International Environmental Law Research Centre FALLACIES OF EQUALITY AND INEQUALITY MULTIPLE EXCLUSIONS IN LAW AND LEGAL DISCOURSES Patricia Kameri-Mbote Published in: Inaugural Lecture, University of Nairobi, 24 January 2013. This paper can be downloaded in PDF format from IELRC’s website at http://www.ielrc.org/content/w1301.pdf International Environmental Law Research Centre
[email protected] www.ielrc.org U N I TAT RE E ET LA BO UNIVERSITY OF NAIROBI Fallacies of Equality and Inequality: Multiple Exclusions in Law and Legal Discourses Inaugural Lecture By Prof. Annie Patricia G. Kameri-Mbote, SC LL.B ’87 (Nairobi), LL.M ’89 (Warwick), JSM ’96, JSD’99 (Stanford) Professor of Law Department of Private Law School of Law Date: 24th January 2013 FALLACIES OF EQUALITY AND INEQUALITY: MULTIPLE EXCLUSIONS IN LAW AND LEGAL DISCOURSES ii FALLACIES OF EQUALITY AND INEQUALITY: MULTIPLE EXCLUSIONS IN LAW AND LEGAL DISCOURSES Contents Profile iii Acknowledgments v Dedication viii I. Introduction 1 II. Laying the Basis: Fundamental Concepts 3 A. Rights 3 B. Human Rights 4 1. Normative Renditions 4 2. Critique of Rights 6 C. Equality 7 D. Discrimination 9 III. Intersectionality and Multiple Exclusions 11 A. What is intersectionality/Multiple Exclusions? 11 B. Intersectionality and Multiple Exclusions in Kenya’s Constitution 12 C. Utilitarianism or Intuitionism? 13 IV. The Fallacies of Equality 15 A. Subjects of Law 15 1. States in International Law 15 2. Gender 18 (a) Elective and Appointive Positions 19 (b) Employment 20 (c) Ownership and Inheritance of Land 21 i FALLACIES OF EQUALITY AND INEQUALITY: MULTIPLE EXCLUSIONS IN LAW AND LEGAL DISCOURSES 3.