To Download a Pdf of This Journal
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
127053 - Front/Back Cover 26/10/04 3:18 pm Page 1 Cornish Archaeology 39–40 2000–1 Editorial Roman Nornour, Isles of Scilly: a reconsideration 5 CORNISH SARNIA BUTCHER with R D PENHALLURICK and D F WILLIAMS The excavation of a multi-period site at Stencoose, Cornwall 45 ANDY M JONES with HENRIETTA QUINNELL, DR ROGER TAYLOR, CARL THORPE, ARCHAEOLOGY ANNA LAWSON JONES, VANESSA STRAKER and DOMINIQUE DE MOULINS Shadows in the imagination: encounters with caves in Cornwall 95 39–40 PETER ROSE 2000–1 Time Team at Boleigh fogou, St Buryan 129 ANDREW YOUNG Recording ancient environments at De Lank, St Breward, Cornwall 146 ANDY M JONES and HEATHER M TINSLEY Discoveries along the St Newlyn East to Mitchell pipeline 161 ANDY M JONES and SEAN TAYLOR Flint finds from Clicker Tor, Menheniot 167 G F WALFORD Recent work by the Cornwall Archaeological Unit, 1998 172 Recent work by the Cornwall Archaeological Unit, 1999 192 ‘A supplement to Corpus of Early Christian Inscribed Stones of South-West Britain’ 218 by Elisabaeth Okasha: some comments, a correction and an addition CHARLES THOMAS Navigational considerations of pre-medieval trade between Cornwall and Brittany: 228 a reply to Mr P R Davis R G WINSLADE Obituary 231 Henry Leslie Douch HENDHYSCANS KERNOW 127053 - Front/Back Cover 26/10/04 3:18 pm Page 2 COVER: Leaded bronze enamelled bow brooch from Nornour, Isles of Scilly. Drawing: Judith Dobie, THE SOCIETY’S AREA CORRESPONDENTS 2000 and 2001 English Heritage. PENWITH Ms A. Hathway, Caer Bran Farm, Higher Grumbia, Sancreed, Penzance. Tel: (01736) 786124 Cornwall Archaeological Society 2000 and 2001 KERRIER Mrs S. Ealey, Roaring Stile, Lanarth, St Keverne, Helston. Tel: (01326) 280130 and Mr David Todd, Trezise, St Martin, Helston. Tel: (01326) 231584 President Mr M. Tangye, Penolva, Trefusis Terrace, Redruth. Tel: (01209) 214016 Nicholas Thomas, MA, FSA, SMA CARRICK Mr H. L. Douch, 2 Enys Road, Truro. Tel: (01872) 272120 and Mrs V. Beeman, Lower Goongilling, Polwheveral, Constantine, Falmouth. Tel: (01326) 341164 RESTORMEL Mr S. V. Hebdige, 14 Bay View Terrace, Newquay, Tel: (01637) 874216 Past President Mrs V. Jacob, 5 Cannis Road, Tregonissey, St Austell. Tel: (01726) 73110 Peter Gathercole, MA, Dip. Archaeol NORTH CORNWALL Rev F. B. J. Coombes, 5 Valley View, Bodmin. Tel: (01208) 73036 Mr R. M. Heard, 4 The Square, Kilkhampton, Bude. Tel: (01288) 882294 Vice-Presidents CARADON Miss M. A. Morris, Clover Cottage, St Ive, Liskeard. Tel: (01579) 83157 M. Fletcher MIFA, MAAIS Mr G. F. Walford, 92 Sunnybanks, Hatt, Saltash, Tel: (01752) 842730 Mrs C. Gaskell-Brown MA, AMA, FSA, FRSA SCILLY Mr F. S. Ottery, 2 Porthcressa Terrace, Hugh Town, St Mary’s. Miss D. G. Harris MA Tel: (01720) 422638 Professor A. C. Thomas CBE, DL, DLitt, FBA, FSA, FRHistS SPECIALISTS (CROSSES) Mr A. Langdon, 34 Dobbs Lane, Truro. Tel: (01872) 774282 SPECIALISTS (FLINTS) Mr N. Wright, Coombe Cottage, Tregood Hill, St Martins-by-Looe. Tel: (01503) 263704 Hon Secretary Ms I. Wood Publications Sub-committee 2000–1 Hon Treasurer Ex-Officio: President, Editors Miss U. M. Davey, 8 Dunheved Road, Saltash PL12 4BW Convenor: Editors Appointed: Miss M. Y. Morgan, Mrs H. Quinnell, H. L. Douch, N. D. Johnson Hon Editors (current) Cornish Archaeology: P. Herring and G. Kirkham, Historic Environment Service, Kennall Building, Old Executive Sub-committee 2000–1 County Hall, Station Road, Truro, TR1 3EX Ex-Officio: President, Vice-Presidents, Secretary, Treasurer Newsletter: H. L. Douch BA (now, 2004, Konstanze Rahn, 13 Beach Road, Porthtowan, Truro TR4 8AA) Convenor: Any one of the above Appointed: N. D. Johnson, Mrs H. Quinnell General Committee (for both years unless otherwise stated) Ex-Officio: President, Past President, Vice-Presidents, Secretary, Treasurer, Editors, Membership Secretary Historic Towns and Buildings Sub-committee 2000–1 Elected: Mrs M. O. Avent, A. Blackman, Mrs D. Cudlipp, Mrs S. Ealey, Mrs V. Jacob (1999), Ex-Officio: President, Secretary, Treasurer Rev. F. B. J. Coombes, H. L. Douch, S. Hartgroves, N. D. Johnson (2000), Mrs P. Lee, Convenor: Any one of the above Mrs H. Quinnell, N. V. Quinnell (2000), P. Rose, Mrs T. M. Rowe, Miss B. Tripp, Ms A. Tyacke Co-opted: A. Langdon, Ms J. Wood Projects Sub-committee 2000–1 Ex-Officio: President, Secretary, Treasurer MEMBERSHIP OF THE SOCIETY is open to all interested in the history and material culture of Cornwall Appointed: M. O. Avent, T. Blackman, Mrs S. Ealey, Mrs V. Jacob, H. L. Douch, and the Isles of Scilly (persons under 14 being admitted at the discretion of the General Committee). The S. Hartgroves, Mr A. Jones, Mrs P. Lee, Mrs H. Quinnell, P. Rose, Mrs T. M. AGM usually takes place in the Spring. Enquiries about membership should be sent to: Mrs J. Beale Rowe, Ms A. Tyacke, Ms J. Wood (Membership Secretary), 16 Cross Street, Padstow, Cornwall PL28 8AT. Requests for any of the Society’s publications should be sent to Miss M. Y. Morgan, 26 Park View, Truro TR1 2BW The Publications Sub-committee is authorised by the Society’s 1961 constitution and is responsible to the General Committee and to the Annual General Meeting for all matters concerned with the Society’s journal and other publications. The various sub-committees CONTRIBUTIONS to Cornish Archaeology or the Newsletter should be sent to the relevant Editors have been appointed by the General Committee to assume responsibility for different aspects of the Society’s work in Cornwall and PRICE of this volume to non-members: £18 Scilly. CORNISH ARCHAEOLOGY 39–40 2000–1 EDITORS PETER HERRING AND GRAEME KIRKHAM (Issued 2004) CORNWALL ARCHAEOLOGICAL SOCIETY © COPYRIGHT CORNWALL ARCHAEOLOGICAL SOCIETY 2004 No part of this volume may be reproduced without permission of the Society and the relevant author ISSN 0070 024X Typesetting, printing and binding by J.W. Arrowsmith Ltd, Bristol Contents Editorial Roman Nornour, Isles of Scilly: a reconsideration 5 SARNIA BUTCHER with R D PENHALLURICK and D F WILLIAMS The excavation of a multi-period site at Stencoose, Cornwall 45 ANDY M JONES with HENRIETTA QUINNELL, DR ROGER TAYLOR, CARL THORPE, ANNA LAWSON JONES, VANESSA STRAKER and DOMINIQUE DE MOULINS Shadows in the imagination: encounters with caves in Cornwall 95 PETER ROSE Time Team at Boleigh fogou, St Buryan 129 ANDREW YOUNG Recording ancient environments at De Lank, St Breward, Cornwall 146 ANDY M JONES and HEATHER M TINSLEY Discoveries along the St Newlyn East to Mitchell pipeline 161 ANDY M JONES and SEAN TAYLOR Flint finds from Clicker Tor, Menheniot 167 G F WALFORD Recent work by the Cornwall Archaeological Unit, 1998 172 Recent work by the Cornwall Archaeological Unit, 1999 192 ‘A supplement to Corpus of Early Christian Inscribed Stones of South-West Britain’ 218 by Elisabaeth Okasha: some comments, a correction and an addition CHARLES THOMAS Navigational considerations of pre-medieval trade between Cornwall and Brittany: 228 a reply to Mr P R Davis R G WINSLADE Obituary 231 Henry Leslie Douch Editorial This enlarged volume is the second double number of Cornish Archaeology, again bringing the journal closer to once more being published and distributed to members in the year which appears on the cover. It is the editors’ hope and intention that this can be accomplished before the end of 2005. The volume also marks the end of the journal’s fourth decade of publication and, as before, an index will be produced to cover the last ten numbers (31–40). This will be published separately and distributed to members as soon as available. Finally, the present editors would like to record their grateful thanks to former editor Peter Gathercole for his help, advice and encouragement in the preparation of the present volume. Cornish Archaeology 39–40, 2000–1 Roman Nornour, Isles of Scilly: a reconsideration with a catalogue of Roman finds from the 1969–73 excavations SARNIA BUTCHER, with contributions by R D PENHALLURICK and D F WILLIAMS Summary The nature of the occupation of Nornour in the Roman period is discussed and the finds reviewed in the light of work done since their first publication in Dudley 1968. There are detailed reports on the Roman-period finds from the later excavations and a catalogue of all coins from the site by Roger Penhallurick. Introduction In 1962 some surprising discoveries were made on the remote islet of Nornour, one of the uninhabited Eastern Islands which lie between St Mary’s and St Martin’s on the eastern edge of the Isles of Scilly (Figs 1 and 2; SV 944 148). A large number of Roman brooches were found in and around a group of stone buildings of prehistoric appearance. Subsequent excavations showed that the buildings were part of a settlement originating in the Bronze Age and occupied through the Iron Age, but with very little evidence for domestic occupation in the Roman period. The site had been exposed by high seas during a gale in March 1962 and, as it was vulnerable to further destruction, the Inspectorate of Ancient Monuments funded excavations. These were directed from 1962–66 by Dorothy Dudley (Dudley 1968, with a catalogue of the brooches by M R Hull). In 1969 the sea exposed further buildings which were excavated by the present writer from 1969–73. A report on the prehistoric buildings and finds was published (Butcher 1978) but, since the Roman- period brooch finds were from recent deposits and were of similar types to those published in the first report, it was decided to relate the whole collection to further work being undertaken on Roman brooches in general (Bayley and Butcher 2004). A full re-appraisal of the Nornour brooches based on this work will appear in a forthcoming volume of Cornish Archaeology.