taylor, Contributors Palo Alto police rousted a home- An officer then opened the van Megan Rawlins, Susan Robles, Johanna Toivio, less man who had been living in door and another then reached into Kris Young, Editorial Interns his van in a residential neighbor- the van and pulled Ciampi out of DESIGN hood just south of downtown. it, resulting in the melee in which Shannon Corey, Design Director The homeless man, Tony Ciam- Diane Haas, Sue Peck, Senior Designers Ciampi struck all three officers. Dana James, Paul Llewellyn, Scott Peterson, pi, 42, was arrested for assaulting The story just gets worse for the Designers police officers. It seemed to a be police. PRODUCTION clear-cut case because if you hit a One officer testified that he Jennifer Lindberg, Production Manager cop that’s a crime. thought Ciampi was a drug user be- Dorothy Hassett, Blanca Yoc, Sales & Production Coordinators There is no question, according cause of pock marks on his arms, ADVERTISING to police testimony, that Ciampi which he cited as justification for Walter Kupiec, Advertising Director fought with three police officers pulling Ciampi out of his van. Cathy Norfleet, Display Advertising Sales Asst. until he was subdued when one of- But Ciampi is an Army veteran Judie Block, Janice Hoogner, Gary Whitman, Display Advertising Sales ficer used his Taser on Ciampi not and has been treated at the Palo Kathryn Brottem, Real Estate Advertising Sales once but twice to subdue him. Alto VA Hospital for a skin con- Joan Merritt, Real Estate Advertising Asst. The arrest happened last March dition that leaves pock mocks on David Cirner, Irene Schwartz, Inside Advertising Sales 15 and the charges against Ciampi his arms. Alicia Santillan, Classified Administrative Asst. were dismissed by Santa Clara Judge Barrett ruled that the Palo EXPRESS, ONLINE AND VIDEO SERVICES County Superior Court Judge Alto police violated the Constitu- Rachel Palmer, Online Operations Coordinator Thang Nugyen Barrett in mid- tional rights of Ciampi by illegally Molly Stenhouse, Online Sales Consultant December. enticing him to leave his van in the ŀ BUSINESS The arrest initially came to the first place, which made everything Haleh Yee, Manager of Payroll & Benefits Paula Mulugeta, Senior Accountant Weekly’s attention because this else they did illegal. Elena Dineva, Mary McDonald, Cathy was a “Taser case,” only the sec- The cops do screw things up Stringari, Doris Taylor, Business Associates ond time Palo Alto police had once in a while, and this was one ADMINISTRATION used an electronic Taser to subdue of those times. Amy Renalds, Assistant to the Publisher & Promotions Director someone. Ron Eadie thought so, too. Janice Covolo, Receptionist; Ruben Espinoza, But it wasn’t just a Taser case. He and his wife attended the Jorge Vera, Couriers Instead, it was a case about the court hearings. EMBARCADERO PUBLISHING CO. Constitutional right that protects “I’ve known Tony for 12 or 15 William S. Johnson, President citizens from unlawful searches years,” Eadie said. They’re part of Michael I. Naar, Vice President & CFO Walter Kupiec, Vice President, Sales & Marketing by the police. a group that has morning coffee to- Robert Stetson, Director of Marketing Judge Barrett sided with the gether in downtown Palo Alto. Frank A. Bravo, Director, Computer Operations Constitution. “I admire Tony for his charac- & Webmaster Connie Jo Cotton, Major Accounts Sales Manager I’m in court often covering hear- ter,” Eadie said. “He has friends Bob Lampkin, Director, Circulation & Mailing ings and I talk with police every who admire him. He’s usually very Services Alicia Santillan, Susie Ochoa, day about what’s happening in the quiet.” Circulation Assistants community, so I’m inclined to be Normally, supporters of criminal Chris Planessi, Chip Poedjosoedarmo, sympathetic to the cops. They have defendants are family members, Oscar Rodriguez, Computer System Associates a tough, thankless job. Most of the not retired Navy captains, like The Palo Alto Weekly (ISSN 0199-1159) is criminal defendants I see in court Eadie. He served on a destroyer published every Friday by Embarcadero Publishing Co., 703 High St., Palo Alto, CA 94302, (650) deserve to be handcuffed and in escort in the later stages of the 326-8210. Periodicals postage paid at Palo Alto, orange jail clothing. Korean War. He also played in the CA and additional mailing offices. Adjudicated a newspaper of general circulation for Santa Clara But the Palo Alto police messed 1952 Rose Bowl as a member of County. The Palo Alto Weekly is delivered free to this one up and now the city may Stanford’s football team. homes in Palo Alto, Menlo Park, Atherton, Portola be liable. Ciampi said he is going “I’m usually sympathetic to cops Valley, East Palo Alto, to faculty and staff house- holds on the Stanford campus and to portions of to sue. because I come from a family of Los Altos Hills. If you are not currently receiving The March 15 arrest started with cops and firemen in Chicago,” the paper, you may request free delivery by calling a call from resident Ken Alsman, Eadie said. 326-8210. POSTMASTER: Send address changes to Palo Alto Weekly, P.O. Box 1610, Palo Alto, which was played in court. Alsman “We’re kind of hoping it gets CA 94302. Copyright ©2009 by Embarcadero complained that a man had been thrown out,” he added, shortly Publishing Co. All rights reserved. Reproduction sleeping in a van in front of his before Barrett dismissed charges without permission is strictly prohibited. Printed by SFOP, Redwood City. The Palo Alto Weekly is avail- home and made his wife uncom- against Ciampi. able on the Internet via Palo Alto Online at: fortable. Now, if Ciampi carries out his www.PaloAltoOnline.com Three Palo Alto officers re- threat to sue, the city will likely Our e-mail addresses are: [email protected], [email protected], [email protected]. sponded. The cops were unable pay for what the officers did March to coax Ciampi out of his van to 15. N Missed delivery or start/stop your paper? talk to them until one of them pre- Senior Staff Writer Don Kazak Call 650 326-8210, or e-mail circulation@paweekly. com. You may also subscribe online at tended to make a radio call for a can be e-mailed at dkazak@paweek- www.PaloAltoOnline.com. Subscriptions are $50/yr tow truck. ly.com. Great homes are as different ($30 within our circulation area). Ciampi, according to court tes- as the people who live in them. Whether you’re building a new home SUBSCRIBE! or remodeling, expect excellence Support your local newspaper by becom- ing a paid subscriber. $30 per year for from De Mattei. residents of our circulation area: $50 for INDEX businesses and residents of other areas. Pulse ...... 15 Name: ______Transitions ...... 16 Address: ______Spectrum ...... 24 Classified 63 City/Zip: ______...... Mail to: Palo Alto Weekly, Puzzles ...... 64 P.O. Box 1610. Palo Alto CA 94302
Page 4ÊUÊ>Õ>ÀÞÊÓÎ]ÊÓääÊUÊ*>ÊÌÊ7iiÞ Upfront Commitment To Excellence $500 Discount Coupon STANFORD (with purchase of new roof) Original Ownership Since 1975 Traffic report: more cars heading to Palo Alto? All Types of Roofi ng & Gutters Residential & Commercial S.C.L#785441 Stanford expansions could make bad situation worse, study states 1901 Old Middlefi eld Way, Mtn. View 650-969-7663 by Gennady Sheyner
n some ways, the new report key intersections along roads, such so much as make a horrible situa- examining the traffic impacts as El Camino Real, Alma Street tion more horrible, commissioners Stanford I of the two mammoth Stanford and Middlefield Road, would be said. University developments says less at a “failing” level of service in “I’m shocked by the bad data in about the projects themselves than 2025. this baseline,” Commissioner Ar- Driving School it does about the future of traffic But in most cases, they would thur Keller said, referring to the Palo Alto. be failing even if neither Stanford data that assumes neither project New Year's Savings Package The picture isn’t pretty. University Medical Center nor the was built. FREE CLASSROOM TRAINING with the purchase That was the somber conclusion Stanford Shopping Center expand- The traffic-impact analysis the Planning and Transportation ed. Those sections that are failing — put together by consultant of Freeway plus driver training Must have coupon for this offer. Expires March 6, 2009 Commission reached Wednesday already would become even more AECOM Transportation — stud- night during a study session on congested, in some cases becom- ies 63 intersections in Palo Alto February-March In-Class Schedule a new long-term traffic analysis. ing virtual parking lots, the report and surrounding communities. It Day 1 Day 2 Day 3 Day 4 The study is part of the Draft projects. tries to predict how these intersec- Sat 2/14 Sun 2/15 Sat 2/21 Sun 2/22 Environmental Impact Report The commission acknowledged tions would look in 2015 and 2025 (EIR) for the proposed Stanford that adding the two gigantic de- and considers the traffic flow if Tues 2/17 Wed 2/18 Thur 2/19 Fri 2/20 Shopping Center and Stanford velopments to the formula prob- one, both or neither of the Stan- Sat 3/14 Sun 3/15 Sat 3/21 Sun 3/22 University Medical Center expan- ably wouldn’t help. ford projects was built. sions. The full EIR is due out this But given the bleak “base pro- Specific impacts at each inter- (Èxä®Ê{ΣÇnÊUÊÎÈäÊ Ê >Ê,i>]Ê*>ÊÌ spring. jections,” the gigantic projects To register online, please visit our website at: The analysis indicates that many wouldn’t create a traffic problem (continued on page 11) www.StanfordDrivingSchool.net
Stanford Continuing Studies, the Program in Medieval Studies, the Sarum Seminar, the Center for Medieval and Early Modern Studies, and the Center for European Studies See what‘s happening at the present
Stanford Pioneers in Science
Death and the Maiden: The Cabaret Supper Club From Chaucer to Pearl Jam Join us for an intimate evening of dining Ever since the ancient Greeks told stories about each Friday & Saturday, 7pm to 10pm the abduction of the maiden Persephone by the Live Music and Dancing god Hades, European cultures have nurtured a darkly erotic link between death and maidenhood. This connection between the horror of death and the allure of virginity was particularly charged during Chaucer's time when, in the wake of the Black Death, Europeans first began to cope with the social, economic, and cultural challenges posed by large numbers of unmarried women in their midst.
How did Chaucer and his contemporaries imagine the deaths of maidens? How did the maidens approach death? And in what ways do these themes resonate in Super Bowl Party contemporary culture? 3UNDAY &EB ST s PM 2 large screens, drink and appetizer specials Join Judith Bennett, Professor of History, University of Southern California, as she discusses the deaths of maidens within a cultural history that extends from Valentine‘s Day Dinner ancient Greek myths to contemporary American pop songs. $79.99COUPLE s PM PM SEATINGS Live Music and Dancing Thursday, January 29 Champagne Brunch 7:00pm Join us each Sunday $29.95 PER PERSON s AM TO PM Pigott Hall (Bldg. 260), Room 113 Early Bird Dining Stanford University DAYS A WEEK s PM TO PM Special Three Course Dinner $13.95 Free and open to the public For reservations, For more information please visit: please call 650-857-0787 ext. 250 continuingstudies.stanford.edu 4290 El Camino Real, Palo Alto, CA 94306
*>ÊÌÊ7iiÞÊUÊ>Õ>ÀÞÊÓÎ]ÊÓääÊU Page 5
Upfront THE NEW STANFORD MEDICINE QUOTE OF THE WEEK OUTPATIENT CENTER ‘‘ IN REDWOOD CITY COMBINES A STATE-OF-THE-ART FACILITY WITH There is no way to describe how cool STANFORD that was. Just, yay. QUALITY CARE —Jessica Brooks, a Palo Alto High senior, whose Twitter message from Washington, D.C., described her feeling upon seeing President Barack Obama. See story HOW CAN ‘‘ on page 18. WE HELP YOU? Around Town RED MEETS GREEN ... The NEW FACES ... While the na- NOW IN A CONVENIENT NEW LOCATION: phrases “green activism” and tion’s eyes zeroed in on the Dermatology “emergency preparedness” historic transition at the White Digestive Health are rarely uttered in the same House, Palo Alto has been ush- Imaging breath. Unless, of course, ering in a few fresh faces into its Orthopaedics & Sports Medicine you’re in Palo Alto, where the own fold. On Jan. 12 — a week Pain Management two subjects remain the surest after Peter Drekmeier and Jack Sleep Medicine ways to get the community’s at- Morton were elected, respec- tention. Now, the green crowd tively, mayor and vice mayor by Featuring is teaming up with neighbor- their City Council colleagues Full Rehabilitation Services hood watchdogs to spread the — the council selected a new Leading-edge Surgical Suites groups’ collective wealth of member for the Parks and Rec- knowledge to the rest of the city. reation Commission and began On Saturday, Jan. 31, the “Red interviewing for a new Planning and Green” campaign — a joint and Transportation Commis- venture of Acterra, Palo Alto sion member. The fresh face in Neighborhoods, Community the parks commission will be Environmental Action Partner- Sunny Dykwel, a local Realtor ship and the City of Palo Alto whose activism resume includes — will send volunteers knocking involvement in Friends of Lyt- on doors in every neighborhood ton Plaza, the Palo Alto Black of the city. Residents wishing to and White Ball and Destination volunteer are asked to gather at Palo Alto. Dykwel, who edged the Mitchell Park or the Rincon- four other non-incumbent com- ada fire stations between 9 and petitors for the board seat, will 10 a.m. to pick up the packets take over for Alex Panelli, who and have some coffee and ba- declined a fresh term because Dallas Black Dance Theatre gels. They would then scatter to of the time commitment. The every nook and cranny of Palo new planning commissioner is Alto to deliver information on expected to be appointed at Fri., Feb. 6 • 8 p.m. how to become a Block Pre- the end of January and will take General Admission, $25; paredness Coordinator, sign up the seat formerly held by Paula at Foothill College for Community Alert and Notifi- Sandas, who resigned Dec. 31, Students with I.D., $20 cation System (CANS) updates, 2008, to become chief executive reduce carbon footprints and officer of the Palo Alto Chamber get a free energy audit. At noon, of Commerce. volunteers would reassemble for a barbecue put together by SMOKELESS IN STANFORD ... Group rates available. Palo Alto firefighters. “The goal A group of Stanford University Tickets on sale at is to reach every household with students is hoping the beginning (650) 949-7360 neighbor-to-neighbor contacts,” of a new year will help bring the Council member Yoriko Kishim- end of cigarette smoke on cam- or www.foothill.edu/fa oto said at the Jan. 12 council pus. Stanford Colleges Against meeting. Cancer has recently launched an on-line petition drive to cre- POOF! ... The release of 14 ate a “smoke-free Stanford.” The white doves Monday at King petition had 395 signatures by Plaza in downtown Palo Alto the middle of this week. “The seemed more like the release of freedom of non-smokers to racing doves than ceremonial move around campus without birds. The doves, symbolic of exposure to secondhand smoke peace and hope, were released is a fundamental right,” the peti- as part of the afternoon Martin tion states. “Students should be Luther King Jr. birthday celebra- able to walk from their dorms tion. In a poof and whiffle, the to the classroom and around doves were gone into the sky as main campus without holding some in the large crowd were their breath or avoiding walk- still looking for them. Richard ways with cigarette smoke.” At Hernandez, Oakland-based least one Stanford professor purveyor of doves for release, has sided with the SCAC, the said sometimes the birds do Stanford Daily reported. “I would that, and some don’t return emphasize this is not about even though they are trained to. depriving smokers of anything. “There’s a lot of predators out This is about allowing people to there,” he explained, adding that breathe clean air,” said Dr. Rob- he’s lost five birds of his 50-bird ert Jackler, professor of otorhi- flock already this year. nolaryngology. N
Page 6ÊUÊ>Õ>ÀÞÊÓÎ]ÊÓääÊUÊ*>ÊÌÊ7iiÞ Upfront
LAND USE Public Agenda Proposed hotel to bring Asian flavor to baylands PALO ALTO CITY COUNCIL ... The City Council plans to hold a joint study session with the Parks and Recreation Commission. The Conference center, plaza and 162 rooms proposed for Ming’s restaurant site council will also consider approval of a site and design review for by Gennady Sheyner Alma Plaza, a mixed-use commercial and residential development n designing a new four-story at 3401, 3415 and 3445 Alma St. The study session will begin at 6 hotel on Embarcadero Road, p.m. on Monday, Jan. 26. The council’s regular meeting will follow in I architects aimed to blend Asian the Council Chambers at City Hall (250 Hamilton Ave.). design elements with those evoking the nearby baylands. PARKS AND RECREATION COMMISSION ... The commission The hotel’s rooftop gardens and ofCourtesy Stoecker Inc. & Architects Northway is scheduled to elect a new chair and vice chair and discuss the pavers on the driveways would ref- needs assessment for the 2010-2020 comprehensive plan for the erence Japanese parks, while the community service department. The meeting is scheduled for 7 building’s muted colors and hori- p.m. on Monday, Jan. 26, in the Council Conference Room at City zontal feel would provide continu- Hall (250 Hamilton Ave.). ity with the surrounding nature, ac- cording to the architects. PALO ALTO BOARD OF EDUCATION ... The board will discuss how Even the project’s layout and en- to go about drawing up new boundaries for the district with plans to trance locations were determined by reopen Garland Elementary School in 2010. The meeting will begin the principles of feng shui, a Chi- at 6:30 p.m. on Tuesday, Jan. 27, in the Administration Building (25 nese philosophy that uses placement Churchill Ave.). of objects and design elements to achieve harmony. PALO ALTO PLANNING AND TRANSPORTATION COMMISSION ... But the most conspicuous sign of The commission is scheduled to discuss a Planned Community zone the project’s Asian flavor would be change for 488 West Charleston Ave., a 35-unit affordable-housing Ming’s restaurant, a popular land- A view from the southwest corner of the proposed hotel at the site of development. The commission is also scheduled to review Zoning mark that now operates, and would Ming’s restaurant in Palo Alto. The current restaurant is to the left Ordinance amendments to add incentives to encourage the provision continue to operate, at 1700 Embar- (slightly hidden). of historic covenants for properties, in exchange for allowing condo- cadero Road. The project still has minium subdivision of two parcels that otherwise would be prohibited a row of hurdles to clear, including keep the main entry as far away project and looked forward to work- from subdivision. The meeting is scheduled for 7 p.m. on Wednesday, a zoning change and approvals by from it as possible.” ing with the applicant. Jan. 28, in the Council Chambers at City Hall (250 Hamilton Ave.). the local planning commissions and The proposed development would “I think using Asian elements in the City Council. But last week, the also include a gym, conference cen- design is fantastic,” board member PALO ALTO ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW BOARD ... The board is city’s Architectural Review Board ter and small retail area and four David Solnick said. “I’m optimistic scheduled to consider a major architectural review of 2805 El Cami- no Real, a two-story, 6,850-square-foot retail building. The board spoke enthusiastically about the rooftop-garden areas. The hotel about the whole project.” N project’s potential to improve the would feature 162 rooms, ranging also plans to conduct a preliminary review of the proposed design neighborhood next to the Palo Alto from studios to two-bedroom units. Staff Writer Gennady Sheyner guidelines for the Stanford Shopping Center expansion. The meet- Airport and the Palo Alto Municipal Each room would have kitchen fa- can be e-mailed at gsheyner@ ing is scheduled for 8:30 a.m. on Thursday, Jan. 29, in the Council Golf Course. cilities. paweekly.com. Chambers at City Hall (250 Hamilton Ave.). The proposed development Several board members, including by Vicky Ching and Wu-Chang Chair Grace Lee and Wasserman, Hsiang would also include a plaza, also encouraged the architects to CENTER FOR AFRICAN STUDIES a bike path and outdoor seating for adhere to principals of “horizontal- Ming’s. ity” to maintain continuity with the Distinguished Lecture Series Board member Judith Wasserman baylands. Gerald Mitchell, principal said she was excited about the myr- with Oakland-based Keller Mitch- iad transportation options the hotel ell & Co., said the Oriental and bay- would provide to its guests. lands themes are “pretty compat- “You can fly in, you can drive in, ible” with each other. MILITARISM and FEMINISM you can bike in, or you can jog by “Our design concept is basically the baylands,” Wasserman said. “I dictated by the theme of the hotel, just think it’s great.” which is intended to be ‘Oriental at- Cynthia Munoz, project architect mosphere,’ but that would take place from local firm Stoecker and North- mostly in roof gardens and interior IN AFRICA way Architects, said the principles spaces,” Mitchell said. “Around the of feng shui helped determine the edges we do plan to reflect a little bit architect’s decision to place the of the bay plantings but still keep an main entrance to the building at Asian flavor.” East Bayshore Road and away from The project had been slightly AMINA MAMA the nearby electrical tower owned modified from its original plans. by PG&E. Most notably, its height was low- “Owners had actually consulted ered from 56 to 50 feet, based on BARBARA LEE Distinguished Professor of Ethnic Studies at Mills College with a feng shui expert and the elec- earlier feedback from the Planning tricity tower at the corner represents and Transportation Commission. Chair of Gender Studies at the African Gender Institute at the University of a major ‘fire’ element,” Munoz told Architectural Review Board mem- the board. “They were advised to bers said they were excited about the Cape Town, South Africa
TUESDAY, JANUARY 27, 4:30-6:00PM Levinthal Hall, Humanities Center Stanford University
CityViewA round-up of government action this week Co-sponsors: African and African American Studies Program, Historic Resources Board (Jan. 21) Michelle R Clayman Institute for Gender Research and 2300 Wellesley Ave. The commission voted to approve a request by the city’s De- Stanford Humanities Center partment of Public Works for the historic rehabilitation of the College Terrace Library at 2300 Wellesley Ave. Yes: Bernstein, DiCicco, Kohler, Loukianoff, Bunnenberg, Makinen Absent: Bower. Planning & Transportation Commission (Jan. 21) ICA Stanford traffic impact: The commission discussed the traffic impact analysis for Stanford Shopping Center and Stanford University Medical Center expansion proj- ects. Action: None
*>ÊÌÊ7iiÞÊUÊ>Õ>ÀÞÊÓÎ]ÊÓääÊU Page 7 Student Camp & Trip Advisors Palo Alto Historical Association Upfront presents a public program SUMMER OPPORTUNITIES FAIR Business tax (continued from page 3) “Make A BRIGHT CHOICE FOR YOUR SUMMER” these cities are $311, $419 and $486, SUNDAY February 1, 2009 10 AM – 1 PM Palo Alto respectively. MENLO SCHOOL 50 Valparaiso, Atherton from Above Mountain View, meanwhile, bases !"" ?! ! its fee on the number of employees ! !" !" a business has. Its system is set up Speaker: Ben Hatfi eld to be more of a business registry MEET DIRECTORS FROM than a revenue generator, bringing OVERNIGHT CAMPS #8(+0:065(3?#,,5?"7,*0(3:> Sunday, January 25, 2009 in roughly $200,000 a year. The av- TRIPS at 2pm erage tax rate there is $45. 0205.?&03+,85,99?&683+=0+,#6;805. Palo Alto has yet to determine PROGRAMS"(0305.?!(5*/?8:9?(5.;(.,?644;50:>",8<0*, which model it wants to use, Perez Lucie Stern Community Center EDUCATIONAL633,.,(47;9,9$")86(+ said. But he noted that a city that 1305 Middlefi eld Road wants to use the BLT to generate 68468,05-684(:065*(33 Palo Alto revenue would likely consider the $'&""#$# #! %" !" 2EFRESHMENTS s .O ADMISSION CHARGE gross-receipts method. 7 ? ?,1;+>=0,9,5(63*64 Adrian Hatfi eld, early aerial photographer Barton, despite his prediction that a tax would earn voter support, said he has mixed feelings about the BLT. He said he would support the PALO ALTO CITY COUNCIL creation of a new business registry CIVIC CENTER, 250 HAMILTON AVENUE Start Your New Year’s Resolution... that could potentially be used as a BROADCAST LIVE ON KZSU, FM 90.1 marketing tool. Palo Alto is already CABLECAST LIVE ON GOVERNMENT and Keep It This Year! a tough city in which to set up shop, ACCESS CHANNEL 26 Barton argued, and adding a tax It’s not just about achieving the goal – it’s about maintaining it. (TENTATIVE) AGENDA - SPECIAL MEETING - would only make things harder. COUNCIL CHAMBERS That’s the Foundations Program difference. “It is, in my opinion, a tax on January 26, 2009 – 6:00 P.M. businesses to do business in Palo Programs Include: * 90-day Total Wellness Boot Camp * 6-week whole food Alto,” said Barton, who runs an 1. Joint Meeting of Parks and Recreation Commission (PARC) detox and coaching program * Lifestyle Coaching * Personal Training architectural firm with a Palo Alto and Council Members Regarding Review of Priorities 7:00 * Whole Food Nutrition * Massage office. “It is a very hard place to do PM or as soon as possible thereafter COUNCIL CHAM- business, often for good reasons BERS and for good outcomes. 2. Adoption of a Resolution Expressing Appreciation to Donald “I support the business registry, but I’m not in favor of the BLT un- Dudak Upon His Retirement Foundations Purify. Strengthen. Restore. less it comes with commitment at 3. Approval of Contract with Dell USA LP in the Amount Not to the policy level to make it easier to Exceed $196,911 for the Microsoft Enterprise Agreement 650.393.3833 do business in Palo Alto,” he said. 4. Finance Committee Recommendation to Adopt an Ordi- www.TheFoundationsProgram.com Meanwhile, city staff and consul- nance Authorizing the Closing of the Budget for the 2008 FREE initial consultation! tants have been gradually winnow- Fiscal Year and to Approve 2008 Comprehensive Annual Fi- ing down their unofficial registry of nancial Report (CAFR) local businesses. In November, Perez estimated the number of businesses 5. Finance Committee Recommendation to Adopt a Resolution in Palo Alto to be around 25,000. Approving the Execution of the Agreement for a Long-Term Since then, the consultant and staff Assignment of the City's Share of Transfer Capability on the Young have identified thousands of dupli- California-Oregon Transmission Project to Other Members of cates and businesses that no longer the Transmission Agency of Northern California exist, Perez said. Current estimates 6. Finance Committee Recommendation to Accept Maze & As- Classic peg the number of local businesses sociates' Audit of the City of Palo Alto's Financial Statements at around 9,000, he said. as of June 30, 2008 and Management Letter Staff had also previously dis- Sample Sale cussed using the BLT revenues to 7. Approval of Amendment No. 1 to Contract No. C08122012 % build a new police headquarters. with Rodan Builders, Inc., in the Amount of $39,332 for the 50-70 OFF But given the dire economic fore- Renovation of the Open Space Maintenance Building at cast, these funds would now likely Foothills Park, Capital Improvement Program (CIP) Project Custom clothing for the be used to close the budget gap OS-07003 for a Total Not to Exceed Amount of $272,232; and sophisticated woman and maintain current services, City Adoption of a Budget Amendment Ordinance for the Fiscal Sue Young Manager James Keene said. Year 2009 to Reappropriate $20,000 from CIP OS-00001 and Designer of Custom Clothes “It would be inaccurate to assume $19,332 from CIP OS-09001 to CIP Project OS-07003 for a that this is being used for the public- By appointment only Total of $39,332 safety building,” Keene said. “It’s really a matter of how to keep an 8. Adoption of a Resolution to Authorize the City Manager to (650) 323-0612 array of services the city provides Award and Sign Contracts for Renewable Certificates from and how to fund them.” Suppliers to Meet the Needs of the PaloAltoGreen Program 7AVERLEY 3TREET 0ALO !LTO s WWWYOUNGCLASSICCOM The City Council’s finance sub- for an Annual Amount Not to Exceed $1,500,000 During Cal- committee is scheduled to discuss the endar Years 2009 Through 2011 BLT at its Feb. 3 meeting, he said. 9. Approval of a Contract with Nova Partners in the Amount of Business owners at Wednesday’s $241,340 for Construction Management Services for a Total breakfast expressed concern about Not to Exceed Amount of $277,540 for the College Terrace the new tax but stopped short of Library and Child Care Center Improvements, Capital Im- outright opposition. Most said they would support a small fee or a busi- provement Program Project ness registry of some sort, as long as PE-05010 the proposal includes some incen- 10. Approval of an Amendment to Enterprise Fund Contract No. tives for businesses. C07122034 with URS Corporation in the Amount of $111,160 Developer Roxy Rapp said he for a Total Not to Exceed Amount of $1,411,160 for Construc- would back the BLT but only if the tion Management Services for the Palo Alto, Mountain View/ city uses the new business registry Moffett Area Recycled Water Pipeline Project, Capital Im- to more effectively identify the city’s retail gaps and development possi- provement Program Project WQ-04010 bilities. But caution, he said, is key. 11. Consider Approval of a Site and Design Review for a Mixed “The city has to be very care- Use Commercial and Residential Project, a Tentative Map to ful on how they tax the businesses Subdivide Three Lots Into Separate Parcels and a Record of *+,-.+ .) downtown, because you can really Land Use Action for a Project Located at 3401, 3415, 3445 /0' 1 + 2 " " 1! 1 hurt us,” he said. “You can only tax so much.” N Alma Street (Alma Plaza) !" "# $ 12. Acceptance of Service Efforts and Accomplishments Report Staff Writer Gennady Sheyner %%%&'(&) can be e-mailed at gsheyner@ FY 2007-08 paweekly.com. Page 8ÊUÊ>Õ>ÀÞÊÓÎ]ÊÓääÊUÊ*>ÊÌÊ7iiÞ Upfront Garland school CITY OF PALO ALTO CITY OF PALO ALTO (continued from page 3) NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING “All the schools around here are only one story, so having two-story buildings will be different,” she NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN, that the City Council of the City NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN, that the City Council of the City said. “The International School of the Peninsula is a two-story build- of Palo Alto will hold a Public Hearing at the Regular Council of Palo Alto will hold a Public Hearing at the Regular Council ing and it is a bit bulky.” Meeting on Monday, February 9, 2009 at 7:00 p.m., or as near Meeting on Monday, February 9, 2009 at 7:00 p.m., or as near Nevertheless, Del Martel con- thereafter as possible, in the Council Chambers, City Hall, 250 thereafter as possible, in the Council Chambers, City Hall, 250 cluded that Palo Alto needs more schools and more classes. Hamilton Avenue, Palo Alto, California to Consider the Approval Hamilton Avenue, Palo Alto, California to Consider the Approval Garland neighbors met with the of a Vesting Tentative Map and Record of Land Use Action for a of Water Supply Assessment for Stanford Medical Center and architects and representatives of the district on Jan. 20. The neighbors 45-unit townhome development at 200 San Antonio Avenue. Stanford Shopping Center Expansion Projects were presented with three potential site plans for Garland. Neighbor Erin Mershon, who DONNA J. GRIDER DONNA J. GRIDER City Clerk City Clerk lives behind the school site, com- mented on the meeting on a Town Square post (at www.paloaltoonline. com). “Two (site designs) consisted of buildings along the back property line of our houses, 10 feet from the DOWNTOWN fence line,” she said. “One was a two-story building, the other, a one- story building with vaulted ceilings much like the normal school rooms that we have now. Both of these L O S A L T O S plans were deemed unacceptable by neighbors. Neither left enough room Unique Shops For Unique Children between the current L and the new building for a fire truck to get onto the campus and neither took into account the huge redwood and pine trees along the back fence. -!2)/. *!#+34/.3 “The third option was to put a two-story building where there are currently portables along the fence between Garland and Jordan,” Mer- 7).4%2 3!,% shon said. “This was the most favor- able except for the two houses clos- #/.4).5%3 est to where this building will be.” Mershon said that she thinks most 50 neighbors are in favor of reopening 4/ /&& the school and expanding it with two-story buildings to provide more field space for students. 15!,)49 #(),$2%.3 #,/4(%3 !.$ 3(/%3 Garland neighbor Karleen Turn- 220 State Street #1, Los Altos, Ca 94022 bull also supported the reopening Mon-Sat: 10am-6pm -AIN 3TREET s ,OS !LTOS s and remodeling of Garland Elemen- tary. “Better schools, better property values,” she said. Karleen is not concerned about having two-story buildings. “More important to me is the basic design, $ ! the colors to match the landscape around it,” Turnbull said. “If they #! can do a good job of remodeling the school to fit the neighborhood then !! I’ll be happy.” “My personal preference is that we have a lot of open space for kids "$ to run around,” board member Ca- mille Townsend said. “I support " Ê- / Ê/ - two-story buildings.” !#! “We have to make sure that if we have two-story buildings that ! ! Ó{nÊ >Ê-ÌÀiiÌÊUÊÃÊÌÃ]Ê Ê{äÓÓ we have strong ventilation,” board * \ÊÈxä®Ê{ÇäÈÊUÊ£äÊÊÈÊ Ê->ÌÊUÊ££ÊÊxÊ-Õ member Melissa Caswell said. Family Concerts are a great With air-conditioning most likely way to spend quality time not an option, Caswell said she was concerned that second-level class- with your children. rooms would be too warm and not The concerts benefi t Music conducive to student learning. for Minors and help bring A Palo Alto resident addressed music education to local this issue in a Town Square post (at elementary schools. www.paloaltoonline.com): “Why would air conditioning not be an Buy your tickets at the store 2OCK option? It’s a matter of health and or by phone during regular safety. ... Thermostats can be cen- business hours or online at IN THE trally controlled; energy can come www.lindentreebooks.com .EW from solar panels.” The resident added that “13 9EAR wrongs” — or a 13th out-of-date school designed to match the other 7ITH 3AVINGS ON ALL 'UIDECRAFT &URNITURE