Recovery of Anterograde Amnesia in a Case of Craniopharyngioma
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
OBSERVATION Recovery of Anterograde Amnesia in a Case of Craniopharyngioma Ron C. Kupers, PhD; Audrey Fortin, PhD; Jens Astrup, MD; Albert Gjedde, MD; Maurice Ptito, PhD, DM Background: Studies of the amnesic syndrome have in- months after tumor removal. A postsurgical magnetic reso- dicated that telencephalic and diencephalic structures are nance image did not show evidence of damage to the hy- critical components of the memory system. The exact role pothalamus, thalamus, hippocampus, or MBs. of the mammillary bodies (MBs) in human memory re- mains elusive, since few cases of selective MB damage have Main Outcome Measures: Changes in brain imag- been reported. ing data and results of neuropsychological testing. Objective: To study a case of severe anterograde am- Results: After tumor removal, the patient showed a com- nesia due to a third-ventricle craniopharyngioma with plete recovery of memory functions. Performance on the severe MB compression. associative memory test was at chance level before sur- gery and dramatically improved postoperatively. Results Design: Case report. of the preoperative positron emission tomographic study showed no activity in memory-related structures. In con- Setting: Neurosurgery clinic of an academic hospital. trast, a significant blood flow increase occurred in the an- terior thalamic nuclei postoperatively. Patient: A 53-year old woman who developed severe anterograde amnesia due to a third-ventricle craniopha- Conclusions: These behavioral and brain imaging data ryngioma strongly compressing the MBs and, to a lesser stress the importance of the MBs in this patient’s amne- extent, the right hippocampus. sia. Our data further suggest that the clinical prognosis of decompressing the mammillothalamic tract is excel- Interventions: Surgical excision of the tumor and neu- lent, even in cases of massive compression. ropsychological testing and positron emission tomogra- phy during an associative memory test before and 2 Arch Neurol. 2004;61:1948-1952 T IS GENERALLY ACCEPTED THAT compression of the right hippocampus and the critical components of the the MBs. Tumor removal abolished the memory system are not only the functional lesion and led to a complete re- medial temporal lobe (MTL) but covery of memory functions. also diencephalic stuctures such Ias the dorsomedial and anterior thalamic REPORT OF A CASE nuclei, fornix, septal nuclei, and the mam- millary bodies (MBs), as well as the fron- A 53-year-old, right-handed woman with tal lobes.1-3 Memory loss associated with no neurologic antecedents developed acute thalamic lesions and related structures is onset of memory problems in July 1999 that described as “diencephalic amnesia”4 and turned rapidly into a full anterograde am- to a certain extent resembles amnesia in Author Affiliations: PET 5 nesic syndrome. The episode that prompted Center (Drs Kupers, Gjedde, cases of MTL lesions or Korsakoff syn- 6 her husband to take her to the hospital, be- and Ptito), Center for drome. There is controversy regarding sides her continuous forgetting of his re- Functionally Integrative which of these structures, the dorsome- quests, was preparation for their holidays. Neuroscience (Drs Kupers and dial thalamus or the MBs (or a combina- When the husband arrived home from Gjedde), and Department of tion of both), are involved in the amnesic work, the patient had completely forgot- Neurosurgery (Dr Astrup), syndrome.7 In humans, damage re- ten that they were leaving the next day and Aarhus University and Aarhus stricted to the MBs7-9 or the mammillo- nothing had been prepared. University Hospitals, Aarhus, 4 Denmark; and Ecole thalamic tract produces severe and per- The patient arrived at the neurologic d’Optométrie, Université de manent memory impairments. ward of the hospital in September 1999. Montréal, Montréal, Québec We studied a patient who developed se- She was alert, oriented for place, person, (Drs Fortin and Ptito). vere anterograde amnesia due to tumor and time, and did not show signs of de- (REPRINTED) ARCH NEUROL / VOL 61, DEC 2004 WWW.ARCHNEUROL.COM 1948 ©2004 American Medical Association. All rights reserved. Downloaded From: https://jamanetwork.com/ on 09/29/2021 A B Figure 1. Preoperative and postoperative magnetic resonance images (MRIs) and 18F-fluorodeoxyglucose positron emission tomography (FDG-PET), showing (from left to right) horizontal, sagittal, and coronal sections. A, Preoperative views of the craniopharyngioma from MRIs (upper row) and FDG-PET (lower row). Note the compression of the right hippocampus and mammillary bodies. B, Postoperative MRIs (upper row) and FDG-PET (lower row) showing complete removal of the tumor and normal perfusion of the brain. The left part of the brain is shown to the left. The PET data acquisition (45 minutes) started 1 hour after an intravenous bolus injection of 365 MBq (9.9 mCi) of FDG. mentia or speech impairment. A T1-weighted magnetic the third ventricle to the level of the foramina Monroi, resonance image of the brain showed a suprasellar cra- and elevating and compressing the MBs by 2.5 cm, as well niopharyngioma with a diameter of 3.5 cm extending into as the cerebral peduncles. The tumor did not reach the (REPRINTED) ARCH NEUROL / VOL 61, DEC 2004 WWW.ARCHNEUROL.COM 1949 ©2004 American Medical Association. All rights reserved. Downloaded From: https://jamanetwork.com/ on 09/29/2021 Table 1. ROI Analysis of FDG Scans* Table 2. Preoperative and Postoperative Neuropsychological Test Results* FDG Uptake, rCMRGLc Preoperative Postoperative Region of Interest Preoperative Postoperative WAIS–Revised, mean score Hippocampus Verbal IQ (similarities) 16 (10 ± 5†) ND Right 83.2 ± 12.9 78.5 ± 7.9 Performance IQ (block design) 15 (10 ± 5†) 15 Left 83.5 ± 11.9 81.8 ± 10.6 Memory Asymmetry index 0.004 0.041 Verbal Text Abbreviations: FDG, 18F-fluorodeoxyglucose; rCMRGLc, regional cerebral First immediate recall 7/18 12/18 metabolic rate of glucose. Second recall 14/18 17/18 The asymmetry index was calculated for quantitative FDG–positron * Delayed recall 4/18‡ 17/18 emission tomography (PET) metabolism, according to the following formula: [(Left−right region of interest [ROI] activity)/(left+right ROI activity)]/2. The 10-Word list ROIs for left and right hippocampus were drawn on coronal preoperative and First immediate recall 4/10‡ 7/10 postoperative magnetic resonance images, following the guidelines by After 5 recitations 7/10‡ 10/10 Watson and colleagues.10 The FDG-PET scans were coregistered to the Delayed recall 2/10‡ 10/10 magnetic resonance images by means of Automated Image Registration 3 Words (explicit memory), (AIR 3.0) software (Roger Woods, Department of Neurology, University of mean No. California, Los Angeles, UCLA School of Medicine). First immediate recall 3 3 Recall after 5 min 0‡ 3 Recall after 1 h 0‡ 3 Nonverbal left hippocampus but was impinging on the mesial sur- 3 Objects/3 hiding places face of the right hippocampus by 4 mm. The tumor was Recall after 10 min 0/3‡ 3/3 predominantly cystic but had a small solid part in rela- Recall after 1 h 0/3‡ 3/3 tion to the pituitary stalk in the suprasellar cistern. The 4 Visual figures temporal horns of the lateral ventricles were in their nor- Copy (mistakes) 9/16‡ 14/16 Immediate recall 8/16‡ 14/16 mal place on both sides, and no structural abnormali- Delayed recall 3/16‡ 16/16 ties were seen in temporal and frontal lobes, amygdalae, 12 Drawing items thalamus, or fornix (Figure 1A, upper row). This was Immediate recall 6/12‡ 9/12 confirmed by the 18F-fluorodeoxyglucose positron emis- Delayed recall 0/12‡ ND sion tomography (FDG-PET) results (Figure 1A, lower Object naming row) showing normal FDG uptake in these regions. (implicit learning) Immediate recall 7/30‡ 27/30 On October 14, 1999, the cystic tumor was surgi- Language, mean score cally removed de visu without injuring the surrounding Sentence repetition 45 ND pituitary gland or hypothalamus. A histologic examina- (Benton t score) tion confirmed the diagnosis of cystic craniopharyn- Object naming test 30 30 gioma. Two days after surgery, the patient developed poly- Problem-solving uria because of diabetes insipidus, which was treated with and attention tests Symbol-number test, 30 43 desmopressin acetate. The patient’s memory problems mean score disappeared completely, and she returned to her nor- Trail-Making Test, part A, s 35 (35 ± 11†) 30 mal occupations. Trail-Making Test, part B, s 88 (78 ± 24†) 73 A magnetic resonance image obtained 1 month after the surgery confirmed the total removal of the tumor Abbreviations: ND, not done; WAIS, Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale. *Data are given as mean score/total possible score unless otherwise (Figure 1B, upper row). An FDG-PET scan taken at the indicated. same time indicated normal brain metabolism in the MTL †Mean±SD for normal age-matched controls. and upper brainstem (Figure 1B, lower row). A region- ‡Significantly low score. of-interest analysis did not show differences in FDG up- take in right hippocampus before and after surgery, as evidenced by unaltered asymmetry indexes of hippo- house, and she had to learn the specific face-house pair- campal activity (Table 1). This was confirmed when pre- ings. After 4 presentations of the series, pairs of stimuli operative FDG scans were subtracted from postopera- were presented in which only 50% were correctly paired, tive FDG scans (data not shown). and she had to indicate whether the pairings were cor- Formal neuropsychological testing was performed be- rect. Twelve sequential measurements (2 conditions re- fore and 2 months after surgery (Table 2). To elucidate peated 6 times each) of regional cerebral blood flow (rCBF) the mechanisms involved in memory loss and recovery, a were acquired. Visual stimuli were displayed on a large PET study was performed preoperatively and postopera- monitor placed in front of the subject at a rate of 1 pair tively.