DOCSLIB.ORG

Taxing Away Citizenship: Do American-Canadian Dual Citizens Consider Their Status to Be an Inconvenience? by James Eastman-Timmo

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Taxing Away Citizenship: Do American-Canadian Dual Citizens Consider Their Status to Be an Inconvenience? by James Eastman-Timmo Taxing Away Citizenship: Do American-Canadian dual citizens consider their status to be an inconvenience? by James Eastman-Timmons A thesis submitted to the Faculty of Graduate and Postdoctoral Affairs in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts in Sociology Carleton University Ottawa, Ontario ©2015 James Eastman-Timmons ABSTRACT Despite growing tolerance of dual citizenship in an era of globalization, this status continues to be problematized by the governments of both the United States and Canada. This is evident in recent changes to Canadian Bill C-24, in which new grounds have been established to revoke the Canadian citizenship of ‘dual citizens,’ and by recent political discourse, which depicts dual citizens as Canadians of ‘convenience’ with ‘thin’ attachments to the nation. This thesis explores how dual citizenship may instead be ‘inconvenient’ for particular citizen subjects, namely ‘American-Canadians.’ To demonstrate this, twenty-three narratives of current and former ‘American-Canadian’ dual citizens were analyzed. It would seem paradoxical to suggest that an individual with a robust citizenship on each end of the hyphen could experience inconveniences. Nonetheless, I will demonstrate how the citizenship-based tax laws of the United States create insecurities for this population and lead to impulses to renounce this ‘robust’ citizenship. i ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Throughout my time at Carleton, both as an undergraduate and graduate student, the support of Dr. Daiva Stasiulis has greatly assisted my growth as an academic. I would like to offer my sincerest thanks to Daiva for her care and guidance as a supervisor. As well, I am grateful to have received her helpful ideas and comments on earlier drafts, all of which made this work possible. I also thank Dr. Amrita Hari for her assistance with this thesis project. Particularly for her insights, thoughtful comments, and encouragement throughout the writing process. She helped make writing this thesis a positive experience. I am incredibly grateful to Paula Whissell for her advice and kindness in moments of stress. Whenever I had a question, she had the answer. Thanks to Kim Mitchell for her encouragement during my time as an undergraduate and graduate student. I would also like to thank the excellent faculty in the Sociology Department, at Carleton University; particularly, Dr. Xiaobei Chen, Dr. Neil Gerlach, and Dr. Augustine Park. I would not be a graduate student without their assistance, time, and energies. I would like to acknowledge Carleton University for providing me with an opportunity to learn, to work in a professional setting as a teaching assistant, and for financial assistance. I would also like to gratefully acknowledge all the participants of this study, who willingly offered their time and shared their experiences, as well as, Max Reed and Steve Katz, at SKL Tax, for volunteering their time and for offering their expertise. My thanks to Anne Bartlett for helping me stay on the pathway to life as a University student, and to Bill and Lynn Morrison for all their help; particularly, when I first arrived in Ottawa to begin my University studies. I am grateful to my colleagues, Victoria Spofford and Steven Ang, for the great conversations—both academic and personal—for the laughs, and friendship. I am also grateful to Nico Church, Josh Lanthier, and Chris Zettel for the fellowship. Thanks as well, to André Morrill for being a great roommate and friend over the years. I cannot thank enough Arianna Di Giacomo-Maika for calling me out on my overuse of parentheses, for the coffee breaks, but most of all for being a continual source of positivity and support. I am thankful to all my extended family dispersed across Canada. Lastly, I owe my deepest thanks to my family: Kate, Alex, Lauren, and to my mother, Deborah. Their continual support, encouragement, and love—whether in person or from a distance—has led me to where I am today. I cherish everything they have done for me. I am humbled by all the support from those mentioned and those who remain unmentioned, but of course, I take full responsibility for any shortcomings of this work. ii TABLE OF CONTENTS INTRODUCTION ....................................................................................................................................... 1 Situating the Study .................................................................................................................................... 2 Taxing Away Citizenship: Thesis Outline ................................................................................................ 5 Self-reflexivity: ‘Locating Myself’ ........................................................................................................... 7 I A HISTORY OF AMERICANS IN CANADA .................................................................................... 11 1.1 U.S./Canada Comparisons ................................................................................................................ 12 1.2 A History of American Migration to Canada .................................................................................... 15 1.3 What is Dual Citizenship? ................................................................................................................. 18 1.4 Canadian Nationality Laws: Implications for Dual Citizens ............................................................ 20 1.5 American Nationality Laws: Implications for Dual Citizens ............................................................ 22 II CONSENTING TO CITIZENSHIP: REVOCATION V. RENUNCATION/RELINQUISHMENT .................................................................................................................................................................... 30 2.1 Citizenship Loss: Revocation, Renunciation, and Relinquishment .................................................. 32 2.2 Citizenship Obtainment: Birthright, and Naturalization ................................................................... 40 2.3 Being Designed out of Citizenship: Theoretical Framework ............................................................ 42 2.4 Who are ‘Accidental Americans?’ .................................................................................................... 50 III THE FOREIGN ACCOUNTS TAX COMPLIANCE ACT (FATCA) AND TAX OBLIGATIONS FOR NON-RESIDENT U.S. CITIZENS ................................................................... 55 3.1 Citizenship-based Taxation v. Residence-based Taxation ................................................................ 57 3.2 Penalties for Inadequately Filing the FBAR ..................................................................................... 62 3.3 ‘Amnesty Programs’ ......................................................................................................................... 63 3.4 The Foreign Accounts Tax Compliance Act and the Intergovernmental Agreement ....................... 64 3.5 Inconveniences for Americans Living Abroad ................................................................................. 67 IV ‘I’M A MINNOW’: NARRATIVES OF INCONVENIENCE ........................................................ 73 4.1 ‘Affective’ State(s)/Citizen Relations ............................................................................................... 74 4.2 Narrative Analysis: What is it, and Why Analyze Narratives? ......................................................... 76 4.2.1 Narrative analysis: further theoretical musings..................................................................... 79 4.3 Data Collection: Participants ............................................................................................................ 81 4.3.1 Data collection: procedure .................................................................................................... 88 4.3.2 Data collection: ethics ........................................................................................................... 91 4.4 The Listening Guide: Analytical Framework ................................................................................... 92 4.5 Michael—Current ‘American-Canadian’ Dual Citizen .................................................................... 96 iii 4.6 Richard—Former ‘American-Canadian’ Dual Citizen .................................................................... 98 4.7 John—Former ‘American-Canadian’ Dual Citizen ........................................................................ 101 4.8 Sandra—Currently Holds Multiple Citizenships (i.e., American, British, and Canadian) ............. 102 4.9 Distancing Narratives ...................................................................................................................... 104 4.9.1 Narratives of the state ‘chasing whales’ and ‘catching minnows’ ...................................... 107 4.9.2 Narratives of parents and their U.S. citizen children .......................................................... 110 4.9.3 Narratives of inconvenience: the ‘affects’ of U.S. citizenship-based tax policy ................ 113 V ACTIVE CITIZENS, REMAKING CITIZENSHIP ....................................................................... 121 5.1 Activist and Dissident Citizenship .................................................................................................. 123 5.2 Remaking Citizenship ....................................................................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Major Research Paper
    MAJOR RESEARCH PAPER IDENTITIES AND EXPERIENCES OF BLACK-AFRICAN IMMIGRANT YOUTH IN CANADA Submitted by: Fenan Kalaty Honours, BA with Specialization in Psychology (2010) Supervisor: Natacha Gagné Committee Member: Philippe Couton Date: February 2013 Master of Arts in Sociology University of Ottawa Department of Sociology and Anthropology Thank you to my parents, their love and support made this major research paper possible. Thank you to my siblings, my built-in best friends. 2 Table of Contents Introduction………………………………………………………………………….5 A Reflexive Note……………………………………………………………………………..5 African Immigrants in Canada………………………………………………………………..9 Research Question…………………………………………………………………………..11 The Challenges in Defining “African-Canadian”……………………………………...........12 Conceptual Tools…………………………………………………………………...17 Youth………………………………………………………………………………………..17 Immigration and Acculturation……………………………………………………………...18 Identity…………………………………………………………………………………........20 Biculturalism………………………………………………………………………………...21 Ethnicity, Ethnic Groups, and Ethnic Identities……………………………………….........24 Methodology………………………………………………………………………..28 Method…………………………………………………………………………………........28 Sample………………………………………………………………………………………29 Literature Review…………………………………………………………………..34 Identifying with Multiple Travels…………………………………………………………...34 The Significance of Loss……………………………………………………………………34 Place Identity………………………………………………………………………………..35 The Third Space……………………………………………………………………………..37 “Black” and Hip-Hop Identity……………………………………………………………....43 “Black” and Gendered
    [Show full text]
  • BUYING IN: RESIDENCE and CITIZENSHIP by INVESTMENT ALLISON CHRISTIANS* Italy Recently Announced a New Immigration Program That I
    SAINT LOUIS UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF LAW BUYING IN: RESIDENCE AND CITIZENSHIP BY INVESTMENT ALLISON CHRISTIANS* INTRODUCTION Italy recently announced a new immigration program that invites certain high net worth individuals to make Italy their country of residence, enticing them with the right to pay a “substitute tax” of €100,000 per year on their foreign income and gains.1 For those already residing in Italy, the highest marginal tax rate on income is 43%, with additional regional and municipal rates bringing the rate closer to 50%; capital gains are subject to a reduced rate (about half the regular rate).2 Assuming eligible immigrants have significant foreign income and gains that would otherwise face the highest marginal rates of tax, the new program’s outcome would seem to ensure that prior residents face a significantly higher overall tax bracket than their new neighbours (unless of course, such individuals use other mechanisms and programs, whether in Italy or elsewhere, to also reduce their own tax rates). Why would Italy design a tax scheme that appears to privilege certain immigrants over its other taxpayers in this manner? In reporting on the program for Forbes, journalist David Schrieberg stated that “[s]ome observers speculate that the new tax regime is aimed particularly at super-rich individuals * H. Heward Stikeman Chair in the Law of Taxation, McGill University Faculty of Law. This research was assisted by a grant from the Social Science and Humanities Research Council of Canada. Thanks for helpful comments on an early draft are due to Montano Cabezas, David Lesperance, Henry Ordower, Peter Szigeti, and the participants of the Sanford E.
    [Show full text]
  • Thesis Draft
    ! ! ! ! ! The Mobile Citizen: Canada’s Treatment of Mobility in Immigration, Citizenship, and Foreign Policy ! Alex M. Johnston ! ! Thesis submitted to the Faculty of Graduate and Postdoctoral Studies in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts in Political Science ! ! School of Political Studies Faculty of Social Science University of Ottawa ! ! © Alex M. Johnston, Ottawa, Canada, 2017. The Mobile Citizen ii Abstract ! Mobility, as the ability among newcomers and citizens to move temporarily and circularly across international borders and between states, has become a pervasive norm for a significant portion of Canada’s population. Despite its pervasive nature and the growing public interest, however, current research has been limited in how Canadian policies are reacting to the ability of citizens and newcomers to move. This thesis seeks to fill that gap by analyzing Canada’s treatment of mobility within and across policies of immigration, citizenship and foreign affairs. An analytical mobility framework is developed to incorporate interdisciplinary work on human migration and these policy domains. Using this framework, an examination of policy developments in each domain in the last decade reveals that they diverge in isolation and from a whole-of-government perspective around the treatment of mobility. In some instances policy accommodates or even embraces mobility, and in others it restricts it. The Mobile Citizen iii Table of Contents Abstract i Table of Contents and List of Table and Figures ii Introduction
    [Show full text]
  • The Offshore Tax Enforcement Dragnet
    Emory Law Journal Volume 67 Issue 4 2018 The Offshore Tax Enforcement Dragnet Shu-Yi Oei Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarlycommons.law.emory.edu/elj Recommended Citation Shu-Yi Oei, The Offshore Tax Enforcement Dragnet, 67 Emory L. J. 655 (2018). Available at: https://scholarlycommons.law.emory.edu/elj/vol67/iss4/1 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Journals at Emory Law Scholarly Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Emory Law Journal by an authorized editor of Emory Law Scholarly Commons. For more information, please contact [email protected]. OEI GALLEYPROOFS 4/23/2018 12:07 PM THE OFFSHORE TAX ENFORCEMENT DRAGNET Shu-Yi Oei* ABSTRACT Taxpayers who hide assets abroad to evade taxes present a serious enforcement challenge for the United States. In response, the United States has developed a family of initiatives that punish and rehabilitate non-compliant taxpayers, raise revenues, and require widespread reporting of offshore financial information by financial institutions and taxpayers. Yet, while these initiatives help catch willful tax cheats, they have also adversely affected immigrants, Americans living abroad, and “accidental Americans.” This Article critiques the United States’ offshore tax enforcement initiatives, such as the Foreign Account Tax Compliant Act and the Internal Revenue Service’s offshore voluntary disclosure programs. It argues that the United States has been overly focused on two policy priorities in designing enforcement at the expense of competing considerations: First, the United States has attempted to equalize enforcement against taxpayers with solely domestic holdings and those with harder-to-detect offshore holdings by imposing harsher reporting requirements and penalties on the latter.
    [Show full text]
  • Eritrean Canadians Protest Eritrean Consulate Fundraising Event
    Eritrean Canadians Protest Eritrean consulate fundraising event Eritrean Canadians Protest Eritrean consulate fundraising event By Aaron Berhane The Eritrean Human Rights Group staged a popular demonstration against an Eritrean consulate-sponsored fundraising event at Sheraton Hotel in downtown Toronto on August 5. The protesters disclosed the hidden agenda of the so-called “community” event by chanting such slogans as: “No Fundraising to finance terrorists”; “No fundraising to finance the dictator”; “Stop soliciting our churches; “Stop the 2% extortion tax; “Shame on Sheraton Hotel for hosting a terrorist fundraising event”; and “Close the Eritrean consulate”. The Eritrean human rights activists attracted the attention of many pedestrians. They distributed literature that disclosed the dictatorial nature of the Eritrean regime, and increased awareness the illegal activities of the Eritrean Consulate in raising funds and extorting Eritrean Canadians to pay the notorious 2% tax. The protest conveyed a strong message and drew the attention of the hotel guests. One of the guests arrived by taxi and saw the protesters and read the picket signs. He happened to be familiar with the Afewerki regime, and said, “‘I am going to cancel my reservation right now and book in another hotel as a support to your cause”. There were also several taxis that stopped with their guests at the gate and left the premise instantly when they saw the protesters. The Eritrean consulate in Toronto rented a hall at Sheraton Hotel in the name of two agents of the consulate who work in the hotel. They hid their politically motivated event to raise funds for the military activities of the Eritrean dictator and to finance terrorist groups in the horn of Africa.
    [Show full text]
  • SSRN Paper by Allison Christians
    Uncle Sam Wants … Who? A Global Perspective on Citizenship Taxation Allison Christians* Abstract Across the globe, banks are flagging accounts with indicia indicating their owners may be “US Persons,” making it possible for the United States to enforce its taxation of nonresident citizens extraterritorially for the first time in history. The indicia method constitutes a mining expedition for US Persons carried out by foreign banks and governments. Establishing a tax jurisdiction in this manner is unprecedented and has significant practical and normative consequences. In the case of so-called “accidental Americans,” it violates one of the most fundamental and universally- acknowledged tenets of taxpayer rights, namely, the right to be informed about what the law requires. Third party indicia-searching should be universally rejected as a means of identifying a taxpayer population. Instead, the United States itself is responsible for cataloguing, informing, and educating its global population of taxpayers. Those who don’t belong in the system should be allowed to opt out without cost. Table of Contents Introduction ........................................................................................................... 1 I. The Accidental American: Origin and Implications ..................................... 3 A. Tina’s Story ............................................................................................ 3 B. Law’s Intent: the “US Person” ................................................................ 6 C. Law’s Reach after
    [Show full text]
  • Body Histories and the Limits of Life in Asian Canadian Literature
    Body Histories and the Limits of Life in Asian Canadian Literature by Ranbir Kaur Banwait M.A., Simon Fraser University, 2008 Thesis Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the Department of English Faculty of Arts and Social Sciences Ranbir Kaur Banwait 2014 SIMON FRASER UNIVERSITY Summer 2014 Approval Name: Ranbir Kaur Banwait Degree: Doctor of Philosophy (English) Title of Thesis: Body Histories and the Limits of Life in Asian Canadian Literature Examining Committee: Chair: Dr. Sean Zwagerman Associate Professor of English Dr. Christine Kim Co-Senior Supervisor Assistant Professor of English Dr. David Chariandy Co-Senior Supervisor Associate Professor of English Dr. Larissa Lai Associate Professor of English University of Calgary Dr. Lara Campbell Internal Examiner Associate Professor of Gender, Sexuality, and Women’s Studies Dr. Donald Goellnicht External Examiner Professor of English and Cultural Studies McMaster University Date Defended/Approved: July 24, 2014 ii Partial Copyright Licence iii Abstract Histories of racialization in Canada are closely tied to the development of eugenics and racial hygiene movements, but also to broader concerns, expressed throughout Western modernity, regarding the “health” of nation states and their subjects. This dissertation analyses books by Velma Demerson, Hiromi Goto, David Chariandy, Rita Wong, Roy Miki and Larissa Lai to argue that Asian Canadian literature reveals, in heightened critical terms, how the politics of racial difference has
    [Show full text]
  • Becoming Latin American Canadian
    In-Between Cultures: Becoming Latin American Canadian by Josue Tario A thesis submitted in conformity with the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts Social Justice Education Ontario Institute for Studies in Education University of Toronto © Copyright by Josue Tario, 2017 In-Between Cultures: Becoming Latin American Canadian Josue Tario Master of Arts Social Justice Education Ontario Institute for Studies in Education University of Toronto 2017 Abstract Rooted in my own experiences and extending to phenomenological interviews with seven Latin American Canadian youth between the ages of 18 and 29 in the Greater Toronto Area, this thesis examines how the dominant educational and cultural narratives shape the heterogeneous ways in which they perceive themselves and others. Findings show that such narratives engender a sense of in-betweenness among Latin American Canadian youth that both inhibit and empower them in pursuing self-fulfillment. This study juxtaposes these findings to feminist pedagogies of “third space” and “critical spirituality” which have the ability to enhance the educational experiences of not just Latin American Canadian students but all participants in education. The overarching objective of this thesis, however, transcends the case study and explores the intersections between discourse, identity formation and agency, proposing critical spirituality as a practice enabling agency and as a transformational “punctum” that embraces the process of becoming over being. ii Acknowledgments I would like to sincerely thank my thesis supervisor, Dr. Miglena Todorova. Her patience and instruction were imperative for this project to be completed. Along with her theoretical insight and pedagogical awareness, the emotional and spiritual support she provided throughout the entire process was immensely pivotal for me to keep going.
    [Show full text]
  • Coercive Transnational Governance and Its Impact on the Settlement Process of Eritrean Refugees in Canada Aaron Berhane and Vappu Tyyskä
    Document generated on 09/25/2021 5:19 a.m. Refuge Canada's Journal on Refugees Revue canadienne sur les réfugiés Coercive Transnational Governance and Its Impact on the Settlement Process of Eritrean Refugees in Canada Aaron Berhane and Vappu Tyyskä Volume 33, Number 2, 2017 Article abstract This article will examine the transnational practices of the Eritrean URI: https://id.erudit.org/iderudit/1043065ar government, and their impact on the settlement of Eritrean refugees in DOI: https://doi.org/10.7202/1043065ar Canada. The focus is on actions by the Eritrean regime that have a negative effect on refugees’ capacities for successful integration, and undermine See table of contents Canadian sovereignty. The concept of coercive transnational governance (CTG) is introduced, to highlight this neglected aspect of refugee resettlement, with illustrations from 11 interviews, including eight Eritrean refugees, one Publisher(s) Eritrean community activist, and two Canadian law enforcement officers, about the impact of CTG on Eritrean refugees’ lives. Centre for Refugee Studies, York University ISSN 0229-5113 (print) 1920-7336 (digital) Explore this journal Cite this article Berhane, A. & Tyyskä, V. (2017). Coercive Transnational Governance and Its Impact on the Settlement Process of Eritrean Refugees in Canada. Refuge, 33(2), 78–87. https://doi.org/10.7202/1043065ar Copyright (c), 2017 Refuge: Canada’s Journal on Refugees This document is protected by copyright law. Use of the services of Érudit (including reproduction) is subject to its terms and conditions, which can be viewed online. https://apropos.erudit.org/en/users/policy-on-use/ This article is disseminated and preserved by Érudit.
    [Show full text]
  • A Cultural Competence Guide for Primary Health Care Professionals in Nova Scotia
    A Cultural Competence Guide for Primary Health Care Professionals in Nova Scotia “Adding wings to caterpillars does not create butterflies--it creates awkward and dysfunctional caterpillars. Butterflies are created through transformation...” Stephanie Marshal 2005 PROMOTING CULTURAL COMPETENCE IN PRMARY HEALTH CARE A Cultural Competence Guide for Primary Health Care Professionals in Nova Scotia Table of Contents Preface Section I General Information • Cultural Competence • Key Concepts • 8 Elements of Cultural Competence • Diverse Communities in Nova Scotia Section II Tools for Primary Health Care Providers • Providing Health Care in a Multicultural Society • Patient and Client Encounter Questions • LIAASE: A General Cultural Competence Tool • Health Professional Self-Assessment Tool Section III Tools for Management and Administrative Staff in Primary Health Care Settings • An Organizational Change Strategy • Organizational Assessment Tool • LIAASE: A General Cultural Competence Tool • Health Professional Self-Assessment Tool Section IV Tools for Front-Line Staff in Primary Health Care Settings • Addressing Conflict • LIAASE: A General Cultural Competence Tool • Health Professional Self-Assessment Tool Section V Additional Resources • Community and Organizational Contact Information • Online Resources • Definition of Terms Appendix A – Diverse Communities of Nova Scotia - Graphs Appendix B – Diversity and Social Inclusion in Primary Health Care Initiative Appendix C – “Bridging the Gap: Bringing Together Culture and Health Care” Appendix D – Culture Competence and the Primary Care Provider by Ardys McNaughton Dunn References PROMOTING CULTURAL COMPETENCE IN PRMARY HEALTH CARE Acknowledgements The information in this guide was collated from a variety of sources. Information about Nova Scotia’s diverse communities, and the barriers diverse communities face in accessing primary health care services, was gathered through a series of consultative workshops held by the Department of Health and each District Health Authority in Nova Scotia.
    [Show full text]
  • Citizenship Revocation in the Mainstream Press: a Case of Re-Ethni- Cization?
    CITIZENSHIP REVOCATION IN THE MAINSTREAM PRESS: A CASE OF RE-ETHNI- CIZATION? ELKE WINTER IVANA PREVISIC Abstract. Under the original version of the Strengthening Canadian Citizenship Act (2014), dual citizens having committed high treason, terrorism or espionage could lose their Canadian citizenship. In this paper, we examine how the measure was dis- cussed in Canada’s mainstream newspapers. We ask: who/what is seen as the target of citizenship revocation? What does this tell us about the direction that Canadian citizenship is moving towards? Our findings show that Canadian newspapers were more often critical than supportive of the citizenship revocation provision. However, the press ignored the involvement of non-Muslim, white, Western-origin Canadians in terrorist acts and interpreted the measure as one that was mostly affecting Canadian Muslims. Thus, despite advocating for equal citizenship in principle, in their writing and reporting practice, Canadian newspapers constructed Canadian Muslims as sus- picious and less Canadian nonetheless. Keywords: Muslim Canadians; Citizenship; Terrorism; Canada; Revocation Résumé: Au sein de la version originale de la Loi renforçant la citoyenneté cana- dienne (2014), les citoyens canadiens ayant une double citoyenneté et ayant été condamnés pour haute trahison, pour terrorisme ou pour espionnage, auraient pu se faire révoquer leur citoyenneté canadienne. Dans cet article, nous étudions comment ce projet de loi fut discuté au sein de la presse canadienne. Nous cherchons à répondre à deux questions: Qui/quoi est perçu comme pouvant faire l’objet d’une révocation de citoyenneté? En quoi cela nous informe-t-il sur les orientations futures de la citoy- enneté canadienne? Nos résultats démontrent que les journaux canadiens sont plus critiques à l’égard de la révocation de la citoyenneté que positionnés en sa faveur.
    [Show full text]
  • A Brief History of the Brief History of Citizenship Revocation in Canada
    A Brief History of the Brief History of Citizenship Revocation in Canada AUDREY MACKLIN * ABSTRACT Four of the men convicted as part of the Toronto 18 prosecution were subject to citizenship revocation on grounds of terrorism. One of the four was born in Canada, and the other three immigrated to Canada and acquired citizenship through naturalization. I situate the politics of the four men’s citizenship revocation in legal and comparative context. Contemporary citizenship revocation policies, especially those invoked in the name of national security, serve both instrumental and symbolic goals. I argue that the citizenship revocation scheme enacted in Canada resonated primarily in the register of symbolic politics and lacked virtually any instrumental value related to national security. Its deployment against four of the Toronto 18 was always, and only, a calculated electoral tactic. I conclude by recounting the case of U.K.-Canadian Jack Letts in order to illustrate how citizenship revocation not only infringes fundamental human rights but is dysfunctional from the vantage point of international relations. Keywords: Canada; U.K.; Citizenship; Denationalization; Revocation; Citizenship Stripping; Electoral Politics; Terrorism; National Security; Securitization * Professor of Law and Chair in Human Rights, University of Toronto. The author is a Fellow of the Pierre Elliott Trudeau Foundation and a CIFAR Fellow in the Boundaries, Membership and Belonging Program. She gratefully acknowledges the support of these organizations. The author thanks the editors and conference participants for their comments and suggestions. 426 MULTI-DISCIPLINARY PERSPECTIVES ON THE TORONTO 18 TERRORISM TRIALS I. INTRODUCTION n early 2014, the Conservative government of Canada introduced legislation to permit the revocation of Canadian citizenship on national I security grounds.
    [Show full text]