Pikionis, Lewerentz, Venezia Y Siza. La Experiencia Como Narración En Ocho Itinerarios
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
UNIVERSIDAD POLITÉCNICA DE MADRID ESCUELA TÉCNICA SUPERIOR DE ARQUITECTURA DE MADRID Pikionis, Lewerentz, Venezia y Siza. La experiencia como narración en ocho itinerarios Pikionis, Lewerentz, Venezia and Siza. The narrative experience in eight itineraries. Tesis Doctoral ZHANG YINGLE. ARQUITECTO 2019 Departamento de Proyectos Arquitectónicos Escuela Técnica Superior de Arquitectura de Madrid Pikionis, Lewerentz, Venezia y Siza. La experiencia como narración en ocho itinerarios. Pikionis, Lewerentz, Venezia and Siza. The narrative experience in eight itineraries. Zhang Yingle. Arquitecto Director: Jesús Ulargui Agurruza. Doctor Arquitecto 2019 D.12 Tribunal nombrado por el Mgfco. Y Excmo. Sr. Rector de la Universidad Politécnica de Madrid, el día Presidente D. Vocal D. Vocal D. Vocal D. Secretario D. Realizado el acto de defensa y lectura de Tesis el día en la Escuela Técnica Superior de Arquitectura de Madrid Calificación: EL PRESIDENTE LOS VOCALES EL SECRETARIO INDICE i ii Resumen . / Abstract . xi Introduction . WITHIN MEMORY . 1 Chapter I . PAVING TO THE ANCIENT SACREDNESS . 16 Dimitris Pikionis, pathways towards the Acropolis and the Philopappou Hill I. A SENTIMENTAL LOOK OF “GREEKNESS” . 19 III. A LAYERED APPROACH . 57 . “a man of the east” . 19 61 . Continuity through an intense transit § § From architecture to a diverging journey . 62 . “from the soil of the earth” . 22 61 . truncation in the experience . “architecture on the road” . 62 an ephemeral encounter . pave a metaphorical landscape . 68 . landscaping the Acropolis . 27 67 . 71 . a manifestation of distance . the loop that deviates . 72 • § Epilogue - . 75 journey of expectation II. COMPOSE A RITUAL TRANSIT . 35 • 39 . Through a choreographed order § § Into the constructed landscape . 40 39 . presentation of the ruin . configure a straightforward ascent . 40 IV. AN UNFOLDING JOURNEY TO THE SACREDNESS . 79 43 . manifesto of the entry . approximation to a privileged plot . 44 81 . The convergence of opposing flows § § Through an abandoned trajectory . 82 47 . pave a “mininature” . the stepped perimeter . 48 § Epilogue - . 87 § Epilogue - . 53 to create another rituality synthesis of the pavement • • V. CONCLUSION - THE DEVOTED ANACHRONISM . 89 iii iv Chapter II. LANDSCAPE OF REMEMBERANCE . 94 Sigurd Lewerentz, the ceremonial routes in Stockholm and Malmö I. AGAINST THE CRISIS OF THANATOLOGY . 97 III. LANDSCAPE AS MONUMENT . 131 i. Displacement of the cemetery . 97 135 . Two sets of narrtive actions § § Landscape of the interior . 136 - from interpretation to illusion 135 . The landscape of remoteness. the descent that detains . 136 . the last landscape . 99 145 . the Way of the Cross - . an anonymous monument . 146 . myth in the modern cities . 103 articulation and deflection d 142 . ascent through excavation . way of reture . 141 . crisis in “the other city” . 101 § Epilogue - . 151 ii. Sigurd Lewerentz, revive the landscape for commemoration. 104 ascent, descent towards farewell • • II. THE SUBLIME LANDSCAPE . 109 IV. A WALK TO THE PLACE OF REMEMBERANCE . 153 . Tallum, a new burial place . 109 155 . Towards the Chapel of Resurrection § § Towards the Twin Chapels . 156 . Ås, retrace the original reality . 112 155 . into the woods . the parallel journeys . 156 161 . the constructional differences . transmit through tectonic approach . 162 115 . Sequential detachment § § Sentimental functionality . 116 115 . a dialectic unity beyond the boundary . architecture as monument of burial . 116 § Epilogue - . 167 123 . transit upon distance . a room of isolation . 124 the paradoxical continuity and material basis for a transit § Epilogue - . 129 • a walk through departure V. CONCLUSION - A PROGRESSIVE APPROXIMATION . 171 • v vi Chapter III. THE ROOTING OF DETACHMENT . 176 Francesco Venezia, the anomalous monuments in Belice I. REDEEM FROM EXCLUSION . 179 IV. “IN FORMA ELICOIDALE” : MOVEMENT THROUGH SENSATIONS . 227 231 . A private journey § § Towards the infinite . 232 • 231 . a round trip . exchange of relationships . 232 II. TOWARDS AN AUTHENTIC SITE . 185 235 . “reposo” . the loop . 236 239 . a garden of isolation . the circulation that withdraws . 238 189 . From the underground § § A Theatre of transit . 190 189 . multiple detachment . the construction of cannibalism . 190 § Epilogue - . 241 monument for walk: from the solitary to the collective 195 . into the subterranean . confronting the horizon . 196 • § Epilogue - . 201 excavation as method V. CONCLUSION - . 245 MELACHOLY, RETROSPECTION AND PERMANENCE • III. CRITICAL SUPERIMPOSITION . 203 207 . Space for intervention: a work of motage § § The inconsistent structure . 208 207 . delivery of views . where those events converge . 208 213 . a hybrid frontal . the walk provoked by distortion . 212 217 . the movement of transgression . the will to connect . 216 § Epilogue - . 223 against exhaustibility • vii viii Chapter IV. THE PROVISIONAL VISUALIZATION . 252 Álvaro Siza, ephemeral images on the paths in Santiago de Compostela and Porto I. THE SIGHT INSIDE THE OTHER: SKETCH AND ARCHITECTURE . 255 III. UNITING THE DETACHED . 297 § The stratification of representation . 255 303 . The conceptual unity § § Through the absense . 304 . the site . 255 305 . bringing together the disparate . the Orchard . 306 . architecture . 258 309 . the inflected responds . the Grove . 310 . the human figure . 259 313 . until the extinction of details . the Cemetery . 314 . the mirror . 262 § Epilogue - . 321 § Epilogue - A fragile invitation . 264 appreciate the accidents § Two works . 265 • • I V. CONCLUSION - CONDITIONAL UN/CONTINUITY . 323 II. CONFIGURE ANOTHER REALITY . 271 • 275 . Critical combination § § Rediscovery of the order . 276 275 . the paradoxial syncretism . reconsidering the limits . 276 General Conclusion . 330 279 . accidental simultaneity . configure the duality . 280 285 . two entryways . a progressive approach . 286 Bibliography . 340 § Epilogue - . 293 an attentive reading of realities • ix ACKNOWLEDGEMENT I have been treasured my identity as a stranger and an outsider in Spain and Europe during the seven years of living, studying and growing in Madrid and in ETSAM. To some extent it obligates me to keep a distance with what I see, hear and learn; and convinces me to accept the truth that I may never understand something what others can, just like I may find something that others can’t. This nomadic perception of “I”, of the context, of the things I learn and write, is such a foundation, a motivation and support that keep accompanying me to start and to finish this investigation. I write this thesis which in turn portrays me. I think it is the essential meaning of every research work, always ending up with a reflection of ourselves. After these years, now it is a difficult time to recall all the names I should appreciate. But I have to remember professor José Ignacio Linazasoro, since this work is due in large part to his suggestive seminar on the silent European architects of 20th century. This course inspired my thesis of Master degree on the pathways around the Acropolis by Dimitris Pikionis, which later serves as the first chapter of the doctoral dissertation. Thanks to my friends and to the professors in Spain and China, who contributed with their advices to the progress of this thesis. Especially to professor José Manuel López Peláez, whose erudition, encouragement and generous help have facilitated the chapter of Sigurd Lewerentz. To professor Luis Martínez Santa-María, his impressive work Tierra Espaciada. El árbol, el camino, el estanque: ante la casa. shows me how to perceive and think, opening the door of this writing. To Jesús Ulargui Agurruza, with his intelligence, passion and kindness sets great examples of an architect who designs, of a professor who teaches, of a tutor who guides, and of a friend whom talk with. To Qirui, thanks to her patience, suggestions, understanding, and above all, her accompany. Finally, I dedicate this book to my parents, their legacy, their endless love and selfless dedication give me the courage to face and enjoy the life. xi xii RESUMEN ABSTRACT Este trabajo de investigación recorre ocho obras de cuatro arquitectos europeos, Dimitris This investigation retraces eight works by four European architects, Dimitris Pikionis, Pikionis, Sigurd Lewerentz, Francesco Venezia y Álvaro Siza, estableciendo análisis Sigurd Lewerentz, Francesco Venezia and Álvaro Siza, establishing analysis and y reflexiones sobre cómo las herramientas de la arquitectura son capaces de articular reflections on the mechanisms that architects have applied to make architecture capable la experiencia temporal que acompaña al visitante. Esa experiencia sobre el tiempo no of articulating temporal experience that accompanies the visitor. This experience of solo incluye la del propio recorrido que acontece en la visita, sino que se amplia en cada time not only includes that acquired during the promenade of the visit, but also expands uno de los ejemplos elegidos hacia una expresión temporal que relaciona la obra con su in each of the selected projects and constitutes temporary narrative that relates the significado. work to its meaning. Las herramientas de trabajo de estos arquitectos varían de acuerdo a las ideas que The research tools vary according to the ideas that the works intend to show. In the pretenden mostrarnos. En los accesos a la Acropolis y Filipappou, los pavimentos accesses to the Acropolis and the Philopappou hill, pavements are able to tell the son capaces de narrarnos mediante sus articulaciones