"They Shot Us Like Animals": Black November & Bolivia's Interim
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
“They Shot Us Like Animals” Black November & Bolivia’s Interim Government “They Shot Us Like Animals” Black November & Bolivia’s Interim Government Acknowledgments Th s report was researched and written by Fabiola Alvelais, JD ’20, Laura Clark, JD ’20, Mohammed Elsha- fi , JD ’20, Rund Khayyat, JD ’21, Delany Sisiruca, JD ’21, Nicolas Walker, JD ’21, Julia Wenck, JD ’20, and Clinical Instructor Thomas Becker, JD ’09, of Harvard Law School’s International Human Rights Clin- ic; Camila Bustos, JD ’21, Hannah Carrese, JD ’22, Luke Connell, JD ’22, and Executive Director of the Uni- versity Network for Human Rights and Sidley Austin–Robert D. McLean Visiting Professor of Law James Cavallaro of Yale Law School; and Gemma Canham, BA ’20, of Queen’s University Belfast. The report was translated by Belén García Martínez. The researchers wish to thank the many individuals who were willing to speak with us and share their stories to make this report possible. Cover Photo: Gregoria Siles mourns the death of her son Omar Calle hours after soldiers shot and killed him in Sacaba. ©2019 Thomas Becker Contents I. Table of Acronyms 2 II. Executive Summary 3 III. Methodology 6 IV. Background on the Current Crisis 7 V. State Violence Against Protesters 10 Sacaba Senkata VI. Obstacles to Impartial Investigations & Justice 26 Destroying, Manipulating, and Losing Evidence Impediments for Prosecutors Witness Intimidation VII. Persecution of Dissent 32 Journalists Human Rights Defenders & Activists Political Persecution VIII. Civilian and Para-State Violence 47 Police Officers Presenting as Civilian Civilians Colluding with State Authorities Vigilantism Motoqueros Pro-MAS Civilian Groups IX. Bolivia’s Legal Obligations 54 X. Recommendations 64 XI. Endnotes 66 1 I. Table of Acronyms Adepcoca Departmental Association of Coca Producers of the Yungas of La Paz BBC British Broadcasting Corporation UNCAT Convention against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment CEDAW Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women CONADE National Committee in Defense of Democracy IACHR Inter-American Commission on Human Rights IACtHR Inter-American Court of Human Rights ICCPR International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights IDIF Forensic Investigations Unit IHRC International Human Rights Clinic ITEI Institute of Therapy and Research on the Aftermath of Torture and State Violence FAL Light Automatic Rifl FELCC Special Force to Combat Crime GA General Assembly (of the United Nations) MAS Movement for Socialism OAS Organization of American States SGBV Sexual and gender-based violence TIPNIS Isiboro Secure Indigenous Territory and National Park UN United Nations UNDRIP United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples UDHR Universal Declaration of Human Rights UNHRC United Nations Human Rights Committee 2 II. Executive Summary Following a disputed presidential election on Octo- sites of the killings, where they harassed, beat, and ber 20, 2019, Bolivia has endured a surge of human detained locals. For example, police arrested a dis- rights violations. On November 12, 2019, Jeanine abled child, Kevin Calle Frauz, and his brother and Áñez Chavez became Bolivia’s interim president sister, charging them with terrorism for, according with the mandate of restoring peace and calling to the siblings, walking through the wrong neigh- new elections. Under her administration, however, borhood. All three were tortured while in custody. state-sponsored violence, restrictions on free speech, Police also arrested artist Leonel Pajsi for sedition and arbitrary detentions have all contributed to a cli- for carrying fliers in his backpack stating, “Flowers mate of fear and misinformation that has undermined for the oligarchy, and bullets for the people” and the rule of law as well as the prospects of fair and “We are the people.” open elections. Since the Sacaba and Senkata killings, the inter- In November 2019, state forces carried out opera- im government has continued to persecute people tions that killed at least 23 Bolivian civilians and that it perceives to be outspoken opponents of the injured over 230. These casualties make November Áñez administration. In November, then-Minister of 2019 the second-deadliest month, in terms of civil- Communications Roxana Lizárraga stated that the ian deaths committed by state forces, since Bolivia government had identified seditious journalists and became a democracy nearly 40 years ago. threatened to take actions against them. The gov- ernment has subsequently shut down critical media On November 15, three days after the interim gov- outlets, and police have attacked and arrested jour- ernment took power, state forces opened fire on nalists and those tangentially connected to the press. a nonviolent march passing through the town of For example, police arrested and charged journalist Sacaba, killing at least 11 people and injuring at Alejandra Salinas with sedition after she wrote an least 120 others. All of those killed and injured were online article condemning the government. The gov- indigenous civilians. No police or soldiers were ernment also arrested and charged Orestes Sotomay- killed or injured. In response, Interim President Áñez or Vásquez for owning the domain of the website published Decree 4078, which purported to give that published her article. immunity to the security forces, sparking widespread condemnation from the international community.1 Members of the interim government, including Ánez herself, have also publicly maligned human rights Four days later, on November 19, soldiers fired on defenders and political rivals, particularly those in demonstrators and bystanders outside the Senkata the Movement for Socialism (MAS) party, referring gas plant in El Alto, killing at least 11 and injuring to them as “Indian(s)” and “animal(s)” and suggest- over 50. Again, all casualties were indigenous civil- ing that they are rapists. Furthermore, the interim ians, and no police or soldiers were shot. The interim government has charged a number of former politi- government asserted that civilians, not state forces, cians with vague crimes such as sedition or terror- were responsible for the violence in Senkata. ism. By the beginning of 2020, over 100 MAS politi- cians had been detained or were facing charges, and In the weeks following these killings, security forces nearly 600 former officials and their families were – often collaborating with para-state groups – en- under investigation, prompting public statements of tered neighborhoods, hospitals, and schools near the concern by representatives from the United Nations 3 and the Inter-American Commission. quired to conduct a prompt, effective, impartial, and transparent investigation. In regard to the Civilian groups aligned with the government have killings in Sacaba and Senkata as well as other also carried out human rights violations, often human rights violations since November, Bolivia with the support of security forces. For example, has yet to fulfill this obligation. The IHRC team anti-MAS protestors kidnapped the mayor of Vin- documented multiple alarming obstacles that to, Patricia Arce, dragged her through the street, have undermined comprehensive investigations, dumped red paint on her, cut her hair, and forced including evidence tampering; autopsy irregular- her to denounce the MAS party. The Inter-Ameri- ities; overworked and under resourced prosecu- can Commission granted Mayor Arce precaution- tors; refusal by state officials to provide infor - ary measures, requiring the interim government to mation; and witness intimidation. These barriers provide her protections. Instead, the Áñez adminis- undermine justice for the victims and create a tration has harassed her, accused her of kidnapping climate of impunity in Bolivia. herself, and charged her with sedition. 3. Persecution of Dissent : Freedom of assembly, In response to these abuses, the International Human association, and expression are fundamental Rights Clinic at Harvard Law School (“IHRC” or pillars of a functioning democracy. According to the “Clinic”) and the University Network for Human eyewitnesses, the Áñez administration has con- Rights carried out a roughly six-month indepen- tinued to undermine these rights since Novem- dent investigation, interviewing over 200 victims, ber 2019. Officials have threatened journalists witnesses, journalists, and officials, to document and shut down critical media outlets; arbitrarily the repression that has occurred since the interim arrested and tortured activists; and charged polit- government came to power in November 2019. This ical opponents with vague crimes such as “sedi- investigation has identified four concrete areas in tion” and “terrorism.” These attacks have pro- which authorities have violated the human rights of voked a climate of fear in many communities in Bolivians and foreign nationals: Bolivia and have raised serious concerns about the possibility of and commitment to holding 1. State Violence Against Protesters: In Sacaba free and fair elections. and Senkata, the use of force by the Bolivian police and armed forces against unarmed or 4. Civilian and Para-state Violence : State actors nonviolent protestors and other civilians has are not the only ones committing human rights directly violated the right to life. According to violations in Bolivia. Civilians have organized eyewitnesses in both locations, security forces into vigilante groups, undertaking policing opened fire –