100Th Anniversary of the Evangelical Lutheran Synod
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
100TH ANNIVERSARY OF THE EVANGELICAL LUTHERAN SYNOD L LU ICA TH EL ER G A N N A S V Y E N E O H D T LUTHERAN SYNOD QUARTERLY VOLUME 58 • NUMBERS 2 & 3 JUNE & SEPTEMBER 2018 The journal of Bethany Lutheran Theological Seminary ISSN: 0360-9685 LUTHERAN SYNOD QUARTERLY 70-6.& t /6.#&34 +6/&4&15&.#&3 Te journal of Bethany Lutheran Teological Seminary Lutheran Synod QuarterLy Editor-in-ChiEf........................................................... Gaylin R. Schmeling Book rEviEw Editor ......................................................... Michael K. Smith Layout Editor ................................................................. Daniel J. Hartwig PrintEr ......................................................... Books of the Way of the Lord The Lutheran Synod Quarterly (ISSN: 0360-9685) is edited by the faculty of Bethany Lutheran Theological Seminary 6 Browns Court Mankato, Minnesota 56001 The Lutheran Synod Quarterly is a continuation of the Clergy Bulletin (1941–1960). The purpose of the Lutheran Synod Quarterly, as was the purpose of the Clergy Bulletin, is to provide a testimony of the theological position of the Evangelical Lutheran Synod and also to promote the academic growth of her clergy roster by providing scholarly articles, rooted in the inerrancy of the Holy Scriptures and the Confessions of the Evangelical Lutheran Church. The Lutheran Synod Quarterly is published in March and December with a combined June and September issue. Subscription rates are $25.00 U.S. per year for domestic subscriptions and $35.00 U.S. per year for international subscriptions. All subscriptions and editorial correspondence should be sent to the following address: Bethany Lutheran Theological Seminary Attn: Lutheran Synod Quarterly 6 Browns Ct Mankato MN 56001 Back issues of the Lutheran Synod Quarterly from the past two years are available at a cost of $10.00 per issue. Back issues of the Lutheran Synod Quarterly and Clergy Bulletin prior to the past two years are available at <www.blts.edu/lsq>. The Lutheran Synod Quarterly is abstracted in Religious and Theological Abstracts, PO Box 215, Myerstown, PA 17067 (E-mail: [email protected]; Website: www.rtabstracts.org). Copyright ©2018 by Bethany Lutheran Theological Seminary. Requests for permission to reproduce more than brief excerpts are to be directed to the Editor- in-Chief. Contents LSQ Vol. 58, Nos. 2 & 3 (June & September 2018) Presidential Quotes From the Past ................................................163 A Brief History of the Evangelical Lutheran Synod ........................165 Gaylin R. Schmeling Our Pioneer Church Fathers .........................................................199 H. M. Tjernagel From De Servo Arbitrio to Opgjør ................................................203 Erling T. Teigen Following the Old Paths: The Theology of the Norwegian Synod (1853 & 1918) ...................................................................219 Erling T. Teigen Enduring Impressions from the Austin Agreement of 1916: An Unintended Compromise with Far Reaching Effects ................241 John A. Moldstad Unto the Third and Fourth Generations: A History of the ELS Within the Broader Context of American Lutheranism ..................271 Craig A. Ferkenstad Confessional Evangelical Lutheran Conference — A Worldwide Fellowship ..............................................................289 Gaylin R. Schmeling 158 Lutheran Synod Quarterly Vol. 58 Sermon on John 6:48–51: Two Reasons to Turn Away Are Two Reasons to Stay .....................................................................293 Thomas A. Kuster Sermon on Ezekiel 22:28–31: Day of Humiliation— December 14, 1941 .....................................................................297 Milton H. Otto Sermon on 2 Timothy 2:1–2 at the Installation of Seminary President Theodore Aaberg ...........................................................307 Milton H. Otto Book Reviews Book Review: Proclaim His Wonders ...........................................313 Gaylin R. Schmeling Book Review: The Election Controversy Among Lutherans in the Twentieth Century ..................................................................316 S. Piet Van Kampen 2018 BjaRne w. Teigen RefoRmaTion LecTuRes ........................................319 Foreword LSQ Vol. 58, Nos. 2 & 3 (June & September 2018) )& :&"3 ."3,4 5)& 0/&ɠ)6/%3&%5) BOOJWFSTBSZPGUIF&WBOHFMJDBM-VUIFSBO4ZOPE &-4 *O TFWFSBM QBTUPST HBUIFSFE BU -JNF $SFFL -VUIFSBO $IVSDI JO 5SVSBM-BLF.JMMT *PXBɩPVHITUBOEJOHTPMJEMZPO4DSJQUVSFTGPVOEB- UJPO UIFZ SFQSFTFOUFE B UIFPMPHJDBM NJOPSJUZ BNPOH UIF /PSXFHJBO "NFSJDBO-VUIFSBOTɩFJSTQJSJUVBMIFSJUBHF IPXFWFS XBTOPUVOJRVF UPFJUIFS/PSXBZPS"NFSJDBɩFQBTUPSTBOEMBZNFONFUUPSFPSHBOJ[F POUIFTBNFGPVOEBUJPOVQPOXIJDIUIFiPMEw/PSXFHJBO4ZOPEXBT CVJMUɩFZXFSFFODPVSBHFECZUIFXPSETPG+FSFNJBIi4UBOEJOUIFXBZ BOETFF BOEBTLGPSUIFPMEQBUIT XIFSFUIFHPPEXBZJT BOEXBMLJOJU UIFOZPVXJMMmOESFTUGPSZPVSTPVMTw ɩFSFPSHBOJ[FETZOPEIBT SFNBJOFEPOUIFPMEQBUITJOBMMJUTUFBDIJOHXIFSFPOFDBOmOESFTUGPS UIFTPVMUSVFSFTUGPVOEJO+FTVTPVS4BWJPS0VSTPVMTBSFOFWFSBUSFTU VOUJMXFBSFBUSFTUJO)JN 0VSTZOPEJTDPOUJOVBMMZTUSJWJOHUPQSPDMBJNUIFHSBDJPVTNFTTBHF PGKVTUJmDBUJPOCZGBJUIBMPOFJO$ISJTUBTUIF4BWJPS8FBSFEFDMBSFE SJHIUFPVT CZ OPUIJOH XF EP PS BDDPNQMJTI CVU BMPOF PO UIF CBTJT PG $ISJTUT SFEFNQUJWF XPSL XIJDI JT DPVOUFE BT PVST UISPVHI GBJUI JO )JN )F BDDPNQMJTIFE TBMWBUJPO GPS BMM PO UIF DSPTT BOE BOOPVODFE JUUPBMMCZ)JTSFTVSSFDUJPOEFDMBSJOHUIFXIPMFXPSMESJHIUFPVTɩJT XPOEFSGVMUSFBTVSFJTPĊFSFEUPVTJOUIFNFBOTPGHSBDF UIF8PSEBOE UIF 4BDSBNFOUT BOE JT SFDFJWFE CZ GBJUI BMPOF JO )JN BT UIF 4BWJPS 160 Lutheran Synod Quarterly Vol. 58 XIJDIGBJUIJTXPSLFE TUSFOHUIFOFE BOEQSFTFSWFEUISPVHIUIFTFTBNF NFBOTPGHSBDF ɩJTJTTVFPGUIFQuarterlyDPOUBJOTFTTBZTXIJDIQSFTFOUUIFIJTUPSZ PG UIF TZOPE ɩFTF FTTBZT SFNJOE VT PG UIF TBDSJmDF NBEF CZ PVS GBUIFSTUPNBJOUBJOBOPSUIPEPY -VUIFSBOTZOPEPG/PSXFHJBOPSJHJO *NQPSUBOUMFTTPOTBSFUBVHIUJOUIJTIJTUPSZDPODFSOJOHUIFQSFTFSWBUJPO PGDPOGFTTJPOBM-VUIFSBOUIFPMPHZBOEDPODFSOJOHUIFGVMmMMNFOUPGUIF -PSET (SFBU $PNNJTTJPO UP QSPDMBJN UIF (PTQFM JO FWFSZ MBOE BOE OBUJPO "MTP XF BSF FODPVSBHFE JO UIJT BOOJWFSTBSZ ZFBS UP UIBOL UIF -PSEGPSBMM)JTCMFTTJOHTBT,PSFOEPFTJOIJTXFMMLOPXOIZNO :FMBOET UPUIF-PSENBLFBKVCJMBOUOPJTF (MPSZCFUP(PE 0TFSWF)JNXJUIKPZ JO)JTQSFTFODFOPXSFKPJDF 4JOHQSBJTFVOUP(PEPVUPG;JPO &-) 8F BSF DPODMVEJOH B TFSJFT PG RVPUBUJPOT FOUJUMFE i1SFTJEFOUJBM 2VPUFT'SPNUIF1BTUwɩFTFSJFTIBTJODMVEFEBOVNCFSPGSFMFWBOU $ISJTUDFOUFSFERVPUFTGSPNUIFGPSNFSQSFTJEFOUTPGUIF&-4BTXF DFMFCSBUFUIFPOFIVOESFEUIBOOJWFSTBSZPGUIFTZOPEɩJTTFSJFTIBT CFFOQSPEVDFECZUIF3FW+PIO.PMETUBE QSFTJEFOUPGUIF&-4 ɩF FTTBZ i"#SJFG )JTUPSZ PG UIF &WBOHFMJDBM -VUIFSBO 4ZOPE w HJWFTBOPWFSWJFXPGUIFTZOPETIJTUPSZXJUIJUTWJUBMXPSLJONJTTJPOT BOEFEVDBUJPOɩFEPDUSJOBMEJTDVTTJPOTPGUIFTZOPEUISPVHIPVUUIF ZFBSTBSFBMTPJODMVEFE "SFQSJOUPGBOBSUJDMFGSPNUIFLutheran Sentinel WPM OP JTJODMVEFEJOUIJTBOOJWFSTBSZJTTVF*UFYQMBJOTXIZ)"1SFVT +" 0UUFTFO BOE67,PSFOBSFDPOTJEFSFEUPCFUIFQSFEPNJOBOUGBUIFST JOUIF/PSXFHJBO4ZOPEɩJTBSUJDMFXBTmSTUXSJUUFOJOSFBDUJPOUPUIF DFOUFOOJBMPG/PSXFHJBO-VUIFSBOJTNJO"NFSJDBJOUIFZFBS *OIJTBondage of the Will -VUIFSSFKFDUT&SBTNVTDMBJNUIBUOBUVSBM NBOIBTGSFFEPNPGDIPJDFJOUIFTQJSJUVBMSFBMNɩJTTBNFFSSPSXBT GPVOEJOUIF/PSXFHJBONFSHFSEPDVNFOU 0QHKS PGBOEJOUIF JOGBNPVTTUBUFNFOUPG'"4DINJEU i4BMWBUJPOJOBDFSUBJOTFOTFEPFT OPUEFQFOEPO(PEBMPOFwɩJTDPOOFDUJPOJTNBEFJOUIFFTTBZ i'SPN %F4FSWP"SCJUSJPUP0QHKSw*UXBTXSJUUFOCZ1SPGFN&SMJOH5FJHFO ɩFUIFPMPHZPGUIF/PSXFHJBO4ZOPEBOEUIFSFPSHBOJ[FETZOPE PG XBT JOnVFODFE CZ UIF -VUIFSBO 3FOFXBM JO &VSPQF XIJDI PDDVSSFE JO UIF FBSMZ ZFBST PG UIF OJOFUFFOUI DFOUVSZ ɩF SFOFXBM DFOUFSFE PO B SFUVSO UP UIF -VUIFSBO $POGFTTJPOT BOE UIF XSJUJOHT Nos. 2 & 3 Foreword 161 PG -VUIFS ɩF EPDUSJOF PG UIF TZOPE XBT UIBU XIJDI XBT SFWFBMFE UISPVHI(PET)PMZ8PSEJOUIFDBOPOJDBMCPPLTPGUIF0MEBOE/FX 5FTUBNFOUT JOUFSQSFUFE JO BHSFFNFOU XJUI UIF TZNCPMJDBM CPPLT PS DPOGFTTJPOBMXSJUJOHTɩJTJTUIFQPJOUPGUIFFTTBZi'PMMPXJOHUIF0ME 1BUITɩFɩFPMPHZPGUIF/PSXFHJBO4ZOPE wXSJUUFO CZ1SPGFN&SMJOH5FJHFO " EPDVNFOU DBMMFE UIF i"VTUJO "HSFFNFOU w XSJUUFO JO TUBUFEUIBUXIJMFUIFUXPQPTJUJPOTFYQSFTTFEJOUIF0QHKSPS.BEJTPO "HSFFNFOUXFSFBMMPXFEUPTUBOEFRVBMMZTJEFCZTJEF BOZPOFXIPGPS DPOTDJFODFTBLFDPVMEBDDFQUPOMZ'PSN*XPVMECFUPMFSBUFEJOUIFOFX VOJUFEDIVSDICPEZGPSNFEJOɩJTDPNQSPNJTFEPDVNFOUNBEF JUQPTTJCMFGPSBTJHOJmDBOUNJOPSJUZUPFOUFSUIFNFSHFS DSFBUJOHUIF /PSXFHJBO -VUIFSBO $IVSDI JO "NFSJDBɩJT IJTUPSZ JT SFWJFXFE JO UIFFTTBZi&OEVSJOH*NQSFTTJPOTGSPNUIF"VTUJO"HSFFNFOUPG w XSJUUFOCZUIF3FW+PIO.PMETUBE QSFTJEFOUPGUIF&-4 *UIBTCFFOTBJEUIBUOPTZOPEIBTSFNBJOFEDPOTFSWBUJWFCFZPOE UIF UIJSE HFOFSBUJPO ɩF mSTU HFOFSBUJPO GPVHIU UIF CBUUMFT ɩF TFDPOEHFOFSBUJPOIFBSEUIFTUPSJFT VOEFSTUPPEBOEBQQSFDJBUFEUIFN )PXFWFSUIFUIJSEHFOFSBUJPOPOMZIBTIJTUPSZBOEPGUFOCFDPNFTJOEJG- GFSFOUBOEHPFTBTUSBZ*OUIJTBOOJWFSTBSZZFBSPGUIF&-4PVSNFNCFS- TIJQJTJOUIFUIJSEHFOFSBUJPO*OIJTFTTBZ i6OUPUIFɩJSEBOE'PVSUI (FOFSBUJPOT " )JTUPSZ PG UIF &-4 8JUIJO UIF #SPBEFS $POUFYU PG "NFSJDBO -VUIFSBOJTN w UIF 3FW $SBJH 'FSLFOTUBE FODPVSBHFT PVS TZOPEUPSFNBJOJOUIFDPOGFTTJPOBOEPSUIPEPYTUBOEPGPVSGPSFGBUIFST "TXFBSFBMMBXBSF MBTUZFBSXFDFMFCSBUFEUIFmWFIVOESFEUIBOOJ- WFSTBSZ PG UIF -VUIFSBO 3FGPSNBUJPO BOE UIJT ZFBS JT UIF IVOESFEUI BOOJWFSTBSZ PG UIF &-4 *O BEEJUJPO UP UIFTF JNQPSUBOU FWFOUT UIJT ZFBS JT UIF UXFOUZmGUI BOOJWFSTBSZ PG PVS XPSMEXJEF GFMMPXTIJQ UIF $POGFTTJPOBM &WBOHFMJDBM -VUIFSBO $POGFSFODF )FSF XF FYQSFTT GFMMPXTIJQXJUIMJLFNJOEFE$ISJTUJBOTGSPNBSPVOEUIFXPSMEBTOPUFE JO i$POGFTTJPOBM &WBOHFMJDBM -VUIFSBO $POGFSFODF" 8PSMEXJEF 'FMMPXTIJQw *ODMVEFE JO UIJT JTTVF PG UIF Quarterly BSF UISFF TFSNPOT POF PG XIJDIJTB#FUIBOZ$IBQFMTFSNPOPO+PIOoCZ%SɩPNBT"