Bulletin Magazine of the Richard III Society
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Ricardian Bulletin Magazine of the Richard III Society ISSN 0308 4337 December 2009 Ricardian Bulletin December 2009 Contents 2 From the Chairman 3 Annual General Meeting 2009 12 Bosworth 2009 17 Julia Redlich receives the Robert Hamblin award 18 Moira Habberjam becomes a Society Vice-President 19 ‘I knew I had found the Battle of Bosworth ...’ 20 Study weekend April 2010: Richard III’s York: People and Places 21 Other Society News and Notices 25 News and Reviews 27 Media Retrospective 29 The Man Himself: the Television Trial of Richard III 31 Margaret Beaufort’s List: by Jennie Powys-Lybbe 34 Retrospective on the Quincentenary of the Death of Henry VII: Part 4: Henry’s illness at Wanstead House and an extraordinary report from Calais: by Peter Foley 35 Notes and Queries 36 Medieval Cosmetics: by Tig Lang 38 ‘A pepe of chykennys’ and other flights of fancy: by Elaine Henderson 39 The Sheriff Hutton Monument, Part 2: by Jane Crease 42 Correspondence 44 The Barton Library 46 Reports on Society Events 55 Future Society Events 57 Branch and Group Contacts 59 Branches and Groups: Reports 63 New Members 63 Obituary 64 Calendar Contributions Contributions are welcomed from all members. All contributions should be sent to Lesley Boatwright. Bulletin Press Dates 15 January for March issue; 15 April for June issue; 15 July for September issue; 15 October for December issue. Articles should be sent well in advance. Bulletin & Ricardian Back Numbers Back issues of The Ricardian and the Bulletin are available from Judith Ridley. If you are interested in obtaining any back numbers, please contact Mrs Ridley to establish whether she holds the issue(s) in which you are interested. For contact details see back inside cover of the Bulletin The Ricardian Bulletin is produced by the Bulletin Editorial Committee, Printed by Micropress Printers Ltd. © Richard III Society, 2009 From the Chairman resident Obama’s well-deserved reputation for oratory means that phrases from his speeches P are already appearing in dictionaries of quotations, and one in particular seems especially apt for the reputation of Richard III and the work of this Society: ‘the arc of history is long but it bends towards justice’. Since 1924, we have been helping to bend that arc in King Richard’s favour and as a mark for our success, it gives me great pleasure to report that HRH The Duke of Gloucester is willing to continue as our Patron for the foreseeable future (see page 21). It would seem that two iconic Ricardian sites, Bosworth and Sheriff Hutton, must now be viewed in a new light. The results of the recent archaeological investigations at Bosworth confirm what most of us already expected about the battle’s location (see page 19), while Jane Crease finishes her article on the Sheriff Hutton tomb with the definitive conclusion, which will be a disappointment to many members, that the tomb is certainly not that of Edward of Middleham. (Presumably this mean we can no longer refer to it as ‘Legless Eddie’?) The Ricardian Churches Restoration Fund supported the consolidation of the tomb in 1985, and our founder Saxon Barton contributed to restoration costs in 1949. However, it is a fifteenth-century monument and is probably the tomb of a Neville, so none of this has been in vain. Where, then, was Richard’s son buried? We’d like to hear your views. So, please, let the debate begin. Once again, in this issue, we have an interesting range of articles and reports. Jennie Powys- Lybbe concludes the series from the Cirencester Conference with an incisive look at the role of Margaret Beaufort, a most appropriate re-evaluation in this the quincentenary year of her death. Following on from references in the last issue to Richard III and lipstick, Tig Lang takes a fascinating look at mediaeval cosmetics. There is a report about the Bosworth weekend and our strong presence there, together with an account of the Society’s visit to South Wales, which gives a real sense of the locations visited and the camaraderie of the trip. The AGM and Members Day went well and, to me, seemed to have been a very happy and friendly day. Most would agree that the lecture by Tobias Capwell was outstanding, challenging, as it did, a lot of preconceived views about English armour in the fifteenth century. We hope Toby will expand on his views in a future issue, but in the meantime Lesley Boatwright’s excellent summary gives you an idea of what he told us. Down in the southern hemisphere, Australian and New Zealand Ricardians held a successful convention in Perth, during which Julia Redlich of the New South Wales Branch was presented with the 2009 Robert Hamblin Award by vice-president Rob Smith. Our congratulations to Julia. At the AGM, we also took a moment to celebrate Geoffrey Wheeler’s forty years of continuous service as a member of the Executive Committee. On behalf of all, I congratulate Geoff on this achievement and thank him for his contribution over those four decades. As the year ends, let me wish everyone a very happy Christmas and a safe and prosperous 2010, which will surely be another busy and productive year for the Society. Phil Stone 2 Annual General Meeting 2009 Minutes of the 2009 Annual General Meeting of the Richard III Society The 2009 Annual General Meeting of the Richard III Society was held at Staple Inn, Holborn, London on Saturday 3 October 2009 at 2.30 pm. 121 members were present. Apologies for absence were received from John Ashdown-Hill, John Audsley, Sandra Church, Rachel & Gordon Field, Yvonne Ginn, Moira Habberjam, Sally Henshaw, Elaine Hunt, Diana & Peter Lee, Andrea Lindow, Shirley & Roy Linsell, Wendy & Brian Moorhen, Jean Nicholls, Ian Rogers, Josephine Tewson, Juliet Wilson and Tom Wallis. The minutes of the 2008 Annual General Meeting, published in the winter Bulletin 2008, were approved and signed as correct. Chairman’s Remarks: Phil Stone welcomed members from the UK and overseas, including Elisabeth Sjoberg who lives in Sweden and Julia Campbell who lives in Paris. He then gave an address, including remarks on the year’s events and proposals for the future, and thanking a number of people for their input. His address is fully reported in this issue on pages 6-8. Secretaries’ Report: David Wells gave a brief report of his and Susan’s first period as Joint Secretaries and emphasised that, although there had been a lot of work and a ‘steep learning curve’, they had both enjoyed the experience and looked forward to continuing to make a contribution to the Society. Susan read out greetings from the American, New Zealand and Canadian branches, and from Moira Habberjam and John Audsley. Reports from Members of the Executive Committee and other Society officers: Richard Van Allen spoke on forthcoming productions/television programmes about the period including: a National Geographic programme examining the fate of the Princes as part of a series about unsolved/unexplained mysteries; a drama series for television written by Philippa Langley (Secretary of the Scottish Branch) entitled Richard III, Last of the Warrior Kings for which production support was being sought; and a possible film of Sharon Penman’s novel The Sunne in Splendour which was a much larger and, therefore, more costly, project. Marian Mitchell gave details of the trips organised during the past year and proposals for 2010 which included: day trip in May to Kenilworth day trip in September, possibly to Tewkesbury long week-end trip to Calais. Marian announced a change to the previously printed dates for this trip which would now take place from 15 to 18 July. Further details would be published in the December Bulletin. Marian went on to emphasise how important it was for Members to support the trips – coaches were becoming ever more expensive, and the more seats taken, the less expensive for each participant. She commented that there were few smaller coaches and, generally, 49 seats were the minimum. She then also emphasised that members of the Visits Committee enjoyed no privileges and paid the same as everyone else for the trips. Lesley Boatwright advised that the September Bulletin was the 26th in the new format, and gave a brief summary of some points of policy. She asked if members thought that the Bulletin Committee were ‘getting it right’ and invited responses by email or in writing to her address on the back cover of Bulletin. 3 Articles ‘for debate’ had not attracted many responses, and so the series had been dropped. For the series about ‘The Man Himself’ it was becoming more difficult to find something meaningful to say. Should the series continue and, if so, what issues could be addressed? Some issues attracted a degree of controversy. Currently, a response to the original article was published and the author given the chance to provide a rejoinder. Thereafter, anything further on the subject was published as general correspondence. Was this the right way to deal with such matters? The publication of fictional short stories had attracted much comment – favourable and unfavourable. She emphasised that the stories were submitted by invitation only by specific authors, who were asked to base their stories on a painting by Graham Turner. Do members find book reviews interesting or tedious? Should fiction be reviewed? It was felt that there should be a consistent policy, and there was a proposal under discussion within the Bulletin Committee for the establishment of a post of Reviews Editor. The Bulletin Committee would welcome information about work done by individual members to promote the Society and its work.