DOCSLIB.ORG

Towards an Ethics of the Poetic Spirit with the Poetry of Francis Webb

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Towards an Ethics of the Poetic Spirit with the Poetry of Francis Webb THE COMMUNITY OF THE POEM Towards an Ethics of the Poetic Spirit With the poetry of Francis Webb Christopher John Wareham Bachelor of Architecture (1980) Advanced-Diploma Library/Information Services (2009) Submitted in fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy (Philosophy) University of Tasmania May 2013 Declaration of Originality This thesis contains no material which has been accepted for a degree or diploma by the University or any other institution, except by way of background information and duly acknowledged in the thesis, and to the best of my knowledge and belief no material previously published or written by another person except where due acknowledgement is made in the text of the thesis, nor does the thesis contain any material that infringes copyright. Signed: Date: 25/06/2013 (Christopher John Wareham) This thesis may be made available for loan and limited copying and communication in accordance with the Copyright Act 1968. Signed: Date: 25/06/2013 (Christopher John Wareham) Abstract There is an ancient antagonism of philosophy towards poetry from the time of Plato that still casts its shadow over philosophical practice. In terms of the univocal standard in philosophy’s critical discourse, poetry appears vague, ambiguous and uninformative with little or no epistemological value. Because a poem’s genesis is thought to be irrational and its claims nonsensical, philosophy devalues poetic inspiration and ignores the truth to be garnered from it. Contrary to these attitudes much in poetry is of considerable relevance to the philosophical program. It is necessary to redress the imbalance caused by the unilateral dominance of critical discourse and its hermeneutic assumptions in philosophy. This thesis undertakes a re-assessment of poetry by returning it to its proper hermeneutic and existential milieu, in turn promoting a deeper appreciation of philosophical possibility from the re-introduction of poetic discourse into philosophical enquiry. Employing cross-between a Hegelian and Kierkegaardian dialectical method, this thesis situates insights gained from literary critical theory into the context of Existentialist and Personalist philosophy. Kierkegaard’s dialectic has proved an appropriate methodology for a philosophy of poetry and poetic experience in its ability to rigorously maintain the tension between negatives and in its organic development of transcendent dialectical stages of increasing explanatory power, without the necessity required by Hegel. However, as Hegel said, truth is expressed in the whole, not merely encapsulated in its end product. A parallel discursive stream critically analyses poetry by Australian poet Francis Webb to complement and ground the philosophy in an authentic poetic voice. The consequent integrated structure fashions a negative mould making possible a further dialectical act in outlining an ethics of the poetic spirit in the thesis conclusion. 1 Table of Contents Abstract ...................................................................................................................... 1 A dialectic of the poetic spirit .................................................................................... 6 The ancient quarrel ......................................................................................... 8 Rationalism and poetry ................................................................................... 13 Hegel’s dialectic ............................................................................................. 19 Kierkegaard’s dialectic ................................................................................... 26 The dialectic as method and theory ................................................................ 44 Theory Chapter contents ................................................................................ 50 The case study: Francis Webb ........................................................................ 53 Case Study Chapter contents .......................................................................... 60 Acknowledgements ........................................................................................ 63 On incompleteness: the indeterminacy of poetic metaphor ....................................... 65 The question of poetic metaphor .................................................................... 66 The self-focusing message ............................................................................. 72 The paradox of poetic metaphor ..................................................................... 81 Gödelian Incompleteness ............................................................................... 84 Incompleteness in Royce’s philosophy .......................................................... 87 Derrida and the undecidability of writing ...................................................... 89 Poetic Incompleteness .................................................................................... 97 A Drum for Ben Boyd ................................................................................................ 102 The “drum” as metaphor ................................................................................ 103 The hero and his critics .................................................................................. 107 Identity and despair ........................................................................................ 114 Power and alienation ...................................................................................... 119 The death of Boyd .......................................................................................... 125 On mystery: poetic being and the meaningful ........................................................... 135 Beauty and the meaningful ............................................................................. 136 The mystery of mystery .................................................................................. 139 Mystery in poetry ........................................................................................... 141 Paul Ricoeur on poetic metaphor ................................................................... 144 The Riddle of the Sphinx ............................................................................... 149 Poetry and thinking being .............................................................................. 154 The withdrawal of mystery ............................................................................ 156 The pointing icon ........................................................................................... 158 Paradox and the relative breach ..................................................................... 160 Revelation in poetry ....................................................................................... 164 Leichhardt in Theatre ................................................................................................. 167 Tropes of display ............................................................................................ 168 The dark pantomime ....................................................................................... 175 Tragedy and the death of Gilbert .................................................................... 180 Lampooning the hero ..................................................................................... 183 Solitude and despair ....................................................................................... 185 The spiritual dimension of oblivion ............................................................... 189 Epilogue in the wasteland .............................................................................. 192 On enrichment: the quest for authenticity .................................................................. 196 2 Entanglement and engagement ....................................................................... 199 The nature of claiming ................................................................................... 203 Contemplation and ingatheredness ................................................................. 207 Possibility and necessity ................................................................................. 210 Enrichment and grace ..................................................................................... 215 The Canticle ............................................................................................................... 218 Aesthete and saint ........................................................................................... 219 Invidia: the envy of the Leper ........................................................................ 223 Avarita: the greed of the Father ...................................................................... 228 Gula: the gluttony of the Wolf of Gubbio ...................................................... 234 Luxuria: the lechery of the Jongleur .............................................................. 238 Acedia: the despair of the Serf ....................................................................... 244 Superba: the pride of the Knight .................................................................... 247 Ira: the wrath of Brother Ass .......................................................................... 251 The poetry of redemption ............................................................................... 254 On affirmation: bearing witness
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Title 30. Husband and Wife Chapter 1 Marriage
    Utah Code Title 30. Husband and Wife Chapter 1 Marriage 30-1-1 Incestuous marriages void. (1) The following marriages are incestuous and void from the beginning, whether the relationship is legitimate or illegitimate: (a) marriages between parents and children; (b) marriages between ancestors and descendants of every degree; (c) marriages between siblings of the half as well as the whole blood; (d) marriages between: (i) uncles and nieces or nephews; or (ii) aunts and nieces or nephews; (e) marriages between first cousins, except as provided in Subsection (2); or (f) marriages between any individuals related to each other within and not including the fifth degree of consanguinity computed according to the rules of the civil law, except as provided in Subsection (2). (2) First cousins may marry under the following circumstances: (a) both parties are 65 years of age or older; or (b) if both parties are 55 years of age or older, upon a finding by the district court, located in the district in which either party resides, that either party is unable to reproduce. Amended by Chapter 317, 2019 General Session 30-1-2 Marriages prohibited and void. (1) The following marriages are prohibited and declared void: (a) when there is a spouse living, from whom the individual marrying has not been divorced; (b) except as provided in Subsection (2), when an applicant is under 18 years old; and (c) between a divorced individual and any individual other than the one from whom the divorce was secured until the divorce decree becomes absolute, and, if an appeal is taken, until after the affirmance of the decree.
    [Show full text]
  • PUBLISHED VERSION Nicholas Jose Geoffrey Dutton
    PUBLISHED VERSION Nicholas Jose Geoffrey Dutton: little Adelaide and New York Nowhere Adelaide: a literary city, 2013 / Buttress, P. (ed./s), Ch.10, pp.183-198 © 2013 The Authors This work, with the exception of the poem, New York Nowhere: Meditations and Celebrations, Neurology Ward, The New York Hospital by Geoffrey Dutton, is licenced under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0) License. Published version https://doi.org/10.20851/adelaide-literary-10a PERMISSIONS http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ 14 December 2017 http://hdl.handle.net/2440/88615 Geoffrey Dutton: Little 10 Adelaide and New York 1 Nowhere 16 Nicholas Jose It ought to be impossible to talk about literary Adelaide without due mention of Geoffrey Dutton (1922-98). As a prime mover of Writers' Week and the Adelaide Festival of Arts, and founding co-editor of Australian Letters (1957–68) and Australian Book Review (1961- ), both magazines based in Adelaide, Dutton was central to the city's post-war cultural initiatives. He was associated with the University of Adelaide, where he studied for a year before enlisting (another magazine, Angry Penguins, appeared controversially there that same year, 1940) and later taught. He was one of the English Department's lively cohort of writers and scholars who were enthusiastic about Australian and other 'new' literatures. From Adelaide, Dutton played important national roles too, as editor at the newly formed Penguin Australia, co-founder of Sun Books, publisher at Macmillan and editor of the Bulletin's literary supplement. He served on 1 I am grateful to Tisi Dutton, Robin Lucas and John Thompson for help with this essay, and to Cheryl Hoskin, Special Collections Librarian, Barr Smith Library, the University of Adelaide.
    [Show full text]
  • Fletcher Class – Supplemental Tribal Law Materials Williams V. Lee
    Fletcher Class – Supplemental Tribal Law Materials Williams v. Lee Notes 1. Professor Wilkinson described the historical context of this landmark decision as follows: The rendering of the Williams decision can fairly be set as a watershed for several reasons. For decades before, Indian law decisions had been rendered fitfully by the Supreme Court. The tribes and the federal government instituted few cases to establish or expand tribal powers. Most of the litigation to reach the Court during the twentieth century before 1959 arose out of disputes involving individual Indians or even non- Indians; as a result the decisions lacked the public law overtones of either the modern era or the nineteenth century. * * * After Williams, the pace of decisions began to accelerate, with the result that the Court has become more active in Indian law than in fields such as securities, bankruptcy, pollution control and international law. Wilkinson, American Indians, Time and the Law, supra, at 1–2. 2. Justice Black cites the "courageous and eloquent" opinion of Chief Justice Marshall in Worcester as the source of the "basic policy" informing the infringement test announced by the Court in Williams: "Absent governing acts of Congress, the question has always been whether the state action infringed on the right of reservation Indians to make their own laws and be ruled by them." Did Williams depart from the basic legal analysis of tribal jurisdiction in Worcester? How would you state the Williams approach if you were an advocate asserting state jurisdiction over reservation Indians? If you were a tribal judge asserting exclusive tribal court civil adjudicatory jurisdiction over a non-Indian on the reservation? 3.
    [Show full text]
  • Order of Celebrating Matrimony Preparation and Policies
    ORDER OF CELEBRATING MATRIMONY PREPARATION AND POLICIES FOR CORPUS CHRISTI UNIVERSITY PARISH TOLEDO, OHIO Short-term preparations for marriage tend to be concentrated on invitations, clothes, the party and any number of other details that tend to drain not only the budget but energy and joy as well. The spouses come to the wedding ceremony exhausted and harried, rather than focused and ready for the great step that they are about to take. Here let me say a word to fiancés. Have the courage to be different. Don’t let yourselves get swallowed up by a society of consumption and empty appearances. What is important is the love you share, strengthened and sanctified by grace. You are capable of opting for a more modest and simple celebration in which love takes precedence over everything else. Pope Francis, Amoris Laetitia #212 Congratulations on your upcoming marriage. Marriage is a serious and sacred commitment. Through it, husband and wife are called on to draw closer to God and to each other in a life-giving community of love. Christ enhanced the dignity of marriage by making the Christian marriage relationship a Sacrament - a living expression of His love for us. Marriage is also a great and marvelous adventure. It is an understanding that holds the promise of joyful years together. People enter marriage with high hopes of a beautiful future together. It is this atmosphere that brings out the best qualities of each person in marriage. Today, more than during the immediate past, the Church has a grave responsibility to help our people enter into a marriage that gives promise of being grace-filled, happy and successful.
    [Show full text]
  • DISPENSATION and ECONOMY in the Law Governing the Church Of
    DISPENSATION AND ECONOMY in the law governing the Church of England William Adam Dissertation submitted in part fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy of the University of Wales Cardiff Law School 2009 UMI Number: U585252 All rights reserved INFORMATION TO ALL USERS The quality of this reproduction is dependent upon the quality of the copy submitted. In the unlikely event that the author did not send a complete manuscript and there are missing pages, these will be noted. Also, if material had to be removed, a note will indicate the deletion. Dissertation Publishing UMI U585252 Published by ProQuest LLC 2013. Copyright in the Dissertation held by the Author. Microform Edition © ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved. This work is protected against unauthorized copying under Title 17, United States Code. ProQuest LLC 789 East Eisenhower Parkway P.O. Box 1346 Ann Arbor, Ml 48106-1346 CONTENTS SUMMARY............................................................................................................................................................IV ACKNOWLEDGMENTS..................................................................................................................................VI ABBREVIATIONS............................................................................................................................................VII TABLE OF STATUTES AND MEASURES............................................................................................ VIII U K A c t s o f P a r l i a m e n
    [Show full text]
  • 1. GENERAL INFORMATION 1.1. Course Teacher Prof. Josip Šalković
    1. GENERAL INFORMATION Prof. Josip Šalković, PhD / 1.1. Course teacher 1.6. Year of the study programme 3 Assist. Prof. Lucija Boljat, PhD 1.2. Name of the course Canon Law 1.7. Credits (ECTS) 6 1.3. Associate teachers 1.8. Type of instruction (number of hours L + S + E + e-learning) 60 L 1.4. Study programme (undergraduate, graduate, Undergraduate 1.9. Expected enrolment in the course 40 integrated) 1.10. Level of application of e-learning (level 1, 2, 3), percentage of 1.5. Status of the course Compulsory online instruction (max. 20%) 2. COURSE DESCRIPTION To capacitate students and direct them to know, understand, comment and apply the provisions of Canon Law of the Latin Church, 2.1. Course particularly the 1983 Code of Canon Law which is inseparable from the mission of RI teachers in primary and secondary schools or objectives the mission of catechists in parish and deacon communities and finally the mission of the lay parish associate. 2.2. Course enrolment requirements and To have a fundamental knowledge of Church history, exegesis, dogma, philosophy and fundamental theology. entry competences required for the To have a fundamental knowledge of Latin. course To apply their knowledge of Canon Law in all curriculums when planning and conducting RI classes in primary and 2.3. Learning outcomes at the secondary schools; level of the programme to To apply their knowledge of Canon Law in pastoral activities with children, adolescents and adults; which the course contributes To interpret and apply Canon Law in the Church and society, in the school and in the parish community; To capacitate students to actively and properly participate in the task of evangelisation in the Church and society.
    [Show full text]
  • NULLITY of MARRIAGE
    NULLITY of MARRIAGE New Edition--Revised and Enlarged F. J. Sheed SHEED AND WARD--NEW YORK Copyright SHEED & WARD, INC., 1959 LIBRARY OF CONGRESS CATALOG CARD NUMBER 59-10656 NIHIL OBSTAT: JOHN R. READY CENSOR LIBRORUM MAY 22,1959 IMPRIMATUR: +ROBERT F. JOYCE BISHOP OF BURLINGTON MAY 28,1959 TO THE LAW SCHOOL OF THE UNIVERSITY OF SYDNEY THIS SMALL TOKEN OF GREAT GRATITUDE Preface to the Second Edition This is not a book on marriage; but only on those cases where marriage appears to be but is not. It is directly concerned with the law of the Catholic Church, but in the first edition I introduced comparisons with the law of England. I have been asked to introduce comparisons with American Law as well, because its historic connection with Church Law is considerably less than England's. As each of the fifty States has its own marriage law, and it would have been impossible to study them all, I chose that of New York. New York's Marriage Law was not taught in the Sydney University Law School in my day, as any American who chances on this book will guess. But its rules, like those of England, are stated here only in their general form, exceptions or modifications not being mentioned where they would not affect the principle. The subject of the book is Church Law. The object of the comparison is not to make civil law and Church law look as much alike as possible, in the hope that the great mass of similarity may lead to an indulgent overlooking of the points on which the Church differs; but to show her laws more clearly by noting how two other codes treat the same problems.
    [Show full text]
  • Catholic Church's Pastoral Counseling Role in Addressing
    68 African Research Journal of Education and Social Sciences, 5(2), 2018 ISSN (online): 2312-0134 | Website : www.arjess.org Catholic Church’s Pastoral Counseling Role in Addressing Domestic Violence against Women in Marriage in Muranga County, Kenya Author: Evan Njuguna Mburu Kenyatta University P.O Box 43844-00100 Nairobi – Kenya Author E-mail: [email protected] Abstract: The main purpose of this study was to examine the role of pastoral counseling by the Catholic Church in addressing domestic violence against women in marriage, in Maragua Parish, Murang’a County. Survey research design was used in this study. The main respondents of this study population were the married couples. The target population for this study was 5420 catholic church members. The sample size included 360 married couples from the parish. Random sampling procedure was used to arrive at the sample. The main research instruments used in the study was questionnaire. Quantitative data analysis procedure was used where data were analyzed and reported in frequencies and percentages and summarized using figures and tables. Quantitative analytical software, namely SPSS was used to process the data. The results showed that Catholic church played a critical role in addressing domestic violence against women in marriage through increasing confidence and self-esteem among women. The study also took into account the contribution of the male members of the society, with a call to respect women and help create coexistence in the society. This study informs the role that faith based organizations could play in addressing gender based disparities in society. Keywords: Pastoral Counselling, Catholic Church's role in Addressing Domestic Violence, Violence against women, Women in Marriage 1.0 Introduction Domestic violence has been a common problem in most families worldwide, and the problem affects both men and women.
    [Show full text]
  • Eric Irvin, Gentleman George: King of Melodrama. Brisbane: the Father
    ELIZABETH PERKINS BRIEF REVIEWS Eric Irvin, Gentleman George: King of Melodrama. Brisbane: University of Queensland Press, 1980. Cloth $14.95. 234 PP. with index. David Williamson, Travelling North. Sydney: The Currency Press, 1980. Paper $4.95. 88 pp. John Summons, Lamb of God. Theatre Australia New Writing Series. Sydney: The Currency Press, 1980. Paper $2.75. 96 pp. Louis Nowra, Visions. Sydney: The Currency Press, 1979. Paper $3.95. Sumner Locke-Elliott, Rusty Bugles. Sydney: The Currency Press, 1980. Paper $4.95. 112 pp. Three Political Plays ed. Airene Sykes. (Steve J. Spears, King Richard; Stephen Sewell, The Father We Loved on A Beach By The Sea; John Bradley, Irish Stew). Brisbane: University of Queensland Press, 1980. Cloth $17.95, paper $9.95. 156 pp. Barry Oakley, The Great God Mogadon and Other Plays. Brisbane: University of Queens- land Press, 1980. Cloth $8.95, paper $4.95. 119 pp. George Darrell is known to followers of Australian drama as the author of The Sunny South, first produced in Melbourne in 1883, and published by The Currency Press in the National Theatre series in 1975. Eric Irvin and the University of Queens- land Press have produced a handsome, well-illustrated biography of George Darrell, with useful references and an index. The Sunny South is apparently the only extant script by Darrell, and has an interest beyond its status as a competent and typical nineteenth century melodrama. Darrell came to Melbourne in 1865 at the age of twenty- three. He was then George Frederick Price, the son of an inn- keeper of Bath, already in love with everything about the theatre.
    [Show full text]
  • Chapter 1 Douglas Stewart
    CHAPTER 1 DOUGLAS STEWART: THE EARLY YEARS 1925-1938 Throughout the many scholarly works that focus on Stewart’s place in Australian literature, the word that recurs in respect of Douglas Stewart’s creative work is ‘versatile’. One of its first appearances is in Nancy Keesing’s Douglas Stewart, which begins with the precise statement: ‘Douglas Stewart is the most versatile writer in Australia today ⎯ perhaps the most versatile who ever lived in this country. He is a poet whose poetry and nature as a poet are central to everything in which he excels’.93 Stewart was not only a poet whose early philosophy that the closer one moves towards nature the closer one moves towards the spirit of the earth, developed as a line of continuity which contributed to his total philosophy; this chapter focuses on Stewart’s life and poetic ambition in New Zealand until his move to Australia as an expatriate in 1938. As a mature poet he was then concerned to apply this pantheism to modern responses regarding humans and their experiences. The purpose of the introductory part of this chapter is to clarify the theme of the dissertation ⎯ Douglas Stewart’s creative impulse; the second part involves a discussion of the poet’s visit to England where he met poets Powys and Blunden. At this time he also journeyed to his ancestral home in Scotland. Upon his return to Australia in 1938 he was offered a position with Cecil Mann at the Bulletin. Stewart was also a distinguished verse dramatist, a successful editor, particularly of the Red Page of the Bulletin from 1940 to 1960,94 and a participant of some repute in journalism and publishing.
    [Show full text]
  • Prajak Boonphao Thesis Submitted to the Faculty of Canon Law, Saint
    CANONICAL CONSIDERATIONS IN PASTORAL CARE OF PERSONS IN MARRIAGES BETWEEN ROMAN CATHOLICS AND BUDDHISTS IN THAILAND Prajak Boonphao Thesis submitted to the Faculty of Canon Law, Saint Paul University, Ottawa, Canada, in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Canon Law Faculty of Canon Law Saint Paul University, Ottawa © Prajak Boonphao, Ottawa, Canada, 2020 ii ABSTRACT Marriage is an institution based on natural law. Every person has the natural right to marriage which is, however, affected by cultural and social conditions. The pastors of the Church, therefore, have to make every effort to understand the particularity of situations within which marriage and family are lived today and respond accordingly through their pastoral action. Thailand is considered a Buddhist country due to the fact that the vast majority of its population is Buddhist. Most marriages celebrated in the Catholic Church are non- sacramental because a Buddhist is the spouse of the Catholic party. Canon 1086 of the 1983 Code states that due to the impediment of disparity of worship, a marriage between a person who was baptized in the Catholic Church or received into it and a non-baptized person is invalid. A dispensation from this impediment must be granted by the competent authority in order for the union to be valid. The conditions stated in cc. 1125–1126 must be taken into account for a dispensation to be granted. The thesis identifies the actual pastoral problems faced by persons in marriages with the disparity of worship and canonical questions faced by Church authorities; it also proposes canonical-pastoral responses to such cases.
    [Show full text]
  • Marriage DISPENSATION Request Diocese of Toledo Office of the Bishop 1933 Spielbusch Ave
    MARRIAGE DISPENSATION REQUEST Diocese of Toledo Office of the Bishop 1933 Spielbusch Ave. Toledo, Ohio 43604-5360 Date ___________________________________ 20______ Marriage Information _______________________________________ Catholic, Priest/Deacon ____________________________________ Name, if woman, maiden name residing in _____________________________________ Parish City Parish ___________________________________________ wishing to marry _______________________________________________ Address _________________________________________ Name, if woman, maiden name Denomination (if Catholic _____________________________________) City _________________________ Zip ________________ Parish City PLEASE CHECK ONE OF THE FOLLOWING: MAIL TO: Diocese of Toledo Office of the Bishop ❑ Baptized Catholic ❑ Baptized non-Catholic ❑ Non-baptized ❑ Doubtfully baptized 1933 Spielbusch Ave., Toledo, Ohio 43604-5360 PRE-NUPTIAL DECLARATION AND PROMISE (Promise must be made in every marriage involving a non-Catholic, or one who has left the church by a formal act.) By the Catholic Party: I reaffirm my faith in Jesus Christ, and with God’s help, intend to continue living that faith in the Catholic Church. At the same time I acknowledge the respect I owe to the conscience of my partner in marriage. I promise to do all that I can to share the faith I have received with our children and to make every effort that I can to have them baptized and reared as Catholics. ___________________________________________ Signature of Catholic Party ___________________________________________ ___________________________________________ Signature of Priest/Deacon City Date Dispensation Requested: ____ Dispensation from disparity of worship for a mixed marriage between a Catholic and a non-baptized person (Disparity of Cult) ____ A precautionary dispensation from disparity of worship and a permission for mixed religion for a marriage between a Catholic and a doubtfully baptized member of another Christian Church.
    [Show full text]