Copyright Law Halpern 3E 00 Fmt Toc Flip 2 1/27/16 9:10 AM Page Ii
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
halpern 3e 00 fmt toc flip 2 1/27/16 9:10 AM Page i Copyright Law halpern 3e 00 fmt toc flip 2 1/27/16 9:10 AM Page ii Carolina Academic Press Law Advisory Board k Gary J. Simson, Chairman Mercer University School of Law Raj Bhala University of Kansas School of Law Davison M. Douglas Dean, Marshall-Wythe School of Law College of William and Mary Paul Finkelman Albany Law School Robert M. Jarvis Shepard Broad College of Law Nova Southeastern University Linda Jellum Mercer University School of Law Vincent R. Johnson St. Mary’s University School of Law Peter Nicolas University of Washington School of Law Michael A. Olivas University of Houston Law Center Kenneth L. Port William Mitchell College of Law H. Jefferson Powell Duke University School of Law Suzanne Rowe University of Oregon School of Law Michael P. Scharf Case Western Reserve University School of Law Michael Hunter Schwartz Dean, William H. Bowen School of Law University of Arkansas at Little Rock Peter M. Shane Michael E. Moritz College of Law The Ohio State University halpern 3e 00 fmt toc flip 2 1/27/16 9:10 AM Page iii Copyright Law Protection of Original Expression Third Edition Sheldon W. Halpern C. William O’Neill Professor of Law and Judicial Administration, Emeritus The Michael E. Moritz College of Law at The Ohio State University Carolina Academic Press Durham, North Carolina halpern 3e 00 fmt toc flip 2 1/27/16 9:10 AM Page iv Copyright © 2016 Sheldon W. Halpern All Rights Reserved ISBN: 978-1-61163-465-5 LCCN: 2015939946 Carolina Academic Press, LLC 700 Kent Street Durham, North Carolina 27701 Telephone (919) 489-7486 Fax (919) 493-5668 www.cap-press.com Printed in the United States of America halpern 3e 00 fmt toc flip 2 1/27/16 9:10 AM Page v For Dorit, Part — the best part — of all that I am and all that I do halpern 3e 00 fmt toc flip 2 1/27/16 9:10 AM Page vi halpern 3e 00 fmt toc flip 2 1/27/16 9:10 AM Page vii Summary of Contents Contents ix Table of Cases xix Chapter 1 · Introduction — Copyright: The Intangible Interest in Tangible Expression 3 1.1. Copyright and “Intellectual Property” 3 1.2. The Intangible Interest and Social Good 4 1.3. Constitutional Compromise: The Copyright Act 5 1.4. The Copyright Act and Technological Change 15 1.5. Globalization and Harmonization 17 Chapter 2 · Copyrightability: Fixation of Original Expression 31 2.1. The Subject Matter of Copyright — Originality 31 2.2. The Subject Matter of Copyright — Authorship 39 2.3. The Subject Matter of Copyright — Expression 68 2.4. The Subject Matter of Copyright: “Fixed” Works 209 Chapter 3 · Copyrights: The Divisible, Exclusive Rights of a Copyright Owner 233 3.1. The Bundle of Separate Rights 233 3.2. The “Quasi Copyrights” of the DMCA 391 3.3 Copyright Ownership and Transfer 426 3.4. Duration of Copyright 516 Chapter 4 · Infringement: Substantive Analysis 539 4.1. Actionable Copying: “Substantial Similarity” 539 4.2. Actionable Copying: Access 597 4.3. Non- Infringing Copying: Fair Use 613 Chapter 5 · Infringement: Procedural Analysis 751 5.1. Subject Matter Jurisdiction 751 5.2. Sovereign Immunity 770 5.3. Federal Preemption of State Law Claims 775 5.4. Personal Jurisdiction, Venue, and Standing 813 5.5. The Defense of Copyright Misuse 818 Chapter 6 · Remedies and the Ambit of Liability 821 6.1. Vicarious and Contributory Infringement 821 6.2. Remedies 881 6.3. Criminal Liability 916 Index 925 vii halpern 3e 00 fmt toc flip 2 1/27/16 9:10 AM Page viii halpern 3e 00 fmt toc flip 2 1/27/16 9:10 AM Page ix Contents Table of Cases xix Chapter 1 · Introduction — Copyright: The Intangible Interest in Tangible Expression 3 1.1. Copyright and “Intellectual Property” 3 1.2. The Intangible Interest and Social Good 4 1.3. Constitutional Compromise: The Copyright Act 5 A. The Grant of Power 5 B. Congressional Implementation: The Copyright Act of 1976 6 1. A Unitary Federal Scheme 6 2. Protection of Fixed “Expression,” and Not “Ideas” 6 3. The Bundle of Discrete Rights of a Copyright Owner 7 4. The Limitations on the Copyright Interests 8 a. The Specifically Enumerated Limitations 8 b. The Broad Fair Use Limitation 9 Suntrust Bank v. Houghton Mifflin Company 9 1.4. The Copyright Act and Technological Change 15 A. Contemplation of and Accommodation to Technological Change 15 B. The Practical and Ethical Impact of Digital Technology 15 1.5. Globalization and Harmonization 17 A. Treaties and Other International Agreements 18 1. National Treatment 18 2. Harmonization: Minimal Substantive Standards 18 B. Copyright Law and Culture 19 C. Constitutional Constraints on Harmonization 19 Golan v. Holder 20 Chapter 2 · Copyrightability: Fixation of Original Expression 31 2.1. The Subject Matter of Copyright — Originality 31 A. The Originality/Creativity Threshold 31 1. Originality as a Constitutional Requirement 31 2. The Low Creativity Threshold 33 Atari Games Corporation v. Oman 33 B. The “NonDiscrimination” Principle 35 Bleistein v. Donaldson Lithographing Co. 35 Notes 37 2.2. The Subject Matter of Copyright — Authorship 39 A. “Authors” and “Writings” 39 Burrow- Giles Lithographic Company v. Sarony 39 1. Authorship 42 ix halpern 3e 00 fmt toc flip 2 1/27/16 9:10 AM Page x x CONTENTS 2. “Writings” 43 3. Photographs and Audiovisual Works as Copyrightable Writings 45 Ets- Hokin v. Skyy Spirits, Inc. 46 Mendler v. Winterland Productions, Ltd. 50 B. “Copying a Copy”: Authorship of Derivative Works 54 1. Re-Creation of the “Original” 55 Gross v. Seligman 55 Notes 56 2. Originality and Derivative Works: Trivial — and Other — Variations 57 L. Batlin & Son, Inc. v. Snyder 58 Notes 59 3. The Impact of Technology on Derivative Works: “Slavish” Copying 61 The Bridgeman Art Library, Ltd. v. Corel Corporation 61 Meshwerks, Inc. v. Toyota Motor Sales U.S.A., Inc. 63 2.3. The Subject Matter of Copyright — Expression 68 A. Generally, the Idea/Expression Continuum 68 Baker v. Selden 68 Mattel, Inc. v. Goldberger Doll Manufacturing Co. 70 Blehm v. Jacobs 75 Note: The Need to Separate “Idea” from “Expression” 83 B. Unprotectable “Facts” and Protectable Original Compilations 85 1. Generally 85 Assessment Technologies of Wisconsin, Llc. v. Wiredata, Inc. 85 2. Compilations 89 Harper House, Inc. v. Thomas Nelson, Inc. 89 Notes 93 3. “Originality” in Compilations 95 Feist Publications, Inc. v. Rural Telephone Service Co., Inc. 96 Notes: The Impact of Feist on Compilations 102 Kregos v. Associated Press 103 Matthew Bender & Company, Inc. v. West Publishing Co. 106 Notes 113 BUC International Corp. v. International Yacht Council Ltd. 114 4. “Original Selection and Arrangement”: “Selection” and Data Protection 120 CCC Information Services, Inc. v. Maclean Hunter Market Reports, Inc. 120 Notes 124 C. Factual and Functional Works 124 1. Generally 124 2. Factual and Historical Works 127 Nash v. CBS, Inc. 127 Notes 130 3. Computer Software 131 a. A Computer Program as a “Literary Work” 131 b. Protection of the “Code” Itself 131 Lexmark International, Inc. v. Static Control Components 132 c. Protectability of the Nonliteral, Structural Elements of a Program 141 d. “Look and Feel” 145 D. Merger and Scènes à Faire: “Expression” as “Idea” 148 halpern 3e 00 fmt toc flip 2 1/27/16 9:10 AM Page xi CONTENTS xi 1. Merger of Idea and Expression 148 Kregos v. Associated Press 149 BUC International Corp. v. International Yacht Council Ltd . 152 Notes 153 2. Merger: The “Copyrightability” and “Infringement” Models 154 3. Scènes à Faire 156 Reyher v. Children’s Television Workshop 157 Notes 159 E. Utilitarian Works 160 1. Limitations on “Useful Articles” 160 Mazer v. Stein 160 Note: “Useful Articles” v. Pictorial, Graphic, or Sculptural Works 164 Masquerade Novelty, Inc., v. Unique Industries, Inc. 165 Superior Form Builders, Inc. v. Dan Chase Taxidermy Supply Co., Inc. 169 Notes 172 2. Physical and Conceptual Separability 173 Carol Barnhart Inc. v. Economy Cover Corporation 174 Note 177 Brandir International, Inc. v. Cascade Pacific Lumber Co. 178 Notes 182 Galiano v. Harrah’s Operating Company, Inc. 183 3. The Special Case of Architectural Works 188 The Architectural Works Copyright Protection Act of 1990 189 F. Literary and Other Characters as Protected Expression 190 1. Generally 190 2. The Second Circuit and Character Copyrightability 191 Warner Bros. Inc. v. American Broadcasting Companies, Inc. 191 Silverman v. CBS Inc. 194 Notes 197 3. The Ninth Circuit and the Character as the “Story” 197 Walt Disney Productions v. Air Pirates 198 Anderson v. Stallone 200 Gaiman v. McFarlane 203 G. Sound Recordings 208 2.4. The Subject Matter of Copyright: “Fixed” Works 209 A. Attachment of Copyright by Fixation 209 1. Fixation v. Publication 209 2. “Fixation” Defined 210 National Football League v. McBee & Bruno’s, Inc. 211 B. Unfixed Works 213 U.S. v. Moghadam 214 United States v. Martignon 221 Chapter 3 · Copyrights: The Divisible, Exclusive Rights of a Copyright Owner 233 3.1. The Bundle of Separate Rights 233 A. The Right to Make Copies and Phonorecords 234 1. “Copying” 234 Cartoon Network LP, LLLP v. CSC Holdings, Inc . 234 Note: “Synchronization Right”: Industry Terms of Art 243 halpern 3e 00 fmt toc flip 2 1/27/16 9:10 AM Page xii xii CONTENTS Agee v. Paramount Communications, Inc. 243 2. Permitted Copying: Exemptions and Compulsory Licensing 248 a. The Compulsory “Mechanical” License 248 Leadsinger, Inc. v. BMG Music Publishing 249 Note: Compulsory Licenses 252 b. Copying and the Audio Home Recording Act 253 Recording Industry Association of America v.