DOCSLIB.ORG

Public Interest Law and Litigation

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Public Interest Law and Litigation !1 Researchers Matthew O’Shea Arlene Walsh-Wallace Aislinn Finnegan Emily Duncan Samantha Tancredi Chloe Dalton Alan Eustace Campbell Whyte Hannah Edwards Orla Murnaghan Veronica Janice Bleeker Caoilainn McDaid Nathan O’Regan Sierra Mueller-Owens Adam Elebert Ronan McGurrin Gareth Foynes Nadine Fitzpatrick Nicola O’Corrbui Jack Synnott Eolann Davis Eoin Forde Roisin Casey Ella Woolfson Seamus Small Editor: Celia Reynolds With thanks to: Professor Gerry Whyte, Trinity College Dublin Eilis Barry, CEO National FLAC Rachel Power, PILA & FLAC Strategic Development Manager Mary Murphy, Secretary, Trinity FLAC Caoilainn McDaid, Fundraising Officer, Trinity FLAC Chloe Dalton, Clinics Coordinator, Trinity FLAC Catherine Teevan, OCM, Trinity FLAC Ivan Rakhmanin, PRO Trinity FLAC !2 DISCLAIMER Trinity FLAC assumes no responsibility for and gives no guarantees, undertakings or warranties concerning the accuracy, completeness or up-to-date nature of the information provided in this report and/or for any consequences of any actions taken on the basis of the information provided, legal or otherwise. The information provided in this report is not a complete source of information on all aspects of the law. Trinity FLAC takes no responsibility for any information or advice passed from a client to a third party. If you need professional or legal advice you should consult a suitably qualified person at one of our weekly clinics. If there are any questions, please contact: [email protected] !3 Trinity FLAC 50th Anniversary Public Interest Law Research Report Table of Contents Foreword 5 Professor Gerry Whyte Introduction 7 FLAC Legal Research Officer: Celia Reynolds Part I: Socioeconomic Rights I.I Socioeconomic Rights in Ireland 10 Nicola O’Corrbui, Roisin Casey, Celia Reynolds I.II Comparative Analysis of Other Jurisdictions 21 Chloe Dalton, Caoilainn McDaid, Ella Woolfson Part II: Rules of Practice and Costs of Litigation II Rules of Practice and Costs of Litigation 36 Aislinn Finnegan, Sierra Mueller-Owens, Matthew O’Shea, Campbell Whyte Part III: Standing of Campaigning Groups III.I Irish Jurisprudence on Standing of Campaigning Groups 54 Adam Elebert, Eolann Davis, Gareth Foynes III.II Comparative Analysis of Other Jurisdictions 62 Ronan McGurrin, Nathan O’Regan, Seamus Small Part IV: Multi-Party Litigation IV.I Representative Actions in Ireland 73 Alan Eustace, Arlene Walsh-Wallace, Hannah Edwards, Eoin Forde IV.II Comparative Analysis to the United States 84 Samantha Tancredi, Veronica Janice Bleeker, Emily Duncan IV.III Comparative Analysis to Other Jurisdictions 95 Jack Synnott, Orla Murnaghan, Nadine Fitzpatrick !4 Foreword Professor Gerry Whyte When FLAC was established in April 1969, it had three objectives: a) To oblige the State to establish a comprehensive scheme of civil legal aid and advice; b) In the meantime, to provide free advice to those unable to afford the services of private practitioners; and c) to improve the education of law students by giving them an opportunity to be involved in providing legal support to marginalised individuals and communities. Fifty years later, FLAC’s services, and the services of other legal aid organisations, are still in great demand, a telling reflection on the limitations of the State scheme of civil legal aid, first introduced in 1980 and put on a statutory footing in 1995. But in addition to making a very significant contribution to the provision of civil legal aid and advice, FLAC has also contributed significantly to the education of law students, in particular, through the operation of FLAC societies in most of our law schools. Trinity College’s involvement with FLAC goes back to FLAC’s earliest days when undergraduate students like Susan Denham and Alan Shatter worked as FLAC volunteers and Kadar Asmal sat on FLAC’s executive as one of four advisors representing each of the four institutions of legal education in Dublin at the time. Trinity FLAC was established in 1986/1987 and formally recognised as a college society in 1990/91. Since that time, it has pursued the twin aims of providing legal advice to Trinity students and also raising awareness among the student population about the need for legal and social reform in certain areas. Marking the fiftieth anniversary of the establishment of FLAC, Public Interest Law and Litigation in Ireland continues in the proud tradition of Trinity FLAC, providing a well- researched and very accessible analysis of four key issues relevant to Irish public interest lawyers. These issues are the system of protection for socioeconomic rights in this !5 jurisdiction, the impact of rules of practice and procedure and legal costs on public interest litigation, the issue of standing in public interest litigation and, finally, the legal regime regulating multi-party litigation here. In relation to each topic, the report provides a comparative analysis of other common law jurisdictions. Public interest law entails the use of political campaigning and, where appropriate, litigation to address the needs of marginalised groups and individuals. Over the past fifty years, FLAC has established a reputation as Ireland’s leading public interest law organisation and has inspired generations of law students to give of their time and energy in the pursuit of social justice. This current publication continues in that proud tradition and is a testimony to the values of social solidarity and empathy that animate Trinity FLAC. Gerry Whyte !6 Introduction TCD FLAC Legal Research Officer: Celia Reynolds In recognition of the 50 year anniversary of the founding of national FLAC, Trinity FLAC decided to conduct this research project on public interest law and litigation in Ireland. The intention of this paper is to provide an analysis of the key issues in PIL, evaluating the current legal system and providing a comparative analysis to other jurisdictions. The hope is that this project will be accessible to both law and non-law students as well as legal and non- legal campaigning organisations. The recommendations that will be made in the concluding remarks will reflect the positions advanced by the volunteer researchers. Part I of this paper will begin by discussing the system of protection of socioeconomic rights that exists in Ireland. The purpose of this part will be to provide public interest litigation in context, exploring judicial conservatism with reference to the background principles that form the underpinnings of the Irish justice system. The analysis will support O'Cinneide assertion that Anglo-American constitutional systems usually lack a ‘social dimension’, rejecting attempts to direct the executive and legislative branches of government from giving effect to principles of social justice.1 For the purpose of this Part, it should be noted that the existence of socioeconomic rights will be assumed.2 Section I.I will attempt to summarise the main arguments advanced against judicial protection of socioeconomic rights, making reference to key Irish judgments that have framed this debate. Efforts will also be made to capture the academic response to such conservative arguments, ultimately attempting to provide a brief overview of the legal discourse. Section I.II will further this discussion by providing a comparative analysis of socioeconomic rights protections in other jurisdictions. The intention, of course, is to bring the Anglo- American background principles that form Irish legal discussion into contrast with thematically opposed constitutions. This will be particularly effective when having regard to 1 Colm O’Cinneide, ‘Zones of Constitutionalisation and the Regulation of State Power: The Missing Social Dimension to the Irish Constitutional Order’ 37 DULJ 173 (2014). 2 This is not an accepted matter in the Irish legal system, controversies exist surrounding the identification of such rights, and whether they may be implied into the Constitution, or read from various provisions. !7 the Indian and South African constitutions. Canadian vindication of socioeconomic rights will also be considered, providing a useful example of an Anglo-American Constitution that supports judicial protection in this arena. Part II of this report will focus upon the rules of practise and costs of litigation that shape the Irish justice system, first with reference to the general access to justice, and then secondly with a focus on public interest litigation in particular. Acute attention will be paid to how costs of ascertaining legal advice and taking claims acts as a barrier to justice. A brief comparison of the Irish approach will also be given to other common law jurisdictions, with the intention of placing Ireland in a global context. Section II.I will also draw attention to the various rules that affect public interest litigation, including those concerning Ireland’s ‘loser pays’ system, maintenance, champerty and the doctrine of mootness. The legal issue of standing in public interest litigation will be brought into focus in Part III, noting how narrow or broad interpretations of this doctrine may impede or empower the advancement of social justice. A simplified history of the doctrine of locus standi will be provided in the Section III.I, noting the doctrine’s limited flexibility. Focus will be paid as to the treatment of campaigning groups in Irish jurisprudence and it will be concluded that the legal system should better embrace the goals of public interest law. The second half of this part, Section III.II will again provide a comparative analysis of Ireland’s legal approach to other jurisdictions, in this case with a particular focus on Canada and the United States. Canada will be identified as a having a favorable approach, in creating a division between private standing and ‘public standing’, such that public interest issues may be appropriately brought into the remit of a court’s decision. The final and largest part of this paper, Part IV, will discuss multi-party litigation, a litigation tool that adequately matches the goals of public interest law. The current system of representative actions in Ireland will be criticised as under utilised and overly constrained.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Report on an Inspection of the Training Unit, Mountjoy Campus, Carried out in Accordance with Section 31(1) of the Prisons Act 2007
    Report on an Inspection of the Training Unit, Mountjoy Campus, carried out in accordance with Section 31(1) of the Prisons Act 2007 4 May 2017 Office of the Inspector of Prisons 24 Cecil Walk Kenyon Street Nenagh Co. Tipperary Tel: + 353 67 42210 E-mail: [email protected] Web: www.inspectorofprisons.gov.ie Report on an Inspection of the Training Unit, Mountjoy Campus, carried out in accordance with Section 31(1) of the Prisons Act 2007 Presented to the Tánaiste and Minister for Justice and Equality pursuant to Part 5 of the Prisons Act 2007. Helen Casey Office of the Inspector of Prisons 4 May 2017 © Inspector of Prisons 2017 1 CONTENTS Acknowledgements 3 Foreword 4 Chapter 1 Introduction 5 Chapter 2 Overview of the Training Unit 8 Chapter 3 Key aspects of the Investigation 12 Chapter 4 Facilities, Education and Workshops 18 Chapter 5 Issues of Concern 21 Chapter 6 Findings 23 Chapter 7 Recommendations 24 Chapter 8 Conclusion 26 Appendix A 27 2 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I received a high level of co-operation from all people involved in my inspection of the Training Unit. I would like to thank all the persons that spoke to me during the inspection including prison staff, prisoners and the service providers for their helpful and candid views. I would, in particular like to thank Campus Governor Brian Murphy, Governor John Kavanagh (since retired) and Chief Officer Tara O’Connell for their willingness to assist me in aspects of my inspection. I would also like to take this opportunity to express my appreciation to Ms.
    [Show full text]
  • Irish History Links
    Irish History topics pulled together by Dan Callaghan NC AOH Historian in 2014 Athenry Castle; http://www.irelandseye.com/aarticles/travel/attractions/castles/Galway/athenry.shtm Brehon Laws of Ireland; http://www.libraryireland.com/Brehon-Laws/Contents.php February 1, in ancient Celtic times, it was the beginning of Spring and later became the feast day for St. Bridget; http://www.chalicecentre.net/imbolc.htm May 1, Begins the Celtic celebration of Beltane, May Day; http://wicca.com/celtic/akasha/beltane.htm. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ February 14, 269, St. Valentine, buried in Dublin; http://homepage.eircom.net/~seanjmurphy/irhismys/valentine.htm March 17, 461, St. Patrick dies, many different reports as to the actual date exist; http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/11554a.htm Dec. 7, 521, St. Columcille is born, http://prayerfoundation.org/favoritemonks/favorite_monks_columcille_columba.htm January 23, 540 A.D., St. Ciarán, started Clonmacnoise Monastery; http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/04065a.htm May 16, 578, Feast Day of St. Brendan; http://parish.saintbrendan.org/church/story.php June 9th, 597, St. Columcille, dies at Iona; http://www.irishcultureandcustoms.com/ASaints/Columcille.html Nov. 23, 615, Irish born St. Columbanus dies, www.newadvent.org/cathen/04137a.htm July 8, 689, St. Killian is put to death; http://allsaintsbrookline.org/celtic_saints/killian.html October 13, 1012, Irish Monk and Bishop St. Colman dies; http://www.stcolman.com/ Nov. 14, 1180, first Irish born Bishop of Dublin, St. Laurence O'Toole, dies, www.newadvent.org/cathen/09091b.htm June 7, 1584, Arch Bishop Dermot O'Hurley is hung by the British for being Catholic; http://www.exclassics.com/foxe/dermot.htm 1600 Sept.
    [Show full text]
  • Teachers' Notes
    TEACHERS’ NOTES PRIMARY VIRTUAL TOUR Introduction This set of Teachers’ Notes has been created by the Education Department of the National Museum of Ireland at Collins Barracks in order to aid the teaching and interpretation of the ‘Proclaiming a Republic: the 1916 Rising’ Virtual Tour. The virtual tour - Provide teachers and student with an engaging and thought-provoking learning resource based around the aims to: 1916 Easter Rising and the National Museum of Ireland’s expansive ‘Easter Week’ collection of artefacts and images. - Provoke discussion and reflection upon key themes reflected in the exhibition. These include the roles of ordinary people during the Rising, in particular children, young people and women – the choices they had to make and what motivated those choices. These Teachers’ - Provide further information about the key artefacts on each stop of the Notes aim to: Virtual Tour, as well as a brief historical context. - Suggest potential discussion points in order to aid classroom discussion, and to suggest possible solo and group activities for students to engage in, which will enhance their understanding of the material presented. - Provide teachers with the relevant curriculum links, highlighting why each section of the tour was chosen and to explain what we hope to achieve for students at each location. Themes 1. The theme of choices – what motivated those who took part in the Rising and why others did not participate? We also consider those who had no A number of themes choice but were impacted by, or caught up in the Rising. We ask students are highlighted and to think about what choices they might have made, and to consider the explored throughout complexities inherent in these choices.
    [Show full text]
  • La Clinique De Médiation De L'université
    LE MAGAZINE DES JURISTES DU QUÉBEC 4$ Volume 24, numéro 6 La Clinique de médiation de l’Université de Montréal et ses partenaires : se mobiliser pour l’accès à la justice Dans l’ordre habituel de gauche à droite, de bas en haut : Mme Rielle Lévesque (Coordonnatrice de la Clinique de médiation de l’Université de Sherbrooke) , Dr Maya Cachecho (Chercheure post- doctoral et coordonnatrice scientifique du Projet de recherche ADAJ), Me Laurent Fréchette (Président du Comité de gouvernance et d’éthique, Chambre des notaires du Québec), Pr Pierre-Claude Lafond (Professeur à l’Université de Montréal, membre du Groupe RéForMa et membre du Comité scientifique de la Clinique de médiation de l’Université de Montréal), Me Hélène de Kovachich (Juge administratif et fondatrice-directrice de la Clinique de médiation de l’Université de Montréal), Pr Marie-Claude Rigaud (Professeure à l’Université de Montréal et directrice du Groupe RéForMa), Pr Catherine Régis (Professeure à l’Université de Montréal et membre du Groupe RéForMa), Me Ariane Charbonneau (Directrice générale d’Éducaloi), Mme Anja-Sara Lahady (Assistante de recherche 2018-2019), Mme Laurie Trottier-Lacourse (Assistante de recherche 2018-2019), L’Honorable Henri Richard (Juge en chef adjoint à la chambre civile de la Cour du Québec), M Serge Chardonneau (Directeur général d’Équijustice), Mme Laurence Codsi (Présidente du Comité Accès à la Justice), Me Nathalie Croteau (Secrétaire-trésorière de l’IMAQ), Me Marie Annik Gagnon (Juge administratif coordonateur section des affaires sociales, TAQ),
    [Show full text]
  • Ireland's Prisons
    ANNUAL REPORT 2020 Irish Prison Service www.irishprisons.ie CREATING A BETTER ENVIRONMENT In 2020, due to public health restrictions, Loughan House Community Outreach, identified the need to maintain their partnerships with community groups throughout the pandemic. As part of the Government Community Call initiative, Loughan House worked with the Civil Defence to supply, in a safe manner, nursing homes, local residential and care facilities with a supply of plants and flowers to maintain and enhance their environments for the benefit and wellbeing of the residents who were unable to receive visitors and were confined in their movements during lockdown. Positive feedback and recognition received from those in need in the community, via social media, phone calls and letters provided a very welcome morale boost and encouragement for staff and prisoners throughout the pandemic. Creating A Better Environment Contents Director General’s Report 2 Overview of Irish Prison Service 5 The Organisation 6 The Prison Estate 22 Statistical Note 30 Strategic Objectives 40 Appendices 56 ANNUAL REPORT 2020 DIRECTOR GENERAL’S REPORT To: Minister of State, Hildegarde Naughton T.D, Dear Minister, I am pleased to submit to you the Annual Report of the Irish Prison Service for 2020. 2020 has been an extraordinary year. COVID-19 presented a huge challenge to our Service as the spread of the virus within the close confines of a prison could have devastating consequences for those who live and work in that environment. Working together as a team, we aimed to prevent the spread of COVID-19 in our prisons, detect early any possible case and contain any possible outbreak.
    [Show full text]
  • Ennis Cathedral
    Ennis Cathedral: The Building & Its People. Saturday 29th. August 2009 Presented by the Clare Roots Society Clare Roots Society The Clare Roots Society, brainchild of Ennisman Larry Brennan, was formed in April 2006 as an amateur family history group. The Society meets once a month in Ennis, and has approx. 50 members. Anyone with an interest in tracing their family tree is welcome to join. Some members are experienced genealogists while others are novices in the field. In addition to local members, we have some 'virtual' members who live overseas, but who follow our activities via email, and dream that they are in Clare. Activities are advertised in local press and in the Ennis Cathedral church bulletin. Under the Chairmanship of Declan Barron and his committee of Fiona de Buitleir, Eric Shaw, Larry Brennan & Paddy Waldron, guest speakers were arranged at past meetings including Paul O’Donnell of the South Galway genealogy group, Peter Beirne of 'The Manse' Local Studies library in Ennis, Jim Herlihy on the RIC, Liam Curran on Irish Soldiers in the British Army, Jonny Dillon of the Folklore Dept., UCD, and Dr. Pat Nugent of the University of Liverpool amongst others. From our own members, speakers have included Dr. Paddy Waldron, Gerry Kennedy, Ger Madden, Declan Barron, Eric Shaw, Robert Cullen, and Larry Brennan. In addition, we have run a number of hands-on computer workshops on genealogical research and the recording of data. The society works in partnership with Clare County Library in order to add to the wonderful fund of genealogy information already available on their website www.clarelibrary.ie Our biggest project to date, completed in 2008 with the assistance of a grant from the Heritage Council of Ireland, involved transcription of the gravestones in the old Drumcliffe Cemetery.
    [Show full text]
  • Miscellaneous Notes on Republicanism and Socialism in Cork City, 1954–69
    MISCELLANEOUS NOTES ON REPUBLICANISM AND SOCIALISM IN CORK CITY, 1954–69 By Jim Lane Note: What follows deals almost entirely with internal divisions within Cork republicanism and is not meant as a comprehensive outline of republican and left-wing activities in the city during the period covered. Moreover, these notes were put together following specific queries from historical researchers and, hence, the focus at times is on matters that they raised. 1954 In 1954, at the age of 16 years, I joined the following branches of the Republican Movement: Sinn Féin, the Irish Republican Army and the Cork Volunteers’Pipe Band. The most immediate influence on my joining was the discovery that fellow Corkmen were being given the opportunity of engag- ing with British Forces in an effort to drive them out of occupied Ireland. This awareness developed when three Cork IRA volunteers were arrested in the North following a failed raid on a British mil- itary barracks; their arrest and imprisonment for 10 years was not a deterrent in any way. My think- ing on armed struggle at that time was informed by much reading on the events of the Tan and Civil Wars. I had been influenced also, a few years earlier, by the campaigning of the Anti-Partition League. Once in the IRA, our initial training was a three-month republican educational course, which was given by Tomas Óg MacCurtain, son of the Lord Mayor of Cork, Tomas MacCurtain, who was murdered by British forces at his home in 1920. This course was followed by arms and explosives training.
    [Show full text]
  • Was Duplessis Right? Roderick A
    Document generated on 09/27/2021 4:21 p.m. McGill Law Journal Revue de droit de McGill Was Duplessis Right? Roderick A. Macdonald The Legacy of Roncarelli v. Duplessis, 1959-2009 Article abstract L’héritage de l’affaire Roncarelli c. Duplessis, 1959-2009 Given the inclination of legal scholars to progressively displace the meaning of Volume 55, Number 3, September 2010 a judicial decision from its context toward abstract propositions, it is no surprise that at its fiftieth anniversary, Roncarelli v. Duplessis has come to be URI: https://id.erudit.org/iderudit/1000618ar interpreted in Manichean terms. The complex currents of postwar society and DOI: https://doi.org/10.7202/1000618ar politics in Quebec are reduced to a simple story of good and evil in which evil is incarnated in Duplessis’s “persecution” of Roncarelli. See table of contents In this paper the author argues for a more nuanced interpretation of the case. He suggests that the thirteen opinions delivered at trial and on appeal reflect several debates about society, the state and law that are as important now as half a century ago. The personal socio-demography of the judges authoring Publisher(s) these opinions may have predisposed them to decide one way or the other; McGill Law Journal / Revue de droit de McGill however, the majority and dissenting opinions also diverged (even if unconsciously) in their philosophical leanings in relation to social theory ISSN (internormative pluralism), political theory (communitarianism), and legal theory (pragmatic instrumentalism). Today, these dimensions can be seen to 0024-9041 (print) provide support for each of the positions argued by Duplessis’s counsel in 1920-6356 (digital) Roncarelli given the state of the law in 1946.
    [Show full text]
  • Manchester Republican Movement
    The IRA in Manchester (1919-23) New Sources and Insight Sam McGrath (Military Service Pensions Collection) Outline 1. Introduction 2. Historical Background 3. Irish Vols. (1913-19) 4. IRA formed (Jan 1919–Nov 1920) 5. Armed Campaign (Nov 1920– Apr 1921) 6. Raid, Arrests & Trial (Apr 1921– July 1921) 7. Truce Period & Civil War (July 1921–May 1923) 8. Conclusion MSPC • 300,000 files / 80,000 individuals • Military Service Pensions Acts - 1916 Rising, War of Independence, Civil War - Na Fianna Éireann, Cumann na mBan, Irish Citizen Army, Irish Vols, Hibernian Rifles, IRA, Nat. Army • Army Pensions Acts - Wounds/disability/disease - Dependents of those killed • Medal files. 47,500. Database online. Physical files in Military Archives • Nominal/Membership rolls & Brigade Activity Reports - Scanned & online Historical Background • United Englishmen (1790s) • Peterloo massacre (1819) • Anti-Irish violence (1830s- 1850s) • Chartism (1830s-1850s) • Fenian campaign & Manchester Martyrs (1867) • Dynamite campaign (1880s) • United Irish League (1890s) • Manchester Martyrs memorial unveiled (1898) Historical Background • James Connolly speaking tour (1901-02) • ‘Oisin’ Gaelic League branch estd. (1904) • Sinn Féin cumann estd. at Richardson St by Pat. O’Donoghue & James Barrett (1908) • Visit of Edward O’Meagher Condon (1909) • IRB activity. Matt Lawless (Head Centre) Irish Vols (1913-19) • Larkin & Connolly speak in MCR during Dublin Lock Out (1913) • Irish Vols. estd. Drilled at St. Wilfred’s, Hulme (late 1913) • Split (Aug 1914). c. 22 remained. Drilled in Derbyshire Hills • MCR unit at O’Donovan Rossa funeral, Dublin (Aug 1915) • Gunrunning in lead up to Rising Manchester Vols. - Easter Week Name DOB Born 1916 WOI CW Place/DO Ref.
    [Show full text]
  • Hunger Strikes by Irish Republicans, 1916-1923 Michael Biggs ([email protected]) University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign
    Hunger Strikes by Irish Republicans, 1916-1923 Michael Biggs ([email protected]) University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign Paper prepared for Workshop on Techniques of Violence in Civil War Centre for the Study of Civil War, Oslo August 2004 “It is not those who can inflict the most, but those who can suffer the most who will conquer.” (Terence MacSwiney, 1920) “The country has not had, as yet, sufficient voluntary sacrifice and suffering[,] and not until suffering fructuates will she get back her real soul.” (Ernie O’Malley, 1923) The hunger strike is a strange technique of civil war. Physical suffering—possibly even death—is inflicted on oneself, rather than on the opponent. The technique can be conceived as a paradoxical inversion of hostage-taking or kidnapping, analyzed by Elster (2004). With kidnapping, A threatens to kill a victim B in order to force concessions from the target C; sometimes the victim is also the target. With a hunger strike, the perpetrator is the victim: A threatens to kill A in order to force concessions.1 Kidnappings staged for publicity, where the victim is released unconditionally, are analogous to hunger strikes where the duration is explicitly 1 This brings to mind a scene in the film Blazing Saddles. A black man, newly appointed sheriff, is surrounded by an angry mob intent on lynching him. He draws his revolver and points it to his head, warning them not to move “or the nigger gets it.” This threat allows him to escape. The scene is funny because of the apparent paradox of threatening to kill oneself, and yet that is exactly what hunger strikers do.
    [Show full text]
  • Bertha Wilson Fonds (R15636) Finding Aid No MSS2578 MIKAN
    Date: 21/06/2017 Bertha Wilson fonds (R15636) Page 1 Finding aid no MSS2578 Y:\App\Impromptu\Mikan\Reports\Description_reports\finding_aids_&_subcontainers_simplelist.im MIKAN Container File/Item Cr. file/item Hierarchy Title, etc Date of/de Extent/Media/Dim/Access cde # Contenant Dos./pièce Dos./item cr. Hiérarchie Titre, etc création Support ou Média / Dim. / Accès 4938705 Series Osler, Hoskin and Harcourt [textual record, graphic material] 1965-1972 4939542 1 1 File Ontario Law Reform Commission Report No. 1 1965 Textual records / 90 4939543 1 2 File Osgoode Hall Law School - Conference on Company Law 1965 Textual records / 90 4939544 1 3 File Portraits of Bertha Wilson n.d Graphic (photo) / 90 4939545 1 4 File York Un ive rsity Estate Planning Seminars 17-18 Textual records / 90 November 1972 4938706 Series Supreme Court of Ontario [textual record] 1962-1982 4938708 Sub-series Administrative and operational files [textual record] 1962-1982 4939546 1 5 File Abortion 1976 Textual records / 90 4939547 1 6 File Appeal Court Seminar 1980 1980 Textual records / 90 4939548 1 7 File Apellate Judges' Seminar, "Role of a Provincial Appellate Court" 1980 Textual records / 90 4939549 1 8 File Arnup, Justice John D., "The Writing of Judgments" n.d Textual records / 90 4939550 1 9 File Articles on Trusts [1975-1981] Textual records / 90 4939550 1 10 File Articles on Trusts [1975-1981] Textual records / 90 4939551 1 11 File Articles on Trusts in the Conflict of Laws [1975-1981] Textual records / 90 4939551 1 12 File Articles on Trusts in the Conflict
    [Show full text]
  • Past and Present Mountjoy Prison 1919
    A t i c O s I a c Edited by Major General Piaras Beaslai. Vol. 1., No. 2. SUMMER, 1961 6d. PAST AND PRESENT MOUNTJOY PRISON 1919 O patriotic Irishman, and, in particular no old I.R.A. man, can A Poetical Picture N regard without the deepest concern the depletion of the Irish countryside by the emigration in excessive numbers of the most N March 16th, 1919, Robert Barton escaped at night from Mountjoy Prison, having sawed through a bar in the window of his cell healthy and vigorous young men and women. Excessive emigration has O in the Prison Hospital near the canal bank wall. He scaled the been an Irish problem for several generations. Under British rule, or wall with the aid of assistants outside, who threw over a rope ladder, rather misrule, the cause of it was largely economic necessity, the same and caught him in a blanket. cause which produced periodic famines in the West of Ireland. In the early Thirteen days later, on March 29th, twenty prisoners escaped from Sinn Fein days, at the beginning of this century, excessive emigration Mountjoy, in broad daylight, by the same method and with the same assistance from outside. These included Patrick Fleming, “ the prison was listed as one of the national evils to be combated, and an Anti- breaker”, who had demolished a special cell built for him in Maryborough Emigration Society was started, with branches all over the country. Prison, of “unbreakable” material; J. J. Walsh, T.D., and the editor of AN tOGLACH. Prior to this escape the last-named scribbled a parody It is a puzzling and disturbing yearly to sweep the rich harvest of Fitzgerald s Omar Khayyam”, which gives a fair idea of conditions fact that in an independent Re­ of the Irish seas and make much in the prison at the time.
    [Show full text]