Priests and Their Books in Late Medieval Eichstätt

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Priests and Their Books in Late Medieval Eichstätt Priests and Their Books in Late Medieval Eichstätt Priests and Their Books in Late Medieval Eichstätt Matthew Wranovix LEXINGTON BOOKS Lanham • Boulder • New York • London Published by Lexington Books An imprint of The Rowman & Littlefield Publishing Group, Inc. 4501 Forbes Boulevard, Suite 200, Lanham, Maryland 20706 www.rowman.com Unit A, Whitacre Mews, 26-34 Stannary Street, London SE11 4AB Copyright © 2017 by Lexington Books All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced in any form or by any electronic or mechanical means, including information storage and retrieval systems, without written permission from the publisher, except by a reviewer who may quote passages in a review. British Library Cataloguing in Publication Information Available Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Library of Congress Control Number: 2017951050 ISBN 978-1-4985-4886-1 (hardback : alk. paper) ISBN 978-1-4985-4887-8 (electronic) TM The paper used in this publication meets the minimum requirements of American National Standard for Information Sciences Permanence of Paper for Printed Library Materials, ANSI/NISO Z39.48-1992. Printed in the United States of America Contents Acknowledgments vii Introduction ix Map of the Diocese of Eichstätt in 1480 xix 1 Education 1 2 The Priest in the Parish, Diocese, and Territory 35 3 Parish Libraries and Personal Collections 67 4 A Professional Library 101 5 Reading Interests 131 Conclusion 167 Appendix A: Texts Appearing in Books Owned and/or Produced by Priests in the Diocese of Eichstätt 175 Appendix B: List of Works Appearing in Books Belonging to the Parish Library of Schwabach 183 Bibliography 189 Index 213 About the Author 221 v Acknowledgments In the course of this project I have accumulated numerous debts, both person- al and financial. I would like to thank both Yale University and the Fulbright Foundation for the monetary support that made my research possible. Anders Winroth, Bob Babcock, and especially my advisor Paul Freedman provided invaluable training and ready aid whenever I encountered problems. My research was aided greatly by the staffs of the libraries and archives in which I worked; in particular I would like to thank Bruno Lengenfelder in the Diözesanarchiv Eichstätt, Christian Büchele, Klaus Walter Littger, and Kon- rad Bauernfeind in the Universitätsbibliothek Eichstätt, and Thomas Engelke in the Staatsarchiv Nürnberg. Three scholars in Germany, Enno Bünz of the University of Leipzig, Sigrid Schmitt of the University of Mainz, and the late Harald Dickerhof of the University of Eichstätt, deserve special thanks both for the aid they offered my research and for the warm welcome they ex- tended to a scholar from abroad. I would also like to thank Brian Noell for his comments on the early drafts of several chapters, Bill Whobrey for his help with several translations, and Jamie Lynn Slenker for the map and mock-ups of several cover designs. My colleagues at the University of New Haven have offered me continuous encouragement, support, and fellowship and for that I am very grateful. Thanks also to the editors at Lexington and the anonymous peer reviewer who saved me from several embarrassing er- rors. Without my family I would never even have begun this project. I would like to thank my parents for the love of books that they instilled in me; Satoko, for her love and generosity; and Miya and Emi, for their patience with a father too often absorbed by his work. vii Introduction In 1460 Ulrich Pfeffel, the rector of the parish church in Preith, a village near Eichstätt, received a manuscript containing a biblical commentary by Mat- thias de Liegnitz along with the following note: Dear Sir Ulrich, I have often been given to understand how much you like the books. I am now sending them to you and will give you a better deal than I would give to others and ask if you could lend me four gulden, which I will repay you. It is not an issue if you do not have the money; keep the books anyway. When I am able to visit you, then we can come to an agreement. If you then must have the [four] gulden, then I do not wish to burden you about it. Karl von Seckendorf.1 Karl von Seckendorf was a former student in Heidelberg and future cathedral canon in Eichstätt. This study is motivated by a series of questions inspired by Karl’s note. What is a small-town rector doing corresponding with such an educated figure? How did he get a reputation as a bibliophile? Were there other parish priests who similarly “liked books”? To try to answer this question I have sought out books, both printed and hand-copied, that once lodged in parish libraries or belonged to members of the parish clergy in the diocese of Eichstätt, located in modern-day Bavaria. What priests read is a question of fundamental importance to our understand- ing of the late medieval parish and the role of the clergy as communicators and cultural mediators. Highly visible and vitally important, the parish clergy worked at the intersection of the institutional Church and the Christian popu- lation of Western Europe.2 Priests were entrusted with saying the Mass, preaching doctrine and repentance, honoring the saints, plumbing the con- science, and protecting the legal rights of the Church. They baptized chil- dren, blessed the fields, and prayed for the souls of the dead. What priests ix x Introduction read would have informed how they understood and how they performed their social and religious roles. Yet this might seem to be an inauspicious topic given the persistent doubts concerning the piety and intellectual attainment of priests expressed throughout the medieval period and into the sixteenth century (and beyond). If the image of the clergy found in the criticisms of churchmen and poets were true, then a study such as this one would be frustrating indeed. In the tense years leading up to the Act of Supremacy (1534), for example, Thomas Starkey held up the parish clergy of England for ridicule: There ys . a grete faute wych ys the ground of al other almost, and that ys concerning the educatyn of them wych appoint themselfe to be men of the Church. They are not brought up in virtu and lernyng as the schold be, nor wel approvyd therin before they be admitted to such hye dygnyte . for common- ly you schal fynd that they can no thing dow but pattyr up theyr matins and mas, mumblying up a certain number of wordys no thynge understoode.3 This is admittedly a piece of polemic, but the image of the medieval priest contained within it has proven remarkably persistent. Scurrilous depictions in goliardic poetry, in vernacular literature such as the Decameron, and in ser- mons and exempla were enough to create an enduring image of the venal, sensual, and ill-educated priest. 4 Visitation records do not survive in suffi- cient numbers to come to general conclusions regarding clerical education, but examples of ill-educated priests are easy to find in those that do. This kind of evidence led G. G. Coulton to declare in the early twentieth century that “the evidence of clerical ignorance all through the Middle Ages . is overwhelming.”5 In 1953, in what remains one of the most frequently cited studies on clerical education, Friedrich Wilhelm Oediger blamed clerical ignorance on a spirituality that emphasized simplicity of spirit over learning. 6 Some more regionally focused studies appeared to bear out this conclusion. 7 Indeed scholarly opinion of the parish clergy has been so low that its failings were often listed among the causes of the Reformation. Joseph Lortz, for example, argued that pluralism led to the creation of a clerical proletariat of such “terrifying size and declining quality” that it contributed to the failure of the Church to dislodge superstition from popular piety. 8 Jean Delumeau doubted that most Europeans were more than superficially Christian, so deep was the ignorance of the clergy. 9 Conclusions such as Delumeau’s have not gone unchallenged; since the 1970s scholars have used prosopographical analysis of university matricula- tion records, visitation protocols, and other administrative sources to call the image of the ignorant priest into question or at least soften the edges. 10 Whereas in 1964 A. G. Dickens described the late medieval English church as “an old, unseaworthy and ill-commanded galleon,” in the early 1990s R. N. Swanson described the late medieval English clergy as “forceful,” and Introduction xi Eamon Duffy defended medieval religion as “vigorous, adaptable, widely understood, and popular” and claimed that the Church was “a highly success- ful educator.”11 Scholars have noted that laypersons rarely lodged complaints during visitations about the intellectual wherewithal of their priests, while others have estimated that as much as 40 to 50 percent of the parish clergy in some areas of Europe had, at least briefly, attended a university. 12 One analy- sis of the fifteenth-century records of the Apostolic Penitentiary and Apostol- ic Chamber concluded that the much derided ordination exam was taken more seriously than previous scholars have assumed. 13 Clerical ignorance has similarly lost favor as an explanation for the Reformation. 14 This modest rehabilitation of the image of the parish clergy is a part of a larger reinterpretation of the late Middle Ages. This period was long de- scribed as an age that careened from crisis to crisis, devastated by the Black Death, torn by the Great Schism, buffeted by the Hundred Years War and Hussite challenge, and finally capsized by the Reformation. 15 With such a backdrop, widespread clerical ignorance was to be expected, a sign of the times.
Recommended publications
  • The Lives of the Saints
    Itl 1 i ill 11 11 i 11 i I 'M^iii' I III! II lr|i^ P !| ilP i'l ill ,;''ljjJ!j|i|i !iF^"'""'""'!!!|| i! illlll!lii!liiy^ iiiiiiiiiiHi '^'''liiiiiiiiilii ;ili! liliiillliili ii- :^ I mmm(i. MwMwk: llliil! ""'''"'"'''^'iiiiHiiiiiliiiiiiiiiiiiii !lj!il!|iilil!i|!i!ll]!; 111 !|!|i!l';;ii! ii!iiiiiiiiiiilllj|||i|jljjjijl I ili!i||liliii!i!il;.ii: i'll III ''''''llllllllilll III "'""llllllll!!lll!lllii!i I i i ,,„, ill 111 ! !!ii! : III iiii CORNELL UNIVERSITY LIBRARY l,wj Cornell Unrversity Library BR 1710.B25 1898 V.5 Lives ot the saints. Ili'lll I 3' 1924 026 082 572 Cornell University Library The original of tliis book is in tine Cornell University Library. There are no known copyright restrictions in the United States on the use of the text. http://www.archive.org/details/cu31924026082572 THE ilibes? of tlje t)atnt0 REV. S. BARING-GOULD SIXTEEN VOLUMES VOLUME THE FIFTH THE ILities of tlje g)amt6 BY THE REV. S. BARING-GOULD, M.A. New Edition in i6 Volumes Revised with Introduction and Additional Lives of English Martyrs, Cornish and Welsh Saints, and a full Index to the Entire Work ILLUSTRATED BY OVER 400 ENGRAVINGS VOLUME THE FIFTH LONDON JOHN C. NFMMO &-• NEW YORK . LONGMANS, GREEN. CO. MDCCCXCVIll / , >1< ^-Hi-^^'^ -^ / :S'^6 <d -^ ^' Printed by Ballantyne, Hanson &> CO. At the Ballantyne Press *- -»5< im CONTENTS PAGE Bernardine . 309 SS. Achilles and comp. 158 Boniface of Tarsus . 191 B. Alcuin 263 Boniface IV., Pope . 345 S. Aldhelm .... 346 Brendan of Clonfert 217 „ Alexander I., Pope .
    [Show full text]
  • Denmark and the Crusades 1400 – 1650
    DENMARK AND THE CRUSADES 1400 – 1650 Janus Møller Jensen Ph.D.-thesis, University of Southern Denmark, 2005 Contents Preface ...............................................................................................................................v Introduction.......................................................................................................................1 Crusade Historiography in Denmark ..............................................................................2 The Golden Age.........................................................................................................4 New Trends ...............................................................................................................7 International Crusade Historiography...........................................................................11 Part I: Crusades at the Ends of the Earth, 1400-1523 .......................................................21 Chapter 1: Kalmar Union and the Crusade, 1397-1523.....................................................23 Denmark and the Crusade in the Fourteenth Century ..................................................23 Valdemar IV and the Crusade...................................................................................27 Crusades and Herrings .............................................................................................33 Crusades in Scandinavia 1400-1448 ..............................................................................37 Papal Collectors........................................................................................................38
    [Show full text]
  • From Rhetoric to Memory: Islam, Ottomans, and Austrian Historians
    F R O M R HETORIC TO M EMORY : Islam, Ottomans, and Austrian Historians in the Renaissance By Paula Sutter Fichtner Analyzing Austrian accounts from before the fall of Constantinople through the failed siege of Vienna in 1529 as contributions to historical memory, the essay not only registers the images of the Islamic opponents, in particular the Ottoman Turks, but also considers the type of experience behind these accounts. In a number of cases interpretations and appeals to mobilization against the Turks relied on second hand information, received rhetoric about the Turks, and religious questioning of God’s hand in the events, yet in some texts this rhetoric goes together with closer experience of Ottoman raids in Austrian lands and in the 1529 siege. Historians today generally agree that Habsburg rulers of the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries, together with the Church of Rome, developed a template of negative Muslim stereotypes that informed European notions of Islam for centuries to come. Individual popes had been working on the project since the early Middle Ages. Impeccably Catholic though almost all of them were, the Habsburgs came far later to the task. As German kings and even crowned Holy Roman Emperors, the dynasty occasionally tried to rally Christendom against the expansion of Muslim rule into Europe. The most notable example was King Albrecht II who died in 1439 on the way to a campaign against the Ottoman Turks. It was, however, only in the reigns of Emperors Frederick III (1415–1493) and his son, Maximilian I (1459–1519) that defense against the sultan’s forces became a centerpiece of Habsburg policy.
    [Show full text]
  • Reframing Empire: Byzantium and the Transformation of European Identity, C
    Reframing Empire: Byzantium and the Transformation of European Identity, C. 1400–1520 The Harvard community has made this article openly available. Please share how this access benefits you. Your story matters Citation Aschenbrenner, Nathanael. 2019. Reframing Empire: Byzantium and the Transformation of European Identity, C. 1400–1520. Doctoral dissertation, Harvard University, Graduate School of Arts & Sciences. Citable link http://nrs.harvard.edu/urn-3:HUL.InstRepos:42029579 Terms of Use This article was downloaded from Harvard University’s DASH repository, and is made available under the terms and conditions applicable to Other Posted Material, as set forth at http:// nrs.harvard.edu/urn-3:HUL.InstRepos:dash.current.terms-of- use#LAA Reframing Empire: Byzantium and the Transformation of European Identity, c. 1400–1520 A dissertation presented by Nathanael Aschenbrenner to The Department of History in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the subject of History Harvard University Cambridge, Massachusetts May 2019 ! © 2019 Nathanael Aschenbrenner All rights reserved. Dissertation Advisor: Professor Dimiter Angelov Nathanael Aschenbrenner Reframing Empire: Byzantium and the Transformation of European Identity, c. 1400–1520 Abstract This dissertation investigates the social and political functions of ideas of empire in sustaining, subverting, and reshaping communities in late medieval and early modern Europe. Examining fifteenth-century imperial thought in and about the Byzantine empire drawn from rarely examined Greek and Latin texts, this dissertation shows how empire became a critical category in negotiations over political legitimacy and identity amidst the rapid reconfigurations of the Mediterranean world c. 1400–1520. In the dying Byzantine empire, oratorical celebrations of imperial authority bound elites together, but also magnified deep social and political divisions over church politics, imperial territory, and succession, hastening the empire’s demise.
    [Show full text]
  • University Microfilms, Inc., Ann Arbor, Michigan Copyright By
    This dissertation has been microfilmed exactly as received 67-16, 299 LENZ, Henry, 1934- THE GERMAN CULTURAL INFLUENCE IN HUNGARY BEFORE THE EIGHTEENTH CENTURY. The Ohio State University, Ph. D. , 1967 Education, history University Microfilms, Inc., Ann Arbor, Michigan Copyright by Henry Lenz 1S67 THE GERMAN CULTURAL INFLUENCE IN HUNGARY BEFORE THE EIGHTEENTH CENTURY DISSERTATION Presented In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Doctor of Philosophy In the Graduate School of The Ohio State University by Henry Lenz, B.S., M.A. ****** The Ohio State University 1967 Approved by Adviser School of Education acknowledgments I wish to acknowledge with sincere gratitude the assistance and guidance of Professor Robert B. Sutton, who, as my major adviser for my graduate program, unselfishly gave many hours of his time to help prepare this study. His advise and counsel led my research into areas not contem­ plated at the outset but without which this document would be incomplete. Dr. Sutton's historical skill and help deserve more credit than the acknowledgment given here can express. For viewing and excerpcing many foreign publications for my use, 1 am greatly indebted to Professor Doctor Johann Weidlein of Schorndorf, Würtemberg, Germany. His continuous interest in this study enabled me to secure many valuable publications otherwise unobtainable in this country. Dr. Weidlein's knowledge of the German cultural influence in Hungary has been a significant help in preparing this study. His aid is sincerely acknowledged. I also wish to express my special appreciation to my wife, Linda. Her help in editing and revising major portions of this work and interest in my study enabled me to make progress when seemingly I had reached an impasse.
    [Show full text]
  • The Princes' War in South Germany 1458-1463
    The Princes’ War in South Germany 1458-1463 Inaugural-Dissertation zur Erlangung der Doktorwürde der Philosophischen Fakultät I der Julius-Maximilians-Universität Würzburg Vorgelegt von Daniel Filin aus Beer-Sheva Würzburg 2017 i The Princes’ War in South Germany 1458-1463 Inaugural-Dissertation zur Erlangung der Doktorwürde der Philosophischen Fakultät I der Julius-Maximilians-Universität Würzburg Vorgelegt von Daniel Filin aus Beer-Sheva Würzburg 2017 i Erstgutachter: Prof. Dr. Franz Fuchs Zweitgutachter: Prof. Dr. Helmut Flachenecker Tag des Kolloquiums: 4.7.2017 i Acknowledgement 1 1. Preface 2 1.1 Sources 2 1.2 Unprinted sources 2 1.3 Printed sources 3 1.4 State of the art 5 2. Historical Background 6 2.1 The Emergence of the rivalling parties 8 2.2 Kaiserliche Landgericht Nürnberg 10 2.3 The warring parties take shape 14 3. Widdern – the first test of strength 19 3.1 The conclusions of the first clash 27 4. The seizure of Donauwörth by Ludwig the Rich 27 5. The path to the “blinden Sprüch” 35 5.1 The meeting in Bamberg 36 5.2 The “Egerer Tag” 36 5.3 War declaration on Duke Ludwig 37 5.4 The imperial cities draw attention 39 5.5 War is avoided in the last moment 40 5.6 The “Blinder Spruch” 41 5.7 The reaction to the “blinder Spruch” 44 5.8 Resume – blinden Spruch and its consequences 49 6. The road to war 50 6.1 The Congress of Mantua 50 6.2 Few short remarks on the imperial cities and Nördlingen during the first 52 interbellum 6.3 The Last attempt of reconciliation 52 6.4 The tensions rise in the “Western Front” 54 7.
    [Show full text]
  • Parish Priests, Preachers, and Books in the Fifteenth Century Matthew Rw Anovix University of New Haven, [email protected]
    University of New Haven Digital Commons @ New Haven History Faculty Publications History 10-2012 Ulrich Pfeffel's Library: Parish Priests, Preachers, and Books in the Fifteenth Century Matthew rW anovix University of New Haven, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: http://digitalcommons.newhaven.edu/history-facpubs Part of the History Commons Publisher Citation Matthew Wranovix, "Ulrich Pfeffel's Library: Parish Priests, Preachers, and Books in the Fifteenth Century," Speculum 87.4 (2012), 1125-1155. Comments This is the author's accepted version of the article published in Speculum. The final version may be accessed at http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/ S0038713412004198 Ulrich Pfeffel’s Library: Parish Priests, Preachers and Books in the Fifteenth Century In 1460 Karl von Seckendorf sent the following note along with a manuscript that included a biblical commentary by Matthias de Liegnitz, the Postilla super epistulas dominicales, to an acquaintance: Dear Sir Ulrich, I have often been given to understand how much you like the books. I am now sending them to you and will give you a better deal than I would give to others and ask if you could lend me four gulden, which I will repay you. It is not an issue if you do not have the money; keep the books anyway. When I am able to visit you, then we can come to an agreement. If you then must have the [four] gulden, then I do not wish to burden you about it. Karl von Seckendorf.1 Karl von Seckendorff matriculated into the University of Heidelberg on 12 August 1457 and later served as a cathedral canon in Eichstätt.
    [Show full text]
  • Mercenary Warriors — an Example of the International Relations of Czech Lands
    FASCICULI ARCHAEOLOGIAE HISTORICAE, Fasc. VII, PL ISSN 0860-0007 WOJCIECH IWAŃCZAK MERCENARY WARRIORS — AN EXAMPLE OF THE INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS OF CZECH LANDS A discussion on mercenary warriors naturally impo- The beginnings of Czech mercenary service are not ses upon a researcher an international perspective. The clear enough yet, though certain references to paid mili- Czech State, being an active participant of the Europem tary service appear quite early. The term "mercede con- political life of the Middle Ages, seems to constitute an ducti" is already used in the 11th century in reference to interesting subject of investigation in this respect. some Czech troops allied with the Serbians3, though it As far as the mercenary army as a certain form of is not an individual payment made to warriors that is organization of warriors is concerned the same general meant here. Later pieces of information pointing to the features and tendencies as known from West-European existence of some forms similar to those used in a mer- countries may also be noticed in Czech lands. It does cenary army date back to the second half of the 11th not mean, however, that the territory observed here is century. In 1081 A.D. 300 armed Czech warriors set out not characterized by its own, particular, local colour and for Italy with Emperor Henry IV , and in 1082 A.D. chronological rhythm imposed, especially in the 15th Vratislav II hired a troop of armed men belonging to the century, by the uniqueness of its development determi- Bishop of Regensburg and paid them for their service5.
    [Show full text]
  • The Wittelsbach Court in Munich: History and Authority in the Visual Arts (1460-1508)
    UNIVERSITY OF GLASGOW FACULTY OF ARTS DEPARTMENT OF HISTORY OF ART PHD Andreas M. Dahlem The Wittelsbach Court in Munich: History and Authority in the Visual Arts (1460-1508) May 2009 © Andreas Dahlem 2009 2 Abstract The culture at the ducal court of Sigmund and Albrecht IV of Bavaria-Munich was characterised by a coexistence of traditional as well as novel concepts and interests, which were expressed in the dukes’ artistic, architectural and literary patronage. Apart from examining the orthodox means of aristocratic self-aggrandizement like jousting, clothes, decorative arts and precious, exotic objects, this thesis discusses ‘innovative’ tendencies like the forward-looking application of retrospective motifs, historicising styles as well as the dukes’ genealogy, the ducal government’s imprint on the territory and the aesthetic qualities of the landscape. The study of a selection of buildings and works of art with the methodologies of the stylistic analysis, iconology and social history emphasises the conceptual relations between the ducal court’s various cultural products, which were conceived as ensembles and complemented each other. The elucidation of their meanings to contemporaries and the patrons’ intentions is substantiated with statements in contemporary written sources like travel reports, chronicles and the ducal court’s literary commissions. The principal chapters explore three thematic strands that are idiosyncratic for the culture at the court of Sigmund and Albrecht IV between 1460 and 1508, because they were consistently realised in several buildings and works of art. The first chapter provides an overview of the history of Munich, the Duchy of Bavaria and the Wittelsbach dynasty. The second chapter explores the princely self-conception at the threshold of the Late Middle Ages and the Early Modern Era by considering the application of clothes, decorative arts, knightly skills, exotic animals, and monuments of the patrons’ erudition as means of social communication and differentiation.
    [Show full text]
  • HUS London: CHARLES H
    THE DAWN OF THE REFORMATION BY HERBERT B. WORKMAN, MA. VOL. II THE AGE OF HUS London: CHARLES H. KELLY 2, CASTLE ST., CITY RD.; AND 26, PATERNOSTER ROW, E.C. 1902 OCR and formatting by William H. Gross www.onthewing.org Nov 2016 Page breaks have been adjusted for readability (widow/orphan) 1 PREFACE I HAVE entitled this little volume The Age of Hus. The name in itself implies a certain changed outlook of the centuries. To the men of his own day, save in Bohemia, Hus was far from being the prominent figure that he is today. They would have called it The Age of Gerson, or rather, The Age of the Schism. To us Hus is of importance, not only for his own sake, but as the representative of the new spirit of 'I consecration to Truth, as distinct from Authority, which, more than anything else, was destined to sweep away Medievalism. For Hus, as for his master, Wyclif, the foundations of Truth lay in its appeal to the individual consciousness. For good or ill this idea now dominates no small portion of the Western World. For this reason, also, Wyclif and Hus may rightly be regarded as standing in the Dawn of the Reformation. vi PREFACE In publishing this second volume I am conscious of the great disadvantage under which I labour in covering ground that in part the late Bishop Creighton has made luminous for us, in a work whose learning is only excelled by its rare judgment. I may, however, claim that my volume, whatever its merits or defects, is in nowise an abbreviation of his.
    [Show full text]
  • Coufal-Kniha 1.Indb
    Summary 625 Summary A Joust of Faith: Polemics on the Chalice at the Council of Basel, 1431–1433 This book details over seven extensive chapters the early phase of the ne- gotiations of the Council of Basel with the Hussites over the Four Articles of Prague and the subsequent agreement. The narrative of the Basel dispu- tations begins here, in the broadest sense, at the end of the Winter of 1431, when the first synodals appeared in Basel, and ends in early September 1433, when both sides had at their disposal the written conditions of unification. It was only then that the representatives of both sides temporarily set aside the “sword of God’s word”, brandished in the disputations and the numerous tractates, and instead prioritized negotiations on formulations in documents. Already from the time of the Council of Constance, a war of faith (bel­ lum fidei, certamen fidei) was waged over the doctrinal matter of the lay chal- ice, and this quickly became the focus of discussion and a catalyst of events in Basel as well. For this reason, attention to the remaining three, non-eu- charistic Articles is limited to the moments when they influenced the devel- opment of negotiations as a whole, and their full intellectual analysis is left aside for other studies. Even though the basic facts, supported by the pragmatic and historio- graphic sources or diaries, are well-known, the broad range of tractate lit- erature has until now remained peripheral to historical attention. This in- cludes not only literature emerging directly from the disputations, but also the expert testimonials for the needs of the Council, as well as the so-called collations (collationes) — positions on Biblical themes used to begin the open sessions of both sides.
    [Show full text]
  • The Church in the Light of Learned Ignorance THOMAS M
    The Church in the Light of Learned Ignorance THOMAS M. IZBICKI The years between 1436 and 1442 were vital ones in the life and thought of Nicholas of Cusa, who entered that period as the leading conciliar theorist of his generation and emerged from it as a papal apologist, "the Hercules of the Eugenians," as well as one of the most original speculative thinkers of the Renaissance. Cu- sanus's change of ecclesiological emphasis coincided with the eclipse of Cardinal Giuliano Cesarini, with whom he was closely associated, as leader of the Council of Basel, and the rise of Cardinal Louis d'Aleman, an ardent foe of Eugenius IV, to supplant him. This change of leadership itself coincided with the factional division of the assem- bly over the site of a council of union with the Greeks and a change in emphasis from open debate on issues of faith, unity, and reform to the attempt to declare conciliar supremacy a dogma.1 Cusanus's own change of allegiance cannot be divorced from his own self-interest;2 1. On the change in the council, see Giuseppe Alberigo, Chiesa conciliare: Idenύta e significato del conciliarismo (Brescia: Paideia, 1979), pp. 256-340. On Cesarini's eclipse, see Gerald Christianson, Cesarini, the Conciliar Cardinal: The Basel Years, 1431-1438 (St. Ottilien: EOS, 1979), pp. 149-180. 2. See, most recently, Joachim W. Stieber, "The Ήercules of the Eugenians' at the Crossroads: Nicholas of Cusa's Decision for the Pope and Against the Council in 1436/1437—Theological, Political and Social Aspects," in Nicholas of Cusa in Search 186 THE CHURCH AND LEARNED IGNORANCE 187 nor can it be separated from the fortunes of Cesarini, to whom, together with Emperor Sigismund, he had dedicated De concordantia catholica, and whom he had supported in the climactic struggle over the location of a council of union.^ This transformation, however, cannot be divided from the contemporaneous changes occurring in Cusanus's internal life, which caused him to emphasize speculative rather than institutional themes in his later writings.
    [Show full text]