University of Florida Thesis Or Dissertation Formatting
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
SOLON THE POET, SOLON THE LAWGIVER, SOLON THE SAGE: THE INTERSECTING LEGENDS OF SOLON OF ATHENS By ANDREW PERRY CLARK A DISSERTATION PRESENTED TO THE GRADUATE SCHOOL OF THE UNIVERSITY OF FLORIDA IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY UNIVERSITY OF FLORIDA 2018 1 © 2018 Andrew Perry Clark 2 misero indigne fratri adempto mihi 3 ACKNOWLEDGMENTS I would first like to thank my dissertation advisor Robert Wagman for his unlimited patience and invaluable guidance through every stage of this project. I am especially thankful for the instruction and insight he provided in a Greek lyric seminar in the fall of 2014, without which I might never have been awakened to the humble enigma that is Solon. I am also greatly indebted to Konstantinos Kapparis, who with great tolerance never failed to answer a single one of my many questions throughout this arduous process. Additionally, I would like to thank the remaining members of my committee Mary Ann Eaverly and Lora Levett, whose patience and support have always been much needed and greatly appreciated. I give further thanks to the other members of the Classics department, in particular Eleni Bozia, Andy Nichols, Jennifer Rea, and formerly Jim Marks, who have all over the years encouraged and contributed in countless ways to my professional development. On a personal note, I must also thank my wonderful cats, Yoshie and Alphie, who have kept me company for years and have never been out of reach throughout the many long and sleepless nights of work. I am extremely grateful for the support of my friends and family, especially my late brother Paul, who taught me how to read. I lastly wish to thank my dearest love Karen for all of her support and encouragement as I worked on a project that threatened to defeat me many times over. 4 TABLE OF CONTENTS page ACKNOWLEDGMENTS ...............................................................................................................4 LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS ..........................................................................................................8 ABSTRACT .....................................................................................................................................9 CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION ..................................................................................................................11 1.1 The Solonian Legend ........................................................................................................11 1.2 Solon’s Poetry and Laws as Biographical Sources ...........................................................15 1.3 Methodology .....................................................................................................................20 2 SOLON THE POET ...............................................................................................................24 2.1 The Poetic Fragments .......................................................................................................24 2.2 Lost Poems of Solon .........................................................................................................28 2.2.1 On Atlantis ..............................................................................................................30 2.2.2 To Croesus ..............................................................................................................34 2.3 Solon’s Poetic Style, Influences .......................................................................................38 2.4 Solon the Poet in the Ancient Sources ..............................................................................48 2.5 The Chronology of Solon’s Poetic Fragments ..................................................................50 2.6 The Transmission of Solon’s Poetry.................................................................................53 2.7 Solon’s Poetic Autobiography ..........................................................................................55 2.7.1 Solon’s Beliefs, Opinions .......................................................................................57 2.7.1.1 Politics at Athens ..........................................................................................57 2.7.1.2 Justice, Fate ..................................................................................................67 2.7.1.3 Life, Happiness, Wealth ...............................................................................74 2.7.1.4 Religion ........................................................................................................83 2.7.2 Solon’s Life ............................................................................................................86 2.7.2.1 Family ...........................................................................................................86 2.7.2.2 Travel ...........................................................................................................88 2.7.3 Solon’s Public Work ...............................................................................................91 2.7.3.1 Salamis .........................................................................................................92 2.7.3.2 Legislation ....................................................................................................94 2.7.3.3 Response to Criticism ...................................................................................99 2.8 Biographical Elements Collected from the Poetry .........................................................101 3 SOLON THE LAWGIVER ..................................................................................................104 3.1 The Legal Fragments ......................................................................................................104 3.1.1 The Question of Authenticity ...............................................................................107 3.1.2 The Scope of Solonian Legislation .......................................................................109 5 3.1.3 Legendary Athenian Lawgivers, Theseus, Dracon ...............................................112 3.2 The Axones, Kyrbeis ......................................................................................................116 3.3 The Date of Solon’s Archonship, Legislative Reforms ..................................................119 3.4 Solon the Lawgiver in the Ancient Sources ...................................................................121 3.5 Solon the Lawgiver in Solon’s Poetry ............................................................................135 3.6 Solon’s Reported Laws, Legislative Reforms ................................................................136 3.6.1 Property-Classes, Eligibility for Office ................................................................141 3.6.2 Constitutional Reforms, Courts ............................................................................146 3.6.3 Criminal Law ........................................................................................................155 3.6.4 Civil Law ..............................................................................................................161 3.6.5 Administrative Law ..............................................................................................175 3.6.6 Tyranny, Stasis .....................................................................................................178 3.6.7 Economic Reforms, Trade, Seisachtheia, Grants of Citizenship .........................180 3.6.8 Funerary Laws ......................................................................................................187 3.6.9 Religious Legislation ............................................................................................191 3.6.10 Calendric Reforms, Other Legislative Activity ..................................................192 3.7 Institutions, Structure of Government within Solon’s Legal Fragments ........................197 3.8 Political Ideology Implied in Solon’s Legal Fragments .................................................199 3.9 Intersection of Solon the Poet and Solon the Lawgiver .................................................202 3.10 Biographical Elements Collected from the Legal Fragments .......................................205 4 SOLON OF ATHENS ..........................................................................................................208 4.1 The Biographical Tradition on Solon .............................................................................208 4.2 Solon’s Biographical Elements in the Poetry and Laws .................................................215 4.3 Statues of Solon ..............................................................................................................216 4.4 Solon’s Biography ..........................................................................................................217 4.4.1 Solon’s Lifetime: Birth, Death, Burial .................................................................218 4.4.2 Solon’s Family ......................................................................................................222 4.4.3 Solon’s Personality, Character .............................................................................225 4.4.4 Solon’s Writings ...................................................................................................230 4.4.5 Solon the Merchant, Other Pre-Legislative Work