EDUCATION FOR
SUSTAINABILITY
CIES 2019 San Francisco
•
April 14-18, 2019
#CIES2019 | #Ed4Sustainability
TABLE of CONTENTS
CIES 2019
OF SPECIAL INTEREST
INTRODUCTION
Meditation & Prayer Space . . . . . . . . 36 Chinese Panels & Round-tables . . . . . . 37 Spanish Panels . . . . . . . . . . . . . 51 Memorial Panels . . . . . . . . . . . . 55
Conference Theme . . . . . . . . . . . .2 About CIES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .3
WELCOME
Gender & Education, UREAG, & New Scholars Committee Events. . . . . . 56
David Post, CIES President-Elect . . . . . .4 Regina Cortina, CIES President . . . . . . .5 Hilary Landorf, CIES Executive Director . . . .6
SIG Events: Highlighted Sessions & Business Meetings. . . . . . . . . . . 57 Book Launch, Poster, & PechaKucha Sessions . . . . . . . . . 61
LEADERSHIP
CIES Board of Directors . . . . . . . . . .7 CIES Presidents . . . . . . . . . . . . . .8
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
Program Committee & Volunteers . . . . . 62
CIES Office of the
Executive Director . . . . . . . . . . . . .9
Unit Planners . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 63
CER Editorial Board . . . . . . . . . . . 10
Committees, 2018-2019 . . . . . . . . . 11
PARTNER ORGANIZATIONS
Sustaining Partners . . . . . . . . . . . 65 Sponsors. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 66 Exhibitors & Advertisers . . . . . . . . . 67 Institutional Receptions. . . . . . . . . . 68 Advertisements . . . . . . . . . . . . . 70
Special Interest Groups, 2018-2019 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13
FEATURED EVENTS
Welcome, Town Hall: Debate, Opening Reception . . . . . . . . . . . 16 Closing: Alphabet Rockers . . . . . . . . 17 George F. Kneller Keynote Lecture . . . . . 18 Plenary Sessions. . . . . . . . . . . . . 20 Presidential Address . . . . . . . . . . . 23
CONFERENCE PROGRAM
Sessions By Day . . . . . . . . . . . . . 82
INDEX
State of the Society . . . . . . . . . . . 23 Film Festivalette. . . . . . . . . . . . . 24
Presenter . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .231
Subject / Keywords . . . . . . . . . . .275 Committee / SIG . . . . . . . . . . . .281
AWARDS
Awards Ceremony . . . . . . . . . . . . 34 UREAG & New Scholars Award . . . . . . 35
INSIDE BACK COVER: Venue Maps
1
INTRODUCTION
EDUCATION FOR
SUSTAINABILITY
CIES 2019 San Francisco
•
April 14-18, 2019
During its “Development Decade” of the 1960s, the
How fitting that CIES will meet in San Francisco,
where representatives of war-torn nation-states gathered at the Herbst Theater to negotiate and sign the UN Charter in 1945. The international institutions emerging from that historic encounter have endured through political tensions, economic crises and war.
They endured partly because the United States played
a positive role supporting them. The US Commission
for UNESCO, for example, met in San Francisco in
1969 to discuss what could be done to improve the
natural environment. That meeting led the way to a worldwide recognition of Earth Day. In 2019 CIES
will return to the Herbst Theater to learn what we as scholars and educators can do to marshal new evidence and craft a sustainable future.
UN advocated education as a driver of economic
growth. But, over the past fifty years, questions have been asked with increasing urgency about
what kind of development is promulgated through
literacy, skills training, and formal schooling. What
is the longer term cost of an education that promises – and sometimes delivers – productivity, industrialization, modernity and consumption? Who pays this price? What are the larger costs? And with what ultimate consequence for the planet? Such
questions prompt the theme of the 63rd annual
meeting of the Comparative and International
Education Society: Education for Sustainability.
- Our 2019 theme connects the CIES with
- a
Today US leadership and engagement in multi-
lateralism is in retreat, with Washington less committed than in the past to the international norms and
efforts needed for sustainability. However, California
remains committed to this effort. Our meeting in San
Francisco thus will remind us that concerted action
and scholarship in education can thwart hatred and
violence, promote human rights and dignity, and
help ensure our planet’s survival. CIES researchers,
analysts, teachers and practitioners can – and must – play roles in these efforts. All hands are needed to analyze curricula, address demographic trends, critique existing paradigms, and advocate for policies
and practices that will develop a sustainable planet for all.
reconsideration of human progress – by scholars,
governments, corporations, international agencies,
and civil society at the grassroots level. This reconsideration is also reflected in the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development adopted by UN member states. The agenda finds its power by setting goals and
building peaceful partnerships for the simultaneous
pursuit of human well-being and ecological integrity.
Our theme will remind us that, while education is both a public and private good, its impact is global. Indeed, education is integral to the four pillars the UN
has seen as supporting sustainability: inclusive social
development, inclusive economic development,
peace and security, and environmental sustainability. We in the CIES, both individually and collectively,
have much to contribute to these pillars.
Come and contribute.
2
ABOUT CIES
CIES, the Comparative and International Education Society, is an academic
association dedicated to increasing understanding of educational issues, trends, and policies through comparative, intercultural, and international perspectives.
CIES is the largest and oldest of 47 comparative and international education societies around the
world. Its more than 3,000 individual members — researchers, analysts, practitioners, and students
— represent over 1,000 universities, research institutes, government departments, non-governmental
organizations, and multilateral agencies across the globe.
CIES members explore educational issues related to schools, students, teachers, and administrators —
from early childhood and primary school to secondary and higher education, as well as non-formal education and lifelong learning. Some compare achievement inequalities across socio-economic status, gender, ethnicity, and language. Others examine the relationship between education and cultural processes, democratization, globalization, economic development, and political conflict.
Established in 1956, CIES has attracted a diverse audience in working towards its mission to foster cross-cultural understanding and scholarship. Within the last decade alone, CIES membership has
doubled — reflecting the global expansion of academic and professional positions as well as a
commitment to international education and cooperation.
ABOUT CIES 2019 SAN FRANCISCO
CIES 2019 San Francisco is the 63rd Annual Conference of the Comparative and International Education Society, to be held in San Francisco, California, from April 14-18, 2019.
CIES Annual Conferences are academic conventions attended by researchers, students, practitioners and policymakers interested in comparative and international education. As part of these events, Society members and the interested public gather together for scholarly and practical exchange, as well as for
debate and networking — via lectures, research presentations, workshops, book talks, social events, and more.
“Each CIES conference has a broad theme covering a range of applied, theoretical or empirical
presentations. This year’s conference theme is “Education for Sustainability,” which aims to connect the CIES audience with a reconsideration of human progress – by scholars, governments, corporations, international agencies, and civil society at the grassroots level. This reconsideration is also reflected in the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development adopted by UN member states. The agenda finds its power by setting goals and building peaceful partnerships for the simultaneous pursuit of human well-being and ecological integrity. Our theme will remind us that, while education is both a public and
private good, its impact is global.
3
WELCOME
David Post
CIES President-Elect
Dear contributors to the 2019 CIES Conference:
This week we launch our historic attempt to reimagine comparative
method and international education for an era where sustainability must
become central to research and debate on education and development.
Welcome to San Francisco.
It was here, at the end of the Second World War, where nations convened
to create the basis for their hoped-for peace and progress. Led by the
United States, delegates gathered at the Herbst Theater to sign the UN
Charter. Monday evening we will return to the Herbst for our Kneller Lecture and a special UNESCO panel (also live-streamed for the benefit of those unable to purchase tickets). With twelve plenary panels and hundreds of parallel sessions, we will highlight some key themes of the UN Sustainable Development Goals. And our conference this year is multi-
lingual, featuring panels in Spanish and Chinese (two heritage languages of California), as well as new forms of presentation.
Although we received a record number of submissions this year, we tried to accommodate as many as possible based on the input of thousands of peer reviewers. Thanks to all of you who assisted with this, especially to our unit planners and the members of my own program planning
committee and student support group at Penn State. See the back of this program for individual acknowledgements. I further appreciate
material and collegial support from my own College of Education for our programing efforts and for Sunday’s Opening Reception. CIES is most grateful to our partners and sponsors for grants and support of many enhanced programs this year, including a film festival in a nearby theater,
ALS signage, childcare, and more. Despite the richness of the conference
program, I hope you will use some of your time to explore California and the world beyond the Hyatt by taking advantage of the many outings that are being cosponsored by our Special Interest Groups.
My heartfelt thanks go to the hardworking staff of the Office of the Executive Director, including Hilary Landorf, as well as to the wonderful
support of the CIES leaders, including our out-going President Regina
Cortina. The theme of this year’s conference will – one hopes- begin
to steer our agenda toward themes of the environment that will remain
central for next year’s exciting meeting in Miami, to be led by the next
President-elect, Iveta Silova.
– David Post, President-elect and Program Chair CIES2019
Professor of Education, Penn State University
4
WELCOME
Regina Cortina
CIES President
Dear CIES 2019 Conference Participants,
I am delighted to welcome you to the 63rd annual conference of CIES in San Francisco!
I applaud the Office of the Executive Director and President-Elect David Post’s team from Pennsylvania State University for coordinating and organizing the conference. As CIES grows each year, it requires a tremendous amount of effort to make this event happen. We hope you
are able to take advantage of all that is planned for this exciting week. Here in the North, the United States government is focused on building
the “Wall” to block the flow of South-North migration. With 57 million
Latinx immigrants residing in the U.S., and that number growing, I
hope our conversations around this year’s theme of Education for Sustainability can address the ways in which our field can combat the racist messages affecting immigrants. Today, one in every five students in K-16 in education institutions in the United States are Latinx. My strong
recommendation to CIES is that in thinking about a sustainable future for all, we should not separate what is happening in schools in the Global
South from schools in the Global North. They are interconnected. The theme of sustainability is also interconnected with the promotion of multiple ways of knowing and the recognition of distinct cultures within global communities. Environmental sustainability depends in large part on maintaining biodiversity, which in turn is linked to language diversity. One of the central contributions of education to achieve a truly
sustainable future should be to protect the multiple forms of knowledge within our local and global communities.
I invite you to discuss ways in which we can truly engage to the call that this year’s organizers have made to us. Please make the most of the diversity of sessions, plenaries, mentoring and networking opportunities
this conference will provide.
– Regina Cortina
Professor of Education
Teachers College, Columbia University
President, Comparative and International Education Society 2018-2019
5
WELCOME
Hilary Landorf
CIES Executive Director
From the CIES Executive Director:
Welcome to the 63rd Annual Conference of the Comparative and International Education Society in San Francisco! On behalf of all of us at the Office of the
Executive Director (OED), I want to extend a special welcome to the attendees
joining us from over 120 countries around the world! The theme of this year’s conference, “Education for Sustainability,” is one of the most
critical issues in our work, as evident from the record number of submissions we received this
year and the enthusiasm shown by all in making this a successful conference. The concept of sustainability has particular relevance for the OED at CIES. Sustainability involves critical and systemic thinking, collaboration, and taking responsibility for present and future generations. Over the past three years, these concepts have been at the heart of all we do at the OED. We have made it our mission to build foundations that will allow the Society to be self-sustaining and to serve our internal and external communities. For the first time ever, CIES has its own membership system and a full-time membership coordinator. This enables members to build their own profiles, access the CER, and communicate and collaborate with other members and
groups all within the CIES website. In addition to the long-standing New Scholars program,
this year we have increased our commitment to the UREAG and New Scholars Committees, so that there are more funds available for travel to the conference and more awards for exemplary scholarship. Beyond discounting registration for scholars and practitioners from low-income
countries, we have encouraged donations to sponsor registration and membership for those in need. These initiatives are just a few examples of our commitment to ensure the responsible
sustainability of CIES. We have been in touch with many of you online and by phone, helping you plan activities, connect with other members, and prepare for the conference. We are very much looking forward to chatting with you in person! We will be at the OED desk throughout the week. We encourage you to visit us there with questions, ideas, suggestions, or just to say hello.
My appreciation goes out to all who have made this conference possible, including the
program chair, David Post and his able team, our presenters, speakers, exhibitors, volunteers,
and sponsors. A special thank you goes to our outgoing president, Regina Cortina, for her work in promoting the good of the Society throughout the year, to the OED Managing Director, Mariusz Galczynski, and the entire OED team, and to Senior Conference Manager Cheryl Gilliland and her staff at Indiana University Conferences. I would also like to thank our
volunteers who come from universities throughout the world.
I hope that you will take advantage of all that this year’s conference has to offer – papers, panel and poster sessions, workshops, roundtables, as well as films, outings, receptions, networking opportunities, and the majesty of San Francisco!
– Hilary Landorf CIES Executive Director
Associate Professor of Education Executive Director,
Office of Global Learning Initiatives,
Florida International University
6
LEADERSHIP
CIES Board of Directors
- Executive Committee
- Board Members at Large
PRESIDENT
Monisha Bajaj
University of San Francisco
Regina Cortina
Teachers College, Columbia University
Cathryn Magno
University of Fribourg, Switzerland
PRESIDENT-ELECT
David Post
Pennsylvania State University
Nagwa Megahed
American University in Cairo
VICE-PRESIDENT
Iveta Silova
Arizona State University
Ameena Ghaffar-Kucher
University of Pennsylvania
Emily Morris
PAST-PRESIDENT
University of Minnesota
Noah W. Sobe
Loyola University Chicago
Anne Mungai
Adelphi University
TREASURER
Amber Gove
RTI International
Moses Oketch
University College London
Aryn Baxter
University of Idaho
SECRETARY
Rhiannon Williams
University of Minnesota
Riyad Shahjahan
Michigan State University
HISTORIAN
Esther Gottlieb
Ohio State University
Norin Taj
OISE-University of Toronto
EDITOR, COMPARATIVE EDUCATION REVIEW
Parliamentarian
Bjorn H. Nordtveit
University of Massachusetts Amherst
Irving Epstein
Illinois Wesleyan University
7
LEADERSHIP
CIES Presidents
2018
Regina Cortina,
1987 1986
Peter Hackett, University of Virginia
Teachers College, Columbia University
Gail P. Kelly,
State University of New York at Buffalo
2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010
Noah W. Sobe, Loyola University Chicago Mark Bray, Hong Kong University
1985
R. Murray Thomas,
University of California-Santa Barbara
N’Dri T Assie-Lumumba, Cornell University
Karen Mundy, University of Toronto Gilbert Valverde, University at Albany David Baker, Penn State University
Ratna Ghosh, McGill University
1984 1983
John N. Hawkins, UCLA Barbara A. Yates,
University of Illinois- Champaign/Urbana
1982 1981
Max. A. Eckstein, Queens College, CUNY
Erwin H. Epstein,
University of Missouri-Rolla
María Teresa Tatto,
Michigan State University
1980 1979 1978 1977 1976 1975 1974 1973 1972 1971 1970 1969 1968 1967
Thomas J LaBelle, UCLA
2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2004
Gita Steiner-Khamsi, Columbia University
Henry Levin, Columbia University
George A. Male, University of Maryland Mathew Zachariah, University of Calgary Joseph P Farrell, University of Toronto Susanne M Shafer, Arizona State University Rolland G. Paulston, University of Pittsburgh Robert F. Lawson, University of Calgary Harold J. Noah, Columbia University Cole S. Brembeck, Michigan State University Andreas Kazamias, University of Wisconsin Philip J. Foster, University of Chicago
Reginald Edwards, McGill University
Stewart E. Fraser, Vanderbilt University
Steven J. Klees, University of Maryland Victor Kobayashi, University of Hawaii Martin Carnoy, Stanford University
Donald B. Holsinger,
Brigham Young University
2003 2002 2001 2000 1999 1998
Kassie Freeman, Vanderbilt University Karen Biraimah, University of Central Florida Heidi Ross, Colgate University Robert Arnove, Indiana University Ruth Hayhoe, University of Toronto
William K Cummings,
State University of New York at Buffalo
William W. Brickman,
University of Pennsylvania
1997 1996
Carlos Alberto Torres, UCLA
1966 1965 1964 1963 1962 1961
David G Scanlon, Columbia University Donald K. Adams, Syracuse University R. Freeman Butts, Columbia University Claude Eggertsen, University of Michigan C. Arnold Anderson, University of Chicago Joseph Katz, University of British Columbia
Gary L Theisen,
Academy of Educational Development
1995 1994
Noel McGinn, Harvard University
Nelly Stromquist,
University of Southern California
1993 1992 1991 1990 1989 1988
David Wilson, University of Toronto
Stephen Heyneman, World Bank
Mark B. Ginsburg, University of Pittsburgh
Val P. Rust, UCLA
1959-1960
William H. E. Johnson,
University of Pittsburgh
1956-1959
William W. Brickman, New York University
Vandra L. Masemann, University of Toronto
Beverly Lindsay, University of Georgia
8
CIES Office of the
Executive Director
(OED)
LEADERSHIP
Office of Global Learning Initiatives
Florida International University
- EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
- OPERATIONS ASSISTANT
- Hilary C. Landorf
- Ashley Roll
- MANAGING DIRECTOR
- EDITORIAL ASSISTANT,
CIES PERSPECTIVES
Mariusz Galczynski
Amanda Earl
FINANCE & IT DIRECTOR
VOLUNTEER COORDINATOR
Catherine Wadley
Birgitta Rausch-Montoto
COMMUNICATIONS & MEMBERSHIP
- MANAGER
- CONFERENCE ASSISTANTS
- Connie Penczak
- Florencia Dominguez
Mariam Vadria
FINANCE ASSISTANT
Bahia Simons-Lane
- Robyn Read
- Taylor Saenz
9
LEADERSHIP
CER Editorial Board
- EDITOR
- ADVISORY BOARD
Bjorn H. Nordtveit,
University of Massachusetts Amherst
Moses Ngware, African Population and Health Research Center
- CO-EDITORS
- M. Najeeb Shafiq, University of Pittsburgh
Kathryn Anderson-Levitt,
University of California, Los Angeles
Karen Mundy, University of Toronto, Canada