From Classical to Fusion: Changes in Hindustani Sitar Music in Malaysia As Exemplified in the Works of Orm Maheswaran and Samuel J
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
FROM CLASSICAL TO FUSION: CHANGES IN HINDUSTANI SITAR MUSIC IN MALAYSIA AS EXEMPLIFIED IN THE WORKS OF ORM MAHESWARAN AND SAMUEL J. DASS PRAVINA A/P MANOHARAN UNIVERSITY SAINS MALAYSIA 2008 FROM CLASSICAL TO FUSION: CHANGES IN HINDUSTANI SITAR MUSIC IN MALAYSIA AS EXEMPLIFIED IN THE WORKS OF ORM MAHESWARAN AND SAMUEL J. DASS by PRAVINA A/P MANOHARAN Thesis submitted in fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts MAY 2008 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS First and foremost my humble prostrations at the lotus feet of Bhagavan for without him this thesis would never have been completed. I would like to extend my warmest gratitude to a number of people who have been very instrumental in helping me complete this thesis. My parents have been the pillar of support for me throughout these years. I thank them from the bottom of my heart for believing in me and encouraging me all the way. Eric Bryan played a very important role in the early stages of my writing. Thank you for being my chief editor. Thank you aunty Arul for helping me proof read my thesis. Most importantly, I must thank Mr. Orm Maheswaran and Mr. Samuel J. Dass for graciously welcoming me into their homes and sharing every bit of knowledge they have on the Sitar and its music. Their knowledge in the fiend of Hindustani Sitar Music is immeasurable. They were more than helpful and ever willing to answer any question I had on the Sitar and its music. My knowledge of Raags and the Hindustani musical system has deepened greatly thanks to them. Finally my deepest gratitude to my supervisor Professor Tan for guiding me throughout this journey. She has been a source of inspiration for me throughout the process of my writing. She has also been most helpful in assisting me to improve my writing style. Finally thank you to one and all. ii TABLE OF CONTENTS Page ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ii TABLE OF CONTENTS iii LIST OF TABLES vii LIST OF FIGURES vii LIST OF PLATES x LIST OF TRACKS xi LIST OF SYMBOLS xiii ABSTRAK xiv ABSTRACT xvi CHAPTER ONE : INTRODUCTION 1 1.0 Introduction 1 1.1 Research Focus 2 1.2 Literature Review 6 1.2.1 Indian Music 6 1.2.2 Hindustani Music in India 11 1.2.3 Hindustani Instrumental Music in India 13 1.2.4 Fusion Music 16 1.2.4.1 Review of Books and Articles that define Fusion 17 Music 1.2.4.2 The Debate between the Elders (Purists) and 19 Younger Generation (Fusion musicians). 1.3 Methodology 26 1.4 Theoretical Approach 29 1.5 Organization of Thesis 33 CHAPTER TWO : THE CLASSICAL SITAR 37 2.0 Introduction 37 iii 2.1 History and Development 38 2.2 Construction of the Sitar 41 2.3 Gharana 48 2.4 Tuning the Sitar 52 2.4.1 Indian Classical Tuning System 54 2.4.2 Vilayat Khan Tuning Method 56 2.4.3 Ravi Shankar Tuning Method 61 2.5 Playing Style 64 2.5.1 The playing style of Vilayat Khan 65 2.5.2 The playing style of Ravi Shankar 67 2.6 Playing Technique 70 2.6.1 Ornaments or Alankara 74 2.7 Summary 77 CHAPTER THREE: THE MODERN SITAR 79 3.0 Introduction 79 3.1 The Development of Indian Music in Malaysia 80 3.2 The Development of Hindustani Music in Malaysia 81 3.3 The Development of the Sitar in Malaysia 83 3.3.1 Orm Maheswaran 87 Contributions 89 3.3.2 From Classical to Fusion: The Transition 91 3.3.3 Samuel J. Dass 93 Contributions 96 3.3.4 Inner Space (TFA) 102 3.4 Modern Sitar Tuning 103 3.5 Playing Style 108 3.6 Playing Technique 109 3.7 Summary 113 iv CHAPTER FOUR: RAAG AND TAAL; 117 THE SOUL OF HINDUSTANI MUSIC 4.0 Introduction 117 4.1 The Scale 118 4.1.1 Notation 122 4.2 Raag 123 4.3 Taal 131 4.4 Classical Sitar Performance 139 4.4.1 Alap 139 4.4.2 Jod 142 4.4.3 Jhala 144 4.4.4 Gat 146 4.5 Summary 151 CHAPTER FIVE: CHANGES IN HINDUSTANI MUSICAL ELEMENTS: 154 RAAG AND TAAL 5.0 Introduction 154 5.1 Raag 155 5.1.1 Example 1 156 i Characteristics of Raags Bhairavi, Malkauns and 156 Nandkauns. ii Analysis of the three classical Raags in the fusion piece 158 Life Breath 5.1.2 Example 2 161 i Characteristics of Raags Bageshri and Pahadi 161 ii Analysis of Raag Bageshri in the fusion piece Vibrations 163 5.1.3 Example 3 165 i Characteristics of Raag Bhairagi Bhairav 166 ii Analysis of Raag Bhairagi Bhairav in the fusion piece 166 Prana Express 5.1.4 Example 4 168 i Characteristics of Raag Bhupali 168 ii Analysis of Raag Bhupali in the fusion piece Chinese Song 169 v 5.2 Taal 172 5.2.1 Example 1 172 5.2.2 Example 2 174 5.2.3 Example 3 176 5.2.4 Example 4 177 5.3 Summary 180 CHAPTER SIX: CHANGES IN HINDUSTANI MUSICAL FORMS: 186 ALAP, GAT, SAWAL JAWAB, TIHAI AND TIRMANAM 6.0 Introduction 186 6.1 Alap 187 6.1.1 Characteristics of a classical alap 188 6.1.2 Example 1 191 6.1.3 Example 2 193 6.2 Gat 194 6.2.1 Characteristics of a classical gat 195 6.2.2 Example 1 197 6.2.3 Example 2 199 6.2.4 Example 3 201 6.2.5 Example 4 204 6.3 Sawal Jawab 207 6.3.1 Characteristics of a classical sawal jawab 208 6.3.2 Example 1 209 6.4 Tihai and Tirmanam 211 6.4.1 Characteristics of a classical tihai 211 6.4.2 Example 1 213 6.4.3 Example 2 214 6.5 Summary 216 CHAPTER SEVEN: CONCLUSION 221 7.0 Summary of Chapters 221 7.1 The Past, The Present & The Future 230 vi LIST OF TABLES Page 4.1 Five Most Important Rules and Characteristics of a Raag 131 Comparison in the characteristics of the musical elements in 184 classical compositions and fusion compositions. Comparison in the characteristics of the musical forms in 218 classical compositions and fusion compositions. LIST OF FIGURES 2.1 Vilayat Khan’s Tuning Method based on Western Notation. 58 2.2 Vilayat Khan’s Tuning Method of the main strings for Raag 59 Kafi 2.3 Ravi Shankar’s Tuning Method based on Western Notation. 63 2.4 Tarab String tuning based on Raag Bilaval. 64 3.1 Ravi Shankar tuning method of the main strings employed by 88 Orm Maheshwaran. 3.2 Vilayat Khan tuning method of the main strings employed by 96 Samuel Dass. 3.3 Tuning of the tarab strings based on the chromatic scale. 106 3.4 Tuning of the tarab strings for the piece Funky Indians. 106 3.5 Tuning of the tarab strings for the piece Damascus 107 3.6 Meend and gamak for the piece Vibrations by Samuel Dass 112 3.7 Gamakas employed by Dass in the solo section for Prana 112 Express 4.1 The twelve swarastanas of the Hindustani scale. 118 4.2 The Saptak of Hindustani music with Western and Hindustani 119 notation 4.3 The seven swaras that fall within the twenty-two shrutis. 121 vii 4.4 Significance of each note in Raag Yaman 126 4.5 Excerpt of a gat for Raag Yaman. 126 4.6 Pakad for Raag Bhairav by Kumar Karthigesu 128 4.7 The structure of a Teen Taal represented by a circle 133 4.8 Notation for Teen Taal. 133 4.9 Theka for Teen Taal. 136 4.10 Matra division for Keherwa Taal 136 4.11 Hand movement Adi Tala 137 4.12 Scale for Raag Basant Mukhari 141 4.13 Alap for Raag Basant Mukhari 141 4.14 Jod section for Raag Basant Mukhari 143 4.15 Jhala section for Raag Basant Mukhari 144 4.16 Rhythm pattern played on the chikari strings for the jhala 145 section 4.17 Gat in Raag Basant Mukhari 148 5.1 Scale for Raag Bhairavi 157 5.2 Scale for Raag Malkauns 157 5.3 Scale for Raag Nandkauns 158 5.4 Excerpt from fusion piece Life Breath by Samuel Dass. 158 5.5 Scale for Raag Bageshri 161 5.6 Scale for Raag Pahadi 162 5.7 Excerpt from fusion piece Vibrations by Samuel Dass 163 5.8 Scale for Raag Bhairagi Bhairav 166 5.9 Pakad for Raag Bhairagi Bhairav 166 5.10 Excerpt from the first Sitar solo section in Prana Express by 167 Samuel Dass viii 5.11 Scale of Raag Bhupali 168 5.12 Pakad for Raag Bhupali 168 5.13 Chinese Song by Samuel Dass 169 5.14 Bossa Novan Rhythm 173 5.15 Tabla Bols for Bombay Bossa Nova by Prakash Kandasamy 173 5.16 Masri Rhythm 175 5.17 Keherwa Taal 176 5.18 Basic theka for Keherwa Taal 177 6.1 Alap for Raag Bhairavi by Orm Maheswaran 188 6.2 Introduction section of Life Breath by Samuel Dass 191 6.3 Introduction section of Vibrations by Samuel Dass 193 6.4 Short Gat in Raag Bhairagi Bhairav by Samuel Dass 196 6.5 Sitar solo for Prana Express by Samuel Dass 198 6.6 Second Sitar solo section from Life Breath by Samuel Dass 199 6.7 Maqam Hisar 201 6.8 Scale for Raag Simhendramadhyamam 202 6.9 Scale for Raag Shanmukhapriya 202 6.10 Sitar solo for Damascus by Samuel Dass 202 6.11 Scale of Raag Chalanata 204 6.12 Sitar solo for Brickfields Blues by Samuel Dass 205 6.13 Structure of a classical sawal jawab by Samuel Dass and 208 Prakash Kandasamy.