Women with High Functioning ASD: Relationships and Sexual Health
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Claremont Colleges Scholarship @ Claremont CMC Senior Theses CMC Student Scholarship 2020 Women with High Functioning ASD: Relationships and Sexual Health Isabelle Taylor Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarship.claremont.edu/cmc_theses Part of the Developmental Psychology Commons Recommended Citation Taylor, Isabelle, "Women with High Functioning ASD: Relationships and Sexual Health" (2020). CMC Senior Theses. 2553. https://scholarship.claremont.edu/cmc_theses/2553 This Open Access Senior Thesis is brought to you by Scholarship@Claremont. It has been accepted for inclusion in this collection by an authorized administrator. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Claremont McKenna College Women with High Functioning ASD: Relationships and Sexual Health A Literature Review and Proposed Workshop Manual Submitted to Professor Caitlyn Gumaer By Isabelle Taylor for Senior Thesis 2020 November 30 Table of Contents Author’s Note.................................................................................................................................. 1 Abstract........................................................................................................................................... 2 Literature Review.................................................................................................................... 3 - 38 Symptoms and Diagnosis.............................................................................................. 3 - 7 Gender Differences...................................................................................................... 7 - 13 Common Treatment Models...................................................................................... 13 - 15 Social Skills Intervention........................................................................................... 15 - 20 Sexual Behavior and Education for Individuals with ASD....................................... 20 - 24 Sexual Education in Female ASD Population........................................................... 24 - 27 Love, Affection, and Intimacy................................................................................... 27 - 29 Concepts of Love & Affection to High Functioning Individuals with ASD............. 29 - 32 Other Important Dating Skills................................................................................... 32 - 37 Conclusion................................................................................................................. 37 - 38 Sexual Health and Dating Workshop Manual for Adolescents and Young Women with High Functioning Autism............................................................................................................... 39 - 87 Module 1: Relationships and Dating......................................................................... 45 - 73 Module 2: Sexual Health and Empowerment........................................................... 74 - 87 Appendix............................................................................................................................. 88 - 134 References......................................................................................................................... 135 - 142 WOMEN WITH HIGH FUNCTIONING ASD: DATING AND SEXUAL HEALTH 1 Women with High Functioning ASD: Relationships and Sexual Health A Literature Review and Proposed Workshop Manual Isabelle Taylor Claremont McKenna College Author’s Note Working at The Autism Center was the most enriching experience I had while at CMC. For that, I would like to thank both Professor Gumaer and Professor Charlop for creating such a rich and exciting community that made every week exciting. Moreover, I’d like to thank all of the kids I worked with at CAC. Interacting with you over the years has brought me endless joy. This thesis is dedicated to all of you. Lastly, I would like to thank so many of my amazing Psychology professors at CMC who inspired me through their passion and intellect- Professor Levin, Professor Kanaya, and Professor Krauss just to name a few. This semester has proven difficult. I definitely never expected to write a thesis at home amidst a global pandemic and historic election. Thankfully, I have had the immense support of my friends and family. Special thanks to Kat and Lena for loving me unconditionally and supporting me through a tumultuous period of time. And to my mom and dad, I would not have had the privilege of attending such a phenomenal college without you and I am truly grateful for that every day. Thank you to my sisters for providing me with endless advice and perspective. Also remember when I got on the microphone at my elementary school graduation to say my goal was to go to a good college and do well to impress my sisters? With the final submission of this project, marking the end of an amazing and formative four(ish) years, I think I may have finally achieved that. / WOMEN WITH HIGH FUNCTIONING ASD: DATING AND SEXUAL HEALTH 2 Abstract Women with high functioning Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) are disproportionately less represented in research in comparison to their male counterparts. Some propose that this is as a result of more men having ASD and therefore the diagnostic criteria being further indicative of their gender, but regardless, it remains apparent that the need for supporting women with Autism Spectrum Disorder is just as crucial (Kreiser & White, 2014). For both genders, though, deficits in social skills and the presence of repetitive and restrictive behaviors often lend themselves to conduct seen as inappropriate or awkward within the neurotypical dating world (Hodges et al., 2020). Nevertheless, many individuals with ASD, particularly those who are high functioning, remain interested in engaging in sexual activities and romantic relationships (Scarpa et al., 2013) . Unfortunately, many high functioning women with ASD who utilize skills such as “camouflaging”, may go undiagnosed or their need for support and treatment may be underestimated, which is in part support for a separate women’s sexual health and romantic relationships group (Hull et al., 2020). Additionally, although the literature underscores that men are in need of and would benefit from a similar program, the differing education on the topic of sexual health and relationships in the context of gender makes for a clear need to establish programs attuned to the separate gender identities. Moreover, with the literature indicating that women with ASD experience harrowingly high rates of sexual assault, it appears necessary that components of specific education on consent and empowerment are necessary for a thorough and useful manual on the aforementioned topics (Hentoff, 2016). In response to a careful review of the literature, a proposed manual has been developed by means to support the specific needs of high functioning women with ASD. Keywords : ASD, gender, sexual health, romantic relationships / WOMEN WITH HIGH FUNCTIONING ASD: DATING AND SEXUAL HEALTH 3 Literature Review Symptoms and Diagnosis Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD), said to affect 1 in 54 American children, is classified as a neurodevelopmental disorder (CDC, 2020). This means that symptoms most commonly become evident during the early developmental period or before the child enters grade school and that the disorder causes significant impairments in the day to day functioning of the person (CDC “Diagnostic Criteria”, 2020). ASD “generally follows a steady course without remission”, highlighting the necessity for treatment programs and methods that help these individuals better acclimate to the world (Akanksha et al., 2011). For one to be diagnosed with autism spectrum disorder, they must consistently show deficits in two different areas: social communication and interaction, as well as repetitive or restricted behaviors (CDC “Diagnostic Criteria”, 2020) (Hodges et al., 2020). The extremity of both of these categories is what ultimately determines the severity of an individual’s ASD. If an individual shows intense deficits in social communication, but does not exhibit repetitive or restrictive behaviors, they may be diagnosed with a social (pragmatic) communication disorder (SPCD) (Hodges et al., 2020). In terms of social communication impairments, an individual must display all three domains of this category in order to be diagnosed with ASD (CDC “Diagnostic Criteria”, 2020). These behaviors include trouble in social-emotional reciprocity, deficits in non-verbal and verbal communication, and issues with maintaining and fostering relationships (CDC “Diagnostic Criteria”, 2020). According to Carpenter (2013), there are a multitude of ways in which the latter symptoms can manifest. Problems with social-emotional reciprocity can range from “indifference/aversion to physical contact and affection” or lack of social initiation (Carpenter, 2013, p. 2). Deficits in nonverbal and verbal communication may take form in the inability to / WOMEN WITH HIGH FUNCTIONING ASD: DATING AND SEXUAL HEALTH 4 properly express one’s emotional range with their words and affect or in avoiding direct eye contact (Carpenter, 2013). Finally, in terms of the maintenance of relationships, people with ASD usually experience difficulty in adjusting their own behaviors to a given social context and may lack “theory of mind”, which is the capacity to see things from someone else’s perspective (Carpenter, 2013, p. 2). For the previous reasons, it is apparent that those