Maryland Historical Magazine, 1974, Volume 69, Issue No. 1
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Vol. 69 No. 1 Spring 1974 Roger B. Taney: A Historiographical In- quiry Marvin Laurence Winitsky Frederick Douglass: Maryland Slave to Religious Liberal William L. Van Deburg The Effects of the Civil War on Southern Protestantism VV. Harrison Daniel Politics, Intrigue, and the Presidency: James McHenry to Bishop John Carroll, May 16, 1800 John B. Boles Roger Brooke Taney A QUARTERLY PUBLISHED BY THE MARYLAND HISTORICAL SOCIETY BOARD OF EDITORS JEAN BAKER Goucher College MAXWELL BLOOMFIELD Catholic University of America RHODA M. DORSEY Chairman, Goucher College JACK P. GREENE Johns Hopkins University AUBREY C. LAND University of Georgia BENJAMIN QUARLES Morgan State College MORRIS L. RADOFF Maryland State Archivist WALTER RUNDELL, JR. University of Maryland A. RUSSELL SLAGLE Baltimore RICHARD WALSH Georgetown University FORMER EDITORS WILLIAM HAND BROWNE 1906 1909 LOUIS H. DIELMAN 1910 1937 JAMES W. FOSTER 1938 1949, 1950-1951 HARRY AMMON 1950 FRED SHELLEY 1951 1955 FRANCIS C. HABER 1955 58 RICHARD WALSH 1958 1967 RICHARD R. DUNCAN, Editor JOHN B. BOLES, Book Review Editor RALPH D. NURNBERGER. Assistant Editor MARY K. MEYER, Genealogical Editor EUGENIA CALVERT HOLLAND and LOIS B. McCAULEY, Graphics Staff Director P. WILLIAM FILBY Published quarterly by the Maryland Historical Society, 201 W. Monument Street, Baltimore, Md. Second-Class postage paid at Baltimore, Md. Composed and Printed at Waverly Press, Inc. Baltimore, Maryland 21202. © 1974, Maryland Historical Society K^ft^ ^^ i C-. 7i MARYLAND HISTORICAL MAGAZINE PUBLISHED BY THE MARYLAND HISTORICAL SOCIETY VOLUME LXIX BALTIMORE 1974 CONTENTS OF VOLUME LXIX CONTRIBUTORS opp. 1, opp. 123, opp. 243, opp. 341 ROGER B. TANEY: HISTORIOGRAPHICAL INQUIRY. Marvin Laurence Winitsky 1 FREDERICK DOUGLASS: MARYLAND SLAVE TO RELIGIOUS LIBERAL. William L. Van Deburg 27 THE EFFECTS OF THE CIVIL WAR ON SOUTHERN PROTESTANTISM. W. Harrison Daniel 44 POLITICS, INTRIGUE, AND THE PRESIDENCY: JAMES MCHENRY TO BISHOP CAR- ROLL, MAY 16, 1800. ]ohn B. Boles 64 NOTES ON MARYLAND HISTORICAL SOCIETY MANUSCRIPT COLLECTIONS 86 A DESCRIPTION OF THE VERTICAL FILE. Richard f. Cox 86 ACCESSIONS OF THE MANUSCRIPT DIVISION SINCE THE PUBLICATION OF MAN- USCRIPT COLLECTIONS OF THE MARYLAND HISTORICAL SOCIETY IN AUGUST, 1968, X 90 GENEALOGICA MARYLANDIA 93, 323, 418 CAPTAIN JOHN FULFORD'S COMPANY, FEBRUARY 13, 1776, To MAY 21, 1777. Edited by Mary K. Meyer 93 REVIEWS OF RECENT BOOKS 98, 228, 327, 426 BOOK NOTES 116, 338, 443 NOTES AND QUERIES 120, 447 THE ST, MARY'S CITY COMMISSION 123 "THE METROPOLIS OF MARYLAND": A COMMENT ON TOWN DEVELOPMENT ALONG THE TOBACCO COAST. Lois Green Can 124 ST. JOHN'S: ARCHAEOLOGICAL QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS. Garry Wheeler Stone. 146 OPPORTUNITY AND INEQUALITY: THE DISTRIBUTION OF WEALTH ON THE LOWER WESTERN SHORE OF MARYLAND, 1638-1705. Russell R. Menard, P. M. G. Harris, Lois Green Carr 169 THE "VIRGINIA HOUSE" IN MARYLAND. Gary Carson 185 A TENANT FARMER'S TABLEWARE: NINETEENTH-CENTURY CERAMICS FROM TABB'S PURCHASE. George L. Miller 197 DEATH IN THE CHESAPEAKE: TWO LIFE TABLES FOR MEN IN EARLY COLONIAL MARYLAND. Lorena S. Walsh and Russell R. Menard 211 IN MEMORIAM: GEORGE L. RADCLIFFE between 241-243 HAROLD RANDALL MANAKEE, 1908-1974. Harry Bard between 241-243 BUSINESS INNOVATION AND SOCIAL CHANGE: THE CAREER OF ALEXANDER BROWN AFTER THE WAR OF 1812. Gary L. Browne 243 A GLIMPSE OF BALTIMORE SOCIETY IN 1827: LETTERS BY HENRY D. GILPIN. Ralph D. Gray and Gerald E. Hartdagen 256 THOMAS STONE AND THE REORGANIZATION OF THE MARYLAND COUNCIL OF SAFETY, 1776. ]ean H. Vivian 271 MT. VERNON PLACE AT THE TURN OF THE CENTURY: A VIGNETTE OF THE GARRETT FAMILY. Katharine B. Dehler 279 SIDELIGHTS 293, 398 THE LOST WORLD OF DANIEL BOORSTIN. Rodney M. Sievers 293 A SELECTED BIBLIOGRAPHY OF ARTICLES ON MARYLAND HISTORY IN OTHER JOURNALS. Dorothy M. Brown and Richard R. Duncan 300 NOTES ON MARYLAND HISTORICAL SOCIETY MANUSCRIPT COLLECTIONS: TWO MARYLANDERS IN THE EARLY NAVY: THE HAMBLETON FAMILY PAPERS, Ms. 2021, by Richard J. Cox 317 ACCESSIONS OF THE MANUSCRIPT DIVISION SINCE THE PUBLICATION OF MANU- SCRIPT COLLECTIONS OF THE MARYLAND HISTORICAL SOCIETY IN AUGUST 1968, XI 321 DEATH RECORDS FROM RICHARD MARKLAND'S COPY BOOK. Mary K. Meyer 323 GEORGE L. RADCLIFFE, 1877-1974. Samuel Hopkins between 340-341 A PORTRAIT OF BALTIMORE IN 1800: ECONOMIC AND OCCUPATIONAL PATTERNS IN AN EARLY AMERICAN CITY. Richard M. Bernard 341 ELLEN SPENCER MUSSEY AND THE WASHINGTON COLLEGE OF LAW. Catherine M. Rottier 361 BENEFIT OF CLERGY IN COLONIAL MARYLAND. Peter G. Yackel 383 A MARYLANDER IN AFRICA: THE LETTERS OF HENRY HANNON. W. Wayne Smith 398 THE GREAT BALTIMORE DELUGE OF 1817. Ralph D. Nurnberger 405 NOTES ON MARYLAND HISTORICAL SOCIETY MANUSCRIPT COLLECTIONS: THE HISTORICAL DEVELOPMENT OF THE MANUSCRIPT'S DIVISION OF THE MARYLAND HISTORICAL SOCIETY. Richard f. Cox 409 SOMERSET PARISH RECORDS. Robert Barnes 418 ILLUSTRATIONS Page Roger Brooke Taney Cover, Spring Roger B. Taney. Library of Congress 3 Home of Roger B. Taney, Bentz Street, Frederick, Maryland. Maryland Historical Society 5 John Marshall. Library of Congress 7 Roger B. Taney. Library of Congress 10 John Bach McMaster. Library of Congress 13 Roger B. Taney. Maryland Historical Society 15 Albert Beveridge. Library of Congress 18 Roger B. Taney. Library of Congress 21 Walker Lewis. Maryland Historical Society 23 Roger B. Taney. Maryland Historical Society 25 Frederick Douglass. Library of Congress 28 Wendell Phillips. Library of Congress 31 John Brown. Library of Congress 33 Henry Ward Beecher. Library of Congress 35 Frederick Douglass. Library of Congress 37 Theodore Parker. Library of Congress 39 Robert G. Ingersoll. Library of Congress 41 William Lloyd Garrison. Library of Congress 42 Rev. L. F. Drake preaching at Camp Dick Robinson, Kentucky, 1864. Library of Congress 47 St. Paul's Episcopal Church, Richmond, 1865. Library of Congress 51 Cathedral of St. John, Charleston. Library of Congress 53 Richmond, 1865. Library of Congress 56 Ruins of the Circular Church, Charleston. Library of Congress 59 Headquarters, United States Christian Commission, Richmond, 1865. Library of Congress 62 James McHenry. By St. Memin. Maryland Historical Society 66 Thomas Jefferson. Maryland Historical Society 67 John Carroll. Maryland Historical Society 70 Charles Cotesworth Pindcney. Maryland Historical Society 73 Alexander Hamilton. Maryland Historical Society 75 George Washington. Maryland Historical Society 77 Aaron Burr. By Gilbert Stuart. From Dictionary of American Portraits 79 Robert Goodloe Harper. By St. Memin. Maryland Historical Society 81 John Jay. By Gilbert Stuart. From Dictionary of American Portraits 83 Archbishop Samuel Eccleston. Maryland Historical Society 87 Charles Joseph Bonaparte. Maryland Historical Society 89 Enlistment Notice. Library of Congress 94 St. Mary's City: The Village Crossroads, 1690's. Detail from a conjectural drawing Cover, Summer The St. Mary's Townlands, 1640-47. Map 1: The tract map is based on original surveys superimposed on a recent topographical map created from aerial sur- veys. Dates of structures reflect the earliest mention in the records 127 The Village 1678. Map 2: 134 Photograph 1: The reconstructed State House of 1676 stands on what was Thomas Notley's lot on Aidermanbury Street 137 Photograph 2: This gun called a saker was found on the river below Church Point in 1824 141 Plate 1A: The house during excavation, looking south 150 Plate IB: The superimposed chimneys after removal of the construction and pre- construction levels (except for a small control strip on the right) 151 Plate II: Excavator uncovering the line of nails of a ball joist 154 St. John's circa 1640 156 St. Mary's Townlands, 1667 159 St. John's circa 1670. Preliminary Interpretation 161 Plate III; Architectural and furniture fragments: hinges, keys, and a brass escutch- eon plate. Items are photographed against a one-inch square grid 162 Plate IV: St. John's in the late seventeenth century 164 Plate V: Archaeological aides, identifiable finds 165 Plate VI: St. John's small objects that fell through cracks in the floor or were lost in the yard 167 Figure I: Mean and Median Total Estate Value on the Lower Western Shore of Maryland, 1638-1705 172 Figure II: Inventories and Taxables on the Lower Western Shore of Maryland, 1658-1705 175 Figure III: Household Inventories and Expected Deaths of Heads of Households on the Lower Western Shore of Maryland, 1658-1705 177 Figure IV: Age Adjusted Mean Total Estate Value on the Lower Western Shore of Maryland, 1658-1705 179 Figure 1: Holly Hill, ground plan 187 Figure 2: Holly Hill axial section (AA1) facing south. The drawing shows all visible fragments of the earliest house and its first enlargement 188 Figure 3: Holly Hill, exploded view of Period I construction at SE corner. The roof clapboards and the eaves board are restored in the drawing to show the original function of the nailing blocks. Not seen are the sprockets that carried the splayed lower edge of the roof over the ends of the extended tie beams . 189 Figure 4: Sarum, perspective view of seventeenth-century timber frame from SE corner 190 Figure 5: Sarum, axial section facing north. The oldest part of the house is cov- ered by the clapboarded roof, in which are still visible traces of two original dormers and the roof to a porch tower 193 The excavated house. In the foreground is the east chimney of Roger Tolle's dwell- ing, beyond which is the cellar added by Moses Tabbs 198 Graduate Student recovering ceramics from the ramp fill 199 Plate II: Drawings by Gretchen Nolley 203 Plate III 204 Plate IV: 207 Plate V 208 Christmas Day I860 Cover, Winter George L. Radcliffe, 1877-1974 between 340-341 Atheneaum. Maryland Historical Society opp. 341 Plan of the Town of Baltimore. A. Folie. 1792. Maryland Historical Society 343 Warner and Hanna's Plan of the City and Environs of Baltimore, 1801.