Thornhill Lake: Hunter-Gatherers, Monuments, and Memory
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
THORNHILL LAKE: HUNTER-GATHERERS, MONUMENTS, AND MEMORY By JON C. ENDONINO A DISSERTATION PRESENTED TO THE GRADUATE SCHOOL OF THE UNIVERSITY OF FLORIDA IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY UNIVERSITY OF FLORIDA 2010 1 © 2010 Jon C. Endonino 2 To Heather 3 ACKNOWLEDGMENTS Many individuals have contributed in innumerable ways to the successful completion of this dissertation. First, my committee chair Ken Sassaman deserves credit for guiding me throughout graduate school and believing in me and my abilities as an archaeologist, that confidence is the highest of compliments. My committee members Peter Schmidt, Mike Heckenberger, and Julianna Barr have my sincerest thanks for their willingness to serve and contributions great and small. Access to the Thornhill Lake Site and the Lake Monroe Conservation Area was provided by the St. Johns River Water Management District (SJRWMD) through a Special Use Authorization. Archaeological research on SJRWMD lands was carried out under a 1A-32 permit allowing archaeological research on State lands by the Bureau of Archaeological Research, Florida Division of Historical Resources. Many thanks are owed to State Archaeologist Ryan Wheeler and Bureau employees Brenda Swann, Andrea White, and Briana Delano and Sharyn Heiland for all their assistance. Funding for field work was provided by a Lewis and Clark Travel and Research Grant from the American Philosophical Society and a Survey and Planning grant from the Florida Division of Historical Resources (Grant No. SO758). A John W. Griffin Award from the Florida Archaeological Council with matching funds from Southeastern Archaeological Research (SEARCH) and Jerald Milanich was used to conduct collections research at the Smithsonian curation facility in Suitland, Maryland. A stipend funding time off from work to write this dissertation and two additional AMS dates was provided by the Hyatt and Cici Brown Foundation for Florida Archaeology. Considerable thanks and credit are due my employer SEARCH, especially Anne Stokes and James Pochurek, for allowing me flexibility in scheduling, time off, for the 4 innumerable opportunities to develop and hone my archaeological skills, covering my tuition toward the end of my tenure in graduate school, and for loaning company equipment – all of this contributed to the successful completion of field work and, ultimately, this study. Special thanks are also owed to Bob Austin for guidance and advice that, over the years, has helped me grow as a professional. Debra Wells aided immeasurably in helping with the conservation of fragile and damaged artifacts. Were it not for the hard work of a group of dedicated volunteers this research would have taken considerably longer. Their contributions in time and talent can not be understated and they have my sincerest thanks: Dave Carlson, Chris “Big Ski” Sypniewski, Heather Endonino, Chuck Alexander, Cameron Alexander, Gavin Alexander, J. P. Petrencsik, Phil Guilford, Warren and Ruth Trager, JoAnne Cross, Jon Simon-Suarez, Jonathan Dupree, Jason Wenzel, Chris Borlas, Cletus Rooney, Micah Mones, Matt Watson, Mary Jo Morrow, Richard and Sherry Goolsby, Susan Trew, Elizabeth Beecher, Chris Altes, Jake Schidner, Johanna Talcott, Keith Edwards, and Josh Foster. Anyone who was omitted or overlooked has my sincerest apologies. Your contributions are valued and appreciated. My mother Mary Jo Morrow suggested taking Introduction to Anthropology and Introduction to Archaeology and unknowingly at the time set me on the course to a career that has been personally fulfilling and I consider myself lucky to have found my calling. My professor for these introductory courses, Gary Ellis, has been a mentor and friend over the years and I owe him so very much for encouraging me as a young undergraduate to pursue my interests – advice that has paid off in spades. I would like to thank the Crabtree and Goolsby families for all that they have done for me throughout 5 graduate school and personally over the years and that is saying a lot. Truly I am lucky to have such good people in my life. Finally I want to give special thanks to my wife Heather Kristen Goolsby-Endonino for sticking by me through the lean years, when it seemed like there was no end in sight, during all the long hours in the field or in front of a computer – thank you for your love, patience, support, and just for being there through it all. 6 TABLE OF CONTENTS page ACKNOWLEDGMENTS.................................................................................................. 4 LIST OF TABLES.......................................................................................................... 11 LIST OF FIGURES........................................................................................................ 14 ABSTRACT ................................................................................................................... 16 CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION AND ORGANIZATION................................................................ 18 Research Questions and Contributions .................................................................. 20 Dissertation Case Study and Data.......................................................................... 23 Organization of the Dissertation.............................................................................. 26 2 THEORETICAL CONSIDERATIONS: MONUMENTS AND MEMORY................... 31 Monuments ............................................................................................................. 31 Monuments Defined ......................................................................................... 31 Why Build Monuments?.................................................................................... 34 Ecological and functionalist explanations for monument construction ....... 34 Monuments as territorial markers............................................................... 36 The Effects of Monuments................................................................................ 37 Memory................................................................................................................... 37 Locating Memory.............................................................................................. 38 Memory Practices............................................................................................. 40 Incorporated practices ............................................................................... 40 Inscribed practices ..................................................................................... 43 Memory and Identity......................................................................................... 44 Memory and Materiality .................................................................................... 46 Citation ............................................................................................................. 48 Conclusions ............................................................................................................ 49 3 PERSPECTIVES ON HUNTER-GATHERERS, MONUMENTS, AND MOUND- BUILDING............................................................................................................... 51 Hunter-Gatherers and Monuments ......................................................................... 52 Ethnographic and Ethnohistoric Evidence for Hunter-Gatherer Monuments .... 55 Archaeological Perspectives on Hunter-Gatherers and Monuments ................ 56 Gobekli, Turkey.......................................................................................... 56 Neolithic Britain and Atlantic Europe.......................................................... 58 Australian Aboriginal mounds .................................................................... 59 North American Monuments............................................................................. 61 7 Archaic origins ........................................................................................... 62 The maritime archaic of Subarctic Canada ................................................ 62 The American Midcontinent ....................................................................... 64 The southeastern United States................................................................. 65 The archaic mortuary mounds of the St. Johns River Valley and northeast Florida..................................................................................... 73 Conclusions ............................................................................................................ 75 4 MOUNT TAYLOR ARCHAEOLOGY....................................................................... 78 The Archaeological Record of the St. Johns River Valley....................................... 79 Early Investigations .......................................................................................... 79 St. Johns Archaeology in the Twentieth Century.............................................. 80 Archaeological Context........................................................................................... 85 Middle Archaic (ca. 7500-5000 cal. B.P.) ......................................................... 85 Mount Taylor (7300-4500 cal. B.P.).................................................................. 89 Chronology................................................................................................. 90 Origins ......................................................................................................