DOCSLIB.ORG

Ś W I a T T E K S T Ó W • R O C Z N I K S Ł U P S K I Nr 18 Ss

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Ś W I a T T E K S T Ó W • R O C Z N I K S Ł U P S K I Nr 18 Ss The argument from authority in the dynamics of the French classic-Romantic quarrel... 41 ŚWIAT TEKSTÓW • ROCZNIK SŁUPSKI Nr 18 ss. 41–52 2020 ISSN 2083-4721 © Katedra Filologii Polskiej Akademii Pomorskiej w Słupsku Oryginalna praca badawcza Przyjęto: 14.01.2020 Zaakceptowano: 24.03.2020 Marta Sukiennicka Adam Mickiewicz University Poznań ORCID: 0000-0002-0683-0860 THE ARGUMENT FROM AUTHORITY IN THE DYNAMICS OF THE FRENCH CLASSIC-ROMANTIC QUARREL (1821–1831) ARGUMENT Z AUTORYTETU W DYNAMICE FRANCUSKIEGO SPORU KLASYKÓW Z ROMANTYKAMI (1821–1831) Słowa kluczowe: Charles Nodier, Victor Hugo, La Muse française, Akademia Francuska, romantyzm jako nowoczesny klasycyzm Key words: Charles Nodier, Victor Hugo, La Muse française, Académie française, Ro- manticism as classicism of modern times In the 1820s, French classicists often accused the Romantics of a lack of proper education and an irreverence towards literary authorities. They saw the Romantics as a literary sect whose members were contributing to the group’s undeserved success by promoting each other through flattery, quoting each other in epigraphs to their volumes of verse, and reviewing each other’s works favourably in La Muse française, a leading journal of early French Romanticism1. This had been unheard of in the past, when only quotations from classical writers such as Virgil or Horace were considered acceptable material for an epigraph. Nevertheless, the young Romantic writers quoted one another without proper respect towards the literary institutions, as if they had not read their classics at all. This strategy of undermining the classicist authority is clearly visible during the period when Romanticism was developing in a close relationship with classicism. In the 1830s, the argument from authority seems to have gradually lost its prominence as a Romantic poetics was evolving in new directions. 1 This accusation in not unfounded: a Romantic dissident, Henri Latouche, took up the charge and turned his back on his Romantic colleagues in a satirical tract, “De la camaderie litteraire” (1829). Cf. A. Glinoer, La Querelle de la camaraderie littéraire. Les romantiques face à leurs contemporains, Droz, Genève 2008. 42 Marta Sukiennicka The nineteenth-century French classic-Romantic quarrel2 has already been well described in extenso3, which is why in this paper I would like to focus on its rhetorical dynamics, and particularly on the accusation of the lack of classical erudition levelled against the Romantics. This line of accusation deserves attention not only because it triggered an avalanche of spiteful responses which form an important part of the clas- sic-Romantic debate, but also because it captures a specific feature of French Roman- ticism which has its source in the Romantic relation to classicism, and more generally, to the literary tradition. In essence, the strategy of the Romanticists in the early years of the quarrel can be described as an attempt to undermine the aesthetic difference between Romanticism and classicism, and to appropriate the argument from classical authority, making it a part of their line of defence. Analysis of the rhetorical dynamics of the quarrel can lead to conclusions expressed in sociological terms, as an attempt to replace the old generation with a new one in an increasingly commercialised literary field4 or in psychoanalytic terms, as a form of oedipal rivalry with the aim of taking the father’s or precursor’s place5. 2 I have chosen not to use the well established military metaphors of “war” or “battle”, as they might create a false image of two opposing camps, which would be a considerable oversimpli- fication. Instead, I employ the term “quarrel”, defined as a “socialising, creative and dynamic” form of debate which structures the literary field and plays the role of a “visibility vector” for its actors (cf. J.-P. Bertrand, D. Saint-Amand & V. Stiénon, Les querelles littéraires: esquisse méthodologique, “COnTEXTES”, 2012, no. 10, http://journals.openedition.org/contextes/5005 [10.01.2020]). In the quoted article, the quarrel, distinguished from dispute, polemics and con- troversy, is defined by its component of hostility and the fact that the “participants are not adver- saries, but rivals who have similar motives and pursue the same goal, though not necessarily in a similar way”. 3 Cf. L. Séché, Le Cénacle de La Muse française, Mercure de France, Paris 1909; J. Marsan, La Bataille romantique, Hachette, Paris 1912; R. Bray, Chronologie du romantisme 1803–1830, Boivin, Paris 1932; E. Eggli, P. Martino, Le débat romantique en France (1813–1816), Les Belles Lettres, Paris 1933. More recently, some French critics have revisited the issue, mainly in order to deconstruct the overly teleological conception of the history of early French Romanti- cism; cf. V. Laisney, L’Arsenal romantique. Le salon de Charles Nodier (1824–1834), Champi- on, Paris 2002. 4 Cf. “The ageing of authors, works or schools is something quite different from a mechanical sliding into the past. It is engendered in the fight between those who have already left their mark and are trying to endure, and those who cannot make their own marks in their turn without consigning to the past those who have an interest in stopping time, in eternalizing the present state; between the dominants whose strategy is tied to continuity, identity and reproduction, and the dominated, the new entrants, whose interest is in discontinuity, rupture, difference and revolution”, P. Bourdieu, The Rules of Art: Genesis and Structure of the Literary Field, trans. by S. Emanuel, Stanford University Press, Stanford 1995, p. 157. 5 A process described by Bloom as a clearing of imaginative space by a misreading of great pre- decessors and then appropriating them. In Bloom’s terms, it can be said that the dynamics of the French Romantic debate, within the chronological scope of this paper, stops at the second of Bloom’s revisionary ratios, tessera, which is described as follows: “A poet antithetically ‘completes’ his precursor, by so reading the parent-poem as to retain its terms but to mean them in another sense, as though the precursor had failed to go far enough”, H. Bloom, The Anxiety of Influence. A Theory of Poetry, Oxford University Press, New York 1973, p. 14. The argument from authority in the dynamics of the French classic-Romantic quarrel... 43 Frivolous quarrel In April 1824, Louis-Simon Auger, secretary of the Académie française, delivered a memorable speech on the occasion of King Louis the XVIII’s return after the French Revolution and the Napoleonic era. Auger’s speech was directed at the Romantic schism, which was, as he put it, a danger to the unity of the literary world. The politi- cal overtones in his speech are conspicuous: Romanticism is not only a manifestation of political liberalism6 but it is also anti-national in character. In contrast to Polish Romanticism, which was closely connected with the question of preserving national identity7, in France, at that stage in the Romantic debate, it was classicism that played the role of the defender of the national tradition. According to Auger, the anti-national character of Romanticism did not merely stem from the fact that it was a movement of foreign origin, but precisely from the fact that it was of German provenance. In Auger’s words, the main representatives of the German “sect”8 in France, such as Madame de Staël or Benjamin Constant, were enchanted by a nation who had neither its own language nor literature, and who deemed it possible to build true art merely by staging folk tales. As he put it, Germany was a country: where literature is as decentralised as political power, where guardians of good taste do not exist, where the minds, disposed to meditation by their isolation, to independence by their dispersion, and to error by their very sin- cerity, have often carried profundity to abstruseness, sentiment to mysticism, and enthusiasm to exaltation. That country had remained for a long time for- eign to the refinement and elegance of modern civilisation. Endowed with an energetic but rough tongue; abundant, but not conducive to accuracy and clar- ity; of a language which, even today, has not yet been codified, [that country] could have no literature proper when other nations of Europe could already pride themselves on their own9. In this diatribe against German literature Auger stresses its lack of taste and prin- ciples, as well as its primitivism and other-wordliness, none of which he recognises as 6 Six years before Victor Hugo (“Préface” of Hernani, 1830), Auger defines Romanticism as a form of liberalism, although his attack is mainly addressed to the strictly monarchist writers from La Muse française. 7 On the subject of this complex question, see T. Jędrzejewski, Literatura w warszawskiej prasie kulturalnej pogranicza oświecenia i romantyzmu, Kraków 2016, pp. 12–15, 21–26. 8 L.-S. Auger, Recueil des discours prononcés dans la séance publique annuelle de l’Institut royal de France le samedi 24 avril 1824, Firmin Didot, Paris 1824, p. 3. 9 «[En Allemagne] la littérature n’a pas pas plus de centre d’unité que le pouvoir, où la police du ridicule n’existe pas, où les esprits, disposés à la méditation par leur isolement, à l’indépendance par leur dispersion, et à l’erreur par leur sincérité même, ont souvent porté la profondeur jusqu’à l’abstrusion, le sentiment jusqu’au mysticisme, et l’enthousiasme jusqu’à l’exaltation. Cette contrée demeura longtemps étrangère au raffinement et à l’élégance de la civilisation moderne. Douée d’une langue énergique, mais rude ; abondante, mais peu favorable à la précision et à la clarté ; d’une langue qui, aujourd’hui même, n’est pas encore fixée, elle n’avait pas de littéra- ture propre quand chacune des autres nations de l’Europe pouvait s’enorgueillir de la sienne»; ibidem, p.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Les Références Antiques Et Modernes Dans Smarra
    Francis Claudon Université de Paris XII [email protected] Les Références antiques et modernes dans Smarra Abstract: Charles Nodier is often thought of as belonging to the “Frenetic School”, he is also perceived as an eccentric author, almost as a humorist, which therefore contrasts with the graveness of the major romantic authors, such as Hugo, Novalis or Shelley. Yet, upon taking a closer look, it becomes obvious that Nodier cultivated “horror”, that is a type of romanticism which would later come to be termed “Black Romanticism”. It is also true that this deeply erudite man very skillfully borrowed elements from various sources in order to create a literature of his own, tales which are his, and his only. In this respect, Nodier is an interesting author for comparative studies. Such is the interest of Smarra, Smarra which initially seems to be an imitation of Apuleius. Yet, when studying the antique text closely, it appears that the Latin author really screens another reference, Shakespeare, the allusions to whom are numerous and difficult to decrypt. The result, a juxtaposition of antiquity and modernity, creates a specific coloring, itself reminiscent of the work of the painter Füssli, who also adapted freely Shakespearian sources, adding to them a sort of neoclassic halo. The true charm of Smarra resides there; Nodier is neither an eccentric nor an amateur, his romanticism is very educated and situates him midway between the erudition of the Enlightenment and the illumination of Romanticism. Keywords: freneticism, influences, Shakespeare, Antiquity, painting. Résumé: On range volontiers Charles Nodier parmi les membres de l’école frénétique ; on le tient aussi pour un auteur fantaisiste, voire humoriste, qui trancherait donc avec le sérieux des « grands » romantiques (Hugo, Novalis, Shelley).
    [Show full text]
  • Information to Users
    INFORMATION TO USERS This manuscripthas been reproduced from the microfilm master. UMI films the text directly from the original or copy submitted. Thus, some thesis and dissertation copies are in typewriter face, while others may be from any type of computer printer. The quality of this reproduction is dépendent upon the quality of the copy submitted. Broken or indistinct print, colored or poor quality illustrations and photographs, print bleedthrough, substandard margins, and improper alignment can adversely affect reproduction. In the unlikely event that the author did not send UMI a complété manuscript and there are missing pages, these will be noted. Also, if unauthorized copyright material had to be removed, a note will indicate the deletion. Oversize materials (e.g., maps, drawings, charts) are reproduced by sectioning the original, beginning at the upper left-hand corner and continuing from left to right in equal sections with small overlaps. Each original is also photographed in one exposure and is included in reduced form at the back of the book. Photographs included in the original manuscript have been reproduced xerographically in this copy. Higher quality 6" x 9" black and white photographie prints are available for any photographs or illustrations appearing in this copy for an additional charge. Contact UMI directly to order. University Microfilms International A Bell & Howell Information Company 300 North Zeeb Road. Ann Arbor, Ml 48106-1346 USA 313/761-4700 800/521-0600 Order Number 9325544 Figures de la coupure: Une étude de l’oeuvre fictionnelle de Charles Nodier Lowe-Dupas, Hélène Marie, Ph.D. The Ohio State University, 1993 Copyright ©1993 by Lowe-Dupas, Hélène Marie.
    [Show full text]
  • Nodier's Fantasticism. As a Matter of Fact, the Temptations of the Devils Sur- Pass in Number the Interventions of the Saints
    NODIER'S FANTASTICISM BY MAXIMILIAN J. RUDWIN FRENCH Romanticism is indebted to its schoolmaster for its fantastic element. The group of young men who gathered around Charles Nodier (1780-1844) Sunday evenings in his salon at the Arsenal (1824-7) to carry out under his leadership the liter- ary revolution called Romanticism followed their host to his holding in the country of fantasy.^ This writer fathered the Fantastic in French fiction. Nodier was a fanatic fantaisiste. He was obsessed with the phantasmagoric world. Reality was to him, as to Hoff- mann, but a pretext for the flight of his imagination. This culti- vated and learned man of letters, this editor and librarian, this bibli- ographer and lexicographer, this grammarian and historian, this botanist and entomologist, this traveler and man of affairs lived in a world of dreams. Nodier had a very complex character. He was at once sceptical and superstitious, heretic and mystic, revolutionary and royalist. This investigator and innovator felt an affinity for the frantic and fantastic.- He had an infatuation for the accidental and exceptional, for the fabulous and monstrous, for the mysterious and miraculous. Our writer was passionately fond of fairy-tales and ghost-stories, of Eastern legends and Western myths. As a boy he read fantastic stories with such relish that he was willing, as he tells us himself, to give ten years of his life for the Fantastic. Nodier's first novel, le Pehitrc dc Saltabourg (1803), already showed its author's preoccupation with the supernatural and supra- sensual. His introduction to Taylor's collection of prints, Ics Voy- ages pittoresqnes ct romantiqucs dans I'ancienne France (1820ff.), expressed the enthusiasm for national antiquities to which Nodier gradually rose.
    [Show full text]
  • Appendix: Translations from Mérimée's La Guzla
    Appendix: Translations from Mérimée’s La Guzla On vampirism In Illyria, in Poland, In Hungary, in Turkey and part of Germany, one would risk being reproached for irreligion and immorality if one denied publicly the existence of vampires. Vampire (vukodlak in Illyrian) is the name for a dead man who leaves his tomb, normally at night, and who torments the living. Often he sucks their necks; other times he squeezes their throats to the point of suffocating them. Those who die in such a way by the act of a vampire become vampires themselves after their deaths. It would appear that all feelings of natural affection have been destroyed within vampires; for, it has been noted that they would torment their friends and parents rather than strangers. Some believe that a man becomes a vampire through divine punishment; others that he has been propelled towards this by a peculiar sort of fate. The most vouched-for opinion is that schismatics buried in holy ground, unable to find any rest therein, and the excommunicated are avenging themselves upon the living for the agonies which they endure. The signs of vampirism are as follows: a corpse remaining preserved after a time when other bodies have begun to putrefy, the fluidity of blood, the suppleness of limbs etc. It is also said that vampires have their eyes open in their graves and that their nails and hair grow like those of the living. Some of them are recognisable by the noise that they make in their tombs while chewing quite about everything that surrounds them, often their very skin.
    [Show full text]
  • Salem Belles, Succubi, and the Scarlet Letter: Transatlantic Witchcraft and Gothic Erotic Affect
    Brigham Young University BYU ScholarsArchive Theses and Dissertations 2019-08-01 Salem Belles, Succubi, and The Scarlet Letter: Transatlantic Witchcraft and Gothic Erotic Affect Sylvia Cutler Brigham Young University Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/etd BYU ScholarsArchive Citation Cutler, Sylvia, "Salem Belles, Succubi, and The Scarlet Letter: Transatlantic Witchcraft and Gothic Erotic Affect" (2019). Theses and Dissertations. 8583. https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/etd/8583 This Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by BYU ScholarsArchive. It has been accepted for inclusion in Theses and Dissertations by an authorized administrator of BYU ScholarsArchive. For more information, please contact [email protected], [email protected]. Salem Belles, Succubi, and The Scarlet Letter: Transatlantic Witchcraft and Gothic Erotic Affect Sylvia Cutler A thesis submitted to the faculty of Brigham Young University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts Mary Kathleen Eyring, Chair Robert James Hudson Nicholas A. Mason Department of English Brigham Young University Copyright © 2019 Sylvia Cutler All Rights Reserved ABSTRACT Salem Belles, Succubi, and The Scarlet Letter: Transatlantic Witchcraft and Gothic Erotic Affect Sylvia Cutler Department of English, BYU Master of Arts In order to reconcile the absence of sexually deviant witch figures (succubae, demonic women, etc.) within the formation of American national literature in the nineteenth century with the
    [Show full text]
  • Concept & Origin/Historical Development of the Short Story 1.1
    Chapter One: Concept & Origin/Historical development of the Short story 1.1. The Concept of Short Story A short story is a brief work of literature, usually written in narrative prose. The short story has grown to encompass a body of work so diverse as to defy easy characterization. At its most prototypical, the short story features a small cast of named characters, and focuses on a self- contained incident with the intent of evoking a "single effect" or mood. In so doing, short stories make use of plot, resonance, and other dynamic components to a far greater degree than is typical of an anecdote, yet to a far lesser degree than a novel. While the short story is largely distinct from the novel, authors of both generally draw from a common pool of literary techniques. Short stories have no set length. In terms of word count there is no official demarcation between an anecdote, a short story, and a novel. Rather, the form's parameters are given by the rhetorical and practical context in which ,story may differ between genres, countries, eras, and commentators. Like the novel, the short story's predominant shape reflects the demands of the available markets for publication, and the evolution of the form seems closely tied to the evolution of the publishing industry and the submission guidelines of its constituent houses. The short story has been considered both an apprenticeship form preceding more lengthy works, and a crafted form in its own right, collected together in books of similar length, price, and distribution as novels.
    [Show full text]
  • The 15Th International Gothic Association Conference Lewis University, Romeoville, Illinois July 30 - August 2, 2019
    The 15th International Gothic Association Conference Lewis University, Romeoville, Illinois July 30 - August 2, 2019 Monday, July 29 Pre-scheduled shuttles from Midway, O’Hare airports to the Aloft hotel, campus: times to be announced Registration for those staying on campus, Mother Teresa Hall: times to be announced Dinner for those staying on campus: 5:00 – 6:30 p.m., Academic Building (Charlie’s Place) Graduate Student Meetup: 6:30 – 8:30 p.m., Gazebo or to be announced Tuesday, July 30 One-time morning shuttle from Midway, O’Hare airports to the Aloft hotel, campus: time to be announced Registration: 8:00 a.m. – 5:00 p.m., Academic Building (AS 150A) Graduate Student Workshop, Turning a Negative into a Positive: 10:30 – 11:30 a.m., Academic Building (AS 158A) 1. Rebecca Duncan, University of Stirling 2. Karen Macfarlane, Mount Saint Vincent University 3. Justin D. Edwards, University of Stirling 4. Xavier Aldana Reyes, Manchester Metropolitan University 5. Enrique Ajuria Ibarra, Universidad de las Américas Puebla Lunch (provided), St. Charles Borromeo (Flight Deck): 12:00 – 1:15 p.m. Welcoming remarks, St. Charles Borromeo (Convocation Hall): 1:30 – 2:15 p.m. David Livingston, President, Lewis University Jamil Mustafa, Lewis University Session 1: 2:30 – 4:00 p.m., Academic Building Classrooms Panel 1a (AS 113S): Frankenstein Chair: Daniel Kasper 1. From Horror to Terror: American Transmediations of Frankenstein – Colleen Karn, Methodist College 2. Beyond the Wound: Transgenerational Trauma Transmission in Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein – Anne Mahler, University College Cork 3. Death Embodied: Ecogothic Interventions in Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein – Bryan McMillan, University of North Carolina Greensboro 1 Panel 1b (AS 018S): Gothic Chapbooks and Prefaces Chair: Hannah-Freya Blake 1.
    [Show full text]
  • Views of 1 If E Str U~Gl Ing for Expression
    TYPES OF HEROINES IN THID ~RENCH ROMANTIC DRAMA: A COMPARISON WITH THE H~ROINES OF RACINE AND CORNEILLE • .A Thesis Presented for the Degree of Master of Arts BY Della Roggers Maidox, B. A. -- - . - - ... - - -- --.. - - ....... ·- ~ ;.: ~ ;~;~;-~~~.~-:~ - - - - - - - - -- - - - .. ... .. - THE OHIO-STATE UNIVERSITY -- 19 :20 BIBLIOGRAPHY I. French Sources Histoire da la Langue et ]e la Litterature Fran9aise Vols. IV, V, and VII Petit de Julleville. Drama Ancien, Drame Moderne Emile Faguet. Les 3rands Maitres du XVII~ Siecle, Vol V, IDmile Faguet. Histoire de la Litterature Fran9aise Brunetiere. Le Mouvement Litt~raire ju XIX! Sihcle t'ellissier. Le Rialisme iu Ro~a~ti3me Pellissier. Histoire ie la Litterature Fran9aise Abr Y..1 A11 Uc et Crou z;et Les Epoques iu Theatre Fran9ais• Bruneti~re~ Les Jranis Eorivains 'ran9ais~~Raoine .Justave Larroumet. " II " " Boilea11 Lanson. Histoire iu Romantisme Th6o~hile Gautier. ld(es et Doctrines Litteraires du XrII' Siecle Vial et Denise. n " II II " XIX ' ti Vial et Denise. Histoire de la Litt~rature Fran9aise, Vols.II,III " " " " " Lanson. Portraits Litteraires, Vol I Sainte-Beuve. CauserEes de Lunii Sainte-Beuve. De La Poesie Dramatique, Belles Lettres, Vol. VII Diderot. L'Art Poetique Boi l'eau. Racine et Victor Hugo P. Stapfer. La Poetique de Racine Robert. Les Granis IDcrivains Fran9ais--Alex. Dumas,P~re Parigot. II. English Sources Rousseau and Romanticism Irving Babbitt. Literature of the French Renaissance, Vols. I and II Tilley. Annals of the· French Stage, Vols. II ani III Hawkins. The Romantic Revolt Vaughan. The Romantic Triumph Omond. Studies in Hugo's Dramatic Characters Bruner. Main Currents of Nineteenth Century Literature, Vol.III Brandes~ History of English Romanticism in the Nineteenth Century Beers.
    [Show full text]
  • French Image of the Inhabitants of the Illyrian Provinces and the Emergence of South Slavic Nationalisms1
    BALCANICA POSNANIENSIA XXVII Poznań 2020 FRENCH IMAGE OF THE INHABITANTS OF THE ILLyRIAN PROVINCES 1 AND THE EMERGENCE OF SOUTH SLAVIC NATIONALISMS w o J c i e c h sa J k o w s k i Abstract. The Illyrian Provinces, a part of the 1st French Empire which existed in the years 1809–1813, are of- ten portrayed as a political entity which anticipated various projects of the political emancipation of the South Slavs. However, the link between later pan-South-Slavic movements and the Napoleonic political activity is a matter which still remains unclear and deserves some in-depth analysis. Most often the Napoleonic impact on the evolution of the nascent South-Slavic nationalisms is viewed in the perspective of the posterior political atti- tudes of the Croat, Slovene or Serbian elites towards the French, and their own interpretations of the Napoleonic impact on the pan-South-Slavic movement. The proposed paper will concentrate on the opposite approach and will investigate how French perceived the South Slavs in the perspective of the nascent nationalisms, especially that French propaganda presented Napoleon as the savior of the European nations including the „Illyrian” one. But how French defined this „Illyrian” nation? This question can be answered thanks to the French strive for de- scription of the societies inhabiting Illyrian Provinces. Author: Wojciech Sajkowski, Adam Mickiewicz University, Faculty of History, Uniwersytetu Poznańskiego st. 7, 61-614 Poznań, Poland, [email protected], OrciD iD: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-8585- 4149 Keywords: Illyrian Provinces, nation, stereotypes, propaganda, stereotypes Balcanica Posnaniensia.
    [Show full text]
  • Introduction
    Cambridge University Press 978-0-521-42959-7 - The Cambridge Companion to Fantasy Literature Edited by Edward James and Farah Mendlesohn Excerpt More information EDWARD JAMES AND FARAH MENDLESOHN Introduction Fantasy is not so much a mansion as a row of terraced houses, such as the one that entranced us in C. S. Lewis’s The Magician’s Nephew with its connecting attics, each with a door that leads into another world. There are shared walls, and a certain level of consensus around the basic bricks, but the internal decor´ can differ wildly, and the lives lived in these terraced houses are discrete yet overheard. Fantasy literature has proven tremendously difficult to pin down. The major theorists in the field – Tzvetan Todorov, Rosemary Jackson, Kathryn Hume, W. R. Irwin and Colin Manlove – all agree that fantasy is about the construction of the impossible whereas science fiction may be about the unlikely, but is grounded in the scientifically possible. But from there these critics quickly depart, each to generate definitions of fantasy which include the texts that they value and exclude most of what general readers think of as fantasy. Most of them consider primarily texts of the nineteenth and early twentieth century. If we turn to twentieth-century fantasy, and in particu- lar the commercially successful fantasy of the second half of the twentieth century, then, after Tolkien’s classic essay, ‘On Fairy Stories’, the most valu- able theoretical text for taking a definition of fantasy beyond preference and intuition is Brian Attebery’s Strategies of Fantasy (1992). Building on his earlier book, The American Fantasy Tradition (1980), Attebery proposed that we view fantasy as a group of texts that share, to a greater degree or other, a cluster of common tropes which may be objects but which may also be narrative techniques.
    [Show full text]
  • Johanna Von Haza, Alias Heinrich Paris. De La Critique D'art Comme
    Mechthild Fend, Melissa Hyde et Anne Lafont (dir.) Plumes et Pinceaux : Discours de femmes sur l’art en Europe (1750-1850) — Essais Publications de l’Institut national d’histoire de l’art Johanna von Haza, alias Heinrich Paris. De la critique d’art comme critique sociale France Nerlich DOI : 10.4000/books.inha.4086 Éditeur : Publications de l’Institut national d’histoire de l’art, Presses du réel Lieu d'édition : Dijon Année d'édition : 2012 Date de mise en ligne : 5 décembre 2017 Collection : Actes de colloques ISBN électronique : 9782917902677 http://books.openedition.org Référence électronique NERLICH, France. Johanna von Haza, alias Heinrich Paris. De la critique d’art comme critique sociale In : Plumes et Pinceaux : Discours de femmes sur l’art en Europe (1750-1850) — Essais [en ligne]. Dijon : Publications de l’Institut national d’histoire de l’art, 2012 (généré le 18 décembre 2020). Disponible sur Internet : <http://books.openedition.org/inha/4086>. ISBN : 9782917902677. DOI : https://doi.org/ 10.4000/books.inha.4086. Ce document a été généré automatiquement le 18 décembre 2020. Johanna von Haza, alias Heinrich Paris. De la critique d’art comme critique s... 1 Johanna von Haza, alias Heinrich Paris. De la critique d’art comme critique sociale France Nerlich 1 « Les Français disposent dans leur vie et dans leur littérature d’une chose pour laquelle nous, Allemands, n’avons même pas de mot […], la causerie. Ce que le Français appelle causer nous échappe presque totalement car cela présuppose l’existence d’une société, or nous ne possédons pas de société parce qu’il nous en manque la condition première, l’égalité1.
    [Show full text]
  • The Machine Awakens: the Science and Politics of the Fantastic Automaton
    The Machine Awakens: The Science and Politics of the Fantastic Automaton John Tresch Abstract Automatons of the eighteenth century testified to a faith in the rationality of a clockwork universe. During the early nineteenth century, in the Restoration and July Monarchy, images of self-moving machines were newly associated with the physics of ethers, conversions, steam and electricity, as well as with animal magnetism; they also frequently had magical and religious associations. This new generation of fantastic automatons can be seen as a reaction to the demiurgic power of mechanized industry and as a focal point for rethinking the past while facing an uncertain future. Images of animated matter and self-moving machines reveal the close partner- ship between romanticism and mechanization. Beyond highlighting the connections among the sciences of fluids, conversions and transmutations, fantastic literature, the emergence of mass entertainment, and early socialism, images of fantastic automatons reveal the supernatural undercurrents of the early industrial age. It is fire which brings metamorphosis; It makes all things obey, It gives a soul to rude bodies; From the mud, at its magic touch, Water rises up with an energetic thrust And moves a forest of steel. Victor de Laprade, Le nouvel âge A Mystery of Love Rests in Metal Machines in the eighteenth century were often seen to embody the promises of reason and enlightenment. This was strikingly the case with automatons: devices that moved on their own in imitation of natural objects and processes. The most celebrated among them were orreries (models of the solar system), clocks, and mechanical ani- mals and humans.
    [Show full text]