A Note on Disability Issues in the Middle East and North Africa
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
37275 Public Disclosure Authorized A NOTE ON DISABILITY ISSUES IN THE MIDDLE EAST AND NORTH AFRICA Public Disclosure Authorized Final June 30, 2005 Public Disclosure Authorized Human Development Department Middle East and North Africa Region Document of the World Bank Public Disclosure Authorized ACRONYMS CBR Community Based Rehabilitation CDD Community Driven Development DF Disability Fund DPO Disabled Person’s Organization EMICS Egypt’s Multiple Indicator Cluster Survey ESCWA Economic and Social Commission for Western Asia ESW Economic Sector Work GDP Gross Domestic Product ICD International Classification of Diseases ICPC International Classification of Primary Care ICR Implementation Completion Report ICT Information and Communication Technology IE Inclusive Education JSL Jordanian Sign Language KG Kindergarten MENA Middle East and North Africa MNSHD Middle East and North Africa Human Development MoE Ministry of Education MoH Ministry of Health MoSA Ministry of Social Affairs MoSAL Ministry of Social Affairs and Labor MoSD Ministry of Social Development NCFA National Council of Family Affairs NDC National Demographic Committee NGO Non-Governmental Organization NPS National Poverty Survey OECD Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development OPAC Online Public Access Catalogue PAD Project Appraisal Document PCBS Palestinian Central Bureau of Statistics PNGO Palestinian NGO PRCS Palestinian Red Crescent Society PTSD Post Traumatic Stress Disorder PWD Persons with Disabilities SPIP Social Protection Initiative Project SWF Social Welfare Fund TA Technical Assistance UNICEF United Nations Children’s Fund UNESCO United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization UNRWA United Nation Relief and Work Organization UNSO United Nations Statistics Office VT Vocational Training WB World Bank WHO World Health Organization YSFD Yemen Social Fund for Development Vice President: Christiaan Poortman Sector Director: Michal Rutkowski Sector Manager: Akiko Maeda Team Leader: Guillermo Hakim ii TABLE OF CONTENTS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY...................................................................................................................... I I. INTRODUCTION..........................................................................................................1 II. PREVALENCE OF DISABILITIES IN THE MENA REGION ..............................2 III. ECONOMIC AND SOCIAL CONSEQUENCES OF DISABILITY........................5 IV. MAIN CAUSES OF DISABILITIES IN MENA ......................................................10 V. ADDRESSING DISABILITIES .................................................................................16 A. PROMOTING AN INCLUSIVE ENVIRONMENT...................................................................16 B. PROMOTING INCLUSIVE EDUCATION .............................................................................18 C. PREVENTION STRATEGIES..............................................................................................19 D. INTEGRATED REHABILITATION AND COMMUNITY-BASED SERVICES ...........................22 E. SOCIAL PROTECTION FOR DISABLED PERSONS..............................................................23 F. PUBLIC AND PRIVATE PARTNERSHIP .............................................................................23 VI. CONCLUSIONS ..........................................................................................................26 A. WORLD BANK POLICIES ON DISABILITY........................................................................26 B. NEXT STEPS....................................................................................................................27 Annex A: Disability-Related Legislation from Selected MENA Countries........................................29 Annex B: Examples of World Bank Projects in the MENA Region with Disability Components.....31 Annex C: Proposed Policy Framework Based on Egypt Social Protection Initiatives Project............34 Annex D: MENA Country Profiles on Disabilities ..............................................................................38 Annex E: EU Disability Assessments: A Comparative Analysis .........................................................43 Annex F: EU Quotas for Disabled Workers .........................................................................................53 Annex G: Employment Rates of People with Disabilities in Europe and USA ...................................55 Annex H: Disability Benefit and Retirement Benefits in the U.S. and EU Countries..........................56 iii FIGURES Figure 1: Disability - Poverty Cycle I – How Persons with Disability are More Likely to Become Poor ........................................................................................................6 Figure 2: Disability - Poverty Cycle II - How the Poor are More Likely to Risk Becoming Disabled .......................................................................................................................6 Figure 3 Main Causes of Work Disabilities in Developed Countries ........................................................11 Figure 4 Estimated Rate of Work-Related Fatal Accident Per 100,000 Workers......................................12 Figure 5: Fatalities Attributed to Work – Global Trends ............................................................................13 Figure 6: Trends in Fatality Rates Due to Traffic Injuries ..........................................................................14 TABLES Table 1 Disabled Population, Selected MENA Countries.............................................................................4 iv Acknowledgements This Report was prepared by Guillermo Hakim, Sr. Economist, and Nedim Jaganjac, Disability and Public Health Specialist, with assistance from Joshua Beal (ECSHD) on the annexes. It was peer reviewed by Mr. Daniel M. Mont, Economist (HDNSP); Mr. Mohammad Kamel Loutfy, Junior Professional Associate, HDNSP; and Ms. Jeanine Braithwaite, Sr. Economist (ECSHD). The report benefited from a report of disability consultants Manal Hamzeh Al Smadi and Karen Saba prepared in 2004. An early draft of this report was reviewed and discussed among the participants at the session on Disability during the Middle East and North Africa Regional Conference on Urban Children and Youth: Addressing Priorities in Education, which took place in Dubai on May 16-18, 2005. The authors benefited greatly from contributions by the members of the MENA Disability Working Group at the World Bank chaired by Eileen Sullivan and Arun Joshi. The authors are especially grateful to Ms. Judith Heumann, Advisor on Disability and Development (HDNSP), for her continual support, and who engaged the Dubai Conference participants on this topic and provided their feedback on the report to the team. v EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Disability, as a development theme, cuts across key mission and corporate goals of the World Bank, including poverty reduction, economic growth, and reaching the Millennium Development Goals by 2015. Without ensuring social inclusion and involving disabled people in every aspect of social life, it is unlikely that all the Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) will be met. Poverty and disability are inextricably linked and form a vicious cycle1. Poverty can contribute to increases in disabilities among individuals from birth to old age. After the onset of a disability, barriers to health and rehabilitation services, education, employment, and other aspects of economic and social life can trap individuals in a life-long cycle of poverty2. If current policies, practices, and perceptions related to individuals with disabilities, coupled with conditions associated with enduring poverty and socio-economic disruptions, remain, the already high burden of disability on the development of countries in the MENA region will increase over the next two decades. This Note examines disability in the MENA region with respect to prevalence and main causes of disability, economic and social consequences of disabilities, prevention and risk mitigation mechanisms, and policies and strategies to create the enabling environment which permits persons with disabilities full participation in society, including access to education and labor force, and participation in decision making. Its purpose is to take stock of our current knowledge of disability issues in the region, and to open the door to new ideas and initiatives that will help mainstream disability as a theme across sectors. The report has several main messages. Disability has significant implications for social and economic development in MENA. Excluding individuals with disabilities from social and economic activities will have negative consequences not only on the individuals concerned, but on their families and community. The integration and accommodation of persons with disabilities into the labor market are important ways to reduce both public expenditures and costs borne by families, as well as to ensure the participation of disabled persons in productive work. Formulating policies and plans to integrate individuals with disabilities into all aspects of social and economic life, including education, vocational rehabilitation and employment, will benefit not only the individual, but the society in general. Gender issues among persons with disabilities also require special attention. Main causes of disability. High rates of birth related disabilities and consanguinity, communicable and chronic diseases, weak access to and availability