DOCSLIB.ORG

The Space Between Aristotle and the Bush Administration: Considering the Impact of "Goodwill" on International Relations" (2008)

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
The Space Between Aristotle and the Bush Administration: Considering the Impact of Eastern Michigan University DigitalCommons@EMU Master's Theses, and Doctoral Dissertations, and Master's Theses and Doctoral Dissertations Graduate Capstone Projects 2008 The ps ace between Aristotle and the Bush administration: Considering the impact of "goodwill" on international relations Anke Thorey Wolbert Follow this and additional works at: http://commons.emich.edu/theses Part of the Rhetoric Commons Recommended Citation Wolbert, Anke Thorey, "The space between Aristotle and the Bush administration: Considering the impact of "goodwill" on international relations" (2008). Master's Theses and Doctoral Dissertations. 187. http://commons.emich.edu/theses/187 This Open Access Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by the Master's Theses, and Doctoral Dissertations, and Graduate Capstone Projects at DigitalCommons@EMU. It has been accepted for inclusion in Master's Theses and Doctoral Dissertations by an authorized administrator of DigitalCommons@EMU. For more information, please contact [email protected]. The space between Aristotle and the Bush Administration: Considering the impact of “goodwill” on international relations by Anke Thorey Wolbert Thesis Submitted to the Department of Communication and Theatre Arts Eastern Michigan University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of MASTERS OF ARTS in Communication Thesis Committee: Raymond Quiel, Chair Michael Tew, PhD Doris Fields, PhD March 13, 2008 ii Abstract Focusing on the Bush Administration’s post-September 11 rhetoric, this thesis investigates the impact this rhetoric had on the Administration’s perceived credibility by the international community with specific focus on Germany’s, France’s, and Great Britain’s reactions. Of particular interest is the importance of eunoia (goodwill) as an aspect of the speaker’s ethos. Considering that goodwill has been viewed as the lost dimension of Aristotle’s ethos (credibility) this analysis provides the basis to argue that goodwill should be treated as a major component of ethos. A textual analysis of rhetorical acts as well as media reactions sheds light on the role goodwill played in the Bush Administration’s credibility post-September 11 as perceived by the international audience. The findings of this thesis indicate that the failure to establish effective goodwill messages has negatively impacted the Bush Administration’s credibility as perceived by the audience, supporting the importance of goodwill on ethos. iii Table of Contents Chapter 1................................................................................................................................... 1 Introduction........................................................................................................................... 1 Literature Review.................................................................................................................. 2 Ethos ................................................................................................................................. 2 Today’s view of ethos....................................................................................................... 2 Aristotle’s view of ethos. .................................................................................................. 4 The concept of goodwill. .................................................................................................. 6 Problem................................................................................................................................. 8 Purpose.................................................................................................................................. 9 Chapter 2................................................................................................................................. 10 Methodology....................................................................................................................... 10 Artifacts........................................................................................................................... 11 Procedures....................................................................................................................... 12 Goodwill ..................................................................................................................... 12 The rhetorical acts of the Bush Administration .......................................................... 13 The international press reactions .................................................................................... 14 Chapter 3................................................................................................................................. 15 Textual Analysis and Response .......................................................................................... 15 Address to a Joint Session of Congress and the American People, September 20, 200115 International press reactions ........................................................................................... 18 “No nation can be neutral in this conflict,” November 6, 2001...................................... 21 iv International press reactions ........................................................................................... 24 “Remarks by President Bush to the United Nations, November 10, 2001” ................... 26 International press reactions ........................................................................................... 30 “Axis of Evil,” State of the Union Address, January 29, 2002....................................... 33 International press reactions ........................................................................................... 37 President thanks world coalition for anti-terrorism efforts, March 11, 2002 ................. 39 International press reactions ........................................................................................... 43 President Bush thanks Germany for support against terror, May 23, 2002.................... 45 International press reactions ........................................................................................... 49 President’s remarks at the United Nations General Assembly, September 12, 2002..... 52 International press reactions ........................................................................................... 57 Findings............................................................................................................................... 60 Chapter 4................................................................................................................................. 66 Discussion........................................................................................................................... 66 Outcome.......................................................................................................................... 66 Implications..................................................................................................................... 67 Limitations ...................................................................................................................... 69 Future Research .............................................................................................................. 70 Conclusion .......................................................................................................................... 71 References............................................................................................................................... 72 Bibliography ........................................................................................................................... 84 APPENDICES ........................................................................................................................ 91 v Appendix A:............................................................................................................................ 92 Address to a Joint Session of Congress and the American People, September 20, 2001... 92 Appendix B:.......................................................................................................................... 102 “No nation can be neutral in this conflict,” November 6, 2001........................................ 102 Appendix C:.......................................................................................................................... 106 “Remarks by President Bush to the United Nations, November 10, 2001” ..................... 106 Appendix D:.......................................................................................................................... 115 “Axis of Evil,” State of the Union Address, January 29, 2002......................................... 115 Appendix E: .......................................................................................................................... 128 President thanks world coalition for anti-terrorism efforts, March 11, 2002 ................... 128 Appendix F: .......................................................................................................................... 135 President Bush thanks Germany for support against terror, May 23, 2002...................... 135 Appendix G:.......................................................................................................................... 144 President’s remarks at the United Nations General Assembly, September 12, 2002....... 144 Chapter 1 Introduction
Load more

Recommended publications
  • George W. Bush Library Press
    George W. Bush Presidential Library Phone: 972-353-0545 1725 Lakepointe Drive Fax: 972-353-0599 Lewisville, TX 75057 Email: [email protected] Press Kit Freedom Plaza George W. Bush Presidential Library Website: www.georgewbushlibrary.gov George W. Bush Presidential Library Phone: 972-353-0545 1725 Lakepointe Drive Fax: 972-353-0599 Lewisville, TX 75057 Email: [email protected] Welcome! Thank you very much for your interest in the George W. Bush Presidential Library. As part of the George W. Bush Presidential Center at Southern Methodist University (SMU), we are proud to serve as the nation’s 13th Presidential library administered by the National Archives and Records Administration. The George W. Bush Presidential Library serves as a resource for the study of George W. Bush and the Bush Administration. More generally, the Library also provides invaluable information for the study of the presidency, important events and developments in recent American history, and the making of public policy. The Library accomplishes its mission by preserving and providing access to presidential records and other donated collections, hosting public programs, creating educational initiatives, preserving artifacts, and producing innovative museum exhibits. Our archival collections are extensive. We have over 70 million pages of paper documents, approximately 80 terabytes of electronic information (including over 209 million emails), 43,000 artifacts (consisting primarily of foreign and domestic gifts to the President and First Lady), and an immense audiovisual archives, including nearly 4 million photographs. Our duty is to preserve these materials, process them, and make them accessible for research. Our future museum will tell the story of the Bush Administration within the context of four principles that guide the decisions and actions of the President and Mrs.
    [Show full text]
  • Policy Brief #155 the Brookings Institution June 2006
    Policy Brief #155 The Brookings Institution June 2006 International Volunteering: Smart Power By Lex Rieffel and Sarah Zalud EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The face of America that has been welcomed most enthusiastically in the rest of the world for decades has been the face of a volunteer: assisting with disaster relief, building houses for poor families, teaching English to university students, and so much more. International volunteer programs contribute directly and indirectly to our nation’s security and well-being. They represent one of the best avenues Americans can pursue to improve relations with the rest of the world. The scale of these programs, however, is far below the levels suggested by their benefits. The federal budget for FY 2006 supports 75,000 AmeriCorps volunteers working domestically but only 7,800 Peace Corps volunteers working in foreign countries. Reflecting the value that Americans see in volunteering overseas, programs in the private sector have grown rapidly in the past ten years. In 2005, at least 50,000 Americans participated in NGO and corporate programs. The number could be much higher, easily more than 100,000, with a program like AmeriCorps that leverages private funding. The number could be doubled again by offering additional options suitable to large pools of talent, such as retiring baby boomers. The potential dividends from scaling up international volunteer programs are impressive relative to most other “soft power” programs of the U.S. government. The time is ripe for a breakthrough in this area, with policies aimed at strengthening existing programs such as increased funding for the Peace Corps, raising the public awareness of volunteer programs overseas, linking service and studie, and measuring effectiveness.
    [Show full text]
  • A Bipartisan Blueprint
    COMMISSION ON POLITICAL REFORM Governing in a Polarized America: A Bipartisan Blueprint to Strengthen our Democracy This report is the product of the BPC Commission on Political Reform with participants of diverse expertise and affiliations, addressing many complex and contentious topics. It is inevitable that arriving at a consensus document in these circumstances entailed compromises. Accordingly, it should not be assumed that every member is entirely satisfied with every formulation in this document, or even that all participants would agree with any given recommendation if it were taken in isolation. Rather, this group reached consensus on these recommendations as a package. The findings and recommendations expressed herein are solely those of the commission and do not necessarily represent the views or opinions of the Bipartisan Policy Center, its founders, or its Board of Directors. Governing in a Polarized America: A Bipartisan Blueprint to Strengthen our Democracy 1 BPC Commission on Political Reform CO-CHAIRS Tom Daschle Dirk Kempthorne Olympia Snowe Former U.S. Senate Majority Leader Former Governor of Idaho, U.S. Former U.S. Senator (D-SD); Co-founder, BPC Secretary of the Interior, and U.S. (R-ME); Senior Fellow, BPC Senator (R-ID); President and CEO, Dan Glickman American Council of Life Insurers Former U.S. Secretary of Agriculture and U.S. Representative (D-KS); Trent Lott Senior Fellow, BPC Former U.S. Senate Majority Leader (R-MS); Senior Fellow, BPC COMMISSIONERS Hope Andrade Heather Gerken David McIntosh Former Texas Secretary of State (R) J. Skelly Wright Professor of Law, Yale Former U.S. Representative (R-IN); Law School Partner, Mayer Brown LLP Molly Barker Founder, Girls on the Run Michael Gerson Eric L.
    [Show full text]
  • Proclamation 7875—National Poison Prevention Week, 2005 March 18
    478 Mar. 18 / Administration of George W. Bush, 2005 by the Office of the Press Secretary also included third week of March each year as ‘‘National the remarks of former First Lady Barbara Bush. Poison Prevention Week.’’ Now, Therefore, I, George W. Bush, President of the United States of America, Proclamation 7875—National Poison do hereby proclaim March 20 through March Prevention Week, 2005 26, 2005, as National Poison Prevention March 18, 2005 Week. I call upon all Americans to observe this week by participating in appropriate By the President of the United States ceremonies and activities and by learning of America how to prevent poisonings among children. In Witness Whereof, I have hereunto set A Proclamation my hand this eighteenth day of March, in National Poison Prevention Week reminds the year of our Lord two thousand five, and us that young children need constant close of the Independence of the United States of supervision by responsible adults to keep America the two hundred and twenty-ninth. them safe. This week highlights the dangers George W. Bush of accidental poisonings, steps that can be taken to reduce risks, and what to do in case [Filed with the Office of the Federal Register, of an emergency. 10:03 a.m., March 22, 2005] Poison control centers receive approxi- NOTE: This proclamation will be published in the mately one million calls each year about chil- Federal Register on March 23. dren who have ingested dangerous medicines or chemicals they have found around their homes. Since the first National Poison Pre- vention Week 43 years ago, many deaths and injuries have been prevented through in- Digest of Other creased public awareness, the use of child- White House Announcements resistant packaging, and a national network of poison control centers.
    [Show full text]
  • Neighborhood Watch Manual Usaonwatch - National Neighborhood Watch Program
    Neighborhood Watch Manual USAonWatch - National Neighborhood Watch Program Bureau of Justice Assistance U.S. Department of Justice 1 This manual has been created for citizen organizers and law enforcement officers that work with community members to establish watch programs. The material contained within covers a number of topics and provides suggestions for developing a watch groups. However, please incorporate topics and issues that are important to your group into your watch. Grant Statement: This document was prepared by the National Sheriffs’ Association, under cooperative agreement number 2005-MU- BX-K077, awarded by the Bureau of Justice Assistance, Office of Justice Programs, U.S. Department of Justice. The opinions, findings, and conclusions or recommendations expressed in this document are those of the authors and do not necessarily represent the official position of the U.S. Department of Justice. Table of Contents Chapter 1: USAonWatch – The National Face of Neighborhood Watch Page 1 • What is Neighborhood Watch • Program History • Many Different Names, One Idea • Benefits of Neighborhood Watch Chapter 2: Who is Involved in Neighborhood Watch? Page 4 • Starting a Neighborhood Watch Chapter 3: Organizing Your Neighborhood Watch Page 6 • Phone Trees • Neighborhood Maps Chapter 4: Planning and Conducting Meetings Page 10 • Inviting Neighbors • Meeting Logistics • Facilitating Meetings • Alternatives to Meetings • Ideas for Creative Meetings • Neighborhood Watch Activities Chapter 5: Revitalizing Watch Groups Page 18 • Recognize
    [Show full text]
  • Volunteers in Police Service
    Volunteers In Police Service Volunteers of all ages are serving their community through their local, county and state law enforcement agencies. The V.I.P.S. are Recognized by the Internation- al Chiefs of Police Associations, Citizens Corps, USA Freedom Corps, United States Department of Justice, and USAonwatch as citizens aid in their own community Serving the Community with: with Home Land Security. d Citizens On Patrol (COPS) d Administrative / Clerical d Police and Fire Dispatching d Community Emergency Response Teams (CERT) d Police Explorer Scout Post #2961 d Community Security Services Volunteers In Service, Pride, Police Service Patience, Courtesy, Vigilance Florence Police Department Become a Volunteer PO Box 988 Make a Difference 425 North Pinal Street Tel: 520-868-7666 Florence, Arizona 85132-0988 [email protected] VIPS: 520-868-7666 [email protected] Explorers: 520-868-7688 [email protected] PROGRAM HISTORY TYPES OF VOLUNTEER OPPORTUNITIES In his 2002 State of the Union Address, Presi- Volunteers in Police Service are for adults 18 dent George W. Bush announced the creation years of age and above who are interested in The Florence Police Explorer Post #2961 is a serving their community through law enforce- of the USA Freedom Corps, an effort to foster worksite-based program for young men and ment. a culture of service, citizenship, and respon- women who have completed the eighth grade sibility, building on the generous spirit of the There are many different types of volunteer pro- and are 14 years of age, or are 15 years of age American People. The Citizen Corps programs grams and volunteer opportunities, including: but have not yet reached their 21st birthday.
    [Show full text]
  • News Archive - OU Student Honored by President Bush
    Oakland University - News Archive - OU student honored by President Bush Friday, January 31, 2003 OU student honored by President Bush By Jeff Samoray, OU Web Writer Presidential receptions, speeches, TV interviews – all have been part of Lenny Compton's world since he began his whirlwind trip to Washington, D.C., Jan. 28 as a guest of President George W. Bush for the State of the Union address. Compton, an OU senior education major, was invited to attend the address in recognition of his volunteer work for AmeriCorps, a national community service program to which he has devoted more than 1,800 hours. During the address, Compton sat three chairs away from First Lady Laura Bush in the House Gallery. He also toured the White House, met the president at a post- address reception and spoke with him about volunteerism at a panel discussion on mentoring. "I can't narrow my visit down to the best part, but my favorite part was going to the White House," Compton said. "To be received at the White House was a privilege, and it was an honor to represent Oakland University and the volunteer work that millions are doing across the nation. "After the State of the Union address, we were escorted downstairs to meet the president and the first lady. I had a chance to have a photo taken with them, and I thanked the first lady for having me. President Bush saw me and said, 'I know this gentleman – he's Lenny Compton.' That was a big thrill. I told him I enjoyed his passionate delivery.” Compton's visit was coordinated by the Corporation for National and Community Service, which oversees AmeriCorps, Senior Corps and Learn and Serve America.
    [Show full text]
  • We're a Peaceful Nation
    “We’re a peaceful nation” – nation” a peaceful “We’re “We’re a peaceful nation” krigsretorik efter 11 september ”Man kan fundera på varför traditionell krigspropaganda i dagens kritiska massmediesamhälle fortfarande fungerar. Svaret är förmodligen enkelt: när det uppstår en hotfull krissituation med många komplicerade faktorer så tas enkla lösningar tacksamt emot. Ett krig som förknippas med begrepp som jakt, spel eller arbete blir mera acceptabelt. En fiende som är ond är ett legitimt mål. Ett krig som omtolkas till humanitär insats är inte längre ett krig. I dagens demokratiska samhälle bör vi emellertid ha kommit längre än att nöja oss med enkla svar, även i akuta krissituationer. Skepsis, tvivel och ifrå- kri gasättanden när det gäller krigsstrategernas verklighetsbeskrivningar bör inte gsretor bara vara tillåtna utan uppmuntras, premieras och prioriteras, för att motverka propagandans övermakt.” Brigitte Mral ikseptember 11 efter Denna studie belyser vilka retoriska grepp som användes under de militära aktioner som inleddes som en direkt följd av händelserna den 11 september. Syftet är att komma fram till en bättre förståelse för krigsstrategernas mål- inriktade arbete med att definiera världen åt oss. Brigitte Mral är professor i retorik vid Humanistiska institutionen, Örebro universitet. Brigitte Mral Brigitte ”We’re a peaceful nation” krigsretorik efter 11 september Krisberedskapsmyndigheten Box 599 KBM:S | 2004:5 TEMASERIE 101 31 Stockholm Brigitte Mral Tel 08-593 710 00 Fax 08-593 710 01 kbm@krisberedskaps myndigheten.se ISSN 1652-2915 ISSN 1652-3970 www.krisberedskaps kbm:s temaserie | 2004:5 ISBN 91-85053-60-0 myndigheten.se kbm:s temaserie | 2004:5 ”We’re a peaceful nation” krigsretorik efter 11 september Brigitte Mral Titel: ”We’re a peaceful nation” – Krigsretorik efter 11 september Utgiven av Krisberedskapsmyndigheten (KBM) Omslagsfoto: President George W.
    [Show full text]
  • George W. Bush Evaluating the President at Midterm
    George W. Bush Evaluating the President at Midterm EDITED BY Bryan Hilliard Tom Lansford Robert P. Watson George W. Bush SUNY series on the Presidency: Contemporary Issues John Kenneth White, editor George W. Bush Evaluating the President at Midterm Edited By Bryan Hilliard, Tom Lansford, Robert P.Watson State University of New York Press Published by State University of New York Press, Albany © 2004 State University of New York All rights reserved Printed in the United States of America No part of this book may be used or reproduced in any manner whatsoever without written permission. No part of this book may be stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means including electronic, electrostatic, magnetic tape, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise without the prior permission in writing of the publisher. For information, address State University of New York Press, 90 State Street, Suite 700, Albany, NY 12207 Production by Michael Haggett Marketing by Susan M. Petrie Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data George W. Bush: evaluating the president at midterm/edited by Bryan Hilliard, Tom Lansford, and Robert P.Watson. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 0-7914-6133-5 (hardcover: alk. paper—ISBN 0-7914-6134-3 (pbk.: alk. paper) 1. Bush, George W. (George Walker), 1946– 2. United States—Politics and government—2001. I. Hilliard, Bryan, 1957– II. Lansford, Tom. III. Watson, Robert P.,1963– E903.G465 2005 973.931Ј092—dc22 2004008538 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 For Brenda, Amber, and Claudia— With all our love and admiration Contents Preface ix Introduction 1 Robert P.Watson, Bryan Hilliard, and Tom Lansford Part 1 Leadership and Character 17 Chapter 1 The Arbiter of Fate: The Presidential Character of George W.
    [Show full text]
  • MD Responds Medical Reserve Corps
    Maryland Department of Health & Mental Hygiene Office of Preparedness & Response MD Responds Medical Reserve Corps Volunteer Management Guide Version 3.1 May 2014 This Page Intentionally Left Blank MDRMRC Volunteer Management Guide, V3.1 Table of Contents Table of Contents Acronym List ..................................................................................................................................... 5 Chapter 1: Introduction ..................................................................................................................... 7 A. Purpose ............................................................................................................................................................7 B. Distribution ......................................................................................................................................................7 C. Revisions ..........................................................................................................................................................8 D. Record of Changes Table .................................................................................................................................9 E. Additional Information .................................................................................................................................. 10 F. Acknowledgements ....................................................................................................................................... 10 Chapter 2:
    [Show full text]
  • Loyalty Day, 2008
    Proclamations Proc. 8245 Through volunteer work, Americans can demonstrate the kindness and gen- erosity that make our Nation great. Mentoring a child, teaching someone to read, visiting the elderly, feeding the hungry, and finding shelter for the homeless are all examples of how Americans can and do aid those in need. Americans are volunteering in record numbers. Each year, millions of Americans volunteer, and more of our fellow citizens are discovering that the pursuit of happiness leads to the path of service. The cumulative effort of the love and compassion from our Nation’s volunteers will help secure a more hopeful future for all our citizens. My Administration remains committed to building a culture of service, citi- zenship, and responsibility. The USA Freedom Corps strengthens civic en- gagement and volunteer service in America and helps people connect with volunteer opportunities. By visiting the USA Freedom Corps website at vol- unteer.gov, individuals can find information about ways they can help in their local areas and across the country. The strength of America comes from its compassionate and loving citizens. National Volunteer Week is an opportunity to show appreciation for our Nation’s volunteers. The time and energy they dedicate to helping those in need reflect the true spirit of America. NOW, THEREFORE, I, GEORGE W. BUSH, President of the United States of America, by virtue of the authority vested in me by the Constitution and laws of the United States, do hereby proclaim April 27 through May 3, 2008, as National Volunteer Week. I call upon all Americans to recognize and celebrate the important work that volunteers do every day throughout our country.
    [Show full text]
  • Subject Index
    Subject Index Abortion. See Health and medical care Agriculture, Department of—Continued Abu Sayyaf terrorist group. See Philippines Forest Service, U.S.—464, 1063 Acquired immune deficiency syndrome (AIDS). Funding—464 See Health and medical care Inspector General—1096 Adoption, National Council for—1101 Secretary—58, 61, 65, 193, 229, 325, 657, Advisory. See other part of subject 781, 858, 1046, 1051 Aeronautics and Space Administration, Na- AIDS. See Health and medical care tional—1089, 1093, 1105, 1110 Air and Space Museum, National. See Smithso- Afghan Children, America’s Fund for—420, 459, nian Institution 460 Air Force, Department of the Afghanistan See also Armed Forces, U.S. Afghan Interim Authority Air Force Academy, U.S.—1104, 812 Chairman—121, 127, 130, 1087, 1098, 1103 Chief of Staff—812 Minister of Women’s Affairs—130 Eglin Air Force Base, FL—170 Ambassador to U.S.—1111 Elmendorf Air Force Base, AK—236 Canadian military personnel, deaths—638, 642 Groom Lake, NV, operating location near— Earthquakes—1098, 1099 143 Peacekeeping efforts—75 Osan Air Base, South Korea—260 Taliban—3, 1017, 1027, 1044 Al Qaida terrorist group—295, 328, 329, 398, Normal trade relations status—714 422, 577, 644, 798, 844, 970, 1006 Transitional Authority—1111 Alabama, Governor—279 U.S. Ambassador—1094 Alaska U.S. assistance—122, 125, 127, 128, 233, 420, Disaster assistance—1113 460, 1103 Governor—236 U.S. military personnel, deaths—8, 40, 987 President’s visit—236, 241, 1092 U.S. military role—328, 422 Republican Party event—241 Africa Alaska Federation of Natives, Inc.—1092 See also specific country Albania, U.S.
    [Show full text]