International Centre for Theoretical Physics
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
IC/89/265 INTERNATIONAL CENTRE FOR THEORETICAL PHYSICS DIRAC - THE TACITURN GENIUS Mujahid Kamran INTERNATIONAL ATOMIC ENERGY AGENCY UNITED NATIONS EDUCATIONAL, SCIENTIFIC AND CULTURAL ORGANIZATION 1989 MIRAMARE-TRIESTE I I IC/K9/265 International Atomic Energy Agency and Almost five years ago, on October 20,' 1984, the English physicist P.A.M. Dirac, one United Nations Educational Scientific and Cultural Organization of the founders of quantum theory, Nobel Laureate and fellow of many distinguished INTERNATIONAL CENTRE FOR THEORETICAL PHYSICS societies, died in Tallahassee in the state of Florida, USA, where he had lived the last fourteen years of his great and long life. The renowned Nobel Laureate Abdus Salam has aptly summed up the significance of Dirac's contribution in the following words: "Paul Adrien Maurice Dirac was undoubtedly DIRAC -THE TACITURN GENIUS * one of the greatest physicists of this or any century. In three decisive years, 1925, 1926 and 1927, with three papers, he laid the foundations first of quantum physics, second of the quantum theory of fields, and third of the theory of elementary particles with his famous Mujahid Kamran ** equation of the electron. No man except Einstein has had such a decisive influence in so International Centre for Theoretical Physics, Trieste, Italy short a time on the course of physics in this century." and The above remarks, coming from one of the foremost leaders of the world of physics, Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Georgia, give an idea of the true stature of this taciturn genius whose name is completely unknown Athens, GA 30602, USA. to the lay public. In his home country, the Cambridge evening newspaper "honored" him with a one line obituary, "Mr. Dirac had a degree from Cambridge University." The paper failed to note that for almost forty years Dirac had occupied the same chair as Isaac Newton two hundred and fifty years before him — he was Lucasian Professor of Mathematics at Cambridge University. Dirac was appointed against this most prestigious position on September 30, 1932, at the age of only 30. The paper could also have MIRAMARE - TRIESTE mentioned that the idea of "anti-matter" that so excites the popular imagination, was a August 1989 direct consequence of his equation of the electron. EARLY LIFE Paul Dirac was born on August 8, 1902, in Bristol, England. His father, who had a very bitter relationship with his parents, was Swiss by birth. Because of the severity of his * To be submitted for publication, parents, he abruptly left Switzerland without informing them and settled in Bristol as a " Fu I bright Fellow. Permanent address: Center for High Energy Physics, Pubjab Unversity, Lahore 54590, Pakistan. teacher of French language at a local school. His ancestors were French but had migrated •33LMJ2L. '"" ••" •*-* to Switzerland during the Napoleonic wars. Sadly, Dirac's father himself turned into a Dirac visited Geneva with his father when he was only two years old. So painful strong disciplinarian whose domineering attitude left a lasting effect on his sensitive were his memories that he did not return to Geneva, his father's "home" for the next children. Dirac's mother has been described as "one of the four beautiful daughters and seventy years! When he visited Geneva in 1973, he stayed with Jagdish Mehra who records two sons" of a ship's captain. Dirac must have been fond of her because he took her to the that Dirac "remembered numerous sights from his visit to Geneva as a child." This ceremony when he was awarded the Nobel prize (his father was alive at the time). She was indicates his phenomenal memory as well as his tortured sensitivity. So profound was his working at a college library when she met her husband who was twelve years older than father's influence on him that when his father died in 1936, Dirac wrote to his future wife, she. Dirac had an older brother and a younger sister. His brother became an engineer but "I feel much freer now." At that time Dirac was 34 years old and a world renowned Nobel eventually committed suicide. Laureate. On account of his father's attitude, Dirac's childhood was, to quote his wife, "very Dirac's father wanted his children to have a good education and encouraged Dirac to difficult." In an interview given in 1963, Dirac recalled the influence of his father on him study mathematics. At primary school, Dirac's mathematical talent was evident. When in the following words: "My father made the rule that I should only talk to him in French. he entered secondary school he was so far ahead of the rest of his class in mathematics that He thought it would be good for me to learn French in that way. Since I found that I he was given advanced books to work through. Dirac learned a lot of new mathematics by couldn't express myself in French, it was better for me to stay silent than to talk in working through various books. In later life, Dirac had the following to say about his English. So I became very quiet at that time — that started very early." His taciturnity school performance, "I was always a slow reader and did not like poetry. In fact I never was thus an early response to his father's attitude and became deeply ingrained in him. understood good poetry. My whole interest was on the scientiGc side and I was really Apart from a deep reticence, Dirac's other way of coping with his childhood ignorant about matters outside my school work." situation was "thinking about nature." Throughout his life he retained a deep interest in the workings of nature and it was this interest that lured him to physics eventually. STUDENT DAYS AT BRISTOL UNIVERSITY There was perhaps another effect his father's linguistic impositions had on him. Dirac finished school in 1918 and entered Bristol University as a student of Professor Dalitz of Oxford University who knew Dirac well states, "...the children were engineering. His elder brother, who wanted to become a doctor, was forced by his father to required to speak only grammatically exact French at the dinner table." Dirac once told take up engineering studies. Why did Dirac want to study engineering? Or did he? In his the historian of science, Jagdish Mehra, that he was the only one who sat with his father at own words, "I did not have much initiative of my own. This path was rather set out for the dinner table. The other two children sat with the mother in the kitchen. The me and I did not know very well what I wanted." He opted eventually for electrical restriction on precision of expression at the dinner table was therefore more often engineering because one of his school teachers had joined the University and was teaching applicable to Dirac. This probably was an important source of his famous trait — extreme in that area. Decades later, Dirac had the following words for this teacher, "I am grateful precision of expression. As the well-known physicist Kemmer notes, "The clarity of his to David Robertson for explaining things in a way that would show mathematical beauty spoken word was the same as in his writings..." in the calculations." As an engineering student, problem solving not merely increased his skills, it left able to provide him with additional financial support. With that avenue closed, at least for him with a certain philosophy concerning the scientific description of nature. Dirac came the time being, fate opened another avenue for Dirac. People in the mathematics to the viewpoint that we cannot have formulae or equations that describe nature exactly. department were aware of Dirac's exceptional record in mathematics. They had always The only description of nature we have is approximate and the fruitful approach in this hoped that ho would pursue mathematics as a subject and were disappointed when he chose regard is a successive improvement of oar approximations. to go into engineering. It says a great deal for them that they now offered Dirac the Reminiscing about his days at Bristol University, Dirac singled out the year 1919 as opportunity of attending lectures informally without having to pay tuition fees. This was marking the beginnings of "an exciting era." In this year, "Relativity burst upon the acceptable to Dirac's parents as well. world with a tremendous impact. Suddenly everyone was talking about relativity. The When he started attending the mathematics course, Dirac came under the influence newspapers were full of it." Dirac further added, "...of course, I was caught up in the of two teachers, H. R. Hasse and Peter Fraser who taught applied and pure mathematics excitement produced by relativity." respectively. More than half a century later, Dirac stated, "During this mathematical During this period, Dirac also tried to cultivate some interest in philosophy. In training, the man who influenced me most was Fraser. Fraser was a mathematician who particular, he attended a series of lectures on relativity given by the philosopher Broad. never did any research, never published anything, but he was a wonderful teacher, able to However, "after a lot of thought," Dirac came to the following conclusion: "I then felt that inspire his students with real excitement about basic ideas in mathematics... There were all the things that philosophers said were rather indefinite, and came to the conclusion two things I learnt from Fraser. One of these was rigorous mathematics... The second eventually that I did not think philosophy could contribute anything to the advance of thing I learned from Fraser was projective geometry.