THE WORLD of ROMANIA Works That Made This Planet a Better Place - Part II

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

THE WORLD of ROMANIA Works That Made This Planet a Better Place - Part II THE WORLD OF ROMANIA Works that made this planet a better place - Part II - The following editorial dossier is elaborated by students at the Master’s Program “International Economic Diplomacy”, from the Faculty of International Business and Economics, the Bucharest University of Economic Studies, Romania. THE WORLD OF ROMANIA TITU MAIORESCU: “CRITICISM Can BE BITTER, BUT IT MUST BE RIGHT” Alexandru IORDĂNESCU f Romanian modern culture and civilization had an in- stance”. He condemns the introduction of institutions im- ventory of its “Founding Fathers”, Titu Maiorescu would ported from the West and which did not correspond to the definitely stand at the forefront. He was a man of his mentality, culture and dispositions of the Romanian peo- words and a man of his deeds: literary critic, essayist, ple. A central personality of the Romanian culture, Maio- Iwriter, aesthetician, professor, philosopher, jurist and pol- rescu is a founding member of the Romanian Academy. itician. He took active part in the establishment of the Ro- manian Academy, but, first and foremost, in the establish- The politics of a true national language ment of critical and creative spirit in both intellectual and civic life, his true legacy. The year 1871 definitively enshrines the entrance of Unlike the other illustrious politicians of his generation, the Junimists on the side of political activism. On April 15, Titu Liviu Maiorescu came from a peasant family from 1871, a meeting between Gheorghe Costaforu and Titu Bucerdea, near Blaj. His father, Ioan, the son of a Maiorescu took place in Iaşi, the first propos- Transylvanian peasant, was called Trifu, but ing to Junimea’s mentor that the members he was named Maiorescu to emphasize of the society should get into politics. his relationship with Petru Maior. He This was a turning point in the histo- was a history teacher, director of ry of Romanian conservatism and the Central School of Craiova, a politics. The Junimists will adopt diplomatic agent of the Walla- an action program in keeping chian government. His mother, with the 1857 Ad Hoc Assem- Maria Popasu, was the sister blies’ decisions, of which a of the scholar Bishop of Ca- series were to be fulfilled: ransebeş. compliance with the Sub- After graduating from lime Porte capitulations, gymnasium in Craiova guaranteed neutrality and and Braşov, young Titu even the achievement of is sent to the Theresian our country’s indepen- Academy in Vienna, dence. which, in July 1858, he The leader of the Juni- graduated as valedictori- mist group made a mark an. He enrolled at the Uni- on the entire cultural versity of Giessen, where, movement of the day. His in 1859, he obtained his works were published in doctorate in Philosophy Convorbiri Literare; of their with the distinction “mag- multitude, we are only in- na cum laudae”. Maiorescu terested in those that focus continued his studies at the on Romanian language and Sorbonne University in Paris, literature, studies by which Titu where he obtained the degree in Maiorescu became the guide of Letters, Philosophy and Law. Romanian literature, our first liter- Through the developmental trends ary critic. As a literary critic, he will of the age, there was a new, modern decisively put his mark on Romanian direction being infused into our culture, de- creations and creators, having a significant fined by its ethical spirit and the sense of aes- intuition for the discovery of talent. thetic value. The conditions in the country were growing The Romanian language spoken today has a founder different from those of the times of Ion Heliade Rădulescu, in Titu Maiorescu. In terms of aesthetics, he will establish Vasile Alecsandri, or Nicolae Bălcescu. Maiorescu and his a stable foundation for the study of literary works, will offer colleagues represented the new generation, the Junimea true lessons of taste, refinement and culture to the young, literary society, with a new conception of the Romanian so- thus proving the most penetrating personality of the sec- cial and cultural life. Titu Maiorescu is also the author of the ond half of 19th century. Junimist and conservative theory of “forms without sub- Titu Maiorescu’s language ideas include three main di- No 10/2018, Mar. - Apr. 26 The betterment of civilizati`on emphasizing the value of the art of correcting and admonishing”. He listed the three great ideolo- gies launched by Titu Maiorescu: the match between substance and form, the inauguration of the critical spirit, and the “placing of criticism on the edges of the truth, that is, its clearing out of any constraint from outside”. We have turned our attention to this aspect because we be- lieve that he himself has speci- fied his role in the era, his stated purpose being not to produce poets but to embellish a “new direction” in Romanian culture in terms of understanding the character and the authentic fea- tures of art. In addition, the later Maiorescu style critique (as ev- idenced in The New Direction in Romanian poetry and prose, Romanian and Foreign Litera- ture, Mr. Caragiale’s Comedies, rections: the writing of the Roman literary language, as Eminescu and his poems, etc.) represents a development opposed to the spoken vernacular; the problem of loan- of the original aesthetic principles formulated during his words, given the disparate influences acting on various studies, being seen as the basis of a true culture that portion of lands inhabited by Romanians; combating the evolves historically, through a concrete manner in which tendencies of language corruption. spiritual values manifest​​ themselves in the historical as- Maiorescu’s principles of writing the Roman language pects of reality. were: introducing the Latin alphabet; removing the Cyrillic Eugen Lovinescu will challenge the validity of the argu- alphabet; phonetic spelling; combating etymological or- ment, arguing that art is not a repaint of intelligence, and thography, where words are written differently from how it demands even greater strain than scientific work. The they are pronounced, as in English. debauchery which Maiorescu speaks of is not confused It is not exaggerated to say that at the root of the great with the fun literature that Lovinescu seems to refer to, but achievements of the Romanian culture we will always dis- is the disinterested action of classical art, in which artistic cover Maiorescu, a lighthouse that illuminates all the aspi- thinking, by its form, has the ability to encompass and in- rations and efforts of the creative and critical spirit. corporate complete meaning in expression. In the study entitled Titu Maiorescu’s Aesthetic Ideas, Tu- The art of correcting and admonishing dor Vianu concludes that the aesthetic ideal that governs the critic’s research is elusive as “while in principle he claims Maiorescu has been criticized for not dedicating more classicism, his developments show some romantic predi- time to literature, but his critically acclaimed work marks one lections”. This idea is generated by the three similarities be- of the most flourishing epochs in the history of Romanian tween affection and poetry: “a greater rapidity of the move- literature: the period of great classics. Junimea (and Maio- ment of ideas, an exaggeration or at least a magnification rescu himself) is (are) related to the creation and pathway and a new look of objects under the impulse of feeling and to the public consciousness of writers such as Eminescu, passion, a rapid growth towards a climax or a catastrophe”. Creangă, Caragiale, Slavici, Duiliu Zamfirescu and others. Maiorescu’s classicist formula explains his intention to Titu Maiorescu had extensive interests, covering many establish the main coordinates of the Romanian poetry of areas. He is the author of ideas, with an original style, char- 1867, but also the artistic exigency manifested against the acterized by a polemic, academic and ironic spirit. He is literature of the moment. also the first literary and cultural critic and he directed the culture in the second half of the nineteenth century. Under his aegis, the literature of the great classics was created. Bibliography He knew how to spot the true value of his contemporaries. Academia Română. 2005. Dicţionarul General al Literaturii Române. Bucureşti: Univers Enciclopedic. He drew attention to the quantity-quality ratio and pulled Manolescu, N. 2000. Contradicţia lui Maiorescu. public regard towards the second part of the equation. Bucureşti: Editura Humanitas. George Călinescu praised Titu Maiorescu as “he is first Orzea, Z. 1997. Viaţa lui Titu Maiorescu, vol. II. Bucureşti: Editura Du Style. of all a great polemicist who can take advantage of the cir- http://cuvintecelebre.ro/citate/autori/titu-maiorescu/. cumstance of living in a world which is inferior to his level, http://enciclopediaromaniei.ro/wiki/Titu_Maiorescu. 27 www.themarketforideas.com THE WORLD OF ROMANIA MIHAIL ManoileSCU: “ProteCTIONISM 2.0” – THE (New) NAME OF THE (OLD) Game IN POStwar DEVelopmentaliSM Larissa BACK ihail Manoilescu, more than an engineer, jour- the First World War, became the General Director of the nalist or professor, was a Romanian political Ministry of Industry and Trade in 1921. and economic thinker. Although in his country Mihail Manoilescu started his incursion into the busi- he was not recognized and his theory used, he ness world through investment in the minerals sector. To- Mhas inspired other countries in different regions. His as- gether with his brother, Grigore Manoilescu, he became cension was great, as great as his fall. Mihail Manoilescu co-owner of Sorecani Mines, in Cluj County. They made a ended up in the darkness of oblivion, obscurity significant investment and opened new galleries and, consequently, death. considerably increasing the production of lignite. They established an agreement Early years with the Belgian company Electrobel to build a power plant in Aghireşu, Mihail Manoilescu was born on inaugurated in 1930.
Recommended publications
  • Fulbright Ripple Effect on International Education Fulbri In
    Coperta_Fulbright_Ripple_Effect.qxd 27.01.2011 11:36 Page 1 EDITORS EDITORS Remus Pricopie Remus Pricopie Dorina Guþu Dorina Guþu Mihai Moroiu Mihai Moroiu Editors Dorina Guþu Mihai Moroiu Remus Pricopie Fulbright Program Fulbright Ripple Effect on International Education in Romania – Landmarks Looking ahead from a Romanian & American Perspective 1960 First document signed by the Government of Romania and the Government of the United States of America setting the bases of This volume is the third in the series celebrating 50 years of Fulbright presence in Romania, the Fulbright Program in Romania; as part of the initiative to present a broad practical and theoretical image of the Fulbright ripple effect on education and society as a whole, its capacity to break down barriers, to connect and set up networks, to create and deepen ties in learning, in science and research. 1960 First U.S. Fulbright grantees in Romania; It is our hope that, putting the spotlight on some of the Fulbright experiences, we will better 1962 First Romanian grantees in the U.S.; understand not just how this great program has changed paths of life and contributed to the progress of at least some aspects of life around us, but also the responsibility we have today 1993 Establishment of the Romanian-U.S. Fulbright Commission; for building future generations. It is our duty to keep the Fulbright spirit at least at the same level of effervescence as before, to make this anniversary mark just the first 50 years of a much longer endeavor, and give our children the possibility to attend, 50 years from now, the 2000 The two Governments decide to renew their agreement and extend 100th celebration of the Fulbright Program in Romania, and to conclude, at the end of THAT cooperation; DAY, acknowledging the fact that we have done all in our power and contributed to it.
    [Show full text]
  • Sus Par Nume Au, Impar Tl
    PORTRETUL PERECHII PRINCIARE MOŞTENITOARE FERDINAND ŞI MARIA DIN VIZIUNEA REGINEI ELISABETA A ROMÂNIEI ÎN SCRISORI PERSONALE ŞI TEXTE PENTRU PUBLICUL LARG * Silvia Irina ZIMMERMANN Abstract: Several literary texts of Carmen Sylva (penname of the Queen Elisabeth, consort of King Carol Ist of Romania) contain autobiographical aspects, but there are only a few diaries she published, such as Pe Dunăre (Sailing the Danube River, 1905), where she writes about the members of the Romanian royal family. Whereas in the autobiographical works Carmen Sylva draws a mostly positive image of the royal family, the personal correspondence of the Queen reveals the whole range of intimate sentiments, hopes, disappointments, and resentments regarding her life and family relationships. In her letters to her princiary family in Neuwied and to her husband, King Carol Ist, she writes frankly, often critically, sometimes caustically, about the family members including the hereditary couple Ferdinand and Marie („Nando” and „Missy”). Keywords: King Carol Ist of Romania, Carmen Sylva – Elisabeth of Romania, King Ferdinand of Romania, Mary of Romania, royality, literature, history, letters. „Carmen Sylva vedea cu ochii ei, auzea cu urechile ei, vorbea cu limba ei” – astfel o caracteriza Principesa Moştenitoare Maria pe prima regină a * Lucrarea a fost prezentată în cadrul simpozionului organizat de Muzeul Naţional Peleş, „Reşedinţele regale de la Sinaia. Artă şi istorie. Regele Ferdinand I şi Regina Maria”, în perioada 17-18 septembrie 2015 la Buşteni. REVISTA BIBLIOTECII ACADEMIEI ROMÂNE, Anul 1, nr. 2, iunie-decembrie 2016, p. 11-35. 12 Silvia Irina ZIMMERMANN României în însemnările din anul 19131. Mai mult decât atât, prima regină a Românei, Elisabeta de Wied, a avut o mare notorietate la vremea ei, datorită activităţii literare sub pseudonimul Carmen Sylva, sub care, de altfel, nu şi-a ascuns adevărata identitate de regină.
    [Show full text]
  • Selected Records Related to A.C. Cuza and the National Christian Party RG-25.059M
    Selected records related to A.C. Cuza and the National Christian Party RG-25.059M United States Holocaust Memorial Museum Archives 100 Raoul Wallenberg Place SW Washington, DC 20024-2126 Tel. (202) 479-9717 e-mail: [email protected] Descriptive summary Title: Selected records related to A.C. Cuza and the National Christian Party Dates: 1834-1948 (inclusive) 1934-1943 (bulk) Accession number: 2009.267 Creator: Partidul Naţional Creştin. Liga Apărării Naţional Creştine Extent: 7,535 digital images 7 microfilm reels (digitized) Repository: United States Holocaust Memorial Museum Archives, 100 Raoul Wallenberg Place SW, Washington, DC 20024-2126 Languages: Romanian Scope and content of collection Contains records relating to A. C. Cuza, a leading anti-Semite in Romania and the leader of the National Christian Party (PNC) which was in power December 1937 to February 1938. Also contains records relating to Istrate Micescu, the Justice Minister of the PNC administration. Administrative Information Restrictions on access: No restrictions on access. Restrictions on reproduction and use: Restrictions on use. Fair use only. Use only for scientific purposes (not for commercial use) Preferred citation: Preferred citation for USHMM archival collections; consult the USHMM website for guidance. Acquisition information: Source of acquisition is the Arhivele Naţionale ale României (Romanian National Archives), Fond personal A.C. Cuza (inv. 1139) and Fond personal Istrate Miscescu. The United States Holocaust Memorial Museum Archives received the collection via the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum International Archives Program in November, 2009. Existence and location of originals: Arhivele Naţionale ale României Historical note The National-Christian Defense League (Romanian: Liga Apararii National Crestine or LANC) was a virulently anti-Semitic political party of Romania formed by A.
    [Show full text]
  • Repere Medicale De-A Lungul Istoriei – 2018 (IV)
    ISTORIA MEDICINEI Repere medicale de-a lungul istoriei – 2018 (IV) Farm. pr. Maria-Gabriela Suliman, Ist. Antoaneta Lucasciuc Societatea Română de Istoria Farmaciei (SRIF) Societatea Română de Istoria Medicinei (SRIM) DR. IOAN MOLNAR-PIUARIU, TRADUCĂTOR MEDICAL 1803, Cluj (215 ani) - Ioan Molnar-Piuariu a tradus în limba română lucrarea medicilor Andrei Szöcs și Ioan Eckstein, colegi de la Școala medico- chirurgicală clujeană, cu titlul: „Învăţătura adevărată pre scurt a vindeca sfranţul după experienţă și ispitirile cele mai nouă” [1]. CEL DE-AL PATRULEA SPITAL DIN BUCUREŞTI ŞI AL DOILEA REGULAMENT SPITALICESC DIN ŢARA ROMÂNEASCĂ 1838, oct. 14, București (180 ani) – Este întemeiat Spitalul Brâncovenesc de către băneasa Safta Elisabeta Brâncoveanu (1776, Balș -1857, Mănăstirea Văratec). Ea va întocmi un Regulament pentru îndrumarea și funcţionarea serviciilor (al doilea de acest fel) după cel conceput de dr. Const. Caracaș (1773-1828) pentru Spitalul Filantropia (Iubirea de oameni), 1813 [2]. FIGURA 1. Băneasa Saft a Brâncoveanu PĂRINTELE BIBLIOGRAFIEI ROMÂNE DIN ZLATNA (1776-1857) AMPELUM (AURARIA MINOR) 1838 (180 ani) – După o cercetare de aproape 20 de ani, „fizicus” Vasile Popp (medic cărturar și dr. în filozofie, cu studii la Viena, a practicat medicina la Brașov iar la Iași a fost profesor la Seminarul teologic „Veniamin Costache”, din 1829 s-a stabilit la Zlatna, unde a decedat la 6 martie 1842) a publicat „Dizertaţia despre tipografiile românești în Transilvania și învecinatele ţări de la începutul lor până în zilele noastre”, fiind considerată „baza bibliografiei române”. Tot o lucrare fundamentală, una din primele FIGURA 2. Spitalul Brâncovenesc scrieri de medicină în limba română, a apărut la Brașov „Despre apele minerale de la Arpătac” (1821); sub aceeași semnătură, a apărut lucrarea „Conscripţie a sufletelor din Domeniul Toponfalvei (Câmpeni) și alte 18 localităţi” (1835).
    [Show full text]
  • Europass Curriculum Vitae
    Europass Curriculum Vitae Personal information First name(s) / Surname(s) Gabriel-Ionuț Stoiciu Nationality Romanian Date of birth 28.06.1975 Current position Researcher at “Francisc Rainer” Anthropological Institute Of Romanian Academy Of Sciences Work experience Dates June 2005 – present Position held Researcher Name of employer “Fr. Rainer” Anthropo-Logical Research Institute Dates Nov. 2002-June 2007 Position held Full stipend Phd student Main activities Research in Sociology and Social Anthropology Name of employer University of Bucharest Dates Oct. 2001- June 2002 Position held MA student Main activities Research In Sociology, Human Resources And Organisational Studies In Several Multinational Companies Name of employer Pierre Mendes-France University, Grenoble, France Dates Jan.-Oct. 2001 Position held Research assisstant Main activities Developing Documentation For On-Going Research Name of employer The Institute of Sociology of Romanian Academy, Bucharest Education and training Dates July 6, 2007 Title of qualification awarded Doctor in Philosophy Principal subjects/occupational skills Specialised on social anthropology, with a thesis on Cross-cultural aspects of employment in covered multinational companies Name and type of organisation providing education and training Dates Nov 2002 – July 2007 Title of qualification awarded PhD candidate Name and type of organisation University Of Bucharest, Department Of Philosophy providing education and training Dates Oct.2001- June 2002 Title of qualification awarded DEA (MA) in industrial
    [Show full text]
  • VOL 12 Isssue 1
    Journal of the Academical Society of Anthropology, JASA Volume 12. issue.1, October 2020, online ISSN 2668-2427, ISSN-L 2668-246X October 08th-10 th, 2020, online event NATIONAL SYMPOSIUM WITH INTERNATIONAL PARTICIPATION “FR. I. RAINER DAYS” - 2020 ANTHROPOLOGY AND TRADITIONS Biomedical and Socio-Cultural Aspects in Medicine BOOK OF ABSTRACTS VOLUME 12 ISSUE 1, 2020 ISSN 2668-2427 - online ISSN 2668-246X – print ISSN L 2668-2427 VOLUM DE REZUMATE SIMPOZIONUL NATIONAL CU PARTICIPARE INTERNAŢIONALĂ “ZILELE FR. I. RAINER” – 2020 ANTROPOLOGIE ŞI TRADIŢII aspecte biomedicale şi socio-culturale în domeniul medicinii 08-10 octombrie 2020, online Page 0 of 122 Journal of the Academical Society of Anthropology, JASA Volume 12. issue.1, October 2020, online ISSN 2668-2427, ISSN-L 2668-246X ISSN 2668-2427 - online ISSN 2668-246X - print ISSN-L 2668-2427 Open acces journal Redactor șef: Andrei KOZMA Redactor șef adj: Adina BACIU, Octavian BUDA, Norina FORNA Redactori: Doriana AGOP-FORNA, Tiberiu DEKANY, Călin POPOVICI Editor: Andrei KOZMA Tehnoredactor: Ioana NANU Coperta: Mihai OGĂȘANU și Andrei KOZMA Volum realizat sub redacția Societății Academice de Antropologie Tiparit la Editura Academiei Române. Editura recunoscuta UEFSCIDI la nr.164 Copyright © Societatea Academica de Antropologie, 2020. Toate drepturile asupra acestei ediții sunt rezervate Societății Academice de Antropologie Societatea Academică de Antropologie - asociaţie ştiinţifică nonprofit; CIF: 25759082 Piata Alba Iulia nr.3, bloc i2, apart.1, Bucureşti, România; cod postal; 031103 E-mail: [email protected] Nicio parte a acestui volum nu poate fi reprodusă sau transmisă sub nicio formă şi prin niciun mijloc, electronic sau mecanic, inclusiv prin fotocopiere, înregistrare sau prin orice sistem de stocare şi accesare a datelor, fără permisiunea Societății Academice de Antropologie.
    [Show full text]
  • Orme) Wilberforce (Albert) Raymond Blackburn (Alexander Bell
    Copyrights sought (Albert) Basil (Orme) Wilberforce (Albert) Raymond Blackburn (Alexander Bell) Filson Young (Alexander) Forbes Hendry (Alexander) Frederick Whyte (Alfred Hubert) Roy Fedden (Alfred) Alistair Cooke (Alfred) Guy Garrod (Alfred) James Hawkey (Archibald) Berkeley Milne (Archibald) David Stirling (Archibald) Havergal Downes-Shaw (Arthur) Berriedale Keith (Arthur) Beverley Baxter (Arthur) Cecil Tyrrell Beck (Arthur) Clive Morrison-Bell (Arthur) Hugh (Elsdale) Molson (Arthur) Mervyn Stockwood (Arthur) Paul Boissier, Harrow Heraldry Committee & Harrow School (Arthur) Trevor Dawson (Arwyn) Lynn Ungoed-Thomas (Basil Arthur) John Peto (Basil) Kingsley Martin (Basil) Kingsley Martin (Basil) Kingsley Martin & New Statesman (Borlasse Elward) Wyndham Childs (Cecil Frederick) Nevil Macready (Cecil George) Graham Hayman (Charles Edward) Howard Vincent (Charles Henry) Collins Baker (Charles) Alexander Harris (Charles) Cyril Clarke (Charles) Edgar Wood (Charles) Edward Troup (Charles) Frederick (Howard) Gough (Charles) Michael Duff (Charles) Philip Fothergill (Charles) Philip Fothergill, Liberal National Organisation, N-E Warwickshire Liberal Association & Rt Hon Charles Albert McCurdy (Charles) Vernon (Oldfield) Bartlett (Charles) Vernon (Oldfield) Bartlett & World Review of Reviews (Claude) Nigel (Byam) Davies (Claude) Nigel (Byam) Davies (Colin) Mark Patrick (Crwfurd) Wilfrid Griffin Eady (Cyril) Berkeley Ormerod (Cyril) Desmond Keeling (Cyril) George Toogood (Cyril) Kenneth Bird (David) Euan Wallace (Davies) Evan Bedford (Denis Duncan)
    [Show full text]
  • Atitudini Februarie Interior.Cdr
    Numărul 2 (143), Februarie 2019, An XVII Nicolae Br eban ’ 85 Atitudini februarie 2019 Editorial Te iubesc, Chișinău! – din jurnalul meu în care îmi notez doar impresiile despre zilele excepționale de Gelu Nicolae Ionescu C h i ș i n ă u , d e ș i î m i Le-am dăruit și materiale propusesem de multe ori o informative despre programele călătorie pe plaiul românesc de noastre culturale, le-am oferit dincolo de Prut. Oportunitatea de informații despre patrimoniul a le vorbi participanților la Târgul cultural ploieștean și prahovean. Internațional de Turism TURISM. La fel de important este, însă, Este timpul ca secolul XXI să L E I S U R E . H OT E L S d e l a faptul că am comunicat, am râs își intre în drepturi! Moldoexpo Chișinău, 7-10 împreună, am legat o prietenie pe S c r i u a c e s t e r â n d u r i februarie 2019 despre oferta care unii o vor ruptă. Ne-am asumându-mi riscul de-a stârni cultură a orașului nostru, de a le plimbat, am făcut atelier de mânia oricărui dușman, oricât de prezenta și dărui cărți editate de teatru, ne-am privit, pentru o puternic ar fi acesta! Niciodată nu Casa de Cultură „Ion Luca clipă, senini, uitând de apăsarea voi eluda adevărul, nu-mi voi Caragiale” a Municipiului Ploiești vremii... surghiuni sufletul în neantul am considerat-o un dar divin. M-a impresionat până la minciunii, pentru a trăi bine Am plecat într-o delegație din lacrimi povestea fraților mei de f ă c â n d f r u m o s l a v r e u n care au mai făcut parte: domnul peste Prut și am avut sufletul preapotent mondial.
    [Show full text]
  • 100858 AVANCES 26 5Indd
    avances en Diabetología Av Diabetol. 2010;26:373-82 Historical perspective From pancreatic extracts to artificial pancreas: history, science and controversies about the discovery of the pancreatic antidiabetic hormone V: The controversy. Who discovered insulin? A. de Leiva-Pérez1, E. Brugués-Brugués1,2, A. de Leiva-Hidalgo1,2,3,4 1Fundación DIABEM. 2Servicio de Endocrinología y Nutrición e Instituto de Investigación. Hospital de la Santa Creu i Sant Pau. Barcelona. 3Centro de Historia de la Ciencia. Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona. 4CIBER-BBN-ISCIII The Nobel Prize controversy were provided by two members of the objection was to making an award on “he- The 1923 Nobel Award Nobel Committee: John Sjöqvist, Profes- resy evidence” from unknown persons or of Physiology or Medicine sor of Chemistry and Pharmacy, and Hans on statements in the two appraisals, like In April 1923, a total of 57 nominations Christian Jacobaeus, Professor of Internal “it is beyond doubt”, or comments as with merits were reviewed by the Nobel Medicine. Sjökvist arrived to the same ”things that are thought as very possible”; Committee. The examiners concluded conclusion as A. Krogh: the prize should the Assembly should take only verifi able that the discovery of insulin was of funda- be divided between Banting and Macleod. facts. The Committee reconsidered and mental importance. The archives of the Professor Göran Liljstrand was the Secre- reconfirmed its previous recommenda- Karolinska Institute depict that Macleod tary of the Nobel Committee from 1918 to tion. August Krogh was identifi ed as the and Banting were nominated for the fi rst 1960. He was a great friend of August source of the “heresy evidence”; he time in 1923: Banting by G.W.
    [Show full text]
  • Editorial in October, 19, 2009 Paulescu Triumphed in Canada
    Editorial In October, 19, 2009 Paulescu Triumphed in Canada When, in 1996, I published – in the group involved in the events related to the Genesis Printing House – the monograph great discovery (Banting died in 1941, entitled “Insulin – the medical discovery of MacLeod died in 1935 and Collip In 1965) – the century belongs to the Romanian .C. the publication of the famous monograph Paulescu” – I was convinced that the truth entitled “ Discovery of Insulin ” could finally be included in this quite lengthy title could not be published; it was authored by the Canadian mystified for an indefinite period of time. At histotian Michael Bliss. the time 75 years had already elapsed since the The paper – that laid emphasis on, and great event, which was correctly related to the gave details concerning the events that had year 1921, took place, but which – according taken place in Canada – had simply wiped to circumstances and subjective preferences – away the myth according to which Banting was incorrectly attributed to either Banting and Best were the discoverers of insulin. The and Best (as it appeared in certain medical great part of the merit in the discovery of treaties) or to Banting and MacLeod (as it insulin was now attributed to the other two appeared in other treaties that mentioned the members of the Canadian group MacLeod and names of those who, in 1923, unfairly Collip. A myth died another myth was born – received the Nobel Prize for the discovery a myth closer to reality, but one that could not made by Paulescu). definitely be separated from the Toronto In 1996 the Canadians organized in events.
    [Show full text]
  • Download PDF Pages from the History of the Anatomical Meeting From
    Rom J Morphol Embryol 2015, 56(1):315–319 R J M E HORT ISTORICAL EVIEW Romanian Journal of S H R Morphology & Embryology http://www.rjme.ro/ Pages from the history of the “Anatomical Meeting” from Cluj CRISTIAN BÂRSU Department of History of Medicine, Social Sciences and Humanism, “Iuliu Haţieganu” University of Medicine and Pharmacy, Cluj-Napoca, Romania Abstract The “Anatomical Meeting” from Cluj was one of the most significant morpho-clinical societies from Romania during the interwar period. It was created in 1920 by Professor Titu Vasiliu (1885–1961). The purpose of our paper is to present the most important landmarks of this Society and to put into evidence its place in the Romanian series of morpho-clinical societies. Documentary Material: The activity reports of “Anatomical Meeting” from Cluj, summaries published in “Medical Cluj” journal referring to the presentations and discussions of the cases, which were held at different meetings of this Society. The activity of the “Anatomical Meeting” from Cluj increased, in a significantly and consistently way, the level of morphological and clinical training of physicians from Cluj. There are mentioned some of the most important presentations and the personalities which had special contributions in the evolution of this Society. Conclusions: The “Anatomical Meeting” was a scientific forum that propagated morpho-clinical concept in Romanian medicine, initially in Cluj, and then on a national level. It contributed to the collaboration between pathologists, clinicians and laboratory physicians from Cluj and favored scientific emulation between them. It also was a tribune from which were discussed a few new medical achievements.
    [Show full text]
  • THE DISCOVERY of INSULIN and NICOLAE PAULESCU
    1 THE DISCOVERY OF INSULIN and NICOLAE PAULESCU F. I. Dworschak 2 : I have tried not to be offensive and you may think I have been too mild, but I know that any criticism of the Toronto workers will be regarded as almost sacrilegious in certain quarters.” Ian Murray to I. Pavel, 4 April 1970 “He (Paulescu) was the first to describe the actions of what was later called insulin and demonstrated clearly that it was a hormone with actions on all aspects of metabolism”. Sir George Al berti December 2001 3 INTRODUCTION This essay will re-examine the contributions to insulin research and other areas of Medicine and Physiology by Nicolae Constantin Paulescu and account for his relative lack of recognition in English language historiography. 1 One important reason was that he wrote and published exclusively in French. He also had little access to English language medical publications, likely because he could not afford them (see his unanswered letter to Banting dated 5 February 1923). As such, he was out of touch with the rapid advances in diabetes research in the Anglo-Saxon medical literature, relying exclusively on French sources. Starting in 1922 this became fatal, he was left behind and his contributions, meager at this stage also due to financial problems, became almost irrelevant. This is in marked contrast to the previous years (1920-1921) when one could rightly say that he was the leading researcher investigating the whole range of physiological properties of the “inner secretion” of the pancreas that eventually would be known as insulin. Viewed from this angle he should be considered the discoverer of insulin as a hormone affecting practically all aspects of the metabolism.
    [Show full text]