Books Layout 31/8

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Books Layout 31/8 book reviews The tree of ignorance Evolution emerges unscathed from the battle of creation. The Triumph of Evolution and the and as she says, “the two are essentially dis- Failure of Creationism tinct, and it was held to be dangerous to con- by Niles Eldredge fuse mythical and rational discourse”. That is Macmillan: 2000. 223 pp. £16.95 & $24.95 precisely what creationists do. Robert W. Cahn This leads me to suggest that perhaps the only way to counter the steady menace that In the third century BC, the Greek philoso- creationists represent to good scientific pher Aristarchus conceived the heliocentric education is to question their motives as COLLECTION/CORBIS BURSTEIN theory of the heavens. For his pains, Clean- publicly as possible; that is, to do what good thes, the head of the Stoics, a militant reli- scientists are trained not to do. In my capac- gious group, sought to have him indicted for ity as a non-American, non-biological and impiety. Two millennia later, the Catholic non-Christian scientist, I want to raise ques- Church did indict Galileo for the same impi- tions of a wholly non-scientific nature. Why ety. In 1925, in Tennessee, a group of reli- have creationists emerged as a political force gious fundamentalists, the ‘creationists’, who (for that is what they are) only in the United insisted (as they still do) on the literal truth of States? Further, why has creationism only the Old Testament account in Genesis, surfaced among Christians, and not Jews sought and failed to use legal recourse to pre- and Muslims (for whom the Old Testament vent a schoolteacher from teaching evolu- is also a holy book), even though these faiths tion. Plus ça change, plus c’est la même chose. include their fair share of extreme funda- Niles Eldredge, a palaeontologist, has mentalists? become infuriated by the antics of modern- Perhaps it is the US constitution, and its day creationists, who still strive to use politi- emphasis on States’ rights, that has given US cal activism and legal action to curb the creationists a tool ideally suited to their pur- teaching of evolution in US schools. This pose. It seems that, time and again, their means that they have to get around the mas- claims for ‘equal time’ have been so cunning- sive evidence in support of evolution. For Creative thought: can evolution be beaten by a ly reformulated that even Federal Supreme instance, they insist on the ‘gospel truth’ of a question of faith? Court rulings can be bypassed. bishop’s calculation that the Earth is only For an outsider such as myself, educated some 4,000 years old. Accordingly, it must Eldredge tries valiantly to counter cre- when T. D. Lysenko in the Ukraine was, with follow that all conclusions based on fossils ationism with scientific arguments, as befits Stalin’s support, destroying Soviet genetics and their dating are an illusion. God put the a respectable working scientist. He mostly by enforcing a Lamarckian orthodoxy, fossils into the Earth to confound impious resists the temptation to question creation- attempts to lay down scientific correctness followers of the archdevil, Darwin, or falsi- ists’ motives; after all, a proper scientist does using the law are immensely dangerous. Per- fied their geological sequence. not ask whether an opponent’s mother failed haps evolutionists should give up trying to Eldredge’s book is in part a very clear and to nurture him properly or his father was counter creationists by convincing them sci- informative thumbnail sketch of the history unduly authoritarian. The one exception to entifically (a hopeless task), and simply of evolutionary theory, and of the experi- this self-denial is the repeated remark that appeal to the public and to judges in terms of mental findings on which it is based. He creationists are convinced that the (Christ- clear and present political danger. places special emphasis on the uneven pace of ian subset of) humanity will behave morally But what intrigues me is: why is creation- change, stasis alternating with rapid changes only if they submit their intellects in every ism confined to US protestant fundamental- at times of great evolutionary stress. He also particular to the word of God as revealed in ists? Ultraorthodox Jews and Muslims place analyses the ever-growing links between evo- the Old Testament. It is surprising that more emphasis on ritual, dietary obser- lutionary theory and genetic insights. those who call themselves cre- vance and behaving appropriately Furthermore, he offers a hair-raising ationist scientists do not on holy days, than on correct account of the creationists’ twists and turns, call to mind the injunc- belief. They would perhaps in particular their repeated attempts to tion to eschew the fruit approve Elizabeth I’s change State law so that biology teachers are of the Tree of Knowl- assertion that she was forced to give ‘creation science’ equal time edge. not inclined to open and emphasis as evolution. Although they The book does windows into men’s seek scientific respectability, Eldredge is at not go into the dis- souls. By contrast, pains to make it clear that creationists are not tinction between creationists seem to scientists. A point he stresses particularly is mythos and logos be wholly focused on that creationists regard disagreements on as expounded in belief. It would take a points of detail between evolutionists as evi- Karen Armstrong’s better historian than dence against their scientific credibility. splendid book on me to assess how far Creationist scientists, we are told, only religious fundamen- the legacy of the New accept as ‘facts’ what all creationists accept as talism (in several England puritans who a matter of faith. In fact, such ‘facts’ are by faiths), The Battle for God fled intolerance in Old Eng- their nature unfalsifiable, and therefore not (HarperCollins, 2000). Gen- land, only to establish an intol- scientific facts at all. esis is mythos, evolution is logos, erant society in the New World, has © 2000 Macmillan Magazines Ltd NATURE | VOL 406 | 31 AUGUST 2000 | www.nature.com 935 book reviews worked through to modern creationism, and if that is indeed the prime source of the scourge, why it migrated from New England (where creationism is not today a menace) to the South. Meanwhile, Eldredge’s book, readily accessible to any educated reader, deserves to be widely read. I Robert W. Cahn is in the Department of Materials Science and Metallurgy, University of Cambridge, Pembroke Street, Cambridge CB2 3QZ, UK. Martian chronicles In Search of Life on Mars by Malcolm Walter Perseus/Allen & Unwin: 1999. 170 pp. $25, £8.99 Down to Earth Dead Mars, Dying Earth by John E. Brandenburg and Monica Rix Building Planet Earth: Five Billion Years of lava on the way, the book reveals the origins of Paxson Earth History (Cambridge University Press, the continents and discusses what causes Element: 1999. 306 pp. £16.99, $26.95 $39.95, £25.00) by Peter Cattermole details the modern-day natural disasters. Familiar Kenneth Nealson geological evolution of Earth. Through a range features, such as Ayers Rock (above), are of colourful diagrams and photographs the described and their genesis detailed. The book The search for extraterrestrial life has tradi- book explains the mechanics behind the also looks at the methods used in geophysics tionally focused on Mars, often with acrimo- planet’s development. Sampling fossils and and geochemistry. nious results. The ‘pro-life’ groups claim that unquestionably there is, or has been, life on Mars. The ‘pro-choice’ groups take a more face with the current Mars meteorite analy- thing in the complex geobiological setting, cautious view, often paraphrasing Carl ses, and perhaps will face with returned Mars and the frustrations of being half-right, or Sagan (“Extraordinary claims require extra- samples. even wrong, as the work has proceeded. ordinary results”) and Richard Feynman Walter is pro-choice: he has a healthy In almost every way imaginable Dead (“Unfortunately, you are the easiest person scepticism about the existence of life on Mars Mars, Dying Earth represents a stark contrast [for you] to fool”). The acrimony often arises and spends a good deal of time discussing to Walter’s book. I found it difficult to read: it because the pro-lifers view such caution as why one should have such a view. Yet he moves from subject to subject distractingly. an anti-life stance, while the pro-choice maintains an open mind. In particular, there It is actually two books in one — the first a group would gladly be convinced by high- are discussions of the problems encountered discussion of the history of Mars and the quality data. in dealing with samples that have sat on our arguments for and against life there. The In these two books, we have some classic planet for many years. Contamination by pro-life arguments are readily accepted, examples of these views. Malcolm Walter both organic materials and living organisms while those against are largely dismissed. The explains the difficulties of ascertaining with is virtually impossible to prevent. These authors make a number of claims without certainty the nature of life, even on this plan- problems, coupled with the use of structures showing any evidence to support them. By et, and suggests some cautious approaches to to infer life (and the ability of many mineral the end they have ‘established’ the history of getting the right answer. Brandenburg and forms to mimic structures), make the unam- Mars, the existence of life on the planet, how Paxson, on the other hand, accept that life biguous interpretation of structural data dif- it was discovered, how and when it was extin- has been discovered on Mars and elsewhere, ficult.
Recommended publications
  • The Tempo and Mode of Evolution Reconsidered Stephen Jay Gould
    Punctuated Equilibria: The Tempo and Mode of Evolution Reconsidered Stephen Jay Gould; Niles Eldredge Paleobiology, Vol. 3, No. 2. (Spring, 1977), pp. 115-151. Stable URL: http://links.jstor.org/sici?sici=0094-8373%28197721%293%3A2%3C115%3APETTAM%3E2.0.CO%3B2-H Paleobiology is currently published by Paleontological Society. Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of JSTOR's Terms and Conditions of Use, available at http://www.jstor.org/about/terms.html. JSTOR's Terms and Conditions of Use provides, in part, that unless you have obtained prior permission, you may not download an entire issue of a journal or multiple copies of articles, and you may use content in the JSTOR archive only for your personal, non-commercial use. Please contact the publisher regarding any further use of this work. Publisher contact information may be obtained at http://www.jstor.org/journals/paleo.html. Each copy of any part of a JSTOR transmission must contain the same copyright notice that appears on the screen or printed page of such transmission. The JSTOR Archive is a trusted digital repository providing for long-term preservation and access to leading academic journals and scholarly literature from around the world. The Archive is supported by libraries, scholarly societies, publishers, and foundations. It is an initiative of JSTOR, a not-for-profit organization with a mission to help the scholarly community take advantage of advances in technology. For more information regarding JSTOR, please contact [email protected]. http://www.jstor.org Sun Aug 19 19:30:53 2007 Paleobiology.
    [Show full text]
  • Springer A++ Viewer
    PublisherInfo PublisherName : BioMed Central PublisherLocation : London PublisherImprintName : BioMed Central Stephen Jay Gould dies ArticleInfo ArticleID : 4486 ArticleDOI : 10.1186/gb-spotlight-20020522-01 ArticleCitationID : spotlight-20020522-01 ArticleSequenceNumber : 152 ArticleCategory : Research news ArticleFirstPage : 1 ArticleLastPage : 3 RegistrationDate : 2002–5–22 ArticleHistory : OnlineDate : 2002–5–22 ArticleCopyright : BioMed Central Ltd2002 ArticleGrants : ArticleContext : 130593311 Hal Cohen Email: [email protected] PHILADELPHIA - Stephen Jay Gould, paleontologist, evolutionary biologist and popular author, died of abdominal mesothelioma Monday in New York City. He was 60. A provocative and controversial thinker, Gould was a fierce public defender of evolution. He became a figurehead for paleontology by making difficult concepts more digestible for the public in forums such as The New York Times and The New York Review of Books. While in graduate school, Gould and fellow student Niles Eldredge disputed the theories of evolution, which held that changes in organisms only occurred gradually, over eons. In their theory, known as punctuated equilibrium, evolution proceeded in bursts, followed by long periods of stasis. Thirty years later after their theory was first developed, the debate still rages. Among the many awards and honors bestowed upon Gould were membership in the National Academy of Sciences, the National Book Award, and the National Book Critics Circle Award. He also served as president of the American Association for the Advancement of Science. Gould wrote more than a dozen books, most recently publishing the 1,454-page The Structure of Evolutionary Theory (Harvard, 2001) and, this month, I Have Landed : The End of a Beginning in Natural History (Harmony Books, 2002).
    [Show full text]
  • Darwin's Doubt
    Debating Darwin’s Doubt A Scientific Controversy that Can No Longer Be Denied DAVID KLINGHOFFER, EDITOR DISCOVERY INSTITUTE PRESS SEATTLE 2015 Description This book contains essays responding to criticism of Darwin’s Doubt: The Explosive Origin of Animal Life and the Case for Intelligent Design by Stephen Meyer. The book explores topics such as orphan genes, cladistics, small shelly fossils, protein evolution, the length of the Cambrian explosion, the God-of-the-Gaps objection to intelligent design, and criticisms raised by proponents of theistic evolution. Contributors include Stephen Meyer, Douglas Axe, David Berlinski, William Dembski, Ann Gauger, Casey Luskin, and Paul Nelson. Edited by David Klinghoffer. Copyright Notice Copyright © 2015 by Discovery Institute. All Rights Reserved. Publisher’s Note This book is part of a series published by the Center for Science & Culture at Discovery Institute in Seattle. Previous books include Signature of Controversy: Responses to CritiCs of Signature in the Cell, edited by David Klinghoffer; The Myth of Junk DNA by Jonathan Wells; The Deniable Darwin & Other Essays by David Berlinski; and DisCovering Intelligent Design: A Journey into the SCientifiC EvidenCe by Gary Kemper, Hallie Kemper, and Casey Luskin. Library Cataloging Data Debating Darwin’s Doubt: A SCientifiC Controversy that Can No Longer Be Denied Edited by David Klinghoffer. BISAC Subject: SCI027000 SCIENCE / Life Sciences / Evolution BISAC Subject: SCI080000 SCIENCE / Essays BISAC Subject: SCI034000 SCIENCE / History ISBN-13: 978-1-936599-30-1 (Kindle) 978-1-936599-31-8 (EPUB) 978-1-936599-28-8 (paperback) Publisher Information Discovery Institute Press, 208 Columbia Street, Seattle, WA 98101 Internet: http://www.discoveryinstitutepress.com/ First Edition.
    [Show full text]
  • Speciation and Bursts of Evolution
    Evo Edu Outreach (2008) 1:274–280 DOI 10.1007/s12052-008-0049-4 ORIGINAL SCIENTIFIC ARTICLE Speciation and Bursts of Evolution Chris Venditti & Mark Pagel Published online: 5 June 2008 # Springer Science + Business Media, LLC 2008 Abstract A longstanding debate in evolutionary biology Darwin’s gradualistic view of evolution has become widely concerns whether species diverge gradually through time or accepted and deeply carved into biological thinking. by rapid punctuational bursts at the time of speciation. The Over 110 years after Darwin introduced the idea of natural theory of punctuated equilibrium states that evolutionary selection in his book The Origin of Species, two young change is characterised by short periods of rapid evolution paleontologists put forward a controversial new theory of the followed by longer periods of stasis in which no change tempo and mode of evolutionary change. Niles Eldredge and occurs. Despite years of work seeking evidence for Stephen Jay Gould’s(Eldredge1971; Eldredge and Gould punctuational change in the fossil record, the theory 1972)theoryofPunctuated Equilibria questioned Darwin’s remains contentious. Further there is little consensus as to gradualistic account of evolution, asserting that the majority the size of the contribution of punctuational changes to of evolutionary change occurs at or around the time of overall evolutionary divergence. Here we review recent speciation. They further suggested that very little change developments which show that punctuational evolution is occurred between speciation events—aphenomenonthey common and widespread in gene sequence data. referred to as evolutionary stasis. Eldredge and Gould had arrived at their theory by Keywords Speciation . Evolution . Phylogeny.
    [Show full text]
  • Evidence for Evolution
    CHAPTER 3 Evidence for Evolution VOLUTIONARY BIOLOGY HAS PROFOUNDLY altered our view of nature and of ourselves. At the beginning of this book, we showed the practical application of Eevolutionary biology to agriculture, biotechnology, and medicine. More broadly, evolutionary theory underpins all our knowledge of biology, explains how organisms came to be (both describing their history and identi- fying the processes that acted), and explains why they are as they are (why organisms reproduce sexually, why they age, and so on). How- ever, arguably its most important influence has been on how we view ourselves and our place in the world. The radical scope of evolution- ary biology has for many been hard to accept, and this has led to much misunderstanding and many objections. In this chapter, we summarize the evidence for evolution, clarify some common misun- derstandings, and discuss the wider implications of evolution by natural selection. Biological evolution was widely accepted soon after the publication of On the Origin of Species in 1859 (Chapter 1.x). Charles Darwin set out “one long argument” for the “descent with modification” of all liv- ing organisms, from one or a few common ancestors. He marshaled evidence from classification of organisms, from the fossil record, from geographic distribution of organisms, and by analogy with artificial se- lection. As we saw in Chapter 1, the detailed processes that cause evo- lution remained obscure until after the laws of heredity were established in the early 20th century. By the time of the Evolutionary Synthesis,in the mid-20th century, these processes were well understood and, cru- cially, it was established that adaptation is due to natural selection (Chapter 1.x).
    [Show full text]
  • Download Curriculum Vitae
    NILES ELDREDGE CURATOR AND PROFESSOR DIVISION OF PALEONTOLOGY HIGHEST DEGREE EARNED Ph. D. AREA OF SPECIALIZATION Evolution of mid-Paleozoic phacopid trilobites EDUCATIONAL EXPERIENCE Ph.D. in Geology, Columbia University, October 1969 A.B., Summa Cum Laude, Columbia College, New York, June 1965 PREVIOUS EXPERIENCE IN DOCTORAL EDUCATION FACULTY APPOINTMENTS Adjunct Professor, Earth and Environmental Sciences, City University of New York, 1992-present Adjunct Professor, Biology, City University of New York, 1972-present Associate Professor, Department of Geology, Columbia University, 1974-1981 Adjunct Assistant Professor, Department of Geology, Columbia University, 1969-1974 GRADUATE ADVISEES Ilya Tëmkin, Ph.D. candidate, New York University, 2003-present Yumiko Iwasaki, Ph.D. candidate, Geology, City University of New York, 2000-present GRADUATE COMMITTEES Ilya Tëmkin, Ph.D. candidate, New York University, 2003-present Yumiko Iwasaki, Ph.D. candidate, Geology, City University of New York, 2000-present RECENT ARTICLES IN REFEREED JOURNALS (2003-2008) Eldredge, N. Ms. Darwin, The Beagle, and Evolution Eldredge, N. In Press. Material Cultural Macroevolution Eldredge, N. 2008. Some thoughts on “adaptive peaks,” “Dobzhansky’s dilemma,”—and how to think about evolution. Evolution: Education and Outreach 1 (3): DOI:10.1007/s12052-008-0057-4. www.Springer.com/12052 Eldredge, N. 2008. Paleontology and Evolution. Essay Review of Evolution. What the Fossils Say and Why it Matters, by Donald Prothero. Evolution DOI:10.1111/j.1558-5646.2008.00382.x Kark, Salit, L. Hadany, U. N. Safriel, I. Noy-Meir, N. Eldredge, C. Tabarroni and E. Randi. 2008. How does genetic diversity change towards the range periphery? An empirical and theoretical test.
    [Show full text]
  • Darwin: Educators' Professional Development Program Evaluation Prepared by Ellen Giusti
    Darwin: Educators' Professional Development Program Evaluation Prepared by Ellen Giusti New York area educators were invited to a professional development event at the American museum of Natural History on February 2, 2006, from 4:00 to 7:00 PM. The purpose of the evening was to acquaint teachers with the Museum's Darwin exhibition and to offer methods for using it to enhance classroom instruction. The event took place in the Hall of Reptiles and Amphibians and the exhibition in Gallery 3. Darwin is organized by the American Museum of Natural History, New York (www.amnh.org), in collaboration with the Museum of Science, Boston; The Field Museum, Chicago; the Royal Ontario Museum, Toronto, Canada; and the Natural History Museum, London, England. The evening began with a talk by Darwin curator, Niles Eldredge, followed by remarks from AMNH Education staff and NYC Board of Education officials. Educators then visited the exhibition and attended demostrations of activities designed to broaden the scope of the exhibition for students. Demonstration tables focused on journal writing, botany, insect observations and voyage of the Beagle. In addition, educators were given materials to use in the classroom, both as stand-alone acitvities and pre- and post-visit experiences. Educators were treated to an appetizing arrray of food and beverages, served by elegantly clad wait staff. Time was available for socializing and networking with colleagues. The American Museum of Natural History gratefully acknowledges The Howard Phipps Foundation for its leadership support. Significant support for Darwin has also been provided by Chris and Sharon Davis, the Austin Hearst Foundation, Jack and Susan Rudin, and Rosalind P.
    [Show full text]
  • Curriculum Vitae
    Curriculum Vitae Robert J. Richards 9/2018 2705 W. Fitch Ave. Chicago, Ill. 60645 USA Phone: (773) 743-8945; Fax: (773) 743-8949; Email: [email protected] Office: Social Science Building 205 The University of Chicago 1126 E. 59th St. Chicago, Ill. 60637 Phone: (773) 702-8348 or 702-8261 Home page: http://home.uchicago.edu/~rjr6 Married: Wife, Barbara Advanced Degrees: Ph.D., History of Science (The University of Chicago) M.A., Biological Psychology (The University of Nebraska) Ph.D., Philosophy (St. Louis University) Appointments at The University of Chicago: Distinguished Service Professor, 2011 Morris Fishbein Professor of the History of Science and Medicine, 2004 Professor, 1991- (Associate Professor, 1984-91; Assistant Professor, 1979-84) Department of History Conceptual and Historical Studies of Science Department of Psychology Department of Philosophy Director, Fishbein Center for the History of Science, 1992- Chair, Conceptual and Historical Studies of Science, 1984-94, 1998-1999, 2002-2003, 2005- 2006, 2008-2009, 2012-2013. Director, B.A. Program in History, Philosophy, and Social Studies of Science and Medicine, 1982- Visiting Teaching: Department of History of Science, Harvard University, Spring, 1983 Grinnell College, Mellon Professor, fall, 2007. 1 Honors: Distinguished Lecturer for the History of the Human Sciences, History of Science Society, 2016 Sarton Medal for distinguished scholarship, History of Science Society, 2011 Distinguished Service Professor, 2011 Laing Prize, University of Chicago Press, for The Tragic
    [Show full text]
  • Eldridge, the Sixth Extinction
    The Sixth Extinction (ActionBioscience) Page 1 of 6 biodiversity environment genomics biotechnology evolution new frontiers educator resources home search topic directory e-newsletter your feedback contact us The Sixth Extinction Niles Eldredge An ActionBioscience.org original article »en español articlehighlights Can we stop the devastation of our planet and save our own species? We are in a biodiversity crisis — the fastest mass extinction in Earth’s history, largely due to: z human destruction of ecosystems z overexploitation of species and natural resources z human overpopulation z the spread of agriculture z pollution June 2001 There is little doubt left in the minds of professional biologists that Earth is currently faced with a mounting loss of species that threatens to rival the five About 30,000 great mass extinctions of the geological species go past. As long ago as 1993, Harvard extinct annually. biologist E.O. Wilson estimated that Earth is currently losing something on the order of 30,000 species per year — which breaks down to the even more daunting Tyrannosaurus rex skull and upper vertebral column, a victim of the fifth major extinction. Palais de la statistic of some three species per hour. Découverte, Paris, photo by David.Monniaux. Some biologists have begun to feel that this biodiversity crisis — this “Sixth Extinction” — is even more severe, and more imminent, than Wilson had supposed. Extinction in the past The major global biotic turnovers were all caused by physical events that lay outside the normal climatic and other physical disturbances which species, and entire ecosystems, experience and survive. What caused them? z First major extinction (c.
    [Show full text]
  • Parsimonious Explanations for Punctuated Patterns
    Evo Edu Outreach (2008) 1:138–146 DOI 10.1007/s12052-007-0025-4 CURRICULUM ARTICLE Views from Understanding Evolution: Parsimonious Explanations for Punctuated Patterns Anastasia Thanukos Published online: 19 January 2008 # Springer Science + Business Media, LLC 2007 Keywords Punctuated equilibria . Allopatric speciation . change (Fig. 1c)—in which, for example, tracing fossils Peripatric speciation . Parsimony . Teaching through rock layers that correspond to a slow cooling in Earth’s climate reveals the gradual evolution of traits suited to colder temperatures. This picture of slow evolution, Antievolution groups have frequently pointed to the debate which Eldredge and Gould termed phyletic gradualism, fits prompted by Niles Eldredge and Stephen Gould’s(1972) well with one of the keystones of evolutionary theory: proposal of punctuated equilibria with triumph. “Look,” natural selection, the process responsible for adapting they’ve claimed, “biologists can’t even agree among them- populations to changes in their environments. It is easy to selves how evolution works. The theory must be failing.” In imagine natural selection, for example, slowly transforming the article included in this issue, “Editor’s Corner: The Early a delicate tropical species into a hardy, well-insulated, cold- “Evolution” of “Punctuated Equilibria”,” Niles Eldredge tolerant species over many millions of years. In some cases, (2008) takes on that mischaracterization. He describes the we do observe such gradualistic patterns in the fossil roots of punctuated equilibria and reveals how it builds on record, but in many others, we observe evolution in (not tears down!) established evolutionary theory. apparent fits and starts. If the evolutionary mechanism of The idea of punctuated equilibria was inspired by a natural selection helps explain apparently gradual evolu- mysterious pattern in the fossil record.
    [Show full text]
  • 25-29 Obituaries
    IN MEMORIUM Norman D. Newell, faculty 1937-45, Paleontology evolution in welcome contrast with prior descriptive courses in Albert R. Perko, BA 1940 "Invertebrate Paleontology." In 1989 Gould wrote, "I was Norman James M. Parks, Jr., MS 1949, PhD 1951 Newell's student, and everything that I ever do, as long as I live, Lewis Austin Weeks, MS 1949, Bacteriology will be read as his legacy." In fact, Newell's 1963 paper, "Crises in Milton Zeni, BS 1949 the History of Life," anticipated and undoubtedly inspired Robert Dollase, BS 1950 Gould's and Eldridge's theory of punctuated equilibrium. Alonzo Jacka, MS 1957 Norman D. Newell was born in Chicago in 1909 and received William H. Guhl, BS 1960 his bachelor's and master's degrees from the University of Kansas, Robert M. Sneider, PhD 1962 where he worked his way through playing in a jazz band. His Tor H. Nilsen, MS 1964, PhD 1967 doctorate was from Yale. He is survived by his wife, the former Charles V. Guidotti, faculty 1969-81, Metamorphic Petrology Gillian Wormall. Gerard Bond, PhD 1970 Albert R. Perko, BA 1940 Charles W. (“Bill”) Berge, PhD 1972 A resident of Kirkland, WA, Mr. Perko passed away on Dec. Michael E. Durch, BS 1975 14, 2005 at the age of 89. He is survived by his wife Margaret, son Lee, and daughter Kathy. Norman D. Newell, faculty James M. Parks, Jr., MS 1949, PhD 1951 1937-45, Paleontology James Marshall Parks, Jr. died January 29, 2005 at his home Norman D. Newell, an in Wilmore, Kentucky.
    [Show full text]
  • Stephen Jay Gould: Did He Bring Paleontology to the “High Table”? a Review of Stephen Jay Gould: Reflections on His View of Life Edited by Warren D
    Philos Theor Biol (2009) 1:e001 Stephen Jay Gould: Did He Bring Paleontology to the “High Table”? A Review of Stephen Jay Gould: Reflections on His View of Life edited by Warren D. Allmon, Patricia H. Kelley, and Robert M. Ross Oxford University Press, 2009 Donald Prothero§ In the seven years since Harvard paleontologist Stephen Jay Gould died, there have been only a few assessments of his role in paleobiology and evolutionary theory. Although non- paleontologists still do not realize it, the “punctuated equilibrium” model first proposed by Gould and Niles Eldredge in 1972 has widespread acceptance among paleontologists. Nearly all metazoans show stasis, with almost no good examples of gradual evolution. The most important implication is that fossil species are static over millions of years, even in the face of dramatic climate changes and other environmental selection factors. This widespread stasis cannot be explained by simplistic concepts like “stabilizing selection,” and remains a mystery that neontologists have not fully addressed or successfully explained. Despite the hope that paleontology would reach the “High Table” of evolutionary biology, the fact that most biologists largely do not understand or accept the implications of paleontological concepts such as species sorting and coordinated stasis suggests that paleontology still has not made the impact on evolutionary thinking that it deserves. KEYWORDS Evolutionary theory ● Paleontology ● Punctuated equilibria ● Stasis ● Stephen Gould It has been over seven years since the passing of Stephen Jay Gould on May 20, 2002 at age 60. Given the normal slow pace of academic publishing, we are just beginning to see the book-length post-mortems by authors assessing his role as a scientist, scholar, and public figure.
    [Show full text]